1 00:00:08,285 --> 00:00:09,785 [bell chimes] 2 00:00:13,657 --> 00:00:19,361 Little Compton is a small and quaint beach town very close to Newport. 3 00:00:21,598 --> 00:00:27,269 Angela Spence-Shaw works in a garden shop in Little Compton, 4 00:00:27,271 --> 00:00:30,372 but she doesn't come to work this particular day, 5 00:00:31,008 --> 00:00:32,540 and that's concerning. 6 00:00:34,645 --> 00:00:39,081 She's 66 years old and in apparently reasonabl good health. 7 00:00:39,149 --> 00:00:41,983 So her co-worker is dispatched to her home.. 8 00:00:42,486 --> 00:00:43,552 Angela. 9 00:00:43,554 --> 00:00:45,787 ...to make sure everything is all right. 10 00:00:48,992 --> 00:00:50,659 Angela, are you home? 11 00:00:55,966 --> 00:00:57,698 [door squeaks] 12 00:01:01,171 --> 00:01:04,539 [Joe Kenda] The co-worker tries the door, finds it to be unlocked. 13 00:01:04,541 --> 00:01:05,974 [woman] Angela. 14 00:01:07,845 --> 00:01:10,145 [Kenda] Nothing's out of place. Everything looks fine. 15 00:01:10,848 --> 00:01:11,847 But there's no Angela. 16 00:01:16,353 --> 00:01:17,652 [woman] Angela, are you up here? 17 00:01:19,356 --> 00:01:21,389 She pushes open the bathroom door. 18 00:01:23,260 --> 00:01:25,861 [screams] No! No! 19 00:01:26,563 --> 00:01:28,463 No! 20 00:01:28,465 --> 00:01:32,501 Angela's Spence-Shaw is submerged in a bathtub filled with water. 21 00:01:32,536 --> 00:01:34,335 [woman screams] No! 22 00:01:34,337 --> 00:01:38,573 [Kenda] And her co-worker has found Angela under questionable condition 23 00:01:39,676 --> 00:01:42,277 Is this a homicide? Is this an accident? 24 00:01:42,379 --> 00:01:43,345 What is this? 25 00:01:43,347 --> 00:01:45,447 Well, that's the $64 question. 26 00:01:50,687 --> 00:01:53,188 I spent my career closing murder cases. 27 00:01:55,159 --> 00:01:58,059 But I'm not the only one who answered the call. 28 00:02:00,364 --> 00:02:03,565 It takes a rare breed to solve the unsolvable, 29 00:02:04,768 --> 00:02:06,368 to catch a ruthless killer, 30 00:02:07,404 --> 00:02:09,704 to find justice for the dead 31 00:02:11,475 --> 00:02:16,244 That's what it takes to be an American Detectiv. 32 00:02:19,850 --> 00:02:21,550 -[man] All right. Sit down here. -[Stephen Lynch] Yep. 33 00:02:25,689 --> 00:02:27,355 My name is Stephen Lynch. 34 00:02:27,357 --> 00:02:30,091 I was with the State Police for 23 years. 35 00:02:30,193 --> 00:02:32,360 At the time of this investigation, 36 00:02:32,362 --> 00:02:33,995 um, I was a lieutenant, 37 00:02:33,997 --> 00:02:38,099 assigned as the officer in charge of the State Police Major Crimes Unit, 38 00:02:38,201 --> 00:02:40,001 as well as the Violent Fugitive Unit. 39 00:02:41,271 --> 00:02:45,874 You do absolutely see peopl at their worst, unfortunatel 40 00:02:45,876 --> 00:02:47,542 but incredibly rewarding, 41 00:02:47,544 --> 00:02:52,080 and the time in those units went by incredibly fast. 42 00:02:54,751 --> 00:02:56,084 Back in 1999, 43 00:02:56,186 --> 00:02:57,452 it was a holiday weekend. 44 00:02:58,255 --> 00:02:59,554 Are you ready for your game today? 45 00:02:59,556 --> 00:03:02,657 And my son at the time was 12 years old. 46 00:03:02,659 --> 00:03:03,758 -[pager beeping] -Oh, hold on. 47 00:03:03,760 --> 00:03:05,860 And I was at his Little League baseball game 48 00:03:05,862 --> 00:03:10,799 and got the call as to what was starting to evolve down in Little Compton. 49 00:03:10,900 --> 00:03:12,601 Oh, shoot. 50 00:03:12,669 --> 00:03:13,802 I gotta go, sweetheart. 51 00:03:13,870 --> 00:03:15,604 As head of the Major Crimes Unit, 52 00:03:15,705 --> 00:03:17,105 when you get the call, you go. 53 00:03:17,107 --> 00:03:19,374 -Go get them, buddy. -[boy] Bye, dad. 54 00:03:21,278 --> 00:03:23,144 [siren wailing] 55 00:03:23,146 --> 00:03:26,348 When we got there, we gathered our personnel 56 00:03:26,350 --> 00:03:30,385 and started to make our list, if you will, 57 00:03:30,487 --> 00:03:34,256 of how we were going to attack this case. 58 00:03:34,258 --> 00:03:37,392 Stephen Lynch is the commander of the Major Case Squad 59 00:03:37,461 --> 00:03:39,160 at the Rhode Island State Police. 60 00:03:39,162 --> 00:03:41,796 He is the quarterback of the team. 61 00:03:41,865 --> 00:03:44,099 He is in command of a group of detectives, 62 00:03:44,101 --> 00:03:47,168 and they descend on the village of Little Compton 63 00:03:47,170 --> 00:03:49,070 to determine the nature of this case. 64 00:03:50,807 --> 00:03:52,374 -[Lynch] Detective. -[Sid Wordell] Lieutenant. 65 00:03:53,043 --> 00:03:54,276 Sorry to ruin your weekend. 66 00:03:54,377 --> 00:03:56,878 There is a detective on this police department, 67 00:03:56,947 --> 00:03:59,147 only one, who's name is Sid Wordell. 68 00:03:59,149 --> 00:04:00,348 Come on in. 69 00:04:01,351 --> 00:04:03,451 [Wordell] I was a patrol officer, 70 00:04:03,453 --> 00:04:04,886 a working detective 71 00:04:04,955 --> 00:04:07,355 for the town of Little Compton, Rhode island. 72 00:04:07,357 --> 00:04:11,259 In 1999, the Little Compton Police Department consisted of nine officers. 73 00:04:11,261 --> 00:04:16,631 This was certainly beyond our capabilities as an agenc 74 00:04:16,633 --> 00:04:21,236 There hasn't been a homicide in Little Compton since the 1960s. 75 00:04:21,238 --> 00:04:25,707 There's probably no one on the police department that's ever seen a homicide, 76 00:04:25,775 --> 00:04:29,611 so they wanna get involved with the Rhode Island State Police. 77 00:04:29,613 --> 00:04:32,380 [Wordell] We did a walkthrou of the scene, 78 00:04:32,449 --> 00:04:37,352 uh, certainly taking note at that time that the house had been under construction, 79 00:04:37,354 --> 00:04:40,755 and the victim was on the second floor of her residence. 80 00:04:41,858 --> 00:04:43,692 What do we know so far? 81 00:04:43,793 --> 00:04:45,493 [Wordell] The body was found in the bathtub. 82 00:04:45,562 --> 00:04:47,195 But first, take a look in here. 83 00:04:53,637 --> 00:04:58,573 What I recall was the tremendous amount of blood evidence in the bedroom. 84 00:05:00,344 --> 00:05:02,277 [Wordell] Some of the thing that are going through your mind 85 00:05:02,346 --> 00:05:04,079 you know, "Was this something accidental? 86 00:05:04,081 --> 00:05:07,549 Did she fall, uh, and cause injury to herself, 87 00:05:07,551 --> 00:05:08,750 and then ends up in the tub? 88 00:05:10,387 --> 00:05:12,253 [Lynch] So, what are we thinking? Head injury? 89 00:05:13,256 --> 00:05:15,090 Most likely, but check this out. 90 00:05:16,460 --> 00:05:19,160 One thing that really jumped out to me 91 00:05:19,162 --> 00:05:22,731 was the bed linens were gone 92 00:05:22,733 --> 00:05:25,467 [Wordell] It was quite clear uh, to me at that point, 93 00:05:25,469 --> 00:05:27,602 that something had gone wrong here 94 00:05:27,670 --> 00:05:30,105 and it wasn't by her own hand. 95 00:05:30,107 --> 00:05:33,208 [Kenda] So, the action takes place in the bedroom. 96 00:05:33,276 --> 00:05:36,544 The result takes place in the bathtub. 97 00:05:36,546 --> 00:05:39,114 [Wordell] We don't know anything about this lady at this point, 98 00:05:39,116 --> 00:05:41,182 so we don't know when this happened, 99 00:05:41,284 --> 00:05:43,685 how long she had been in the bathtub. 