1 00:00:01,712 --> 00:00:03,487 NARRATOR: In the criminal justice system 2 00:00:03,548 --> 00:00:07,360 the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups, 3 00:00:07,418 --> 00:00:09,295 the police who investigate crime 4 00:00:09,353 --> 00:00:12,163 and the district attorneys who prosecute the offenders. 5 00:00:12,223 --> 00:00:13,998 These are their stories. 6 00:00:14,125 --> 00:00:15,126 (WOMAN MOANING) 7 00:00:15,193 --> 00:00:16,604 The one in the yellow G-string? 8 00:00:16,661 --> 00:00:17,662 Yeah. 9 00:00:17,728 --> 00:00:19,208 I think she liked me. 10 00:00:19,264 --> 00:00:21,471 You also believe she's a grad student at Columbia? 11 00:00:21,533 --> 00:00:23,706 Comp Lit. They're all weird. 12 00:00:24,103 --> 00:00:26,879 I didn't think that was anatomically possible. 13 00:00:26,972 --> 00:00:29,953 I don't think the Surgeon General recommends the position. 14 00:00:30,008 --> 00:00:32,215 He ought to put a warning label on her. 15 00:00:32,511 --> 00:00:33,649 (WOMAN MOANING ON TV) 16 00:00:33,912 --> 00:00:35,892 Hey, Dr. Jerry. 17 00:00:35,948 --> 00:00:39,395 Are you and Sheila going by Doctor and Mrs., 18 00:00:39,451 --> 00:00:42,227 or Doctor and Doctor, or Doctor and Mrs. Doctor? 19 00:00:42,287 --> 00:00:45,393 I have any more drinks, I don't think there'll be a wedding. 20 00:00:45,457 --> 00:00:46,800 I'll drive you to church. 21 00:00:46,859 --> 00:00:50,705 Hey, you know, I think I left my wallet in that stripper bar. 22 00:00:51,063 --> 00:00:54,067 WALLY: And here's couple number two. Yeah! 23 00:00:54,166 --> 00:00:56,272 At least this one's younger than my mother. GIRL ON TV: Stop it! 24 00:00:56,336 --> 00:00:57,406 And this one can act. 25 00:00:57,470 --> 00:00:58,471 Stop! 26 00:00:58,538 --> 00:01:01,644 I think the handcuffs are motivating her. It's a method technique. 27 00:01:01,708 --> 00:01:03,244 She looks really scared. 28 00:01:03,309 --> 00:01:05,653 Hey, Frank, it's after 3:00. You want to share a cab? 29 00:01:05,712 --> 00:01:07,419 I'm married already. I'm staying. 30 00:01:07,480 --> 00:01:10,791 You know, what do you think he's going to do with that pillow? 31 00:01:11,217 --> 00:01:13,026 Put it under her ass? 32 00:01:13,453 --> 00:01:15,160 What about that? 33 00:01:15,855 --> 00:01:17,334 Hey, what the... 34 00:01:17,390 --> 00:01:18,994 (SHRIEKING) 35 00:01:19,959 --> 00:01:21,063 (GUN FIRING ON TV) 36 00:01:21,928 --> 00:01:23,373 (MEN EXCLAIMING) 37 00:01:25,632 --> 00:01:26,940 (SHRIEKING) 38 00:01:27,934 --> 00:01:29,936 Stop it! Stop! 39 00:01:32,840 --> 00:01:33,875 (GUN FIRING ON TV) 40 00:01:33,941 --> 00:01:36,547 It's supposed to be a collection of amateur porn. 41 00:01:36,610 --> 00:01:38,988 You know, horny housewives. 42 00:01:39,113 --> 00:01:41,423 BRISCOE: This was for a bachelor party? Yeah. 43 00:01:41,482 --> 00:01:44,622 We didn't want to do hookers. You know, nowadays. 44 00:01:45,085 --> 00:01:48,464 I heard about these things, but I always thought they were an urban legend. 45 00:01:48,522 --> 00:01:50,160 Where'd you get this tape, Mr. Baker? 46 00:01:50,224 --> 00:01:52,727 Riga Video on my corner. 47 00:01:53,494 --> 00:01:57,032 My 10-year-old niece was over last week. I rented Dumbo there. 48 00:01:57,164 --> 00:01:59,235 Well, you did the right thing, bringing it in. 49 00:01:59,300 --> 00:02:01,507 I'm on my way to the wedding. 50 00:02:01,802 --> 00:02:04,544 I wish the happy couple a lot of luck. 51 00:02:07,942 --> 00:02:11,789 Snuff films. There were some fakes floating around in the '80s. 52 00:02:11,846 --> 00:02:13,154 (GIRL SCREAMING ON TV) 53 00:02:13,215 --> 00:02:14,717 You think she's acting? 54 00:02:15,850 --> 00:02:16,920 (GUN FIRING ON TV) 55 00:02:17,485 --> 00:02:18,623 Nope. 56 00:03:08,604 --> 00:03:12,643 Those XXX tapes, I don't watch them. It is against my religion. 57 00:03:12,942 --> 00:03:14,319 But renting them isn't? 58 00:03:14,377 --> 00:03:15,685 This is America. 59 00:03:15,745 --> 00:03:18,783 It's called Home-Cooked Pies. You got the box it came in? 60 00:03:18,848 --> 00:03:20,350 KHAN: Let me see. 61 00:03:25,022 --> 00:03:26,262 Here. 62 00:03:26,657 --> 00:03:29,001 "The girls next door you always dreamed about" 63 00:03:29,059 --> 00:03:31,403 "behind closed doors for the first time." 64 00:03:31,461 --> 00:03:32,769 Or the last time. 65 00:03:32,829 --> 00:03:36,174 Produced by I & B Entertainment, New York City. 66 00:03:36,233 --> 00:03:37,769 What is all this about? 67 00:03:37,834 --> 00:03:41,748 This tape has been rented many times. My customers have never complained. 68 00:03:41,805 --> 00:03:43,375 And nobody called the cops. 69 00:03:43,440 --> 00:03:44,817 This is America. 70 00:03:48,779 --> 00:03:50,281 So it's mine. So what? 71 00:03:50,347 --> 00:03:53,885 So there's a girl on it getting raped, and then getting killed. 72 00:03:53,950 --> 00:03:56,396 Come on. You think I'd touch something like that? 73 00:03:56,453 --> 00:03:59,196 "I & B Entertainment, Producer." That's you. 74 00:03:59,257 --> 00:04:00,736 Nice word, producer. 75 00:04:00,792 --> 00:04:02,567 My mother thinks I'm Mike Todd. 76 00:04:02,627 --> 00:04:04,004 You're not. 77 00:04:04,495 --> 00:04:07,908 Hey, come on. I run ads in swinger magazines. 78 00:04:08,700 --> 00:04:12,477 I mean, every freak in the country's got a video camera in his bedroom, right? 79 00:04:13,438 --> 00:04:16,351 They send me footage, I send them 500 bucks. 80 00:04:16,574 --> 00:04:19,145 I compile it, I dupe it, I ship it out. 81 00:04:19,911 --> 00:04:21,083 NICK: People love the stuff. 82 00:04:21,145 --> 00:04:23,352 So you saw the one we're talking about? 83 00:04:23,414 --> 00:04:25,451 Maybe the first couple of minutes. 84 00:04:25,516 --> 00:04:28,520 I mean, all I need to know is that they're in focus and they're naked. 85 00:04:28,586 --> 00:04:30,361 Where'd you get this footage? 86 00:04:30,488 --> 00:04:31,592 (SIGHS) 87 00:04:31,656 --> 00:04:33,192 What number is it on the tape? 88 00:04:33,257 --> 00:04:34,827 BRISCOE: It's the second one. 89 00:04:35,527 --> 00:04:37,871 Home-Cooked Pies. 90 00:04:39,598 --> 00:04:40,906 There. 91 00:04:41,133 --> 00:04:42,134 (CLEARS THROAT) 92 00:04:42,201 --> 00:04:46,479 The kid in the tape walked in off the street. He wanted his money in cash. 93 00:04:46,538 --> 00:04:48,108 And you never saw him before? 94 00:04:48,173 --> 00:04:49,277 No. 95 00:04:49,341 --> 00:04:50,649 People know where to find me. 96 00:04:50,709 --> 00:04:52,245 But you got his name, right? 97 00:04:52,311 --> 00:04:54,848 Right. Signed a release. 98 00:04:56,682 --> 00:05:00,027 You'd think this bastard was selling videos on how to knit an afghan. 99 00:05:00,085 --> 00:05:03,589 If this is what they send in, I'd hate to see what their private collection's like. 100 00:05:03,655 --> 00:05:06,363 Hey, how'd you like to be in one of these movies? 101 00:05:06,425 --> 00:05:09,406 Are you kidding? I don't even like to look at my own X-rays. 102 00:05:09,461 --> 00:05:12,671 Guy says he finds these scumbags in swinger magazines. 103 00:05:12,766 --> 00:05:17,112 Yeah, let's see if this Malcolm Zanacek has a current subscription. 104 00:05:21,374 --> 00:05:26,119 Our readers don't pay $50 a year to get their names on a police report, Detective. 105 00:05:26,212 --> 00:05:27,520 It's a matter of privacy. 106 00:05:27,580 --> 00:05:29,992 And this is a matter of rape and murder. 107 00:05:30,049 --> 00:05:32,893 And the guy we're looking for may be one of your readers. 108 00:05:32,952 --> 00:05:34,329 I don't think so. 109 00:05:34,454 --> 00:05:37,401 Rape isn't a part of the swinging lifestyle. 110 00:05:37,791 --> 00:05:40,601 The pleasure comes from an open and willing sharing. 111 00:05:40,693 --> 00:05:43,037 But whatever happened to romance? 