1 00:00:06,340 --> 00:00:08,042 (male announcer) In the criminal justice system, 2 00:00:08,076 --> 00:00:10,278 the people are represented by two separate 3 00:00:10,311 --> 00:00:12,246 yet equally important groups-- 4 00:00:12,280 --> 00:00:13,714 the police who investigate crime 5 00:00:13,747 --> 00:00:16,717 and the district attorneys who prosecute the offenders. 6 00:00:16,750 --> 00:00:19,353 These are their stories. 7 00:00:19,387 --> 00:00:20,521 [knocking] 8 00:00:20,554 --> 00:00:21,522 Chelsea? 9 00:00:21,555 --> 00:00:23,757 Auntie Chelsea? 10 00:00:25,593 --> 00:00:27,695 Chelsea, it's me. 11 00:00:28,696 --> 00:00:30,698 I've got those clothes for you. 12 00:00:34,468 --> 00:00:35,736 Oh, my God. 13 00:00:38,839 --> 00:00:41,242 Stay here. Um, don't move. 14 00:00:41,275 --> 00:00:42,510 Mommy's gotta do something. 15 00:00:42,543 --> 00:00:44,745 I have to go potty. Okay, good. 16 00:00:44,778 --> 00:00:46,547 Come on. Come on, go inside there. 17 00:00:46,580 --> 00:00:48,082 Don't come out 'til I tell you. 18 00:00:50,351 --> 00:00:52,653 Chelsea? 19 00:00:52,686 --> 00:00:56,490 Chelsea! Oh, my God. 20 00:00:56,524 --> 00:00:58,792 Nicky? 21 00:00:58,826 --> 00:01:01,129 Nicky! 22 00:01:01,162 --> 00:01:03,131 Nicky! 23 00:01:03,164 --> 00:01:05,433 The victim's Chelsea Hagarty, 20 years old. 24 00:01:05,466 --> 00:01:08,136 Her sister found her when she dropped by. 25 00:01:08,169 --> 00:01:09,069 The door was unlocked. 26 00:01:09,103 --> 00:01:10,804 Says the DOA had a newborn son here with her. 27 00:01:10,838 --> 00:01:11,839 Where is he? 28 00:01:11,872 --> 00:01:13,407 We searched the whole building. 29 00:01:13,441 --> 00:01:14,808 Nothing. 30 00:01:17,611 --> 00:01:19,113 Excuse us, ma'am. 31 00:01:19,147 --> 00:01:20,281 My name is Detective Fontana. 32 00:01:20,314 --> 00:01:21,449 This is Detective Green. 33 00:01:21,482 --> 00:01:23,351 Can you tell us what happened? 34 00:01:23,384 --> 00:01:25,153 I came by around 1:30 35 00:01:25,186 --> 00:01:27,755 to drop off some baby clothes. 36 00:01:27,788 --> 00:01:29,623 But Chelsea didn't answer. 37 00:01:29,657 --> 00:01:31,159 I knocked on the door. 38 00:01:31,192 --> 00:01:32,760 And that's when I found her. 39 00:01:32,793 --> 00:01:33,761 Tell us about the baby. 40 00:01:33,794 --> 00:01:36,797 He's name's Nicky. 41 00:01:36,830 --> 00:01:38,832 He's only five days old. 42 00:01:38,866 --> 00:01:39,833 Is there a babysitter or a friend 43 00:01:39,867 --> 00:01:40,834 that would have taken him out? 44 00:01:40,868 --> 00:01:41,902 Nothing like that. 45 00:01:41,935 --> 00:01:43,171 Where's the baby's father? 46 00:01:43,204 --> 00:01:44,838 Steve. 47 00:01:44,872 --> 00:01:46,840 He's at Phoenix House. 48 00:01:46,874 --> 00:01:49,210 He's a drug counselor there. 49 00:01:49,243 --> 00:01:50,911 Officer, send someone over to the Phoenix House 50 00:01:50,944 --> 00:01:52,780 to make a notification to the baby's father 51 00:01:52,813 --> 00:01:54,615 and then bring him back here. 52 00:01:54,648 --> 00:01:56,284 Thank you. 53 00:01:56,317 --> 00:01:57,818 Is everything okay between Steve and Chelsea? 54 00:01:57,851 --> 00:01:59,420 Yeah, they're... 55 00:01:59,453 --> 00:02:00,888 They were great together. 56 00:02:00,921 --> 00:02:02,390 They were so happy about Nicky. 57 00:02:02,423 --> 00:02:03,824 Well, was Chelsea having any problems with anyone? 58 00:02:03,857 --> 00:02:05,759 Anyone that would wanna hurt her 59 00:02:05,793 --> 00:02:06,760 or take the baby? 60 00:02:06,794 --> 00:02:08,162 No, no one. 61 00:02:08,196 --> 00:02:09,563 I can't believe this is happening. 62 00:02:09,597 --> 00:02:10,698 Ma'am, if you don't mind, 63 00:02:10,731 --> 00:02:12,766 I'm gonna hold on to this photo. 64 00:02:12,800 --> 00:02:13,801 And we're gonna need to ask you 65 00:02:13,834 --> 00:02:15,203 some follow-up questions, so... 66 00:02:15,236 --> 00:02:17,905 If you could keep in contact. 67 00:02:17,938 --> 00:02:20,374 Blunt force trauma? 68 00:02:20,408 --> 00:02:21,409 She took a beating, 69 00:02:21,442 --> 00:02:22,476 but it wasn't what killed her. 70 00:02:22,510 --> 00:02:26,280 Petechial hemorrhaging, cyanosis. 71 00:02:26,314 --> 00:02:27,481 She was suffocated. 72 00:02:27,515 --> 00:02:29,217 Can you ballpark the time of death? 73 00:02:29,250 --> 00:02:31,519 Somewhere between noon and 2:00 p.m. 74 00:02:31,552 --> 00:02:33,921 I found something else, though. 75 00:02:33,954 --> 00:02:35,523 You see this scarring on her arm? 76 00:02:35,556 --> 00:02:36,857 (Fontana) Track marks. 77 00:02:36,890 --> 00:02:38,926 Yeah, but they look old. 78 00:02:38,959 --> 00:02:40,861 We'll know more when we get her on the table. 79 00:02:40,894 --> 00:02:42,596 Ah, keep looking. 80 00:02:42,630 --> 00:02:45,165 My guess is you'll find fresh ones. 81 00:03:34,882 --> 00:03:36,550 (Craig) It was around 11:15 this morning. 82 00:03:36,584 --> 00:03:37,951 I was leaving for practice. 83 00:03:37,985 --> 00:03:39,720 And I heard her arguing with somebody. 84 00:03:39,753 --> 00:03:41,289 Do you have any idea who it was? 85 00:03:41,322 --> 00:03:42,790 I heard a man's voice. 86 00:03:42,823 --> 00:03:43,791 But I figured it was her husband. 87 00:03:43,824 --> 00:03:44,792 But I'm not sure. 88 00:03:44,825 --> 00:03:46,260 Did they fight a lot? 89 00:03:46,294 --> 00:03:47,261 No, no, they really seemed like they were 90 00:03:47,295 --> 00:03:48,729 into each other. 91 00:03:48,762 --> 00:03:50,598 Did you happen to hear what they were fighting about? 92 00:03:50,631 --> 00:03:52,333 I was in a rush, I just took off. 93 00:03:52,366 --> 00:03:53,334 What apartment do you live in? 94 00:03:53,367 --> 00:03:54,635 3C, right across the hall. 95 00:03:54,668 --> 00:03:55,836 Detectives! 96 00:03:55,869 --> 00:03:58,005 The baby's father's downstairs. 97 00:03:58,038 --> 00:03:59,373 Hey man, if you remember anything else, 98 00:03:59,407 --> 00:04:00,441 give us a call, all right? Yeah, sure. 99 00:04:00,474 --> 00:04:02,510 Thanks. 100 00:04:02,543 --> 00:04:04,712 All right, so what about my son? 101 00:04:04,745 --> 00:04:05,946 I mean, do you have any leads yet? 102 00:04:05,979 --> 00:04:07,281 Do you have anything at all? 103 00:04:07,315 --> 00:04:08,316 Mr. Monroe, we're not gonna give up 104 00:04:08,349 --> 00:04:11,051 until we find your boy, you can count on that. 105 00:04:11,084 --> 00:04:13,387 Now, when was the last time you saw Chelsea? 106 00:04:13,421 --> 00:04:16,357 This morning around 9:00 before I left for work. 107 00:04:16,390 --> 00:04:18,359 Did you notice anything unusual? 108 00:04:18,392 --> 00:04:19,893 No, she looked totally fine. They both did. 109 00:04:19,927 --> 00:04:20,961 (Green) Did you talk to her after that? 110 00:04:20,994 --> 00:04:22,296 No. 111 00:04:22,330 --> 00:04:24,398 I didn't notice any rings. 112 00:04:24,432 --> 00:04:25,833 Are the two of you married? 113 00:04:25,866 --> 00:04:26,867 We were planning on it. 114 00:04:26,900 --> 00:04:28,569 Uh, we were trying to pull some cash together. 115 00:04:28,602 --> 00:04:31,339 Any problems between the two of you? 116 00:04:31,372 --> 00:04:33,641 No, things were great. We were really solid. 117 00:04:33,674 --> 00:04:36,577 We understand that Chelsea had a drug history. 118 00:04:36,610 --> 00:04:39,012 Oh, she's been clean for over a year. 119 00:04:39,046 --> 00:04:40,381 I was her counselor at Phoenix House. 120 00:04:40,414 --> 00:04:41,181 That's where we met. 121 00:04:41,214 --> 00:04:43,016 Any chance she could have slipped? 122 00:04:43,050 --> 00:04:44,685 I think I would know. 123 00:04:46,820 --> 00:04:49,022 Was she in contact with any of the people she used with? 124 00:04:49,056 --> 00:04:50,391 No, after she got sober, 125 00:04:50,424 --> 00:04:51,759 she put that life behind her. 126 00:04:51,792 --> 00:04:53,327 She didn't hang out with those people anymore. 127 00:04:53,361 --> 00:04:54,628 Well, who did she hang out with? 128 00:04:54,662 --> 00:04:56,330 Nobody really. 129 00:04:56,364 --> 00:04:58,031 I mean, after work she'd just usually come home and rest. 130 00:04:58,065 --> 00:04:59,567 And where did she work? 131 00:04:59,600 --> 00:05:01,034 Uh, over at Flair Dry Cleaners 132 00:05:01,068 --> 00:05:02,069 on 72nd and First. 133 00:05:02,102 --> 00:05:03,203 Mr. Monroe, 134 00:05:03,236 --> 00:05:05,606 where were you between noon and 2:00 this afternoon? 135 00:05:05,639 --> 00:05:07,007 What? 136 00:05:07,040 --> 00:05:08,909 Oh, wait wait wait wait, listen. 137 00:05:08,942 --> 00:05:10,778 The sooner we rule you out, 138 00:05:10,811 --> 00:05:12,813 the sooner we can focus on other suspects. 139 00:05:12,846 --> 00:05:13,881 Rule me out? 140 00:05:13,914 --> 00:05:15,349 I didn't kill Chelsea. 141 00:05:15,383 --> 00:05:16,717 (Green) Look, nobody's saying you did. 142 00:05:16,750 --> 00:05:18,952 But right now, everybody's a suspect. 143 00:05:21,955 --> 00:05:24,358 I was at work. 144 00:05:24,392 --> 00:05:27,695 I was filing patient intake forms. 145 00:05:27,728 --> 00:05:30,097 The Amber Alert should say "Male, white. 146 00:05:30,130 --> 00:05:32,500 "Five days old. Black hair, blue eyes. 147 00:05:32,533 --> 00:05:33,667 Seven pounds." 