100 00:05:43,754 --> 00:05:46,788 Did she come home and find somebody breaking into her house? 101 00:05:48,291 --> 00:05:50,291 Take a look at this. 102 00:05:50,393 --> 00:05:53,094 [Wordell] There was a lot of things in that house that were of value. 103 00:05:53,096 --> 00:05:54,796 Yeah, it doesn't seem like a robbery. 104 00:05:54,898 --> 00:05:56,765 [Nicholas] There was no thef 105 00:05:56,767 --> 00:06:01,970 Uh, there was $500 left in her wallet in her bedroom. 106 00:06:01,972 --> 00:06:04,239 All her jewelry was still there. 107 00:06:04,241 --> 00:06:06,641 There was no obvious motive here. 108 00:06:06,643 --> 00:06:07,742 What do we got in here? 109 00:06:08,779 --> 00:06:11,045 [Wordell] Upon going through the scene, 110 00:06:11,047 --> 00:06:14,048 the victim had been removed from the bathtub. 111 00:06:15,552 --> 00:06:19,053 [Lynch] This scene was very unique. 112 00:06:19,055 --> 00:06:21,089 The fact that where she was found within a bathtub, 113 00:06:22,392 --> 00:06:27,362 the hair dryer in the tub of water with her body. 114 00:06:28,665 --> 00:06:32,534 So I think some natural instinct is that this was accidental. 115 00:06:32,536 --> 00:06:35,303 You know, is... Is someone being electrocuted? 116 00:06:35,372 --> 00:06:38,873 Whoa! Definitely not an accident. 117 00:06:38,875 --> 00:06:43,645 It was abundantly clear that she had sustained tremendous blunt force trauma, 118 00:06:44,448 --> 00:06:48,049 that what happened to her 119 00:06:48,051 --> 00:06:51,853 was nothing you would ever want anyone to have to go through. 120 00:06:51,855 --> 00:06:56,090 [Nicholas] This was a viciou brutal crime. 121 00:06:56,192 --> 00:07:01,095 The injuries on the victim made her unrecognizable. 122 00:07:01,164 --> 00:07:04,265 One of her friends that worked on the rescue service, 123 00:07:04,267 --> 00:07:08,069 she told us, "I can't even tell you if that's her." 124 00:07:08,071 --> 00:07:10,672 That's how brutal the injuries were. 125 00:07:12,209 --> 00:07:14,976 [Kenda] You kill someone. You put them in a bathtub. 126 00:07:15,579 --> 00:07:17,545 And you throw in a dryer, 127 00:07:17,547 --> 00:07:21,316 hoping the police believe accidental electrocution. 128 00:07:21,318 --> 00:07:23,685 What sort of pig did this? 129 00:07:26,189 --> 00:07:28,456 Lieutenant, the victim's sons are waiting outside. 130 00:07:36,099 --> 00:07:37,665 [Lynch] Speaking with the family, 131 00:07:39,669 --> 00:07:42,203 you have to weigh what you're able to disclos 132 00:07:42,239 --> 00:07:44,372 at that point in the investigation, 133 00:07:44,374 --> 00:07:46,975 with the understanding that these are two sons 134 00:07:46,977 --> 00:07:50,845 looking for answers as to what happened to their mom. 135 00:07:50,847 --> 00:07:53,181 Would you mind telling me a little bit about your mother? 136 00:07:53,249 --> 00:07:54,582 [young man] She was a wonderful person. 137 00:07:54,584 --> 00:07:58,186 We wanted to know what was going on in her life at the time 138 00:07:58,255 --> 00:07:59,754 as far as relationships. 139 00:07:59,756 --> 00:08:04,459 We needed to get as much background on the victim as possible. 140 00:08:04,461 --> 00:08:08,496 Lynch is informed that the victim is Angela Spence-Shaw, 141 00:08:09,799 --> 00:08:12,500 an immigrant from Great Britain 142 00:08:12,569 --> 00:08:16,004 who came with her then husband, to live in the United States 143 00:08:16,873 --> 00:08:18,907 Her first husband passed awa 144 00:08:18,942 --> 00:08:20,775 She remarried. 145 00:08:20,844 --> 00:08:23,244 And her second husband also passed away. 146 00:08:23,246 --> 00:08:27,682 So she came to live in the village of Little Compton as a widow 147 00:08:28,652 --> 00:08:30,351 and to work in a garden shop 148 00:08:32,088 --> 00:08:36,558 She was a nice woman within that community who gave of herself, 149 00:08:36,560 --> 00:08:38,793 working at a greenhouse, 150 00:08:38,862 --> 00:08:43,932 that she had a kind of a lo profile lifestyle there in Little Compton. 151 00:08:43,934 --> 00:08:46,467 [young man] It just doesn't make any sense. 152 00:08:46,469 --> 00:08:49,404 [Nicholas] She was extremel close with her children. 153 00:08:49,505 --> 00:08:52,907 She was just a beloved mother and grandmother. 154 00:08:52,976 --> 00:08:55,243 I have no idea who would do this to her. 155 00:08:55,245 --> 00:08:59,080 She has no habits that would produce danger in her world. 156 00:08:59,149 --> 00:09:02,183 So the question becomes obvious in everyone's mind. 157 00:09:02,285 --> 00:09:05,553 How did Angela come to be in this bathtub? 158 00:09:07,190 --> 00:09:09,490 We're gonna find out whoever did this to your mother. 159 00:09:10,160 --> 00:09:11,459 I can promise you that. 160 00:09:11,461 --> 00:09:14,662 I felt a responsibility to get this solved. 161 00:09:14,664 --> 00:09:19,901 I think that family deserved and Angela Spence-Shaw deserved answers. 162 00:09:21,905 --> 00:09:23,371 [phone ringing] 163 00:09:25,041 --> 00:09:26,240 Hey guys, check this out. 164 00:09:26,242 --> 00:09:27,742 We got a few early findings. 165 00:09:29,079 --> 00:09:33,147 We were getting results back from the medical examiner's office 166 00:09:33,149 --> 00:09:37,652 that alerted us to the fact that she was raped 167 00:09:37,654 --> 00:09:39,754 and that semen was found within her body. 168 00:09:41,491 --> 00:09:45,693 That adds a whole 'nother element into the investigation. 169 00:09:48,865 --> 00:09:51,699 The fact that there was sexual assault that came into play, 170 00:09:51,801 --> 00:09:55,570 that certainly made us then begin concentrating 171 00:09:55,572 --> 00:09:59,507 on anybody that would have been a sexual offender in the area. 172 00:10:00,443 --> 00:10:02,143 [Lynch] This could be our guy. 173 00:10:02,145 --> 00:10:04,545 [Kenda] Any they remarkably find one, 174 00:10:04,981 --> 00:10:06,648 Patrick Zimmerman, 175 00:10:07,584 --> 00:10:09,283 who lives in the area. 176 00:10:09,319 --> 00:10:12,387 -Zimmerman. Let's go pick him up. -Yeah. 177 00:10:12,488 --> 00:10:14,989 [Kenda] "Well, now, Mr. Zimmerman, 178 00:10:15,058 --> 00:10:17,558 what were you up to the other evening? 179 00:10:17,560 --> 00:10:19,160 And how do you explain yourself?" 180 00:10:19,663 --> 00:10:21,262 Let's go ask him. 181 00:10:25,869 --> 00:10:27,802 [female reporter] Early Sunday morning, 66-year-old Angela Spence-Shaw 182 00:10:27,871 --> 00:10:29,470 is found murdered in her hom 183 00:10:29,472 --> 00:10:33,141 A horrific crime that stunne and frightened residents 184 00:10:33,143 --> 00:10:36,377 of the quiet, normally peaceful town of Little Compton. 185 00:10:36,446 --> 00:10:40,181 State and Little Compton Police launch a massive search for her killer. 186 00:10:40,283 --> 00:10:41,249 [helicopter whirs] 187 00:10:43,553 --> 00:10:44,752 [siren wailing] 188 00:10:46,189 --> 00:10:49,357 One guy's been discovered that's a little edgy. 189 00:10:51,094 --> 00:10:52,994 Zimmerman. This could be our guy. 190 00:10:53,863 --> 00:10:55,897 [Kenda] Patrick Zimmerman. 191 00:10:55,998 --> 00:10:58,299 He's a violent sex offender 192 00:10:58,401 --> 00:11:00,068 His history says so. 193 00:11:00,070 --> 00:11:01,002 He fits. 194 00:11:06,509 --> 00:11:07,475 [Lynch] Afternoon. 