112 00:05:43,096 --> 00:05:46,805 Our readers are interested in exploring another side of their sexual selves. 113 00:05:46,866 --> 00:05:49,245 Yeah. The side marked "this end up." 114 00:05:50,271 --> 00:05:54,378 Hey, Miss Kerr, we're not asking for the formula for the secret aphrodisiac. 115 00:05:54,442 --> 00:05:56,046 I'd like to help, but I'm sure you can... 116 00:05:56,110 --> 00:05:57,748 Look, we can get a warrant 117 00:05:57,812 --> 00:06:00,816 and knock on the door of every single subscriber of your magazine, 118 00:06:00,881 --> 00:06:02,656 or you can help us with one name. 119 00:06:02,716 --> 00:06:04,525 Malcolm Zanacek. 120 00:06:07,655 --> 00:06:09,191 (PEOPLE CHATTERING) 121 00:06:13,661 --> 00:06:14,765 Nope. 122 00:06:15,729 --> 00:06:18,903 Maybe your guy likes to browse at the newsstand. 123 00:06:22,103 --> 00:06:24,344 LOGAN: Okay. All right, thanks a lot. 124 00:06:25,907 --> 00:06:27,511 What are you looking for, a date? 125 00:06:27,576 --> 00:06:30,819 "Open-minded MBBF seeks mature man." 126 00:06:31,346 --> 00:06:34,088 What's that? Male bisexual bondage freak? 127 00:06:34,149 --> 00:06:37,062 I'm more in the mood for a BLT. What'd you get? 128 00:06:37,619 --> 00:06:40,395 Big surprise. No record on Malcolm Zanacek. 129 00:06:40,455 --> 00:06:43,595 It means he's smart enough not to put his real name on a snuff film. 130 00:06:43,658 --> 00:06:46,502 Yeah, but he's dumb enough to star in the film. 131 00:06:46,661 --> 00:06:49,801 Dumb but not shy. There was a witness there. 132 00:06:49,931 --> 00:06:52,969 Somebody was adjusting focus. The camera moved. 133 00:06:53,902 --> 00:06:56,815 Let's have the video freaks take a look at the tape. 134 00:06:58,106 --> 00:07:02,487 It was recorded November 23rd, assuming the clock in the camera was set correctly. 135 00:07:02,578 --> 00:07:04,956 He was celebrating Thanksgiving a day early. 136 00:07:05,014 --> 00:07:07,358 Well, we didn't see any date stamp when we watched it. 137 00:07:07,416 --> 00:07:08,793 No, it was coded on the tape. 138 00:07:08,851 --> 00:07:11,855 You can raise it any time by pushing the right button. 139 00:07:11,921 --> 00:07:14,060 LOGAN: So we got the when. What about the who? 140 00:07:18,194 --> 00:07:20,105 This is the best I can do with him. 141 00:07:22,198 --> 00:07:24,735 Great, if we knew who it was we'd know who it was. 142 00:07:24,867 --> 00:07:28,371 Well, he's about 5'10", white, late teens to mid 20s. 143 00:07:28,471 --> 00:07:30,974 BRISCOE: Yeah, that narrows it down to about a million guys. 144 00:07:31,040 --> 00:07:33,111 SCHWARTZ: There aren't a million of these. 145 00:07:36,012 --> 00:07:37,047 The window? 146 00:07:37,113 --> 00:07:39,560 SCHWARTZ: Yeah, 6' wide and nearly floor-to-ceiling. 147 00:07:40,117 --> 00:07:43,121 And check out the gate. How often do you see that around here? 148 00:07:43,253 --> 00:07:45,233 How do we know it's from around here? 149 00:07:45,322 --> 00:07:47,359 There was a radio on. 150 00:07:48,225 --> 00:07:49,704 ANNOUNCER ON RADIO: This weekend only. 151 00:07:49,760 --> 00:07:53,503 Selected models on sale at prices you won't believe, folks. 152 00:07:53,564 --> 00:07:57,171 So come on in at the Appliance Circus at 555... 153 00:07:57,234 --> 00:07:59,145 Appliance Circus on Broadway. 154 00:07:59,202 --> 00:08:01,512 Can we take another look at the girl? 155 00:08:02,372 --> 00:08:03,749 (SCREAMING) 156 00:08:04,675 --> 00:08:06,245 Man, she's just a kid. 157 00:08:06,310 --> 00:08:08,119 You want me to print you a copy? LOGAN: Yeah. 158 00:08:08,178 --> 00:08:10,283 You'll want her thigh, too. 159 00:08:31,636 --> 00:08:34,173 A tattoo of an eyeball with a knife through it? 160 00:08:34,239 --> 00:08:35,843 Somebody would have made a note. 161 00:08:35,907 --> 00:08:39,286 Well, if the skin was partly decomposed, would you maybe have missed it? 162 00:08:39,744 --> 00:08:42,054 Yeah. Then we wouldn't have made a note. 163 00:08:42,113 --> 00:08:45,526 It's about three months ago. White female. Looked like a teenager. 164 00:08:45,583 --> 00:08:49,554 Who doesn't? Hookers, runaways, DOA. 165 00:08:49,621 --> 00:08:51,066 And nobody knows their name. 166 00:08:51,122 --> 00:08:52,830 Yeah, with tattoos? 167 00:08:52,891 --> 00:08:54,234 MALONE: Okay. 168 00:08:55,060 --> 00:08:58,041 We got Hell's Angel's wings, 169 00:08:58,130 --> 00:09:01,339 a rose, a rose, 170 00:09:02,134 --> 00:09:03,408 a rose, 171 00:09:04,336 --> 00:09:06,976 unidentified flower, possibly a rose, 172 00:09:07,906 --> 00:09:12,082 and one "Sandy loves Frank" on a left buttock. 173 00:09:12,144 --> 00:09:15,250 But this, this is Sandy Wilner. We cleared this one already. 174 00:09:15,314 --> 00:09:16,952 Was this girl reported missing? 175 00:09:17,016 --> 00:09:19,462 If she was, nobody mentioned the decoration. 176 00:09:20,019 --> 00:09:23,228 Well, there can't be that many tattoo parlors around. 177 00:09:23,288 --> 00:09:24,494 Why'd you come to me? 178 00:09:24,556 --> 00:09:27,469 Antonio over on Eighth Street said this looks like your work. 179 00:09:27,526 --> 00:09:31,031 Antonio can't ink a straight line so he knew it couldn't be his. 180 00:09:31,264 --> 00:09:34,006 Yeah, I remember this. The red took very nicely. 181 00:09:34,267 --> 00:09:35,940 Gonna last this girl a lifetime. 182 00:09:36,002 --> 00:09:37,572 It already did. 183 00:09:37,737 --> 00:09:40,308 Dagger through the eye, is that a standard design of yours? 184 00:09:40,373 --> 00:09:43,752 A little macabre, don't you think? No, the girl brought it in. 185 00:09:43,810 --> 00:09:45,050 You know her name? 186 00:09:45,111 --> 00:09:46,715 No, but I saved the artwork. 187 00:09:47,480 --> 00:09:49,653 Always looking for new ideas. 188 00:09:53,687 --> 00:09:56,691 Here it is. I wrote her name on it. Corey. 189 00:09:57,824 --> 00:09:59,394 Nice copy work. 190 00:09:59,459 --> 00:10:00,904 I added some blood. 191 00:10:00,960 --> 00:10:02,268 What is that? 192 00:10:02,329 --> 00:10:04,400 It looks like part of a flyer to a band. 193 00:10:04,464 --> 00:10:06,604 And the eye is their emblem? 194 00:10:06,767 --> 00:10:10,840 "Live at the Club" something-or-other, "Seeing-Eye Dogs." 195 00:10:15,743 --> 00:10:18,314 Hey, are you the famous Seeing-Eye Dogs? 196 00:10:18,379 --> 00:10:20,916 Yeah, we used to be. Now we're Protozoa. Who are you? 197 00:10:20,981 --> 00:10:21,982 We're the police. 198 00:10:22,049 --> 00:10:24,427 Too late, guys. Sting already used that one. 199 00:10:24,585 --> 00:10:25,791 You know a girl named Corey? 200 00:10:25,853 --> 00:10:26,957 Why? 201 00:10:27,388 --> 00:10:29,595 Corey. With a 202 00:10:29,657 --> 00:10:31,568 What happened to her? She got dead. 203 00:10:31,625 --> 00:10:32,968 You know her? 204 00:10:33,027 --> 00:10:34,301 Not me. 205 00:10:34,362 --> 00:10:36,273 She used to hang around with this crappy drummer 206 00:10:36,330 --> 00:10:38,503 we used when Boffer got sick. 207 00:10:38,566 --> 00:10:40,773 You know, Kenny. What's his name? 208 00:10:42,137 --> 00:10:44,242 What's his name, Kenny? 209 00:10:44,606 --> 00:10:45,607 Mitchell Pauley. 210 00:10:45,674 --> 00:10:46,982 You know where we can find him? 211 00:10:47,042 --> 00:10:49,545 Yeah. I hear his career's really taken off. 212 00:10:50,345 --> 00:10:52,689 Corey? What, is she in trouble or something? 213 00:10:52,748 --> 00:10:55,558 Well, maybe. We heard you were seeing her pretty regularly. 214 00:10:55,617 --> 00:10:58,325 No, not since last year. I haven't seen her for a couple months now. 215 00:10:58,387 --> 00:10:59,422 Really, why's that? 216 00:10:59,488 --> 00:11:00,626 She ran away. 217 00:11:00,689 --> 00:11:05,638 Her parents got divorced. Mrs. Russell, her mom, she's a real bitch. 