148 00:05:33,701 --> 00:05:34,802 That's all we've got right now. 149 00:05:34,835 --> 00:05:37,905 We'll follow up with a photo ASAP. 150 00:05:37,938 --> 00:05:39,106 What do you have? 151 00:05:39,139 --> 00:05:40,674 CSU found a bloody fingerprint 152 00:05:40,708 --> 00:05:42,142 on the crib, but so far no matches. 153 00:05:42,175 --> 00:05:43,877 Did canvass turn up anything? 154 00:05:43,911 --> 00:05:46,947 There's a neighbor in 3C said she heard Chelsea arguing 155 00:05:46,980 --> 00:05:48,449 with a man around lunchtime, 156 00:05:48,482 --> 00:05:49,717 but we haven't been able to come up with a face. 157 00:05:49,750 --> 00:05:50,718 Did you run the baby's father? 158 00:05:50,751 --> 00:05:51,785 He's clean. 159 00:05:51,819 --> 00:05:52,953 And so far there's no record 160 00:05:52,986 --> 00:05:53,954 of any domestic disturbances 161 00:05:53,987 --> 00:05:55,489 at that location. 162 00:05:55,523 --> 00:05:56,524 He seems like a pretty stand-up guy. 163 00:05:56,557 --> 00:05:58,859 Yeah, well, so did Scott Peterson. 164 00:05:58,892 --> 00:06:00,461 Maybe he's overwhelmed by the responsibility 165 00:06:00,494 --> 00:06:02,963 of a new baby. Money was tight. 166 00:06:02,996 --> 00:06:04,565 Maybe she was spending her money on drugs. 167 00:06:04,598 --> 00:06:06,934 Tox screen, Chelsea had crack in her lung tissue. 168 00:06:06,967 --> 00:06:09,437 We ran Chelsea's name. 169 00:06:09,470 --> 00:06:10,404 She took a pinch for possession 170 00:06:10,438 --> 00:06:11,572 about a year and a half ago. 171 00:06:11,605 --> 00:06:12,506 Oh, if she was using, 172 00:06:12,540 --> 00:06:14,408 this baby could need medical attention. 173 00:06:14,442 --> 00:06:16,444 We'll check the local hospitals, 174 00:06:16,477 --> 00:06:18,546 see if anybody came in with a newborn. 175 00:06:18,579 --> 00:06:20,013 Lieu, Chief of D's on your office line. 176 00:06:20,047 --> 00:06:21,982 All right, great. 177 00:06:22,015 --> 00:06:23,050 Listen, see if Chelsea had any co-defendants 178 00:06:23,083 --> 00:06:24,151 on her last collar. 179 00:06:24,184 --> 00:06:25,686 With any luck, you should be able 180 00:06:25,719 --> 00:06:27,488 to find her dealers. 181 00:06:29,957 --> 00:06:31,158 (Keys) I haven't seen Chelsea 182 00:06:31,191 --> 00:06:32,159 in over a year. 183 00:06:32,192 --> 00:06:34,094 I had nothing to do with this. 184 00:06:34,127 --> 00:06:36,096 Look, man, we'd love to believe you. Love to. 185 00:06:36,129 --> 00:06:37,731 But the thing is, she had crack in her system 186 00:06:37,765 --> 00:06:38,932 when she was killed. 187 00:06:38,966 --> 00:06:40,468 And since you were her dealer, 188 00:06:40,501 --> 00:06:41,535 we figured she owed you some money 189 00:06:41,569 --> 00:06:43,471 and things got out of hand. 190 00:06:43,504 --> 00:06:45,172 I'm telling you, I'm not in that game no more. 191 00:06:45,205 --> 00:06:46,474 I've been clean six months. 192 00:06:46,507 --> 00:06:49,943 My kid brother got shot in January. 193 00:06:49,977 --> 00:06:52,513 The bullet was meant for me. 194 00:06:52,546 --> 00:06:53,814 Maybe it takes something like to that 195 00:06:53,847 --> 00:06:56,850 to, like, I don't know, refocus you or something. 196 00:06:56,884 --> 00:06:58,051 Yeah, it's all very touching. 197 00:06:58,085 --> 00:07:00,187 Just tell us where you were yesterday around lunchtime. 198 00:07:00,220 --> 00:07:03,156 Harrison High up in Harlem. 199 00:07:03,190 --> 00:07:04,592 My NA group sponsored a "scared straight" 200 00:07:04,625 --> 00:07:08,061 with some high school kids. 201 00:07:08,095 --> 00:07:09,162 You can check with the principal. 202 00:07:09,196 --> 00:07:11,164 Oh, we will. 203 00:07:11,198 --> 00:07:12,933 Thanks for the tip, man. 204 00:07:12,966 --> 00:07:13,967 I can go now, right? 205 00:07:14,001 --> 00:07:15,068 No, you can't go now. 206 00:07:15,102 --> 00:07:16,236 There's one more thing. 207 00:07:16,269 --> 00:07:17,905 If Chelsea didn't get her drugs from you, 208 00:07:17,938 --> 00:07:18,906 who did she score them from? 209 00:07:18,939 --> 00:07:20,541 Talk to Frank. 210 00:07:20,574 --> 00:07:21,241 He used to buy for the both of them. 211 00:07:21,274 --> 00:07:22,242 Frank who? 212 00:07:22,275 --> 00:07:24,077 Never caught his last name. 213 00:07:24,111 --> 00:07:27,548 He and Chelsea were pretty tight, though. 214 00:07:27,581 --> 00:07:31,018 Frank Stoll. 215 00:07:31,051 --> 00:07:32,953 Chelsea was with him a few years back. 216 00:07:32,986 --> 00:07:35,055 Before she met Steve. 217 00:07:35,088 --> 00:07:36,924 What can you tell us about this dude? 218 00:07:36,957 --> 00:07:39,693 He's bad news. 219 00:07:39,727 --> 00:07:43,030 Always involved in these scams. 220 00:07:43,063 --> 00:07:45,533 He got Chelsea hooked on drugs. 221 00:07:45,566 --> 00:07:46,934 How did that end? 222 00:07:46,967 --> 00:07:48,201 Chelsea OD'ed. 223 00:07:48,235 --> 00:07:49,537 She was in the hospital for four days, 224 00:07:49,570 --> 00:07:51,271 followed by three months in rehab. 225 00:07:51,304 --> 00:07:52,673 Why didn't tell us about this guy before? 226 00:07:52,706 --> 00:07:55,108 'Cause he's out of the picture. 227 00:07:55,142 --> 00:07:56,276 Chelsea hasn't seen him in over a year. 228 00:07:56,309 --> 00:07:57,945 Are you sure about that? 229 00:07:57,978 --> 00:07:59,246 That's what she told me. 230 00:07:59,279 --> 00:08:01,749 Why would she lie about it? 231 00:08:01,782 --> 00:08:04,518 All right, listen, let me ask you this. 232 00:08:04,552 --> 00:08:06,253 Where do you think we could find this guy now? 233 00:08:08,689 --> 00:08:10,257 Oh, he used to be a dishwasher 234 00:08:10,290 --> 00:08:12,560 at a restaurant called Picnic. 235 00:08:14,595 --> 00:08:15,996 Hey. Hey you, come here. 236 00:08:16,029 --> 00:08:17,531 Can I help you? 237 00:08:17,565 --> 00:08:18,966 Yeah, we're looking for Frank Stoll. 238 00:08:18,999 --> 00:08:20,568 He called in sick today. Why? 239 00:08:20,601 --> 00:08:21,969 We need to ask him a couple questions. 240 00:08:22,002 --> 00:08:23,537 You got an address for him? 241 00:08:23,571 --> 00:08:24,905 Should be in my office somewhere. 242 00:08:24,938 --> 00:08:26,907 You'd need a forklift to find it, though. 243 00:08:26,940 --> 00:08:29,610 Let's go. 244 00:08:35,215 --> 00:08:36,550 Is there something on your mind? 245 00:08:36,584 --> 00:08:37,818 No, not really. 246 00:08:37,851 --> 00:08:39,019 I just heard you asking about Frank. 247 00:08:39,052 --> 00:08:40,253 We are. 248 00:08:40,287 --> 00:08:41,321 Do you know where we can find him? 249 00:08:41,354 --> 00:08:43,724 I don't wanna get him jammed up. 250 00:08:46,093 --> 00:08:47,260 Maybe this'll ease the pain. 251 00:08:49,897 --> 00:08:51,932 He sees this chick sometimes, work over at Shooters. 252 00:08:51,965 --> 00:08:53,300 Pool bar on 49th street? 253 00:08:53,333 --> 00:08:54,968 Yeah, she's a waitress. 254 00:08:55,002 --> 00:08:56,103 There's gotta be a few of those there. 255 00:08:56,136 --> 00:08:58,672 Not with 38 double Ds. 256 00:09:01,108 --> 00:09:02,275 Frankie would never hurt a kid. 257 00:09:02,309 --> 00:09:03,276 We're not saying he would. 258 00:09:03,310 --> 00:09:04,344 We just wanna talk to him. 259 00:09:04,377 --> 00:09:05,345 He lives up in Queens, Maspeth. 260 00:09:05,378 --> 00:09:06,714 He's not there. 261 00:09:06,747 --> 00:09:08,281 Well, I haven't seen him in, like, a week. 262 00:09:08,315 --> 00:09:10,884 Gina, do you wanna help us find this baby or not? 263 00:09:10,918 --> 00:09:12,219 Of course I do. 264 00:09:12,252 --> 00:09:13,987 Then you get on the phone, you call Frankie, 265 00:09:14,021 --> 00:09:15,355 you tell him you have the afternoon off. 266 00:09:15,388 --> 00:09:17,290 Invite him to your place. 267 00:09:17,324 --> 00:09:19,359 And make him an offer he can't refuse. 268 00:09:19,392 --> 00:09:21,061 I'm not some hooker, you know. 269 00:09:21,094 --> 00:09:22,796 Well, maybe you don't get this, but time is running out 270 00:09:22,830 --> 00:09:24,698 for this little boy. 271 00:09:24,732 --> 00:09:26,566 Now, are you gonna help us or not? 272 00:09:28,235 --> 00:09:31,772 Gina? 273 00:09:31,805 --> 00:09:34,574 Is that him? 274 00:09:38,679 --> 00:09:39,680 Let's go. 275 00:09:42,115 --> 00:09:43,684 Frank Stoll? What? 276 00:09:43,717 --> 00:09:44,685 New York City Police Department. 277 00:09:44,718 --> 00:09:46,119 You're coming with us. For what? 278 00:09:46,153 --> 00:09:47,821 Bench warrant for unpaid parking tickets. 279 00:09:47,855 --> 00:09:49,222 Oh, come on, that's ridiculous. 280 00:09:49,256 --> 00:09:50,891 Where's the baby, Frankie? What baby? 281 00:09:50,924 --> 00:09:52,025 You know what I'm talking about. 282 00:09:52,059 --> 00:09:54,227 I don't know anything about no baby! 283 00:09:54,261 --> 00:09:55,829 That'll hold up in court. 284 00:10:03,403 --> 00:10:06,273 Narcotics. Four arrests, two convictions. 285 00:10:06,306 --> 00:10:07,941 A bench warrant. Yeah, a parking ticket. 286 00:10:07,975 --> 00:10:10,177 And now you've moved on to murder and kidnapping. 287 00:10:10,210 --> 00:10:11,679 Talk about failing upwards. 288 00:10:11,712 --> 00:10:13,113 I told you, I had nothing to do with that. 289 00:10:13,146 --> 00:10:14,047 And that's the God's truth. 290 00:10:14,081 --> 00:10:16,650 Then why didn't you show up at work that day 291 00:10:16,684 --> 00:10:17,651 if you're so damn innocent? 