[Jeremiah] Previously on Return to Amish...
[Daniel] I'm just thinking of, you know,
how it's been down here. You know, like, the English life.
Yeah?
Thinking of all those English girls?
[Fannie] Daniel wants someone that understands his background,
understands him,
but I am still not ready to tell Daniel how I feel.
[Kenneth] I wanna be the first Amish, college basketball player,
and I've never had the opportunity to work with a coach.
Like, Coach T that knows as much as he does.
Dude, you got somethin'. You definitely can hoop a little, man.
What you have to do right now, ASAP, after today,
is do exactly what you did today, tomorrow.
You have no time to waste.
I'm actually going home.
[Johnny] Having an elder Amish in the house
made me more comfortable.
And now I'm worried what's gonna happen.
Hello.
-I'm Claudia. -Johnny.
She has a way of influencing people,
and that's what worries me,
that she's gonna influence Rose.
[speaking Pennsylvania German]
I know what you're [bleep] tryin' to do.
-Get the [bleep] off my face. -[Johnny] Get outta here.
[Raymond] Johnny has crossed the line,
talking to my sister like that.
Get out of my goddamn face!
You're dating my goddamn sister!
You get outta...
[Jeremiah] Last night was a wild night for these kids.
Since Ada left,
these kids think they can get drunk whenever they want to,
and just go crazy.
Last night was hard. It definitely got out of hand.
It was just way more than I expected.
[Sabrina] The partying has to stop.
These guys, they need to be able to experience more things
'cause that's the only way they're gonna grow.
Because if they just focus on partying,
they're never gonna grow.
They're never gonna be able to become who they're meant to be.
I definitely think we need to have a house meeting
because I'm worried that things are gonna get worse.
[Johnny] Can I talk to you?
Last night, I feel like I needed to say something
to Rosanna,
'cause I felt like all the English temptation was corrupting her,
but I should've come at it in a different way.
I just want to talk about what happened last night,
-fighting. -[Rosanna] Mmm-hmm.
You disrespected me, and that was not okay.
I was really upset.
Johnny said some things to me last night
that really hurt me.
I don't like to get disrespected like that.
And you shouldn't have brought it up about that
in front of Claudia either.
That's why it upset me so bad, too,
is because you had to do this fight
in front of Claudia and everyone.
Like, that really pissed me off.
[Rosanna speaking Pennsylvania German]
[Johnny speaking Pennsylvania German]
[Johnny speaking English] We just kind of went...
Took it overboard last night about it.
[Johnny speaking Pennsylvania German]
[speaking English] I don't wanna see that.
[speaking English] Well, I'm... I'm afraid
if I would go back Amish with you,
what will happen... I want, like...
I'm trying to experience all this stuff out here in the English world.
[speaking Pennsylvania German]
[speaking English] Maybe we should just walk our separate ways,
and then you can live out here, and I can just go back.
I wanna support you and everything you wanna do,
but I think that we would be...
We could have a better life
if would just stay in the community,
and it would be better for us.
I could take care of you better.
But if you wanna go out there and experience that,
and if you don't wanna come home with me
and live the Amish life again, well, that's okay.
I'm gonna let you make that decision.
But I, personally, wanna go home
and continue my life being Amish,
and be with my brothers and sisters and family,
and I feel like it would be better for both of us.
[speaking English] Stop being so dramatic.
We'll work something out.
[Rosanna] It was rare how Johnny acted last night,
but we can't break up
because I have news to tell Johnny.
But I'm nervous
because I'm not sure what he's gonna say.
I set up a baby shower for Sabrina,
and I think it looks pretty good.
I think she's gonna be tickled pink.
Today, my focus is, uh, making Sabrina feel beautiful
and feel like a princess,
and I just want her to have fun.
[knock at door]
-[Jethro] Hey. -[Carmela] Hey.
[Jethro] Come in.
Oh, it's so cute in here.
