1
00:00:07,840 --> 00:00:10,108
[female narrator] when a
devoted mother disappears,
2
00:00:10,177 --> 00:00:13,111
Loved ones fear the worst.
3
00:00:13,180 --> 00:00:14,379
No matter where
joleen was at,
4
00:00:14,448 --> 00:00:17,182
She would always
answer her phone.
5
00:00:17,184 --> 00:00:19,918
I just felt like
somethin' bad had happened
6
00:00:19,987 --> 00:00:22,988
And that she wouldn't be back.
7
00:00:23,056 --> 00:00:24,190
[narrator]
a woman with a history
8
00:00:24,258 --> 00:00:27,193
Of choosing the wrong man...
9
00:00:27,195 --> 00:00:28,861
She didn't always
pick the best guys.
10
00:00:28,929 --> 00:00:30,129
I don't know why.
11
00:00:30,131 --> 00:00:31,463
She could always
do so much better.
12
00:00:36,337 --> 00:00:40,205
[narrator] ...Crosses a stranger
with a secret past.
13
00:00:40,273 --> 00:00:43,442
[bill] she went by around
17 different aliases.
14
00:00:43,510 --> 00:00:47,246
She had several driver's
licenses in different states,
15
00:00:47,314 --> 00:00:50,682
[charity] we just didn't know
what we had at that point.
16
00:00:50,684 --> 00:00:51,951
Who is this lady?
17
00:01:00,294 --> 00:01:02,427
[narrator] the search
uncovers an overwhelming
18
00:01:02,429 --> 00:01:07,700
Amount of lies
and unspeakable violence.
19
00:01:07,768 --> 00:01:09,501
And you say, holy crap.
20
00:01:09,503 --> 00:01:11,971
You know, something really
serious happened in here.
21
00:01:17,244 --> 00:01:19,312
[wayne]
she was extremely jealous.
22
00:01:19,379 --> 00:01:23,448
She was very controlling.
She was at times very violent.
23
00:01:23,517 --> 00:01:26,318
This is a, a weird, evil woman.
24
00:01:30,991 --> 00:01:36,929
[music]
25
00:01:41,001 --> 00:01:42,734
[music]
26
00:01:42,736 --> 00:01:45,638
[narrator] the quaint charm
of fernandina beach, florida
27
00:01:45,706 --> 00:01:50,676
Makes it a favorite destination
for locals and visitors alike.
28
00:01:50,745 --> 00:01:54,079
[wayne] fernandina beach is
located on amelia island.
29
00:01:54,148 --> 00:01:56,381
It's in the very northeastern
corner of florida,
30
00:01:56,383 --> 00:01:58,550
Just above jacksonville.
31
00:01:58,619 --> 00:02:02,555
It's a little island.
Everybody knows everybody.
32
00:02:02,623 --> 00:02:06,292
And so it's a great place
to grow up and raise a family.
33
00:02:09,429 --> 00:02:14,366
[narrator] but on may 14, 2018,
a feeling of dread settles over
34
00:02:14,434 --> 00:02:18,570
The beach town when anne johnso
calls the local sheriff's offic
35
00:02:18,639 --> 00:02:20,973
To report her
34-year-old daughter,
36
00:02:21,041 --> 00:02:24,243
Joleen cummings, missing.
37
00:02:25,646 --> 00:02:27,513
[charity] we originally got a
call from anne johnson,
38
00:02:27,581 --> 00:02:31,583
And she said, the last time
somebody spoke to joleen
39
00:02:31,585 --> 00:02:33,318
Was may 12th.
40
00:02:33,320 --> 00:02:38,657
And a couple of days later,
no one had still heard from her.
41
00:02:38,659 --> 00:02:42,562
[narrator] anne says she began
to worry on Sunday, may 13th,
42
00:02:42,629 --> 00:02:44,930
When jolene failed
to pick up her two sons
43
00:02:44,932 --> 00:02:48,600
After their week-long visit
with their father.
44
00:02:48,669 --> 00:02:51,671
The kids' father contacted
her mother, anne johnson,
45
00:02:51,738 --> 00:02:53,472
And said, do you know
where joleen's at?
46
00:02:53,474 --> 00:02:55,273
She's supposed to
pick the kids up.
47
00:02:55,342 --> 00:02:58,410
And he didn't know
where she was.
48
00:02:58,478 --> 00:03:00,879
[narrator] what's more,
the Sunday of may 13th
49
00:03:00,948 --> 00:03:05,617
Was a very special day
for joleen and her kids.
50
00:03:05,686 --> 00:03:09,254
[charity] her mother told me
it was joleen's birthday,
51
00:03:09,323 --> 00:03:13,625
And also,
this is mother's day.
52
00:03:13,694 --> 00:03:15,994
Joleen's mother reported
that she had not been able
53
00:03:16,063 --> 00:03:18,498
To reach her by phone.
54
00:03:18,565 --> 00:03:20,498
[bill] it was a big concern
that she couldn't be found
55
00:03:20,567 --> 00:03:23,435
Because she does have kids.
She loves her kids.
56
00:03:23,504 --> 00:03:27,173
So certainly, you wanna try to
find 'em as soon as possible.
57
00:03:27,241 --> 00:03:29,975
I just felt like somethin'
bad had happened
58
00:03:30,043 --> 00:03:32,578
And that she wouldn't be back.
59
00:03:38,185 --> 00:03:43,321
[narrator] born on may 13, 1984,
joleen jenson was a small-town
60
00:03:43,390 --> 00:03:46,992
Girl who loved her
family fiercely.
61
00:03:46,994 --> 00:03:50,328
It was just joleen and her mom,
and her stepdad.
62
00:03:50,397 --> 00:03:52,731
They had a good relationship.
63
00:03:52,733 --> 00:03:56,067
They were always together,
having family dinners.
64
00:03:56,136 --> 00:04:00,605
[narrator] joyful and energetic,
joleen drew people in.
65
00:04:00,674 --> 00:04:02,807
[alma] joleen had a
large circle of friends.
66
00:04:02,876 --> 00:04:04,843
Everybody loved joleen.
67
00:04:07,414 --> 00:04:09,014
[narrator]
after graduating high school,
68
00:04:09,082 --> 00:04:11,683
Joleen left for
cosmetology school,
69
00:04:11,685 --> 00:04:15,487
But she know she would
never be gone for long.
70
00:04:15,556 --> 00:04:17,089
[alma] joleen was very much a
small-town girl.
71
00:04:17,157 --> 00:04:19,492
She wanted to own a salon,
72
00:04:19,559 --> 00:04:22,761
So the small town is
the best for that.
73
00:04:25,165 --> 00:04:26,699
[narrator]
after a few years away
74
00:04:26,767 --> 00:04:30,102
And a failed relationship
that left her a single mother,
75
00:04:30,170 --> 00:04:33,772
Joleen moved back
to her hometown.
76
00:04:33,841 --> 00:04:35,574
Joleen was very excited
to be a mom.
77
00:04:35,576 --> 00:04:37,842
She didn't always
pick the best guys.
78
00:04:37,911 --> 00:04:38,978
I don't know why.
79
00:04:39,046 --> 00:04:41,379
She could always
do so much better.
80
00:04:41,448 --> 00:04:44,916
She worked at tangles hair salon
in fernandina beach.
81
00:04:44,985 --> 00:04:47,119
[crystal] the salon
we worked at was a very
82
00:04:47,187 --> 00:04:49,788
Family-friendly place.
83
00:04:49,857 --> 00:04:51,990
We had fun there.
84
00:04:51,992 --> 00:04:55,460
Everybody got along.
You know, had lunches together.
85
00:04:55,462 --> 00:04:59,131
She was the light of the salon.
86
00:04:59,199 --> 00:05:03,669
[narrator] joleen used this time
to build toward her dreams.
87
00:05:03,737 --> 00:05:08,674
She advertised herself
a lot on social media,
88
00:05:08,742 --> 00:05:11,943
And she built a
very good clientele.