292 00:10:17,685 --> 00:10:18,919 A woman gets murdered, 293 00:10:18,952 --> 00:10:21,254 first stop is the husband or the ex-boyfriend. 294 00:10:21,288 --> 00:10:22,923 That's because they're usually the ones that did it, 295 00:10:22,956 --> 00:10:23,924 you genius. 296 00:10:23,957 --> 00:10:26,660 Hey, me and Chelsea, we had no problems, okay. 297 00:10:26,694 --> 00:10:28,295 So you still saw her. Yeah, once in a while. 298 00:10:28,328 --> 00:10:29,930 We'd get together to party. 299 00:10:29,963 --> 00:10:31,198 When was the last time? 300 00:10:31,231 --> 00:10:32,365 I don't know, a few months ago. 301 00:10:32,399 --> 00:10:33,967 We have a witness that heard Chelsea 302 00:10:34,001 --> 00:10:36,069 arguing with a male right before she was murdered. 303 00:10:36,103 --> 00:10:38,672 It wasn't me. 304 00:10:38,706 --> 00:10:39,673 You ever hear of a voice line-up? 305 00:10:39,707 --> 00:10:40,941 Where we put you in a room 306 00:10:40,974 --> 00:10:43,010 next to the witness, we make you scream and holler? 307 00:10:43,043 --> 00:10:44,177 It's true. 308 00:10:44,211 --> 00:10:45,713 We've convicted dudes with less. 309 00:10:45,746 --> 00:10:47,815 You better have a damn good alibi, my friend. 310 00:10:51,184 --> 00:10:52,986 I just went by to see if Chelsea was okay 311 00:10:53,020 --> 00:10:54,054 with the baby and all. 312 00:10:54,087 --> 00:10:55,255 What were you arguing about? 313 00:10:55,288 --> 00:10:56,289 It was nothing. 314 00:10:56,323 --> 00:10:57,991 Her sister was coming over. 315 00:10:58,025 --> 00:10:58,959 She wanted me to leave. 316 00:10:58,992 --> 00:11:01,394 I wanted to hang. (Fontana) And then what? 317 00:11:01,428 --> 00:11:03,263 Then I said I'd see her later and I left. 318 00:11:03,296 --> 00:11:04,297 What time was this? 319 00:11:04,331 --> 00:11:05,966 I don't know, 11:00, 11:30? 320 00:11:05,999 --> 00:11:07,768 Anybody see you come or go? 321 00:11:07,801 --> 00:11:09,202 I don't remember anyone. 322 00:11:09,236 --> 00:11:10,838 [knock at door] 323 00:11:15,075 --> 00:11:16,209 What's up? 324 00:11:16,243 --> 00:11:17,711 The victim's neighbor responded 325 00:11:17,745 --> 00:11:19,112 to an information wanted poster. 326 00:11:19,146 --> 00:11:20,347 I want you to go talk to her. 327 00:11:20,380 --> 00:11:22,349 Stoll just admitted that he was with Chelsea 328 00:11:22,382 --> 00:11:23,817 the day she was murdered, 329 00:11:23,851 --> 00:11:25,118 so we should just keep hitting him. 330 00:11:25,152 --> 00:11:26,453 This neighbor claims she saw a woman 331 00:11:26,486 --> 00:11:28,221 running outside of Chelsea's apartment 332 00:11:28,255 --> 00:11:29,857 yesterday with a newborn. 333 00:11:33,794 --> 00:11:35,228 (woman) Yeah, sure I saw her. 334 00:11:35,262 --> 00:11:36,163 She came running out of there 335 00:11:36,196 --> 00:11:37,831 with a little baby. 336 00:11:37,865 --> 00:11:38,932 Could you tell how old the baby was? 337 00:11:38,966 --> 00:11:40,734 Oh, no bigger than a shoebox. 338 00:11:40,768 --> 00:11:42,235 Little black hairs. 339 00:11:42,269 --> 00:11:43,036 What time did you see this? 340 00:11:43,070 --> 00:11:45,105 Uh, yesterday around 11:00 a.m. 341 00:11:45,138 --> 00:11:47,007 I was going to the Wash & Dry. 342 00:11:47,040 --> 00:11:47,975 Can you describe the woman? 343 00:11:48,008 --> 00:11:51,178 She looked pregnant. Uh, late 30s, early 40s. 344 00:11:51,211 --> 00:11:53,413 And you're sure she was pregnant. 345 00:11:53,446 --> 00:11:55,215 Well, she was wearing maternity clothes. 346 00:11:55,248 --> 00:11:56,516 Expensive. 347 00:11:56,549 --> 00:11:57,885 Not the schmattes you see around here. 348 00:11:57,918 --> 00:11:59,219 Do you remember anything else about her? 349 00:11:59,252 --> 00:12:01,889 Brown hair, medium height. 350 00:12:01,922 --> 00:12:03,156 Would you recognize her if you saw her again? 351 00:12:03,190 --> 00:12:04,291 Oh, it all happened so fast. 352 00:12:04,324 --> 00:12:05,959 I didn't get a good look at her face. 353 00:12:05,993 --> 00:12:08,962 I can only say she looked pregnant. 354 00:12:08,996 --> 00:12:11,799 Uh, Chelsea didn't know any pregnant women. 355 00:12:11,832 --> 00:12:13,166 How about Lamaze classes? 356 00:12:13,200 --> 00:12:15,235 Uh, we couldn't afford anything like that. 357 00:12:15,268 --> 00:12:17,237 We think this woman was older. 358 00:12:17,270 --> 00:12:20,974 Maybe late 30s, early 40s. 359 00:12:21,008 --> 00:12:23,143 There was one older pregnant woman. 360 00:12:23,176 --> 00:12:24,344 Uh, but she wasn't a friend. 361 00:12:24,377 --> 00:12:25,245 Who was she? 362 00:12:25,278 --> 00:12:27,781 She was a customer at the Dry Cleaners 363 00:12:27,815 --> 00:12:28,782 where she worked. 364 00:12:28,816 --> 00:12:30,417 She was always giving her pregnancy advice. 365 00:12:30,450 --> 00:12:32,552 Did she ever mention her name? 366 00:12:32,585 --> 00:12:34,454 No. 367 00:12:34,487 --> 00:12:37,925 Just that she was sick of the advice. 368 00:12:40,961 --> 00:12:42,295 (Beth) We have over 1,000 customers. 369 00:12:42,329 --> 00:12:44,264 The woman we're looking for is pregnant. 370 00:12:44,297 --> 00:12:46,366 She's about 40 years old and has brown hair. 371 00:12:46,399 --> 00:12:47,968 (Green) She might have talked to Chelsea. 372 00:12:48,001 --> 00:12:50,037 Maybe paid special attention to her. 373 00:12:50,070 --> 00:12:51,238 What about that woman who gave her that little bear 374 00:12:51,271 --> 00:12:53,273 with the heartbeat and the pregnancy book? 375 00:12:53,306 --> 00:12:54,407 Right. 376 00:12:54,441 --> 00:12:56,043 She said dry cleaning chemicals 377 00:12:56,076 --> 00:12:57,978 were dangerous to the fetus. 378 00:12:58,011 --> 00:12:59,179 I think her name's Arlene. 379 00:12:59,212 --> 00:13:01,214 Does she have a last name? 380 00:13:01,248 --> 00:13:02,415 She was a new customer. 381 00:13:02,449 --> 00:13:03,817 She was only in here three or four times. 382 00:13:03,851 --> 00:13:04,852 Does she have any clothes here? 383 00:13:04,885 --> 00:13:06,519 No way to tell without a receipt. 384 00:13:06,553 --> 00:13:08,155 Can't you look the receipt up? 385 00:13:08,188 --> 00:13:09,957 They're filed by phone number, not name. 386 00:13:09,990 --> 00:13:11,959 You mentioned something about a pregnancy book and a bear. 387 00:13:11,992 --> 00:13:14,027 Did Chelsea come in, take that stuff home? 388 00:13:14,061 --> 00:13:15,562 I think the book's still here. 389 00:13:15,595 --> 00:13:17,197 Chelsea wasn't much of a reader. 390 00:13:18,899 --> 00:13:19,967 Here it is. Don't touch it. 391 00:13:20,000 --> 00:13:21,835 Please. Thank you. 392 00:13:26,073 --> 00:13:27,540 Latent matched a print on the book 393 00:13:27,574 --> 00:13:29,076 to the bloody print on the crib. 394 00:13:29,109 --> 00:13:30,443 Any headway on the I.D.? 395 00:13:30,477 --> 00:13:32,479 No, and neither Monroe or the victim's sister 396 00:13:32,512 --> 00:13:34,281 know anyone named Arlene. 397 00:13:34,314 --> 00:13:35,883 Hey, we got a tip from Crimestoppers. 398 00:13:35,916 --> 00:13:37,851 The caller said that a woman tried to steal 399 00:13:37,885 --> 00:13:39,186 her daughter's baby last month. 400 00:13:39,219 --> 00:13:40,087 From the apartment? 401 00:13:40,120 --> 00:13:43,190 No, from a park in the upper sixties. 402 00:13:43,223 --> 00:13:44,291 Meet her there. 403 00:13:44,324 --> 00:13:46,026 See if she can recreate the crime. 404 00:13:46,059 --> 00:13:48,929 Any similarity's a plus. 405 00:13:51,131 --> 00:13:52,532 (Green) Can you describe the woman? 406 00:13:52,565 --> 00:13:54,201 Late 30s, early 40s. 407 00:13:54,234 --> 00:13:55,302 Brown shoulder-length hair. 408 00:13:55,335 --> 00:13:56,203 She was pregnant. 409 00:13:56,236 --> 00:13:57,070 How about a name? 410 00:13:57,104 --> 00:13:59,907 I'm pretty sure she said it was Arlene. 411 00:13:59,940 --> 00:14:01,274 That's it. No last name? 412 00:14:01,308 --> 00:14:03,576 No, just Arlene. 413 00:14:03,610 --> 00:14:05,578 Okay, tell us exactly what happened. 414 00:14:05,612 --> 00:14:07,447 My mom works in a diner on 73rd. 415 00:14:07,480 --> 00:14:09,950 We were gonna meet up here after work 416 00:14:09,983 --> 00:14:11,118 and have a picnic with Connor. 417 00:14:11,151 --> 00:14:12,219 When did the woman approach you? 418 00:14:12,252 --> 00:14:14,021 While I was waiting for my mom. 419 00:14:14,054 --> 00:14:15,355 She walked up and gave Conner this little 420 00:14:15,388 --> 00:14:17,590 stuffed dolphin and we started talking about-- 421 00:14:17,624 --> 00:14:19,392 She told Lindsay she volunteered 422 00:14:19,426 --> 00:14:20,627 at some children's organization 423 00:14:20,660 --> 00:14:23,296 and could get her some free baby supplies. 424 00:14:23,330 --> 00:14:24,564 That was the carrot she dangled, right, hon? 425 00:14:24,597 --> 00:14:26,299 Then what? My cell phone rang. 426 00:14:26,333 --> 00:14:28,201 And I was trying to get it out of the diaper bag 427 00:14:28,235 --> 00:14:29,903 and she offered to hold Conner. 428 00:14:29,937 --> 00:14:31,638 I mean, she seemed really nice. 429 00:14:31,671 --> 00:14:33,473 Lindsay turned away to get better reception-- 430 00:14:33,506 --> 00:14:34,975 And when I turned back, 431 00:14:35,008 --> 00:14:36,209 she was all the way over there. 