1
00:00:10,595 --> 00:00:12,597
[indistinct chatter]
2
00:00:14,599 --> 00:00:15,600
[on video] Hey!
3
00:00:18,144 --> 00:00:21,022
[Dianne Valiante] Tiffany was just...
just always beautiful.
4
00:00:21,022 --> 00:00:24,025
Always bright. Energetic.
5
00:00:25,234 --> 00:00:28,446
She got a scholarship to play volleyball.
6
00:00:30,198 --> 00:00:33,117
She was gonna be a middle starter.
7
00:00:33,201 --> 00:00:36,746
That doesn't happen in college,
being a freshman starter.
8
00:00:37,872 --> 00:00:39,415
She wanted things in life.
9
00:00:41,459 --> 00:00:43,461
We were all so very proud of her.
10
00:00:49,300 --> 00:00:54,347
That night, she was found approximately
four miles away from our house,
11
00:00:55,640 --> 00:00:57,600
where she was hit by that train.
12
00:00:59,352 --> 00:01:03,481
New Jersey Transit put it out there
that my daughter committed suicide.
13
00:01:04,899 --> 00:01:06,901
There's absolutely no way!
14
00:01:06,901 --> 00:01:08,569
No way at all.
15
00:01:10,196 --> 00:01:12,448
I wanna know what happened to my daughter.
16
00:01:13,074 --> 00:01:15,076
[mysterious music playing]
17
00:01:58,244 --> 00:02:00,246
[somber music playing softly]
18
00:02:10,423 --> 00:02:11,799
This is my daughter's room.
19
00:02:15,887 --> 00:02:18,139
The whole room is the way she left it.
20
00:02:23,936 --> 00:02:26,480
That's her writing
and her little hearts and what.
21
00:02:27,565 --> 00:02:29,525
No one will ever go in this room.
22
00:02:30,693 --> 00:02:31,819
It's like a tomb.
23
00:02:35,072 --> 00:02:38,159
She loved life,
and she was full of it too.
24
00:02:40,745 --> 00:02:42,038
That's my baby.
25
00:02:47,627 --> 00:02:51,547
[Dianne] I met Stephen in 1989,
26
00:02:51,631 --> 00:02:55,718
{\an8}and I had already had my girls,
Jessica and Krystal.
27
00:02:55,718 --> 00:03:00,181
I ended up pregnant with Tiffany
and had her in 1997.
28
00:03:01,474 --> 00:03:04,018
We were shocked when we had Tiffany.
29
00:03:07,980 --> 00:03:10,358
You know,
we didn't expect to get pregnant,
30
00:03:10,358 --> 00:03:13,277
but the first time we laid eyes on her,
it was just like...
31
00:03:13,361 --> 00:03:14,987
you know, just heaven. It just...
32
00:03:15,071 --> 00:03:17,031
She was absolutely gorgeous.
33
00:03:18,324 --> 00:03:20,284
[Stephen Valiante] Tiff was just
a ball of joy.
34
00:03:20,368 --> 00:03:23,496
She enjoyed what she was doing.
She didn't worry about nothing.
35
00:03:23,496 --> 00:03:26,666
{\an8}I mean, there's nothing
that she didn't like.
36
00:03:28,626 --> 00:03:31,796
[Dianne] Picture up there
is of her on a beach in North Carolina.
37
00:03:32,755 --> 00:03:34,382
This is New Year's Eve.
38
00:03:35,967 --> 00:03:39,720
Uh, here's her graduation.
You can see how happy she is.
39
00:03:43,057 --> 00:03:45,935
Tiffany's sisters are the ones
that had this made for me.
40
00:03:47,103 --> 00:03:50,439
Just a memorial of all,
you know, of Tiffany's life.
41
00:03:51,440 --> 00:03:55,111
To walk in here every day
just makes me feel close.
42
00:03:56,279 --> 00:03:59,448
I feel like she's with me
'cause I miss her so much.
43
00:04:02,243 --> 00:04:05,246
{\an8}[intriguing music playing quietly]
44
00:04:09,417 --> 00:04:10,668
{\an8}[Dianne] It was a Sunday.
45
00:04:10,668 --> 00:04:14,797
We went to Tiffany's cousin's
graduation party across the street.
46
00:04:15,923 --> 00:04:17,591
And Tiffany came with us.
47
00:04:19,051 --> 00:04:21,470
We were there for several hours
48
00:04:21,971 --> 00:04:24,765
steaming clams and having a good old time.
49
00:04:24,849 --> 00:04:26,183
Tiff was having a great time.
50
00:04:26,267 --> 00:04:29,186
Playing volleyball, having fun,
waiting for her friends to come over.
51
00:04:30,479 --> 00:04:33,983
{\an8}[Dianne] I remember Tiffany
running back home.
52
00:04:35,359 --> 00:04:38,279
{\an8}We were still at the party, and at 9:15,
53
00:04:38,279 --> 00:04:41,615
{\an8}I got a phone call
from one of her girlfriends and says,
54
00:04:41,699 --> 00:04:44,744
"I'm pulling up now.
Can you come over to the house?"
55
00:04:44,744 --> 00:04:46,912
I said, "Sure, is everything okay?"
56
00:04:46,996 --> 00:04:51,334
So I told my husband, Stephen,
that I gotta go over to the house,
57
00:04:51,334 --> 00:04:53,336
and he said, "Oh, I'll go with you."
58
00:04:53,336 --> 00:04:57,548
And we walked up
to the road between the two houses.
59
00:05:00,384 --> 00:05:03,304
Tiffany's friend got out
screaming and hollering,
60
00:05:03,304 --> 00:05:07,725
and accused Tiffany of using
her credit card without her knowledge.
61
00:05:07,725 --> 00:05:11,062
And Tiffany denied it
until after the friend left,
62
00:05:11,062 --> 00:05:14,940
and then she told me that she did use it.
63
00:05:16,692 --> 00:05:19,361
And I said, "Why would
you use somebody else's card?"
64
00:05:19,445 --> 00:05:22,948
"You know better than that.
Didn't raise you that way."
65
00:05:23,032 --> 00:05:25,701
"And now I gotta go tell your dad
you used the card."
66
00:05:26,660 --> 00:05:28,162
And I went in the house,
67
00:05:28,162 --> 00:05:33,667
I got Stephen, and within one minute,
we walked back out, and Tiffany was gone.
68
00:05:43,594 --> 00:05:45,429
[Stephen] We looked for her.
Looked around.
69
00:05:45,513 --> 00:05:47,473
I walked up and down the street
many times.
70
00:05:47,473 --> 00:05:51,602
There must've been at least 20 or 30 cars
going back and forth up this road.
71
00:05:51,602 --> 00:05:55,064
They were all parked on the
side of the road. Nobody's seen nothin'.
72
00:05:56,649 --> 00:05:59,860
[Dianne] I know if Tiffany walked,
somebody would have saw her.
73
00:05:59,944 --> 00:06:03,823
There's no doubt in my mind.
She's 6'2". You couldn't miss her.
74
00:06:04,657 --> 00:06:07,284
[Robert Valiante, Sr.]
We were walkin' up and down the streets,
75
00:06:07,368 --> 00:06:09,578
{\an8}looking behind houses and everything close
76
00:06:09,662 --> 00:06:12,957
{\an8}'cause we knew
she wouldn't walk any distance
77
00:06:12,957 --> 00:06:15,084
because she was scared to death
of the dark.
78
00:06:15,084 --> 00:06:17,169
[phone chiming]
79
00:06:23,509 --> 00:06:25,636
[Dianne] Everybody was calling, texting,
80
00:06:25,636 --> 00:06:28,389
you know,
trying to find out where she was.
81
00:06:33,227 --> 00:06:35,729
Stephen's calling
and she's not answering her phone.
82
00:06:36,897 --> 00:06:39,733
[Stephen on phone]
Tiff, please, just come home.
83
00:06:40,734 --> 00:06:44,488
I love you to death.
You mean everything in the world to me.
84
00:06:46,073 --> 00:06:47,825
Please just come home.
85
00:06:49,869 --> 00:06:51,704
[Stephen] I walked
up and down that street.
86
00:06:51,704 --> 00:06:53,956
And all of a sudden,
I looked down at the ground,
87
00:06:53,956 --> 00:06:56,083
and I had seen something flat.