[Jethro] Babe, they're here!
[Johnny] Where do you want all these gifts at?
-[Jethro] Just put them here on the table. -[Johnny] Right here?
Hi.
-[Carmela] Hey. -[Jeremiah] Hello.
[Carmela] Oh, you look beautiful.
-Look at you. -Thank you.
You guys didn't have to bring gifts.
[Jeremiah] Oh, we had to.
Well, I have so much baby stuff,
I don't know what to do with it anymore.
This is the first time I've ever done baby showers,
so I brought you some pickled stuff.
I already have a pickle. I don't need another one.
[all laughing]
Size extra-large.
[all laughing]
So, you guys wanna open the gifts?
-[Jethro] Hell yeah. Let's go. -[Sabrina] Yeah.
You guys sit down right here.
-[Sabrina] All right. -[Jethro] All right.
[Fannie] The Amish, they don't really celebrate like that.
We're not supposed to shed light on just one person.
It's like vanity.
But I just don't know what's wrong
with having a party like that,
because the baby shower was very fun.
[Sabrina] I need to keep this away from Jethro.
Because this stuff will make you stink so bad.
[all laughing]
-[Sabrina] Thank you. -[Fannie] You're welcome.
I'm really thankful that Jethro set this up,
and that he invited everybody,
but I feel bad for Carmela.
I feel guilty because I keep having babies.
I've been pregnant now, three years in a row, pretty much,
and it's hard for Carmela to conceive.
[Carmela] I'm really happy for Sabrina,
but at the same time, I'm a little sad
just because I, you know, want that
to be me and Jeremiah sitting there.
You know, me pregnant and, you know...
It's something we want.
But I'm still getting all these negative pregnancy tests.
It's really frustrating.
Well, these gifts are really nice.
-Thank you to everybody. -[all] You're welcome.
Back home, um, in the Mennonites,
everybody always takes care of everybody
whenever they're pregnant,
[voice shaking] so it's really nice to have your...
[crying] We have such a good life now.
Like, we were homeless. We were...
Like, I slept on park benches,
like, freakin'...
lifeless...
I had holes in my arms from needles, like...
Just keep it...
Please honor,
because I don't wanna see you hurt the way I've hurt.
I wouldn't have really picked my baby shower
to be the place to tell them this.
But if I can warn them
to stay away from something,
then that's what I'm gonna do,
because I really care about them
and I don't want to see them go through
the same hurt and anguish,
and make the same terrible choices that I did.
Because the partying and [bleep]
isn't gonna help them.
[Jeremiah] Listen, if you guys are gonna survive out here in the world,
you guys are partying way too much and going down the wrong path.
[Jeremiah] This is the way it is.
Best way to explain it is, an Amish kid
going into the English community for the first time
is like a rubber band that's stretched real tight.
And when you let it go,
you have no idea which way it's gonna fly.
You have no idea how far it's gonna go.
Or it could snap. You don't know.
When I left, all I did was party.
And I don't even remember half of it.
I don't wanna see them make the same mistakes that I did.
One of the stars of the reality show,
Breaking Amish,
is facing public drunkenness charges.
[Jeremiah] I've experienced disorderly conduct quite a few times already,
because I grew up in a strict community,
and when I got out,
I just went all-out like most Amish kids do,
and trouble followed me.
[whoops]
[sobbing]
You know, being at a baby shower...
You know, a baby... Having a baby, that's a joyful moment.
And I just wanted the kids to know, you know,
if they keep going down the path that they're on right now,
you know, [scoffs] if they have a baby on the way,
or whatever, they could ruin their kid's life.
You know, they could ruin their own life,
and I don't wanna see that happen.
And I regret every day.
It's not worth it.
And you party for so long, and then you have kids,
and you see your child
being carried away from you, kicking and screaming...
[crying] You don't wanna... You don't wanna party anymore.
