[narrator] Previously on Return to Amish.
[Ada] Jeremiah, Carmela, Sabrina,
and I have decided to come together.
-Hey. -And ride this virus
out in Florida.
Have you and Jeremiah met before?
No.
-That's whatever it is. -We never...
We never were a thing.
If I wanted him, I would have had him.
[Ada] My granddaughter, Maureen, and her friend,
Rosanna, wants to leave the Amish.
[Rosanna] I'm really excited to see
how the outside world is.
-Oh. -[Maureen laughs]
[Jeremiah] My biological father
is potentially coming down to Florida.
I would like to meet your dad.
[Rosanna] I can't stop thinking...
my family not talking to me anymore.
It's kind of scary.
[Sabrina] Jeremiah.
[Maureen speaking]
-Don't panic. -Rose.
-Hold on. -[Maureen] Rose!
[Sabrina] Here, drink some water.
[EMT] Where are you from?
[suspenseful music playing]
[Maureen] Put your head back. Put your head back.
You're okay, Rose.
[Maureen] Rosanna and I just arrived
at the house in Florida, and all of a sudden,
Rosanna had a panic attack.
It got to the point where I was like,
"We need to get the ambulance out here."
Calm.
In some Amish communities,
they don't go to the English doctor
unless it's something really bad
and they have to go.
[Maureen in Amish]
[Maureen] Jeremiah!
Rose. Rose.
Rose.
[Maureen in Amish]
[Sabrina] Dear God, please be with Rosanna.
Please help her.
Just help her to calm down and help her know
that you got her in the palm of your hand
and that everything is gonna be okay.
Just help her to calm down and just be with her
and relieve her anxiety
and hopefully not to worry anymore.
[Rosanna] It's just my mouth.
[Maureen in Amish]
Rosanna.
No. No.
Rose.
[sirens wailing]
[Jeremiah] She's back there.
I don't know if it's anxiety attack or...
But her heart's racing.
And she said she can't feel her mouth and nothing.
[EMT] What's your name?
[Maureen speaking Amish]
[EMT] Hi. What's your name?
Rosanna.
-[EMT] What is it? -Rosanna.
[EMT] Rosan? What happened, Rosan?
I don't know.
[EMT] Has she been exposed
or been traveling out of the country?
-[Maureen] No. -[EMT] Has she been in contact
-with anyone with COVID? -[Maureen] No.
[EMT] So where are you from?
Where are you from? What country?
-[Ada speaking Amish] -PA.
-[Ada] Yeah. -[EMT] Excuse me.
-She lives... -What country are you from?
-PA. -[EMT] What?
-PA. -[EMT] Pennsylvania?
Yeah.
[EMT] Oh, you're from Pennsylvania?
You're not from Europe?
No.
[Sabrina] I don't know if Rosanna's cut out
for the English world.
This is a lot of stress on her,
and I don't know if she can pull it off or not.
[man speaking]
[Carmela] I sense that she wants to go back Amish.
Like, everything was just too much.
[Jeremiah] I mean, whether she wants to or not,
I think that would be the best thing for her.
[EMT] Do you have any chest pain?
-I can't talk right. -[EMT] You can't talk?
[man speaking]
[sirens wailing]
[man speaking]
[EMT] [indistinct] in the back of the car.
Rosanna has never left her family.
And it's really scary because she could be shunned,
her parents could be shunned. And I'm sure
there's a lot of things that she hasn't thought about,
and it's hitting her like a ton of bricks.
[EMT] We're gonna get you to the hospital.
Rosanna, we're gonna take you to the hospital.
[woman speaking]
[speaking Amish]
[Rosanna grunts]
Rose?
[Rosanna speaking]
[EMT] Oh, you're feeling better now?
[woman in Amish]
[Maureen] It's almost like
when the professional people came,
she relaxed.
[EMT] Let me check your pulse.
[Maureen] It was weird. Like,
it happened so fast and just like that,
she was getting better.
All of a sudden I started feeling weird
-but now... -[EMT] Well, you're about...