218 00:11:06,528 --> 00:11:08,508 Corey's kind of messed up. 219 00:11:08,563 --> 00:11:10,509 Hey, she didn't tell you where she was going? 220 00:11:10,565 --> 00:11:12,067 I mean, weren't you her boyfriend? 221 00:11:12,134 --> 00:11:13,238 Oh, no, it was casual, man. 222 00:11:13,301 --> 00:11:15,804 I mean, you know how girls just like to hang out with musicians, right? 223 00:11:15,871 --> 00:11:18,614 Oh, yeah, yeah, right. She never called you after she ran away? 224 00:11:18,674 --> 00:11:20,449 No, I had a new girl already. 225 00:11:20,510 --> 00:11:22,387 Do you have Mrs. Russell's address? 226 00:11:28,084 --> 00:11:29,495 There it is. 227 00:11:29,619 --> 00:11:30,996 "Oh, hello, Mrs. Russell." 228 00:11:31,053 --> 00:11:34,432 "We just saw a video of your daughter getting raped and shot in the head." 229 00:11:34,490 --> 00:11:35,628 You want me to do it? 230 00:11:35,691 --> 00:11:37,227 No, I'll do it. 231 00:11:45,201 --> 00:11:46,874 BRISCOE: Corey? 232 00:11:46,936 --> 00:11:48,847 Yeah. Who are you? 233 00:11:53,976 --> 00:11:56,480 Oh, she's run away three or four times. 234 00:11:56,580 --> 00:11:59,186 I come home from work, she's not there. 235 00:11:59,249 --> 00:12:02,389 I don't know if she'll be back in an hour or two days. 236 00:12:02,619 --> 00:12:04,326 Like you really care. 237 00:12:05,355 --> 00:12:07,096 And this is what I have to deal with. 238 00:12:07,157 --> 00:12:09,398 Mrs. Russell, we thought your daughter was dead. 239 00:12:09,459 --> 00:12:11,097 The gun wasn't real. 240 00:12:11,161 --> 00:12:13,573 What kind of a game were you playing? 241 00:12:14,298 --> 00:12:16,300 Do you realize how dangerous this is? 242 00:12:16,366 --> 00:12:18,277 I wasn't playing a game. 243 00:12:20,604 --> 00:12:24,074 This tape was in video stores? 244 00:12:24,141 --> 00:12:25,449 Is that all you care about? 245 00:12:25,542 --> 00:12:28,751 Look, somebody has to care about something sometimes! 246 00:12:28,812 --> 00:12:32,022 Mrs. Russell, why don't we just take this a little slower... 247 00:12:32,083 --> 00:12:36,395 Yet she thinks I'm evil if I don't let her get a ring through her nipple. 248 00:12:36,454 --> 00:12:37,831 I never said that. 249 00:12:37,889 --> 00:12:39,891 You're not home enough to say anything. 250 00:12:39,958 --> 00:12:41,995 You're out making pornography. 251 00:12:42,060 --> 00:12:44,540 You think I let them do this to me? 252 00:12:48,399 --> 00:12:50,436 You don't understand anything. 253 00:12:51,870 --> 00:12:54,942 Tell it to me, Corey. What happened? 254 00:12:59,510 --> 00:13:00,989 They raped me. 255 00:13:04,282 --> 00:13:05,920 Who are they? 256 00:13:07,752 --> 00:13:12,065 I met these guys at a party, who took me to a bar where I met these other guys, 257 00:13:12,958 --> 00:13:15,199 then they invited me back to their place. 258 00:13:16,095 --> 00:13:17,904 And you went? Mrs. Russell... 259 00:13:17,963 --> 00:13:20,034 I didn't know this was going to happen. 260 00:13:21,467 --> 00:13:23,344 VAN BUREN: What were their names? 261 00:13:25,204 --> 00:13:27,047 Aland Bill, I think. 262 00:13:27,706 --> 00:13:29,617 Bill was the one running the camera. 263 00:13:29,842 --> 00:13:32,186 You don't know their last names? 264 00:13:32,978 --> 00:13:35,117 Where did they take you? 265 00:13:35,414 --> 00:13:37,655 I don't know. I'd had a lot to drink. 266 00:13:38,517 --> 00:13:41,361 It's not so easy to get that drunk, Corey. 267 00:13:42,187 --> 00:13:44,133 If you wanna be, it is. 268 00:13:47,961 --> 00:13:49,872 The family of the year it's not. 269 00:13:50,030 --> 00:13:53,170 Hey, a messed-up kid like her is just asking for something like this. 270 00:13:53,233 --> 00:13:55,338 She's lucky it wasn't a snuff film. 271 00:13:55,402 --> 00:13:58,440 It looked real. I could've sworn that girl was killed. 272 00:13:58,505 --> 00:14:01,577 You think the guy faked it for fun or for $500? 273 00:14:01,641 --> 00:14:05,179 What about the guy who bought it? Doesn't that make him an accessory? 274 00:14:05,245 --> 00:14:06,883 It might stand up. 275 00:14:07,013 --> 00:14:09,823 It might make him remember the rapist's real name. 276 00:14:10,483 --> 00:14:13,657 We got him for rape, Mike, even if we never find the guy who did it. 277 00:14:13,720 --> 00:14:15,597 That is crap, and you know it. 278 00:14:15,655 --> 00:14:18,693 Hey, you paid him for it. That makes you and him partners. 279 00:14:18,758 --> 00:14:20,135 Your lawyer can explain it to you. 280 00:14:20,193 --> 00:14:22,640 Hey, I'd tell you his name if I knew it. 281 00:14:22,697 --> 00:14:25,940 Did you look in here, Nick? I mean, maybe you wrote it down. 282 00:14:26,000 --> 00:14:27,377 Cut it out. 283 00:14:28,836 --> 00:14:30,782 Okay, you look. 284 00:14:31,539 --> 00:14:33,280 Come here. What... 285 00:14:34,909 --> 00:14:36,513 Look at that. Hey! 286 00:14:36,577 --> 00:14:38,784 I'm going to file a complaint against you bastards. 287 00:14:38,846 --> 00:14:42,157 Yeah, and we're going to unroll every inch of tape in your warehouse 288 00:14:42,216 --> 00:14:43,217 looking for evidence. 289 00:14:43,284 --> 00:14:47,528 Look, look, you thought she was shot. That was an act. 290 00:14:47,588 --> 00:14:49,329 Maybe the rape was an act, too, huh? 291 00:14:49,390 --> 00:14:52,769 Yeah, we got a 16-year-old girl who says different. Arrest him, Mike. 292 00:14:52,827 --> 00:14:54,101 I don't want to get my hands dirty. 293 00:14:54,161 --> 00:14:56,971 I don't know his name. Oh, jeez! 294 00:14:57,031 --> 00:14:58,102 Keep looking. Come on, look. 295 00:14:58,166 --> 00:14:59,509 Wait, wait. 296 00:15:01,169 --> 00:15:04,275 I bought some other tapes from him before, okay? 297 00:15:05,040 --> 00:15:06,417 Thank you, Nick. 298 00:15:08,377 --> 00:15:09,651 BRISCOE: That's not the same kid. 299 00:15:09,711 --> 00:15:10,917 LOGAN: And that's not Corey. 300 00:15:11,580 --> 00:15:13,719 BRISCOE: Not much older than Corey, though. 301 00:15:14,816 --> 00:15:16,727 But this one's not complaining. 302 00:15:16,985 --> 00:15:18,089 Next. 303 00:15:27,029 --> 00:15:28,406 LOGAN: That's him. 304 00:15:29,631 --> 00:15:33,306 With a different girl. Whatever happened to spin the bottle? 305 00:15:33,535 --> 00:15:35,641 Whatever happened to their parents? 306 00:15:40,977 --> 00:15:42,388 What was that? 307 00:15:44,013 --> 00:15:45,219 Run it again. 308 00:15:49,118 --> 00:15:50,756 BRISCOE: Did you see that? 309 00:15:51,120 --> 00:15:53,031 Here's where the recording cut out. 310 00:15:53,089 --> 00:15:54,124 Power failure? 311 00:15:54,190 --> 00:15:56,636 Yeah, it lasted 0.03 seconds, 312 00:15:56,692 --> 00:15:59,366 and during which it did not record over the previous image. 313 00:15:59,429 --> 00:16:00,874 The guy taped over an old tape? 314 00:16:00,930 --> 00:16:02,341 Don't you? 315 00:16:02,699 --> 00:16:05,202 What's the old tape? Gangbang Granny? 316 00:16:05,435 --> 00:16:09,315 Looks like a family birthday party. Yeah. 317 00:16:11,007 --> 00:16:12,419 Check this out. 318 00:16:16,847 --> 00:16:18,724 At Danny's Steak House. 319 00:16:19,983 --> 00:16:21,223 Yes, sir. Right this way, please. 320 00:16:21,285 --> 00:16:23,026 Detectives, we have a few birthday parties here. 321 00:16:23,087 --> 00:16:24,122 For old ladies? 322 00:16:24,188 --> 00:16:26,691 Old ladies, young ladies, men dressed as ladies. 323 00:16:26,757 --> 00:16:29,761 Look, we pulled this off the video. Does it ring any bells? 324 00:16:29,827 --> 00:16:32,467 Yeah. They had the $8 wine. 325 00:16:32,529 --> 00:16:34,770 Maybe the waiter would remember. Is he around? 326 00:16:34,832 --> 00:16:36,869 Not since November. He moved to Vegas. 327 00:16:36,967 --> 00:16:41,040 Believe it or not, that helps. Now how long has the busboy been with you? 328 00:16:41,104 --> 00:16:42,811 I don't know. Since August. 