89
00:05:12,012 --> 00:05:15,548
I never knew a day
that she wasn't booked.
90
00:05:17,551 --> 00:05:20,151
[narrator] joleen's
career was taking off,
91
00:05:20,153 --> 00:05:22,220
And when she met jason cummings
92
00:05:22,289 --> 00:05:25,957
Her personal life
quickly followed suit.
93
00:05:26,026 --> 00:05:30,495
After the birth of their
first son in 2013, they married
94
00:05:30,564 --> 00:05:34,666
And joleen gave birth
to another boy in 2015.
95
00:05:35,769 --> 00:05:38,369
[mariah] she was so
obsessed with those babies
96
00:05:38,439 --> 00:05:42,474
That nothing else mattered.
Those kids came first.
97
00:05:44,711 --> 00:05:48,180
[narrator] although joleen was
overjoyed to grow her family,
98
00:05:48,248 --> 00:05:51,883
Her marriage to jason
soon began to fray.
99
00:05:53,387 --> 00:05:56,187
They didn't have a very good
relationship in the end.
100
00:05:56,189 --> 00:05:59,057
But she, she kept trying.
She loved him.
101
00:05:59,126 --> 00:06:03,596
And she always put her men
and her kids before anything.
102
00:06:03,663 --> 00:06:07,665
[narrator]
the two separated in 2017.
103
00:06:07,734 --> 00:06:11,002
[crystal] she wasn't real
talkative about jason.
104
00:06:11,004 --> 00:06:13,738
She was focused on her kids.
105
00:06:13,807 --> 00:06:15,473
They would go visit their
father,
106
00:06:15,542 --> 00:06:18,544
But her kids always
lived with joleen.
107
00:06:21,281 --> 00:06:22,682
[narrator]
soon after the separation,
108
00:06:22,749 --> 00:06:25,016
She began dating someone new.
109
00:06:25,018 --> 00:06:27,686
But after her past
failed relationships,
110
00:06:27,688 --> 00:06:32,090
Joleen wanted to keep
this one to herself.
111
00:06:32,092 --> 00:06:35,628
[mariah] with men,
she was a very private girl.
112
00:06:35,695 --> 00:06:38,129
I knew she was dating a new guy.
113
00:06:38,131 --> 00:06:42,168
And at times when I would see
her, she was very excited.
114
00:06:42,235 --> 00:06:45,237
It was new.
It was butterflies.
115
00:06:45,305 --> 00:06:47,439
[narrator] joleen was
enjoying motherhood,
116
00:06:47,507 --> 00:06:50,842
A flourishing career,
and a growing romance.
117
00:06:50,911 --> 00:06:53,111
It seemed all of
the pieces of her life
118
00:06:53,180 --> 00:06:56,481
Were falling into place.
119
00:06:59,052 --> 00:07:02,387
Until may 14, 2018,
120
00:07:02,455 --> 00:07:07,258
When the reliable mother
is nowhere to be found.
121
00:07:07,327 --> 00:07:08,726
Everyone was just panicking.
122
00:07:08,795 --> 00:07:11,863
We didn't know what
could've happened.
123
00:07:11,932 --> 00:07:15,534
We still held on to the hope
that she was okay somewhere.
124
00:07:15,602 --> 00:07:18,837
But it was like deep down
we knew better.
125
00:07:21,008 --> 00:07:23,141
[narrator] local authorities
start their search
126
00:07:23,210 --> 00:07:27,412
By contacting the first person
to notice joleen's absence,
127
00:07:27,480 --> 00:07:31,483
Her estranged husband,
jason cummings.
128
00:07:31,551 --> 00:07:33,819
Joleen was going through a
divorce with her husband,
129
00:07:33,887 --> 00:07:35,287
Jason cummings.
130
00:07:35,355 --> 00:07:38,423
And the final custody
had not been determined.
131
00:07:38,425 --> 00:07:40,358
A custody dispute can be a
huge motivator to
132
00:07:40,427 --> 00:07:42,493
Possibly to do violence.
133
00:07:42,563 --> 00:07:44,930
I wanted to meet
with him in person.
134
00:07:47,701 --> 00:07:49,768
[narrator] jason agrees to come
to the sheriff's office
135
00:07:49,770 --> 00:07:51,971
The next day for an interview.
136
00:07:52,038 --> 00:07:54,372
And investigators continue
to call more
137
00:07:54,441 --> 00:07:57,642
Of joleen's family and friends.
138
00:07:57,711 --> 00:08:00,111
[wayne] through contacting
people who know her
139
00:08:00,180 --> 00:08:01,379
And doing interviews with them,
140
00:08:01,381 --> 00:08:04,315
The last place that we could
determine that joleen was seen
141
00:08:04,384 --> 00:08:05,917
Was at her place of employment,
142
00:08:05,986 --> 00:08:09,587
At tangles hair salon,
on the 12th of may.
143
00:08:09,656 --> 00:08:12,056
We talked to the salon owner.
144
00:08:12,125 --> 00:08:14,993
We got the names of the people
who were working that day.
145
00:08:14,995 --> 00:08:17,262
She, uh, had joleen cummings,
who had been with her
146
00:08:17,264 --> 00:08:20,132
For several years.
147
00:08:20,200 --> 00:08:23,602
Ann morgan, who had been there
for approximately 10 years.
148
00:08:23,670 --> 00:08:26,671
And she had a newer employee
who had only been there
149
00:08:26,740 --> 00:08:29,908
For a couple of months, and
her name was jennifer sybert.
150
00:08:31,144 --> 00:08:33,678
[narrator] the salon owner
says joleen and jennifer
151
00:08:33,747 --> 00:08:38,950
Closed the salon on Saturday,
may 12th, around 5:00 pm.
152
00:08:39,019 --> 00:08:42,620
Well, we knew the type of
vehicle that joleen drove.
153
00:08:42,689 --> 00:08:45,156
It was not anywhere
near the salon.
154
00:08:45,158 --> 00:08:49,827
And the salon had a camera,
but it was not working.
155
00:08:49,896 --> 00:08:52,830
[wayne] we did attempt
to ping her cell phone,
156
00:08:52,899 --> 00:08:55,367
And the cell phone
was either not working
157
00:08:55,435 --> 00:08:57,702
Or it had been turned off.
158
00:08:57,771 --> 00:08:59,505
We checked her bank records.
159
00:08:59,573 --> 00:09:01,239
We checked
social media accounts.
160
00:09:01,308 --> 00:09:04,108
None of those had had any, uh,
activity since the last day
161
00:09:04,177 --> 00:09:06,844
That she had worked,
which was on may 12th.
162
00:09:07,581 --> 00:09:09,915
We know that after that,
nobody had seen her,
163
00:09:09,983 --> 00:09:13,184
So the focus of our timeline
was basically between
164
00:09:13,186 --> 00:09:15,587
The 12th and the 14th.
165
00:09:18,525 --> 00:09:20,458
[narrator] investigators
immediately release
166
00:09:20,527 --> 00:09:23,127
A description of joleen
and her vehicle
167
00:09:23,196 --> 00:09:24,662
To the local news,
168
00:09:24,731 --> 00:09:27,932
And reach out to her
co-worker, jennifer.
169
00:09:28,001 --> 00:09:31,069
We asked if joleen had mentioned
anything about going anywhere.
170
00:09:31,137 --> 00:09:35,274
Jennifer went into a long
explanation about why
171
00:09:35,342 --> 00:09:39,744
She could not be involved in a
law enforcement investigation.
172
00:09:39,746 --> 00:09:42,013
She stated that she had
an ex-boyfriend who was
173
00:09:42,015 --> 00:09:45,016
A computer expert,
and that he was a stalker,
174
00:09:45,085 --> 00:09:46,484
And if her name
was listed anywhere,
175
00:09:46,553 --> 00:09:48,419
He would track her down.
