1 00:00:02,306 --> 00:00:05,005 NICKI: What does your mom do again?I don't know, charity stuff. 2 00:00:05,048 --> 00:00:07,050 ROBYN: I'm the one you call when you can't call 911. 3 00:00:07,094 --> 00:00:09,052 Previously onThe Equalizer... 4 00:00:09,096 --> 00:00:11,141 DELILAH: You don't work for a charity, do you, Mom? 5 00:00:11,185 --> 00:00:12,621 No matter what I do, I'm always your mom. 6 00:00:12,664 --> 00:00:13,578 I know that you lied to me. 7 00:00:14,492 --> 00:00:15,885 I am a NYPD...MORALES: Stop! 8 00:00:15,928 --> 00:00:17,756 [grunts] This guy's a cop. 9 00:00:17,800 --> 00:00:19,062 We'll take him out to Youngstrom's farm. 10 00:00:19,106 --> 00:00:20,411 No one will ever know.[gunshot] 11 00:00:20,455 --> 00:00:21,891 [grunting] 12 00:00:24,024 --> 00:00:25,112 DANTE: Give that to the chief for me. 13 00:00:25,155 --> 00:00:27,157 I'm afraid of who I might become. 14 00:00:28,767 --> 00:00:31,161 ♪ Here we are 15 00:00:31,205 --> 00:00:34,077 ♪ Under the stars... [laughter] 16 00:00:34,121 --> 00:00:36,471 Okay, what about Leroy, if it's a boy? 17 00:00:36,514 --> 00:00:38,429 Leroy? Oh, you can't be serious. 18 00:00:38,473 --> 00:00:40,388 What? It's distinguished. 19 00:00:40,431 --> 00:00:41,867 My uncle's name is Leroy. 20 00:00:41,911 --> 00:00:44,696 [laughs]: Your uncle is also 82 years old. 21 00:00:44,740 --> 00:00:46,481 I will not do that to our child. 22 00:00:47,786 --> 00:00:50,006 Our child. 23 00:00:50,050 --> 00:00:51,486 ♪ So far 24 00:00:51,529 --> 00:00:53,401 ♪ Under the stars... [knocking] 25 00:00:53,444 --> 00:00:55,185 The food.No, no, no. I'll go. 26 00:00:55,229 --> 00:00:57,405 You and little Leroy stay. 27 00:00:57,448 --> 00:00:59,624 Uh-uh. I'm telling you, Leroy is gonna come out 28 00:00:59,668 --> 00:01:01,148 with an AARP card.[laughs] 29 00:01:01,191 --> 00:01:03,280 Tim Colvin? 30 00:01:03,324 --> 00:01:04,890 Yeah. 31 00:01:04,934 --> 00:01:06,675 You're under arrest for rape and murder 32 00:01:06,718 --> 00:01:08,329 in the first degree.Wait, wait, I'm under arrest for what? 33 00:01:08,372 --> 00:01:09,939 You have the right to remain silent, anything you say 34 00:01:09,982 --> 00:01:11,158 can and will be held against youThis isn't right. 35 00:01:11,201 --> 00:01:12,289 in a court of law.You got the wrong guy. 36 00:01:12,333 --> 00:01:14,117 Stop! He-he didn't do anything! 37 00:01:14,161 --> 00:01:15,292 We'll figure this out. I love you.Tim? 38 00:01:15,336 --> 00:01:17,468 I love you![cries]: Tim! 39 00:01:17,512 --> 00:01:19,644 ♪ 40 00:01:22,473 --> 00:01:25,520 JUDGE: If, after considering the testimony and evidence, 41 00:01:25,563 --> 00:01:28,088 you find that the defendant did commit the offenses 42 00:01:28,131 --> 00:01:30,220 of rape and murder in the first degree, 43 00:01:30,264 --> 00:01:33,136 then you are authorized to find the defendant guilty. 44 00:01:33,180 --> 00:01:35,051 If you have any reasonable doubt, 45 00:01:35,095 --> 00:01:36,661 then you must acquit the defendant. 46 00:01:36,705 --> 00:01:38,315 The verdict must be unanimous. 47 00:01:38,359 --> 00:01:40,622 And despite the seriousness of the alleged offenses, 48 00:01:40,665 --> 00:01:42,319 you are to consider the facts 49 00:01:42,363 --> 00:01:45,496 without sympathy or concern for punishment. 50 00:01:45,540 --> 00:01:47,759 ♪ 51 00:01:49,065 --> 00:01:52,286 Well, that's nine days we will never get back again. 52 00:01:52,329 --> 00:01:54,026 Could've been one if they didn't insist 53 00:01:54,070 --> 00:01:55,506 on "talking lawyer." 54 00:01:55,550 --> 00:01:57,291 I don't know, I mean, 55 00:01:57,334 --> 00:01:58,640 you hear about guys like this all the time, 56 00:01:58,683 --> 00:02:00,120 but to actually be a part of it-- 57 00:02:00,163 --> 00:02:01,121 pretty cool. 58 00:02:01,164 --> 00:02:02,948 JI-YOON: Let me guess. 59 00:02:02,992 --> 00:02:04,254 You're obsessed with true crime. 60 00:02:04,298 --> 00:02:06,517 Excuse me? What do you care? 61 00:02:06,561 --> 00:02:07,779 How long do you think we all have to be in here? 62 00:02:07,823 --> 00:02:09,172 I have work. 63 00:02:09,216 --> 00:02:10,434 Oh, we all got our lives to get back to. 64 00:02:10,478 --> 00:02:12,349 Well, you're the foreman. 65 00:02:12,393 --> 00:02:14,134 What do you think about taking a vote now? 66 00:02:14,177 --> 00:02:15,135 Sure. 67 00:02:15,178 --> 00:02:17,006 Let's take a vote. 68 00:02:17,049 --> 00:02:18,355 Let's do hands in the air. 69 00:02:18,399 --> 00:02:19,661 All for guilty? 70 00:02:24,883 --> 00:02:26,494 Wait. Really? 71 00:02:26,537 --> 00:02:28,539 I was gonna say the same thing. 72 00:02:28,583 --> 00:02:31,063 You really think the defense proved this guy is innocent? 73 00:02:31,107 --> 00:02:32,587 She doesn't have to. 74 00:02:32,630 --> 00:02:35,546 The prosecution has to prove that he's guilty 75 00:02:35,590 --> 00:02:37,766 beyond a reasonable doubt, 76 00:02:37,809 --> 00:02:38,897 and I have one. 77 00:02:38,941 --> 00:02:40,203 He's clearly guilty. 78 00:02:40,247 --> 00:02:42,031 He admitted to being at the scene. 79 00:02:42,074 --> 00:02:43,772 He was spotted running away 80 00:02:43,815 --> 00:02:45,817 right after the victim's time of death. 81 00:02:45,861 --> 00:02:48,168 He admitted to being in the building, not at the scene, 82 00:02:48,211 --> 00:02:50,605 and haven't you ever run for a cab? 83 00:02:50,648 --> 00:02:52,607 What about his violent history? 84 00:02:52,650 --> 00:02:53,999 The argument with his fiancée? 85 00:02:54,043 --> 00:02:55,392 The cut on his arm? 86 00:02:55,436 --> 00:02:57,916 Right, from struggling with the victim. 87 00:02:57,960 --> 00:02:59,222 Weren't you listening to the evidence? 88 00:02:59,266 --> 00:03:00,528 I was. 89 00:03:00,571 --> 00:03:02,617 He said he got the cut 90 00:03:02,660 --> 00:03:06,011 from tripping on the street, and... 91 00:03:06,055 --> 00:03:08,318 it was on his hand, not his arm. 92 00:03:08,362 --> 00:03:10,625 Does it matter where the cut was?Maybe. 93 00:03:10,668 --> 00:03:12,235 Look, I'm not sure 94 00:03:12,279 --> 00:03:13,802 of his innocence, but what I do know is that 95 00:03:13,845 --> 00:03:16,979 if we vote to convict, 96 00:03:17,022 --> 00:03:19,024 a human being goes to prison 97 00:03:19,068 --> 00:03:21,418 for the rest of his life. 98 00:03:21,462 --> 00:03:23,681 So he deserves to have us take a hard look 99 00:03:23,725 --> 00:03:26,206 at the facts. 100 00:03:26,249 --> 00:03:29,209 The least we could do is start by getting them straight. 101 00:03:30,166 --> 00:03:32,168 [groans] 102 00:03:32,212 --> 00:03:34,475 DELILAH: Mom. Hey, where's my red hoodie? 103 00:03:34,518 --> 00:03:36,433 I want to wear it to Dad's this weekend. 104 00:03:36,477 --> 00:03:38,870 It is in the laundry room. 105 00:03:38,914 --> 00:03:42,222 And you know that machine is not password protected, right? 106 00:03:42,265 --> 00:03:43,832 When's Aunt Vi done with jury duty again? 107 00:03:45,094 --> 00:03:47,444 What does that have to do with you helping out around here 108 00:03:47,488 --> 00:03:48,576 before you go to your dad's? 109 00:03:49,838 --> 00:03:51,535 By the way... 110 00:03:51,579 --> 00:03:53,624 how are you feeling about seeing your dad? 111 00:03:53,668 --> 00:03:55,365 What do you mean? 112 00:03:56,845 --> 00:03:59,064 These questions he's been asking you about me, 113 00:03:59,108 --> 00:04:00,675 about what I'm involved in. 114 00:04:00,718 --> 00:04:03,286 I mean, I'm-I'm fine. 115 00:04:03,330 --> 00:04:04,722 Well, if I have to lie to keep your secret... 116 00:04:04,766 --> 00:04:06,985 [stammers] 117 00:04:07,029 --> 00:04:08,422 I know how to handle Dad. 118 00:04:10,293 --> 00:04:12,121 Well... 119 00:04:13,427 --> 00:04:15,646 Don't start trying that around here. 120 00:04:15,690 --> 00:04:16,995 What? [scoffs] 121 00:04:17,039 --> 00:04:18,432 What? No way. 122 00:04:18,475 --> 00:04:19,824 Would never. 123 00:04:19,868 --> 00:04:21,435 [chuckles]Yeah, never. That's right. 124 00:04:21,478 --> 00:04:23,480 Hey, Aunt Vi. 125 00:04:23,524 --> 00:04:25,003 You look exhausted. 126 00:04:25,047 --> 00:04:26,266 Locked in a room 127 00:04:26,309 --> 00:04:28,311 for hours with 11 strangers. 128 00:04:28,355 --> 00:04:29,878 Can't imagine why. 129 00:04:29,921 --> 00:04:31,314 Five minutes in, they're ready 130 00:04:31,358 --> 00:04:32,576 to send this young man away for life, 131 00:04:32,620 --> 00:04:34,274 with no discussion. 132 00:04:34,317 --> 00:04:36,276 Hell no. 133 00:04:36,319 --> 00:04:38,103 I will get these people talking. 134 00:04:38,147 --> 00:04:40,410 I will keep them there till winter if that's what it takes. 135 00:04:40,454 --> 00:04:42,847 Well, guess I got some laundry to do. 136 00:04:42,891 --> 00:04:43,805 VI: Thank you. 137 00:04:43,848 --> 00:04:45,720 [scoffs] 138 00:04:45,763 --> 00:04:47,852 The arrogance of these people. 