88
00:06:56,167 --> 00:06:58,335
- And it was Tiff's phone.
- [phone vibrates]
89
00:06:58,836 --> 00:07:01,714
[Stephen] Phone was about five to eight
feet off the side of the road.
90
00:07:01,714 --> 00:07:03,007
In front of my house.
91
00:07:05,092 --> 00:07:06,886
That kid would have
never left her phone here.
92
00:07:06,886 --> 00:07:10,639
That phone was locked to her hand 24/7,
seven days a week.
93
00:07:10,723 --> 00:07:12,141
She took a shower with the phone.
94
00:07:12,141 --> 00:07:13,601
Then when we found the phone,
95
00:07:13,601 --> 00:07:15,728
all kinds of things
are going through my head.
96
00:07:15,728 --> 00:07:17,479
I knew there was something wrong.
97
00:07:18,647 --> 00:07:19,815
We were searching,
98
00:07:19,899 --> 00:07:24,111
and then later on,
Stephen remembered about
99
00:07:24,195 --> 00:07:26,655
the deer camera being in the woods.
100
00:07:26,739 --> 00:07:28,741
[ominous music playing faintly]
101
00:07:34,121 --> 00:07:36,957
[Stephen] Tiff left at 9:28,
according to my deer camera.
102
00:07:37,666 --> 00:07:43,631
And me and Dianne walked out at 9:29
with Tucker, which is her dog.
103
00:07:44,173 --> 00:07:46,300
We walked outside and she was gone.
104
00:07:48,928 --> 00:07:51,347
[Dianne] Tiffany was
wearing a black shirt,
105
00:07:51,347 --> 00:07:54,308
white blue-jean shorts.
106
00:07:54,308 --> 00:07:56,977
She had her flat shoes
that she had just bought,
107
00:07:57,061 --> 00:08:00,606
and she put her hair up
with a messy bob on the top
108
00:08:00,606 --> 00:08:02,107
and her white headband.
109
00:08:04,693 --> 00:08:08,280
She's doing her regular stride,
walking down the driveway.
110
00:08:08,781 --> 00:08:11,534
And because of the picture
on the deer camera,
111
00:08:11,534 --> 00:08:15,120
the only thing I could come up with
is that somebody called her name.
112
00:08:17,831 --> 00:08:20,417
And at that point, she was gone.
113
00:08:22,753 --> 00:08:24,672
{\an8}I got a phone call,
"Hey, Tiffany's missing."
114
00:08:24,672 --> 00:08:26,507
{\an8}"Can you come and help look for Tiffany?"
115
00:08:26,507 --> 00:08:27,758
{\an8}I said, "Sure."
116
00:08:27,758 --> 00:08:30,844
We went to my mom's house 'cause
they assumed she probably went there.
117
00:08:32,304 --> 00:08:36,725
It's walking distance. I would say
roughly a half mile it would be at most.
118
00:08:37,977 --> 00:08:38,811
She wasn't there.
119
00:08:38,811 --> 00:08:41,480
{\an8}So then we started
driving around different places.
120
00:08:41,480 --> 00:08:42,856
{\an8}We couldn't find her.
121
00:08:43,816 --> 00:08:46,360
{\an8}Something told me just to go down Pomona.
122
00:08:46,360 --> 00:08:49,655
{\an8}And when I drove down Pomona,
I crossed the railroad tracks.
123
00:08:51,615 --> 00:08:54,076
{\an8}There's a roadway alongside of the tracks.
124
00:08:54,577 --> 00:08:57,162
- An access road for transit.
- [police siren chirps]
125
00:09:00,916 --> 00:09:02,126
[Michael] It was lit up.
126
00:09:06,463 --> 00:09:11,010
There was a Galloway police officer there
said somebody was hit, possibly a female.
127
00:09:11,010 --> 00:09:14,013
{\an8}But Galloway Township
didn't get involved in it
128
00:09:14,013 --> 00:09:18,559
{\an8}because this happened
in the jurisdiction of New Jersey Transit.
129
00:09:22,855 --> 00:09:24,857
I saw a transit police officer there.
130
00:09:28,611 --> 00:09:29,445
I spoke to him.
131
00:09:29,445 --> 00:09:32,615
I say, "Hey, did you
happen to see a very big girl,
132
00:09:33,157 --> 00:09:35,659
6'2", very athletic?"
133
00:09:36,869 --> 00:09:40,414
And he said, "No, but we had somebody
who was struck by the train."
134
00:09:42,499 --> 00:09:45,294
At that point,
I'm thinking, "I hope it's not Tiffany."
135
00:09:45,961 --> 00:09:48,297
But they were pretty
confident that it was her.
136
00:09:53,636 --> 00:09:57,139
The transit officer said to me,
"Can you identify her?"
137
00:09:59,475 --> 00:10:01,602
And I said, "Yes, I can."
138
00:10:05,189 --> 00:10:09,234
And I am very glad
that I am the one that went down there,
139
00:10:09,318 --> 00:10:12,196
'cause I truly believe in my whole heart
140
00:10:12,196 --> 00:10:15,032
that my brother would never
have been able to handle it.
141
00:10:17,618 --> 00:10:20,579
What I saw that night,
no one needs to see that.
142
00:10:22,706 --> 00:10:25,584
It was probably one of
the most horrific things I've seen.
143
00:10:27,169 --> 00:10:29,171
You know, being struck by a train.
144
00:10:31,840 --> 00:10:34,468
So I went there,
and I did do the identification,
145
00:10:34,968 --> 00:10:38,639
and then they said, "Hey,
we have to go back to your brother's,
146
00:10:38,639 --> 00:10:40,474
and you have to tell your brother."
147
00:10:44,353 --> 00:10:46,188
[Dianne] It was 2:30 in the morning.
148
00:10:46,730 --> 00:10:53,070
And I remember walking out of the house,
and my son-in-law was standing there,
149
00:10:53,070 --> 00:10:57,449
and he said that Uncle Mickey called him,
told us to stay put.
150
00:10:58,075 --> 00:11:01,578
And I remember my son-in-law
looking totally white.
151
00:11:03,330 --> 00:11:06,166
And I remember us waiting
152
00:11:06,250 --> 00:11:09,378
and some type of cop car pull in.
153
00:11:11,505 --> 00:11:14,299
My brother, Mickey,
got out of a transit police car,
154
00:11:14,383 --> 00:11:17,761
and Dianne's yelling, "What happened?
What happened? What happened?"
155
00:11:20,764 --> 00:11:24,977
[Michael] And I told my brother
what happened. Tiffany was hit by a train.
156
00:11:28,772 --> 00:11:32,192
He did say, "I wanna go down there."
I'm like, "No, you're absolutely not."
157
00:11:32,276 --> 00:11:34,069
"You don't need to see this."
158
00:11:36,530 --> 00:11:37,865
[Stephen] We just lost it.
159
00:11:38,532 --> 00:11:41,368
It's like... you lost your life.
160
00:11:41,869 --> 00:11:44,830
When one of your kids die,
you lose part of your life.
161
00:11:45,622 --> 00:11:47,624
[crying] Oh, God, I miss her so much.
162
00:11:48,375 --> 00:11:49,585
She was my baby.
163
00:11:51,670 --> 00:11:53,338
I miss everything about her.
164
00:12:02,431 --> 00:12:04,725
[Robert, Sr.] I mean,
we just held each other and cried.
165
00:12:04,725 --> 00:12:06,143
It was like in disbelief.
166
00:12:08,187 --> 00:12:12,107
It was the most horrible thing
you could even imagine at that time
167
00:12:12,191 --> 00:12:14,443
that something like that could happen.
168
00:12:15,861 --> 00:12:17,946
[crying] We were in such shock.
169
00:12:18,030 --> 00:12:19,406
Total shock.
170
00:12:20,699 --> 00:12:22,451
'Cause, like, hit by a train?
171
00:12:22,451 --> 00:12:24,453
It just didn't make sense to me.
172
00:12:38,550 --> 00:12:41,553
[Stephen] Mickey said that
Tiffany got hit by a train.
173
00:12:42,054 --> 00:12:43,555
We didn't know what happened.
174
00:12:46,850 --> 00:12:49,061
Then the following morning,
175
00:12:49,061 --> 00:12:51,814
it was already in the papers
Tiffany had committed suicide.