176
00:09:48,421 --> 00:09:49,955
I said, I just need to know,
177
00:09:50,023 --> 00:09:52,890
Did you work with
joleen on Saturday,
178
00:09:52,959 --> 00:09:55,694
And if she discussed
any upcoming plans?
179
00:09:55,762 --> 00:09:59,031
Jennifer stated that her
and jolene were not close,
180
00:09:59,099 --> 00:10:03,435
That joleen was acting normally,
and that, uh, she didn't mention
181
00:10:03,503 --> 00:10:05,937
Any upcoming plans
for the weekend.
182
00:10:08,174 --> 00:10:10,776
[narrator] with concern
for joleen mounting,
183
00:10:10,844 --> 00:10:14,413
Detectives dig deeper
into her history.
184
00:10:14,481 --> 00:10:15,780
[wayne] if somebody's
reported missing,
185
00:10:15,782 --> 00:10:18,416
We're gonna look for recent
police reports.
186
00:10:18,485 --> 00:10:22,487
I had discovered a previous
police report on the 9th of may.
187
00:10:22,555 --> 00:10:25,790
There had been a
domestic situation.
188
00:10:25,792 --> 00:10:29,194
Jason gee had come over
and asked to spend the night.
189
00:10:29,262 --> 00:10:32,964
When she told him he could not
spend the night, he got upset.
190
00:10:37,137 --> 00:10:39,071
[narrator] detectives then
arrange to meet joleen's
191
00:10:39,139 --> 00:10:42,675
Stepfather at her home
to conduct a wellness check,
192
00:10:42,742 --> 00:10:46,679
And what they find
is concerning.
193
00:10:46,746 --> 00:10:50,081
[mark] that afternoon,
on Monday the 14th,
194
00:10:50,083 --> 00:10:53,751
We noticed that the
residence was secured,
195
00:10:53,820 --> 00:10:57,890
But once entering in,
the house looked
196
00:10:57,957 --> 00:11:01,159
A little bit in disarray.
197
00:11:01,161 --> 00:11:03,762
There were some cabinet doors
that were loose,
198
00:11:03,830 --> 00:11:06,432
Some holes in the walls.
199
00:11:06,499 --> 00:11:10,001
We actually reached out to an
officer who had responded there,
200
00:11:10,070 --> 00:11:13,572
And he advised that,
that was typical for that house.
201
00:11:16,476 --> 00:11:17,775
[narrator] coming up,
202
00:11:17,844 --> 00:11:21,779
Detectives suspect that joleen'
disappearance could be connecte
203
00:11:21,848 --> 00:11:25,117
To her complicated love life.
204
00:11:25,185 --> 00:11:27,786
We did discover that sometimes
joleen may not have
205
00:11:27,854 --> 00:11:31,790
Made the best decisions with
the guys that she chose to date.
206
00:11:31,858 --> 00:11:33,524
[bill] we'd call him.
He'd hang up.
207
00:11:33,593 --> 00:11:35,193
We go to his house.
He's not there.
208
00:11:35,195 --> 00:11:37,695
It seemed like
he's trying to avoid us.
209
00:11:39,132 --> 00:11:42,600
[music]
210
00:11:53,279 --> 00:11:56,280
[narrator] may 15, 2018.
211
00:11:56,349 --> 00:11:59,418
It's been three days since
34-year-old mother
212
00:11:59,486 --> 00:12:03,488
Joleen cummings was last seen.
213
00:12:03,556 --> 00:12:05,890
[mariah] no one knew
what had happened,
214
00:12:05,892 --> 00:12:09,161
But we had a feeling something
bad had happened.
215
00:12:10,163 --> 00:12:12,563
[narrator] after finding
her house in disarray,
216
00:12:12,632 --> 00:12:16,502
Investigators start looking
into the men in joleen's life,
217
00:12:16,569 --> 00:12:21,639
Beginning with her estranged
husband, jason cummings.
218
00:12:21,641 --> 00:12:24,243
[wayne] joleen was going through
a divorce with her husband.
219
00:12:24,310 --> 00:12:26,444
If somebody's reported missing,
and they're going through
220
00:12:26,513 --> 00:12:29,113
A separation or a divorce,
221
00:12:29,182 --> 00:12:31,450
You know, the person involved
with that's gonna be
222
00:12:31,518 --> 00:12:34,920
One of the first people
we look at.
223
00:12:37,857 --> 00:12:40,324
[narrator] three days
after joleen's disappearance,
224
00:12:40,393 --> 00:12:44,829
Jason sits down with detectives
for an interview.
225
00:12:44,831 --> 00:12:47,865
He admits that he
and joleen had arguments,
226
00:12:47,934 --> 00:12:50,803
But denies any
physical altercations.
227
00:13:03,917 --> 00:13:07,552
He gave a alibi
of being with some friends
228
00:13:07,620 --> 00:13:10,188
At a specific location
all weekend.
229
00:13:10,256 --> 00:13:12,690
I asked him
for permission to search
230
00:13:12,759 --> 00:13:15,094
And download his cellular phone.
231
00:13:15,161 --> 00:13:17,695
I didn't find anything
of evidentiary value
232
00:13:17,697 --> 00:13:20,264
On the cell phone.
233
00:13:20,333 --> 00:13:23,701
He also gave written consent
for a search of his vehicle.
234
00:13:23,703 --> 00:13:26,637
We actually had a crime scene
unit go out and examine it
235
00:13:26,706 --> 00:13:28,574
And take photos of it.
236
00:13:28,641 --> 00:13:33,445
But we saw nothing inside the
vehicle of a suspicious nature.
237
00:13:36,449 --> 00:13:38,516
[narrator]
before the interview is over,
238
00:13:38,518 --> 00:13:40,251
Jason cummings has a question
239
00:13:40,320 --> 00:13:43,154
About the other man
in joleen's life.
240
00:14:12,619 --> 00:14:16,087
[narrator] detectives find jason
cummings has never been charged
241
00:14:16,156 --> 00:14:19,391
Nor convicted of any crimes
against joleen,
242
00:14:19,459 --> 00:14:23,761
So they release him while they
work to confirm his alibi.
243
00:14:23,763 --> 00:14:26,030
At that point in time,
we began to look
244
00:14:26,099 --> 00:14:28,166
For joleen's boyfriend,
jason gee,
245
00:14:28,168 --> 00:14:30,034
Whose name and information
I had discovered
246
00:14:30,103 --> 00:14:32,136
In a domestic incident.
247
00:14:32,205 --> 00:14:34,171
There was no physical
violence documented,
248
00:14:34,240 --> 00:14:36,542
But it was documented
that he had gotten angry
249
00:14:36,609 --> 00:14:38,743
And damaged the cabinets
in the home.
250
00:14:39,979 --> 00:14:42,313
[bill] when we try to contact
jason gee, we'd call him.
251
00:14:42,315 --> 00:14:44,383
He'd hang up.
We go to his house.
252
00:14:44,450 --> 00:14:45,783
He's not there.
253
00:14:45,785 --> 00:14:48,586
It seemed like
he's trying to avoid us.
254
00:14:48,655 --> 00:14:51,389
[wayne] he had a active warrant
for violation of probation.
255
00:14:51,391 --> 00:14:53,458
And we knew that
he was dodging that,
256
00:14:53,526 --> 00:14:56,460
But still the more he dodged us,
257
00:14:56,529 --> 00:14:59,898
He certainly was becoming
more of a suspect.
258
00:15:03,336 --> 00:15:05,803
[narrator] investigators
concentrate more resources
259
00:15:05,805 --> 00:15:08,939
On locating jason.
260
00:15:09,009 --> 00:15:10,741
[wayne] we were also looking
at his background,
261
00:15:10,810 --> 00:15:13,177
And any relatives,
any friends,
262
00:15:13,246 --> 00:15:16,014
Any locations
that he frequented.
263
00:15:16,082 --> 00:15:18,749
Jason gee was eventually found
in hilliard, florida.