You're about a hundred percent better
than you were about thirty seconds ago.
Yeah. It's going away.
[EMT] You weren't able to talk.
[Maureen] Her heart rate has gone down.
[Rosanna] I think I'm good now. Like I can...
I can now talk and I can now feel like...
Yeah. She can actually talk now.
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
-[Ada] No. -[Rosanna] No, I don't.
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
[Ada speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
[man speaking]
[Rosanna speaking]
-[EMT] Okay. -[Ada] Okay.
[Rosanna] All of a sudden, I was just thinking
how far away I am from all my family,
and my heart just started beating really fast,
and I just...
I couldn't breathe.
It was like... It was scary.
[man speaking]
-It's good, to see this. -[Rosanna] Oh, thank you.
-[EMT] Don't worry. -Thank you.
[EMT] All right. I'm glad you're feeling better.
I don't want a scare like this ever, ever again.
[EMT] Yeah.
[dramatic music playing]
[Rosanna] I wanna do this,
and I think I'm strong enough that I can like do this.
I just hope like...
I can still be in my parents
and like all their lives.
Like, still go see them and stuff.
I don't know.
[Rosanna speaking]
[Rosanna] But...
I wanna stay out here.
[mellow music playing]
[Carmela] Rosanna, she is very sweet.
She's very nice. But...
I feel like all this is new to her so,
I think she's just afraid.
[Ada] I think she's really brave
but I'm concerned about her.
Rosanna is taking a huge step leaving her family behind
and experience English world.
[dramatic music playing]
[Jeremiah] Rosanna, having this panic attack,
you know, it's all new for her to be out here.
But I can't really relate to it
because when I left,
I was excited to leave and go out and explore
and do all these new things.
And maybe Rosanna is just not ready
to be out here in the real world.
Maybe she just needs to be back Amish.
[Sabrina] Rosanna, are you okay?
I just wanna check up on Rosanna
and see how she's feeling about everything
because leaving is very hard.
She's in a whole new world. She's overwhelmed.
She's trying to leave.
It's going to trigger you into a panic attack.
[dramatic music playing]
[Sabrina] So what's up, Rosanna?
How are you doing?
[Rosanna] I feel better but like I don't know.
Like,
I just freaked out.
[Sabrina] Why?
[Rosanna speaking]
-[Sabrina] Really? -Uh-hmm.
[clears throat]
[Rosanna speaking]
Yeah.
It's very scary experience to go through by yourself,
but that said,
on the outside world, you can do whatever you want.
That's why I don't wanna leave
so I can do what I want and just be free.
[Sabrina] Yeah.
I don't know if Rosanna knows how tough
the English world is
but I really hope that she's cut out for it.
[Rosanna] So how are you feeling
with the baby?
[Sabrina] Tired. Ready to...
just not be pregnant. I've been pregnant
for like two years straight, it feels like.
Sounds like you're gonna have a big baby.
I hope not.
If I end up having a ten-pound baby,
that makes me really like nervous
because I'm afraid it'll shred my vagina.
Last time I had a baby,
my vagina ripped the whole way from my vagina
to my ass [bleep].
Are you serious?
Does your vagina ever, like comes back to normal?
[chuckles]
Yes, it does actually.
I thought it wouldn't but it does.
They sew you tight. Like they sew you
right back up the way you were.
I thought I would be like stretched out
-and floppy but it's not. -Uh-huh?
[Sabrina] After you have a baby,
it goes right back to normal.
[Rosanna] I've never been pregnant
but my sister-in-laws like they were pregnant.
The one, like, she didn't...
It didn't come out of her vagina, and, like,
they got it out of, like, they cut her belly up.
I don't know if I ever wanna get pregnant.
-It's just the pain, like... -Yeah.
The baby makes it all worth it though.
[crickets chirping]
[upbeat music playing]
[Carmela] And tonight, we decided to go out
and have some fun. And just hang out.