329 00:16:42,873 --> 00:16:46,878 Okay, so between August and November, a party of 10, a birthday cake... 330 00:16:46,944 --> 00:16:49,289 I'll check my reservation book. 331 00:16:53,485 --> 00:16:56,125 It was my mother's birthday. We're a very close family. 332 00:16:56,187 --> 00:16:58,360 Why are the police investigating? 333 00:16:58,423 --> 00:17:00,630 Well, you did make a videotape of the party? 334 00:17:00,892 --> 00:17:01,927 Yes. 335 00:17:03,094 --> 00:17:05,700 I'm still waiting to hear what law got broken. 336 00:17:05,764 --> 00:17:10,372 Rape, Mr. Sutter. And somebody decided to capture the moment for posterity. 337 00:17:10,468 --> 00:17:12,948 On a tape of my mother's birthday party? 338 00:17:15,073 --> 00:17:16,848 Well, I made some copies, I sent them around. 339 00:17:16,908 --> 00:17:18,444 Maybe one of my cousins threw his out. 340 00:17:18,510 --> 00:17:21,286 I don't know, anyone could have taken it out of the trash. 341 00:17:24,182 --> 00:17:26,595 Do you recognize him, Mr. Sutter? 342 00:17:31,891 --> 00:17:32,892 No. 343 00:17:35,394 --> 00:17:37,738 I don't know what else I can tell you. 344 00:17:39,398 --> 00:17:41,901 "Anyone could have taken it out of the trash"? 345 00:17:41,967 --> 00:17:46,643 Oh, yeah. The kid can afford a $2,000 video camera, but he can't afford a $2 tape? 346 00:17:47,239 --> 00:17:50,186 Listen, man, do you think there's any family resemblance 347 00:17:50,242 --> 00:17:52,279 between the kid and Sutter? 348 00:17:52,444 --> 00:17:55,948 Hard to tell, but I would like to see Sutter's apartment. 349 00:17:58,017 --> 00:18:01,898 Nice light. I guess you don't get windows like these except in lofts, huh? 350 00:18:01,955 --> 00:18:05,698 No, I suppose not. You said you talked to my husband? 351 00:18:05,759 --> 00:18:09,764 Yeah, yeah, we did, but we had a couple things to ask you if you don't mind. 352 00:18:09,830 --> 00:18:11,104 Is this your bedroom? 353 00:18:11,164 --> 00:18:12,905 No, that's my son's. 354 00:18:13,099 --> 00:18:15,636 Does this have something to do with Shane? 355 00:18:16,636 --> 00:18:19,276 Does your son have access to a video camera? 356 00:18:19,739 --> 00:18:21,082 Is Shane in some kind of trouble? 357 00:18:21,141 --> 00:18:22,245 He might be. 358 00:18:22,542 --> 00:18:24,886 We're gonna need to talk to him. Where is he now? 359 00:18:24,945 --> 00:18:26,185 At school. 360 00:18:26,847 --> 00:18:29,384 Look, I think I'd better call my husband. 361 00:18:33,486 --> 00:18:37,628 My mom and dad both called here. They said I shouldn't talk to you. 362 00:18:38,826 --> 00:18:41,272 Well, play it your way. We can all talk down at the precinct. 363 00:18:41,329 --> 00:18:42,501 Talk about what? 364 00:18:42,563 --> 00:18:43,633 Videotapes, Shane. 365 00:18:43,698 --> 00:18:44,768 What about videotapes? 366 00:18:44,832 --> 00:18:47,005 Oh, hot stuff. 367 00:18:47,201 --> 00:18:50,080 Young girls, porno, rape. 368 00:18:50,705 --> 00:18:52,514 They sound pretty good. Yeah. 369 00:18:52,640 --> 00:18:55,416 And we got a pretty good look at you on the tape. 370 00:18:55,476 --> 00:18:58,946 We got a good enough look that we know you got two big feet. 371 00:18:59,914 --> 00:19:02,861 You do understand that I don't know what you're talking about? 372 00:19:03,017 --> 00:19:05,156 How about a girl named Corey Russell, Shane? 373 00:19:05,219 --> 00:19:07,460 I guess you don't know anything about her either, huh? 374 00:19:07,522 --> 00:19:09,832 Corey? I know her from around. 375 00:19:09,924 --> 00:19:12,336 "Around"? What, you hang out in the same bars? 376 00:19:12,393 --> 00:19:15,068 I don't go to bars. I'm underage. 377 00:19:15,864 --> 00:19:19,778 Corey goes to school here. You want her? I think she's in Geometry. 378 00:19:23,405 --> 00:19:26,249 You told me you didn't know who did it, Corey. 379 00:19:30,112 --> 00:19:34,458 Do you want me to introduce you to Shane Sutter? He's across the hall. 380 00:19:36,718 --> 00:19:39,255 God, I can't believe you tracked him down. 381 00:19:39,321 --> 00:19:42,530 That's what we do here, Corey. Why did you lie? 382 00:19:43,959 --> 00:19:46,166 Can't we just forget the whole thing? 383 00:19:46,228 --> 00:19:48,731 Did you lie about being raped, too? 384 00:19:51,768 --> 00:19:53,475 I did Corey. So? 385 00:19:53,569 --> 00:19:56,448 You handcuffed her to a bed, you tore her clothes off. 386 00:19:56,506 --> 00:19:59,248 You forced yourself on her. Then you pretended to shoot her. 387 00:19:59,309 --> 00:20:01,585 Pretended. It was a goof. 388 00:20:01,644 --> 00:20:04,591 It's not a goof, Shane. It's a felony. 389 00:20:05,381 --> 00:20:07,383 Detective, these kids today... 390 00:20:07,450 --> 00:20:08,861 Are kids. 391 00:20:08,918 --> 00:20:11,865 Would you like to see the video your kid made of this girl 392 00:20:11,921 --> 00:20:13,628 and then sold for 500 bucks? 393 00:20:13,690 --> 00:20:18,400 But it's not just the boys. These girls, they call Shane all the time. 394 00:20:18,895 --> 00:20:20,636 You should hear some of the things they say. 395 00:20:20,697 --> 00:20:22,768 This one said stop, Mrs. Sutter. 396 00:20:23,433 --> 00:20:27,780 It was an act. If Corey's telling you different, she's lying. 397 00:20:28,405 --> 00:20:31,750 I can't help you, Corey, unless you tell me what happened. 398 00:20:31,842 --> 00:20:33,549 Did I ask for help? 399 00:20:33,610 --> 00:20:36,386 On the tape you did. You were screaming for it. 400 00:20:36,880 --> 00:20:38,450 I just wanna leave. 401 00:20:39,049 --> 00:20:40,790 I don't have to tell you anything. 402 00:20:42,219 --> 00:20:46,099 Look, you can play these games with your mother all you want, 403 00:20:46,156 --> 00:20:50,502 but you play them with me, little girl, and I cause you real trouble. 404 00:20:50,561 --> 00:20:54,475 Either that boy committed a crime, or you did by lying about it. 405 00:20:54,531 --> 00:20:56,408 Somebody's gonna be arrested here, 406 00:20:56,467 --> 00:20:59,141 and I'm getting so I don't give a damn who it is. 407 00:21:02,973 --> 00:21:04,247 (EXHALES) 408 00:21:07,212 --> 00:21:10,489 I have to see him and the other Rangers every day. 409 00:21:10,882 --> 00:21:12,327 What Rangers? 410 00:21:13,952 --> 00:21:15,625 The Mack Rangers. 411 00:21:16,721 --> 00:21:19,463 Shane's friends. It's what they're called. 412 00:21:19,524 --> 00:21:21,401 Did they threaten you? 413 00:21:24,696 --> 00:21:27,609 I knew it would happen. I had nowhere to go. 414 00:21:28,333 --> 00:21:31,075 One of these other boys made the video? 415 00:21:35,340 --> 00:21:36,842 Kyle Winters. 416 00:21:39,678 --> 00:21:42,216 I didn't know it was going to be like that. 417 00:21:47,086 --> 00:21:50,829 Corey, did Shane Sutter have your consent to do what he did? 418 00:21:52,925 --> 00:21:54,563 No. It was so awful. 419 00:21:55,695 --> 00:21:59,575 Did he have your consent? That's all I need to know. 420 00:22:07,406 --> 00:22:08,544 (SIGHS) 421 00:22:11,577 --> 00:22:12,578 No. 422 00:22:18,151 --> 00:22:21,564 Shane Sutter, you are under arrest for the rape of Corey Russell. 423 00:22:21,988 --> 00:22:23,865 You have the right to remain silent. 424 00:22:23,924 --> 00:22:27,133 Anything you do say can and will be used against you in a court of law. 425 00:22:27,194 --> 00:22:29,674 You understand? You have the right to an attorney. 426 00:22:29,729 --> 00:22:32,039 If you cannot afford one, one will be provided for you. 427 00:22:33,133 --> 00:22:36,342 BAILIFF: "Case number 775587." 428 00:22:36,403 --> 00:22:39,384 "People v. Shane Sutter and Kyle Winters." 429 00:22:39,506 --> 00:22:41,247 "Rape in the first degree." 430 00:22:41,308 --> 00:22:42,981 Let's have a plea. 431 00:22:43,043 --> 00:22:45,080 Not guilty. Not guilty. 