264
00:15:18,818 --> 00:15:21,752
He had a relative
that lived there.
265
00:15:21,821 --> 00:15:23,955
Law enforcement went
to the relative's house.
266
00:15:24,023 --> 00:15:27,092
He was hiding under some boxes
in the bedroom.
267
00:15:29,095 --> 00:15:30,963
[narrator]
authorities arrest jason gee
268
00:15:31,030 --> 00:15:32,763
On an outstanding warrant
269
00:15:32,832 --> 00:15:35,833
And bring him in
for an interview.
270
00:15:35,835 --> 00:15:37,969
Jason gee had some
criminal history
271
00:15:38,037 --> 00:15:40,439
And some brushes with the law.
272
00:16:32,825 --> 00:16:35,893
[narrator] detectives press
jason gee for his whereabouts
273
00:16:35,895 --> 00:16:38,396
On the day joleen went missing.
274
00:17:00,320 --> 00:17:02,420
[narrator] for detectives,
this information
275
00:17:02,488 --> 00:17:04,455
Raises a red flag.
276
00:17:04,524 --> 00:17:07,258
It's the same day
joleen was last seen ,
277
00:17:07,326 --> 00:17:10,929
And only an hour
before the salon closed.
278
00:17:22,608 --> 00:17:24,276
[narrator]
the whereabouts of jason's phon
279
00:17:24,343 --> 00:17:27,346
Fuels only more suspicion.
280
00:17:54,941 --> 00:17:56,907
[wayne] he's knowing he's gonna
sit in jail for a little while.
281
00:17:56,976 --> 00:17:58,776
He's obviously angry
with law enforcement.
282
00:17:58,845 --> 00:18:02,513
But when it come to joleen, you
know, his demeanor did change.
283
00:18:02,515 --> 00:18:05,117
He seemed legitimately concerned
that she was missing.
284
00:18:07,854 --> 00:18:11,256
[narrator] investigators
need to confirm jason's alibi,
285
00:18:11,324 --> 00:18:15,527
But first, they head to the
last place joleen was spotted,
286
00:18:15,595 --> 00:18:17,662
The salon.
287
00:18:17,730 --> 00:18:18,863
[bill] we had no
other indication
288
00:18:18,931 --> 00:18:19,997
She was anywhere else.
289
00:18:19,999 --> 00:18:21,999
Nobody had seen her after work,
290
00:18:22,001 --> 00:18:24,335
And no one had
seen her leave work.
291
00:18:24,404 --> 00:18:27,872
We didn't know
what time, or if,
292
00:18:27,874 --> 00:18:31,410
Joleen cummings actually walked
out of the hair salon.
293
00:18:33,213 --> 00:18:34,746
[narrator] coming up,
294
00:18:34,814 --> 00:18:39,683
A potential witness refuses
to cooperate with police.
295
00:18:39,752 --> 00:18:41,219
[bill] she calls her owner.
296
00:18:41,221 --> 00:18:43,487
She said, hey, I'm quitting.
You can mail my check
297
00:18:43,556 --> 00:18:46,323
I can't be involved
in any police activity.
298
00:18:46,392 --> 00:18:49,426
[narrator] and new evidence
sends investigators on a hunt
299
00:18:49,495 --> 00:18:52,696
For a mysterious suspect.
300
00:18:52,765 --> 00:18:54,298
Once the vehicle was parked,
301
00:18:54,300 --> 00:18:55,567
A minute or so later,
302
00:18:55,635 --> 00:18:58,670
You could see someone
exit the driver's side.
303
00:18:59,906 --> 00:19:02,740
[music]
304
00:19:12,985 --> 00:19:18,523
[narrator] may 15, 2018,
34-year-old mother of three
305
00:19:18,591 --> 00:19:23,994
Joleen cummings has been missin
for more than 48 hours.
306
00:19:24,063 --> 00:19:27,499
Up until now, the investigation
has centered on joleen's
307
00:19:27,567 --> 00:19:32,903
Former spouse, jason cummings,
and her boyfriend, jason gee.
308
00:19:32,972 --> 00:19:36,473
Both men say they were visiting
friends and family the weekend
309
00:19:36,542 --> 00:19:40,145
Of joleen's disappearance.
310
00:19:40,213 --> 00:19:43,414
[bill] jason cummings gave us
all of his phones,
311
00:19:43,482 --> 00:19:45,816
And we could check
and see where he was at.
312
00:19:45,818 --> 00:19:48,486
And, uh, so we could
eliminate him as being
313
00:19:48,488 --> 00:19:51,622
Any person of interest
or even a suspect.
314
00:19:51,691 --> 00:19:53,857
[narrator] despite having a
criminal record,
315
00:19:53,927 --> 00:19:58,430
Detectives are also
able to clear jason gee.
316
00:19:58,497 --> 00:20:01,366
[wayne] jason gee gave an alibi
that he was at some
317
00:20:01,434 --> 00:20:03,701
Friend's house in jacksonville.
318
00:20:03,703 --> 00:20:06,503
We sent detectives to talk to
the friends in jacksonville
319
00:20:06,572 --> 00:20:09,440
Who confirmed that he was there.
320
00:20:09,508 --> 00:20:11,375
Jason gee's father
confirmed that he was
321
00:20:11,444 --> 00:20:13,578
The one who transported him.
322
00:20:15,715 --> 00:20:17,715
[narrator]
with their leads dwindling,
323
00:20:17,783 --> 00:20:20,651
Authorities decide to circle
back to the location
324
00:20:20,653 --> 00:20:25,456
Where joleen was last seen,
the salon.
325
00:20:25,524 --> 00:20:27,858
[charity] one of our detectives
went to the hair salon,
326
00:20:27,860 --> 00:20:31,328
And while he's in there speaking
to the owner of the hair salon,
327
00:20:31,397 --> 00:20:35,199
Jennifer sybert comes
to the shop.
328
00:20:36,135 --> 00:20:37,868
Only jennifer sybert
and joleen cummings
329
00:20:37,937 --> 00:20:40,071
Were working that day.
330
00:20:40,139 --> 00:20:44,008
So jennifer was the last person
that we know who'd seen her.
331
00:20:44,878 --> 00:20:47,544
The owner of the shop
actually told jennifer,
332
00:20:47,613 --> 00:20:51,081
Hey, there's a detective in here
that wants to speak to you.
333
00:20:51,150 --> 00:20:54,685
[narrator] however, jennifer
makes it clear once again
334
00:20:54,687 --> 00:20:57,755
That she doesn't want
to get involved.
335
00:20:57,757 --> 00:20:59,691
She decided she didn't
want to have any part
336
00:20:59,759 --> 00:21:01,225
Of the police.
337
00:21:01,227 --> 00:21:04,962
As she leaves,
she said, hey, I'm quitting.
338
00:21:04,964 --> 00:21:06,597
You can mail my check.
339
00:21:06,599 --> 00:21:09,099
I can't be involved in
any police activity,
340
00:21:09,101 --> 00:21:11,435
Which is a concern.
341
00:21:11,504 --> 00:21:12,837
[wayne] I thought
it was very unusual,
342
00:21:12,839 --> 00:21:16,707
But there are certainly people
who don't like law enforcement,
343
00:21:16,709 --> 00:21:19,510
And don't want contact
with law enforcement.
344
00:21:21,881 --> 00:21:24,114
[narrator] as detectives
prepare to look deeper
345
00:21:24,116 --> 00:21:26,117
Into jennifer's background,
346
00:21:26,185 --> 00:21:29,821
They receive their
biggest tip yet.
347
00:21:29,889 --> 00:21:33,123
[bill] well, after we put the
flyer out for joleen's vehicle,
348
00:21:33,125 --> 00:21:36,594
We did receive a call from an
individual who thought he seen
349
00:21:36,596 --> 00:21:40,397
That vehicle in a home depot
parking lot.
350
00:21:40,466 --> 00:21:43,668
When we responded, we verified
that it was joleen's car.