[singer] ♪ I play no rule, I play no rule ♪
♪ I get back up, Like I'm born again ♪
♪ Oh, oh, oh ♪
[Jeremiah] Okay. There you go.
[singer] ♪ I play no rule, I play no rule ♪
[Jethro] Sabrina and I met three years ago.
We were both Mennonite, we both left the Mennonites.
And we connect on a lot of different levels
of the things that we've been through
in our life. We both...
had a past with, like, drug addiction.
We have a child named Zekiah,
and we're now expecting our second child.
It's a girl. And I'm extremely excited.
-[woman] Hey, everybody. -[Carmela] Hi.
-[Jethro] How you doin'? -[Carmela] Good. How are you?
[Jethro] Sabrina said after two years
of being sober that she would be ready
to marry me.
It's two years, she's sober.
I feel like, now would be the time to proceed.
He's such a love bug.
[laughs]
[Jeremiah] What about the, uh, sampler.
You wanna start with the sampler?
-Yes, please. -[woman] Okay.
For starters, you're gonna eat them, Jethro.
Hell, yeah.
-Okay. -You never had them?
[Jethro] No, no, but I'll try anything once.
Yes, I know you will.
[Jeremiah] When Sabrina said that...
I knew exactly what she was talking about
because I had heard from Sabrina
about all the rumors of him being with other guys.
[woman speaking]
Nothing wrong with that,
I mean, Matt's always been a nice guy to me.
I don't know, I'm just saying what I heard.
Okay. We got the food.
-You can put that right here. -[woman] Right in the middle?
All right. We have some more food coming up, okay?
-Okay. Thank you so much. -[woman] You got it. Enjoy.
Do you eat the inside?
-Yes. -Yeah, you just pick them up
and...
-No. Nope. -...sip them out.
The longer I look at it, the grosser it looks.
-Excuse my reach. -[Sabrina] But this one...
This one right here doesn't look quite as bad, Jethro.
Try that one.
It stinks.
[Jeremiah] No, don't listen.
-It's an aphrodisiac. -[Jethro] What's that mean?
-What's that mean? -[Carmela] You don't know...
That's where, um,
you will... Tonight, you will get in the mood.
He's always in the mood to begin with.
Jethro is incapable of keeping his penis
-where it belongs -Hmm.
She walks around with no underwear on, literally.
She'll walk around the house with no underwear on,
just a T-shirt.
Cats need air, so they can breathe.
-I would try that one. -[Jethro] Do I just dump it?
[Sabrina] Just suck on it. Suck it back.
[laughter]
Here, you should try an oyster.
Oh, no. No,
-I'll throw up. Oh, my gosh. -It looks like a mushroom.
No, it doesn't. It looks like it had
a dead mouse in there.
[laughter]
[Jethro] And I just wanted to ask everybody,
um, Sabrina's been going through a lot
with her pregnancy and everything,
and I wanna do something nice for her maybe.
Throw a baby shower or something.
Absolutely.
[Carmela] Yeah. That would be nice.
So I wanna throw, uh, a baby shower for Sabrina
because it would make her happy,
and show that people care about her.
Also, I may have a surprise for her at this shower.
Really? What?
Hmm? What? It's a surprise,
-so... -Can you give me a hint?
I think it's adorable that he cares
so much about me,
and I think it's really thoughtful.
And it just makes me love him so much.
Oh [bleep]
Hang on. I got to take this call.
Hello?
[Sabrina] What do you think is going on over there
-with Jeremiah? -[Carmela] I'm not sure.
Uh, he didn't even show me, he just got up
and walked walked away.
I didn't see who it was.
He looks nervous.
I hope everything's okay.
[dramatic music playing]
-Whoa. -[laughter]
I would like to go see the beach.
Woo. Oh, my God!
[Jethro] So I wanna throw a baby shower for Sabrina
because it would make her happy, and also,
I may have a surprise for her at this shower.
-[Matt] Hey. -Oh, my goodness.
-[Jeremiah] What in the world? -[Carmela] What?