432 00:22:45,178 --> 00:22:47,749 People request $200,000 for each defendant. 433 00:22:47,814 --> 00:22:49,054 GREER: They're minors, Your Honor. 434 00:22:49,116 --> 00:22:52,290 We ask they be remanded to the custody of their parents. 435 00:22:52,352 --> 00:22:54,390 Parental control means nothing to them, Your Honor. 436 00:22:54,455 --> 00:22:57,493 They raped a 16-year-old girl while making a pornographic tape 437 00:22:57,558 --> 00:22:59,003 at the home of one of the defendants. 438 00:22:59,060 --> 00:23:00,596 They made a tape of it? 439 00:23:00,695 --> 00:23:02,003 And they sold it, Your Honor. 440 00:23:02,063 --> 00:23:04,009 Your Honor, the boys' parents are here today. 441 00:23:04,065 --> 00:23:06,909 They'll agree to whatever supervision the court stipulates. 442 00:23:06,968 --> 00:23:10,848 So, based on their track record, seems to me they could use a little incentive. 443 00:23:10,905 --> 00:23:14,011 Bail is set at $100,000 for each defendant. Next. 444 00:23:14,509 --> 00:23:17,046 I don't know what you people are going nuts over. 445 00:23:17,245 --> 00:23:20,624 Corey wanted to hook up with us. She wanted to be in our video. 446 00:23:20,781 --> 00:23:23,387 She screamed no, but she really meant yes? 447 00:23:23,451 --> 00:23:26,762 It was an act. The bitch deserves the Sharon Stone award. 448 00:23:26,821 --> 00:23:28,767 Kyle, please. Mr. McCoy, 449 00:23:29,257 --> 00:23:32,398 if we're in for a lecture on the moral decay of society, skip it. 450 00:23:32,995 --> 00:23:34,668 My client's already late for school. 451 00:23:34,730 --> 00:23:36,334 Sit down and listen. 452 00:23:37,866 --> 00:23:39,812 His behavior turns my stomach, 453 00:23:39,868 --> 00:23:42,178 but your client's not the principal actor in this crime. 454 00:23:42,237 --> 00:23:43,739 You're offering us a deal? 455 00:23:43,806 --> 00:23:45,911 If he testifies against Shane Sutter. 456 00:23:47,209 --> 00:23:50,486 Must mean that you're not entirely convinced by Miss Russell's performance. 457 00:23:50,546 --> 00:23:54,153 You really want to bet on how convinced a jury will be? 458 00:23:56,018 --> 00:23:57,588 What kind of deal we talking about? 459 00:23:57,653 --> 00:24:00,293 This is a joke, man. I'm not saying anything against Shane. 460 00:24:00,355 --> 00:24:02,266 LAURIN: Kyle. KYLE: No way, nohow. 461 00:24:02,324 --> 00:24:04,770 Look, Corey spread them because she wanted it. 462 00:24:04,993 --> 00:24:06,836 She wasn't there to play Mario Bros. 463 00:24:06,895 --> 00:24:09,843 She's only saying it's rape because she's embarrassed. 464 00:24:10,767 --> 00:24:14,340 The kid acts as if he was making an audition tape for the NYU Film School. 465 00:24:14,404 --> 00:24:17,044 Maybe the girl was auditioning for Yale Drama. 466 00:24:17,373 --> 00:24:18,852 She convinced three cops. 467 00:24:18,908 --> 00:24:22,117 The boy's ready to go to prison to protect a rapist? 468 00:24:22,345 --> 00:24:25,724 According to Corey, Kyle and Shane are part of a clique at school. 469 00:24:25,782 --> 00:24:26,988 The Mack Rangers. 470 00:24:27,050 --> 00:24:28,859 Must've taken an oath of stupidity. 471 00:24:29,152 --> 00:24:32,156 Even the mob doesn't command that kind of loyalty anymore. 472 00:24:33,089 --> 00:24:34,898 They made other tapes with other girls. 473 00:24:34,958 --> 00:24:38,064 Maybe Corey isn't the only one who had to be handcuffed to a bed. 474 00:24:43,166 --> 00:24:46,979 We'd all go to Shane's place after school, watch Beavis and Butthead. Mess around. 475 00:24:47,037 --> 00:24:48,846 I thought making a tape'd be fun. 476 00:24:48,906 --> 00:24:50,943 You went along with it? 477 00:24:51,308 --> 00:24:53,914 Did they tell you they planned to sell the tape? 478 00:24:53,978 --> 00:24:58,393 Yeah. I kind of got a little kick thinking some perv's watching me do it. 479 00:24:59,149 --> 00:25:01,095 But that's not the point anyway. 480 00:25:01,152 --> 00:25:02,961 What was the point? 481 00:25:03,787 --> 00:25:08,236 Well, the guys I did it with, they needed it for the proof that we did it. 482 00:25:08,292 --> 00:25:09,498 Proof for whom? 483 00:25:09,560 --> 00:25:11,369 The other Mack Rangers at school. 484 00:25:11,528 --> 00:25:14,168 They keep score. Like, one girl, one point. 485 00:25:14,231 --> 00:25:16,837 You know, it's dumb, I guess it's just guy stuff. 486 00:25:16,900 --> 00:25:18,538 And all the girls went along with this? 487 00:25:18,602 --> 00:25:20,081 The ones I hang with. 488 00:25:20,604 --> 00:25:22,915 I mean, look, the Rangers are cool. 489 00:25:22,974 --> 00:25:25,420 You do it anyway, you might as well do it with them. 490 00:25:25,477 --> 00:25:28,822 They're not gonna get all goofy on you, like they're your boyfriend or anything. 491 00:25:28,880 --> 00:25:31,019 Corey Russell says that Shane raped her. 492 00:25:31,082 --> 00:25:32,686 Like he'd have to. 493 00:25:33,018 --> 00:25:35,555 Come on, Corey is no virgin. 494 00:25:35,653 --> 00:25:39,157 Anyway, these guys, they're into scoring, not hurting. 495 00:25:41,626 --> 00:25:43,333 They tell you stuff like, 496 00:25:43,395 --> 00:25:47,275 "Oh, come on, baby. Everybody's doing it." They act real sweet. 497 00:25:47,932 --> 00:25:50,378 After, they tell all the other Rangers, 498 00:25:50,435 --> 00:25:52,881 and there you are on the shelf like some kind of trophy. 499 00:25:52,938 --> 00:25:55,145 If you knew their reputation, why did you do it? 500 00:25:55,407 --> 00:25:59,288 Same as everybody. I liked the attention. 501 00:25:59,545 --> 00:26:03,925 See, these are the cool guys in school, you know. They kind of run the place. 502 00:26:04,417 --> 00:26:06,158 The school knows this is going on? 503 00:26:06,385 --> 00:26:09,025 What're they gonna do, hand out chastity belts? 504 00:26:09,655 --> 00:26:11,293 And if you said no? 505 00:26:11,590 --> 00:26:16,266 No problem, as long as you don't mind being a leper for the rest of the year. 506 00:26:16,829 --> 00:26:20,174 See, this girl, Beth Ritchie, she didn't want any part of it. 507 00:26:20,232 --> 00:26:23,441 So Shane and all the other guys, you know, they kind of whirlpooled her. 508 00:26:25,671 --> 00:26:27,582 They got all around her in the swimming pool. 509 00:26:27,640 --> 00:26:30,678 They touched her everywhere. They even took her top off. 510 00:26:30,876 --> 00:26:32,480 Did she complain to the school? 511 00:26:32,545 --> 00:26:34,219 They couldn't prove anything. 512 00:26:35,048 --> 00:26:37,619 Next day, the buzz in class was she had AIDS. 513 00:26:37,884 --> 00:26:39,557 The Rangers started a rumor? 514 00:26:39,619 --> 00:26:41,758 Yeah, they ragged on her so bad. 515 00:26:41,822 --> 00:26:45,531 They even said she did it with her brother. She had to transfer. 516 00:26:45,592 --> 00:26:48,334 See, I don't have anywhere to transfer to. 517 00:26:49,096 --> 00:26:50,200 (BELL RINGING) 518 00:26:51,031 --> 00:26:54,012 You paint a picture of orgies in the hallways, Miss Kincaid. 519 00:26:54,067 --> 00:26:56,013 Points for sex, Mr. Marx? 520 00:26:56,069 --> 00:26:58,310 It's hard enough getting them to show up for class. 521 00:26:58,372 --> 00:27:00,682 You try stopping them from having sex. 522 00:27:00,741 --> 00:27:02,277 What about Beth Ritchie? 523 00:27:02,342 --> 00:27:04,618 She didn't want to have sex. No one helped her. 524 00:27:04,678 --> 00:27:08,091 We investigated her problem with the boys in the swimming pool. 525 00:27:08,148 --> 00:27:10,857 Yeah, well, her problem sounds like an assault. 526 00:27:10,918 --> 00:27:14,525 Well, what Beth said happened and what could be proven are two different things. 527 00:27:14,589 --> 00:27:16,865 You spoke to the boys? To the witnesses? 528 00:27:16,958 --> 00:27:19,996 I'm a vice-principal, Miss Kincaid, not a policeman. 