351
00:21:45,538 --> 00:21:47,004
[wayne] when we searched
the vehicle, we did not see
352
00:21:47,073 --> 00:21:51,476
Any kind of blood or anything
of evidentiary value.
353
00:21:51,544 --> 00:21:53,210
Once we found her vehicle,
354
00:21:53,279 --> 00:21:56,880
It gave us a place to start and
to work backwards from there.
355
00:21:56,949 --> 00:22:01,419
So what we did was we looked
for surveillance video.
356
00:22:01,487 --> 00:22:03,687
[narrator] when investigators
pull video surveillance
357
00:22:03,689 --> 00:22:08,492
From a nearby bank,
they make a startling discovery
358
00:22:08,494 --> 00:22:11,896
Early in the morning,
the 13th, at about 1:17,
359
00:22:11,964 --> 00:22:15,165
You could see the vehicle
being driven into the home depot
360
00:22:15,234 --> 00:22:16,967
Parking lot.
361
00:22:17,036 --> 00:22:18,803
A minute or so later,
you could see someone
362
00:22:18,871 --> 00:22:21,906
Exit the driver's side.
363
00:22:24,777 --> 00:22:26,911
[narrator] the grainy
footage makes it impossible
364
00:22:26,979 --> 00:22:28,847
To identify the driver,
365
00:22:28,914 --> 00:22:31,349
But investigators
can see the figure walk
366
00:22:31,418 --> 00:22:34,319
To a nearby gas station.
367
00:22:34,387 --> 00:22:37,054
[mark] one of the videos was
from a gate gas station.
368
00:22:37,056 --> 00:22:41,125
It was a very clear video
showing a female wearing
369
00:22:41,193 --> 00:22:43,861
All black enter into the store.
370
00:22:43,929 --> 00:22:46,196
[wayne] once she enters
into the gas station,
371
00:22:46,265 --> 00:22:47,664
And walks up
near the counter,
372
00:22:47,733 --> 00:22:49,867
The surveillance
is even clearer.
373
00:22:49,869 --> 00:22:52,536
And, you know, judging off the
driver's license picture I have,
374
00:22:52,605 --> 00:22:54,939
I'm like,
that's jennifer sybert.
375
00:22:59,479 --> 00:23:01,278
[narrator]
with this new revelation
376
00:23:01,347 --> 00:23:03,214
On Wednesday, may 16th,
377
00:23:03,282 --> 00:23:08,319
Investigators return to joleen'
place of work for a closer look
378
00:23:09,622 --> 00:23:13,023
[mark] the salon had been
closed since joleen cumming's
379
00:23:13,092 --> 00:23:16,226
Disappearance due to the fact
that the salon's normally
380
00:23:16,295 --> 00:23:18,562
Closed Sunday and Monday.
381
00:23:18,564 --> 00:23:21,231
On Tuesday,
when the owner showed up
382
00:23:21,233 --> 00:23:26,036
To open up the business, she had
no employees there to cut hair.
383
00:23:26,105 --> 00:23:28,305
The salon being closed was
pretty important in that
384
00:23:28,307 --> 00:23:32,777
Nobody had cleaned anything.
Nothing had been disturbed.
385
00:23:32,845 --> 00:23:35,512
[narrator] when the crime scene
unit applies luminol,
386
00:23:35,581 --> 00:23:37,781
A chemical that
reacts with blood,
387
00:23:37,850 --> 00:23:40,484
Hidden horrors are revealed.
388
00:23:42,054 --> 00:23:45,656
It just lit up.
And you say, holy crap.
389
00:23:45,724 --> 00:23:48,493
You know, something really
serious happened in here.
390
00:23:51,764 --> 00:23:54,331
[wayne] that was really the
moment when I said,
391
00:23:54,333 --> 00:23:57,034
I'm working a
homicide investigation.
392
00:23:58,204 --> 00:24:00,304
And our number one priority
at that point in time is
393
00:24:00,306 --> 00:24:03,341
To find jennifer sybert.
394
00:24:06,946 --> 00:24:09,479
[narrator] detectives send
samples of the blood evidence
395
00:24:09,549 --> 00:24:11,750
For dna testing.
396
00:24:11,817 --> 00:24:14,419
While they wait for results,
they release a bolo
397
00:24:14,487 --> 00:24:17,822
For jennifer's vehicle
and ping her phone.
398
00:24:17,890 --> 00:24:20,624
Location data places her
somewhere in neighboring
399
00:24:20,626 --> 00:24:22,826
St. Johns county.
400
00:24:22,895 --> 00:24:25,029
[wayne] st. Johns county,
which is a couple of counties
401
00:24:25,031 --> 00:24:26,564
South of nassau.
402
00:24:26,632 --> 00:24:29,967
She had given a false
address to her employer.
403
00:24:29,969 --> 00:24:33,704
Instructions were given to check
any area where somebody needed
404
00:24:33,772 --> 00:24:36,441
To stay or sleep in their car.
405
00:24:36,509 --> 00:24:37,642
[charity] we were informed,
406
00:24:37,710 --> 00:24:39,511
Hey, she's a
transient sometimes.
407
00:24:39,578 --> 00:24:41,345
She's living out of her vehicle.
408
00:24:41,413 --> 00:24:43,782
So I went to a rest area.
409
00:24:43,849 --> 00:24:46,050
I was not expecting
to find her vehicle.
410
00:24:46,118 --> 00:24:49,853
But when I looked to my left
and saw her black kia
411
00:24:49,855 --> 00:24:52,890
Between two semis,
I knew it was her.
412
00:24:57,063 --> 00:24:59,997
I made a phone call
to another detective.
413
00:25:00,065 --> 00:25:03,001
I told him,
hey, her vehicle's here.
414
00:25:03,068 --> 00:25:05,804
[wayne] several, uh,
detectives quickly responded
415
00:25:05,871 --> 00:25:09,273
To st. Johns county,
including myself.
416
00:25:09,341 --> 00:25:11,275
We approached and it appeared
that there was someone
417
00:25:11,343 --> 00:25:13,277
Sleeping in the vehicle.
418
00:25:13,345 --> 00:25:14,611
At that point in time,
419
00:25:14,680 --> 00:25:16,881
I gave the person
verbal commands to
420
00:25:16,949 --> 00:25:21,019
Step out of the vehicle
with their hands visible.
421
00:25:21,086 --> 00:25:24,655
Jennifer sybert exited the
front door of the vehicle.
422
00:25:27,226 --> 00:25:30,361
She had a nasty cut on her face.
423
00:25:30,429 --> 00:25:35,033
Her story was she was riding her
bicycle and she ran into a tree.
424
00:25:35,100 --> 00:25:37,701
But that's not, not what she
would have looked like
425
00:25:37,770 --> 00:25:39,304
If she'd hit a tree.
426
00:25:39,371 --> 00:25:41,772
Looks like she'd
been in a fight.
427
00:25:41,840 --> 00:25:44,375
We asked her, have you ever
been in joleen's vehicle?
428
00:25:44,443 --> 00:25:47,244
She said, no, never have.
429
00:25:47,313 --> 00:25:50,180
[wayne] at that point and time,
I knew she was lying.
430
00:25:50,182 --> 00:25:54,051
I then confronted her and said,
I don't believe you.
431
00:25:54,053 --> 00:25:55,186
At that time she said,
432
00:25:55,254 --> 00:25:57,854
Well, if you don't believe me,
maybe I need an attorney.
433
00:25:57,923 --> 00:26:00,658
[narrator] investigators place
jennifer under arrest
434
00:26:00,726 --> 00:26:04,562
And transport her to the
st. Johns county jail.
435
00:26:06,065 --> 00:26:09,399
We originally charged
jennifer sybert with
436
00:26:09,401 --> 00:26:12,770
Grand theft of joleen's vehicle.