432 00:14:36,243 --> 00:14:37,644 Halfway across the park and she had Connor. 433 00:14:37,677 --> 00:14:39,446 I started screaming. 434 00:14:39,479 --> 00:14:41,281 Luckily my mom had just gotten here. 435 00:14:41,314 --> 00:14:42,649 I pulled Connor away from her 436 00:14:42,682 --> 00:14:44,351 right at that corner. 437 00:14:44,384 --> 00:14:45,552 Then she ran off. 438 00:14:45,585 --> 00:14:46,686 When I heard the Amber Alert, 439 00:14:46,719 --> 00:14:49,222 I thought there might be a connection. 440 00:14:49,256 --> 00:14:51,358 Everything's within a five-block radius. 441 00:14:51,391 --> 00:14:53,260 That park where Arlene met Lindsay Doyle, 442 00:14:53,293 --> 00:14:54,161 that's on 68th. 443 00:14:54,194 --> 00:14:56,429 The dry cleaner's two blocks east of that. 444 00:14:56,463 --> 00:14:57,597 We found the place where she got the pregnancy book. 445 00:14:57,630 --> 00:14:59,666 Four blocks west on 71st street. 446 00:14:59,699 --> 00:15:02,402 So chances are she lives in the neighborhood. 447 00:15:02,435 --> 00:15:04,037 We put out a "Finest Message" to all the precincts 448 00:15:04,071 --> 00:15:05,538 with her description, so... 449 00:15:05,572 --> 00:15:06,406 All right, call the two-two, 450 00:15:06,439 --> 00:15:08,141 make sure they read it at roll calls. 451 00:15:08,175 --> 00:15:09,542 We'll have someone pass out leaflets 452 00:15:09,576 --> 00:15:11,078 to the local merchants. 453 00:15:11,111 --> 00:15:12,379 (Van Buren) Wait a minute, wait a minute. 454 00:15:12,412 --> 00:15:15,415 You said Arlene purchased stuffed animals 455 00:15:15,448 --> 00:15:17,417 for both victims and that this bear 456 00:15:17,450 --> 00:15:18,251 had a heartbeat? 457 00:15:18,285 --> 00:15:19,452 You know, you put those bears 458 00:15:19,486 --> 00:15:21,254 in the crib with a newborn. 459 00:15:21,288 --> 00:15:24,958 And they only sell them at baby stores. 460 00:15:24,992 --> 00:15:26,559 Baby Village. 461 00:15:26,593 --> 00:15:29,462 There's one at 74th and 3rd. 462 00:15:31,431 --> 00:15:33,433 We've got two. Arlene Ferrelli. 463 00:15:33,466 --> 00:15:34,567 What's her address? 464 00:15:34,601 --> 00:15:35,969 Greenport, Long Island. 465 00:15:36,003 --> 00:15:36,769 What's the other one? 466 00:15:36,803 --> 00:15:39,272 Arlene Tarrington, 68th and 2nd. 467 00:15:39,306 --> 00:15:41,474 Bought a car seat here last week. 468 00:15:41,508 --> 00:15:42,342 I'll print out the receipt. 469 00:15:42,375 --> 00:15:43,743 You read my mind. I'm calling the DMV. 470 00:15:43,776 --> 00:15:45,278 I'm gonna get them to pull a photo 471 00:15:45,312 --> 00:15:47,114 so we can show it to the ladies at the cleaners. 472 00:15:47,147 --> 00:15:48,348 Thank you. 473 00:15:50,350 --> 00:15:52,185 [knocking at door] 474 00:15:52,219 --> 00:15:54,254 Police! Open up! 475 00:15:58,225 --> 00:15:59,326 Can I help you? 476 00:15:59,359 --> 00:16:00,160 We're looking for Arlene Tarrington. 477 00:16:00,193 --> 00:16:01,694 We have a warrant for her arrest. 478 00:16:02,795 --> 00:16:04,397 You've made some kind of mistake here. 479 00:16:04,431 --> 00:16:05,398 Step aside, sir. Hey, wait a minute. 480 00:16:05,432 --> 00:16:06,633 Wait a minute! 481 00:16:06,666 --> 00:16:08,335 You mind telling me what's going on here? 482 00:16:08,368 --> 00:16:10,637 We're looking for this baby. He's been abducted. 483 00:16:10,670 --> 00:16:13,406 The only baby here is the one my wife just gave birth to. 484 00:16:13,440 --> 00:16:14,641 Where did you deliver the baby? 485 00:16:14,674 --> 00:16:16,676 St. Mary's on 79th. 486 00:16:16,709 --> 00:16:18,045 Well, we need to see him. 487 00:16:18,078 --> 00:16:19,779 Were you present at the birth? 488 00:16:19,812 --> 00:16:22,082 No, I was in Tokyo when she went into labor. 489 00:16:22,115 --> 00:16:23,416 I caught the first plane home. 490 00:16:23,450 --> 00:16:24,751 I got in at 3:00 this morning. 491 00:16:30,357 --> 00:16:33,426 Here he is, our son Stephan. 492 00:16:33,460 --> 00:16:34,627 Where's the birth certificate? 493 00:16:40,133 --> 00:16:41,401 Arlene. 494 00:16:41,434 --> 00:16:43,470 What's going on, Stuart? 495 00:16:47,540 --> 00:16:48,641 It's the same baby. 496 00:16:48,675 --> 00:16:50,243 No. 497 00:16:50,277 --> 00:16:53,180 Ma'am, I'm gonna take the baby now. 498 00:16:53,213 --> 00:16:55,448 No. No, no, no, no! 499 00:16:55,482 --> 00:16:57,717 I won't let you take him! You can't take him away! 500 00:16:57,750 --> 00:16:59,486 Ma'am, remain calm! 501 00:16:59,519 --> 00:17:00,653 Wait a minute. 502 00:17:00,687 --> 00:17:02,289 I'm sure we can get this straightened out. 503 00:17:02,322 --> 00:17:03,823 No! 504 00:17:03,856 --> 00:17:06,659 No, he's my son! 505 00:17:06,693 --> 00:17:08,495 Stop. Stop, please! 506 00:17:08,528 --> 00:17:09,696 That is my son! 507 00:17:09,729 --> 00:17:11,531 He's supposed to be here with us! 508 00:17:11,564 --> 00:17:12,432 I won't let you do this. 509 00:17:12,465 --> 00:17:14,401 Arlene Tarrington, you're under arrest 510 00:17:14,434 --> 00:17:17,237 for the kidnapping of Nicholas Hagarty. 511 00:17:23,376 --> 00:17:26,313 A month ago Arlene tried to abduct a baby 512 00:17:26,346 --> 00:17:28,081 from a park. 513 00:17:28,115 --> 00:17:29,382 When that failed, she set her sights 514 00:17:29,416 --> 00:17:31,384 on Chelsea Hagarty. 515 00:17:31,418 --> 00:17:32,852 So she murdered this poor young woman 516 00:17:32,885 --> 00:17:35,388 just so she could steal her child. 517 00:17:35,422 --> 00:17:36,423 That's what the police think. 518 00:17:36,456 --> 00:17:38,358 Several witnesses described Arlene 519 00:17:38,391 --> 00:17:39,692 as being pregnant. 520 00:17:39,726 --> 00:17:41,228 Whatever happened to her baby? 521 00:17:41,261 --> 00:17:42,829 St. Mary's has no record of the birth. 522 00:17:42,862 --> 00:17:45,332 In fact, there's no evidence that Arlene was ever pregnant. 523 00:17:45,365 --> 00:17:47,334 So she faked it for nine months 524 00:17:47,367 --> 00:17:48,635 and her husband never found out? 525 00:17:48,668 --> 00:17:51,338 Stuart Tarrington does merges and acquisitions 526 00:17:51,371 --> 00:17:52,272 for a British investment bank. 527 00:17:52,305 --> 00:17:55,442 He spends extended periods of time overseas. 528 00:17:55,475 --> 00:17:57,877 Anybody saying this marriage was on the rocks? 529 00:17:57,910 --> 00:17:59,679 Her neighbor says they were near divorce 530 00:17:59,712 --> 00:18:01,481 until Arlene got pregnant. 531 00:18:01,514 --> 00:18:03,250 It's kind of sad, don't you think? 532 00:18:03,283 --> 00:18:05,352 This woman did a murder/kidnapping. 533 00:18:05,385 --> 00:18:06,486 Breaks my heart. 534 00:18:06,519 --> 00:18:09,622 Arlene's lawyer. She wants a sit-down. 535 00:18:09,656 --> 00:18:13,393 This oughta be interesting. 536 00:18:13,426 --> 00:18:14,794 No one is denying my client 537 00:18:14,827 --> 00:18:16,263 was at Chelsea Hagarty's apartment 538 00:18:16,296 --> 00:18:17,764 on the day of the murder. 539 00:18:17,797 --> 00:18:19,432 I just went there to drop off a gift. 540 00:18:19,466 --> 00:18:22,269 When she got there, Hagarty was already dead. 541 00:18:22,302 --> 00:18:24,637 We've got evidence that says otherwise. 542 00:18:24,671 --> 00:18:26,773 The so-called bloody fingerprint? 543 00:18:26,806 --> 00:18:27,807 When Ms. Tarrington 544 00:18:27,840 --> 00:18:29,576 saw the victim lying on the floor, 545 00:18:29,609 --> 00:18:31,478 she felt for a pulse. 546 00:18:31,511 --> 00:18:32,745 If she was so concerned, why didn't she just 547 00:18:32,779 --> 00:18:33,846 call the police? 548 00:18:36,216 --> 00:18:37,850 You can answer that. 549 00:18:40,387 --> 00:18:42,355 They would have taken the baby. 550 00:18:44,324 --> 00:18:45,658 And when I'd gotten home, 551 00:18:45,692 --> 00:18:48,461 and I put him in the nursery, 552 00:18:48,495 --> 00:18:51,564 he just looked so peaceful and so content. 553 00:18:51,598 --> 00:18:53,866 And I just thought about the wonderful life 554 00:18:53,900 --> 00:18:55,368 that we could give him. 555 00:18:55,402 --> 00:18:56,869 And all of the opportunities 556 00:18:56,903 --> 00:18:59,939 that wasn't gonna have otherwise. 557 00:18:59,972 --> 00:19:01,208 What about the baby's father? 558 00:19:01,241 --> 00:19:02,209 Didn't you think he had any rights? 559 00:19:02,242 --> 00:19:04,577 I wasn't thinking clearly. 560 00:19:04,611 --> 00:19:06,413 The baby was screaming. 561 00:19:06,446 --> 00:19:07,447 He was all alone. 562 00:19:09,849 --> 00:19:13,353 So, any opinion as to who was responsible 563 00:19:13,386 --> 00:19:14,287 for the murder? 564 00:19:14,321 --> 00:19:16,789 I had known that Chelsea had drug problems, 565 00:19:16,823 --> 00:19:19,759 so I just assumed that it was all connected with that. 566 00:19:19,792 --> 00:19:20,960 And Lindsay Doyle's baby? 567 00:19:20,993 --> 00:19:23,463 What's your excuse for trying to take him? 568 00:19:23,496 --> 00:19:26,366 The so-called prior bad act? 569 00:19:26,399 --> 00:19:27,800 I'm glad you brought that up. 570 00:19:27,834 --> 00:19:31,338 Motion to exclude Lindsay Doyle. 571 00:19:31,371 --> 00:19:33,540 No one can accuse you of not being prepared. 572 00:19:33,573 --> 00:19:35,408 I'll take that as a compliment. 