[Sabrina] I know, firsthand,
how hard it can be adjusting to the English world,
'cause I've been through everything that you can think of.
Hey, how are you?
[Sabrina] I have two older daughters, Oakley and Arianna,
and due to my previous addiction issues,
I signed my parental rights over to their aunt who adopted them.
[sobs]
I haven't seen them in a long time.
Their aunt requested that I...
...stay out of their lives.
I [bleep] up. And I get that.
And I regret it every single day of my life,
but I can't change it now.
[Jethro] I'm happy, like, that I'm where I am now, and, like...
Like, I ain't gonna lie. Like, sometimes I get stressed out,
and, like, I think about the [bleep] I did
and, like, I wanna do [bleep],
but when I see my kids and stuff,
then I don't wanna go back.
[Daniel] Since I've been down here,
I've definitely done my share of partying.
Like, I feel like I'm gonna have to slow down
and open my eyes to reality and get my [bleep] together.
When you're younger in the Amish community,
you're always told of the dangers
out in the English world that we're gonna have to face.
So, I really appreciated the fact
that Jeremiah and Jethro and Sabrina,
would talk to us, and, you know, kind of warn us
about dangers of getting into that stuff.
[Fannie] I really hope that some of them were listening
because I really care about all of them.
And I just hope they took some of that advice.
[Jethro] After the baby shower,
we decided to take these young kids out
'cause I just think it's gonna help reset the mood for all of us.
[woman] Come on aboard.
So, we're going on a boat ride
to see dolphins.
-Are you all excited? -[Kenneth] Hell yeah!
Absolutely, Jeth, let's go.
[Sabrina] I hope that we can help show them
that there's other ways of being English
and having fun that do not involve drugs, alcohol or women.
This is so cool. I feel like I'm in the movie Titanic.
-[woman] Dolphins? -There they go! Over there!
Oh, right.
[Jethro] Yeah, they're going round like this.
-[woman] Over there, yeah. -[Jethro] There he goes.
[woman] I saw it.
Right there, right there. He opened his mouth. There he goes.
[whistling]
That was my first time I've ever seen dolphins.
I did not want to miss one dolphin jumping out of the water.
-There's one over here. -[Sabrina gasps, exclaims]
[all laughing]
[Sabrina] Oh, my God, this is so cool.
[Fannie] Oh, my God, there's three of them.
-[Fannie] Kitty, kitty. -[Sabrina] He's so cute.
[Raymond] Back home in PA, there's no dolphins,
but we also don't have an ocean.
[Sabrina] Did you see the little baby one?
This is only the first time I've ever seen dolphins in real life,
and it was awesome.
[indistinct chatter]
[overlapping chatter]
[Fannie] It doesn't look like the dolphins in the picture books.
It's unexplainable. It's awesome.
[Fannie] Growing up Amish, all our lives we're taught
not to explore the English world.
It feels like you're in a prison.
I don't know why the Amish keep us from seeing the world.
Like, they really have no idea what they're missing out on.
Dolphins are God's creatures
and I don't know why they're stopping us from seeing them.
They are amazing.
The more I'm out here,
the more I start thinking that being Amish just doesn't make sense.
[Rosanna] I love Johnny, and I know he wants me to be Amish,
but this is my last chance in the English world,
and I want to do everything I can
before I tell Johnny my secret.
[Sabrina] Sex is so much better when you're waxed. Honestly.
Nobody wants what looks like a Founding Father
on their...
-[rips] -Ow!
[Kenneth] This is my first English pick-up basketball game.
[man shouting]
[Kenneth] I was just a little overwhelmed with these guys
and how good they actually were.
[Johnny] I don't know how to tell Rosanna this, but I'm gonna go home.
[Johnny] What do you want?
[speaking Pennsylvania German]
[upbeat jazz music playing]
♪ Oh, yeah ♪
Well, I brought y'all to get waxed
so that we can clean up the nether regions
so that you don't go on the beach
looking like a hairy octopus.