529 00:27:20,461 --> 00:27:23,931 We're talking about over-stimulated teenagers who can't turn on a TV 530 00:27:23,998 --> 00:27:27,275 without getting an insider's view of Madonna's cleavage. 531 00:27:27,368 --> 00:27:31,316 Now that's tough competition for lectures on Hannibal's Carthage. 532 00:27:31,372 --> 00:27:34,046 So the school ignores the problem, hoping it'll go away? 533 00:27:34,509 --> 00:27:36,785 We teach our girls to say no. 534 00:27:36,844 --> 00:27:38,619 Well, what are you teaching the boys? 535 00:27:45,186 --> 00:27:46,563 Points for what? 536 00:27:47,923 --> 00:27:50,767 It's the Mack Rangers' idea of an intramural sport. 537 00:27:50,893 --> 00:27:53,840 And they play dirty. Vicious rumors, assaults. 538 00:27:53,896 --> 00:27:56,103 Well, none of it's admissible in this case. 539 00:27:56,165 --> 00:27:58,805 They created an atmosphere of terror in that school. 540 00:27:59,001 --> 00:28:00,878 A few girls were happy to play along. 541 00:28:00,936 --> 00:28:03,177 For the rest, the peer pressure was intolerable. 542 00:28:03,238 --> 00:28:05,218 Peer pressure isn't against the law. 543 00:28:05,274 --> 00:28:06,548 Rape is. 544 00:28:06,842 --> 00:28:11,018 And the defense is gonna say Corey Russell wanted to be with the in-crowd. 545 00:28:11,213 --> 00:28:13,625 That's when I'll introduce evidence of peer pressure. 546 00:28:13,682 --> 00:28:15,286 And that will make the girl look willing. 547 00:28:15,350 --> 00:28:17,023 I'm not talking about pressure on her. 548 00:28:17,086 --> 00:28:18,963 I mean pressure on Shane. 549 00:28:19,188 --> 00:28:21,566 JACK: He had to score points to stay in the game. 550 00:28:21,623 --> 00:28:23,125 Points, yeah. 551 00:28:23,926 --> 00:28:25,497 It gave him motive to commit rape. 552 00:28:25,562 --> 00:28:29,601 And that same pressure got Corey up into his apartment to give him opportunity. 553 00:28:34,237 --> 00:28:37,150 All right, you got something legal here and inadmissible. 554 00:28:37,640 --> 00:28:40,814 And you wanna sneak it in the back door twice. I like it. 555 00:28:44,848 --> 00:28:50,025 BETH: They all came on to me. Shane, Kyle, Ethan, all of them. 556 00:28:51,588 --> 00:28:54,660 I didn't want to have anything to do with them. 557 00:28:55,892 --> 00:29:01,434 Then they started bumping me in the hallway, grabbing my breasts. 558 00:29:02,700 --> 00:29:06,113 By "them," Miss Ritchie, you mean members of the so-called Mack Rangers? 559 00:29:06,437 --> 00:29:07,472 I renew my objection. 560 00:29:07,538 --> 00:29:11,543 The defendant's association with this club is prejudicial and irrelevant. 561 00:29:11,609 --> 00:29:14,715 It goes to the heart of the crime, Your Honor. Motive and opportunity. 562 00:29:15,045 --> 00:29:18,288 I'll let it in. You're overruled, Mr. Greer. Exception. 563 00:29:18,349 --> 00:29:22,422 Noted. You may answer the question, Miss Ritchie. 564 00:29:22,520 --> 00:29:25,660 Yes. They were the Mack Rangers. 565 00:29:26,423 --> 00:29:31,600 And what, if anything, happened to you in the school swimming pool last November? 566 00:29:33,697 --> 00:29:35,938 They surrounded me in the shallow end. 567 00:29:37,702 --> 00:29:44,085 They started pinching me and touching me all over. 568 00:29:44,643 --> 00:29:48,614 I tried to get out, they held my head under water. 569 00:29:49,681 --> 00:29:51,319 I thought I was going to drown. 570 00:29:52,751 --> 00:29:56,722 They pulled the top of my bathing suit down while I was trying to breathe. 571 00:29:58,056 --> 00:29:59,501 JACK: And did they say anything to you? 572 00:29:59,558 --> 00:30:01,367 Objection, Your Honor. Hearsay. 573 00:30:01,426 --> 00:30:02,905 Statement against interest. 574 00:30:02,961 --> 00:30:04,201 Overruled. 575 00:30:05,931 --> 00:30:11,142 They called me names. "Bitch." "Dyke." 576 00:30:12,504 --> 00:30:15,611 Shane said the Mack Rangers don't take no for an answer. 577 00:30:16,209 --> 00:30:17,381 JACK: Thank you. 578 00:30:20,813 --> 00:30:23,623 How long did you go to school with the defendants? 579 00:30:24,317 --> 00:30:25,762 Year and a half. 580 00:30:26,018 --> 00:30:29,022 Did either of them ever rape you? 581 00:30:30,156 --> 00:30:31,260 No. 582 00:30:32,158 --> 00:30:34,365 I guess they did take no for an answer. 583 00:30:36,929 --> 00:30:39,535 I didn't really want to go to Shane's place. 584 00:30:39,599 --> 00:30:42,443 But I felt I kind of had to. 585 00:30:42,501 --> 00:30:44,037 Can you explain that? 586 00:30:45,938 --> 00:30:50,444 I knew what happened to Beth, and I thought if I just did it with him, 587 00:30:50,577 --> 00:30:52,420 I wouldn't have to worry about it anymore. 588 00:30:53,514 --> 00:30:55,755 JACK: What happened at Shane's apartment? 589 00:31:00,220 --> 00:31:03,201 Shane, Kyle and I, we had a beer. 590 00:31:03,857 --> 00:31:09,330 And then Shane and I went into his room, and we started fooling around. 591 00:31:11,198 --> 00:31:13,804 And he put these handcuffs on me. 592 00:31:14,868 --> 00:31:16,245 It was getting really weird. 593 00:31:17,204 --> 00:31:21,653 And then Kyle came in with the camera, and that's when I said no way. 594 00:31:21,708 --> 00:31:23,483 And I told him to stop. 595 00:31:23,977 --> 00:31:25,923 And what did Shane do? 596 00:31:26,046 --> 00:31:27,617 He kept going. 597 00:31:30,385 --> 00:31:36,666 He took my panties off, and Kyle was moving around with the camera, 598 00:31:39,827 --> 00:31:41,704 and that's when Shane did it. 599 00:31:42,931 --> 00:31:44,638 What did he do, Miss Russell? 600 00:31:47,769 --> 00:31:49,339 He got inside me. 601 00:31:51,773 --> 00:31:54,083 And then he pulled out this gun. 602 00:31:54,776 --> 00:32:00,021 He covered my face with a pillow, and I heard this loud bang right in my ear. 603 00:32:02,250 --> 00:32:03,695 JACK: And then? 604 00:32:03,751 --> 00:32:05,356 I was crying. 605 00:32:06,622 --> 00:32:08,499 Shane took off the handcuffs. 606 00:32:10,859 --> 00:32:12,532 They were laughing. 607 00:32:14,630 --> 00:32:16,166 I got dressed and I left. 608 00:32:19,301 --> 00:32:20,803 They were still laughing. 609 00:32:25,808 --> 00:32:29,381 At this time, I'd like to play People's One, Your Honor. 610 00:32:29,445 --> 00:32:30,549 Proceed. 611 00:32:37,920 --> 00:32:38,921 COREY ON TAPE.' Stop it! 612 00:32:40,155 --> 00:32:42,966 JACK: Can you identify the people on the tape, Corey? 613 00:32:43,059 --> 00:32:44,094 COREY ON TAPE.' Stop! 614 00:32:44,160 --> 00:32:45,639 That's me. And that's Shane. 615 00:32:46,496 --> 00:32:52,105 Get off me! Get off! Stop! 616 00:32:53,003 --> 00:32:54,539 (COREY SCREAMING ON TAPE) 617 00:32:55,505 --> 00:33:01,547 This really hurts. Stop it! Stop it! Stop! 618 00:33:01,611 --> 00:33:03,249 Get off me! 619 00:33:03,346 --> 00:33:04,347 No! 620 00:33:05,548 --> 00:33:06,788 (COREY CRYING ON TAPE) 621 00:33:10,653 --> 00:33:11,996 Please. 622 00:33:12,055 --> 00:33:16,629 Stop! 623 00:33:22,666 --> 00:33:23,872 (GUN FIRING ON TAPE) 624 00:33:43,420 --> 00:33:44,899 Thank you. 625 00:33:48,492 --> 00:33:53,134 Ms. Russell, after you left Shane's apartment, 626 00:33:55,367 --> 00:33:58,678 did you report this alleged rape to the police? 627 00:33:59,704 --> 00:34:00,705 No. 628 00:34:01,706 --> 00:34:03,617 GREER: Did you see a doctor? 629 00:34:03,675 --> 00:34:05,279 No. 630 00:34:05,877 --> 00:34:08,221 Did you tell your mother? 631 00:34:08,280 --> 00:34:10,817 I couldn't tell her that. 632 00:34:11,249 --> 00:34:12,751 In other words, 633 00:34:12,818 --> 00:34:16,766 it wasn't until after the police showed up at your front door with this tape 634 00:34:17,289 --> 00:34:19,428 that you cried rape. 635 00:34:19,491 --> 00:34:21,698 I was raped. 