-[Matt] Good to see you, guys. -[Jeremiah] Matt?
Yeah.
[dramatic music playing]
[Jeremiah] I got to take this call.
Hello.
How you doing?
[Dennis] I'm good. How about you?
I was thinking about you, thought I'd reach out to you.
[Jeremiah] Dennis is my biological father,
and he lives in Ohio.
Dennis has been calling and texting me
over the last, what, two years?
-Uh-hmm. -And...
he's been trying to be there as a father.
And he even sent letters, and pictures, and stuff.
And I don't know, I just never really acknowledged it,
because I met my biological mother,
and she said I was adopted out
because the state came in and took all...
Of all of us kids from my biological mother,
and she fought to get all of them back
except for me. So at eight month old,
I was put in to the, uh, County Home.
And then, at one and a half, I was adopted out.
It's a lot to deal with,
and I have a lot of walls build up
because of all the hurt.
But honestly, I've never had anybody
try to be in my life as much as he has.
[Dennis] I was hoping I could come down to Florida.
I was thinking about it, but...
I mean, as far as coming up there,
I mean, I'm sure we can make something work.
[Dennis] That would be great.
-I would... -[Dennis speaking]
[dramatic music playing]
[Jeremiah] Now, I wanna go and meet him.
And try to have some kind of relationship
with my father, but I'm so scared
that this is going to break me the way it broke me
when I met my mother.
By the way, I have you on speaker,
and, uh, Carmela just walked up, so...
[Dennis speaking]
Hi.
[Dennis speaking]
Oh, hi.
-[Dennis] Hi. -Nice to meet you.
It's nice to hear your voice.
[Dennis] I'd love to meet my son's bride.
Aww. I would love to meet you.
I've been waiting
since he told me that you guys spoke.
We need to make some plans.
[Dennis] Okay, great.
All right.
[Dennis speaking]
[Jeremiah] You have no idea how much it actually
means to me that my real father
wants to meet my wife.
Because at this point, my Amish parents
don't even wanna see her.
They don't wanna meet her, you know,
because I've been divorced and remarried.
They don't believe in that.
They wouldn't let her inside the house.
And for Dennis to say, "Hey, I wanna meet Carmella,"
that means a lot to me because,
you know, he is my father,
and for my father to meet my wife,
it's awesome.
Sounds good.
[Dennis] I'm glad to see you soon.
Absolutely. It's good to hear from you.
[Dennis] Okay.
Okay, I'll talk to you later.
-[Dennis] See you. -Yup, bye.
[mellow music playing]
[singer] ♪ You lost A little piece of yourself ♪
♪ But I don't care to how ♪
♪ Put it back together Again ♪
-Rose. -[laughter]
Sorry.
[Maureen] Are you guys, okay?
Stupid.
Pinecraft is an Amish community in Sarasota,
and it's a great place to go on a vacation.
Grandma, I just [indistinct] me and you.
-I can imagine you... Oh. -[laughter]
[Ada] It makes my heart happy to see Rosanna's doing well,
after she almost ended up in the hospital
with a panic attack.
God is good.
-Don't hit that vehicle. -[Maureen] Yes.
You're a reckless driver.
[Rosanna] I would like to go see the beach.
-[Ada] The beach? -[Maureen] Me too.
What are you gonna be wearing?
[Maureen] Well, we have to wear our dress.
[Ada] Do you guys have any swimming suits
you can sneak along?
Grandma won't tell.
[Rosanna] Being Amish for like,
wearing a bathing suit,
the girls are supposed to be covered up.
They're not allowed to like show their skin
or anything.
[Maureen] Our dresses have to be...
no more than six inches from our ankles.
We're only allowed to wear short sleeve dresses
when we're working at home.
But if we go anywhere,
we have to wear long sleeve dresses.
We always have to have our hair up in a bun,
and have a head covering on.
[Ada] You don't want Jeremiah and Jethro.
You want them to see your ankles?
We can just have a girls' day.
-[Maureen] Yes. -[Ada] Yeah.