176
00:12:56,777 --> 00:12:57,945
I was devastated.
177
00:12:59,238 --> 00:13:03,075
I couldn't understand, you know,
how they could come up with that.
178
00:13:11,542 --> 00:13:14,294
My daughter wasn't depressed.
She wasn't suicidal.
179
00:13:15,671 --> 00:13:17,589
Tiffy was happy.
180
00:13:17,673 --> 00:13:20,592
She was making plans to go to college.
181
00:13:20,676 --> 00:13:23,428
She was making plans with her roommate.
182
00:13:23,929 --> 00:13:28,600
She was making plans
to play softball that Wednesday.
183
00:13:29,184 --> 00:13:35,023
She had plans to go to Great Adventure
the next morning with friends.
184
00:13:37,693 --> 00:13:41,113
[Robert Valiante, Jr.] The night I spoke
with Tiffany, obviously, at the party,
185
00:13:41,113 --> 00:13:43,866
{\an8}she showed no signs of any kind of stress.
186
00:13:43,866 --> 00:13:47,452
She had her school clothes.
She had things prepared.
187
00:13:48,412 --> 00:13:51,957
Tiffany was ready to make that next move.
188
00:13:55,002 --> 00:13:57,838
[Dianne] There's no way in hell
she committed suicide.
189
00:14:02,342 --> 00:14:07,180
New Jersey Transit made the determination
that my daughter stood on those tracks
190
00:14:07,890 --> 00:14:12,144
and committed suicide in less than
24 hours from the time she was hit.
191
00:14:15,022 --> 00:14:18,400
People that knew Tiffany
just couldn't believe it.
192
00:14:21,695 --> 00:14:25,324
We were on a mission because we knew
our daughter didn't do this.
193
00:14:25,324 --> 00:14:27,409
[intriguing music playing]
194
00:14:29,870 --> 00:14:32,247
My name is Paul D'Amato.
195
00:14:33,790 --> 00:14:37,169
{\an8}I've been a trial lawyer for 46 years.
196
00:14:39,129 --> 00:14:43,550
{\an8}Most of my cases
have involved representing victims.
197
00:14:44,217 --> 00:14:47,804
And there have been those cases,
like Tiffany's case,
198
00:14:47,888 --> 00:14:51,058
that you simply cannot say no to.
199
00:14:53,727 --> 00:14:56,647
When I first met Steve and Dianne,
200
00:14:56,647 --> 00:14:58,482
they were sitting right here.
201
00:14:59,149 --> 00:15:03,612
And they were so broken
202
00:15:04,404 --> 00:15:06,448
and so upset.
203
00:15:07,866 --> 00:15:10,494
They told me that
204
00:15:10,494 --> 00:15:13,914
their daughter did not take her own life.
205
00:15:14,706 --> 00:15:18,335
I didn't know if I could help them,
and I said to myself,
206
00:15:18,335 --> 00:15:22,047
{\an8}let me get the records
207
00:15:22,047 --> 00:15:24,591
from the New Jersey Transit
Police Department.
208
00:15:24,675 --> 00:15:29,221
I'll present the reports to them,
and sadly, I'll have to tell them,
209
00:15:29,221 --> 00:15:31,431
"Your daughter took her own life."
210
00:15:33,100 --> 00:15:35,894
But that never happened
once we got the records.
211
00:15:37,938 --> 00:15:41,483
Tiffany Valiante was 18 years old
and lived with her family
212
00:15:41,483 --> 00:15:46,029
in a very rural area of New Jersey
west of Atlantic City.
213
00:15:48,532 --> 00:15:52,244
Now here's what we know
about the night that she was killed.
214
00:15:54,663 --> 00:15:56,748
On Sunday, July 12th,
215
00:15:56,832 --> 00:16:00,293
New Jersey Transit train number 4693
216
00:16:00,377 --> 00:16:03,422
left Philadelphia at 9:50 p.m.,
217
00:16:03,422 --> 00:16:05,632
heading east to Atlantic City.
218
00:16:08,218 --> 00:16:11,722
There were about
60 passengers and crew on board.
219
00:16:13,682 --> 00:16:17,978
The train had just passed under the bridge
at Tilton Road in Galloway Township
220
00:16:17,978 --> 00:16:21,148
and was headed toward the crossing
at Genoa Avenue.
221
00:16:21,148 --> 00:16:25,026
It was 11:12 p.m. at mile marker 45
222
00:16:25,110 --> 00:16:29,322
on a very dark stretch of track
where Tiffany was hit by the train.
223
00:16:31,116 --> 00:16:33,118
[dark music playing]
224
00:16:34,828 --> 00:16:36,705
[Paul] When the train was examined later,
225
00:16:36,705 --> 00:16:42,210
it showed that the impact was specifically
on the lower left side of the train,
226
00:16:42,294 --> 00:16:43,712
close to the track.
227
00:16:46,840 --> 00:16:49,259
There were two engineers
on board the train.
228
00:16:49,259 --> 00:16:51,970
A senior engineer and a student engineer.
229
00:16:52,929 --> 00:16:55,182
{\an8}That night, they both signed the report
230
00:16:55,182 --> 00:16:58,518
{\an8}saying that Tiffany
dove in front of the train.
231
00:17:01,021 --> 00:17:03,106
But here's the problem.
232
00:17:03,190 --> 00:17:07,444
Six days later, when he's put under oath,
233
00:17:07,444 --> 00:17:13,158
the senior engineer comes up
with a completely different version
234
00:17:13,158 --> 00:17:16,995
of what he told the detective
the night of the incident.
235
00:17:17,079 --> 00:17:18,580
Here's his story.
236
00:17:19,623 --> 00:17:22,209
"I was talking to the conductor."
237
00:17:22,751 --> 00:17:26,630
"I never saw her. My back was turned."
238
00:17:27,964 --> 00:17:30,842
So you throw his statements out,
239
00:17:31,635 --> 00:17:35,263
and then you look at what
the student engineer said.
240
00:17:36,264 --> 00:17:38,850
Initially, he was asked,
241
00:17:38,934 --> 00:17:42,395
"When did you first see the trespasser?"
242
00:17:42,479 --> 00:17:44,272
What was his answer?
243
00:17:44,856 --> 00:17:49,694
"I didn't see her
until I was on top of her."
244
00:17:49,778 --> 00:17:51,404
[train whistle blowing]
245
00:17:52,781 --> 00:17:56,118
Ten days later, he's put under oath,
246
00:17:56,118 --> 00:17:58,870
and now here's his story.
247
00:17:59,913 --> 00:18:02,958
"I see something
when I'm half a mile away."
248
00:18:03,792 --> 00:18:07,337
"Then I see something
when I'm a quarter-mile away."
249
00:18:07,838 --> 00:18:11,341
"And then I see this person
250
00:18:11,341 --> 00:18:15,512
jump out of the woods on to the tracks."
251
00:18:21,309 --> 00:18:25,397
In the end, the student engineer
was the only witness.
252
00:18:25,397 --> 00:18:28,942
A student engineer who gave variations
253
00:18:28,942 --> 00:18:31,695
of what he saw that night.
254
00:18:33,989 --> 00:18:35,198
To this day,
255
00:18:35,907 --> 00:18:39,494
the New Jersey Transit Police Department
256
00:18:39,578 --> 00:18:42,998
stands by the inconsistent,
257
00:18:43,790 --> 00:18:48,044
contradictory statements
of the student engineer.
258
00:18:52,757 --> 00:18:55,010
My name's Louise Houseman,
259
00:18:55,010 --> 00:18:58,680
{\an8}and I'm retired from the Atlantic County
Medical Examiner's Office,
260
00:18:58,680 --> 00:19:01,766
{\an8}where I was the senior investigator.
I worked there for 20 years.
261
00:19:04,936 --> 00:19:08,648
I've probably been to
several thousand scenes
262
00:19:08,732 --> 00:19:10,150
over the course of 20 years.
263
00:19:12,444 --> 00:19:13,862
I was really concerned
264
00:19:13,862 --> 00:19:20,243
with the sworn statements by the engineer
and the student engineer.
265
00:19:21,661 --> 00:19:24,164
Because a great deal of weight
was apparently given
266
00:19:24,164 --> 00:19:27,125
to the information
they provided at the scene,
267
00:19:28,084 --> 00:19:31,713
which turned out to not be correct.