195 00:11:09,245 --> 00:11:10,445 Are you Mr. Zimmerman? 196 00:11:11,481 --> 00:11:12,447 Uh... 197 00:11:13,483 --> 00:11:14,782 Yeah, what's going on? 198 00:11:14,851 --> 00:11:16,751 Do sex offenders repeat their crimes? 199 00:11:17,253 --> 00:11:18,252 Yeah, they do. 200 00:11:18,254 --> 00:11:20,354 Absolutely, they do. 201 00:11:20,356 --> 00:11:23,257 We'd like to ask you some questions about Angela Spence-Shaw. 202 00:11:24,728 --> 00:11:27,361 [Kenda] What if he notices the neighbor lady? 203 00:11:27,363 --> 00:11:30,965 What if he notices that nobody's ever around but her? 204 00:11:30,967 --> 00:11:32,400 Is it an opportunity? 205 00:11:32,468 --> 00:11:33,901 Of course it is. 206 00:11:33,970 --> 00:11:37,071 Look, guys, my wife's about to get home, 207 00:11:37,073 --> 00:11:39,607 and I really don't wanna explain to her why the cops are here. 208 00:11:39,676 --> 00:11:42,543 [Wordell] You're still tryin to be respectful of individuals 209 00:11:42,545 --> 00:11:47,248 and not bring unnecessary light onto their past. 210 00:11:47,250 --> 00:11:50,651 So then you wouldn't mind coming down to the station for a quick blood sample then. 211 00:11:51,755 --> 00:11:56,157 You're asking someone to provide a blood sample 212 00:11:56,159 --> 00:11:59,093 to eliminate themselves from a crime. 213 00:11:59,696 --> 00:12:00,628 A blood sample. 214 00:12:00,630 --> 00:12:03,064 And how does that compare to the DNA profile 215 00:12:03,066 --> 00:12:04,999 of the semen found in Angela Spence-Shaw? 216 00:12:07,470 --> 00:12:08,703 Yeah, okay. 217 00:12:09,439 --> 00:12:11,072 Whatever it takes. 218 00:12:11,074 --> 00:12:13,708 Zimmerman is the picture of cooperation. 219 00:12:15,545 --> 00:12:16,577 [Lynch] "I don't wanna be tied to this. 220 00:12:16,646 --> 00:12:18,479 I'll give you my blood sampl 221 00:12:18,481 --> 00:12:22,550 I'll account for my activities at the time in question when this attack took place." 222 00:12:26,389 --> 00:12:29,157 [Kenda] They take a blood sample for subsequent comparison. 223 00:12:30,994 --> 00:12:33,261 Blood sample is no match. 224 00:12:33,263 --> 00:12:35,463 So he was a promising lead to being with. 225 00:12:35,999 --> 00:12:37,365 But it's not him. 226 00:12:41,004 --> 00:12:42,637 [female reporter] A mother, a grandmother, 227 00:12:42,639 --> 00:12:44,472 her face barely recognizable 228 00:12:44,474 --> 00:12:46,240 [Soljane] The word spread quickly. 229 00:12:46,242 --> 00:12:49,443 There was a very somber feeling in the town. 230 00:12:49,445 --> 00:12:51,846 Uh, kind of this cloud that hung over it. 231 00:12:51,848 --> 00:12:53,948 [bell rings] 232 00:12:53,950 --> 00:12:56,450 The last homicide had been almost 40 years. 233 00:12:56,452 --> 00:12:58,553 [siren wailing] 234 00:12:58,555 --> 00:13:01,088 [Lynch] This is a very quiet, low-key community. 235 00:13:01,090 --> 00:13:03,357 It's an affluent community. 236 00:13:03,359 --> 00:13:06,861 Something like this, uh, just does not happen there. 237 00:13:08,264 --> 00:13:11,532 The Rhode Island State Police are faced with the same problem 238 00:13:11,534 --> 00:13:14,569 homicide detectives all over the world are faced with, 239 00:13:14,571 --> 00:13:17,972 you have little or nothing to go on. 240 00:13:17,974 --> 00:13:19,106 The clock is ticking. 241 00:13:20,076 --> 00:13:21,976 [Kenda] You've got to take what you've got 242 00:13:22,045 --> 00:13:23,544 and get creative with it. 243 00:13:23,546 --> 00:13:24,679 Yeah, I got something. 244 00:13:24,747 --> 00:13:26,179 What you got? 245 00:13:26,181 --> 00:13:28,883 What about the only other guy in town who's committed a murder? 246 00:13:28,985 --> 00:13:30,985 [Wordell] Just throwing it on the table, 247 00:13:31,087 --> 00:13:33,087 you know, we have this individual... 248 00:13:33,089 --> 00:13:34,155 Who's that? 249 00:13:34,157 --> 00:13:35,890 Stanley. Stanley Gendreau. 250 00:13:35,892 --> 00:13:39,493 [Wordell] ...that committed the only other murder in Little Compton, 251 00:13:39,562 --> 00:13:44,465 and his family lives almost right across the street from the victim's house. 252 00:13:46,002 --> 00:13:47,702 [Kenda] Stanley Gendreau. 253 00:13:47,770 --> 00:13:49,704 He's out of custody these days. 254 00:13:49,805 --> 00:13:52,406 Served a great deal of time in prison for the initial murder. 255 00:13:52,942 --> 00:13:54,208 So he inquires, 256 00:13:54,210 --> 00:13:57,778 "What happened to this other murder that happened in 1965?" 257 00:14:03,653 --> 00:14:05,353 [man] All right. Thank you. I appreciate it. 258 00:14:05,355 --> 00:14:10,458 Stanley Gendreau, there was an infatuation that he had with this babysitter. 259 00:14:11,561 --> 00:14:13,160 He staked out the house. 260 00:14:13,162 --> 00:14:15,162 He had been watching through the windows. 261 00:14:16,666 --> 00:14:18,499 He talked about going for a ride. 262 00:14:20,770 --> 00:14:24,572 And when she ultimately had refused to go with him... 263 00:14:24,574 --> 00:14:27,008 -[Stanley] I got my car right here. -No, no thank you, I'm good. 264 00:14:29,445 --> 00:14:30,978 [footsteps shuffling] 265 00:14:34,350 --> 00:14:36,150 -[body thuds] -[woman yells] 266 00:14:37,587 --> 00:14:39,153 [Wordell] He picked up a roc 267 00:14:39,155 --> 00:14:40,788 actually hit her over the head 268 00:14:40,890 --> 00:14:42,089 and ended up murdering her. 269 00:14:42,158 --> 00:14:43,858 [Stanley breathes heavily] 270 00:14:43,860 --> 00:14:45,693 [Kenda] He smashed a girl's head in with a rock. 271 00:14:46,262 --> 00:14:47,561 Really. 272 00:14:47,563 --> 00:14:49,430 Violent attack, female victi 273 00:14:49,432 --> 00:14:51,265 Fast forward to 1999, 274 00:14:51,267 --> 00:14:54,268 a violent attack, a female victim. 275 00:14:54,270 --> 00:14:58,706 That was certainly information to digest, to take a look at. 276 00:14:58,808 --> 00:15:00,174 All right then, 277 00:15:00,176 --> 00:15:01,776 let's go have a chat with Stanley. 278 00:15:01,877 --> 00:15:02,843 [Kenda] Stanley killed once 279 00:15:02,845 --> 00:15:04,045 Does that mean he can kill again? 280 00:15:04,047 --> 00:15:06,647 Of course, it does. "Let's go see Stanley 281 00:15:06,649 --> 00:15:08,082 and see what he has to say." 282 00:15:12,956 --> 00:15:14,055 [Lynch] How's it going, sir? 283 00:15:14,057 --> 00:15:15,556 We're looking for your son, Stanley. 284 00:15:16,459 --> 00:15:17,892 Well, he's not here. 285 00:15:17,994 --> 00:15:20,895 Upon speaking to the parents, we actually learn 286 00:15:20,964 --> 00:15:23,698 that Mr. Gendreau had been in town, 287 00:15:23,766 --> 00:15:25,967 uh, just a few days earlier. 288 00:15:25,969 --> 00:15:27,701 I'm not sure when he'll be back. 289 00:15:27,703 --> 00:15:30,371 [Wordell] It raised suspicio because we weren't able to find him. 290 00:15:30,373 --> 00:15:32,173 [Lynch] Well, if you hear anything, let us know. 291 00:15:32,909 --> 00:15:34,241 Sure. 292 00:15:34,243 --> 00:15:37,645 Could this individual, who committed that murder, 293 00:15:37,647 --> 00:15:39,480 come back to town and had done it again? 294 00:15:44,954 --> 00:15:46,554 [Wordell] I mean, he could have fled up north into Boston. 