[Sabrina] About a year ago, Rosanna mentioned to me
that she's never shaved or waxed.
Did you get a [clears throat] hair removal?
No.
That's something we're gonna have to do.
-I didn't do it-- -We're gonna go do that.
[Rosanna giggles]
[Fannie] So, where do you get waxed?
[Sabrina] Wherever you have hair that you don't want it
is where you get waxed.
♪ Oh, yeah ♪
I'm gonna take Fannie and Rosanna to get waxed
because Amish women have all this hair,
and they need to get rid of it
if they're gonna wear English clothes,
because, like, people aren't gonna understand
in the outside world,
like, why they're hairy.
So, we're gonna go hairless and careless
and take our [bleep] to the barber.
[employee speaking]
[Fannie] Seeing some of those words on the cards
was a little confusing to me,
because I'm, like, "What is that?"
Like...
What is Brazilian?
[Sabrina] Um, that's everything.
Like, all the hair on your vajayjay, gone. Bye.
[laughing quietly]
Because Jethro likes it.
'Cause it's smooth.
I think I'm gonna get my eyebrows, and my vagina.
That's what girls do in the English world.
That's what I wanted to do.
But like, that's disgusting to me.
I like natural.
-Like-- -Well, that's more disgusting with hair.
Yeah, but God gave us hair down there.
So... To keep it clean, just like your nose.
-It has hair, too. -I don't care.
I'll never have hair on my vagina.
[employee speaking]
I'm just gonna get my eyebrows.
[employee speaking]
[Fannie] I'm really nervous about getting waxed,
because in the Amish community,
removing anything that God gave you
is considered vain and a sin.
Do you realize how freaking annoying, right now, it is for me
to try to shave with this in the way?
I can't [beep] see my own huha.
-Like-- -[Rosanna] Oh, yeah, I can imagine.
It's hard, and, like, I'm not gonna grow [bleep] down there, so...
You guys will get to watch me do it.
And then, I think, like, after you see it,
like, you'll feel better about it.
Is it painful?
It's like ripping a Band-Aid off.
[door closes]
It's probably the same as eyebrows.
-Yeah, you never got your eyebrows waxed, Fannie? -No.
-Really? -Yeah.
Well, you know how the Amish are.
You can't do anything that's considered vain.
Yeah, I know,
but sex is so much better when you're waxed.
Honestly. Way better.
-Way, way, way, way, way better. -Okay.
Like, who wants to freaking part a sea of hair
to get in there?
-And then have that hair-- -[giggling] Stop.
I'm serious.
-Who wants to have hair rubbing up on their [bleep]? -Okay! Okay.
-Nobody. -Okay, it's done now.
[Sabrina] No braids, no dreadlocks, nothing. It needs to be clean.
And nobody wants what looks like a Founding Father
on their...
[chuckles]
[waxer] I'm gonna have you pull your dress up.
[Sabrina] Fannie, please don't look at my butthole.
I'm not looking. Trust me.
[waxer] They call it a butterfly,
so, you're gonna bend your legs out. Perfect.
-[Rosanna snorting] -[waxer] It'll be quick.
[Rosanna laughs]
[Sabrina] Oh, God.
[laughs] Did that hurt?
[Sabrina] Mmm-hmm.
[Fannie] I'm not even gonna watch.
-'Cause... I'm gonna get the hell out of here. -[wax strips ripping]
[rips]
[Sabrina] The things I do for Jethro, I swear to God.
-[rips] -[Sabrina grunts]
[waxer] It hurts for a second...
[waxer] Yeah. But you know what?
The results afterwards are super nice.
I mean, it's probably gonna be worth it
'cause then you won't have to shave for a while.
[waxer] Do the Amish normally shave?
Not supposed to, but...
There's a lot of Amish girls that do shave.
This is the first time I've seen Amish people come into the salon,
and ask for Brazilians as well.