268
00:19:32,589 --> 00:19:36,968
The major incident event recorder
is considered the black box.
269
00:19:37,052 --> 00:19:42,599
It records everything that happens
with the engine as it's going along.
270
00:19:42,599 --> 00:19:44,935
The speed of the train,
271
00:19:45,477 --> 00:19:47,479
when the hand brakes are used,
272
00:19:47,479 --> 00:19:49,731
when the horn is rung,
273
00:19:49,731 --> 00:19:51,399
if the headlights are on.
274
00:19:52,150 --> 00:19:54,527
And it gives the distance
the train has traveled
275
00:19:54,611 --> 00:19:56,071
when all this happens.
276
00:19:56,071 --> 00:19:58,406
So it's very easy to read.
277
00:19:58,490 --> 00:20:02,077
There's nothing mysterious about it.
It's very straightforward.
278
00:20:03,828 --> 00:20:06,581
According to the event recorder,
279
00:20:06,665 --> 00:20:11,002
from the time the apprentice engineer
sounded the horn, struck Tiffany,
280
00:20:11,086 --> 00:20:13,255
and applied the emergency brake,
281
00:20:13,255 --> 00:20:16,132
it took a total of 4.1 seconds.
282
00:20:16,216 --> 00:20:18,343
That train's traveling 80 miles an hour.
283
00:20:19,344 --> 00:20:22,514
So, did he see what he thought he saw?
284
00:20:22,514 --> 00:20:25,684
That she jumped in front of him?
I don't know.
285
00:20:29,270 --> 00:20:34,776
I believe that the student engineer
was in a type of trauma, in shock.
286
00:20:34,776 --> 00:20:35,944
Anyone would be.
287
00:20:35,944 --> 00:20:37,862
If you hit someone in a car,
288
00:20:37,946 --> 00:20:41,366
are you gonna be able
to describe exactly what happened?
289
00:20:41,366 --> 00:20:42,701
Probably not.
290
00:20:44,369 --> 00:20:48,039
When you read the transcription,
it seems to be rambling.
291
00:20:49,708 --> 00:20:53,670
He's not really sure of what he saw,
292
00:20:53,670 --> 00:20:56,631
and it's possible what he saw was
293
00:20:56,715 --> 00:20:58,508
when the train struck her,
294
00:20:58,508 --> 00:21:03,096
the body parts flew
in all different directions
295
00:21:03,096 --> 00:21:05,181
because she was being dismembered.
296
00:21:05,807 --> 00:21:07,434
[train whistle blowing]
297
00:21:07,434 --> 00:21:10,562
[Louise] I don't think
he saw her jump in front of the train.
298
00:21:10,562 --> 00:21:13,648
And she may have been dead on the tracks.
299
00:21:23,575 --> 00:21:26,661
[Jim Brennenstuhl] If you assume
that it's a suicide right at the beginning
300
00:21:27,162 --> 00:21:29,998
and then tailor the facts
to fit your assumption,
301
00:21:31,041 --> 00:21:33,376
everything else after that is suspect.
302
00:21:36,212 --> 00:21:38,256
My name is Jim Brennenstuhl.
303
00:21:38,340 --> 00:21:40,300
{\an8}I have, for the last 45 years,
304
00:21:40,300 --> 00:21:42,635
{\an8}either done police work
or private detective work.
305
00:21:42,719 --> 00:21:45,722
Mr. D'Amato called me and asked
if I would be involved in the case.
306
00:21:46,973 --> 00:21:51,519
The train strike is variously recorded
as some time a little after 11:00.
307
00:21:54,564 --> 00:21:59,277
According to the way they reported it,
this is where it happened.
308
00:21:59,361 --> 00:22:00,570
Milepost 45.
309
00:22:05,366 --> 00:22:06,826
{\an8}It's pretty dark.
310
00:22:09,079 --> 00:22:13,333
Why would she walk all of that distance
and jump in front of a train there?
311
00:22:13,333 --> 00:22:14,793
What is it about there?
312
00:22:15,877 --> 00:22:19,089
If she killed herself that way, why?
313
00:22:19,089 --> 00:22:22,425
Why go that far? Why do it that way?
314
00:22:26,846 --> 00:22:30,683
[Louise] When I saw exactly
where she was struck by the train,
315
00:22:30,767 --> 00:22:32,102
I was really surprised.
316
00:22:33,019 --> 00:22:36,231
She was a mile
from the closest intersection
317
00:22:36,231 --> 00:22:37,732
into the woods.
318
00:22:37,816 --> 00:22:39,651
And it was dark. There's no light.
319
00:22:41,569 --> 00:22:43,696
The hairs on the back of my head
just went up.
320
00:22:43,780 --> 00:22:45,865
I said, "There's something
really wrong here."
321
00:22:46,741 --> 00:22:48,743
[train whistle blowing]
322
00:22:50,286 --> 00:22:53,832
{\an8}I think there's probably not a day,
certainly not a week,
323
00:22:53,832 --> 00:22:56,960
{\an8}that goes by
that I don't ask myself the question.
324
00:22:58,211 --> 00:23:00,422
"How did Tiffany Valiante die?"
325
00:23:01,840 --> 00:23:04,634
I am convinced
she did not take her own life.
326
00:23:07,053 --> 00:23:11,683
The lead investigating agency
into the death of Tiffany Valiante
327
00:23:13,017 --> 00:23:14,894
was the transit system.
328
00:23:18,940 --> 00:23:23,486
New Jersey Transit is one of America's
largest transit operators.
329
00:23:23,570 --> 00:23:26,197
It runs commuter rail trains
330
00:23:26,281 --> 00:23:30,785
and it has
a significant-size police force.
331
00:23:30,869 --> 00:23:33,997
And I have great respect
for transit police officers
332
00:23:33,997 --> 00:23:35,665
and the job they do.
333
00:23:35,665 --> 00:23:40,336
However, most transit police officers
will tell you,
334
00:23:40,420 --> 00:23:45,717
their wheelhouse
is not homicide investigations
335
00:23:46,384 --> 00:23:50,388
and not suspicious death investigations.
336
00:23:52,056 --> 00:23:55,894
The first thing investigators need to do,
337
00:23:55,894 --> 00:23:59,898
even in the case of a suspected incident
338
00:23:59,898 --> 00:24:03,026
of somebody
possibly taking their own life,
339
00:24:03,026 --> 00:24:07,822
is first determine whether
they were the victim of a murder.
340
00:24:08,740 --> 00:24:11,326
We have no indication that was ever done.
341
00:24:12,619 --> 00:24:15,205
[Paul] The area
where this whole event took place
342
00:24:15,205 --> 00:24:17,540
was not treated as a crime scene.
343
00:24:18,541 --> 00:24:21,002
People were walking all around there,
344
00:24:21,002 --> 00:24:25,006
and it had not been
roped off appropriately.
345
00:24:27,383 --> 00:24:29,344
[Stephan] It appeared from the outset
346
00:24:29,344 --> 00:24:34,182
to be a textbook example
of a rush to judgment
347
00:24:34,182 --> 00:24:38,770
to misclassify
the manner by which she died.
348
00:24:39,854 --> 00:24:41,814
This is the death certificate.
349
00:24:43,066 --> 00:24:47,862
Tiffany Valiante died
shortly before midnight, July 12th.
350
00:24:47,946 --> 00:24:51,950
On the 17th of July, when this is dated,
351
00:24:51,950 --> 00:24:55,745
the manner of death is suicide.
352
00:24:57,372 --> 00:25:02,752
You cannot draw conclusions
that early in an investigation.
353
00:25:03,503 --> 00:25:05,463
That's an impossibility.
354
00:25:07,465 --> 00:25:10,635
[Louise] Suicide closes a case,
355
00:25:10,635 --> 00:25:13,513
as far as
a prosecutor's office is concerned.
356
00:25:14,138 --> 00:25:16,641
As far as the medical examiner's office
is concerned.
357
00:25:16,641 --> 00:25:19,644
As far as New Jersey Transit is concerned.
358
00:25:19,644 --> 00:25:23,648
"This is a suicide,"
and it's simply a statistic.
359
00:25:24,399 --> 00:25:28,194
As far as the family's concerned,
it's their child,
360
00:25:28,278 --> 00:25:31,114
and they wanna know
what happened to their child.