636 00:34:23,795 --> 00:34:26,708 Certainly convenient to say so after that tape came to light, wasn't it? 637 00:34:26,765 --> 00:34:27,766 JACK: Objection. 638 00:34:27,832 --> 00:34:29,971 Withdrawn. No more questions. 639 00:34:35,274 --> 00:34:37,880 Actually, the whole thing was sort of Corey's idea. 640 00:34:38,611 --> 00:34:41,148 She wanted to do something different than the other girls. 641 00:34:42,248 --> 00:34:44,660 She was, like, showing off. 642 00:34:45,118 --> 00:34:49,089 So she went up to your apartment of her own free will? 643 00:34:49,322 --> 00:34:51,393 She kept asking when she could come. 644 00:34:52,091 --> 00:34:57,939 And in everything that we saw on that tape, Miss Russell was a willing participant? 645 00:34:58,197 --> 00:35:01,838 She told Kyle where to stand. She wanted him to get the best angle. 646 00:35:02,935 --> 00:35:04,608 GREER: No more questions. 647 00:35:05,705 --> 00:35:09,620 So what we've seen is just your way of doing Corey a favor? 648 00:35:09,910 --> 00:35:12,584 I wouldn't say favor. It was mutual. 649 00:35:12,679 --> 00:35:14,852 She wanted to be raped, and you obliged her? 650 00:35:15,916 --> 00:35:17,452 It wasn't rape. 651 00:35:17,518 --> 00:35:20,465 You said that Corey wanted to do something different than the other girls. 652 00:35:20,521 --> 00:35:23,468 By the other girls, you mean the other girls that you and the other Mack Rangers 653 00:35:23,524 --> 00:35:24,798 had sex with? 654 00:35:24,858 --> 00:35:25,928 Yeah. 655 00:35:26,793 --> 00:35:28,329 SHANE: The other girls at school. 656 00:35:28,762 --> 00:35:31,333 And you got one point for each girl, is that right? 657 00:35:31,398 --> 00:35:32,502 Your Honor. 658 00:35:32,566 --> 00:35:34,603 Sit down, Mr. Greer. 659 00:35:36,837 --> 00:35:38,942 We've heard about this competition before, Mr. Sutter. 660 00:35:39,006 --> 00:35:40,679 One girl, one point, right? 661 00:35:42,509 --> 00:35:43,544 Right. 662 00:35:43,611 --> 00:35:46,182 At the time that you made the tape, how were you doing? 663 00:35:46,915 --> 00:35:47,916 Fine. 664 00:35:48,183 --> 00:35:50,129 JACK: How many points did you have? 665 00:35:54,355 --> 00:35:55,732 Your Honor? 666 00:35:55,790 --> 00:35:58,031 Answer the question, Mr. Sutter. 667 00:35:58,092 --> 00:35:59,935 Seventeen. 668 00:36:00,028 --> 00:36:01,405 JACK: So were you in first place? 669 00:36:01,462 --> 00:36:02,600 SHANE: No. 670 00:36:03,298 --> 00:36:04,800 Were you in second place? 671 00:36:04,866 --> 00:36:06,004 No. 672 00:36:06,468 --> 00:36:08,141 You weren't doing too well, were you? 673 00:36:08,202 --> 00:36:10,842 I was third and moving up. 674 00:36:21,083 --> 00:36:22,653 DOREMUS: Has the jury reached a verdict? 675 00:36:22,718 --> 00:36:24,197 FOREMAN: Yes, Your Honor. 676 00:36:24,253 --> 00:36:28,167 Against the defendant, Kyle Winters, on the sole count of the indictment, 677 00:36:28,224 --> 00:36:31,205 rape in the first degree, how do you find? 678 00:36:31,293 --> 00:36:33,500 We find the defendant guilty. 679 00:36:33,829 --> 00:36:36,309 Against the defendant, Shane Sutter, 680 00:36:36,365 --> 00:36:40,074 on the sole count of the indictment, rape in the first degree, how do you find? 681 00:36:40,369 --> 00:36:41,939 We find the defendant guilty. 682 00:36:42,905 --> 00:36:48,184 Thank you, sir. Jury is excused. Bail continued pending sentencing. 683 00:36:48,243 --> 00:36:49,244 (GAVEL BANGS) 684 00:37:01,958 --> 00:37:04,336 The pre-sentence report recommended the minimum. 685 00:37:04,961 --> 00:37:06,963 Two years. Wonderful. 686 00:37:07,030 --> 00:37:08,941 Be out in time for graduation. 687 00:37:09,399 --> 00:37:11,310 Greer filed his notice of appeal. 688 00:37:11,368 --> 00:37:14,178 All evidence relating to the Mack Rangers should have been excluded. 689 00:37:14,337 --> 00:37:16,749 Why? Because without it, Greer might have won? 690 00:37:16,806 --> 00:37:19,650 First Amendment. The Constitution? 691 00:37:19,709 --> 00:37:22,189 Yeah, that pesky thing. 692 00:37:27,717 --> 00:37:31,961 MCNAMARA: Are you sure you're not elevating this matter excessively, Counselor? 693 00:37:32,022 --> 00:37:35,664 The right of free association, Your Honors, is as fundamental to American liberties 694 00:37:35,726 --> 00:37:37,228 as freedom of speech. 695 00:37:37,295 --> 00:37:41,437 Even if the association in question is engaged in criminal behavior? 696 00:37:41,499 --> 00:37:44,002 No such evidence was presented at trial. 697 00:37:44,368 --> 00:37:45,574 The People dwelt at length 698 00:37:45,636 --> 00:37:49,448 on my client's association with non-criminal activities of the Mack Rangers. 699 00:37:50,308 --> 00:37:53,255 That would be the points-for-sex competition? 700 00:37:53,377 --> 00:37:55,653 Which may be abhorrent but is not illegal. 701 00:37:55,713 --> 00:37:57,351 The People claimed it went to motive. 702 00:37:57,415 --> 00:37:58,621 That was the claim. 703 00:37:58,683 --> 00:38:01,527 I submit they in fact accomplished their real goal, 704 00:38:01,852 --> 00:38:03,627 which was to inflame the passion of the jury 705 00:38:03,688 --> 00:38:06,601 by appealing to its members' sense of moral outrage. 706 00:38:07,491 --> 00:38:08,834 Thank you, Your Honors. 707 00:38:09,960 --> 00:38:14,467 This court has consistently held that evidence of motive may be introduced 708 00:38:14,966 --> 00:38:18,072 to weaken the presumption of innocence and to establish guilt. 709 00:38:18,136 --> 00:38:19,410 Can the State accomplish that 710 00:38:19,471 --> 00:38:22,418 at the expense of constitutional rights, Mr. McCoy? 711 00:38:22,774 --> 00:38:26,813 In Dawson, the Supreme Court rejected the evidence of a defendant's membership 712 00:38:26,878 --> 00:38:28,516 in a racist gang. 713 00:38:28,580 --> 00:38:32,118 In Dawson, the crime charged wasn't motivated by racism. 714 00:38:32,617 --> 00:38:36,258 In this case, the crime is rape. The only issue is consent. 715 00:38:36,955 --> 00:38:39,231 Rape typically is both the means and the end. 716 00:38:39,291 --> 00:38:41,703 In this case, it was the means to an end, points. 717 00:38:41,927 --> 00:38:43,338 SANDERSON: Do the People concede 718 00:38:43,395 --> 00:38:47,003 the defendants didn't rape any of the other girls to obtain points? 719 00:38:47,700 --> 00:38:50,112 Yes, Your Honor, but... If the competition 720 00:38:50,169 --> 00:38:53,275 had led to other rapes, you could have established a pattern of conduct 721 00:38:53,339 --> 00:38:54,716 under Molineux. 722 00:38:54,974 --> 00:38:58,945 But that didn't apply, so you dressed the same evidence up as motive. 723 00:39:08,087 --> 00:39:09,896 (PEOPLE CHATTERING) 724 00:39:10,890 --> 00:39:13,063 Rule number one, never drink at work. 725 00:39:13,126 --> 00:39:16,403 Rule number two, never discuss work while drinking. 726 00:39:17,697 --> 00:39:20,974 They've overturned the verdicts and remanded for a new trial. 727 00:39:22,068 --> 00:39:25,642 Evidence of the Mack Rangers is excluded. 728 00:39:27,674 --> 00:39:31,645 Rule number three, if rule number two is broken, 729 00:39:33,414 --> 00:39:34,950 never drink alone. 730 00:39:42,890 --> 00:39:47,930 I just want you to understand a jury may not believe Corey's story 731 00:39:47,995 --> 00:39:49,975 without understanding why Shane did it. 732 00:39:50,531 --> 00:39:52,340 And that evidence is now gone. 733 00:39:52,399 --> 00:39:54,379 We can't go through this again anyway. 734 00:39:54,435 --> 00:39:56,506 CLAIRE: We? What about you, Corey? 735 00:39:56,570 --> 00:39:57,776 I don't care. 736 00:39:58,739 --> 00:40:00,151 If they're not convicted, Corey, 737 00:40:00,208 --> 00:40:02,279 you're going to have to see these boys every day. 738 00:40:04,345 --> 00:40:08,191 She's going to live with her father in Michigan. New school. 