295 00:15:47,557 --> 00:15:48,656 Or down towards New York. 296 00:15:49,892 --> 00:15:51,659 Either way, he's gonna be tough to find. 297 00:15:53,062 --> 00:15:55,563 A full autopsy report just came in. 298 00:15:55,565 --> 00:15:57,865 [Nicholas] The medical examiner's report came back 299 00:15:59,669 --> 00:16:04,772 Blunt force trauma and drowning was ultimately determined to be the cause. 300 00:16:06,476 --> 00:16:09,076 She had also been electrocuted. 301 00:16:09,078 --> 00:16:12,046 Once we had a clear picture from the ME's office, 302 00:16:12,048 --> 00:16:16,283 unfortunately, I think the attack on her was savage-like 303 00:16:16,352 --> 00:16:18,085 is the best way that I could put that. 304 00:16:19,088 --> 00:16:20,688 Jesus. 305 00:16:20,757 --> 00:16:23,157 [Kenda] Her major organs are ruptured. 306 00:16:23,159 --> 00:16:25,292 No one can punch that hard, 307 00:16:25,394 --> 00:16:27,795 even someone in a blind rage. 308 00:16:27,864 --> 00:16:31,298 But they can jump up and down on the body 309 00:16:31,367 --> 00:16:33,801 and create that kind of damage, 310 00:16:33,870 --> 00:16:36,437 snapping ribs, and crushing the liver, 311 00:16:36,439 --> 00:16:38,105 and crushing the lungs. 312 00:16:39,976 --> 00:16:45,346 This is an attack of someone who's become an animal for those few moments. 313 00:16:45,348 --> 00:16:51,986 This, by far, was the most brutal and heinous crime that I've ever seen. 314 00:16:53,456 --> 00:16:55,156 This was an evil individual. 315 00:16:55,158 --> 00:16:57,058 We've got to move on this. 316 00:16:57,060 --> 00:17:01,262 [Kenda] Whoever did this is incredibly dangerous. 317 00:17:01,264 --> 00:17:02,763 Incredibly so. 318 00:17:02,765 --> 00:17:04,532 Yeah, get me through to Violent Fugitives, will you? 319 00:17:04,534 --> 00:17:08,936 We brought Violent Fugitive detectives into this case. 320 00:17:08,938 --> 00:17:10,404 Members assigned to that unit 321 00:17:10,406 --> 00:17:13,841 get very good at tracking people who don't wanna be tracked. 322 00:17:13,843 --> 00:17:16,844 They have to find him right away 323 00:17:16,846 --> 00:17:18,546 because he's gonna do this again. 324 00:17:24,454 --> 00:17:26,020 [Wordell] Stanley Gendreau, 325 00:17:26,022 --> 00:17:28,556 we were unable to locate him originally for a couple of days. 326 00:17:30,059 --> 00:17:34,161 But there were two other detectives that ended up locating him, 327 00:17:34,163 --> 00:17:35,863 and, uh, you know, 328 00:17:35,865 --> 00:17:39,166 he had gotten word that we were looking for him 329 00:17:39,168 --> 00:17:40,868 -[Lynch] Have a seat. -[Kenda] Here we have Stanle 330 00:17:40,870 --> 00:17:42,103 Stanley killed once. 331 00:17:42,171 --> 00:17:44,472 Does it mean he killed this woman? No. 332 00:17:44,474 --> 00:17:45,873 But it means he could have. 333 00:17:48,077 --> 00:17:49,276 [Lynch] How's it going, Stanley? 334 00:17:51,981 --> 00:17:54,448 [Wordell] Having committed the murder in '65... 335 00:17:54,450 --> 00:17:56,550 Glad you could make it down. 336 00:17:56,552 --> 00:17:59,753 ...I gotta say that the odd were pretty high that this individual 337 00:17:59,755 --> 00:18:02,456 had something to do with this murder as well. 338 00:18:02,458 --> 00:18:04,091 [Stanley] I didn't know you were looking for me. 339 00:18:04,093 --> 00:18:07,061 This was somebody we needed to look very closely at. 340 00:18:07,063 --> 00:18:08,095 [Kenda] There's an old expression, 341 00:18:08,097 --> 00:18:09,463 "What does a killer look like?" 342 00:18:09,465 --> 00:18:12,099 Well, a killer looks like you, and you, 343 00:18:12,768 --> 00:18:14,135 and me. 344 00:18:14,137 --> 00:18:17,104 They don't wear a sign that says, "I'm a killer." 345 00:18:17,106 --> 00:18:19,773 They are all potential killers 346 00:18:20,543 --> 00:18:22,543 because they're humans. 347 00:18:22,545 --> 00:18:23,978 Where were you the night of the murder? 348 00:18:26,215 --> 00:18:27,982 [Stanley] Home, reading a book. 349 00:18:28,083 --> 00:18:30,084 [Lynch] Was it a romance novel, Stanley? 350 00:18:30,086 --> 00:18:32,386 Now, those policemen are not gonna accept an explanation, 351 00:18:32,488 --> 00:18:34,388 and they tell them that. 352 00:18:34,490 --> 00:18:36,757 Look, I came down as a courtesy. 353 00:18:36,759 --> 00:18:38,659 You've got the wrong guy. 354 00:18:38,661 --> 00:18:42,663 But he absolutely maintains that he has learned his lesson. 355 00:18:42,665 --> 00:18:44,265 I'll give you guys whatever you need. 356 00:18:45,768 --> 00:18:47,902 [Kenda] He comes across as believable. 357 00:18:47,970 --> 00:18:50,905 [Lynch] All right. Let's go. 358 00:18:50,973 --> 00:18:53,774 [Kenda] They polygraph him, they blood sample him, 359 00:18:53,776 --> 00:18:56,744 and the result of that is it's not him. 360 00:18:56,746 --> 00:18:57,845 He's not the guy. 361 00:18:59,148 --> 00:19:00,581 Person had nothing to do with this crime. 362 00:19:01,450 --> 00:19:02,750 It's a roller coaster ride. 363 00:19:02,752 --> 00:19:05,553 We're moving in a very interesting direction, 364 00:19:05,555 --> 00:19:08,789 only to learn that we're moving the wrong way. 365 00:19:12,595 --> 00:19:13,761 [Kenda] If you've run out of suspects, 366 00:19:14,764 --> 00:19:17,464 the best thing to do is to start over. 367 00:19:18,100 --> 00:19:19,366 And where does this begin? 368 00:19:22,205 --> 00:19:24,171 Back at the crime scene. 369 00:19:25,074 --> 00:19:26,674 What did we not see? 370 00:19:27,843 --> 00:19:29,443 What was here that's significant? 371 00:19:32,281 --> 00:19:33,347 Whoa! 372 00:19:34,350 --> 00:19:35,616 Check this out. 373 00:19:37,753 --> 00:19:39,853 [Wordell] We knew the house was under construction. 374 00:19:40,990 --> 00:19:42,756 [Nicholas] But one thing that we didn't know 375 00:19:42,758 --> 00:19:46,560 was that they were in the process then of breaking through a wall 376 00:19:46,562 --> 00:19:50,264 to connect the addition to the existing home. 377 00:19:50,266 --> 00:19:52,233 [Wordell] It wasn't secured by any type of lock. 378 00:19:52,235 --> 00:19:56,136 So that was a vulnerability that happened at the house that was unique. 379 00:19:56,138 --> 00:19:58,872 Do you think our killer could have entered here? 380 00:19:58,874 --> 00:20:02,476 This brought a lot of new suspects to this investigation. 381 00:20:03,446 --> 00:20:05,246 [Kenda] Anyone who worked there, 382 00:20:05,248 --> 00:20:08,816 or anyone who passed by when the work was being done, 383 00:20:08,818 --> 00:20:11,485 would know that this house is vulnerable, 384 00:20:11,554 --> 00:20:12,987 and so is the resident. 385 00:20:17,293 --> 00:20:20,160 It vastly expands the possibilities, 386 00:20:22,098 --> 00:20:23,797 and Lynch doesn't like that 387 00:20:24,700 --> 00:20:25,666 nor would I. 388 00:20:29,805 --> 00:20:31,805 [sirens wailing] 389 00:20:37,780 --> 00:20:38,779 Whoa! 390 00:20:42,652 --> 00:20:44,485 Stephen Lynch is very distraught 391 00:20:44,586 --> 00:20:47,955 when he realizes something he hasn't seen before. 