139 00:04:47,896 --> 00:04:49,245 I mean, 140 00:04:49,289 --> 00:04:50,507 I don't know if he did it or not, 141 00:04:50,551 --> 00:04:52,335 but they don't either. 142 00:04:52,379 --> 00:04:54,511 And that's why we're supposed to deliberate, 143 00:04:54,555 --> 00:04:56,818 not just declare a hung jury 144 00:04:56,861 --> 00:04:59,255 because they've already made up their minds. 145 00:04:59,299 --> 00:05:01,649 No one likes to admit they could be wrong. 146 00:05:01,692 --> 00:05:03,955 Means they have to reexamine everything. 147 00:05:03,999 --> 00:05:06,393 Yes, and that's why we're there. 148 00:05:06,436 --> 00:05:08,438 But I'm telling you 149 00:05:08,482 --> 00:05:10,353 there is something about this evidence 150 00:05:10,397 --> 00:05:13,051 that just doesn't sit right with me. 151 00:05:13,095 --> 00:05:14,488 It's too... 152 00:05:14,531 --> 00:05:18,187 It's too tidy. It's too black and white. 153 00:05:18,230 --> 00:05:20,320 Well, what's the case? 154 00:05:20,363 --> 00:05:22,931 [sighs] You know I can't tell you that. 155 00:05:23,975 --> 00:05:25,499 Doesn't matter. 156 00:05:25,542 --> 00:05:27,544 It's too late now, anyway. 157 00:05:28,937 --> 00:05:32,114 I just think there's a messy truth out there that... 158 00:05:34,029 --> 00:05:36,640 I just wish someone had taken the time to find it. 159 00:05:41,558 --> 00:05:43,517 So, she refused to give you any details about the trial, 160 00:05:43,560 --> 00:05:45,214 and you took that as a personal invitation 161 00:05:45,257 --> 00:05:46,389 to dig into the case? 162 00:05:46,433 --> 00:05:48,391 Well, Aunt Vi is too smart to ask. 163 00:05:48,435 --> 00:05:49,653 But she has really good instincts, 164 00:05:49,697 --> 00:05:51,568 and a man's life is at stake, 165 00:05:51,612 --> 00:05:54,223 so let's just make sure the jury has all the evidence. 166 00:05:54,266 --> 00:05:55,355 You know which courthouse? 167 00:05:55,398 --> 00:05:57,095 Nah. It's somewhere in Brooklyn. 168 00:05:57,139 --> 00:05:59,097 Brooklyn, male defendant, life sentence. 169 00:05:59,141 --> 00:06:00,272 Hold, please. 170 00:06:00,316 --> 00:06:01,491 [typing] 171 00:06:01,535 --> 00:06:03,580 MEL: What's up? 172 00:06:03,624 --> 00:06:06,670 You have that "I'm here in body only" look. 173 00:06:06,714 --> 00:06:08,411 Dee is lying again. 174 00:06:08,455 --> 00:06:10,805 Isn't that what teenagers do? 175 00:06:10,848 --> 00:06:12,894 Yeah, but she's lying to protect me. 176 00:06:12,937 --> 00:06:14,939 To her dad. 177 00:06:14,983 --> 00:06:16,071 He's been asking questions. 178 00:06:16,114 --> 00:06:17,768 Yeah, that is tricky. 179 00:06:17,812 --> 00:06:19,640 Yeah. 180 00:06:19,683 --> 00:06:21,946 I always taught her that lying was wrong, 181 00:06:21,990 --> 00:06:24,122 but now she's learning it's okay, 182 00:06:24,166 --> 00:06:25,341 that it can be necessary. 183 00:06:25,385 --> 00:06:26,821 Well, she's not wrong. 184 00:06:26,864 --> 00:06:28,431 I lie about Harry being dead for years. 185 00:06:28,475 --> 00:06:29,911 Yeah, but you're an adult. 186 00:06:29,954 --> 00:06:31,913 Delilah is a high school kid, 187 00:06:31,956 --> 00:06:33,305 and it's her father. 188 00:06:33,349 --> 00:06:35,220 [sighs] 189 00:06:35,264 --> 00:06:36,787 Lying can be a dangerous road, 190 00:06:36,831 --> 00:06:38,485 and I'm the one that's put her on it. 191 00:06:38,528 --> 00:06:40,617 [computer beeps]All right, I got it. 192 00:06:40,661 --> 00:06:43,490 Defendant's name is Tim Colvin. 193 00:06:43,533 --> 00:06:45,970 He's charged with the rape and murder of 194 00:06:46,014 --> 00:06:48,320 Sarah Ross, a white college undergrad. 195 00:06:48,364 --> 00:06:50,366 [typing]So, eight months ago, 196 00:06:50,410 --> 00:06:52,020 Sarah, the victim, is drinking at the bar 197 00:06:52,063 --> 00:06:53,587 with her roommate, Olivia, 198 00:06:53,630 --> 00:06:55,458 who sees Sarah talking to this guy, Tim. 199 00:06:55,502 --> 00:06:57,068 Olivia goes home later, finds Sarah 200 00:06:57,112 --> 00:06:59,201 strangled and raped in her apartment, 201 00:06:59,244 --> 00:07:01,203 and Tim is seen running away from the building. 202 00:07:01,246 --> 00:07:02,509 And what's Tim's story? 203 00:07:02,552 --> 00:07:04,206 I mean, guy says he's innocent. 204 00:07:04,249 --> 00:07:05,642 Says the only reason he was even in the building was, 205 00:07:05,686 --> 00:07:07,862 he was going on a walk, he got cold. 206 00:07:07,905 --> 00:07:09,733 Spotted the vestibule through the window upstairs. 207 00:07:09,777 --> 00:07:11,431 Building looked cozy. 208 00:07:11,474 --> 00:07:13,041 Went in there, warmed up. 209 00:07:13,084 --> 00:07:14,434 Gets a cab and goes home. 210 00:07:14,477 --> 00:07:16,392 And talking to Sarah at the bar? 211 00:07:16,436 --> 00:07:17,654 I mean, he denies even being at the bar, 212 00:07:17,698 --> 00:07:18,829 but he's got no alibi. 213 00:07:18,873 --> 00:07:20,396 The evidence is pretty damning. 214 00:07:20,440 --> 00:07:21,963 Who is this guy?[typing] 215 00:07:22,006 --> 00:07:23,443 HARRY: I mean, he's an associate 216 00:07:23,486 --> 00:07:25,096 at an investment firm. 217 00:07:25,140 --> 00:07:26,576 He's got no record. 218 00:07:26,620 --> 00:07:28,186 He just bought a condo with his fiancée. 219 00:07:28,230 --> 00:07:29,623 They look like a nice couple. 220 00:07:29,666 --> 00:07:31,102 ROBYN: Aunt Vi sat through this whole trial 221 00:07:31,146 --> 00:07:32,843 and felt that it was full of holes. 222 00:07:32,887 --> 00:07:34,584 I want to talk to Tim's fiancée, Morgan. 223 00:07:36,456 --> 00:07:38,153 She knew him best. Let's see what she thinks. 224 00:07:38,196 --> 00:07:39,415 [knocking] 225 00:07:40,634 --> 00:07:42,418 Morgan Carver?Yeah. 226 00:07:42,462 --> 00:07:44,507 I'm with Champions for the Wrongfully Convicted. 227 00:07:44,551 --> 00:07:47,031 We think your fiancé's case may 228 00:07:47,075 --> 00:07:48,990 deserve a second look. 229 00:07:51,079 --> 00:07:53,124 Are you moving? 230 00:07:53,168 --> 00:07:54,474 Not by choice. 231 00:07:56,258 --> 00:07:58,303 Uh, with the attorney bills and the baby... 232 00:07:58,347 --> 00:08:00,305 Morgan, 233 00:08:00,349 --> 00:08:02,090 between you and I, 234 00:08:02,133 --> 00:08:04,353 what do you think happened eight months ago? 235 00:08:04,396 --> 00:08:07,574 Tim had just learned that he was being let go. 236 00:08:07,617 --> 00:08:10,272 And that night, I found out that 237 00:08:10,315 --> 00:08:13,449 he'd been offered a new job by an ex-girlfriend, 238 00:08:13,493 --> 00:08:14,842 and he hadn't told me. 239 00:08:14,885 --> 00:08:16,104 We argued. 240 00:08:16,147 --> 00:08:18,715 He left... [sighs] 241 00:08:18,759 --> 00:08:21,065 but the prosecution took it all out of context 242 00:08:21,109 --> 00:08:24,068 and made it seem like he was so angry from being fired 243 00:08:24,112 --> 00:08:25,679 that he went out and killed a girl. 244 00:08:25,722 --> 00:08:27,681 Even dragged his upbringing into it, 245 00:08:27,724 --> 00:08:29,204 as if growing up in a rough neighborhood 246 00:08:29,247 --> 00:08:30,553 makes you a monster. 247 00:08:30,597 --> 00:08:33,077 Well, didn't the defense track his phone? 248 00:08:33,121 --> 00:08:35,689 He left his phone at the house that night. 249 00:08:35,732 --> 00:08:38,561 He went out for a walk to cool down. 250 00:08:38,605 --> 00:08:40,345 So no one can account for where he went. 251 00:08:40,389 --> 00:08:42,260 He was upset. 252 00:08:42,304 --> 00:08:44,567 We've all been there. 253 00:08:44,611 --> 00:08:46,264 Morgan, I have to ask you this, 254 00:08:46,308 --> 00:08:48,702 do you believe your fiancé 255 00:08:48,745 --> 00:08:51,052 could have done something like this? 256 00:08:52,053 --> 00:08:53,620 He didn't do it. 257 00:08:53,663 --> 00:08:56,492 I know that man 258 00:08:56,536 --> 00:08:57,754 without a shadow of a doubt, 259 00:08:57,798 --> 00:08:59,713 and he would not do something like this. 260 00:09:02,672 --> 00:09:05,545 When I look at my son... 261 00:09:05,588 --> 00:09:07,590 I see Tim. 262 00:09:07,634 --> 00:09:09,940 [crying]: What destroys me is that 263 00:09:09,984 --> 00:09:13,553 they may never see each other outside of prison. 264 00:09:14,684 --> 00:09:15,772 If there's... 265 00:09:15,816 --> 00:09:18,296 any help that you can offer us, 266 00:09:18,340 --> 00:09:20,429 I'm begging you for it. 267 00:09:29,003 --> 00:09:30,744 ♪ Yeah, yeah, can't train, Caine 'bout to travel ♪ 268 00:09:30,787 --> 00:09:33,573 ♪ Haul off, I could do the same thing, rap game... ♪ 269 00:09:36,619 --> 00:09:37,620 Thinking about a career change? 270 00:09:39,579 --> 00:09:41,450 Might've missed my NBA window. 271 00:09:41,493 --> 00:09:43,365 I was actually talking about that walk 272 00:09:43,408 --> 00:09:45,410 down memory lane. 273 00:09:45,454 --> 00:09:46,890 Thinking you want to go back to law school? 274 00:09:48,196 --> 00:09:50,415 Lot of people make decisions because they're running toward 275 00:09:50,459 --> 00:09:52,461 or away from their parents. 