[Sabrina] Ooh, that one hurt. That hurt like a bitch.
[waxer] Are you all ready for the back side?
[Rosanna] Okay. That's not okay, Sabrina.
[Sabrina] This is how you give birth.
-[Fannie laughing] -[Rosanna] No, it's not.
[all laughing]
-[waxer] You guys are funny. -[Rosanna chuckles]
[Sabrina] That hurt like a bitch.
[waxer] All right, you are all done.
[Sabrina] I'm sorry for the view.
-[Rosanna laughing] -[Fannie laughing] I wasn't looking.
[continues laughing]
It hurt more than it normally does,
but I think that's 'cause I'm pregnant.
Like, they say it hurts more when you're pregnant.
I don't know, but it hurt.
[Fannie] Here we go again.
[Rosanna] I'm really nervous.
-[exhales] -[waxer] Try to relax for me, okay?
The more you tense up, your pores kind of tighten.
[Rosanna chuckles]
[laughing] I can do that myself. I'm sorry.
-[waxer] Are you okay? -Yeah, I'm okay.
-Okay. -It didn't really even hurt.
It's just, like, I'm scared.
[waxer] Exfoliant, moisturizer,
all products that are gonna help keep ingrowns away...
-[rips] -Ow!
...keep your skin smooth.
[Rosanna chuckles]
-[laughs] -[waxer] It's just my hand. It's just my hand.
So, I'm gonna do this little section here.
There's, like, eight hairs there.
[chuckling] Ow. Ow.
No, that did hurt, though.
-You good? Okay. -Yeah, I'm good.
I think the waxing hurt more than getting my belly-button pierced.
Like, I was laughing, but I could have cried, almost.
[Rosanna groans]
-[grunts, chuckles] -[waxer] Okay, hold on.
I've gotta pull it.
-[rips] -[screams] Holy [bleep]!
[laughing] No, I cannot stand this.
[both laughing]
[Rosanna laughing]
[waxer] You wanna just flip over and do the backside?
-Yeah, because... -[waxer] Okay.
-[chuckles] -I'll take care of that when I get home.
[waxer] All right. So, you're gonna turn all the way around.
[laughing silently]
[Sabrina] I should have brought my sunglasses in here.
[laughing]
I probably have a lot of...
[laughing]
-[waxer] Okay. -You know what?
Why don't we just do my eyebrows?
-[chortles] -[waxer] You'll be fine.
All right. I'm just gonna have you go on your elbow--
I really need to pee.
I'm gonna, like, 'frickin' pee myself.
[Sabrina] For security reasons, I am going to move over here.
Not that I'm trying to look at your ass,
but because I'm desperate not to get kicked in the face.
[laughing silently]
Rosanna, like, tried to get waxed,
and they waxed, like, half of her vagina.
[Sabrina] So, she had half her Founding Father on one side and...
nothing on the other side, I guess. I don't know.
[Fannie laughing]
-[waxer] Wait-- -[Rosanna laughing]
[Sabrina] Oh, my God.
[Fannie laughing heartily]
What the hell was that? Seriously.
[all laughing]
[Fannie laughing]
[waxer] Yeah. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.
Hold on. Hold on. Hold on.
There it goes. Okay. There you go.
[waxer] We didn't finish Rosanna's Brazilian
because she was in a lot of pain.
I did my best. I tried to talk her through it,
but she just... It was a lot for her.
-How did it feel? -[Rosanna] It hurt.
Why do English people go through so much pain just to look good?
Well, it makes us feel good. It's not just about looking good.
Then I don't wanna feel good.
[laughing] It just makes me feel good,
and then depending on the wax, it just makes me feel cleaner.
Okay, Fannie, you're up next.
[waxer] What service are we doing?
-[Fannie] I don't know. -[Sabrina] Come on.
-You know what? I can do this. -[waxer] You'll be okay.