392 00:20:47,957 --> 00:20:50,991 He discovers that a door has been removed 393 00:20:51,060 --> 00:20:53,460 in the process of this construction, 394 00:20:53,462 --> 00:20:56,497 and the opening is only covered by a tarp. 395 00:20:57,667 --> 00:21:02,903 Anyone who knows this has an entryway into this ho 396 00:21:03,005 --> 00:21:06,173 involving no effort and no evidence of break-in. 397 00:21:11,347 --> 00:21:14,748 [Lynch] We were gonna have to drill down on anybod 398 00:21:14,750 --> 00:21:16,450 that had been on that property, 399 00:21:16,452 --> 00:21:19,453 that had any knowledge, or had ever worked on that property. 400 00:21:19,455 --> 00:21:21,021 All right, fellas, bring it in. 401 00:21:21,057 --> 00:21:25,993 We were gonna have a very detailed conversation with those folks involved. 402 00:21:26,862 --> 00:21:28,261 Here's the plan. 403 00:21:28,263 --> 00:21:33,600 We conducted a really thorough sweep of all the residences 404 00:21:33,669 --> 00:21:36,170 that were adjacent to hers. 405 00:21:36,172 --> 00:21:37,738 We're gonna find out what happened. 406 00:21:37,740 --> 00:21:39,907 [radio chatter] 407 00:21:40,008 --> 00:21:41,342 Bannon, I want you to run up that hill. 408 00:21:41,344 --> 00:21:43,444 -You talk to that neighbor first. -Copy that. 409 00:21:43,446 --> 00:21:45,379 At the time, I was in the Major Crimes Unit 410 00:21:45,447 --> 00:21:47,648 but we were, kind of, split into two groups. 411 00:21:47,650 --> 00:21:50,551 And Lieutenant Lynch, he pulled me 412 00:21:50,553 --> 00:21:52,553 and the other folks doing that type of work 413 00:21:52,555 --> 00:21:54,488 into this investigation. 414 00:21:56,959 --> 00:21:58,392 [Nicholas] Talked to some of the neighbors. 415 00:21:58,461 --> 00:22:00,794 Got the construction crew information. 416 00:22:00,863 --> 00:22:03,097 And it was a local construction crew 417 00:22:03,099 --> 00:22:04,665 who had been working at the property 418 00:22:04,667 --> 00:22:06,800 for about three months. 419 00:22:06,869 --> 00:22:10,771 [Kenda] This crew consists of 30 people. 420 00:22:11,607 --> 00:22:12,806 Okay. 421 00:22:12,875 --> 00:22:14,208 [tool clicks] 422 00:22:14,276 --> 00:22:15,642 Better than 300. 423 00:22:15,644 --> 00:22:17,644 Certainly better than 3,000. 424 00:22:17,646 --> 00:22:19,546 Now we have 30 possibilities here. 425 00:22:20,349 --> 00:22:21,548 So, let's get to work. 426 00:22:21,550 --> 00:22:23,550 [tool coming to a stop] 427 00:22:23,552 --> 00:22:26,553 Those were people we wanted to talk to right away. 428 00:22:26,555 --> 00:22:28,455 [Kenda] So, two of the peopl on the list 429 00:22:28,457 --> 00:22:32,259 are the people that actuall cut this hole in the wall. 430 00:22:32,261 --> 00:22:35,462 Does that make them uniquely more suspicious than the others? 431 00:22:35,564 --> 00:22:36,730 No. 432 00:22:36,732 --> 00:22:39,500 But if you're picking someon to talk to first, 433 00:22:39,535 --> 00:22:41,969 let's pick the guys that made the hole in the wall. 434 00:22:43,906 --> 00:22:46,106 And they are Kevin Moore 435 00:22:46,876 --> 00:22:48,542 and Jeremy Motyka. 436 00:22:49,645 --> 00:22:53,847 Moore and Motyka were work colleagues 437 00:22:53,849 --> 00:22:55,149 and they knew each other. 438 00:22:57,153 --> 00:22:59,753 We spoke with Kevin at lengt 439 00:22:59,755 --> 00:23:01,555 [Kenda] Kevin's story is straightforward. 440 00:23:01,557 --> 00:23:03,090 Explains he was with his girlfriend 441 00:23:03,159 --> 00:23:04,858 the night in question. 442 00:23:04,860 --> 00:23:06,760 They check out the alibi. It works. 443 00:23:07,663 --> 00:23:09,062 So, Kevin's out. 444 00:23:09,064 --> 00:23:12,332 Now the next focus is Mr. Motyka. 445 00:23:12,334 --> 00:23:14,968 I was assigned to go find Jeremy Motyka. 446 00:23:16,338 --> 00:23:18,906 [Kenda] They determine he lives in Fall River, Massachusetts, 447 00:23:19,007 --> 00:23:20,474 just across the state line. 448 00:23:23,646 --> 00:23:24,978 So, they go visit him. 449 00:23:24,980 --> 00:23:26,447 [Stephen Bannon] Appreciate you talking to me, Jeremy. 450 00:23:27,149 --> 00:23:28,982 Yeah, sure thing. 451 00:23:28,984 --> 00:23:31,452 There was nothing about him that stood out. 452 00:23:32,154 --> 00:23:34,087 He almost looked angelic. 453 00:23:34,156 --> 00:23:35,556 You know, very innocent, 454 00:23:35,558 --> 00:23:38,091 blond hair, blue eyes. 455 00:23:38,160 --> 00:23:40,394 [Bannon] There were no injuries that I could see 456 00:23:40,496 --> 00:23:43,363 that would, you know, raise any suspicions. 457 00:23:43,365 --> 00:23:46,166 Just an average, you know, contractor. 458 00:23:46,168 --> 00:23:48,368 I wasn't forming any impressions. 459 00:23:48,370 --> 00:23:50,304 Just trying to figure out where was he 460 00:23:50,405 --> 00:23:52,439 on the night of May 29th. 461 00:23:52,441 --> 00:23:54,308 Well, I was at work 'til about 3:30. 462 00:23:56,145 --> 00:23:57,344 [Kenda] Motyka says he went home 463 00:23:57,346 --> 00:23:58,745 from work that day 464 00:23:59,849 --> 00:24:01,415 and started drinking 465 00:24:01,417 --> 00:24:03,951 with the teenagers next door 466 00:24:03,953 --> 00:24:06,253 Continued drinking all evening with them. 467 00:24:06,255 --> 00:24:07,488 Then he went to bed. 468 00:24:08,557 --> 00:24:11,458 He may have been 21, 22 years old. 469 00:24:11,460 --> 00:24:14,194 So, if he's with 18, 19-year-old's, 470 00:24:14,296 --> 00:24:15,863 drinking beer and drinking rum, 471 00:24:15,865 --> 00:24:17,798 it sounds, like, he's being honest about it, 472 00:24:17,866 --> 00:24:19,666 if he's acknowledging something that, 473 00:24:19,668 --> 00:24:21,535 you know, he knows he may get in trouble for it. 474 00:24:21,537 --> 00:24:22,703 The next morning, I went up and visited... 475 00:24:22,804 --> 00:24:23,903 [Kenda] The next day, 476 00:24:23,973 --> 00:24:25,005 he said he went to visit his girlfriend 477 00:24:25,007 --> 00:24:27,374 who is spending some time in Cape Cod. 478 00:24:28,043 --> 00:24:28,842 [Bannon] Okay. 479 00:24:29,745 --> 00:24:31,144 Thank you, Jeremy. 480 00:24:31,146 --> 00:24:33,046 -[Jeremy Motyka] Sure thing. -We'll be in touch. 481 00:24:33,048 --> 00:24:35,649 [Wordell] He was pretty specific about his alibi. 482 00:24:35,651 --> 00:24:37,351 Uh, and for us, it was good things 483 00:24:37,353 --> 00:24:39,152 that he put timelines on 484 00:24:39,154 --> 00:24:41,388 that we certainly knew we could check on later. 485 00:24:44,260 --> 00:24:45,592 [phone rings] 486 00:24:45,661 --> 00:24:46,793 -[beep] -[knocking on door] 487 00:24:48,163 --> 00:24:50,764 Trisha, thanks for coming on such short notice. 488 00:24:52,268 --> 00:24:54,968 [Bannon] When we spoke to Motyka's girlfriend... 489 00:24:54,970 --> 00:24:56,670 Can you tell us about where Jeremy was... 490 00:24:56,672 --> 00:24:58,272 ...she corroborated Jeremy's story, 491 00:24:58,274 --> 00:25:01,575 that he had been drinking beer and drinking rum 492 00:25:01,677 --> 00:25:03,877 um, 'til about 1:00 a.m. 493 00:25:03,946 --> 00:25:06,980 [Trisha] Or, at least, that's what he told me 494 00:25:07,016 --> 00:25:08,549 when I saw him the next day. 495 00:25:08,551 --> 00:25:09,850 At some time around 8:00, 496 00:25:09,852 --> 00:25:10,717 8:00 or 9:00 a.m., 497 00:25:10,719 --> 00:25:13,053 he decided to get up and drive 498 00:25:13,055 --> 00:25:15,556 out to where his girlfriend was, on the cape. 499 00:25:17,560 --> 00:25:19,560 [Trisha] He seemed really hungover. 