[Rosanna] I've never been to a beach.
I never saw the ocean,
and I really wanna go and see how that looks.
[Carmela] Jeremiah and I are going to Ohio
to see Dennis.
I'm scared that Dennis might reject Jeremiah,
and if he does, it might cause
a lot of problems in our relationship.
[Dennis] Jeremiah.
-[water lapping] -[indistinct chatter]
[Rosanna] Oh, my gosh.
Just look out there if you can't see anything.
I'm really excited to go to the beach
because, like,
I never, like, saw the ocean or anything.
Oh, my gosh. This is so beautiful.
Like, I never saw anything so beautiful in my life.
Like I heard people say stuff about the beach,
but I never imagined it looking like this.
Like, I always dreamed like touching the sand
and stuff. Like, it feels so good.
I wanna go into the water.
[upbeat music playing]
[Maureen] This feels really good.
[Rosanna] Oh, it feels so good.
[Maureen] Do you wanna...
-[Rosanna] Yeah. -[Maureen] Uh-huh.
-[laughter] -[Maureen] Look at grandma.
She's got...
It got all wet.
[singer] ♪ Can't help [indistinct] ♪
♪ Together ♪
-[Ada] Oh. -[laughter]
[singer] ♪ Can't [indistinct] ♪
♪ Forever ♪
[Rosanna] Like, I'm having so much fun right now.
Like, this is the best day of my life.
[Maureen] I'm so happy that Rosanna stayed
and didn't leave me here alone.
-[laughs] -It's sour.
What is that out there, way out here?
[Maureen] Look how high that is.
I wanna do that.
It looks like it's something fun.
I would really like to go up there.
Okay.
[Rosanna] I'm really glad that I did not leave
after my panic attack, because I would have never
got to see the beach.
And it was really something to see.
[dramatic music playing]
[Carmela] Jeremiah and I are going to Ohio to see Dennis.
And honestly, my anxiety is going through the roof.
I'm scared that Dennis might reject Jeremiah.
And if he does, it might cause
a lot of problems in our relationship.
And I just don't know how he's going to take it.
[singer] ♪ Will it be♪
♪ Always like this♪
[Carmela] Are you nervous?
[Jeremiah] Very nervous.
[Carmela] Hmm.
I have no idea what to expect.
I really don't.
I'll be here with you.
-Okay? -All right.
Just... Let's do this.
All right. Let's go.
I'm going in, probably with my wall
built higher than what it should be,
but, you know, it is what it is.
[Dennis] Jeremiah?
[dramatic music playing]
[Dennis] Jeremiah?
[Jeremiah] Dennis is my biological father.
Dennis invited Carmela and I to go up to Ohio to meet him,
and I'm nervous.
Son.
-[Jeremiah] How you doing? -Hello?
Hello. Oh, my God.
Oh, my.
Hi, Carmella, oh, my goodness.
-This is Carmela, by the way. -Nice to meet you.
Oh, my.
If you're as pretty inside as your outside,
he's got it paid.
-So, how are you doing? -I'm doing good.
How you've been?
Yeah, getting through life.
Getting through life?
I'll show you what dad bought me.
Well, he found it for me, got it for me.
-Oh, boy. -And I paid him back.
-Oh, wow. -[Dennis] Yeah.
[Jeremiah] You know what's crazy?
When I was still Amish,
we did roofing up here in this town.
-[Dennis] Did you? -Yup.
Dennis's house is about 35 minutes
from where I grew up at.
And to me, it's kind of weird that he's that close,
but we never really knew about it.
But, man, I'm glad to see you.
[Jeremiah] And yes, I did get your mail.
I do get your phone calls and text messages.
Well, good. Now I know.
[Jeremiah] No, I'll just be very honest with you.
The reason that I've been kind of standoffish,
and not communicating
is because of what my mother said to me.
She said that she has all the kids with her
that she loves,
uh-huh,
and a whole bunch of stuff,
so...
That's what kind of pushed me away from everybody.