573 00:19:40,447 --> 00:19:42,282 (Walters) Your Honor, Lindsay Doyle 574 00:19:42,315 --> 00:19:45,452 is a 16-year-old unwed mother. 575 00:19:45,485 --> 00:19:46,719 The only reason Mr. McCoy is calling her 576 00:19:46,753 --> 00:19:49,422 is portray my client as some kind of predator. 577 00:19:49,456 --> 00:19:50,523 Which she is. 578 00:19:50,557 --> 00:19:51,691 Ms. Doyle's testimony demonstrates 579 00:19:51,724 --> 00:19:52,925 enough of a pattern of conduct-- 580 00:19:52,959 --> 00:19:54,694 I see no pattern here. 581 00:19:54,727 --> 00:19:57,597 The manner, the location of the alleged abductions 582 00:19:57,630 --> 00:19:59,399 was entirely different. 583 00:19:59,432 --> 00:20:00,800 Minor distinctions. 584 00:20:00,833 --> 00:20:02,435 The bedrock of jurisprudence. 585 00:20:02,469 --> 00:20:03,770 But in this case, irrelevant. 586 00:20:03,803 --> 00:20:04,971 The witness is in 587 00:20:05,004 --> 00:20:06,873 on ID under Molineux. But, Judge-- 588 00:20:06,906 --> 00:20:09,709 Don't push it, counselor. 589 00:20:09,742 --> 00:20:11,411 Jack. 590 00:20:11,444 --> 00:20:13,680 Your case is shaping up, Jack. 591 00:20:13,713 --> 00:20:16,983 How about you throw something low carb on the table? 592 00:20:17,016 --> 00:20:18,351 She killed a young mother. 593 00:20:18,385 --> 00:20:19,952 Destroyed an entire family's future. 594 00:20:19,986 --> 00:20:22,422 Save the morality speech for the jury. 595 00:20:22,455 --> 00:20:23,923 She didn't kill anyone. 596 00:20:23,956 --> 00:20:25,425 Your notification of an affirmative defense 597 00:20:25,458 --> 00:20:26,759 for the kidnapping? 598 00:20:26,793 --> 00:20:29,028 She took the baby, she'll admit to it. 599 00:20:29,061 --> 00:20:31,964 But she wasn't in her right mind. 600 00:20:31,998 --> 00:20:33,600 Postpartum depression? 601 00:20:33,633 --> 00:20:35,502 Postpartum psychosis. 602 00:20:35,535 --> 00:20:37,870 It makes postpartum depression look like a day at the beach. 603 00:20:37,904 --> 00:20:40,573 The police found no evidence your client was pregnant. 604 00:20:40,607 --> 00:20:43,042 They didn't have access to her medical records. 605 00:20:43,075 --> 00:20:45,312 Arlene miscarried at seven months. 606 00:20:45,345 --> 00:20:47,447 She sunk into a deep depression 607 00:20:47,480 --> 00:20:49,716 which gave way to a psychotic break. 608 00:20:49,749 --> 00:20:51,518 (McCoy) This defense didn't work with Andrea Yates 609 00:20:51,551 --> 00:20:54,621 in Texas and she drowned five children. 610 00:20:54,654 --> 00:20:55,722 In case you haven't been keeping up 611 00:20:55,755 --> 00:20:56,923 with your law journal, 612 00:20:56,956 --> 00:20:58,691 Andrea Yates is getting a new trial. 613 00:20:58,725 --> 00:21:01,661 And Arlene Tarrington didn't kill anyone. 614 00:21:08,535 --> 00:21:09,302 (Olivet) Did she have a history 615 00:21:09,336 --> 00:21:11,471 of infertility, marital problems, 616 00:21:11,504 --> 00:21:12,472 and depression? 617 00:21:12,505 --> 00:21:14,741 Medical records say yes. 618 00:21:14,774 --> 00:21:16,743 Was she in a psychotic state 619 00:21:16,776 --> 00:21:19,312 when she entered Chelsea Hagarty's apartment? 620 00:21:19,346 --> 00:21:20,380 I doubt it. 621 00:21:20,413 --> 00:21:22,482 But you're not sure. 622 00:21:22,515 --> 00:21:24,417 She stopped her therapist after the miscarriage, 623 00:21:24,451 --> 00:21:25,685 so there is no psych evaluation. 624 00:21:25,718 --> 00:21:27,887 I'm gonna need something 625 00:21:27,920 --> 00:21:28,888 more solid than that if I'm gonna 626 00:21:28,921 --> 00:21:29,889 put you on the stand. 627 00:21:29,922 --> 00:21:32,024 When I met with her, 628 00:21:32,058 --> 00:21:34,761 she described having felt some of the classic symptoms. 629 00:21:34,794 --> 00:21:37,330 Hostility, paranoia, despair, 630 00:21:37,364 --> 00:21:38,398 mental confusion. 631 00:21:38,431 --> 00:21:39,666 Delusions. 632 00:21:39,699 --> 00:21:41,468 Yet she still managed to plan 633 00:21:41,501 --> 00:21:43,035 this murder/kidnapping 634 00:21:43,069 --> 00:21:44,437 in great detail. 635 00:21:44,471 --> 00:21:45,905 Which seems very calculating. 636 00:21:45,938 --> 00:21:47,507 Inconsistent with the syndrome. 637 00:21:47,540 --> 00:21:49,709 Doesn't the fact that she had a miscarriage 638 00:21:49,742 --> 00:21:52,512 instead of a live birth also rule out psychosis? 639 00:21:52,545 --> 00:21:54,947 If that had happened during the first trimester, yes. 640 00:21:54,981 --> 00:21:56,616 But at seven months? 641 00:21:56,649 --> 00:21:57,984 The hormonal fluctuations would have been 642 00:21:58,017 --> 00:21:59,051 much more severe. 643 00:21:59,085 --> 00:22:01,788 Combine that with her marriage being on the rocks 644 00:22:01,821 --> 00:22:02,855 and having just lost a child. 645 00:22:02,889 --> 00:22:05,091 Are you saying she could have snapped? 646 00:22:05,124 --> 00:22:06,125 I'm saying she would have been 647 00:22:06,158 --> 00:22:08,327 very depressed at the very least. 648 00:22:10,497 --> 00:22:11,998 Thanks for nothing, Liz. 649 00:22:12,031 --> 00:22:16,603 It's a subjective science, Jack. 650 00:22:16,636 --> 00:22:17,937 I understand you were overseas 651 00:22:17,970 --> 00:22:19,872 during most of Arlene's pregnancy. 652 00:22:19,906 --> 00:22:22,609 We spoke on the phone several times a week. 653 00:22:22,642 --> 00:22:23,876 If I knew she was troubled, 654 00:22:23,910 --> 00:22:25,412 I would have done something about it. 655 00:22:25,445 --> 00:22:26,679 So you didn't think she was troubled? 656 00:22:29,115 --> 00:22:32,084 You're asking if I thought my wife was crazy? 657 00:22:32,118 --> 00:22:33,620 How dare you? 658 00:22:33,653 --> 00:22:36,923 I'm just trying to understand what happened. 659 00:22:36,956 --> 00:22:39,526 I thought maybe you could give me some perspective. 660 00:22:39,559 --> 00:22:42,562 Arlene is complicated. 661 00:22:42,595 --> 00:22:45,598 She was never one for sharing her innermost feelings. 662 00:22:45,632 --> 00:22:47,467 Did she have a close friend she might have confided in? 663 00:22:47,500 --> 00:22:49,669 I am her best and closest friend. 664 00:22:49,702 --> 00:22:51,971 Mr. Tarrington, you didn't even know 665 00:22:52,004 --> 00:22:53,473 that she'd miscarried. 666 00:22:54,641 --> 00:22:56,976 This thing has ruined my life. 667 00:22:57,009 --> 00:22:58,978 So last thing I need is some DA 668 00:22:59,011 --> 00:23:00,580 laying a guilt trip on me. 669 00:23:00,613 --> 00:23:01,648 I'm done. 670 00:23:06,753 --> 00:23:09,522 Arlene killed Chelsea Hagarty and stole her baby. 671 00:23:09,556 --> 00:23:11,658 She planned it down to the last detail. 672 00:23:11,691 --> 00:23:13,593 If she was psychotic, it didn't hinder 673 00:23:13,626 --> 00:23:15,662 her thought process. 674 00:23:15,695 --> 00:23:16,963 All we have to show the jury 675 00:23:16,996 --> 00:23:19,666 is that she could distinguish right from wrong. 676 00:23:19,699 --> 00:23:20,700 Well, you'll also have to show them 677 00:23:20,733 --> 00:23:22,835 how a sophisticated woman from the upper east side 678 00:23:22,869 --> 00:23:25,672 could turn into a cold-blooded murderer. 679 00:23:25,705 --> 00:23:26,573 She was desperate. 680 00:23:26,606 --> 00:23:27,306 She thought the baby was the only thing 681 00:23:27,339 --> 00:23:29,709 holding her marriage together. 682 00:23:29,742 --> 00:23:31,544 She couldn't adopt? 683 00:23:31,578 --> 00:23:32,579 Once she decided not to tell her husband 684 00:23:32,612 --> 00:23:33,846 about the miscarriage, 685 00:23:33,880 --> 00:23:35,615 she only had two months to come up with a baby. 686 00:23:35,648 --> 00:23:37,650 And once she couldn't get Lindsay Doyle's baby, 687 00:23:37,684 --> 00:23:39,586 she had to find somebody else. 688 00:23:39,619 --> 00:23:41,588 Do we know that she went to Chelsea Hagarty's apartment 689 00:23:41,621 --> 00:23:42,589 planning to kill her? 690 00:23:42,622 --> 00:23:44,156 I doubt she thought Chelsea 691 00:23:44,190 --> 00:23:45,925 would just hand over her child. 692 00:23:45,958 --> 00:23:47,460 She had a fully furnished nursery. 693 00:23:47,494 --> 00:23:49,729 She'd bought a car seat the week before the murder. 694 00:23:49,762 --> 00:23:50,597 She had intent. 695 00:23:50,630 --> 00:23:53,666 Sounds solid. 696 00:23:53,700 --> 00:23:55,602 But not perfect. 697 00:23:55,635 --> 00:23:58,104 Any juror who's miscarried or knows someone who has 698 00:23:58,137 --> 00:24:00,006 understands clinical depression. 699 00:24:00,039 --> 00:24:01,841 Depression isn't postpartum psychosis. 700 00:24:01,874 --> 00:24:05,111 We need to make sure they see the difference. 701 00:24:05,144 --> 00:24:06,145 I had a friend who lost twins 702 00:24:06,178 --> 00:24:07,747 in her seventh month. 703 00:24:07,780 --> 00:24:08,548 She didn't leave her apartment for weeks. 704 00:24:08,581 --> 00:24:10,617 Now, I don't know if she was crazy 705 00:24:10,650 --> 00:24:12,251 or depressed or what, but it's safe to say 706 00:24:12,284 --> 00:24:14,621 she wasn't thinking straight for a long time. 707 00:24:14,654 --> 00:24:17,123 Well, your friend didn't kill anybody, did she? 708 00:24:22,629 --> 00:24:23,663 (McCoy) Do you see the woman 709 00:24:23,696 --> 00:24:27,199 who tried to take your child in the courtroom today? 710 00:24:27,233 --> 00:24:29,802 She's right over there. 