500 00:25:22,398 --> 00:25:24,064 [Kenda] He kept throwing up 501 00:25:24,066 --> 00:25:25,966 and he spent most of the day in bed. 502 00:25:26,869 --> 00:25:29,403 Well, now, he didn't mention that to us. 503 00:25:29,471 --> 00:25:31,138 What's he up to here? 504 00:25:31,140 --> 00:25:33,473 [Bannon] That's when we started doing more follow-up 505 00:25:33,475 --> 00:25:34,708 Thanks for coming in. 506 00:25:34,776 --> 00:25:37,077 [Kenda] They do a backgroun on Jeremy Motyka. 507 00:25:37,179 --> 00:25:38,245 He has a criminal record. 508 00:25:40,549 --> 00:25:42,649 He was arrested for kidnapping and assaulting 509 00:25:42,651 --> 00:25:43,850 a woman in Massachusetts. 510 00:25:45,254 --> 00:25:47,654 A history of violence towards women. 511 00:25:47,656 --> 00:25:50,290 This case is extreme violence towards women. 512 00:25:50,392 --> 00:25:52,659 That's a clue in the murder business. 513 00:25:54,063 --> 00:25:57,264 It was not to the level of this savage attack, 514 00:25:57,266 --> 00:25:59,166 but it was certainly of note 515 00:25:59,168 --> 00:26:01,768 as to Motyka's history. 516 00:26:01,770 --> 00:26:03,470 [tools whirring] 517 00:26:04,673 --> 00:26:06,406 [Kenda] Jeremy is rising abo 518 00:26:06,508 --> 00:26:08,375 his 29 fellow workers 519 00:26:08,444 --> 00:26:11,645 as the guy that's the most interesting so far. 520 00:26:13,182 --> 00:26:16,149 Jeremy is a candidate for this. 521 00:26:17,186 --> 00:26:19,553 As you talk to somebody, they'll say one thing 522 00:26:19,555 --> 00:26:20,587 and then maybe the next time, 523 00:26:20,689 --> 00:26:22,289 they'll give you additional information. 524 00:26:22,391 --> 00:26:26,159 So, we did go back and talk to him, 525 00:26:26,161 --> 00:26:27,995 to try and corroborate what he was saying. 526 00:26:27,997 --> 00:26:29,029 [dog barking] 527 00:26:31,166 --> 00:26:32,799 [Bannon] So, help me clarify a few things. 528 00:26:32,835 --> 00:26:35,002 You said you left work around 3:30 p.m. 529 00:26:36,005 --> 00:26:37,304 Where did you go from there? 530 00:26:37,373 --> 00:26:40,273 The second time, he told me some information 531 00:26:40,275 --> 00:26:41,608 that he hadn't previously. 532 00:26:41,644 --> 00:26:44,444 And he said he had stopped at a bar 533 00:26:44,446 --> 00:26:45,746 on the way home. 534 00:26:45,748 --> 00:26:46,980 What bar was that? 535 00:26:46,982 --> 00:26:48,448 I don't remember the name. 536 00:26:49,952 --> 00:26:53,253 He says he ordered a pizza that night... 537 00:26:53,989 --> 00:26:55,555 Yeah, I got a pizza. 538 00:26:55,557 --> 00:26:57,791 ...and the local shop should know that, 539 00:26:57,893 --> 00:27:00,260 again trying to provide himself with an alibi. 540 00:27:01,263 --> 00:27:02,763 You sit tight. 541 00:27:02,765 --> 00:27:03,764 [Bannon] Trying to get out of him 542 00:27:03,766 --> 00:27:05,298 the things that we could track down 543 00:27:05,367 --> 00:27:07,167 and verify whether that was what happened. 544 00:27:08,771 --> 00:27:10,671 [Kenda] They check with the pizza shop. 545 00:27:11,573 --> 00:27:14,274 Jeremy's truthful. He ordered a pizza, 546 00:27:14,276 --> 00:27:17,077 but it was the night before the homicide. 547 00:27:17,980 --> 00:27:19,046 What's he up to here? 548 00:27:20,683 --> 00:27:22,015 Well, it's pretty simple what he's up to. 549 00:27:22,017 --> 00:27:24,584 He's lying through his teeth. 550 00:27:28,357 --> 00:27:30,057 [birds squawking] 551 00:27:30,059 --> 00:27:31,658 Experienced homicide detectives 552 00:27:31,660 --> 00:27:33,393 feel it in their bones... 553 00:27:33,395 --> 00:27:34,427 [dog barking] 554 00:27:34,429 --> 00:27:36,563 ...when they're talking to a liar. 555 00:27:36,565 --> 00:27:38,432 [Motyka] Stopped to get some beer on my way home. 556 00:27:38,434 --> 00:27:41,134 [Kenda] Every time somebody speaks to Jeremy, 557 00:27:41,136 --> 00:27:43,270 Jeremy's got different things to say. 558 00:27:43,338 --> 00:27:45,872 Are the inconsistencies significant? 559 00:27:45,874 --> 00:27:46,873 No. 560 00:27:46,942 --> 00:27:49,443 But they are inconsistencies. 561 00:27:49,445 --> 00:27:52,012 And that's where it begins. 562 00:27:52,014 --> 00:27:54,314 People lie for a reason. 563 00:27:58,854 --> 00:28:02,255 By all accounts, Motyka left work at 3:30. 564 00:28:02,357 --> 00:28:03,322 We were able to corroborate 565 00:28:03,325 --> 00:28:05,826 that he was with the neighbors next door 566 00:28:05,828 --> 00:28:09,062 drinking from 6:00 p.m. until at least midnight. 567 00:28:09,064 --> 00:28:10,564 That's where things get fuzzy. 568 00:28:10,566 --> 00:28:11,431 ...and then that's it. 569 00:28:11,433 --> 00:28:13,500 We don't have any other idea 570 00:28:13,602 --> 00:28:15,535 of where he was after that. 571 00:28:15,537 --> 00:28:18,472 So, that was certainly a factor in this. 572 00:28:18,474 --> 00:28:20,173 [Kenda] He ultimately has no account 573 00:28:20,175 --> 00:28:24,010 for the hours between midnight and 9:00 a.m. 574 00:28:24,012 --> 00:28:25,645 That's a very long time. 575 00:28:27,015 --> 00:28:28,715 An adequate amount of time 576 00:28:28,717 --> 00:28:31,351 for him to do what was done to Angela. 577 00:28:35,991 --> 00:28:37,257 [birds squawking] 578 00:28:39,461 --> 00:28:41,461 [dialing] 579 00:28:41,463 --> 00:28:43,563 [dial tone] 580 00:28:43,565 --> 00:28:44,598 [phone rings] 581 00:28:44,699 --> 00:28:46,032 Detective Tella. 582 00:28:46,034 --> 00:28:47,234 [on phone] Hey, detective. This is Kevin. 583 00:28:47,236 --> 00:28:48,535 We talked a few days ago. 584 00:28:48,537 --> 00:28:50,871 Jeremy Motyka has a co-worker 585 00:28:50,873 --> 00:28:52,339 named Kevin Moore, 586 00:28:52,341 --> 00:28:54,141 who the police have already talked to 587 00:28:54,143 --> 00:28:55,442 and already eliminated. 588 00:28:55,444 --> 00:28:56,943 Thought I'd just give you a call. 589 00:28:56,945 --> 00:28:58,244 What's going on? 590 00:28:58,246 --> 00:28:59,379 [Kevin Moore] Jeremy's been acting weird the past... 591 00:28:59,381 --> 00:29:01,248 [Nicholas] He calls me to tell me that 592 00:29:01,250 --> 00:29:03,350 Jeremy was acting suspicious. 593 00:29:03,418 --> 00:29:06,553 You know, just, uh, different while on the job. 594 00:29:07,956 --> 00:29:09,222 [Nicholas] Okay, like what? 595 00:29:09,224 --> 00:29:11,158 [Moore] He's just been sayin some things that 596 00:29:11,259 --> 00:29:12,893 don't really make a lot of sense. 597 00:29:12,895 --> 00:29:13,860 'Cause my prior arrest. 598 00:29:13,862 --> 00:29:15,262 He's trying to pin this on me. 599 00:29:15,264 --> 00:29:16,530 Jeremy was telling Kevin 600 00:29:16,532 --> 00:29:19,099 police were trying to pin this crime on him 601 00:29:19,101 --> 00:29:21,768 because of his prior criminal record. 602 00:29:21,837 --> 00:29:22,869 They're out to get me. 603 00:29:22,871 --> 00:29:24,771 [Kenda] And he was very agitated 604 00:29:24,773 --> 00:29:26,106 and very distressed. 605 00:29:26,108 --> 00:29:26,973 I wouldn't have touched her. 606 00:29:28,243 --> 00:29:29,475 Come on, think. 