[Fannie] Watching Sabrina and then Rosanna,
when I got up on that table, I'm thinking, like, "Oh [bleep]!
What did I get myself into?"
I was, like, scared,
so I couldn't do it.
but I still did my eyebrows and my massage just to get waxed.
Want me to hold your hand?
[Fannie] No, keep your hands off me.
That doesn't even hurt. Jesus.
[Sabrina] Anybody can get their eyebrows waxed.
I've had my eyebrows waxed. It don't hurt.
[Rosanna] You're pretending.
[Fannie laughing] I'm not.
I'm not. it just, like, didn't even hurt.
[waxer] I'm really proud of you.
I was, like, all nerved up,
and my body, like, was all tensed up,
and she did the first one, and I'm like,
"That wasn't even... That didn't even hurt.
Why was I so worried about it?"
Now get your vagina waxed.
[waxer] We can do just a bikini.
You would probably hear me cussing.
[Sabrina] Well, Fannie's determined to grow a forest down there,
but I tried.
[waxer] Okay. There you go.
Hold that and take a look.
Wow.
They look a lot better.
-[waxer] Well, that's it. -[Rosanna] I don't know.
-That's quick and easy. -[Sabrina] Okay. Let's go.
I definitely am happy I did this,
and definitely something I'll probably do in the future.
-That was an experience I'll never forget. -[Rosanna chuckles]
I'm really glad that I tried to get it waxed
even though I just got, like, halfway through.
But I never wanna go back.
-But thank you. -[Fannie] Thank you so much.
[waxer] Of course. Yeah, anytime.
[Kenneth] I'm intimidated by them.
You know, this is probably the highest level of basketball
I've played with.
[Kenneth] Well, here we are.
[Jeremiah] Wow.
They look pretty good.
[Kenneth] Coach T and J.R. told me about this pickup game
and I'm intimidated.
You know, this is probably the highest level of basketball
I've played with.
-Listen, this is something you've wanted for a long time. -Yeah.
This has been your dream, so...
You just need to go out there and just show them
what the Amish kids are made of.
[Kenneth] Okay.
-[Daniel] You got this, Kenneth. -[Carmela] Yes.
[Jeremiah] Yeah, yeah. Let's get it.
[Carmela] Show 'em what's up.
-You got it. -[Daniel] We believe in you.
Hey J.R., what's going on?
-[J.R. speaking indistinctly] -Oh, yes, sir.
[J.R.] Last time we was at HoopWERX again,
like, we played, and after that we exchanged numbers,
and he told me, like, "Yo, whenever there's a pickup game coming up,
y'all let me know."
And that's what I did.
-Yeah, just to let you know, you gonna be on my squad. -Okay, got it.
Here you go.
-[man] Oh, for real? -[J.R.] You gonna hoop like this, right?
-Talk to him. -What's that?
-You gonna hoop like that, right? -[man] Like that?
Yeah, I grew up hooping.
I grew up hooping like this.
-[man chuckling] -Oh, man, I didn't even know who he was.
-I was... I was like... -Yeah.
..."Who is this guy coming in with a hat?" I mean...
[man] The clothes alone is already enough.
-Like, you see how he plays-- -He really caught us by surprise
when he came in with the hat, and I was, like...
-The pants. -Yeah, I was like, "What?"
-The pants. -"Is he gonna play like this?"
[J.R.] Y'all ready to run the game?
[man] Oh, let's go!
[Kenneth] I'm so frustrated right now
because, you know, I've never played with guys like this.
[J.R.] We was gonna challenge him.
We was gonna definitely let him know, like,
you're stepping into a new world.
It's not easy. It's not fun.
We're not gonna let you just get a layup out here.
We will block your shot.
[shouting indistinctly]
We will put you on the floor.
[Kenneth] I was just a little overwhelmed with these guys
and how good they actually were.
Yeah!
-Yeah, they don't dunk like that in the Amish. -No.