711 00:24:31,604 --> 00:24:32,939 Let the record show that the witness 712 00:24:32,972 --> 00:24:35,542 identified the defendant. 713 00:24:35,575 --> 00:24:38,010 Thank you, Ms. Doyle. 714 00:24:42,682 --> 00:24:44,951 When you first met Ms. Tarrington in the park, 715 00:24:44,984 --> 00:24:46,753 how long did you talk with her 716 00:24:46,786 --> 00:24:47,754 before your mother joined you? 717 00:24:47,787 --> 00:24:51,791 About 20 minutes, I guess. 718 00:24:51,824 --> 00:24:52,859 20 minutes. 719 00:24:52,892 --> 00:24:55,227 What did you talk about? 720 00:24:55,261 --> 00:24:56,763 Babies. 721 00:24:56,796 --> 00:24:58,264 What it's like to have a baby 722 00:24:58,297 --> 00:24:59,899 when you're only 16. 723 00:24:59,932 --> 00:25:02,702 Didn't you tell Arlene Tarrington 724 00:25:02,735 --> 00:25:03,970 that you felt your life was ruined 725 00:25:04,003 --> 00:25:05,104 and you didn't want the baby? 726 00:25:05,137 --> 00:25:08,675 I don't remember saying that. 727 00:25:08,708 --> 00:25:11,110 Do you remember Ms. Tarrington telling you 728 00:25:11,143 --> 00:25:12,912 she could find a good home for your son 729 00:25:12,945 --> 00:25:14,714 if that's what you wanted? 730 00:25:14,747 --> 00:25:17,149 No. 731 00:25:17,183 --> 00:25:18,818 Then you probably don't remember 732 00:25:18,851 --> 00:25:19,852 asking how much money you could get for the baby. 733 00:25:19,886 --> 00:25:20,853 Objection. 734 00:25:20,887 --> 00:25:21,688 I'll allow it. 735 00:25:21,721 --> 00:25:24,023 The witness may answer. 736 00:25:24,056 --> 00:25:27,560 I wasn't serious about that. 737 00:25:27,594 --> 00:25:29,596 You weren't serious? 738 00:25:29,629 --> 00:25:31,631 Seems like an odd subject to joke about. 739 00:25:31,664 --> 00:25:32,699 I wasn't joking. 740 00:25:32,732 --> 00:25:35,802 I was--my son was only two weeks old at the time. 741 00:25:35,835 --> 00:25:37,970 And I was feeling totally out of it. 742 00:25:38,004 --> 00:25:41,841 Are you sure you weren't suffering from depression? 743 00:25:41,874 --> 00:25:42,775 Objection! 744 00:25:42,809 --> 00:25:43,810 Withdrawn. 745 00:25:43,843 --> 00:25:46,979 No further questions, your honor. 746 00:25:55,822 --> 00:25:57,023 What happened in there? 747 00:25:57,056 --> 00:25:59,692 That lawyer just got me all mixed up. 748 00:25:59,726 --> 00:26:00,627 I'm sorry. 749 00:26:00,660 --> 00:26:03,630 I don't want an apology, I want the truth. 750 00:26:03,663 --> 00:26:06,165 I can't. 751 00:26:06,198 --> 00:26:07,967 Why not? 752 00:26:08,000 --> 00:26:11,704 My mother. 753 00:26:11,738 --> 00:26:14,206 If she finds out the truth, she'll totally lose it on me. 754 00:26:14,240 --> 00:26:16,776 Lindsay, this is a murder trial. 755 00:26:22,782 --> 00:26:24,083 You tell me what happened, 756 00:26:24,116 --> 00:26:25,785 and I will deal with your mother. 757 00:26:25,818 --> 00:26:28,821 I'm sure that I can make her understand. 758 00:26:31,824 --> 00:26:34,226 Arlene offered me a lot of money. 759 00:26:34,260 --> 00:26:35,795 She said she could find Connor a home 760 00:26:35,828 --> 00:26:37,930 with rich people. 761 00:26:37,964 --> 00:26:41,267 And you wanted him to have a good life. 762 00:26:41,300 --> 00:26:44,737 We're all crammed into a studio apartment. 763 00:26:44,771 --> 00:26:45,805 I don't even have enough money 764 00:26:45,838 --> 00:26:46,873 to buy him a crib, 765 00:26:46,906 --> 00:26:51,944 so yeah, I thought about it for, like, a minute. 766 00:26:51,978 --> 00:26:55,047 But then I said no. 767 00:26:55,081 --> 00:26:58,217 I just couldn't go through with it. 768 00:26:58,250 --> 00:27:01,253 Lindsay, how much money did she offer you? 769 00:27:05,958 --> 00:27:06,793 $50,000? 770 00:27:06,826 --> 00:27:07,994 Why didn't you find this out during prep? 771 00:27:08,027 --> 00:27:09,829 She's only 16, Jack. 772 00:27:09,862 --> 00:27:11,731 She was terrified of her mother's reaction. 773 00:27:11,764 --> 00:27:13,900 If Arlene was throwing money Lindsay Doyle's way, 774 00:27:13,933 --> 00:27:16,836 who's to say she didn't do the same with Hagarty? 775 00:27:16,869 --> 00:27:18,304 You think they had some kind of arrangement? 776 00:27:18,337 --> 00:27:19,405 If they did, I'd prefer to know about it 777 00:27:19,438 --> 00:27:21,741 before Arlene takes the stand. 778 00:27:21,774 --> 00:27:23,009 I'll take a look at her financials. 779 00:27:23,042 --> 00:27:25,344 Take more than a look. 780 00:27:25,377 --> 00:27:27,947 [knocking at door] 781 00:27:27,980 --> 00:27:29,015 I subpoenaed Arlene's credit card 782 00:27:29,048 --> 00:27:30,750 and bank statements. 783 00:27:30,783 --> 00:27:31,851 Anything? 784 00:27:31,884 --> 00:27:32,852 Nothing unusual, but I found something 785 00:27:32,885 --> 00:27:33,886 in her LUDs. 786 00:27:33,920 --> 00:27:35,387 She called Chelsea Hagarty. 787 00:27:35,421 --> 00:27:38,157 No, she called Frank Stoll. 788 00:27:38,190 --> 00:27:39,959 Chelsea's ex-boyfriend. 789 00:27:39,992 --> 00:27:41,393 He told the police he visited Chelsea 790 00:27:41,427 --> 00:27:43,295 the morning she was killed. 791 00:27:43,329 --> 00:27:44,831 What was she doing talking to him? 792 00:27:44,864 --> 00:27:47,033 I don't know, but check out the date. 793 00:27:49,969 --> 00:27:52,371 Three days before the murder. 794 00:27:55,007 --> 00:27:56,876 (Fontana) Plasma TV. 795 00:27:56,909 --> 00:27:59,779 Oh damn, Frankie, where'd you get the money 796 00:27:59,812 --> 00:28:00,947 to pay for this? 797 00:28:00,980 --> 00:28:03,482 Oh, I didn't. I won it in a bet. 798 00:28:03,515 --> 00:28:05,351 Hey, Frankie boy, if you're in the mood 799 00:28:05,384 --> 00:28:06,886 for telling stories, why don't you tell us 800 00:28:06,919 --> 00:28:07,920 the one about you 801 00:28:07,954 --> 00:28:10,089 and Arlene Tarrington? 802 00:28:10,122 --> 00:28:12,024 What, the lady from the news? 803 00:28:12,058 --> 00:28:12,959 The one who killed Chelsea? 804 00:28:12,992 --> 00:28:14,927 The one who called you on your cell phone 805 00:28:14,961 --> 00:28:15,862 three days before the murder. 806 00:28:15,895 --> 00:28:17,997 Well, that must have been a wrong number, 807 00:28:18,030 --> 00:28:19,331 'cause I don't know her. 808 00:28:19,365 --> 00:28:21,300 (Green) Your boss says that Arlene comes by the restaurant 809 00:28:21,333 --> 00:28:23,302 that you work at once a month 810 00:28:23,335 --> 00:28:24,336 to pick up food donations. 811 00:28:24,370 --> 00:28:25,271 Come on, man, you've been seen talking to her 812 00:28:25,304 --> 00:28:27,473 in the kitchen on at least two occasions. 813 00:28:27,506 --> 00:28:29,275 And both of you were at Chelsea's apartment 814 00:28:29,308 --> 00:28:30,342 the day she was murdered. 815 00:28:30,376 --> 00:28:32,311 That constitutes knowing in our neck of the woods. 816 00:28:32,344 --> 00:28:34,981 You know what? Get the hell out of here. 817 00:28:35,014 --> 00:28:36,215 I don't have to talk to you people. 818 00:28:36,248 --> 00:28:37,449 If you were involved in this murder 819 00:28:37,483 --> 00:28:38,818 and this kidnapping, 820 00:28:38,851 --> 00:28:40,386 you're gonna wanna come off that position. 821 00:28:40,419 --> 00:28:44,123 Man, you're way off base. 822 00:28:44,156 --> 00:28:46,058 Then set us straight. 823 00:28:47,459 --> 00:28:50,396 That baby is mine. 824 00:28:58,404 --> 00:29:00,172 Frank Stoll is the father? 825 00:29:00,206 --> 00:29:01,874 That's what he's saying now. 826 00:29:01,908 --> 00:29:03,042 He filed a paternity suit. 827 00:29:03,075 --> 00:29:05,377 We're still waiting on the DNA. 828 00:29:05,411 --> 00:29:06,846 That child was born into an existing marriage. 829 00:29:06,879 --> 00:29:08,014 He has no grounds. 830 00:29:08,047 --> 00:29:10,316 Steve Monroe and Chelsea Hagarty 831 00:29:10,349 --> 00:29:11,250 were never married. 832 00:29:13,485 --> 00:29:15,087 If Stoll was in on it, 833 00:29:15,121 --> 00:29:16,856 why didn't Arlene point the finger at him? 834 00:29:16,889 --> 00:29:19,325 And implicate herself in the murder? 835 00:29:19,358 --> 00:29:21,227 She's better off with her insanity defense. 836 00:29:21,260 --> 00:29:22,862 What about a money trail? 837 00:29:22,895 --> 00:29:24,196 There were no unusual withdrawals 838 00:29:24,230 --> 00:29:25,497 on Arlene's bank statements. 839 00:29:25,531 --> 00:29:27,133 But her maid said she always kept 840 00:29:27,166 --> 00:29:28,434 large amounts of cash at home. 841 00:29:28,467 --> 00:29:30,502 Her husband made over $3 million a year. 842 00:29:30,536 --> 00:29:32,204 She could have squirreled away a small fortune. 843 00:29:35,274 --> 00:29:37,309 What a world. 844 00:29:37,343 --> 00:29:38,410 A child loses his mother 845 00:29:38,444 --> 00:29:40,379 and now risks being taken away from the only father 846 00:29:40,412 --> 00:29:41,881 he's ever known. 847 00:29:41,914 --> 00:29:43,582 And handed over to a complete stranger 848 00:29:43,615 --> 00:29:45,051 who tried to sell him. 849 00:29:45,084 --> 00:29:47,586 Not if we put Frank Stoll away for the murder. 850 00:29:47,619 --> 00:29:50,356 Based on a cell phone call and a plasma TV? 851 00:29:50,389 --> 00:29:51,824 He put himself in Chelsea Hagarty's apartment 852 00:29:51,858 --> 00:29:53,926 on the day she was killed. 