607 00:29:30,112 --> 00:29:31,578 [Bannon] It's reasonable to think that somebody 608 00:29:31,680 --> 00:29:34,447 might be anxious that now we've spoken to them twice 609 00:29:34,449 --> 00:29:35,949 about a homicide. 610 00:29:35,951 --> 00:29:37,551 Well, I mean, they interviewed all of us. 611 00:29:37,553 --> 00:29:38,952 [Kenda] Kevin says to Jeremy 612 00:29:38,954 --> 00:29:40,453 "Well, don't worry about it 613 00:29:40,455 --> 00:29:42,856 You were never upstairs in this house. 614 00:29:42,925 --> 00:29:45,358 So, there can't be anything up there from you." 615 00:29:45,427 --> 00:29:47,227 And Jeremy, once again, 616 00:29:47,229 --> 00:29:48,862 gets excited and agitated. 617 00:29:48,931 --> 00:29:50,463 Now, they've seen my fingerprints 618 00:29:50,465 --> 00:29:52,365 up in her bathroom, 'cause I use it sometimes. 619 00:29:52,367 --> 00:29:53,433 You did? 620 00:29:53,435 --> 00:29:54,568 Yeah, man. I gotta go to the bathroom sometimes. 621 00:29:54,570 --> 00:29:56,169 Sue me. 622 00:29:56,238 --> 00:29:58,071 Kevin thought that was interesting. 623 00:29:59,474 --> 00:30:01,508 [Lynch] He knew that what Motyka was saying 624 00:30:01,576 --> 00:30:04,244 was inconsistent in his recollection 625 00:30:04,246 --> 00:30:07,013 of their work on the property 626 00:30:07,015 --> 00:30:10,584 while they were there, uh, with Angela Spence-Shaw. 627 00:30:13,722 --> 00:30:16,356 But then something even more interesting took place. 628 00:30:16,358 --> 00:30:17,591 See them looking at shoe prints? 629 00:30:17,692 --> 00:30:19,259 They are still going to work 630 00:30:19,328 --> 00:30:21,862 at the crime scene everyday. 631 00:30:21,864 --> 00:30:24,497 Jeremy sees a box 632 00:30:24,566 --> 00:30:26,533 from the Rhode Island State Police. 633 00:30:26,535 --> 00:30:30,370 And it says, "Shoe impressions." on the box. 634 00:30:30,372 --> 00:30:32,072 How many people have the same shoeprints, man. 635 00:30:32,074 --> 00:30:32,973 No. 636 00:30:32,975 --> 00:30:34,241 [Kenda] Later in the day, 637 00:30:34,243 --> 00:30:36,409 Kevin overheard Jeremy on the phone 638 00:30:36,411 --> 00:30:38,144 talking to his girlfriend, 639 00:30:38,246 --> 00:30:41,548 instructing her in a very agitated way 640 00:30:41,550 --> 00:30:45,318 to take his work boots up to Cape Cod. 641 00:30:47,022 --> 00:30:48,555 [Lynch] Wanting to get his shoes 642 00:30:48,557 --> 00:30:51,458 as far away from that scene as possible, 643 00:30:51,460 --> 00:30:54,461 to me, speaks to trying to get rid of evidence 644 00:30:55,097 --> 00:30:56,463 involved in this case. 645 00:30:56,465 --> 00:30:58,465 [Nicholas] Appreciate you coming forward with this, Kevin. 646 00:31:00,102 --> 00:31:01,034 What's on Kevin's mind? 647 00:31:02,004 --> 00:31:04,037 Kevin believed this whole conversation 648 00:31:04,039 --> 00:31:05,438 was out of the ordinary. 649 00:31:05,440 --> 00:31:08,141 And to him, it was, in some ways, alarming. 650 00:31:09,144 --> 00:31:10,810 [Lynch] It certainly was helpful 651 00:31:10,812 --> 00:31:12,746 that Kevin was now supplying 652 00:31:12,748 --> 00:31:15,982 this information of his own suspicious concerns 653 00:31:15,984 --> 00:31:18,318 regarding what Motyka was trying to say, 654 00:31:18,320 --> 00:31:20,220 how he's trying to account for himself. 655 00:31:23,225 --> 00:31:25,358 Now we bring in his girlfriend. 656 00:31:27,162 --> 00:31:29,462 She tells us about the shoe 657 00:31:29,464 --> 00:31:32,432 that he asked her to remove 658 00:31:32,434 --> 00:31:34,668 from their apartment in Fall River 659 00:31:34,736 --> 00:31:36,670 and bring them to the Cape Cod residence 660 00:31:36,672 --> 00:31:38,004 where her parents live. 661 00:31:38,874 --> 00:31:39,873 [Bannon] Why would he do tha 662 00:31:41,476 --> 00:31:42,742 I have no idea. 663 00:31:42,744 --> 00:31:44,377 [Nicholas] Your next question is, 664 00:31:44,379 --> 00:31:46,246 "Have you ever done this in the past?" 665 00:31:46,248 --> 00:31:47,814 "Never." 666 00:31:47,816 --> 00:31:49,749 And she thought it was highly suspicious. 667 00:31:50,352 --> 00:31:51,985 Thanks for the heads up. 668 00:31:51,987 --> 00:31:54,988 [Kenda] In my mind, as an experienced homicide detective, 669 00:31:54,990 --> 00:31:57,824 Jeremy's become more than somewhat of interest. 670 00:31:57,826 --> 00:31:58,925 Jeremy's the guy. 671 00:31:59,728 --> 00:32:00,560 It's him. 672 00:32:01,563 --> 00:32:03,229 He knows it's him 673 00:32:03,231 --> 00:32:05,765 and he's afraid we're figuri out that it's him. 674 00:32:06,735 --> 00:32:08,868 Now we gotta figure out how to prove it. 675 00:32:08,904 --> 00:32:10,370 [Lynch] We knew that there w 676 00:32:11,239 --> 00:32:12,672 that one element of evidence 677 00:32:12,674 --> 00:32:15,008 that he could never walk away from 678 00:32:15,010 --> 00:32:16,476 and that's his DNA profile 679 00:32:17,245 --> 00:32:18,845 being in our victim. 680 00:32:20,449 --> 00:32:22,248 We had no probable cause 681 00:32:22,250 --> 00:32:24,050 to get a warrant for their blood. 682 00:32:24,052 --> 00:32:26,453 The best we could do was ask for their consent. 683 00:32:31,927 --> 00:32:34,861 We requested the DNA sample 684 00:32:34,863 --> 00:32:36,363 from Jeremy Motyka. 685 00:32:41,003 --> 00:32:43,003 He was quite willing to provide 686 00:32:43,005 --> 00:32:45,271 evidence that he had nothing to do with this. 687 00:32:54,649 --> 00:32:57,650 Jeremy thought that that blood 688 00:32:57,652 --> 00:33:00,220 was to match blood left at the scene. 689 00:33:00,222 --> 00:33:02,422 He had no idea 690 00:33:02,424 --> 00:33:06,092 that we found semen. 691 00:33:06,094 --> 00:33:09,596 So, this guy did not have a care in the world. 692 00:33:09,664 --> 00:33:11,765 He was cool as a cucumber. 693 00:33:20,175 --> 00:33:21,775 [Kenda] In the United States 694 00:33:21,843 --> 00:33:24,411 you're innocent until you're proven guilty. 695 00:33:25,147 --> 00:33:28,248 However, the true test will be 696 00:33:28,817 --> 00:33:30,650 match or no match. 697 00:33:31,586 --> 00:33:34,254 If the specialized lab cannot match it 698 00:33:34,322 --> 00:33:36,022 to Jeremy Motyka, 699 00:33:36,758 --> 00:33:38,258 Jeremy walks away 700 00:33:38,326 --> 00:33:41,327 and this investigation has gone up in a puff of smoke. 701 00:33:47,669 --> 00:33:49,736 All of this effort, all of this work 702 00:33:50,739 --> 00:33:54,007 is designed to satisfy one fact. 703 00:33:54,076 --> 00:33:58,078 Who took Angela Spence-Shaw's life? 704 00:33:58,980 --> 00:34:01,247 Who savagely beat her to dea 705 00:34:01,249 --> 00:34:04,050 and raped her at age 66? 706 00:34:07,856 --> 00:34:09,556 We believe it's probably Jeremy Motyka. 707 00:34:11,259 --> 00:34:13,259 But the DNA sampling will tell us 708 00:34:13,261 --> 00:34:14,561 the answer to that question 709 00:34:17,399 --> 00:34:18,898 We got a solid alibi for Zimmerman. 710 00:34:19,000 --> 00:34:20,667 We got a solid alibi for Gendreau. 711 00:34:20,768 --> 00:34:21,835 [phone rings] 712 00:34:22,671 --> 00:34:23,736 Lieutenant Lynch. 713 00:34:23,738 --> 00:34:25,405 [Kenda] We get the result 714 00:34:25,474 --> 00:34:27,006 of the DNA sample 715 00:34:27,075 --> 00:34:29,542 taken from Jeremy Motyka. 