437
00:26:12,838 --> 00:26:14,938
We need to continue
gathering evidence,
438
00:26:14,940 --> 00:26:17,075
Looking for,
for any clues,
439
00:26:17,142 --> 00:26:20,711
Certainly looking to see if
we can find joleen somewhere.
440
00:26:20,713 --> 00:26:22,613
[narrator] they start
by canvassing the area
441
00:26:22,681 --> 00:26:26,117
Around the salon for
more surveillance footage.
442
00:26:26,185 --> 00:26:29,486
[wayne] we did discover a camera
for the alleyway behind tangles
443
00:26:29,555 --> 00:26:32,656
Where the dumpsters are located.
444
00:26:36,095 --> 00:26:39,697
In that video, you can see
jennifer sybert exiting
445
00:26:39,699 --> 00:26:44,101
The rear of the business
with large garbage bags
446
00:26:44,169 --> 00:26:47,171
And throwing them into the
dumpster behind the business
447
00:26:47,173 --> 00:26:49,840
For several hours
after tangles was closed
448
00:26:49,842 --> 00:26:53,177
On the 12th of may.
449
00:26:53,179 --> 00:26:56,314
[narrator] footage further shows
a truck emptying the dumpster
450
00:26:56,382 --> 00:26:58,115
On may 14th,
451
00:26:58,117 --> 00:27:02,719
Just two hours after joleen
was reported missing.
452
00:27:02,788 --> 00:27:04,922
We contacted the,
the company that services
453
00:27:04,924 --> 00:27:07,057
The dumpsters,
and they were able to give us
454
00:27:07,126 --> 00:27:11,195
A general area of where that
particular truck dumped.
455
00:27:11,197 --> 00:27:12,796
We asked them
to isolate the area,
456
00:27:12,798 --> 00:27:14,898
So that we could
later search it.
457
00:27:16,201 --> 00:27:18,268
[narrator] authorities
obtain a search warrant
458
00:27:18,337 --> 00:27:21,138
For jennifer's car.
459
00:27:21,207 --> 00:27:25,208
[bill] we found a bag in there
with combs and scissors.
460
00:27:25,277 --> 00:27:26,944
[wayne] the screw that
attaches two pieces
461
00:27:26,946 --> 00:27:28,479
Of the scissors together,
there was a little bit
462
00:27:28,547 --> 00:27:30,814
Of a darker color
substance in there.
463
00:27:30,816 --> 00:27:33,183
It could have been rust.
It could have been anything.
464
00:27:33,252 --> 00:27:35,952
It was something that
we need to have analyzed.
465
00:27:36,021 --> 00:27:39,823
We did that and it did,
uh, come back as positive for,
466
00:27:39,892 --> 00:27:42,059
Not just blood,
but joleen's blood.
467
00:27:44,029 --> 00:27:45,762
I did believe
at that point
468
00:27:45,831 --> 00:27:48,932
That we had located
the murder weapon.
469
00:27:52,571 --> 00:27:55,906
[narrator] detectives also
discover a record of purchases
470
00:27:55,974 --> 00:28:00,944
Made by jennifer at walmart
around 9:00 pm on may 12th,
471
00:28:00,946 --> 00:28:04,649
The last day
joleen was seen alive.
472
00:28:04,717 --> 00:28:05,982
The detective went
to the walmart
473
00:28:06,051 --> 00:28:08,051
And obtained video surveillance.
474
00:28:08,120 --> 00:28:10,787
[charity] she bought ammonia,
475
00:28:10,856 --> 00:28:14,624
Large trash bags, gloves,
476
00:28:14,693 --> 00:28:17,127
And a carving knife.
477
00:28:17,196 --> 00:28:19,097
[narrator] detectives
re-examine the hours
478
00:28:19,164 --> 00:28:22,265
Of surveillance footage
and quickly realize
479
00:28:22,334 --> 00:28:24,936
That after jennifer purchased
the items at walmart,
480
00:28:25,003 --> 00:28:28,038
She returned to the salon.
481
00:28:28,040 --> 00:28:30,340
Over an hour later, she emerges
482
00:28:30,342 --> 00:28:34,277
And continues
her trips to the dumpster.
483
00:28:34,346 --> 00:28:38,482
[bill] what really floored me
was the electric knife.
484
00:28:38,484 --> 00:28:40,350
When I saw that,
I'm thinking,
485
00:28:40,352 --> 00:28:41,751
She cut joleen up,
486
00:28:41,821 --> 00:28:44,555
Stuffed her in those
black trash bags,
487
00:28:44,623 --> 00:28:47,324
And threw her away like garbage.
488
00:28:50,963 --> 00:28:52,863
[narrator] coming up,
489
00:28:52,931 --> 00:28:57,668
A shocking confession with
a twist no one sees coming.
490
00:29:03,442 --> 00:29:07,310
At the time, I had no idea
if this was true or not true.
491
00:29:07,379 --> 00:29:10,113
[charity] all of a sudden,
there's this information
492
00:29:10,182 --> 00:29:12,783
With a little girl
named jennifer sybert,
493
00:29:12,851 --> 00:29:16,787
Same date of birth,
who died in a car accident
494
00:29:16,855 --> 00:29:20,891
In germany at 13 years old.
It just gave us chills.
495
00:29:22,261 --> 00:29:25,429
[music]
496
00:29:35,074 --> 00:29:39,510
[narrator] joleen cummings is
missing and presumed dead.
497
00:29:39,578 --> 00:29:42,946
Her coworker, jennifer sybert,
is in custody after
498
00:29:43,015 --> 00:29:47,684
Surveillance video shows her
stealing joleen's vehicle.
499
00:29:47,753 --> 00:29:53,557
But blood evidence now points
to a much darker crime.
500
00:29:53,626 --> 00:29:58,428
When the luminol lit up
the salon, it was obviously
501
00:29:58,497 --> 00:30:00,163
A lot of blood.
502
00:30:00,232 --> 00:30:04,367
At that point, we knew
we had a murder on our hands.
503
00:30:04,436 --> 00:30:07,037
[wayne] the amounts of blood
that were found on the walls
504
00:30:07,105 --> 00:30:09,706
And the floor, there were
samples of those collected.
505
00:30:09,775 --> 00:30:12,175
They were sent,
506
00:30:12,244 --> 00:30:15,212
And they did come back
as joleen's dna.
507
00:30:19,918 --> 00:30:21,385
The evidence was mounting,
508
00:30:21,387 --> 00:30:24,254
And we knew that this crime
occurred inside tangles.
509
00:30:24,323 --> 00:30:26,524
[bill] whenever you have a
murder and you can't locate
510
00:30:26,592 --> 00:30:29,326
The body, it's a difficult case.
511
00:30:29,395 --> 00:30:32,329
You have to have
overwhelming evidence.
512
00:30:32,397 --> 00:30:35,065
[narrator] investigators search
the landfill where they believe
513
00:30:35,134 --> 00:30:38,468
Joleen's body may be located.
514
00:30:38,537 --> 00:30:41,871
The area was enormous.
It was almost inconceivable
515
00:30:41,941 --> 00:30:44,375
The amount of refuse
that we went through.
516
00:30:44,443 --> 00:30:46,076
We analyzed what we could,
517
00:30:46,144 --> 00:30:49,847
But nothing of
evidentiary value was found.
518
00:30:52,751 --> 00:30:55,486
[narrator] investigators search
for a potential motive
519
00:30:55,554 --> 00:30:57,020
By interviewing the staff
520
00:30:57,089 --> 00:31:00,825
About jennifer
and joleen's relationship.
521
00:31:00,893 --> 00:31:03,493
When jennifer sybert first
went to work at tangles,
522
00:31:03,562 --> 00:31:07,030
It seemed like her and joleen
got along very well.
523
00:31:07,099 --> 00:31:10,701
But as time went on, there was
tension and eventually downright
524
00:31:10,769 --> 00:31:13,437
Just dislike between the two.
525
00:31:13,439 --> 00:31:15,238
[mariah] joleen had
all the clients.