276 00:09:52,504 --> 00:09:54,594 I think I was doing both, becoming a cop. 277 00:09:55,856 --> 00:09:57,205 I don't know if I ever really knew 278 00:09:57,248 --> 00:09:58,728 what I wanted. 279 00:10:00,687 --> 00:10:02,819 Maybe I never really knew myself at all. 280 00:10:03,820 --> 00:10:06,780 I think, in the end... 281 00:10:06,823 --> 00:10:10,044 we are what we can't let go of and what can't let go of us. 282 00:10:14,657 --> 00:10:16,398 I left the force for a reason. 283 00:10:17,660 --> 00:10:19,575 I need some time to work through things. 284 00:10:19,619 --> 00:10:21,316 And I respect that. 285 00:10:21,359 --> 00:10:23,361 All I need is a consult. 286 00:10:23,405 --> 00:10:25,146 Just give me five minutes, 287 00:10:25,189 --> 00:10:27,191 and if you don't want to be involved, I will leave you be. 288 00:10:32,066 --> 00:10:33,458 So, what do you think? 289 00:10:33,502 --> 00:10:35,809 Solid case. 290 00:10:35,852 --> 00:10:38,289 Some of the evidence is circumstantial, sure-- 291 00:10:38,333 --> 00:10:40,988 the sedative in her system, and Tim having a prescription. 292 00:10:41,031 --> 00:10:42,642 But without DNA or fingerprints, 293 00:10:42,685 --> 00:10:44,556 lots of cases are built this way. 294 00:10:44,600 --> 00:10:46,384 You know the detectives? 295 00:10:46,428 --> 00:10:48,691 They're good guys. Casework's by the book. 296 00:10:48,735 --> 00:10:52,042 Maybe, but Tim was arrested two days after the killing. 297 00:10:52,086 --> 00:10:53,870 No other suspects were interviewed. 298 00:10:53,914 --> 00:10:55,655 Isn't it possible they missed something? 299 00:10:55,698 --> 00:10:57,047 Sure. 300 00:10:57,091 --> 00:10:59,789 But sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. 301 00:11:01,225 --> 00:11:02,792 I mean, I'd like to talk to Tim, 302 00:11:02,836 --> 00:11:05,099 but he's at trial and in custody. 303 00:11:05,142 --> 00:11:07,667 His lawyer is the only one allowed in to see him. 304 00:11:07,710 --> 00:11:09,843 Without my badge I can't help with that. 305 00:11:09,886 --> 00:11:12,802 I'm also out of favors. 306 00:11:12,846 --> 00:11:15,718 And I meant what I said about taking time. 307 00:11:15,762 --> 00:11:17,764 These questions you want answered, 308 00:11:17,807 --> 00:11:19,853 you don't need me to ask them. 309 00:11:21,463 --> 00:11:22,507 HOWARD: What's there to question? 310 00:11:22,551 --> 00:11:24,814 The prosecution's case is solid. 311 00:11:24,858 --> 00:11:26,729 It's Tim's story that is shaky as hell. 312 00:11:26,773 --> 00:11:28,513 I found it to be believable. 313 00:11:28,557 --> 00:11:30,211 Which part was the most believable? 314 00:11:30,254 --> 00:11:31,647 Him taking a walk 315 00:11:31,691 --> 00:11:33,344 and conveniently forgetting where he went? 316 00:11:33,388 --> 00:11:35,085 Or the bad luck 317 00:11:35,129 --> 00:11:36,739 where he was in the building 318 00:11:36,783 --> 00:11:37,914 while a girl was being raped and murdered? 319 00:11:37,958 --> 00:11:39,437 JI-YOON:Dude, 320 00:11:39,481 --> 00:11:40,874 sarcasm is not gonna help here. 321 00:11:40,917 --> 00:11:42,397 Let's stick to the evidence. 322 00:11:42,440 --> 00:11:43,877 SOFIA: Which is that 323 00:11:43,920 --> 00:11:45,879 nobody can vouch for Tim's story. 324 00:11:45,922 --> 00:11:48,664 On the other hand, Sarah's roommate saw Tim 325 00:11:48,708 --> 00:11:51,101 giving her a glass of water at the bar at 11:00 p.m. 326 00:11:51,145 --> 00:11:53,495 Later, Sarah's neighbor heard a scream, 327 00:11:53,538 --> 00:11:56,106 just as her favorite show was starting at 11:30, 328 00:11:56,150 --> 00:11:59,544 and Tim admits to running for the cab a-at midnight. 329 00:11:59,588 --> 00:12:01,546 What about the DNA? 330 00:12:01,590 --> 00:12:03,331 Is anyone else disturbed by the fact 331 00:12:03,374 --> 00:12:04,854 that there's no DNA evidence? 332 00:12:04,898 --> 00:12:07,030 Oh, he made sure of that. 333 00:12:07,074 --> 00:12:09,511 Tim had a half hour to kill Sarah 334 00:12:09,554 --> 00:12:10,686 and clean up well enough that there was 335 00:12:10,730 --> 00:12:12,427 no evidence left behind. 336 00:12:12,470 --> 00:12:14,342 The timeline makes sense. 337 00:12:14,385 --> 00:12:17,345 HOWARD: We can go around and around all day. 338 00:12:17,388 --> 00:12:20,130 I have no doubt in my mind that this man killed Sarah Ross. 339 00:12:20,174 --> 00:12:21,566 Why? 340 00:12:21,610 --> 00:12:23,133 This man with no record, 341 00:12:23,177 --> 00:12:25,614 with everything going for him, what is his motive? 342 00:12:25,657 --> 00:12:28,573 I don't know if getting fired is having everything going for you. 343 00:12:28,617 --> 00:12:30,140 The guy was pissed. 344 00:12:30,184 --> 00:12:31,838 He's riled up after the fight. 345 00:12:31,881 --> 00:12:33,491 He sees a white woman 346 00:12:33,535 --> 00:12:35,624 who looks just like the boss who fired him, 347 00:12:35,667 --> 00:12:36,886 and he takes his rage out on her. 348 00:12:36,930 --> 00:12:38,975 You can take 'em out of the hood... 349 00:12:39,019 --> 00:12:41,412 Well. That seems a little...What? 350 00:12:41,456 --> 00:12:43,153 I don't know, problematic. 351 00:12:43,197 --> 00:12:45,503 And what would you know about it, Connecticut? 352 00:12:45,547 --> 00:12:47,854 HOWARD: Now, he went from having nothing 353 00:12:47,897 --> 00:12:49,420 to everything. 354 00:12:49,464 --> 00:12:50,813 No wonder he feels so entitled. 355 00:12:50,857 --> 00:12:52,597 And he's the reason men are being forced 356 00:12:52,641 --> 00:12:53,816 into early retirement. 357 00:12:53,860 --> 00:12:54,904 You mean men like you? 358 00:12:56,340 --> 00:12:59,126 Okay. [scoffs] 359 00:12:59,169 --> 00:13:02,825 Since we're all spinning stories about who he might be, 360 00:13:02,869 --> 00:13:03,826 I'd like to try one 361 00:13:03,870 --> 00:13:05,741 that isn't based on 362 00:13:05,785 --> 00:13:07,830 a tired stereotype. 363 00:13:07,874 --> 00:13:09,832 How about Tim Colvin 364 00:13:09,876 --> 00:13:12,530 is a levelheaded young man who walks away from an argument 365 00:13:12,574 --> 00:13:14,010 before it gets too heated? 366 00:13:14,054 --> 00:13:16,317 We know he's upset with his fiancée, 367 00:13:16,360 --> 00:13:18,188 who's Black. 368 00:13:18,232 --> 00:13:20,364 Why not go out and kill someone who looks like her? 369 00:13:20,408 --> 00:13:22,845 That same fiancée, I might add, 370 00:13:22,889 --> 00:13:26,196 was standing by him every day in court. 371 00:13:26,240 --> 00:13:29,765 Yeah, but can you ever really know someone? 372 00:13:29,809 --> 00:13:31,941 I had an ex who cured me of that. Hmm. 373 00:13:31,985 --> 00:13:34,552 If my husband was ever accused of something like this, 374 00:13:34,596 --> 00:13:36,467 I'd put him in the chair myself. 375 00:13:36,511 --> 00:13:37,773 [scattered chuckles] 376 00:13:37,817 --> 00:13:39,427 VI: And this idea that-that Tim 377 00:13:39,470 --> 00:13:43,126 drugged Sarah with a glass of water... 378 00:13:43,170 --> 00:13:45,563 If he was so upset when he left the house 379 00:13:45,607 --> 00:13:47,130 he forgot his phone, 380 00:13:47,174 --> 00:13:50,873 why would he think to bring a Vexinax? 381 00:13:50,917 --> 00:13:52,614 He could've had one in his pocket. 382 00:13:52,657 --> 00:13:54,355 He dissolves it in the glass of water, 383 00:13:54,398 --> 00:13:56,487 hands it to Sarah-- easy. 384 00:13:56,531 --> 00:13:58,054 Vexinax doesn't dissolve. 385 00:14:00,709 --> 00:14:02,189 I got a prescription for it 386 00:14:02,232 --> 00:14:03,886 when I was going through my divorce. 387 00:14:03,930 --> 00:14:06,193 I don't like taking pills, so I tried it once. 388 00:14:06,236 --> 00:14:08,108 Didn't work.JI-YOON: Wait. 389 00:14:08,151 --> 00:14:11,024 So that means he would've had to be carrying a Vexinax pill 390 00:14:11,067 --> 00:14:12,764 that he'd already crushed up when he saw Sarah. 391 00:14:12,808 --> 00:14:13,765 So? 392 00:14:13,809 --> 00:14:15,419 That doesn't exactly line up 393 00:14:15,463 --> 00:14:16,943 with the prosecution's story 394 00:14:16,986 --> 00:14:19,162 that this was a crime of opportunity. 395 00:14:19,206 --> 00:14:20,598 You knew this all along. 396 00:14:21,730 --> 00:14:24,080 Why would you vote guilty? 397 00:14:24,124 --> 00:14:26,169 There was so much other evidence. 398 00:14:26,213 --> 00:14:29,477 He was seen at the bar. He was at her building. 399 00:14:29,520 --> 00:14:31,653 HOWARD: No, no, no, no. She's right. 400 00:14:31,696 --> 00:14:33,220 So, the prosecution was wrong about it being 401 00:14:33,263 --> 00:14:34,438 a crime of opportunity. 402 00:14:34,482 --> 00:14:36,658 So what? 403 00:14:36,701 --> 00:14:38,660 So now I'm wondering what else they were wrong about. 404 00:14:41,968 --> 00:14:43,752 The thing I keep bumping up against is, 405 00:14:43,795 --> 00:14:46,015 why would Sarah take a pill from a total stranger? 