[speaking indistinctly]
[J.R.] Yeah, good shot, bro.
[Kenneth] That first game, I played really bad.
I'm surprised they let me keep my sneakers after that first game.
[Kenneth] Hard to breathe.
[Daniel] These guys are killing it.
Like, you just need to hang in there.
[Jeremiah] You know, if this is really what you want,
you're gonna have to push through it.
And think about it,
you'd be the first Amish, college basketball player.
-[Daniel] That'd be badass, seriously. -Yeah.
Seriously, that'd be awesome.
Only in here is what's holding you back.
Let loose.
I'm just gonna go out there having confidence.
I believe that's all it takes.
Go out and get them.
Go get them.
It was really important that I showed myself
that I could play at the English level.
I may not be perfect,
but I could still hold my own on an English team.
[all cheer]
He's not giving up and just not being intimidated.
Yeah!
[Daniel] Yes, sir!
[clapping]
[Kenneth] It feels pretty good, you know,
that I can come out of the Amish and, you know,
play with some of these players
that aren't Amish, that are really good.
You definitely surprised me.
Yeah.
[J.R.] Kenneth did awesome.
He really surprised all of us, you know, uh,
from last time, you know, we played at HoopWERX,
uh, yeah, he did his thing.
But today, nah, I feel like he really stepped up to the plate.
Hey, I appreciate your help.
Appreciate you letting me come in and play.
All right.
It's pretty cool that we're two different guys from two different...
Two different area codes
and two different upbringings,
two different states.
You know, it's pretty cool that, you know,
we're bonding over playing basketball,
and we would have never known each other if it wasn't for basketball.
Oh, it was good. It felt great.
Oh, yeah.
-[Jeremiah speaking] -[Kenneth] Oh, yeah.
I think so.
You know, after that game,
yeah, I feel like I'm a little bit more closer to my dream.
You know...
I mean, I still have a ways to go,
but that's one more step closer.
[Johnny] I'm ready to go back home
and have Rosanna come back with me, if she wants to.
If she don't, I don't know what's gonna happen.
[speaking Pennsylvania German]
[Rosanna] Johnny really misses home,
so I'm gonna take him to Pinecraft
'cause I think he'll feel a lot better
if he's around other Amish people.
[Johnny] I don't know how to tell Rosanna this,
but I'm gonna go home,
So, I don't know what's gonna happen.
-How does yours taste? -It's really good.
Being out here,
it just feels like I'm missing out on so much fun stuff.
Uh, you have such a nice family.
Like, they're all so jolly and happy.
Yeah, they're always happy.
And I'm out here and...
-It's so hard being so far away. -[Rosanna] Yeah.
How do you imagine us, like,
together, like, living Amish together?
I think it would be better, better for us...
-Yeah. -...living together Amish.
[Johnny] I mean, I'm ready to go back home
and have Rosanna come back with me, if she wants to.
If she don't, you know, she can stay, too.
I'm not gonna force her to come back, but I hope she does.
That would be the best... Best thing...
Like, that's what I really wanna do.
I wanna go back, and I'm just hoping you want to, too.
I don't wanna be here,
so you have to decide.
What do you want?
[speaking Pennsylvania German]
I don't care, Amish or English.
I wanna be with you.
I wanna spend the rest of my life with you.
You mean the world to me.
[Rosanna] I haven't told Johnny yet, but...
I'm pregnant.
I don't know what Johnny's reaction will be,
but going back Amish with him
is the best thing for me to do right now.
[Sabrina] Hey, what are you doing?
[Fannie] Oh, I have some chicken,
and I'm making two apple pies and one cherry.
Ooh, the baby's gonna like that.
Rosanna asked me to make a dinner for everyone tonight,
and I love to cook,
so I'm more than happy to do it.
Whoa! Look at all this food.
-Oh, my gosh, you made all this? -Yes.
I don't even know where to start.
[Jeremiah] I'll eat those eggs.