361
00:25:33,741 --> 00:25:37,161
[Dianne] They should have
investigated like they were supposed to.
362
00:25:38,454 --> 00:25:41,332
You know, the State of New Jersey
has books on procedures
363
00:25:41,416 --> 00:25:45,086
on what they're supposed to follow,
and those procedures weren't followed.
364
00:25:48,506 --> 00:25:52,302
[Stephan] A full autopsy
was never conducted.
365
00:25:52,302 --> 00:25:55,138
No rape kit was ever performed.
366
00:25:55,138 --> 00:25:57,307
DNA was never tested.
367
00:25:57,307 --> 00:25:59,934
No organs were examined.
368
00:26:01,311 --> 00:26:02,186
Why?
369
00:26:02,812 --> 00:26:03,896
Why?
370
00:26:05,440 --> 00:26:09,402
You have to give weight
to the toxicology report.
371
00:26:09,402 --> 00:26:15,491
There was no alcohol,
no drugs in Tiffany Valiante's system.
372
00:26:15,575 --> 00:26:18,036
A totally clean toxicology report.
373
00:26:18,828 --> 00:26:21,414
After the toxicology report came back,
374
00:26:21,414 --> 00:26:25,501
and it was found that Tiffany
had no drugs or alcohol in her system,
375
00:26:25,585 --> 00:26:30,590
the manner of death probably should have
been amended to "undetermined."
376
00:26:32,008 --> 00:26:37,847
There's no reason to rule the case
"suicide" unless you're sure,
377
00:26:37,847 --> 00:26:39,891
you're absolutely sure,
378
00:26:41,309 --> 00:26:43,019
that this was a suicide.
379
00:26:44,437 --> 00:26:48,483
[Paul] Within a couple of days
after Tiffany's death,
380
00:26:48,483 --> 00:26:50,943
her remains were cremated.
381
00:26:51,027 --> 00:26:54,280
So it's not as if we can exhume the body
382
00:26:54,364 --> 00:26:56,407
and have a fresh look at this.
383
00:26:57,909 --> 00:27:02,038
[Louise] Also, the detective
does write in his report
384
00:27:02,038 --> 00:27:04,957
that no shoes were found at the scene.
385
00:27:05,041 --> 00:27:07,001
Her shoes were not with the body.
386
00:27:08,127 --> 00:27:10,004
To me, that is suspicious.
387
00:27:12,423 --> 00:27:15,843
[Dianne] When she walked away,
she had a white headband on,
388
00:27:15,927 --> 00:27:18,888
she had blue jean shorts
that were almost white,
389
00:27:18,888 --> 00:27:21,891
and she had a black T-shirt on and shoes.
390
00:27:23,226 --> 00:27:28,439
When they found her, all she had on
was a sports bra and black underwear.
391
00:27:29,190 --> 00:27:31,776
Well, where's her shorts?
Where's her shirt?
392
00:27:33,319 --> 00:27:37,156
[Louise] Isn't that one of the questions
a medical examiner would wanna know?
393
00:27:38,282 --> 00:27:43,621
The medical examiner's report
was so small, so scant.
394
00:27:47,542 --> 00:27:51,712
I saw no evidence
that they contacted Tiffany's doctor,
395
00:27:51,796 --> 00:27:54,465
that they contacted
anyone from her school.
396
00:27:55,133 --> 00:27:59,595
Nobody ever came and talked to us
and asked me questions about my daughter.
397
00:28:00,179 --> 00:28:03,558
[Robert, Jr.] They didn't talk to her mom
and dad. They didn't talk to anybody.
398
00:28:03,558 --> 00:28:07,729
You're just gonna say "oh, it's a suicide"
because somebody got hit on the tracks?
399
00:28:07,729 --> 00:28:08,896
That's crazy.
400
00:28:12,650 --> 00:28:15,862
[Louise] She had no history
of any medical problems.
401
00:28:15,862 --> 00:28:19,323
No history of drug abuse.
No history of alcohol abuse.
402
00:28:19,407 --> 00:28:20,867
An active athlete.
403
00:28:20,867 --> 00:28:25,288
Someone that was really loved
and was just doted on by her family.
404
00:28:28,583 --> 00:28:32,670
The phone messages
that I was able to look at,
405
00:28:32,754 --> 00:28:35,423
I didn't see anything really unusual.
406
00:28:35,923 --> 00:28:40,803
She had broken up with her girlfriend,
but it seemed to be amicable.
407
00:28:42,430 --> 00:28:44,849
[Dianne] Tiffany had
a girlfriend from Philly.
408
00:28:45,349 --> 00:28:50,521
It was, uh, right around that Friday
before she died that they broke up.
409
00:28:51,189 --> 00:28:52,482
But it was mutual.
410
00:28:57,361 --> 00:29:00,031
[Louise] There didn't
seem to be any hostility
411
00:29:00,031 --> 00:29:01,991
from the phone records that I read.
412
00:29:03,326 --> 00:29:08,414
And actually, Tiffany had started
another relationship with another woman,
413
00:29:09,165 --> 00:29:11,000
according to her phone records.
414
00:29:13,044 --> 00:29:14,462
[Dianne] She actually wrote,
415
00:29:14,462 --> 00:29:16,714
even in her phone
the night before she died,
416
00:29:16,714 --> 00:29:19,175
that "I'm actually content with my life."
417
00:29:21,761 --> 00:29:24,013
[Louise] So, why did she do this?
418
00:29:24,013 --> 00:29:26,516
If she committed suicide,
was there a reason?
419
00:29:26,516 --> 00:29:28,309
Why would she commit suicide?
420
00:29:35,107 --> 00:29:39,320
[Robert, Sr.] This happened at night,
and I came down early the next morning.
421
00:29:41,739 --> 00:29:46,577
I didn't want my brother, Stephen,
or his wife, Dianne,
422
00:29:46,661 --> 00:29:49,664
to have to walk down that tracks
and see what I saw.
423
00:29:50,456 --> 00:29:52,166
Pieces that they just left behind.
424
00:29:52,917 --> 00:29:54,919
[somber music playing]
425
00:29:56,462 --> 00:29:59,465
[Robert, Jr.] My father and I were
looking for things that were missing.
426
00:29:59,549 --> 00:30:01,050
{\an8}We're looking for her sneakers.
427
00:30:01,050 --> 00:30:02,677
{\an8}We're looking for her headband.
428
00:30:02,677 --> 00:30:08,015
We're looking for her earrings,
her jewelry, her shorts.
429
00:30:08,683 --> 00:30:10,434
[Robert, Sr.] I don't know how I did it,
430
00:30:10,518 --> 00:30:14,230
{\an8}but I picked up pieces of her skull
with hair on it.
431
00:30:14,230 --> 00:30:20,444
I picked up a jawbone with teeth
and various parts of her bones.
432
00:30:22,780 --> 00:30:25,366
We found one of her bracelets
and gave it to Dianne,
433
00:30:25,366 --> 00:30:26,867
and she has that today.
434
00:30:27,410 --> 00:30:30,204
And that was on her at the time.
435
00:30:32,206 --> 00:30:35,126
To have to pick up
pieces of her off the track
436
00:30:35,126 --> 00:30:38,588
was the most devastating thing
I ever done in my life.
437
00:30:44,135 --> 00:30:45,636
[Robert, Jr.] Walking to the tracks,
438
00:30:45,720 --> 00:30:49,307
I see bloody rubber gloves
laying on the ground.
439
00:30:49,307 --> 00:30:51,267
That scene's already contaminated.
440
00:30:52,143 --> 00:30:53,894
It wasn't even roped off.
441
00:30:55,271 --> 00:30:58,274
New Jersey Transit just...
They're not trained for that.
442
00:30:58,774 --> 00:31:01,277
And they didn't do a good job
cleaning the tracks.
443
00:31:02,069 --> 00:31:04,697
We would go down there
and keep looking, and looking,
444
00:31:04,697 --> 00:31:06,532
but we never found her shoes there,
445
00:31:06,616 --> 00:31:08,492
we never found her headband there,
446
00:31:08,576 --> 00:31:10,995
we never found any of her clothes there.
447
00:31:13,748 --> 00:31:17,126
Where is the stuff
that she was wearing from the party?