406 00:14:46,059 --> 00:14:47,669 They're assuming he spiked her drink. 407 00:14:47,712 --> 00:14:49,976 No, I looked it up. Vexinax isn't soluble. 408 00:14:51,281 --> 00:14:52,630 I wonder if the jury knows that. 409 00:14:52,674 --> 00:14:54,719 And would a prescription antianxiety pill 410 00:14:54,763 --> 00:14:55,851 be his drug of choice? 411 00:14:55,895 --> 00:14:57,635 I mean, Rohypnol, GHB, 412 00:14:57,679 --> 00:14:59,550 even ketamine would be better options. 413 00:14:59,594 --> 00:15:01,422 Well, it got into her system somehow. 414 00:15:01,465 --> 00:15:02,858 And, according to the police report, 415 00:15:02,902 --> 00:15:04,642 Sarah didn't have a prescription. 416 00:15:04,686 --> 00:15:06,557 Either she took it willingly or somebody slipped it to her, 417 00:15:06,601 --> 00:15:08,081 and if it wasn't Tim, then who was it? 418 00:15:08,124 --> 00:15:11,388 We need to know who Sarah saw that night, 419 00:15:11,432 --> 00:15:14,957 and if she spent time with anyone else at that bar. 420 00:15:15,001 --> 00:15:15,915 She was there with her roommate, Olivia. 421 00:15:15,958 --> 00:15:18,134 Maybe she can shed some light. 422 00:15:19,135 --> 00:15:20,484 Olivia Simmons? 423 00:15:21,703 --> 00:15:23,748 Cynthia Westfield. D.A.'s office. 424 00:15:23,792 --> 00:15:25,141 Can we talk? 425 00:15:27,317 --> 00:15:29,102 No, it was just us at the bar. 426 00:15:29,145 --> 00:15:31,843 The place was filled with finance bros. 427 00:15:31,887 --> 00:15:34,063 Not our scene. 428 00:15:34,107 --> 00:15:35,978 So, other than Tim Colvin, you didn't see her with anyone else? 429 00:15:37,023 --> 00:15:39,721 No. Why? 430 00:15:39,764 --> 00:15:41,157 New evidence has come to light 431 00:15:41,201 --> 00:15:42,942 about how the Vexinax got into her system. 432 00:15:44,813 --> 00:15:46,815 What'd you mean that it wasn't your scene? 433 00:15:47,947 --> 00:15:51,167 We were just looking to chill, 434 00:15:51,211 --> 00:15:53,865 then the place got packed for the game. 435 00:15:53,909 --> 00:15:56,172 Not a fan of crowds, huh? 436 00:15:56,216 --> 00:15:58,696 Guys yelling. Everybody bumping into you. 437 00:15:58,740 --> 00:16:00,742 Must've been stressful. 438 00:16:02,004 --> 00:16:04,137 We think Sarah may have gotten the pills 439 00:16:04,180 --> 00:16:05,747 from someone she might have trusted. 440 00:16:07,401 --> 00:16:09,838 Olivia, I'm not a cop. 441 00:16:09,881 --> 00:16:11,709 And you were never asked about 442 00:16:11,753 --> 00:16:13,059 where Sarah got the drugs, 443 00:16:13,102 --> 00:16:15,017 so technically, you didn't lie. 444 00:16:15,061 --> 00:16:18,281 But you didn't exactly tell the whole truth, did you? 445 00:16:18,325 --> 00:16:20,980 The crowd was making Sarah anxious, 446 00:16:21,023 --> 00:16:23,983 so I gave her one of my pills. 447 00:16:24,026 --> 00:16:25,985 And you didn't say anything because... 448 00:16:26,028 --> 00:16:27,899 Everyone would've thought it was my fault. 449 00:16:27,943 --> 00:16:30,337 Maybe if I hadn't given it to her, 450 00:16:30,380 --> 00:16:32,556 she wouldn't have been so vulnerable. 451 00:16:34,384 --> 00:16:35,733 Maybe she would still be alive. 452 00:16:35,777 --> 00:16:37,648 I just thought that 453 00:16:37,692 --> 00:16:39,346 since they got the guy... 454 00:16:39,389 --> 00:16:42,218 What made you so sure that Tim was the guy, 455 00:16:42,262 --> 00:16:43,741 knowing he didn't give her the drugs? 456 00:16:43,785 --> 00:16:45,961 He was in our building. 457 00:16:46,005 --> 00:16:49,399 The cops showed me his picture. I recognized him. 458 00:16:49,443 --> 00:16:52,054 How many drinks had you had when you saw them talking? 459 00:16:52,098 --> 00:16:54,143 Not too many because I-I... 460 00:16:54,187 --> 00:16:56,145 'Cause you had taken a Vexinax, too. 461 00:16:58,365 --> 00:17:00,193 You're still sure it was him? 462 00:17:00,236 --> 00:17:02,804 He was at our building. 463 00:17:02,847 --> 00:17:04,327 He's the guy. 464 00:17:06,025 --> 00:17:07,200 Right? 465 00:17:08,897 --> 00:17:09,854 VI: It bears questioning. 466 00:17:09,898 --> 00:17:11,334 I've had my doubts 467 00:17:11,378 --> 00:17:12,683 about the eyewitness account from the start. 468 00:17:12,727 --> 00:17:15,599 It was dim in the bar and dark outside. 469 00:17:15,643 --> 00:17:17,079 She has twenty-twenty vision. 470 00:17:17,123 --> 00:17:18,646 They made a point of that. 471 00:17:18,689 --> 00:17:21,170 She was also 30 feet away through a crowded bar. 472 00:17:21,214 --> 00:17:23,607 Olivia also testified, under oath, 473 00:17:23,651 --> 00:17:25,870 that it was Tim she saw talking to Sarah. 474 00:17:25,914 --> 00:17:27,872 She has no doubt in her mind. 475 00:17:27,916 --> 00:17:28,873 Are you saying she's lying? 476 00:17:28,917 --> 00:17:30,875 No, but what I am saying is that 477 00:17:30,919 --> 00:17:34,401 maybe she believed she saw something that she didn't. 478 00:17:34,444 --> 00:17:37,447 The girl was traumatized from finding her friend murdered. 479 00:17:37,491 --> 00:17:40,363 A police officer shows her a photo of a Black suspect. 480 00:17:40,407 --> 00:17:43,236 The man Sarah was talking to at the bar is Black. 481 00:17:43,279 --> 00:17:45,847 Her brain fills in the rest. 482 00:17:45,890 --> 00:17:48,415 Oh, so now we're just making up reasons 483 00:17:48,458 --> 00:17:50,243 why the evidence doesn't point to him. 484 00:17:50,286 --> 00:17:51,940 No, we're just looking at possibilities, 485 00:17:51,983 --> 00:17:53,115 and we haven't even taken into account 486 00:17:53,159 --> 00:17:55,030 that cross-racial identifications 487 00:17:55,074 --> 00:17:57,380 are historically inaccurate. 488 00:17:57,424 --> 00:17:59,817 "Cross-racial identifications"? 489 00:17:59,861 --> 00:18:02,603 Uh, she is saying that all white people are so racist 490 00:18:02,646 --> 00:18:04,909 that they can't tell Black people apart. 491 00:18:04,953 --> 00:18:06,824 That is not what I'm saying. 492 00:18:06,868 --> 00:18:08,435 And for the record, I'm insulted. 493 00:18:08,478 --> 00:18:11,133 Howard, this is not a personal attack. 494 00:18:11,177 --> 00:18:14,180 It is just the way our brains work. 495 00:18:14,223 --> 00:18:15,529 KEELEY: She's right. 496 00:18:15,572 --> 00:18:17,052 42% of wrongful convictions 497 00:18:17,096 --> 00:18:18,836 based on eyewitness testimonies 498 00:18:18,880 --> 00:18:20,621 are cross-racial misidentifications. 499 00:18:21,926 --> 00:18:23,276 How do you know that? 500 00:18:23,319 --> 00:18:24,886 I saw an infographic on Instagram. 501 00:18:24,929 --> 00:18:26,496 SOFIA: So, what? 502 00:18:26,540 --> 00:18:28,150 Now you think this guy's innocent, too? 503 00:18:28,194 --> 00:18:30,152 I don't know. 504 00:18:31,458 --> 00:18:32,981 [scoffs] 505 00:18:33,024 --> 00:18:33,982 She was your age, you know. 506 00:18:35,288 --> 00:18:36,767 The girl 507 00:18:36,811 --> 00:18:38,465 who was raped and strangled to death. 508 00:18:39,770 --> 00:18:40,989 And you're ready 509 00:18:41,032 --> 00:18:42,556 to let her killer go free. 510 00:18:44,514 --> 00:18:46,908 Or maybe you are, by convicting an innocent man. 511 00:18:50,346 --> 00:18:54,133 Well, Olivia saw someone talking to Sarah that night. 512 00:18:57,179 --> 00:18:58,746 All right, this is everybody who used a credit card 513 00:18:58,789 --> 00:19:00,356 at the bar that night. 514 00:19:00,400 --> 00:19:03,533 No Tim and no one Olivia would mistake for Tim. 515 00:19:03,577 --> 00:19:04,882 Any company cards? 516 00:19:04,926 --> 00:19:06,884 Uh, yeah. There's a couple. 517 00:19:06,928 --> 00:19:08,190 Any big tabs? 518 00:19:08,234 --> 00:19:09,887 This one's over a grand. 519 00:19:09,931 --> 00:19:11,324 They may have been having a party. 520 00:19:11,367 --> 00:19:13,282 Harry, check the company roster. 521 00:19:13,326 --> 00:19:15,545 See if there's anyone who might've been at that party 522 00:19:15,589 --> 00:19:17,808 who could've been mistaken for Tim Colvin. 523 00:19:22,726 --> 00:19:24,815 Devin Ellis? 524 00:19:24,859 --> 00:19:26,991 You got a minute?What the hell? 525 00:19:27,035 --> 00:19:28,863 Hey, do you remember going to a company party 526 00:19:28,906 --> 00:19:30,517 about eight months ago? 527 00:19:30,560 --> 00:19:32,823 At a bar downtown called The King George. 528 00:19:32,867 --> 00:19:34,608 You recall talking to a blonde girl outside? 529 00:19:37,132 --> 00:19:39,178 Sarah Ross. This is the picture 530 00:19:39,221 --> 00:19:40,353 they showed of her all over the news 531 00:19:40,396 --> 00:19:42,268 when she was murdered later that night. 532 00:19:42,311 --> 00:19:44,008 Why? Who are you? 533 00:19:44,052 --> 00:19:45,184 Friend of the family. 534 00:19:45,227 --> 00:19:46,750 And before you say anything, 535 00:19:46,794 --> 00:19:47,838 I talked to your colleagues, 536 00:19:47,882 --> 00:19:49,797 so I know you were there. 