[Sabrina] I'm so happy that Fannie decided to make a meal for everyone.
Get off there.
You know, we all miss that
because where we come from,
that's what our families did.
You know, sitting down at the dinner table to eat together.
That's the only time that we get
that reminds us of our childhoods.
You guys did such a great job.
I've made up my mind to go back Amish with Johnny.
But now I have to tell everybody.
You guys did good, whoever did the cooking.
-Johnny, did you know your shirt has a hole in it? -[Johnny] Yeah.
He was flexing so hard that it just blew up.
-It's AC. -You gotta get home and get your mom to fix it.
[snorting]
[Johnny chuckling]
[Rosanna] So, I have something I have to say.
I decided to back Amish.
I'm worried that everyone's gonna think that Johnny's making me go back Amish,
but he isn't.
I'm going back to my Amish community because I'm pregnant
and Johnny still doesn't know it.
In the Amish community,
it's a sin if you get pregnant before you get married,
so I'm afraid that Johnny will leave me.
We're excited to get back to a little bit slower life,
you know, keep continuing with work.
Johnny saying that he's going back Amish doesn't surprise me,
but Rosanna saying she's going back,
that is very confusing.
[Sabrina] Well...
Do you wanna be Amish?
[Rosanna] I think it would just be best for us to go back Amish.
I don't lying to my friends,
but no one should know that I'm pregnant before I tell Johnny.
You know, being out here made you realize, you know,
you really have a lot at home,
a lot of good at home that you didn't realize.
So, that was, like, a good experience.
One good thing about being out here.
[Daniel] If this is what they have to do
to figure out who they are,
I will fully support them.
But personally,
I feel like both of them do not belong in the Amish.
Like, I really feel like they'll always be happier outside of the Amish.
[Jeremiah] Here's the thing,
Carmela, Sabrina, me,
we all want the best for these kids, right?
But you can only do so much.
You gotta... You gotta let them live their life,
and if you try to hold them back,
you're just being just as bad as the Amish.
[Jeremiah] You know, going back to your Amish family
can be a little difficult,
but it could be difficult out here, so...
you gotta do what you got--
Like, what your heart tells you to do, you know?
[Rosanna] We had a lot of fun out here.
A lot of fun hanging out with all you guys.
We're gonna miss all of you.
I'm still gonna miss everyone.
I mean, we had our fights and stuff,
but we still had a good time.
[Johnny] Yeah, it was okay.
I'm just ready to get out of here,
-be done with everything. -Yeah.
You know, go back home.
♪ If it all went away ♪
♪ What would you do? ♪
♪ You know that we don't have to walk this road alone... ♪
[Rosanna] I know I'm running out of time,
but Johnny will find out that I am pregnant
when the time is right.
♪ On my way back Oh-oh-oh ♪
♪ Whoa-oh Oh-oh-oh ♪
♪ Whoa-oh Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh ♪
♪ This is where I belong ♪
♪ Oh-oh-oh Whoa-oh ♪
♪ Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh ♪
[Jeremiah] On the next episode of Return to Amish...
Jethro is throwing an end-of-summer party for everyone,
and me and Daniel definitely wanna look good for this.
-[barber] Were you guys allowed to get haircuts? -No.
[Daniel] Like, it was just a homemade bowl cut.
That's unfortunate.
[Fannie] Today I'm going to do a makeover.
And now that it's actually time, I'm very nervous.
Honestly, I'm so scared.
I know once I do this, I'm gonna be, like, shunned,
for sure.
Kenneth, let's see it.
[door squeaks]
No.
Why are you so nervous?
'Cause I wanna propose to her, you know?
I'm not sure what her reaction is gonna be.
[sniffles]
We need to get the bishop's permission for us to get married.
[Johnny speaking Pennsylvania German]
[bishop speaking]
[Johnny] To me, it seemed like he was trying to say
that Rosanna ain't good enough for me.