526
00:31:15,307 --> 00:31:18,709
I don't think she was making the
money that joleen was making.
527
00:31:18,777 --> 00:31:22,178
Joleen had talked
to me about jennifer
528
00:31:22,247 --> 00:31:25,549
And said that something
was really weird with her.
529
00:31:29,187 --> 00:31:32,056
[narrator] another coworker,
anh morgan, who has worked
530
00:31:32,124 --> 00:31:36,192
With joleen for nearly six year
claims that the day before
531
00:31:36,261 --> 00:31:39,897
Her disappearance,
joleen and jennifer argued.
532
00:32:01,587 --> 00:32:05,355
Joleen basically told her,
you're not who you say you are,
533
00:32:05,357 --> 00:32:08,091
And I'm gonna
find out who you are.
534
00:32:08,160 --> 00:32:10,827
[narrator] detectives believe
that cryptic confrontation
535
00:32:10,896 --> 00:32:14,431
May have led to joleen's murder
536
00:32:14,433 --> 00:32:17,801
Something triggered,
uh, jennifer to do this.
537
00:32:17,870 --> 00:32:20,470
What exactly it was,
we don't know.
538
00:32:25,644 --> 00:32:29,112
[narrator] on may 18th,
after two days in custody,
539
00:32:29,181 --> 00:32:32,182
Jennifer drops a bombshell.
540
00:32:55,440 --> 00:32:58,409
[charity] we just didn't know
what we had at that point.
541
00:32:58,477 --> 00:33:00,278
Who is this lady?
542
00:33:00,345 --> 00:33:03,246
What is she about?
Where is she from?
543
00:33:03,248 --> 00:33:06,917
[narrator] kimberly says she
grew up in butler, pennsylvania
544
00:33:15,293 --> 00:33:17,093
[narrator] kimberly tells
investigators
545
00:33:17,162 --> 00:33:18,628
That she dropped out of school
546
00:33:18,697 --> 00:33:21,698
And left pennsylvania
for something new
547
00:33:21,700 --> 00:33:23,934
That proved dangerous.
548
00:33:54,866 --> 00:33:58,135
[narrator] kimberly claims that
after the relationship ended,
549
00:33:58,137 --> 00:34:01,038
She changed her name
and went on the run.
550
00:34:08,280 --> 00:34:11,382
She stuck by the premise
that she was running
551
00:34:11,450 --> 00:34:15,119
From an ex who,
uh, she was afraid of.
552
00:34:17,689 --> 00:34:19,956
[narrator] when the conversation
shifts to joleen,
553
00:34:20,025 --> 00:34:22,626
Kimberly quickly shuts it down.
554
00:34:43,915 --> 00:34:46,983
[narrator] what's more,
investigators find no proof
555
00:34:46,985 --> 00:34:52,790
That anyone is pursuing
kimberly, fbi or otherwise.
556
00:34:52,858 --> 00:34:56,392
[wayne] at the time, I had no
idea what was true or not true.
557
00:34:56,461 --> 00:35:00,930
So we set to work on
finding out who she was.
558
00:35:00,999 --> 00:35:04,601
[charity] I typed in the name,
jennifer sybert, date of birth.
559
00:35:04,669 --> 00:35:09,205
And all of a sudden,
there's this information
560
00:35:09,274 --> 00:35:12,008
With a little girl
named jennifer sybert,
561
00:35:12,077 --> 00:35:14,145
Same date of birth,
562
00:35:14,212 --> 00:35:18,681
Who was in a car
accident in germany.
563
00:35:18,751 --> 00:35:20,684
She died at 13 years old.
564
00:35:23,221 --> 00:35:25,488
It just gave us chills.
565
00:35:26,157 --> 00:35:28,626
She was buried
in butler, pennsylvania,
566
00:35:28,693 --> 00:35:31,861
And we knew that jennifer was
from butler, pennsylvania.
567
00:35:31,863 --> 00:35:34,898
[narrator] they suspect she
stole the real jennifer sybert'
568
00:35:34,966 --> 00:35:38,101
Identity from her gravestone.
569
00:35:38,169 --> 00:35:40,237
[wayne] a detective
contacted the real
570
00:35:40,239 --> 00:35:44,173
Jennifer sybert's father.
He was very surprised.
571
00:35:44,243 --> 00:35:48,845
He said that he had no idea how,
um, kimberly kessler
572
00:35:48,914 --> 00:35:52,048
Could have obtained his
daughter's information.
573
00:35:52,117 --> 00:35:53,983
I've worked identity
theft before.
574
00:35:53,985 --> 00:35:56,452
There's sites you can go to
online, dark web and such,
575
00:35:56,521 --> 00:35:58,322
And get that kind of thing.
576
00:35:58,390 --> 00:36:00,657
[narrator] pennsylvania
authorities tell detectives
577
00:36:00,725 --> 00:36:04,295
That kimberly kessler
was reported missing
578
00:36:04,362 --> 00:36:09,365
By her mother in 2004,
when she was 36 years old.
579
00:36:09,434 --> 00:36:11,601
[wayne] she was an adult
at the time she went missing.
580
00:36:11,603 --> 00:36:13,536
As matter of fact,
her mother waited several
581
00:36:13,605 --> 00:36:15,739
Years before she even
reported her missing.
582
00:36:15,741 --> 00:36:17,374
I think she had
talked about leaving,
583
00:36:17,442 --> 00:36:19,543
Getting out
of butler, pennsylvania.
584
00:36:19,611 --> 00:36:24,013
We actually sent an fbi
agent to the mother's home
585
00:36:24,082 --> 00:36:27,017
And got a dna swab
and discovered, yes,
586
00:36:27,085 --> 00:36:29,687
This is truly her daughter.
587
00:36:32,323 --> 00:36:34,691
[narrator] investigators
continue digging,
588
00:36:34,693 --> 00:36:38,261
Conducting interviews with
anyone who knew kimberly.
589
00:36:49,107 --> 00:36:51,941
In talking with people
that she had dated in the past,
590
00:36:51,943 --> 00:36:57,047
She was extremely jealous.
She was very controlling.
591
00:36:57,115 --> 00:36:59,616
She was at times very violent.
592
00:37:05,624 --> 00:37:07,523
[bill] when we're interviewing
people, we found out she went
593
00:37:07,592 --> 00:37:10,627
By around 17 different aliases.
594
00:37:10,695 --> 00:37:14,063
She had several driver's
licenses in different states,
595
00:37:14,065 --> 00:37:17,167
This is a weird, evil woman.
596
00:37:20,472 --> 00:37:22,273
[narrator] coming up,
597
00:37:22,340 --> 00:37:25,975
Circumstantial evidence
continues to mount,
598
00:37:25,977 --> 00:37:30,281
But kimberly presents an
unexpected new obstacle.
599
00:37:30,348 --> 00:37:33,917
[bill] she was just very
nasty to our deputies
600
00:37:33,919 --> 00:37:35,151
In the jail.
601
00:37:35,220 --> 00:37:38,021
She'd actually
throw crap at them.
602
00:37:38,089 --> 00:37:39,856
Cuss at them,
spit on them,
603
00:37:39,925 --> 00:37:40,691
All that.
604
00:37:44,896 --> 00:37:47,731
[music]
605
00:37:57,309 --> 00:38:01,177
[narrator] may 2018.
It's been eight days since
606
00:38:01,179 --> 00:38:05,181
34-year-old joleen cummings
went missing.
607
00:38:05,183 --> 00:38:08,452
Investigators now suspect the
mother of three has been
608
00:38:08,520 --> 00:38:11,988
Killed by her coworker,
kimberly kessler
609
00:38:11,990 --> 00:38:14,458
Who has allegedly been
on the run and living
610
00:38:14,526 --> 00:38:19,796
Under false indentities
for nearly 25 years.
611
00:38:19,865 --> 00:38:24,735
However, investigators
have yet to recover a body.