537 00:19:51,233 --> 00:19:54,584 Look, I talked to her, okay? 538 00:19:54,628 --> 00:19:56,238 Frankly, she looked wasted, 539 00:19:56,282 --> 00:19:57,935 so I offered her a glass of water, 540 00:19:57,979 --> 00:20:00,286 but I had nothing to do with her murder. 541 00:20:00,329 --> 00:20:03,202 Ask anyone I work with, they'll tell you. 542 00:20:03,245 --> 00:20:05,247 I was at the party when she was killed. 543 00:20:05,291 --> 00:20:07,206 Sounds like you've given this a lot of thought. 544 00:20:07,249 --> 00:20:09,860 You heard about the murder back then. 545 00:20:09,904 --> 00:20:12,907 You knew this whole case was being built on bad information. 546 00:20:12,950 --> 00:20:15,257 Why wouldn't you come forward when you knew you had an alibi? 547 00:20:15,301 --> 00:20:16,737 You think an alibi means a damn 548 00:20:16,780 --> 00:20:18,347 when they got a dead white woman? 549 00:20:18,391 --> 00:20:20,262 I can easily be the one on trial today. 550 00:20:20,306 --> 00:20:21,524 But you're not. 551 00:20:21,568 --> 00:20:23,047 And at any minute, 552 00:20:23,091 --> 00:20:24,353 an innocent man could be sent to prison 553 00:20:24,397 --> 00:20:26,747 for something he didn't do. 554 00:20:26,790 --> 00:20:28,531 I'm sorry, 555 00:20:28,575 --> 00:20:30,925 but I got a family who needs me. 556 00:20:30,968 --> 00:20:33,232 If you want to help your guy, you got to do it on your own. 557 00:20:33,275 --> 00:20:35,625 [door closes][engine starts] 558 00:20:35,669 --> 00:20:37,410 [tires screech] 559 00:20:44,678 --> 00:20:46,984 D.A. Grafton's agreed to meet with me tomorrow morning. 560 00:20:47,028 --> 00:20:49,117 Maybe she can intercede with the prosecutor. 561 00:20:49,160 --> 00:20:51,902 Well, you did just punch a giant hole in the case. 562 00:20:51,946 --> 00:20:54,296 Yeah, but Devin still won't come forward, 563 00:20:54,340 --> 00:20:56,124 even though his alibi checked out. 564 00:20:56,167 --> 00:20:57,256 Can't say I blame him. 565 00:20:57,299 --> 00:20:58,779 HARRY: And if it wasn't for your aunt, 566 00:20:58,822 --> 00:21:00,259 "not talking to you" about the trial, 567 00:21:00,302 --> 00:21:01,390 we wouldn't even know that. 568 00:21:01,434 --> 00:21:02,826 Does your aunt know how right she was 569 00:21:02,870 --> 00:21:03,566 to fight for this guy? 570 00:21:03,610 --> 00:21:05,829 Not yet. 571 00:21:05,873 --> 00:21:09,485 But Aunt Vi has never needed a reason to do what's right. 572 00:21:09,529 --> 00:21:11,008 What time is it? 573 00:21:12,271 --> 00:21:13,881 7:30. 574 00:21:13,924 --> 00:21:16,100 We're just going nowhere fast. 575 00:21:16,144 --> 00:21:19,278 I say we go home, get some sleep. 576 00:21:19,321 --> 00:21:21,584 Come back at this fresh tomorrow. 577 00:21:21,628 --> 00:21:23,456 You know, some of us have jobs. 578 00:21:25,196 --> 00:21:26,328 Why don't we just tell the judge the truth: 579 00:21:26,372 --> 00:21:28,156 we're deadlocked. 580 00:21:28,199 --> 00:21:30,071 He'll get a new trial, be found guilty, like he should. 581 00:21:30,114 --> 00:21:32,421 You think you can't afford to miss a day's work? 582 00:21:33,727 --> 00:21:35,816 Try paying a defense attorney for a second trial. 583 00:21:35,859 --> 00:21:37,296 SOFIA: You know what? 584 00:21:37,339 --> 00:21:38,819 I think you have too much time on your hands. 585 00:21:38,862 --> 00:21:39,994 You might not want to get back to your husband, 586 00:21:40,037 --> 00:21:41,430 but the rest of us do. 587 00:21:41,474 --> 00:21:42,301 I don't have a husband, sweetheart. 588 00:21:42,344 --> 00:21:43,389 I'm not married. 589 00:21:43,432 --> 00:21:44,912 Yes, you do. You said... 590 00:21:44,955 --> 00:21:46,174 JEANIE: That was me. 591 00:21:46,217 --> 00:21:47,697 The other Black woman. 592 00:21:48,959 --> 00:21:50,744 Really? 593 00:21:51,832 --> 00:21:53,747 No. 594 00:21:53,790 --> 00:21:55,226 We've been together two weeks, and you just... 595 00:21:55,270 --> 00:21:56,837 confused us. 596 00:22:00,057 --> 00:22:02,146 Which is my point. 597 00:22:03,887 --> 00:22:04,932 Isn't it possible 598 00:22:04,975 --> 00:22:07,369 that Sarah's roommate 599 00:22:07,413 --> 00:22:09,458 misidentified Tim? 600 00:22:11,765 --> 00:22:14,637 That she saw a different Black man 601 00:22:14,681 --> 00:22:16,770 talking to Sarah that night? 602 00:22:18,032 --> 00:22:21,992 And isn't it possible that when Tim says 603 00:22:22,036 --> 00:22:25,344 he wasn't at that bar, 604 00:22:25,387 --> 00:22:28,738 that he's actually telling the truth? 605 00:22:32,046 --> 00:22:34,309 [scoffs] Well, there she goes again, playing the race card. 606 00:22:34,353 --> 00:22:36,703 This is about race. 607 00:22:36,746 --> 00:22:40,402 This is a Black man on trial for raping a white woman. 608 00:22:40,446 --> 00:22:43,100 No, this is about a man 609 00:22:43,144 --> 00:22:45,364 who was seen running from a building 610 00:22:45,407 --> 00:22:47,104 where a girl was killed inside. 611 00:22:47,148 --> 00:22:48,802 Now, 612 00:22:48,845 --> 00:22:51,413 we were instructed to be honest, 613 00:22:51,457 --> 00:22:53,720 conscientious and unbiased. 614 00:22:53,763 --> 00:22:56,940 And now you're dragging his race into it. 615 00:22:56,984 --> 00:23:00,944 To be intentionally blind to the historical precedent here 616 00:23:00,988 --> 00:23:03,556 is the most dangerous bias of all. 617 00:23:03,599 --> 00:23:05,296 And what about you? 618 00:23:05,340 --> 00:23:07,429 Isn't it possible 619 00:23:07,473 --> 00:23:10,084 that you have some baggage of your own 620 00:23:10,127 --> 00:23:13,043 that is making you overlook some pretty damning evidence? 621 00:23:13,087 --> 00:23:15,568 And isn't it possible 622 00:23:15,611 --> 00:23:17,308 that this is about you being a Black woman, 623 00:23:17,352 --> 00:23:19,441 trying to protect her own? 624 00:23:19,485 --> 00:23:22,401 And wouldn't it be a shame 625 00:23:22,444 --> 00:23:26,056 if we didn't convict a rapist and a murderer 626 00:23:26,100 --> 00:23:29,146 because your bias got in the way? 627 00:23:33,368 --> 00:23:34,543 [door closes] 628 00:23:34,587 --> 00:23:36,153 That you, Auntie? 629 00:23:36,197 --> 00:23:38,721 Boy, they got you working like crazy down there. 630 00:23:39,940 --> 00:23:42,116 Hey. 631 00:23:42,159 --> 00:23:43,465 Come here. Sit down. 632 00:23:44,858 --> 00:23:46,990 What happened?Nothing yet. 633 00:23:47,034 --> 00:23:48,470 No decision. 634 00:23:48,514 --> 00:23:50,646 Well, at least you got them talking. 635 00:23:50,690 --> 00:23:52,256 Yeah, well... 636 00:23:52,300 --> 00:23:54,389 maybe they shouldn't be. 637 00:23:55,390 --> 00:23:56,652 What do you mean? 638 00:23:56,696 --> 00:23:59,263 What if I'm wrong about this guy? 639 00:23:59,307 --> 00:24:01,614 What if when I look at him, all I see are... 640 00:24:01,657 --> 00:24:04,834 are the Black men behind bars that shouldn't be there? 641 00:24:04,878 --> 00:24:08,708 I don't want to be responsible for setting someone free 642 00:24:08,751 --> 00:24:10,666 who may have raped and killed a woman. 643 00:24:11,928 --> 00:24:13,495 Auntie, you know your initial doubt 644 00:24:13,539 --> 00:24:14,801 about the prosecution's case? 645 00:24:14,844 --> 00:24:16,585 Mm-hmm. 646 00:24:17,847 --> 00:24:19,240 I would stick with it. 647 00:24:21,503 --> 00:24:23,462 Trust your gut. 648 00:24:23,505 --> 00:24:24,637 Robyn? 649 00:24:26,508 --> 00:24:27,988 I'm going to bed. 650 00:24:28,031 --> 00:24:29,816 Love you. 651 00:24:35,561 --> 00:24:36,910 [gasps] 652 00:24:36,953 --> 00:24:38,128 [grunts] 653 00:24:38,738 --> 00:24:40,870 DANTE: Where are my boys?[gunshot] 654 00:24:40,914 --> 00:24:43,046 I'm afraid of who I might become. 655 00:24:43,090 --> 00:24:44,526 [gasps] 656 00:24:47,877 --> 00:24:49,923 ♪ 657 00:25:07,288 --> 00:25:09,333 ♪ 658 00:25:13,599 --> 00:25:15,383 GRAFTON: What you're telling me is concerning 659 00:25:15,426 --> 00:25:16,471 but not actionable. 660 00:25:16,515 --> 00:25:17,907 The defendant was at the building 661 00:25:17,951 --> 00:25:18,865 where and when the murder took place, 662 00:25:18,908 --> 00:25:19,953 by his own admission. 663 00:25:19,996 --> 00:25:21,171 But not at the bar. 664 00:25:21,215 --> 00:25:22,738 The jury is deciding 665 00:25:22,782 --> 00:25:25,828 this man's fate based off a faulty narrative. 666 00:25:25,872 --> 00:25:27,264 I'm sympathetic, 667 00:25:27,308 --> 00:25:28,788 and the narrative might be imperfect, 668 00:25:28,831 --> 00:25:29,702 but there are other aspects of the case 669 00:25:29,745 --> 00:25:31,355 that tie him to the crime. 670 00:25:31,399 --> 00:25:33,444 If he is unfairly convicted, he can appeal. 671 00:25:33,488 --> 00:25:35,969 You're joking, right? 672 00:25:36,012 --> 00:25:38,972 Only thing harder than winning an appeal is being granted one. 673 00:25:40,626 --> 00:25:42,976 Unless you can find exculpatory evidence 674 00:25:43,019 --> 00:25:44,586 that Tim Colvin didn't kill 675 00:25:44,630 --> 00:25:46,545 Sarah Ross, 676 00:25:46,588 --> 00:25:48,068 there's nothing I can do. 677 00:25:50,679 --> 00:25:51,724 I'm sorry. 