448
00:31:30,890 --> 00:31:34,518
[Dianne] Walking down Tilton Road,
just walking,
449
00:31:34,602 --> 00:31:37,647
I had already been
up and down that street a million times.
450
00:31:40,733 --> 00:31:44,403
For weeks, we were walking just looking
for any kind of sign of something
451
00:31:44,487 --> 00:31:46,864
'cause I knew
my daughter's shorts were missing.
452
00:31:46,948 --> 00:31:49,700
Her headband was missing.
Her shoes were missing.
453
00:31:49,784 --> 00:31:51,702
And as I'm walking along,
454
00:31:52,912 --> 00:31:59,251
I got to about here, and I looked over,
and I saw my daughter's shoes.
455
00:32:05,174 --> 00:32:08,177
[crying softly] And when I saw that,
I fell to the ground.
456
00:32:10,346 --> 00:32:13,599
And when I fell to the ground,
about six feet away,
457
00:32:13,683 --> 00:32:16,185
was Tiffany's white headband.
458
00:32:18,312 --> 00:32:21,607
I felt like a Mack truck hit me.
459
00:32:23,317 --> 00:32:24,652
I'll never forget that day.
460
00:32:24,652 --> 00:32:26,779
And I remember it like yesterday.
461
00:32:26,779 --> 00:32:28,823
We got a phone call from my Aunt Dianne.
462
00:32:30,032 --> 00:32:32,576
That she found
Tiffany's shoes and headband.
463
00:32:33,160 --> 00:32:35,413
And it was almost two miles away
464
00:32:35,413 --> 00:32:37,039
from where she was struck.
465
00:32:38,624 --> 00:32:41,127
I ran down there and she's just losing it.
466
00:32:41,127 --> 00:32:45,756
She's... I mean, my wife was hysterical.
I couldn't understand what she was saying.
467
00:32:48,843 --> 00:32:54,515
Her shoes and stuff were,
like, in here, this area.
468
00:32:56,642 --> 00:33:00,646
And they were side-by-side almost,
like a foot apart.
469
00:33:01,814 --> 00:33:05,109
The way they were positioned,
like, I just...
470
00:33:05,109 --> 00:33:07,945
I felt like somebody took her
right out of her shoes.
471
00:33:07,945 --> 00:33:09,029
That's how I felt.
472
00:33:10,614 --> 00:33:13,826
But other people thought
maybe somebody placed them there.
473
00:33:16,287 --> 00:33:18,289
New Jersey Transit came here.
474
00:33:18,289 --> 00:33:23,544
They took pictures of her shoes,
and they put the shoes in a brown bag.
475
00:33:23,544 --> 00:33:26,464
They took the items in
and that was the last you heard of it.
476
00:33:26,464 --> 00:33:28,340
You never heard anything else.
477
00:33:34,013 --> 00:33:35,848
They had all these items,
478
00:33:35,848 --> 00:33:39,685
but they were never sent out
for any type of testing
479
00:33:41,062 --> 00:33:44,899
to see if there was any other
possible DNA on them.
480
00:33:46,025 --> 00:33:48,819
Five years
after their daughter was killed,
481
00:33:48,903 --> 00:33:52,740
the families had to pay
to have those items tested for DNA.
482
00:33:54,116 --> 00:33:57,077
But the chain of custody
has been broken on that,
483
00:33:57,161 --> 00:33:59,413
so it's not of any use at all.
484
00:34:01,832 --> 00:34:03,918
[Dianne] After we found her shoes,
485
00:34:03,918 --> 00:34:06,378
we actually got about 15 of us together,
486
00:34:06,462 --> 00:34:08,964
and we scoured that woods
487
00:34:09,048 --> 00:34:11,717
{\an8}all the way to the train tracks
where she was hit,
488
00:34:11,801 --> 00:34:15,888
{\an8}looking for anything that would help
to prove that she didn't do this.
489
00:34:16,764 --> 00:34:19,600
{\an8}The one thing
that's still missing of my daughter's...
490
00:34:19,600 --> 00:34:21,185
{\an8}[voice breaks] ...is her shorts.
491
00:34:21,727 --> 00:34:23,479
[dark music playing]
492
00:34:23,479 --> 00:34:25,898
[Dianne] To this day,
those shorts are missing.
493
00:34:28,859 --> 00:34:32,947
[Paul] I asked myself,
"How did the shoes get to this area?"
494
00:34:36,408 --> 00:34:40,287
It may very well be
that Tiffany was the victim of foul play.
495
00:34:41,038 --> 00:34:44,708
Someone that was involved in the foul play
496
00:34:44,792 --> 00:34:50,130
picked those items up and threw them away
when they were leaving the scene.
497
00:34:55,427 --> 00:34:59,265
Another theory is that
Tiffany took her shoes and headband off
498
00:34:59,265 --> 00:35:03,185
where Dianne found them
and walked barefoot to the tracks.
499
00:35:05,646 --> 00:35:07,690
I don't know what sense it would make
500
00:35:07,690 --> 00:35:13,612
to walk from Tiffany's house
to where the shoes were found,
501
00:35:13,696 --> 00:35:16,740
and then take your shoes off
and put them in the woods,
502
00:35:16,824 --> 00:35:19,243
and then walk
to where the train strike happened.
503
00:35:21,370 --> 00:35:23,372
You got your shoes on. Why take 'em off?
504
00:35:29,795 --> 00:35:34,383
See how far we've gone so far
on this ride down the tracks?
505
00:35:36,719 --> 00:35:39,096
You're sitting in the back.
Can you feel this?
506
00:35:39,972 --> 00:35:41,640
- Feel the road surface?
- [producer] Yeah.
507
00:35:41,724 --> 00:35:43,434
How you doing that in bare feet?
508
00:35:43,934 --> 00:35:46,604
This is just a railroad bed
509
00:35:47,188 --> 00:35:49,982
and has nothing
but sharp rocks with edges.
510
00:35:55,112 --> 00:36:00,367
[Paul] If you look at the photographs
of Tiffany's feet,
511
00:36:00,451 --> 00:36:02,620
especially her right foot,
512
00:36:03,704 --> 00:36:07,208
there are no markings whatsoever
513
00:36:07,750 --> 00:36:09,919
that you would expect to see
514
00:36:09,919 --> 00:36:12,963
if someone had walked in their bare feet,
515
00:36:13,047 --> 00:36:18,886
especially over the rocks
and the glass along the tracks.
516
00:36:19,970 --> 00:36:22,431
[Dianne] If she walked
on the train tracks itself,
517
00:36:22,431 --> 00:36:24,600
she would have had splinters on her feet.
518
00:36:25,309 --> 00:36:28,771
To walk for miles
and have her feet completely clean
519
00:36:28,771 --> 00:36:31,398
proves to you that she did not walk.
520
00:36:34,235 --> 00:36:37,029
[Robert, Sr.] I walked that tracks
after the fact,
521
00:36:37,029 --> 00:36:39,698
and I had a hard time
walking on 'em with work shoes,
522
00:36:39,782 --> 00:36:43,786
and that's what makes me feel
that she never ever walked there.
523
00:36:44,995 --> 00:36:46,997
[ominous music playing]
524
00:36:50,709 --> 00:36:54,505
[Louise] If someone,
especially a female 6'3",
525
00:36:54,505 --> 00:36:56,465
is walking on the roadway,
526
00:36:56,465 --> 00:36:59,677
someone is going to see them,
and going to notice them,
527
00:36:59,677 --> 00:37:03,681
because it's very unusual to see anyone
walking on the roadway in this area.
528
00:37:04,556 --> 00:37:07,643
[Paul] If you look at the photos
529
00:37:08,310 --> 00:37:13,440
from Steve's deer cameras
outside of his home,
530
00:37:14,191 --> 00:37:18,028
you will see headlights of motor vehicles
531
00:37:18,112 --> 00:37:21,991
at the same time
Tiffany's walking down the driveway.
532
00:37:23,117 --> 00:37:28,080
I believe she enters a motor vehicle.
533
00:37:28,080 --> 00:37:31,333
I suspect voluntarily.
534
00:37:34,253 --> 00:37:37,381
I believe she got in a car
with somebody she thought she knew,
535
00:37:37,381 --> 00:37:39,258
was very comfortable with them.