853 00:29:53,960 --> 00:29:55,061 The neighbor overheard an argument. 854 00:29:55,094 --> 00:29:56,963 That's not gonna get you a conviction. 855 00:29:56,996 --> 00:29:58,497 He was a career criminal drug addict 856 00:29:58,530 --> 00:30:00,399 who had a pregnant girlfriend. 857 00:30:00,432 --> 00:30:02,334 If a desperate woman came along needing a child, 858 00:30:02,368 --> 00:30:04,436 you don't think he'd take a chance to make a buck? 859 00:30:04,470 --> 00:30:06,372 I can think whatever I like, 860 00:30:06,405 --> 00:30:08,374 but how do you prove that he killed the girlfriend? 861 00:30:08,407 --> 00:30:12,178 Talk to Arlene. 862 00:30:12,211 --> 00:30:13,579 See if she has anything to say. 863 00:30:13,612 --> 00:30:16,182 And if you like her story, you offer a plea? 864 00:30:16,215 --> 00:30:18,284 She'd still be looking at hard time. 865 00:30:18,317 --> 00:30:19,986 And we'd have a shot to try Frank Stoll 866 00:30:20,019 --> 00:30:21,120 for the murder. 867 00:30:21,153 --> 00:30:23,255 (Branch) You put her on the stand 868 00:30:23,289 --> 00:30:25,291 she'll be walking into a buzz saw. 869 00:30:25,324 --> 00:30:26,926 Stoll's lawyer will carve her up 870 00:30:26,959 --> 00:30:29,996 like some kind of a self-confessed nutcase 871 00:30:30,029 --> 00:30:31,363 grabbing for a way out of a murder conviction. 872 00:30:31,397 --> 00:30:34,066 I understand and I'm willing to take that chance. 873 00:30:34,100 --> 00:30:35,334 If we don't at least explore this, 874 00:30:35,367 --> 00:30:36,368 Stoll gets away with murder. 875 00:30:39,138 --> 00:30:42,341 Well, talk to her and see if she'll give you something, 876 00:30:42,374 --> 00:30:44,343 but it's riding on you, Jack. 877 00:30:48,414 --> 00:30:49,949 [door slams] 878 00:30:49,982 --> 00:30:51,283 We recently discovered evidence that suggests 879 00:30:51,317 --> 00:30:54,020 your client was involved in a conspiracy. 880 00:30:54,053 --> 00:30:55,021 With who? 881 00:30:55,054 --> 00:30:56,122 Frank Stoll. 882 00:31:02,528 --> 00:31:04,430 [whispered conversation] 883 00:31:08,500 --> 00:31:09,969 We're listening. 884 00:31:10,002 --> 00:31:11,037 We can put them together at the restaurant 885 00:31:11,070 --> 00:31:12,571 where Stoll works. 886 00:31:12,604 --> 00:31:13,906 We also have a cell phone call 887 00:31:13,940 --> 00:31:14,907 between them. 888 00:31:14,941 --> 00:31:16,042 A little elbow grease, 889 00:31:16,075 --> 00:31:17,243 I'm sure we can come up with more. 890 00:31:17,276 --> 00:31:19,578 So what are you offering? 891 00:31:19,611 --> 00:31:22,314 Depends on what she's got to say. 892 00:31:22,348 --> 00:31:25,384 He told me that he could get me a baby-- 893 00:31:25,417 --> 00:31:27,086 Not another word, Arlene. 894 00:31:27,119 --> 00:31:28,254 If the rest of her information's good, 895 00:31:28,287 --> 00:31:32,424 we'll offer kidnapping, 15 years. 896 00:31:32,458 --> 00:31:34,260 And she testifies against Stoll. 897 00:31:34,293 --> 00:31:36,528 Ten. 898 00:31:36,562 --> 00:31:37,229 I don't think you're in much of a position 899 00:31:37,263 --> 00:31:39,031 to bargain here, Ms. Walters. 900 00:31:39,065 --> 00:31:40,532 There's still a chance the jury might go 901 00:31:40,566 --> 00:31:41,633 for the insanity defense. 902 00:31:41,667 --> 00:31:43,435 If you were confident about that, 903 00:31:43,469 --> 00:31:44,503 you wouldn't be here. 904 00:31:44,536 --> 00:31:45,604 And if you didn't have concerns, 905 00:31:45,637 --> 00:31:47,373 you wouldn't be here either. 906 00:31:47,406 --> 00:31:50,276 We think Stoll was involved. 907 00:31:50,309 --> 00:31:51,978 We want him held responsible. 908 00:31:55,481 --> 00:31:57,984 Tell your client 15's the best deal 909 00:31:58,017 --> 00:31:59,285 she's ever gonna get. 910 00:32:07,593 --> 00:32:11,563 Right now? 911 00:32:22,474 --> 00:32:25,511 Frank told me that he'd gotten 912 00:32:25,544 --> 00:32:28,180 his ex-girlfriend pregnant. 913 00:32:28,214 --> 00:32:29,581 He said that they'd sell me the child 914 00:32:29,615 --> 00:32:32,251 for $50,000. 915 00:32:32,284 --> 00:32:34,053 And when I said that I wanted to see 916 00:32:34,086 --> 00:32:37,323 the baby's mother, he told me where Chelsea worked. 917 00:32:38,524 --> 00:32:40,559 You discussed the adoption with her? 918 00:32:40,592 --> 00:32:43,262 Frank told me not to. 919 00:32:43,295 --> 00:32:46,765 He said she didn't wanna know who was getting the baby. 920 00:32:46,798 --> 00:32:51,337 She didn't want that connection. 921 00:32:54,573 --> 00:32:58,444 She sells it pretty good. 922 00:32:58,477 --> 00:33:00,646 But I don't know that I'm convinced. 923 00:33:00,679 --> 00:33:03,482 Her details seem to add up. 924 00:33:03,515 --> 00:33:04,416 We gave her the broad stroke, 925 00:33:04,450 --> 00:33:06,452 she could be just filling in the blanks. 926 00:33:06,485 --> 00:33:07,519 We'll never know exactly what happened 927 00:33:07,553 --> 00:33:09,621 in that apartment. 928 00:33:09,655 --> 00:33:11,123 But if you compare Arlene's background 929 00:33:11,157 --> 00:33:13,259 to Frank Stoll's... 930 00:33:13,292 --> 00:33:15,194 my money's on Stoll for the murder. 931 00:33:15,227 --> 00:33:16,495 She's always admitted to the kidnapping 932 00:33:16,528 --> 00:33:17,529 but not the murder. 933 00:33:17,563 --> 00:33:20,032 She's never wavered from that. 934 00:33:23,602 --> 00:33:24,670 But do we believe her? 935 00:33:24,703 --> 00:33:28,574 I just don't think it was Arlene. 936 00:33:28,607 --> 00:33:30,142 [knocking] 937 00:33:30,176 --> 00:33:33,312 This just came in. 938 00:33:34,680 --> 00:33:36,282 DNA results. 939 00:33:36,315 --> 00:33:37,416 It's confirmed. 940 00:33:37,449 --> 00:33:38,684 Frank Stoll is the baby's father. 941 00:33:43,855 --> 00:33:46,158 What? 942 00:33:46,192 --> 00:33:48,527 Nicky's not mine? 943 00:33:48,560 --> 00:33:49,628 (Borgia) The court's ordered a DNA test 944 00:33:49,661 --> 00:33:53,565 when Frank Stoll filed for paternity. 945 00:33:53,599 --> 00:33:57,269 The results show that the baby is his. 946 00:34:00,806 --> 00:34:06,178 But no... there must be some mistake. 947 00:34:06,212 --> 00:34:08,180 There's no mistake. 948 00:34:08,214 --> 00:34:14,086 No--Chelsea would have told me if he wasn't mine. 949 00:34:14,120 --> 00:34:15,854 I can't believe this. 950 00:34:15,887 --> 00:34:18,757 She never mentioned anything about Frank? 951 00:34:18,790 --> 00:34:21,127 No, nothing. 952 00:34:21,160 --> 00:34:22,394 She even told me that Nicky looked like me. 953 00:34:22,428 --> 00:34:25,431 She said he had my ears, my hands. 954 00:34:25,464 --> 00:34:28,634 I spent nine months listening to his heartbeat. 955 00:34:28,667 --> 00:34:30,569 I get up with him at night. 956 00:34:30,602 --> 00:34:34,406 I feed him, I read to him. 957 00:34:34,440 --> 00:34:37,109 He knows my voice. He knows my smell. 958 00:34:37,143 --> 00:34:40,146 [baby cooing] 959 00:34:40,179 --> 00:34:42,481 Now that Chelsea's gone, 960 00:34:42,514 --> 00:34:43,582 I am the only one in this world 961 00:34:43,615 --> 00:34:44,650 that's here for him. 962 00:34:47,253 --> 00:34:49,755 If there is a custody case, it won't be anytime soon. 963 00:34:49,788 --> 00:34:52,691 Stoll's facing criminal charges right now. 964 00:34:52,724 --> 00:34:54,826 Where is he? 965 00:34:54,860 --> 00:34:57,429 He's been arraigned and remanded to Rikers. 966 00:34:57,463 --> 00:34:59,698 Arlene's agreed to testify against him. 967 00:34:59,731 --> 00:35:03,502 If you lose the case... 968 00:35:03,535 --> 00:35:05,604 he'll get custody of Nicky, won't he? 969 00:35:08,640 --> 00:35:11,643 I guess you should be ready for that possibility. 970 00:35:15,247 --> 00:35:19,485 How do you prepare to lose your child, Mr. McCoy? 971 00:35:24,756 --> 00:35:27,459 (McCoy) When Frank Stoll told you he could get you a baby, 972 00:35:27,493 --> 00:35:29,361 how did you respond? 973 00:35:29,395 --> 00:35:30,662 I was thrilled. 974 00:35:30,696 --> 00:35:33,232 He said he'd found homes for two other babies 975 00:35:33,265 --> 00:35:34,766 and that everything had gone off without a hitch. 976 00:35:34,800 --> 00:35:37,636 Did he tell you how he'd encountered these babies? 977 00:35:37,669 --> 00:35:38,737 He just said that 978 00:35:38,770 --> 00:35:40,406 there were a lot of young girls 979 00:35:40,439 --> 00:35:41,873 on the streets that wound up pregnant. 980 00:35:41,907 --> 00:35:44,910 So he was a black-market baby broker 981 00:35:44,943 --> 00:35:46,945 of some sort. 982 00:35:46,978 --> 00:35:48,747 Didn't you know that was against the law? 983 00:35:48,780 --> 00:35:51,350 Yes, but I was desperate 984 00:35:51,383 --> 00:35:54,586 and--and it was his baby. 985 00:35:54,620 --> 00:35:56,188 His baby with Chelsea Hagarty. 986 00:35:56,222 --> 00:35:57,223 Yes. 987 00:35:57,256 --> 00:35:58,524 Frank said that she'd agreed 988 00:35:58,557 --> 00:35:59,658 to sell the child 989 00:35:59,691 --> 00:36:02,228 if they found the right person. 990 00:36:02,261 --> 00:36:04,696 (McCoy) How much money did he want for this transaction? 991 00:36:04,730 --> 00:36:05,564 $50,000. 992 00:36:05,597 --> 00:36:09,435 He said most of that would go to Chelsea. 993 00:36:09,468 --> 00:36:10,936 Several days after the baby was born, 994 00:36:10,969 --> 00:36:12,938 you called him on his cell phone. 