678 00:25:54,944 --> 00:25:56,555 HARRY: Unreal. 679 00:25:56,598 --> 00:25:58,339 Trials really are about who spins the best story. 680 00:25:58,382 --> 00:26:00,689 How are we supposed to prove Tim didn't do this? 681 00:26:00,733 --> 00:26:02,691 By finding the person who did. 682 00:26:08,610 --> 00:26:10,873 It's hard to imagine having your whole life 683 00:26:10,917 --> 00:26:12,745 ripped out from under you just because you were 684 00:26:12,788 --> 00:26:13,789 in the wrong place at the wrong time. 685 00:26:13,833 --> 00:26:15,182 And we have no way to exonerate him 686 00:26:15,225 --> 00:26:16,618 unless we find the real killer. 687 00:26:16,662 --> 00:26:18,098 With virtually no evidence to go on. 688 00:26:18,141 --> 00:26:19,142 I mean, the only thing we know at this point 689 00:26:19,186 --> 00:26:20,230 is what didn't happen. 690 00:26:20,274 --> 00:26:22,450 There's always a move. 691 00:26:22,493 --> 00:26:24,583 If the bar is not relevant, 692 00:26:24,626 --> 00:26:26,323 then it's all about the building. 693 00:26:26,367 --> 00:26:28,674 Which key witnesses were there? I want to talk to them. 694 00:26:28,717 --> 00:26:30,066 Well, by his own admission, there's Tim. 695 00:26:30,110 --> 00:26:31,328 I tried. 696 00:26:31,372 --> 00:26:33,243 They have him locked down. 697 00:26:33,287 --> 00:26:35,202 What about the witness who saw him running to the cab? 698 00:26:35,245 --> 00:26:36,812 Christian Messina. 699 00:26:36,856 --> 00:26:38,248 Sarah's downstairs neighbor. 700 00:26:38,292 --> 00:26:40,686 Okay. That's our move. 701 00:26:43,210 --> 00:26:44,559 Minute to talk, Kerry? 702 00:26:44,603 --> 00:26:46,866 That depends. 703 00:26:46,909 --> 00:26:49,346 You here to put away another one of my clients? 704 00:26:49,390 --> 00:26:50,957 Just a temperature check. 705 00:26:51,000 --> 00:26:53,002 Tim Colvin. 706 00:26:53,046 --> 00:26:54,787 I know you go to the mat for everyone you represent, 707 00:26:54,830 --> 00:26:56,615 but what's your honest feeling on him? 708 00:26:56,658 --> 00:26:59,313 I think he's innocent. Why? 709 00:26:59,356 --> 00:27:01,141 Been looking into it. 710 00:27:01,184 --> 00:27:04,057 Bit late for police to be auditing casework, isn't it? 711 00:27:05,406 --> 00:27:06,799 I'm not police anymore. 712 00:27:08,496 --> 00:27:10,367 Not after... 713 00:27:10,411 --> 00:27:12,935 The fact that all that still goes on. 714 00:27:14,415 --> 00:27:16,286 But you left? 715 00:27:16,330 --> 00:27:17,853 What was it you said that one time? 716 00:27:17,897 --> 00:27:19,202 If you never saw me in court again, 717 00:27:19,246 --> 00:27:20,421 it would be too soon? 718 00:27:20,464 --> 00:27:22,205 Much as I hate to admit it, 719 00:27:22,249 --> 00:27:24,643 I'd rather bust my ass going up against cases 720 00:27:24,686 --> 00:27:26,383 built by cops like you. 721 00:27:27,820 --> 00:27:29,473 At least it's a fair fight. 722 00:27:29,517 --> 00:27:31,562 Is it ever really fair? 723 00:27:31,606 --> 00:27:32,868 Is anything? 724 00:27:36,655 --> 00:27:38,657 How do you keep doing it? 725 00:27:38,700 --> 00:27:40,397 Knowing how the system can be? 726 00:27:42,443 --> 00:27:44,401 If not me, then who? 727 00:27:44,445 --> 00:27:46,490 ♪ 728 00:27:48,231 --> 00:27:50,494 Can you get me in to see Tim? 729 00:27:50,538 --> 00:27:52,235 I might know someone who can help. 730 00:27:53,802 --> 00:27:55,282 Yeah, let me see what I can do. 731 00:27:57,545 --> 00:27:59,025 CHRISTIAN: Hell of a thing. 732 00:27:59,068 --> 00:28:00,940 You know if I didn't see him get in that cab, 733 00:28:00,983 --> 00:28:03,029 they probably would've never tracked him down. 734 00:28:03,072 --> 00:28:04,857 I hope they throw the book at him. 735 00:28:04,900 --> 00:28:06,989 Sarah's family does, too, Christian. 736 00:28:07,033 --> 00:28:08,295 But if he appeals, 737 00:28:08,338 --> 00:28:09,688 they want to make sure there's nothing 738 00:28:09,731 --> 00:28:11,341 that'll surprise them in the next trial. 739 00:28:11,385 --> 00:28:12,908 Is there anything else 740 00:28:12,952 --> 00:28:14,344 you might have seen or heard that night? 741 00:28:14,388 --> 00:28:16,216 I said it all on the stand. 742 00:28:16,259 --> 00:28:17,739 I was home watching the football game. 743 00:28:17,783 --> 00:28:19,088 I made myself some tea before bed, 744 00:28:19,132 --> 00:28:20,568 and that's when I looked out my window. 745 00:28:20,611 --> 00:28:22,222 From the basement window in the front 746 00:28:22,265 --> 00:28:23,266 that looks out onto the street? 747 00:28:23,310 --> 00:28:24,485 That's right, 748 00:28:24,528 --> 00:28:26,269 and I saw a guy running out. 749 00:28:26,313 --> 00:28:28,619 He got in a cab, and that was at midnight. 750 00:28:28,663 --> 00:28:29,708 [scoffs] 751 00:28:30,970 --> 00:28:32,058 Sorry. 752 00:28:32,101 --> 00:28:33,712 Landlord is a cheapskate. 753 00:28:33,755 --> 00:28:35,148 A year ago, he put all the building lights 754 00:28:35,191 --> 00:28:37,716 on motion sensors with ridiculously short timers. 755 00:28:37,759 --> 00:28:39,805 Anyway, cops ran the cab and caught the guy. 756 00:28:39,848 --> 00:28:41,241 Showed me a photo and it was him. 757 00:28:41,284 --> 00:28:42,764 End of story. 758 00:28:42,808 --> 00:28:44,374 [mailbox door rattles] 759 00:28:49,075 --> 00:28:50,772 SOFIA: How can you accept 760 00:28:50,816 --> 00:28:52,687 that he couldn't remember where he walked that night? 761 00:28:52,731 --> 00:28:55,690 He said he was angry and in his own head. 762 00:28:55,734 --> 00:28:57,736 Hasn't that ever happened to you? 763 00:28:57,779 --> 00:28:59,650 Oh, hell, I remember where I was that night, 764 00:28:59,694 --> 00:29:00,956 and it was eight months ago. 765 00:29:02,088 --> 00:29:03,089 Watching the Giants comeback. 766 00:29:03,132 --> 00:29:04,873 Killer game. 767 00:29:04,917 --> 00:29:06,701 Went into overtime, Giants intercepted?Yep. 768 00:29:06,745 --> 00:29:08,311 I was at the bar late that night. 769 00:29:08,355 --> 00:29:10,183 Giants threw that Hail Mary. 770 00:29:10,226 --> 00:29:12,576 Boom. Tied it all up.SOFIA: Guys. 771 00:29:12,620 --> 00:29:13,708 He's right. 772 00:29:13,752 --> 00:29:15,710 Can we just focus, please? 773 00:29:15,754 --> 00:29:17,581 That Giants game did go to overtime. 774 00:29:18,582 --> 00:29:20,280 Those games, do they air on the same network 775 00:29:20,323 --> 00:29:22,935 as the-the show the neighbor was watching? 776 00:29:22,978 --> 00:29:25,111 Yeah. So, what?So... 777 00:29:25,154 --> 00:29:26,895 the neighbor said she heard the scream 778 00:29:26,939 --> 00:29:30,725 from Sarah's apartment at 11:30. 779 00:29:30,769 --> 00:29:32,640 She knew exactly what time it was 780 00:29:32,683 --> 00:29:34,337 because that's the time that her show normally starts. 781 00:29:34,381 --> 00:29:35,425 What are you getting at? 782 00:29:35,469 --> 00:29:36,949 It didn't start at 11:30. 783 00:29:36,992 --> 00:29:38,864 If the game went into overtime, 784 00:29:38,907 --> 00:29:40,822 then the game 785 00:29:40,866 --> 00:29:43,303 pushed back the start of the show. 786 00:29:44,608 --> 00:29:47,437 Which means the scream could have happened later than 11:30. 787 00:29:47,481 --> 00:29:49,091 JI-YOON: Way later. 788 00:29:49,135 --> 00:29:50,527 That overtime could've easily lasted half an hour 789 00:29:50,571 --> 00:29:51,311 with all the time-outs they called. 790 00:29:51,354 --> 00:29:52,921 VI: Yes. 791 00:29:52,965 --> 00:29:55,968 And Tim was seen running for a cab at midnight, 792 00:29:56,011 --> 00:29:58,361 which means the scream could have happened 793 00:29:58,405 --> 00:30:00,755 when he was already in the cab. 794 00:30:00,799 --> 00:30:02,104 HOWARD:Look. 795 00:30:02,148 --> 00:30:04,585 We are not allowed to look it up. 796 00:30:04,628 --> 00:30:06,848 And if it was shorter than half an hour, 797 00:30:06,892 --> 00:30:08,981 he was still in the building when she screamed. 798 00:30:09,024 --> 00:30:11,200 That's true. 799 00:30:11,244 --> 00:30:13,333 But that would mean 800 00:30:13,376 --> 00:30:15,465 he had to rape and kill Sarah, 801 00:30:15,509 --> 00:30:17,598 clean the apartment of all the evidence, 802 00:30:17,641 --> 00:30:19,252 get downstairs, 803 00:30:19,295 --> 00:30:23,169 hail a cab in mere minutes. 804 00:30:23,212 --> 00:30:24,648 Is it possible that he did it? 805 00:30:25,954 --> 00:30:26,955 Sure. 806 00:30:26,999 --> 00:30:29,131 But is it reasonable 807 00:30:29,175 --> 00:30:31,830 to doubt that he did? 808 00:30:31,873 --> 00:30:33,875 ♪ 809 00:30:44,190 --> 00:30:45,669 It is. 810 00:30:45,713 --> 00:30:47,889 Oh, you got to be kidding me. 811 00:30:47,933 --> 00:30:50,500 I'm changing my vote to "not guilty." 