And I wanted absolutely no part of anybody
that had anything to do with my biological family.
Just being honest.
Words like that come from a selfish...
There ain't no word for it.
-A selfish... -[Carmela] Heartless.
-Heartless. -There's no heart in there.
I don't know if that's possible.
I would like to try.
It [bleep] up my life, just to be honest with you.
Majorly.
It was the worst mistake I've ever made in life.
She said [bleep] about me, I'm sure.
And the reason you're still just not coming around.
I met Jeremiah's mother when I was in the Army.
I was married to her for a total of, I think,
it was five years, and then, things hit the fan,
and I tried to be... Do the right thing
and get back and take over, and responsibility.
I didn't know that she was pregnant with Jeremiah
when it came to a head, and I left, finally.
I found out Jeremiah was my son
when his two older brother and sister found me.
He came to me and said they had a brother.
And then, I said, well, let's find him.
I had never dreamt I had a son living with the Amish,
but here it is.
Whatever she said about me, or told you anything about me,
I'm not that person.
[Jeremiah] She actually hasn't said a word about you.
Not once.
[Dennis] She can't say nothing about me
because I haven't done anything to her
other than stayed away.
[Jeremiah] My biological mother rejected me,
and left me heartbroken.
And I don't want my biological father to do the same thing.
I wanna be your dad. Well, I can't be your dad,
you're already growed up, but...
-He still got... -I wanna...
I wanna do them father and son things
that we never did.
I would love to get together more often with you.
One-on-one.
I love you, son. I wanna spend time with you.
-One hundred percent. -One hundred percent.
[Carmela] I think that Dennis is a really nice guy.
He's really trying to show Jeremiah
how much he loves him, how much he appreciates him,
and he wants to build a relationship.
Wow.
It was a very positive experience
when I met Dennis for the first time.
I mean that he wants me to be his son,
even though he missed out on all the prior years,
he's...he wants to be there as a father.
[Dennis] You've ridden before?
[Jeremiah] I'll go.
-Keep your feet in the pegs. -Yup.
Because you never know what I'm taking off.
That's right.
Sit back, let me lean in you.
Because if you lean opposite of what I'm doing,
-you're gonna turn me. -That's right.
And enjoy.
[Singer] ♪ We all sail through the life♪
♪ On a dream boat♪
♪ He keeps riding the waves♪
[Dennis] And you got your glasses on?
[Jeremiah] Yes.
[Singer] ♪ And the skies look gray♪
♪ Sail along♪
♪ Push on through♪
♪ Past the storm♪
♪ The skies that are blue♪
[guitar music playing]
[Ada] People on the beach told us to come to this pier
if we wanted to do something called parasailing.
So I set up a last minute reservation for us to fly.
-I'm excited. -Yeah. I'm very excited, too.
-Hello, hello. -[Rosanna] Hi.
-[Ada] Hello, how are you? -I'm good.
-Welcome aboard. -[Ada] Thank you.
-Thank you. -Thank you.
You guys ready for this?
[Ada] Um...
-no. -[Maureen] No.
I'm nervous because of the height.
The water doesn't bother me, it's the height.
[Rosanna] In my community, like, they say, like,
it's a sin, like, to go up, way up in the air.
That would be a big thing for them, you know.
Yeah. I've never been out on the ocean.
[man] Five minutes still, we're getting to our fly zone.
And it looks so... It's huge.
[man] All right. Girls, it's gonna get a little bumpy,
so hold on to your bonnets.
[Ada] Okay.
-Oh. -[laughter]
[Maureen] Oh, this is fun.
[Ada] I'm gonna pee my pants before we would parasail.
[man] Oh, can we go ahead and harness up?
You're gonna hold these two strips,
you're gonna slide that other foot.
Hey, you're going with her. If she likes it, I'll go.
[Maureen] Are you nervous?
[Rosanna] I am kind of a... I don't know.
I just wanted... I just wanna go up there.
[Maureen] How high are we actually gonna be up there?
[man] You're gonna be about 450 feet off the water.