536
00:37:42,177 --> 00:37:45,973
When she entered that vehicle,
somebody grabbed the phone.
537
00:37:45,973 --> 00:37:47,808
And I think that phone
538
00:37:48,350 --> 00:37:51,395
was thrown out of the car
539
00:37:51,395 --> 00:37:53,188
as they were pulling away.
540
00:37:54,398 --> 00:37:58,193
[Dianne] When they took her phone,
that's when I think reality hit.
541
00:37:58,277 --> 00:37:59,570
She was in trouble.
542
00:38:04,783 --> 00:38:07,244
[voice breaking] Everybody has
their own scenarios
543
00:38:07,328 --> 00:38:09,204
of what happened to my daughter.
544
00:38:09,955 --> 00:38:12,499
I thought,
"Well, maybe they tried to rape her,
545
00:38:12,583 --> 00:38:13,625
and she ran from them,
546
00:38:13,709 --> 00:38:16,045
and maybe she was trying
to get away from them,
547
00:38:16,045 --> 00:38:18,172
and then she just couldn't run anymore."
548
00:38:18,839 --> 00:38:22,509
[crying] I truly believe that she
was hanging on to this for dear life,
549
00:38:22,593 --> 00:38:25,262
trying to save herself,
you know what I mean?
550
00:38:25,346 --> 00:38:27,514
And trying to keep them from taking her.
551
00:38:27,598 --> 00:38:29,600
[mysterious music playing]
552
00:38:36,023 --> 00:38:38,609
{\an8}[Robert, Sr.] Right behind us,
where the tracks are,
553
00:38:38,609 --> 00:38:40,402
that's where Tiffany lost her life.
554
00:38:42,613 --> 00:38:46,950
It's really desolate back here.
It's really kind of creepy or spooky.
555
00:38:48,410 --> 00:38:51,455
If you were to pull back here,
you wouldn't hear anybody.
556
00:38:51,455 --> 00:38:53,540
You have the noise of the train
on one side,
557
00:38:53,624 --> 00:38:57,169
and you have the noise of the pike
to the right of me here.
558
00:38:59,296 --> 00:39:02,466
[Robert, Jr.] If I wanted to get rid
of somebody, what a better spot to do it.
559
00:39:02,466 --> 00:39:04,760
That remote location,
you could do anything you want.
560
00:39:04,760 --> 00:39:07,262
There's nothing there.
Nobody's gonna hear a scream.
561
00:39:07,346 --> 00:39:08,680
Nobody's gonna hear anything.
562
00:39:09,723 --> 00:39:12,309
What a perfect spot to commit a murder.
563
00:39:12,393 --> 00:39:14,395
[dark music playing]
564
00:39:18,524 --> 00:39:21,151
[Paul] If you look at the photographs
565
00:39:21,235 --> 00:39:24,947
that were taken by
the New Jersey Transit Police Department,
566
00:39:25,823 --> 00:39:29,785
as well as the New Jersey
State Medical Examiner's Office...
567
00:39:31,995 --> 00:39:36,125
you will see that at the point
that the train and the body of Tiffany
568
00:39:36,125 --> 00:39:38,710
came in contact with each other,
569
00:39:38,794 --> 00:39:41,797
there is what looks like
a large pool of blood.
570
00:39:43,799 --> 00:39:46,677
Which suggests that the body
could have been laid there
571
00:39:46,677 --> 00:39:49,805
and was bleeding
before the train hit the body.
572
00:39:51,181 --> 00:39:53,183
[ominous music playing]
573
00:39:55,060 --> 00:39:56,895
[Paul] They never tested anything.
574
00:39:56,979 --> 00:40:01,066
They said they had enough
to conclude that it was suicide
575
00:40:01,150 --> 00:40:02,776
without doing the testing.
576
00:40:03,652 --> 00:40:05,362
So it was never determined
577
00:40:05,446 --> 00:40:08,574
if that was, in fact,
Tiffany's blood on the tracks.
578
00:40:12,536 --> 00:40:16,915
The medical examiner in this report says,
579
00:40:16,999 --> 00:40:22,087
when referring to Tiffany's arms and legs,
580
00:40:22,671 --> 00:40:25,841
that they were cut from the torso.
581
00:40:25,841 --> 00:40:30,262
That word "cut" is right in their report.
582
00:40:30,262 --> 00:40:33,223
Not ripped away, but cut.
583
00:40:34,349 --> 00:40:36,101
And that says to me
584
00:40:36,185 --> 00:40:39,688
that there is a viable theory
585
00:40:39,688 --> 00:40:44,985
that she was harmed
before the body was placed on the tracks.
586
00:40:46,153 --> 00:40:47,654
The arms were placed out,
587
00:40:47,738 --> 00:40:50,949
and the legs
were hanging over the other track.
588
00:40:51,867 --> 00:40:54,411
[Dianne] Her feet were intact,
and her hands were intact.
589
00:40:54,495 --> 00:40:55,454
What's that tell you?
590
00:40:55,454 --> 00:40:59,500
She wasn't standing on that track
and hit by the train.
591
00:40:59,500 --> 00:41:01,335
She was laying there.
592
00:41:01,919 --> 00:41:03,045
They were cut off.
593
00:41:06,298 --> 00:41:09,510
[Robert, Sr.] I believe
somebody laid her on the tracks,
594
00:41:09,510 --> 00:41:12,554
and, uh, she bled out there.
595
00:41:14,848 --> 00:41:16,225
{\an8}[Robert, Jr.] Seeing the location,
596
00:41:16,225 --> 00:41:19,019
{\an8}definitely she was murdered
and laid on that tracks.
597
00:41:19,520 --> 00:41:21,021
No doubt in my mind.
598
00:41:21,021 --> 00:41:24,775
She was laid on those tracks.
That's how they got rid of her.
599
00:41:24,775 --> 00:41:26,735
And somebody's getting away with it.
600
00:41:27,778 --> 00:41:29,279
Somebody's getting away with it.
601
00:41:36,119 --> 00:41:39,331
{\an8}My name is Chuck Atkinson.
I'm a private investigator.
602
00:41:39,331 --> 00:41:42,292
{\an8}I was in New Jersey State Police
for 26 years.
603
00:41:42,376 --> 00:41:44,419
As a detective for 17 years.
604
00:41:44,503 --> 00:41:48,882
I've been working for Paul D'Amato
since early 2008.
605
00:41:48,966 --> 00:41:50,968
[suspenseful music playing]
606
00:41:52,636 --> 00:41:55,472
Paul and the family
had decided to set up a hotline,
607
00:41:55,556 --> 00:41:58,725
and they were looking
for any type of anonymous tips.
608
00:41:58,809 --> 00:42:00,060
And we got a call
609
00:42:00,060 --> 00:42:03,438
from a convenience store worker
610
00:42:03,522 --> 00:42:07,776
who had overheard three employees
of that convenience store
611
00:42:07,776 --> 00:42:10,529
speaking about the Valiante case.
612
00:42:11,697 --> 00:42:14,825
[Paul] I remember quite clearly
613
00:42:14,825 --> 00:42:17,828
my legal assistant telling me,
"There's a gentleman,
614
00:42:17,828 --> 00:42:21,873
and he has information
about Tiffany's death."
615
00:42:24,751 --> 00:42:27,921
{\an8}[on video] Sergeant Rosell's gonna be here
any minute. We can get started.
616
00:42:28,005 --> 00:42:33,260
{\an8}And that particular individual
was interviewed under oath.
617
00:42:33,260 --> 00:42:34,678
{\an8}Extensively.
618
00:42:34,678 --> 00:42:36,972
{\an8}[on video] Of course,
I read about it in the newspaper.
619
00:42:36,972 --> 00:42:40,392
{\an8}I heard about it, you know.
The kids were talking about it at work.
620
00:42:40,392 --> 00:42:43,729
{\an8}[Paul] He shared with that detective
621
00:42:43,729 --> 00:42:45,564
what he had heard.
622
00:42:45,564 --> 00:42:48,984
{\an8}I had been given some information
from these guys that work for me.
623
00:42:48,984 --> 00:42:52,654
[Chuck] They were telling a story
about how it had been a homicide.
624
00:42:52,738 --> 00:42:54,948
So the three subjects that he overheard
625
00:42:55,032 --> 00:42:58,201
did not have anything to do
with this homicide.