812 00:30:52,067 --> 00:30:54,417 ♪ 813 00:30:54,461 --> 00:30:56,463 Same with me. 814 00:30:56,506 --> 00:30:57,943 Me, too. 815 00:30:57,986 --> 00:30:59,422 I will, too. 816 00:30:59,466 --> 00:31:00,859 And me. 817 00:31:05,254 --> 00:31:07,778 And you're 100% sure 818 00:31:07,822 --> 00:31:09,998 he could've done all of that 819 00:31:10,042 --> 00:31:11,478 in just a few minutes? 820 00:31:16,309 --> 00:31:18,093 ♪ 821 00:31:21,270 --> 00:31:23,011 No. 822 00:31:23,055 --> 00:31:24,404 I'm not. 823 00:31:25,971 --> 00:31:28,321 ALAN: I think we take a break now, 824 00:31:28,364 --> 00:31:31,019 then come back and take another vote, 825 00:31:31,063 --> 00:31:32,978 since it seems like 826 00:31:33,021 --> 00:31:34,980 we're all on the same page now. 827 00:31:37,983 --> 00:31:40,202 [phone rings] 828 00:31:40,246 --> 00:31:42,335 Dante, what's up? 829 00:31:42,378 --> 00:31:43,902 I got you a meeting with Tim Colvin. 830 00:31:43,945 --> 00:31:45,425 What happened to "taking time"? 831 00:31:45,468 --> 00:31:46,513 Don't read into it. 832 00:31:46,556 --> 00:31:47,775 Wouldn't dare. 833 00:31:47,818 --> 00:31:49,516 But I'm glad you did. 834 00:31:49,559 --> 00:31:50,996 I have a few questions for Tim. 835 00:31:51,039 --> 00:31:52,475 What's wrong? 836 00:31:52,519 --> 00:31:54,390 In his testimony, 837 00:31:54,434 --> 00:31:56,349 Tim said Sarah's building looked warm and inviting, 838 00:31:56,392 --> 00:31:58,133 which is why he ducked in, 839 00:31:58,177 --> 00:32:00,919 but the indoor lights are on motion sensors. 840 00:32:00,962 --> 00:32:03,008 So if no one was coming or going, 841 00:32:03,051 --> 00:32:04,705 it would've looked cold and dark, 842 00:32:04,748 --> 00:32:06,750 which means he lied. 843 00:32:06,794 --> 00:32:08,448 Why would he lie about that? 844 00:32:08,491 --> 00:32:10,319 Maybe because someone was there. 845 00:32:10,363 --> 00:32:11,973 Maybe because he actually did 846 00:32:12,017 --> 00:32:13,975 follow Sarah into the building. 847 00:32:14,019 --> 00:32:16,238 Maybe he's not innocent at all. 848 00:32:22,375 --> 00:32:24,681 What was I supposed to do? 849 00:32:24,725 --> 00:32:25,769 Tell the truth? 850 00:32:25,813 --> 00:32:28,816 The cops had me at the scene. 851 00:32:28,859 --> 00:32:30,687 I didn't even tell my attorney. 852 00:32:30,731 --> 00:32:32,472 Well, since we're not cops, 853 00:32:32,515 --> 00:32:34,474 why don't you tell us what really happened. 854 00:32:36,302 --> 00:32:38,695 Sarah did let me into the building that night. 855 00:32:38,739 --> 00:32:41,089 She was drunk and heading in. 856 00:32:41,133 --> 00:32:44,179 And it looked warm, so I followed her in. 857 00:32:44,223 --> 00:32:47,008 And I asked if she was okay, and she said she was fine, 858 00:32:47,052 --> 00:32:48,705 and then she headed up the stairs. 859 00:32:48,749 --> 00:32:49,880 You know how that sounds. 860 00:32:49,924 --> 00:32:51,404 Of course I do. 861 00:32:52,709 --> 00:32:54,407 But I didn't kill her. 862 00:32:54,450 --> 00:32:56,757 You know what they were arresting me for. 863 00:32:56,800 --> 00:32:59,325 If I had admitted that she let me in that night, 864 00:32:59,368 --> 00:33:01,022 I would've been digging my own grave. 865 00:33:01,066 --> 00:33:03,111 What happened after she let you in? 866 00:33:03,155 --> 00:33:05,853 She went on her way, 867 00:33:05,896 --> 00:33:07,376 and I stayed in the vestibule, 868 00:33:07,420 --> 00:33:09,335 warming up until I caught the cab. 869 00:33:09,378 --> 00:33:11,815 I know I shouldn't have lied, 870 00:33:11,859 --> 00:33:13,992 but I'm not the only one. 871 00:33:15,471 --> 00:33:18,518 I heard the prosecution's narrative in the court. 872 00:33:21,129 --> 00:33:23,001 You know what they're doing. 873 00:33:23,044 --> 00:33:24,350 I do know. 874 00:33:24,393 --> 00:33:26,004 I keep thinking, 875 00:33:26,047 --> 00:33:28,093 if I hadn't fought with Morgan that night, 876 00:33:28,136 --> 00:33:31,052 hadn't gone in that building, 877 00:33:31,096 --> 00:33:33,011 hadn't tripped on that trash and cut my hand 878 00:33:33,054 --> 00:33:34,447 while running to catch the cab, 879 00:33:34,490 --> 00:33:36,362 maybe I wouldn't be here right now. 880 00:33:36,405 --> 00:33:39,582 Wait, what'd you say you tripped over? 881 00:33:39,626 --> 00:33:41,976 Garbage day is Tuesday. So what? 882 00:33:43,325 --> 00:33:46,154 So they would've put the bags out on the street on Monday. 883 00:33:46,198 --> 00:33:48,461 Same night Sarah was murdered. 884 00:33:48,504 --> 00:33:50,724 Harry, can you find me photos from Sarah's street 885 00:33:50,767 --> 00:33:52,639 from last Monday night?Yeah, they just put a new street cam up 886 00:33:52,682 --> 00:33:53,988 a couple months ago. 887 00:33:54,032 --> 00:33:56,121 Here we go. 888 00:33:56,164 --> 00:33:57,600 So, this is what it would have looked like 889 00:33:57,644 --> 00:33:59,037 the night Tim ran for the cab. 890 00:33:59,080 --> 00:34:00,864 What are we looking for?That. 891 00:34:00,908 --> 00:34:03,171 Christian's window. You see it? 892 00:34:03,215 --> 00:34:05,173 The garbage is blocking the view. 893 00:34:05,217 --> 00:34:06,566 So Christian wouldn't have been able 894 00:34:06,609 --> 00:34:09,003 to see Tim run for the cab. 895 00:34:09,047 --> 00:34:10,613 But Christian did see Tim. 896 00:34:10,657 --> 00:34:12,659 ID'ing the cab was how the cops found him. 897 00:34:12,702 --> 00:34:15,096 Well, why would Christian lie about where he saw him from? 898 00:34:16,271 --> 00:34:18,230 Harry, run a background check on Christian. 899 00:34:18,273 --> 00:34:19,666 And hurry up. 900 00:34:19,709 --> 00:34:21,668 Aunt Vi's running out of time.[typing] 901 00:34:24,062 --> 00:34:27,456 Seems like we're all in agreement. 902 00:34:27,500 --> 00:34:28,849 So... 903 00:34:28,892 --> 00:34:30,285 all voting to acquit? 904 00:34:32,896 --> 00:34:34,507 Oh, please. 905 00:34:34,550 --> 00:34:36,422 No. 906 00:34:36,465 --> 00:34:38,250 You're still voting "guilty"? 907 00:34:38,293 --> 00:34:40,730 But we just blew holes through every piece of evidence. 908 00:34:40,774 --> 00:34:42,645 You can twist the evidence any way you want. 909 00:34:42,689 --> 00:34:43,907 To me, it is what it is. 910 00:34:43,951 --> 00:34:46,432 But we can't be sure it is. 911 00:34:46,475 --> 00:34:48,869 Yeah. No one's saying they're sure he's innocent, 912 00:34:48,912 --> 00:34:50,088 but it's reasonable to think 913 00:34:50,131 --> 00:34:51,915 he might not have done it.Thanks. 914 00:34:51,959 --> 00:34:54,048 I do understand the concept of "reasonable doubt." 915 00:34:54,092 --> 00:34:55,832 Look, why don't we go over it again. 916 00:34:55,876 --> 00:34:57,486 Maybe if we just...No. 917 00:34:58,705 --> 00:35:00,141 I don't need to go over it again. 918 00:35:00,185 --> 00:35:02,622 I don't need it to be explained to me. 919 00:35:02,665 --> 00:35:05,799 I know guys like this, and I see him for who he is. 920 00:35:05,842 --> 00:35:07,757 [door opens] 921 00:35:07,801 --> 00:35:09,542 COURT OFFICER:Jurors. 922 00:35:09,585 --> 00:35:11,631 The judge is asking if you're approaching a decision. 923 00:35:11,674 --> 00:35:13,502 Uh... 924 00:35:13,546 --> 00:35:15,287 Could we just have another minute? 925 00:35:19,726 --> 00:35:21,249 [door closes] 926 00:35:25,558 --> 00:35:27,777 You said you see him for who he is. 927 00:35:28,996 --> 00:35:30,084 Who is that? 928 00:35:30,128 --> 00:35:33,043 Someone who hurt you? 929 00:35:33,087 --> 00:35:34,871 Someone who lied to you, someone 930 00:35:34,915 --> 00:35:36,917 Who broke your trust? 931 00:35:36,960 --> 00:35:38,136 That person isn't Tim. 932 00:35:40,268 --> 00:35:41,791 He's not your ex. 933 00:35:41,835 --> 00:35:43,097 You don't know what you're talking about. 934 00:35:43,141 --> 00:35:44,794 And you won't change my mind. 935 00:35:44,838 --> 00:35:46,187 I'm not gonna try. 936 00:35:46,231 --> 00:35:49,495 All I've ever asked of anyone here is 937 00:35:49,538 --> 00:35:53,063 to scrutinize the evidence with care, 938 00:35:53,107 --> 00:35:55,327 and then vote your conscience. 939 00:35:55,370 --> 00:35:58,112 So... 940 00:35:58,156 --> 00:36:01,333 if you truly think that Tim is guilty, 941 00:36:01,376 --> 00:36:04,727 then you should stand in that truth 942 00:36:04,771 --> 00:36:06,294 and vote that way. 943 00:36:10,820 --> 00:36:12,605 HARRY: All right, so Christian looks clean, right? 944 00:36:12,648 --> 00:36:14,346 But you dig a little deeper, you're gonna discover 945 00:36:14,389 --> 00:36:15,912 that he was part of a fraternity ten years ago 946 00:36:15,956 --> 00:36:17,827 that dissolved after rape allegations surfaced. 947 00:36:17,871 --> 00:36:19,394 NDAs?Yeah. Exactly. 948 00:36:19,438 --> 00:36:20,700 No suspects were ever named. 949 00:36:20,743 --> 00:36:22,136 Then a few years ago, 950 00:36:22,180 --> 00:36:23,790 he was living in an apartment building 951 00:36:23,833 --> 00:36:24,834 where a woman was attacked and killed in the stairwell. 