And the reason I can't send you any higher
is we'll start running into airplanes.
[Rosanna] Whoa!
Wow. Look at that right there.
-[man] Hey, there's your ride. -[Maureen] Hey, that's nice.
[Rosanna] Wow!
That is big.
Have a seat on the top stair.
[Ada] Good luck.
[Maureen] Once they start harnessing me and everything,
my heart was just beating like crazy.
It's like...
[man] Are we clear for takeoff?
[Rosanna] My heart already feels like it's going, like,
"Boom, boom, boom, boom."
[man] All right. Girls, you ready?
-Yeah. -Yes.
[man] All right. We'll see you later.
Have fun!
[Ada] Rose, your hat!
There goes your hat!
[Maureen] Oh, my God!
This is... Yes.
[indistinct]
[Maureen] Yeah, it's [bleep]
Oh, my word.
[giggles] This is all fun.
[Singer] ♪ You know I'm living free♪
[laughter]
This is so fun.
[Maureen] It was so fun,
like, it was the best feeling ever.
I didn't even realize I was up that high.
You could actually see that that Earth is like round.
I was up that high.
[Rosanna] When I was way up there, like,
it felt like...
I felt like I was closer to God.
-Whoo. -All right.
[man] All right. I'm gonna get ready for the dip.
You're going down!
Hold your breath.
Oh, here we go!
-[screams] -[laughs]
I never had so much fun in my life.
[man] Oh, welcome back.
-Yeah. -[Maureen] Thank you!
[Rosanna] Thank you!
It was so exciting, like, going way up there.
Oh, my God, am I going?
My heart just kind of started beating fast.
But once I started going up there, like,
it was so amazing that, like,
you could see everywhere.
[upbeat music playing]
Woohoo.
[Rosanna] I finally feel, like, myself now,
since like, I am having so much fun,
and I'm finding out actually what is out here,
and, like, what life is.
[dramatic music playing]
-[Jeremiah] This is a nice little lake. -[Dennis] It is.
There's a lot of fish in here, too.
You know, in the future, I'd really love it
if you all could come back up,
and then, we can try and do
those father-son things
that we're gonna start on.
Stuff I never was able to do.
I had a great time meeting my father.
And I'm glad that I came to see him.
I wish we could actually stay longer,
but one of our friends down in Florida
is having a baby shower, so...
[Dennis] Oh, you got to go to the baby shower.
That's right. I'd be there for them, too.
I'm so glad I got to see you.
Too many years, son.
Let's not make that many again.
Oh, it won't.
[Dennis] Good. I'd prefer it not.
Give me a hug, son.
I love you.
-We're gonna be back. -I love you.
Good.
Good. I hope so.
I miss you so much.
[dramatic music playing]
[upbeat music playing]
[Ada in German]
These are really, really good
-because I ate two. -I'll be.
[Ada] [indistinct] I did.
[Jethro] I would really like to throw a baby shower for Sabrina,
show her how much I appreciate her and love her.
But, unfortunately, all the people that we know
from out of state can't come because of the Coronavirus.
So, today we're having a baby shower,
but there might be a bigger surprise,
you know.
I don't know if it's gonna happen there or not,
but [bleep] I'm just gonna
drop it in the bag like that.
-[man] See what happens? -See what happens.
[laughs]
[upbeat music playing]
Oh, this is sweet.
Wow, everything's pink.
[Ada] Wanna give her a baby gift?
[Carmela] Yes.
Start with this one.
Oh, it's a little elephant, look.
[Maureen] The Amish don't have baby showers.
After they have the baby, if it's a boy or a girl,
we give them a gift of, like,
boy clothes or a girl, whatever they need.
[gasps] Oh, my goodness!
Look, it's the hand puppet that I wanted.
-Thank you so much. -You're welcome.
[Jethro] I plan on proposing to Sabrina,
and I feel nervous,
like this is the first time I'm doing this.
I don't know.
I'm afraid I'm gonna [bleep] it up.