612
00:38:24,803 --> 00:38:27,604
No body homicides,
they are much more difficult
613
00:38:27,606 --> 00:38:30,540
To prosecute than
when you have a body.
614
00:38:30,542 --> 00:38:33,443
The body itself is evidence,
you know.
615
00:38:33,512 --> 00:38:36,379
And juries are
very visual people.
616
00:38:39,484 --> 00:38:41,217
[narrator] a search of
kimberly's cell phone
617
00:38:41,219 --> 00:38:44,620
Leads to crucial evidence.
618
00:38:44,622 --> 00:38:46,923
We have her
internet searches--
619
00:38:46,991 --> 00:38:52,094
Coworker guilty of murder,
coworker not found,
620
00:38:52,163 --> 00:38:54,330
No body, no crime.
621
00:38:54,332 --> 00:38:56,766
There were literally
hundreds of searches
622
00:38:56,835 --> 00:39:00,637
In reference to
joleen cummings' disappearance.
623
00:39:04,109 --> 00:39:08,845
[narrator] despite having no
body, on September 7, 2018,
624
00:39:08,847 --> 00:39:12,115
A nassau county grand jury
indicts kimberly
625
00:39:12,183 --> 00:39:15,585
On first-degree murder charges.
626
00:39:15,654 --> 00:39:17,587
Once she is behind bars,
627
00:39:17,656 --> 00:39:19,590
Kimberly exhibits a string
628
00:39:19,657 --> 00:39:23,459
Of increasingly
concerning behaviors.
629
00:39:23,528 --> 00:39:25,995
[bill] she would just be very
nasty to our deputies
630
00:39:26,064 --> 00:39:27,463
In the jail.
631
00:39:27,532 --> 00:39:31,935
She'd actually throw crap
at them she'd save in a cup,
632
00:39:31,937 --> 00:39:36,106
And smear it on the windows,
all over her cell.
633
00:39:36,174 --> 00:39:37,875
Cuss at them,
spit on them,
634
00:39:37,942 --> 00:39:40,243
All that.
635
00:39:42,747 --> 00:39:45,681
[narrator] the behaviors warrant
enough concern to conduct
636
00:39:45,750 --> 00:39:49,285
A mental evaluation to determni
if kimberly is fit
637
00:39:49,287 --> 00:39:51,854
To stand trial.
638
00:39:51,923 --> 00:39:53,356
[dr. Durvasula] she was
diagnosed with
639
00:39:53,425 --> 00:39:55,024
Delusional disorder--
640
00:39:55,026 --> 00:40:00,096
Somebody who has shown
that they maintain behaviors
641
00:40:00,165 --> 00:40:04,100
That are, that are not based
642
00:40:04,102 --> 00:40:06,636
In any form of fact or reality.
643
00:40:09,841 --> 00:40:14,510
Now, if a person is a very,
very convincing actor,
644
00:40:14,579 --> 00:40:17,046
They could convince
somebody that they have
645
00:40:17,115 --> 00:40:18,716
Delusional disorder.
646
00:40:18,783 --> 00:40:23,052
So another psychologist
reevaluated kimberly,
647
00:40:23,121 --> 00:40:27,457
And based on their assessment,
found that kimberly met criteria
648
00:40:27,525 --> 00:40:30,593
For an unspecified
personality disorder
649
00:40:30,662 --> 00:40:33,730
And not a delusional disorder.
650
00:40:33,798 --> 00:40:37,266
It's not considered to be
that real break from reality
651
00:40:37,335 --> 00:40:40,670
That we would see
in successful sorts of
652
00:40:40,738 --> 00:40:43,072
Use of an insanity defense.
653
00:40:43,141 --> 00:40:45,208
[charity] well, the judge
is actually the one who
654
00:40:45,276 --> 00:40:47,477
Makes the final decision.
655
00:40:47,545 --> 00:40:50,780
He decided she was clearly okay
to stand for trial.
656
00:40:54,686 --> 00:40:58,889
[narrator] when kimberly's trial
begins in December 2021,
657
00:40:58,957 --> 00:41:04,561
Her gaunt appearance is
shocking, as are her antics.
658
00:41:04,563 --> 00:41:06,897
When she was housed at,
in the nassau county jail
659
00:41:06,965 --> 00:41:09,967
Detention facility,
she went on a hunger strike.
660
00:41:11,035 --> 00:41:14,971
Every time that, uh, kimberly
had a court hearing,
661
00:41:15,039 --> 00:41:17,306
She would come in
and she would be disruptive.
662
00:41:17,375 --> 00:41:19,742
So the judge would
have her removed.
663
00:41:23,114 --> 00:41:26,515
[narrator] the theatrics do
nothing to distract prosecutors
664
00:41:26,585 --> 00:41:29,986
From building their case.
They present kimberly
665
00:41:30,055 --> 00:41:33,523
As a troubled woman who lashed
out when joleen threatened to
666
00:41:33,591 --> 00:41:37,827
Uncover her long-kept secrect.
667
00:41:37,896 --> 00:41:40,597
I think whenever
joleen told her,
668
00:41:40,599 --> 00:41:41,865
I'm gonna find out who you are,
669
00:41:41,933 --> 00:41:44,001
That was the straw that
broke the camel's back.
670
00:41:46,337 --> 00:41:47,871
For somebody with
kimberly kessler's
671
00:41:47,939 --> 00:41:51,941
Personality style,
once somebody is on to them,
672
00:41:51,943 --> 00:41:55,745
It is not unusual for that
person with that personality
673
00:41:55,814 --> 00:41:59,148
To really agitated,
to escalate.
674
00:41:59,150 --> 00:42:02,286
I believe they got
into a physical altercation.
675
00:42:02,353 --> 00:42:04,887
Joleen cummings fought back,
676
00:42:04,956 --> 00:42:08,892
But I think kimberly was able to
get ahold of a pair of scissors.
677
00:42:08,960 --> 00:42:12,161
That was what incapacitated
joleen cummings,
678
00:42:12,230 --> 00:42:14,764
So that the body could be
disposed of later on
679
00:42:14,766 --> 00:42:16,700
In the back part of the salon.
680
00:42:19,971 --> 00:42:23,306
[dr. Durvasula] kimberly kessler
likely felt entitled
681
00:42:23,308 --> 00:42:25,708
To eliminating joleen,
682
00:42:25,710 --> 00:42:29,579
So that she could maintain
her own false reality
683
00:42:29,647 --> 00:42:31,515
That she had been using
to get through the world
684
00:42:31,583 --> 00:42:34,751
All of these years.
It's actually quite chilling.
685
00:42:37,522 --> 00:42:40,189
[narrator] on December 9, 2021,
686
00:42:40,191 --> 00:42:44,061
The jury convicts
53-year-old kimberly kessler
687
00:42:44,128 --> 00:42:47,630
Of first-degree murder
and grand theft auto.
688
00:42:49,067 --> 00:42:50,733
She was sentenced
to life in prison without
689
00:42:50,802 --> 00:42:53,870
Possibility of parole.
690
00:42:56,808 --> 00:42:59,742
[narrator] to this day,
the search for joleen's body
691
00:42:59,811 --> 00:43:04,213
Continues, and investigators
remain determined to reunite
692
00:43:04,282 --> 00:43:07,483
Her with her beloved family.
693
00:43:07,485 --> 00:43:11,021
I will never give up hope
on locating joleen.
694
00:43:11,089 --> 00:43:13,489
[crystal] I love
and miss joleen very much,
695
00:43:13,491 --> 00:43:15,224
And I would like to say
to kimberly,
696
00:43:15,293 --> 00:43:18,629
If you have any decency
697
00:43:18,696 --> 00:43:23,766
Or any feelings whatsoever,
698
00:43:23,768 --> 00:43:26,635
At least give this family
some closure
699
00:43:26,705 --> 00:43:28,871
And tell them where she is.
700
00:43:31,309 --> 00:43:37,113
[music]