739 00:40:08,783 --> 00:40:12,822 Yeah, I wonder how long before they hear about it there. 740 00:40:14,089 --> 00:40:17,229 Would you rather they hear you're a victim who got justice? 741 00:40:17,892 --> 00:40:20,839 Or that you're a slut and a liar? 742 00:40:24,199 --> 00:40:25,678 What difference does it make? 743 00:40:27,869 --> 00:40:32,545 What that girl needs is counseling. Not another trial you can't win. 744 00:40:33,074 --> 00:40:35,953 I think I can convince her to testify. And I think I can win. 745 00:40:36,010 --> 00:40:39,185 Well, that's great. All right, you get an A for self-esteem. 746 00:40:39,748 --> 00:40:41,489 But without the Mack Rangers evidence, 747 00:40:41,550 --> 00:40:44,554 your case makes exciting bedtime reading, and that's it. 748 00:40:44,720 --> 00:40:48,099 Great. So the boys go back to school bragging about how they beat the law. 749 00:40:48,257 --> 00:40:50,760 And the girls start lining up again to be humiliated. 750 00:40:50,960 --> 00:40:53,236 You want to save them? Tell me how. 751 00:40:53,295 --> 00:40:55,332 JACK: What if we aimed wrong before? 752 00:40:55,698 --> 00:40:57,735 The Mack Rangers aren't evidence of a crime. 753 00:40:57,800 --> 00:40:59,074 They are the crime. 754 00:40:59,135 --> 00:41:01,513 Mack Rangers as a criminal conspiracy. 755 00:41:01,570 --> 00:41:03,049 To commit rape. 756 00:41:03,239 --> 00:41:06,277 Under the conspiracy law, we don't even have to prove they committed one. 757 00:41:06,342 --> 00:41:08,515 You have to prove that they agreed to. 758 00:41:08,978 --> 00:41:11,686 The only reason they exist is for sex. 759 00:41:11,747 --> 00:41:15,161 And when they whirlpooled that girl, they said, "We don't take no for an answer." 760 00:41:15,218 --> 00:41:18,791 Then you also have to prove that at least one of them committed an overt act 761 00:41:18,989 --> 00:41:20,627 implementing the agreement. 762 00:41:20,891 --> 00:41:24,134 Every threat, every act of intimidation. That's very cute. 763 00:41:24,928 --> 00:41:27,966 But the appeals court just shot you down when you had a good argument. 764 00:41:28,031 --> 00:41:29,237 You think you can win this one? 765 00:41:29,299 --> 00:41:30,778 I don't think we'll have to. 766 00:41:36,640 --> 00:41:38,551 I left my aerobics shoes at the Vertical Club. 767 00:41:38,608 --> 00:41:42,021 So you exercise there. But you just don't like to exercise here? Is that it? 768 00:41:42,078 --> 00:41:43,079 Well, they don't make you wear... 769 00:41:43,146 --> 00:41:44,557 Excuse me. Can I help you? 770 00:41:44,614 --> 00:41:45,752 Here's our hall pass. 771 00:41:45,816 --> 00:41:48,228 All right, listen up, folks. Hold the action. 772 00:41:48,285 --> 00:41:50,197 We're from the New York City Police Department. 773 00:41:50,254 --> 00:41:51,733 We're gonna call out some names. 774 00:41:51,789 --> 00:41:54,668 If you hear your name, I want you to step up to the foul line. 775 00:41:55,059 --> 00:41:58,040 Mayfield, Winters, 776 00:41:59,897 --> 00:42:05,347 Henderson, Quinn, Kort 777 00:42:06,804 --> 00:42:09,785 and the sentimental favorite, Shane Sutter. 778 00:42:09,907 --> 00:42:12,751 You are all under arrest for conspiracy to commit rape. 779 00:42:13,311 --> 00:42:14,915 You have the right to remain silent. 780 00:42:14,979 --> 00:42:18,426 Anything you do say can and will be used against you in a court of law. 781 00:42:19,517 --> 00:42:20,621 (KNOCKING ON DOOR) 782 00:42:21,152 --> 00:42:22,153 Yeah. 783 00:42:24,322 --> 00:42:27,532 You're going to wait? It's only the first night, Jack. 784 00:42:28,193 --> 00:42:30,537 I'll stay till the dinner table's cleared. 785 00:42:31,363 --> 00:42:33,673 That's when it hit the fan in my house. 786 00:42:34,666 --> 00:42:36,202 We know they're loyal. 787 00:42:36,268 --> 00:42:39,181 Kyle already risked a rape conviction to protect Shane. 788 00:42:39,538 --> 00:42:40,642 That leaves four. 789 00:42:40,706 --> 00:42:44,677 Don't you think there's one boy in the group who'd rather go to college than prison? 790 00:42:47,980 --> 00:42:51,928 Or one parent who's making a stronger appeal than you or I could? 791 00:42:52,984 --> 00:42:56,124 You won't take it personally if I don't man the lighthouse with you? 792 00:42:56,188 --> 00:42:57,189 Nah. 793 00:42:57,456 --> 00:42:59,094 (PHONE RINGING) 794 00:43:03,796 --> 00:43:07,005 You understand, Mr. McCoy, we're only interested in full immunity. 795 00:43:07,433 --> 00:43:09,538 No jail, no probation, no charges. 796 00:43:09,602 --> 00:43:13,049 Preferably, the arrest is expunged. 797 00:43:13,106 --> 00:43:16,952 And what do we get from Mr. Quinn in exchange for our largesse? 798 00:43:17,009 --> 00:43:18,682 Anything you want to know about the Mack Rangers. 799 00:43:18,745 --> 00:43:19,917 Whatever you need to make your case. 800 00:43:19,979 --> 00:43:21,754 This is wrong. I don't want... Shut up. 801 00:43:21,814 --> 00:43:25,694 No, thanks. I can make the conspiracy case without him. 802 00:43:26,019 --> 00:43:27,555 Then why are you doing this? 803 00:43:27,620 --> 00:43:29,657 I want Shane Sutter for rape. 804 00:43:29,789 --> 00:43:31,097 I told you there was no... 805 00:43:31,157 --> 00:43:32,761 If I have to tell you to shut up again, 806 00:43:32,825 --> 00:43:34,964 you're going to remember it. 807 00:43:35,762 --> 00:43:40,337 Mr. Quinn, did Shane ever tell you what he did to Corey Russell? 808 00:43:43,070 --> 00:43:45,778 Ethan, talk. 809 00:43:48,308 --> 00:43:51,050 How many points do you think you'll be worth in prison, son? 810 00:44:02,256 --> 00:44:03,860 Shane bragged about it. 811 00:44:05,993 --> 00:44:08,405 He said Corey put up a hell of a fight. 812 00:44:14,868 --> 00:44:16,712 He said he ought to get double points. 813 00:44:19,975 --> 00:44:23,047 I've never heard of this other boy before. I think he's lying. 814 00:44:23,111 --> 00:44:25,682 You can tell yourself whatever you want, Mr. Sutter. 815 00:44:25,981 --> 00:44:27,961 I have what I need to go to a jury. 816 00:44:28,016 --> 00:44:29,359 What are you offering, Jack? 817 00:44:29,417 --> 00:44:33,160 Who cares? My son didn't rape anybody. These girls give it away. 818 00:44:33,221 --> 00:44:36,668 Stop saying that. You act like he didn't do anything wrong. 819 00:44:36,725 --> 00:44:38,398 Monica. Not here! 820 00:44:41,029 --> 00:44:43,236 The sentencing recommendation was two years. 821 00:44:44,599 --> 00:44:49,139 Fine. And he allocutes. Starting now. 822 00:44:52,674 --> 00:44:55,519 Tell your father what you did to Corey Russell. 823 00:44:58,314 --> 00:45:03,195 I told you. She wanted to be there. They all did. 824 00:45:03,719 --> 00:45:06,393 It was no big deal. She got cold feet, that's all. 825 00:45:06,922 --> 00:45:08,731 So she wasn't acting? 826 00:45:10,426 --> 00:45:15,136 No. She was mad. Even after. 827 00:45:15,664 --> 00:45:17,041 I didn't think she would be. 828 00:45:17,099 --> 00:45:18,373 JACK: After what? 829 00:45:19,568 --> 00:45:22,481 After you helped her get over her cold feet? 830 00:45:23,305 --> 00:45:25,751 Yeah. Against her will? 831 00:45:32,849 --> 00:45:34,988 You have to say it, Shane. 832 00:45:37,988 --> 00:45:41,561 Yes. She was really fighting. 833 00:45:43,060 --> 00:45:45,097 So you raped her? 834 00:45:47,431 --> 00:45:51,504 Yeah, fine. I raped her. 835 00:45:56,139 --> 00:45:59,245 We dealt Kyle Winters, too. Eighteen months. 836 00:45:59,843 --> 00:46:02,847 Drop the conspiracy case. You've got what you wanted. 837 00:46:03,246 --> 00:46:05,692 I think they should all be going to jail. 838 00:46:05,749 --> 00:46:08,060 They still don't think they did anything wrong. 839 00:46:08,252 --> 00:46:11,597 Maybe seeing their friends in Attica will convince them. 840 00:46:11,656 --> 00:46:14,330 Teenage boys? Good luck.