All right, everybody, grab a drink.
I'm just ready to get married already.
I just wanna thank you guys for, uh,
all helping me put this together tonight.
Um, I couldn't have done it on my own obviously.
Um, we're all family.
And I just wanna thank you guys
for all your support.
[Matt] My name is Mathew,
and I'm friends with Jeth and Sabrina.
So I'm making you spaghetti...
-[Sabrina] Ooh. -...and sauce.
So, me and Sabrina were both ex-Mennonite.
Being ex-Mennonite, it's kind of hard sometimes
to get your bearings.
[Sabrina] That's pretty impressive.
Too bad you're not straight.
[laughs]
But since then, life is great for me.
I mean, I am proud. And...
Hey.
-[Jeremiah] What in the world? -What?
-Matt? -Yeah.
Wow.
[Sabrina] I was especially surprised
when I saw Matt Bristol.
The last place he should've show up was at my baby shower.
[Jeremiah] When did you get here?
-[Matt] I just got here. -[Ada] Hey, look, it's...
-[Jeremiah] It's good to see you. -It's good to see you, guys.
-[Carmela] Oh, my gosh. -I brought you guys a gift.
-Matthew. -Thank you so much.
-Hey, how are you? -[Jethro] Good.
[Matt] So, who's little tyke?
-Hey, bud. -It's okay.
-Hey, bud. -Well...
[Matt] Carmela, what have you been up to?
[Carmela] Um, just working all the time, nonstop...
-[Matt] okay. -...pretty much.
[Ada] This is my granddaughter, Maureen.
And I'm Ada Marie.
[Matt] Okay. Where you guys from?
Uh, Western Pennsylvania.
-[Maureen] And that's Rosanna. -Rosanna.
[Sabrina] So, who... did you invite him?
How did you find out?
-Oh, really. -Yeah.
[Jethro] I was really excited to see him.
Matt is a nice guy, and, um, a good person.
[Sabrina] Oh, look. It's a little Mennonite dress.
Here, hold it.
Aww, thank you, Matt.
[Matt] You're welcome. You know what I do.
-[Sabrina] You sewed it? -Yup, uh-hmm.
-Oh, my God, for real? -[Matt] I sewed it out for you last night.
-Yes. -[Sabrina] Well, thank you.
That was very sweet of you.
-Thank you. -[Matt] You're welcome.
Just so you know, Sabrina, I'm happy to see you guys.
You and Jeth have been, like, in my life
back-and-forth for so many years.
It's good that to see you,
like, you're doing better,
and that you're back,
you know, from being rehab and all that. It's just...
Because, uh, every time I hear
that you're in and out of rehab,
-it's just like, ugh. -[Sabrina] Yeah.
And just praying for you.
-So, it's really... -[Sabrina] Oh, thank you.
I'm really glad that you guys are doing better.
-Thank you. -[Matt] Yeah.
Even though we haven't talked, I thought about you often.
Yo.
So, what's up with you, Jeremiah?
I haven't heard or talk to you in a while either.
Hmm?
Whole bunch of stuff going on.
Yeah? You don't like it...
get me all caught up on everything.
Oh, we will, at some point.
[laughs]
[Jeremiah] I can guarantee you.
When Jethro invited Matt Bristol
to the baby shower, he had no idea
that I knew their secret.
[makes sound]
[Sabrina] Jeremiah's a wild card.
And he likes to try to make a fire
everywhere possible that he can,
and that scares me.
[Jeremiah] If Jethro thought there was any chance
that Sabrina would tell anybody their secret,
he would have never invited Matt.
[makes sound]
[tense music playing]
[Jeremiah] On the next episode of Return to Amish.
Sabrina said how you gave Jethro...
[bleep].
[man speaking]
[Jeremiah speaking]
[Maureen] I was actually a schoolteacher.
So how much, like, school do you do?
-Until 8th Grade. -[woman] Okay.
[Maureen] The English people think we're dumb.
[woman] The baby is not moving as much,
and I just don't feel right.