995 00:36:12,971 --> 00:36:14,740 What did you discuss? 996 00:36:14,773 --> 00:36:17,443 We set up the meeting. 997 00:36:17,476 --> 00:36:18,710 I gave him the money, 998 00:36:18,744 --> 00:36:20,879 he told me to wait on the street 999 00:36:20,912 --> 00:36:22,814 outside of Chelsea's apartment. 1000 00:36:22,848 --> 00:36:24,683 He was gonna go up, get the baby, 1001 00:36:24,716 --> 00:36:26,318 and bring him to me. 1002 00:36:26,352 --> 00:36:30,222 Could you describe what happened next? 1003 00:36:30,256 --> 00:36:33,359 I waited for about 10 minutes outside. 1004 00:36:33,392 --> 00:36:36,228 And then Frank came running out of the apartment 1005 00:36:36,262 --> 00:36:37,563 in a panic. 1006 00:36:37,596 --> 00:36:39,665 He said something had gone wrong 1007 00:36:39,698 --> 00:36:40,966 and told me to get out of there. 1008 00:36:40,999 --> 00:36:43,402 What did you do? 1009 00:36:43,435 --> 00:36:44,836 I asked him if the baby was okay. 1010 00:36:44,870 --> 00:36:46,472 And he said, yeah, the baby was fine, 1011 00:36:46,505 --> 00:36:47,906 but that we had to leave. 1012 00:36:47,939 --> 00:36:49,007 Did you? 1013 00:36:49,040 --> 00:36:53,379 No, I went up to the apartment. 1014 00:36:53,412 --> 00:36:54,480 The door was unlocked. 1015 00:36:54,513 --> 00:36:57,683 What did you see inside? 1016 00:36:57,716 --> 00:37:02,754 Chelsea was lying on the floor. 1017 00:37:02,788 --> 00:37:04,856 And there was blood all around her head. 1018 00:37:04,890 --> 00:37:06,758 Did you call 911? 1019 00:37:06,792 --> 00:37:07,759 No. 1020 00:37:07,793 --> 00:37:08,727 Why not? 1021 00:37:08,760 --> 00:37:10,896 There was no pulse. She was already dead. 1022 00:37:10,929 --> 00:37:13,765 What happened next? 1023 00:37:13,799 --> 00:37:15,701 The baby started crying. 1024 00:37:15,734 --> 00:37:17,969 And, uh... 1025 00:37:18,003 --> 00:37:21,373 I went-- 1026 00:37:21,407 --> 00:37:24,876 I went over to the crib and he was just lying there. 1027 00:37:24,910 --> 00:37:26,512 Small and helpless. 1028 00:37:26,545 --> 00:37:29,481 And at that moment, I thought that he was mine. 1029 00:37:29,515 --> 00:37:34,520 And I... 1030 00:37:34,553 --> 00:37:37,323 I just remember feeling very desperate... 1031 00:37:37,356 --> 00:37:38,790 to save him. 1032 00:37:38,824 --> 00:37:41,460 So you took him and drove him home. 1033 00:37:41,493 --> 00:37:44,496 Yes. 1034 00:37:48,567 --> 00:37:50,936 Nothing further, Your Honor. 1035 00:37:58,944 --> 00:38:03,048 Let's put our cards on the table, Ms. Tarrington. 1036 00:38:03,081 --> 00:38:05,617 You were indicted in this case 1037 00:38:05,651 --> 00:38:06,885 on second degree murder. 1038 00:38:06,918 --> 00:38:08,920 You actually went to trial. 1039 00:38:08,954 --> 00:38:09,755 That's right. 1040 00:38:09,788 --> 00:38:11,790 You claimed you were suffering from 1041 00:38:11,823 --> 00:38:13,759 postpartum psychosis. 1042 00:38:13,792 --> 00:38:15,494 And admitted your involvement. 1043 00:38:15,527 --> 00:38:16,895 Only in the kidnapping. 1044 00:38:16,928 --> 00:38:18,630 In fact, didn't your attorney 1045 00:38:18,664 --> 00:38:20,732 put a psychiatrist on the stand 1046 00:38:20,766 --> 00:38:22,534 who confirmed your diagnosis? 1047 00:38:22,568 --> 00:38:24,035 Yes. 1048 00:38:24,069 --> 00:38:25,003 It was only when you thought you were gonna 1049 00:38:25,036 --> 00:38:27,439 get convicted of murder that you cut a deal. 1050 00:38:27,473 --> 00:38:28,574 Objection. 1051 00:38:28,607 --> 00:38:29,875 Sustained. 1052 00:38:33,412 --> 00:38:35,013 The sentence you're serving... 1053 00:38:35,046 --> 00:38:38,550 is a reduced charge on kidnapping, isn't it? 1054 00:38:38,584 --> 00:38:40,919 Yes. 1055 00:38:40,952 --> 00:38:44,089 Because you agreed to testify 1056 00:38:44,122 --> 00:38:45,891 against Mr. Stoll. 1057 00:38:45,924 --> 00:38:47,993 Yes. 1058 00:38:48,026 --> 00:38:50,829 But, in fact, if it hadn't been for you, 1059 00:38:50,862 --> 00:38:52,864 Chelsea Hagarty would still be alive today. 1060 00:38:52,898 --> 00:38:55,367 No. 1061 00:38:55,401 --> 00:38:57,936 He said that she agreed to give up the child. 1062 00:38:57,969 --> 00:39:00,506 And I had no idea that he was going to hurt her. 1063 00:39:00,539 --> 00:39:02,874 But he didn't hurt her, you did. 1064 00:39:02,908 --> 00:39:05,110 When he told you the deal had fallen through, 1065 00:39:05,143 --> 00:39:06,878 something inside of you snapped. 1066 00:39:06,912 --> 00:39:08,380 No. 1067 00:39:08,414 --> 00:39:09,781 Your husband was joyfully awaiting 1068 00:39:09,815 --> 00:39:12,951 the birth of his child. 1069 00:39:12,984 --> 00:39:14,152 Your friends had already thrown you a shower. 1070 00:39:14,185 --> 00:39:15,721 You wanted that baby 1071 00:39:15,754 --> 00:39:16,788 at any cost. 1072 00:39:16,822 --> 00:39:18,590 Objection. Sustained. 1073 00:39:18,624 --> 00:39:20,091 Is there a question in there, Mr. Tracer? 1074 00:39:22,494 --> 00:39:25,997 Can you prove that you were waiting 1075 00:39:26,031 --> 00:39:27,966 on that sidewalk, Ms. Tarrington? 1076 00:39:27,999 --> 00:39:30,035 Did anybody see you? No. 1077 00:39:30,068 --> 00:39:33,405 That's because you weren't outside, were you? 1078 00:39:33,439 --> 00:39:34,673 You went into the apartment 1079 00:39:34,706 --> 00:39:36,007 to get your baby. 1080 00:39:36,041 --> 00:39:37,976 And when Chelsea wouldn't give him to you, 1081 00:39:38,009 --> 00:39:39,611 you went into a psychotic rage-- 1082 00:39:39,645 --> 00:39:40,779 That's not true. 1083 00:39:40,812 --> 00:39:42,481 You smashed her in the head 1084 00:39:42,514 --> 00:39:44,783 and then smothered her. 1085 00:39:44,816 --> 00:39:46,852 Frank Stoll wasn't even in the room. 1086 00:39:46,885 --> 00:39:47,919 He had your 50,000, 1087 00:39:47,953 --> 00:39:49,888 why should he stick around? 1088 00:39:49,921 --> 00:39:51,657 That's not what happened. No? 1089 00:39:51,690 --> 00:39:54,493 You set this whole tragedy in motion. 1090 00:39:54,526 --> 00:39:55,661 You. 1091 00:39:55,694 --> 00:39:58,597 And you alone. 1092 00:39:58,630 --> 00:40:03,101 The only thing Frank Stoll is guilty of 1093 00:40:03,134 --> 00:40:06,438 is scamming money from a desperate rich woman. 1094 00:40:06,472 --> 00:40:08,039 Correct? 1095 00:40:08,073 --> 00:40:09,908 No, he said that I could have the baby. 1096 00:40:09,941 --> 00:40:12,511 He said that I could have the baby. 1097 00:40:12,544 --> 00:40:14,012 I was supposed to have the baby. 1098 00:40:14,045 --> 00:40:17,849 He was supposed to be my baby. 1099 00:40:20,151 --> 00:40:22,087 Nothing further, Your Honor. 1100 00:40:44,810 --> 00:40:46,645 Has the jury reached a verdict? 1101 00:40:46,678 --> 00:40:48,980 We have. 1102 00:41:00,659 --> 00:41:01,760 The defense will please rise. 1103 00:41:04,095 --> 00:41:06,031 On the count of murder in the second degree, 1104 00:41:06,064 --> 00:41:08,066 how do you find the defendant Frank Stoll? 1105 00:41:08,099 --> 00:41:11,069 We find the defendant not guilty. 1106 00:41:34,192 --> 00:41:36,027 We took our shot. 1107 00:41:36,061 --> 00:41:37,228 Cold comfort. 1108 00:41:37,262 --> 00:41:38,630 Colder for Steven Monroe. 1109 00:41:38,664 --> 00:41:40,065 You don't have to remind me. 1110 00:41:40,098 --> 00:41:42,033 He's gonna have a hard fight 1111 00:41:42,067 --> 00:41:44,603 trying to keep custody of that baby. 1112 00:41:44,636 --> 00:41:47,072 I saw him running out of the courtroom too. 1113 00:41:47,105 --> 00:41:48,139 I don't think he's sticking around 1114 00:41:48,173 --> 00:41:50,742 for any fight. 1115 00:41:52,043 --> 00:41:53,011 The neighbors have been complaining 1116 00:41:53,044 --> 00:41:56,047 about the noise up here the last couple of days. 1117 00:41:56,081 --> 00:41:57,182 Did you talk to Monroe about it? 1118 00:41:57,215 --> 00:41:59,785 I called him, said he was moving some furniture around. 1119 00:41:59,818 --> 00:42:00,986 He'd keep it low. 1120 00:42:01,019 --> 00:42:02,287 You ever bother to stop in? 1121 00:42:02,320 --> 00:42:05,123 Hey, this ain't my only building. 1122 00:42:06,858 --> 00:42:10,562 Mr. Monroe! NYPD! 1123 00:42:10,596 --> 00:42:14,199 Now, this is why God created security deposits. 1124 00:42:16,167 --> 00:42:18,837 There's nothing here, Detective. 1125 00:42:18,870 --> 00:42:20,238 (Fontana) Well, he's got a couple hours head start on us. 1126 00:42:20,271 --> 00:42:22,173 He could anywhere by now. 1127 00:42:22,207 --> 00:42:23,775 Does Mr. Monroe have any family 1128 00:42:23,809 --> 00:42:24,776 we could speak to? 1129 00:42:24,810 --> 00:42:26,077 Not that I know of. 1130 00:42:26,111 --> 00:42:27,913 I could check the rental application. 1131 00:42:27,946 --> 00:42:30,281 (Fontana) Do that. 1132 00:42:36,655 --> 00:42:38,757 Frank Stoll wants to know what we're doing 1133 00:42:38,790 --> 00:42:40,291 to find his son. 1134 00:42:40,325 --> 00:42:43,695 Why, so he can sell him off to the highest bidder? 1135 00:42:43,729 --> 00:42:44,630 I spoke to the police. 1136 00:42:44,663 --> 00:42:49,034 They already have a few leads on Monroe. 1137 00:42:49,067 --> 00:42:50,368 Tell them to take the weekend off. 1138 00:42:50,401 --> 00:42:53,104 Get a fresh start on Monday. 1139 00:42:56,742 --> 00:42:59,678 Captioning by CaptionMax www.captionmax.com