626
00:42:58,285 --> 00:43:00,954
They were just relating
something that they had heard.
627
00:43:02,247 --> 00:43:05,292
One of the subjects
was at the uncle's party
628
00:43:05,292 --> 00:43:07,586
that Tiffany was at that night,
629
00:43:07,586 --> 00:43:10,005
and he did see Tiffany at the party.
630
00:43:11,506 --> 00:43:13,842
There were references to an argument.
631
00:43:14,426 --> 00:43:17,554
[man on video] And the argument went on,
and then Tiffany left.
632
00:43:18,096 --> 00:43:21,266
{\an8}Now they told me
she was picked up by somebody.
633
00:43:21,350 --> 00:43:22,768
They knew Tiffany.
634
00:43:27,439 --> 00:43:32,569
[Chuck] It was two females and a male
who pick Tiffany up in a vehicle,
635
00:43:33,362 --> 00:43:36,323
taking her somewhere
near the train tracks.
636
00:43:36,323 --> 00:43:40,452
Stripped her naked, held her at gunpoint,
and humiliated her.
637
00:43:41,995 --> 00:43:44,498
- [man] I'm telling you third-party stuff.
- [officer] Yeah, right.
638
00:43:44,498 --> 00:43:47,042
- I'm just telling you what was told to me.
- [officer] Okay.
639
00:43:50,045 --> 00:43:53,048
{\an8}[Chuck] The prosecutor
interviewed the three individuals
640
00:43:53,048 --> 00:43:55,342
{\an8}that were overheard
at the convenience store.
641
00:43:55,342 --> 00:43:57,427
{\an8}[officer] With relation
to the possible homicide,
642
00:43:57,511 --> 00:43:58,887
{\an8}did you hear anything about that?
643
00:43:58,887 --> 00:44:02,599
{\an8}Like how it went down
or where that came from?
644
00:44:02,683 --> 00:44:04,643
{\an8}[man 1] No. I don't know.
645
00:44:05,352 --> 00:44:07,020
{\an8}[officer] Did you hear any other rumors?
646
00:44:07,104 --> 00:44:08,814
{\an8}- [man 2] I haven't heard anything.
- Nothing.
647
00:44:08,814 --> 00:44:09,898
{\an8}[man 2] No.
648
00:44:11,733 --> 00:44:15,821
{\an8}[officer] There's rumors that
you knew a lot about what happened.
649
00:44:15,821 --> 00:44:18,865
{\an8}[man 3] To be honest,
that sounds completely absurd.
650
00:44:18,949 --> 00:44:22,077
{\an8}[Chuck] All three witnesses
denied ever saying anything
651
00:44:22,077 --> 00:44:26,123
to the effect of what was overheard
by the convenience store worker.
652
00:44:26,123 --> 00:44:29,042
{\an8}[officer] Since that night,
have you heard anything about it?
653
00:44:29,126 --> 00:44:30,168
{\an8}[man 1] No, just...
654
00:44:32,129 --> 00:44:35,090
{\an8}It's just the... suicide.
655
00:44:35,090 --> 00:44:36,341
{\an8}[officer] So, there was no--
656
00:44:36,425 --> 00:44:38,385
{\an8}It was never brought up about
657
00:44:39,177 --> 00:44:41,847
{\an8}possibly being anything
other than a suicide?
658
00:44:41,847 --> 00:44:43,265
{\an8}[man 2] Uh, no. No.
659
00:44:46,226 --> 00:44:51,064
[Paul] In the reports of the interviews
of certain people that knew Tiffany,
660
00:44:51,773 --> 00:44:55,610
some of them did say that she was sad,
that she was depressed.
661
00:44:55,694 --> 00:44:58,196
{\an8}[woman] I don't think she was,
like, very happy.
662
00:44:58,280 --> 00:45:00,323
{\an8}Like... I mean, like...
663
00:45:00,407 --> 00:45:03,702
{\an8}I don't think you could see it unless
you were, like, really close to her.
664
00:45:03,702 --> 00:45:05,287
{\an8}-Because...
- [officer] Sure.
665
00:45:05,287 --> 00:45:08,748
{\an8}[woman] ...she always was, like,
so happy, and like...
666
00:45:08,832 --> 00:45:10,959
Well, like, if you really knew her,
667
00:45:10,959 --> 00:45:12,711
she just, like, I don't know.
668
00:45:12,711 --> 00:45:17,048
I just feel like
she felt like she could never fit in.
669
00:45:17,549 --> 00:45:20,719
[officer] Did she ever
mention anything to you before about, um...
670
00:45:20,719 --> 00:45:22,763
besides just noticing she wasn't happy,
671
00:45:22,763 --> 00:45:26,600
that she wanted to... she was thinking
about harming herself at all?
672
00:45:26,600 --> 00:45:27,684
{\an8}[woman] No.
673
00:45:28,602 --> 00:45:29,603
{\an8}[officer] Um...
674
00:45:31,563 --> 00:45:33,565
[somber music playing]
675
00:45:53,543 --> 00:45:55,545
[mysterious music playing]
676
00:45:58,465 --> 00:46:01,426
{\an8}[Paul] How did Tiffany get from her home
677
00:46:01,510 --> 00:46:05,472
{\an8}to where her body
came in contact with the train?
678
00:46:06,056 --> 00:46:07,307
Did she walk?
679
00:46:07,307 --> 00:46:10,268
Did someone pick her up
and drive her there?
680
00:46:10,352 --> 00:46:12,896
Was her death some kind of accident
681
00:46:12,896 --> 00:46:14,648
or was it foul play?
682
00:46:14,648 --> 00:46:16,733
[mysterious music continues]
683
00:46:17,943 --> 00:46:22,072
[Paul] There are people out there,
as we speak,
684
00:46:22,656 --> 00:46:25,200
that have knowledge of what happened.
685
00:46:25,200 --> 00:46:28,578
And I'm begging them to come forward
686
00:46:28,662 --> 00:46:30,288
and help this family.
687
00:46:35,001 --> 00:46:36,837
[Stephen] Before my daughter
went to college,
688
00:46:36,837 --> 00:46:39,089
I promised her
I'd build her a volleyball court.
689
00:46:39,089 --> 00:46:41,967
And after Tiffany's passing, I said,
690
00:46:41,967 --> 00:46:44,344
"Well, I promised it." So I built it.
691
00:46:47,764 --> 00:46:51,434
Tiffany just couldn't wait to
go to college and have fun at volleyball.
692
00:46:53,603 --> 00:46:57,148
But somebody took that away from her,
and it ain't fair.
693
00:46:58,358 --> 00:46:59,484
We need justice.
694
00:47:10,203 --> 00:47:12,122
[Stephen] Is it rough every day? Sure.
695
00:47:12,122 --> 00:47:13,957
Every day, it's a job to wake up.
696
00:47:13,957 --> 00:47:15,667
Every day, to go to sleep.
697
00:47:15,667 --> 00:47:19,462
But it's what I have to do
until I find out who did this to our baby.
698
00:47:22,632 --> 00:47:27,137
[Dianne] This here is a cabinet of nothing
but beautiful memories of Tiffany.
699
00:47:27,137 --> 00:47:28,096
And...
700
00:47:29,639 --> 00:47:32,601
friends and relatives
have brought things here
701
00:47:32,601 --> 00:47:35,478
in memory of Tiffany
to put in her cabinet.
702
00:47:35,562 --> 00:47:37,689
Tiffany's bracelet here.
703
00:47:38,565 --> 00:47:41,943
This was on her the night she died.
704
00:47:42,902 --> 00:47:45,196
So I wore it for a long time.
705
00:47:45,947 --> 00:47:50,911
This is Tiffany here
in the solid wood urn.
706
00:47:51,703 --> 00:47:53,955
It's a prayer box. I pray every night.
707
00:47:56,207 --> 00:47:58,043
Then I put a message in there.
708
00:48:01,254 --> 00:48:03,214
"For justice for Tiffany
709
00:48:03,298 --> 00:48:06,718
and hope that the people
that did this to her will come forward."
710
00:48:13,767 --> 00:48:14,768
[kisses]
711
00:48:20,982 --> 00:48:22,359
I love you, Tiffy.
712
00:48:37,123 --> 00:48:40,126
[dramatic music playing]