952 00:36:24,878 --> 00:36:26,662 Case went unsolved. 953 00:36:26,706 --> 00:36:29,230 Okay, so we know Christian saw Tim get in the cab, 954 00:36:29,274 --> 00:36:31,232 but he wasn't in his apartment. 955 00:36:31,276 --> 00:36:33,930 And he wasn't in the foyer, because Tim would've seen him. 956 00:36:33,974 --> 00:36:35,280 But there's one other place he could've been. 957 00:36:35,323 --> 00:36:37,064 Oh, God.Harry. 958 00:36:38,761 --> 00:36:41,155 [sighs] 959 00:36:41,199 --> 00:36:42,330 HARRY: There's a clear line of sight 960 00:36:42,374 --> 00:36:43,592 from Sarah's apartment to the street. 961 00:36:43,636 --> 00:36:45,551 That's why Christian lied. 962 00:36:45,594 --> 00:36:47,379 He should be the one on trial. 963 00:36:47,422 --> 00:36:48,771 Speaking of which, they're calling the jury 964 00:36:48,815 --> 00:36:50,382 back in, looks like they have a verdict. 965 00:36:50,425 --> 00:36:52,210 [sighs] 966 00:36:54,603 --> 00:36:56,344 I know that look. 967 00:36:56,388 --> 00:36:58,433 I got a real suspect. 968 00:36:58,477 --> 00:37:01,610 He looks good for it but nothing concrete. 969 00:37:01,654 --> 00:37:05,527 So, I guess it's all in the hands of the jury. 970 00:37:09,836 --> 00:37:11,098 [door closes] 971 00:37:12,273 --> 00:37:15,189 ♪ 972 00:37:18,671 --> 00:37:20,629 [baby fussing] 973 00:37:20,673 --> 00:37:22,544 JUDGE: Ladies and gentlemen, 974 00:37:22,588 --> 00:37:23,893 welcome back. Mr. Desoto, 975 00:37:23,937 --> 00:37:26,853 you are the jury foreperson, correct? 976 00:37:26,896 --> 00:37:28,768 Yes, Your Honor. 977 00:37:28,811 --> 00:37:30,117 I understand you've been unable 978 00:37:30,160 --> 00:37:31,814 to reach a verdict on either charge. 979 00:37:31,858 --> 00:37:33,251 Is that the case? 980 00:37:33,294 --> 00:37:34,774 At least it's not "guilty." 981 00:37:34,817 --> 00:37:36,210 Yeah, but if the next jury is not willing 982 00:37:36,254 --> 00:37:37,603 to ask the hard questions, 983 00:37:37,646 --> 00:37:39,344 odds are, 984 00:37:39,387 --> 00:37:41,302 he'll be convicted. 985 00:37:41,346 --> 00:37:42,695 JUDGE: Mr. Desoto, if I were to return you 986 00:37:42,738 --> 00:37:45,306 to the jury room, do you think 987 00:37:45,350 --> 00:37:46,655 you could make progress towards a verdict? 988 00:37:51,878 --> 00:37:53,619 No, Your Honor. 989 00:37:53,662 --> 00:37:56,317 I want to remind you all of your duty to this court. 990 00:37:56,361 --> 00:37:58,624 And that is, for you all to decide 991 00:37:58,667 --> 00:38:00,495 the case for yourself. 992 00:38:01,757 --> 00:38:04,020 Now, with that said, your jury foreperson 993 00:38:04,064 --> 00:38:07,110 has stated that you've done all you can to reach a verdict. 994 00:38:07,154 --> 00:38:10,679 If any of you disagree with that, 995 00:38:10,723 --> 00:38:12,377 you'd better tell me now. 996 00:38:14,335 --> 00:38:16,424 ♪ 997 00:38:25,999 --> 00:38:27,348 In that case... 998 00:38:27,392 --> 00:38:28,523 Wait. 999 00:38:32,135 --> 00:38:33,267 I want to change my vote. 1000 00:38:38,141 --> 00:38:39,534 Mr. Desoto, it appears 1001 00:38:39,578 --> 00:38:41,231 to me that from your correspondence 1002 00:38:41,275 --> 00:38:43,103 on behalf of all the jurors 1003 00:38:43,146 --> 00:38:44,670 that this makes the jury's verdict 1004 00:38:44,713 --> 00:38:46,846 on both charges unanimous. 1005 00:38:46,889 --> 00:38:48,326 Uh... 1006 00:38:48,369 --> 00:38:49,501 Yes, Your Honor. 1007 00:38:50,893 --> 00:38:52,286 And what is that verdict? 1008 00:38:53,722 --> 00:38:54,723 Not guilty. 1009 00:38:54,767 --> 00:38:56,551 JUDGE: In that case, 1010 00:38:56,595 --> 00:38:57,683 ladies and gentlemen of the jury, 1011 00:38:57,726 --> 00:38:59,467 this case has now concluded, 1012 00:38:59,511 --> 00:39:00,555 and the court wishes to express its appreciation 1013 00:39:00,599 --> 00:39:02,296 to you for your services. 1014 00:39:04,254 --> 00:39:06,779 Mr. Colvin, you are free to go. 1015 00:39:09,608 --> 00:39:10,696 BAILIFF: All rise. 1016 00:39:15,440 --> 00:39:17,572 ♪ 1017 00:39:25,363 --> 00:39:27,016 [baby cooing][chuckles] 1018 00:39:32,195 --> 00:39:33,762 Thanks for the assist today. 1019 00:39:33,806 --> 00:39:36,156 And for what it's worth, 1020 00:39:36,199 --> 00:39:38,245 I think you'd make a great lawyer. 1021 00:39:39,899 --> 00:39:41,204 Hmm. 1022 00:39:49,038 --> 00:39:50,344 Congratulations. 1023 00:39:50,388 --> 00:39:52,999 Jury got it right this time. 1024 00:39:53,042 --> 00:39:55,131 Which means there's a guilty man walking around out there. 1025 00:39:55,175 --> 00:39:58,134 And there will continue to be. 1026 00:39:58,178 --> 00:40:00,528 They think they got it right. The A.D.A., the NYPD-- 1027 00:40:00,572 --> 00:40:02,269 they think Tim got 1028 00:40:02,312 --> 00:40:05,446 a get-out-of-jail-free card today. 1029 00:40:05,490 --> 00:40:07,100 Which means this case will never be reinvestigated, 1030 00:40:07,143 --> 00:40:08,406 and Sarah's family 1031 00:40:08,449 --> 00:40:10,538 will never get any kind of closure. 1032 00:40:14,847 --> 00:40:16,414 [speaking quietly] 1033 00:40:16,457 --> 00:40:18,590 ♪ 1034 00:40:32,386 --> 00:40:33,431 DELILAH: Mom? 1035 00:40:33,474 --> 00:40:34,606 Hey, Dad's almost here. 1036 00:40:34,649 --> 00:40:35,650 I'm gonna wait for him outside. 1037 00:40:35,694 --> 00:40:37,304 Okay. Hey, hold up a second. 1038 00:40:39,872 --> 00:40:41,917 [sighs] 1039 00:40:41,961 --> 00:40:44,180 I want to apologize for putting you in a position 1040 00:40:44,224 --> 00:40:45,747 to have to lie to your father. 1041 00:40:45,791 --> 00:40:48,271 Mom, I told you. It is not a big deal. 1042 00:40:48,315 --> 00:40:50,012 It is a big deal. 1043 00:40:50,056 --> 00:40:52,493 It's true that lies can be necessary 1044 00:40:52,537 --> 00:40:54,060 to protect your family, 1045 00:40:54,103 --> 00:40:56,671 but they can backfire on you. 1046 00:40:56,715 --> 00:40:58,107 They can hurt you and those around you 1047 00:40:58,151 --> 00:41:00,022 in ways you never anticipate. 1048 00:41:00,066 --> 00:41:02,111 Lying is dangerous, 1049 00:41:02,155 --> 00:41:03,896 and I just want you to realize that. 1050 00:41:08,335 --> 00:41:10,250 Well, 1051 00:41:10,293 --> 00:41:11,904 feels more dangerous not to. 1052 00:41:11,947 --> 00:41:13,819 But... 1053 00:41:13,862 --> 00:41:15,690 I understand. 1054 00:41:15,734 --> 00:41:17,344 I do. 1055 00:41:22,436 --> 00:41:23,698 Hey, you know how 1056 00:41:23,742 --> 00:41:25,483 Dad asked me if I felt safe here? 1057 00:41:27,093 --> 00:41:29,487 I didn't have to lie about that. 1058 00:41:35,144 --> 00:41:37,277 Mm. 1059 00:41:40,585 --> 00:41:42,369 Hey, Auntie! 1060 00:41:42,412 --> 00:41:43,849 How'd deliberations go? 1061 00:41:43,892 --> 00:41:46,286 They ended. Not guilty. 1062 00:41:46,329 --> 00:41:49,245 Ah!Yeah. Thank goodness. 1063 00:41:49,289 --> 00:41:50,508 Wait, so you're back? That's great. 1064 00:41:50,551 --> 00:41:52,031 [chuckles] 1065 00:41:52,074 --> 00:41:53,815 Yeah, 'cause, you know, we missed you. 1066 00:41:53,859 --> 00:41:56,122 Yeah? 1067 00:41:56,165 --> 00:41:58,559 I heard you got mighty familiar with the laundry room, 1068 00:41:58,603 --> 00:42:00,648 so I think I'll just leave the ironing 1069 00:42:00,692 --> 00:42:02,563 for you until you get back from your dad's. 1070 00:42:02,607 --> 00:42:04,826 Yeah, no, I'm good, but I love you. 1071 00:42:04,870 --> 00:42:05,871 [laughter] 1072 00:42:05,914 --> 00:42:07,481 I love you, baby, have fun. 1073 00:42:07,525 --> 00:42:08,743 I love you, Aunt Vi.I love you more. 1074 00:42:08,787 --> 00:42:11,093 Bye. [chuckles] 1075 00:42:14,880 --> 00:42:16,838 Well, I can't say that I was surprised 1076 00:42:16,882 --> 00:42:18,710 to see you in the courtroom today. 1077 00:42:18,753 --> 00:42:21,190 I may have followed the case, 1078 00:42:21,234 --> 00:42:23,149 but that young man 1079 00:42:23,192 --> 00:42:25,064 owes his freedom to you. 1080 00:42:26,065 --> 00:42:27,545 Well... 1081 00:42:28,720 --> 00:42:30,373 I just did what was required of me. 1082 00:42:30,417 --> 00:42:32,288 ♪ I see all the light 1083 00:42:32,332 --> 00:42:34,726 ♪ That lifts us 1084 00:42:34,769 --> 00:42:38,077 Now, see, that's what the world needs more of: 1085 00:42:38,120 --> 00:42:40,209 that. 1086 00:42:40,253 --> 00:42:43,256 People willing to take the time and the trouble 1087 00:42:43,299 --> 00:42:45,432 to find the truth. 1088 00:42:46,912 --> 00:42:48,696 ♪ 1089 00:42:51,003 --> 00:42:53,005 DANTE: Got a minute? 1090 00:42:53,048 --> 00:42:55,007 Detective Dante. 1091 00:42:55,050 --> 00:42:56,661 NYPD. 1092 00:42:56,704 --> 00:42:58,401 I have a few questions for you. 1093 00:42:58,445 --> 00:43:00,752 ♪ We'll all be, we'll all be 1094 00:43:00,795 --> 00:43:02,797 ♪ We'll all be all right. 1095 00:43:09,630 --> 00:43:12,328 Captioning sponsored by CBS 1096 00:43:15,636 --> 00:43:19,422 Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org