716 00:34:29,544 --> 00:34:32,178 There is an absolute DNA match 717 00:34:32,247 --> 00:34:34,080 with what was found on our victim. 718 00:34:34,082 --> 00:34:35,114 Are you sure? 719 00:34:35,116 --> 00:34:35,982 [Lynch] They came up with a number 720 00:34:36,084 --> 00:34:39,819 that it was no one but Jeremy Motyka. 721 00:34:39,821 --> 00:34:41,554 He is the individual that is responsible 722 00:34:41,556 --> 00:34:42,655 for this homicide. 723 00:34:42,657 --> 00:34:43,656 No doubt about it. 724 00:34:44,459 --> 00:34:46,459 That was a moment of satisfaction. 725 00:34:46,461 --> 00:34:47,994 That was a moment of relief. 726 00:34:48,096 --> 00:34:49,195 Let's go get his ass. 727 00:34:49,197 --> 00:34:52,165 We were taking Jeremy Motyka off the street 728 00:34:52,167 --> 00:34:53,466 [sirens blaring] 729 00:34:53,468 --> 00:34:54,501 [handcuffs clicking] 730 00:34:58,273 --> 00:35:00,106 [Kenda] Jeremy is arrested 731 00:35:00,108 --> 00:35:01,975 and charged with first degree murder 732 00:35:01,977 --> 00:35:03,810 and first degree sexual assault. 733 00:35:05,580 --> 00:35:08,181 He is interrogated after an advisement of his rights. 734 00:35:09,584 --> 00:35:11,184 [Lynch on speaker] We've got your DNA at the crime scene. 735 00:35:13,688 --> 00:35:15,555 His accountability for why his semen 736 00:35:15,557 --> 00:35:19,292 would be associated with this investigation 737 00:35:19,361 --> 00:35:21,261 is that he engaged in sexual intercourse 738 00:35:21,263 --> 00:35:23,363 with his girlfriend at times 739 00:35:23,365 --> 00:35:25,165 before he came into work 740 00:35:25,167 --> 00:35:26,666 and that he would use 741 00:35:26,668 --> 00:35:30,670 Angela Spence-Shaw's bathtub to wash himself off. 742 00:35:30,672 --> 00:35:31,905 [Motyka] You don't understan 743 00:35:32,006 --> 00:35:34,908 [Kenda] And therefore, that's how his DNA sample 744 00:35:34,976 --> 00:35:38,444 got into the victim because she then took a bath 745 00:35:38,446 --> 00:35:40,046 after he used the bathtub. 746 00:35:40,882 --> 00:35:42,182 What? 747 00:35:42,283 --> 00:35:43,750 Earth to Jeremy. 748 00:35:45,253 --> 00:35:47,820 That is the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life 749 00:35:47,822 --> 00:35:49,255 and I've heard a lot of dumb things. 750 00:35:50,358 --> 00:35:51,991 Why don't you just tell us what happened? 751 00:35:51,993 --> 00:35:53,393 Get it off your conscience. 752 00:35:54,329 --> 00:35:55,762 I mean, he's a sociopath. 753 00:35:55,764 --> 00:35:57,564 [Motyka] I had nothing to d with this and you know it. 754 00:35:59,201 --> 00:36:00,867 Reaching for any kind of excuse 755 00:36:00,869 --> 00:36:02,202 or grasping at straws 756 00:36:02,303 --> 00:36:04,404 to try and save his ass, you know. 757 00:36:04,472 --> 00:36:05,572 You fabricated these results. 758 00:36:07,776 --> 00:36:09,242 He's not gonna admit anything. 759 00:36:09,244 --> 00:36:10,977 I didn't do it. 760 00:36:10,979 --> 00:36:13,279 [Kenda] Because, after all, he didn't do anything. 761 00:36:13,381 --> 00:36:14,614 He's innocent. 762 00:36:14,616 --> 00:36:16,449 [Motyka] I had nothing to do with this and you know it. 763 00:36:16,451 --> 00:36:17,750 You're trying to pin this on me. 764 00:36:19,254 --> 00:36:20,086 Well, all right then. 765 00:36:21,456 --> 00:36:22,388 [Lynch] Good luck with that. 766 00:36:23,091 --> 00:36:24,757 [Kenda] Go to jail, Jeremy. 767 00:36:25,360 --> 00:36:26,993 Do not pass go. 768 00:36:27,062 --> 00:36:28,661 Do not collect $100. 769 00:36:28,763 --> 00:36:30,163 Just go to jail 770 00:36:30,165 --> 00:36:32,265 and stay there until you die. 771 00:36:34,269 --> 00:36:35,835 [Lynch] Unfortunately, Jeremy Motyka 772 00:36:35,837 --> 00:36:38,771 doesn't have the conscience 773 00:36:39,741 --> 00:36:44,143 to say why he did what he did. 774 00:36:44,145 --> 00:36:47,046 And what he did, uh, were unspeakable acts 775 00:36:47,048 --> 00:36:48,815 towards a woman in her mid '60s. 776 00:36:48,817 --> 00:36:49,782 A grandmother. 777 00:36:54,089 --> 00:36:55,989 [Kenda] Jeremy meets this woman. 778 00:36:57,092 --> 00:36:58,591 He knows she lives alone. 779 00:36:58,660 --> 00:37:00,326 He's there everyday. 780 00:37:00,328 --> 00:37:02,161 What does that add up to in his mind? 781 00:37:03,898 --> 00:37:06,499 Victim. Someone who can be overcome. 782 00:37:07,669 --> 00:37:09,102 Someone who can be used 783 00:37:09,104 --> 00:37:11,604 to satisfy his needs if that moment comes. 784 00:37:14,476 --> 00:37:16,442 [muffled rock music playing] 785 00:37:20,081 --> 00:37:22,982 Motyka has done work at the property that day. 786 00:37:22,984 --> 00:37:24,550 He then goes on, 787 00:37:24,552 --> 00:37:26,819 engages in drinking alcohol 788 00:37:30,392 --> 00:37:33,459 And for whatever reason, makes a decision to drive 789 00:37:33,461 --> 00:37:35,561 into Little Compton 790 00:37:35,563 --> 00:37:38,298 and onto Angela Spence-Shaw's property. 791 00:37:44,005 --> 00:37:45,338 [Wordell] He had to drive 792 00:37:45,340 --> 00:37:48,508 about 20 minutes from Fall River, Mass 793 00:37:48,576 --> 00:37:53,146 and know that there was coordination on his part to do this. 794 00:37:53,148 --> 00:37:55,181 That's a whole other level of sickness. 795 00:37:59,154 --> 00:38:00,653 He enters that home because he knows he can. 796 00:38:04,659 --> 00:38:06,659 [muffled screams] 797 00:38:08,163 --> 00:38:09,362 [Kenda] He attacks this woma 798 00:38:10,031 --> 00:38:11,731 She's 66 years old. 799 00:38:12,400 --> 00:38:13,733 He doesn't care about that. 800 00:38:14,436 --> 00:38:15,601 [grunting] 801 00:38:15,670 --> 00:38:18,104 [Kenda] He beats her unmercifully in the face. 802 00:38:19,674 --> 00:38:20,773 He rapes her. 803 00:38:21,743 --> 00:38:24,444 He jumps up and down on her 804 00:38:24,446 --> 00:38:26,379 like she's a bed cushion. 805 00:38:27,816 --> 00:38:31,150 He is satisfying some need within him 806 00:38:31,152 --> 00:38:32,985 to punish a woman. 807 00:38:34,155 --> 00:38:36,723 And he selected her to do that with. 808 00:38:37,859 --> 00:38:39,058 What made him do that? 809 00:38:39,594 --> 00:38:40,493 I don't know. 810 00:38:43,098 --> 00:38:46,766 I have no idea what that sociopathic mind 811 00:38:47,602 --> 00:38:49,268 can justify in those moments. 812 00:38:51,773 --> 00:38:52,772 [water splashing] 813 00:38:54,309 --> 00:38:55,208 [Kenda] Then he drags her 814 00:38:55,276 --> 00:38:56,809 and throws her in a bathtub 815 00:38:58,146 --> 00:39:01,381 The whole point of him putting her in that tub 816 00:39:01,449 --> 00:39:04,150 was to wash away the semen from her. 817 00:39:05,987 --> 00:39:07,387 [Lynch] He was trying to clean up, 818 00:39:08,089 --> 00:39:09,856 as best he possibly could, 819 00:39:11,359 --> 00:39:12,392 what he had done. 820 00:39:14,562 --> 00:39:16,396 [hair dryer blowing] 821 00:39:16,497 --> 00:39:18,765 He wants the police to believe it's an accident... 822 00:39:21,669 --> 00:39:23,836 [electricity surging] 823 00:39:24,839 --> 00:39:26,739 ...by throwing an appliance into the water 824 00:39:26,741 --> 00:39:28,007 when it's plugged in and running, 825 00:39:29,744 --> 00:39:31,577 causing electrocution to occur. 826 00:39:34,349 --> 00:39:37,049 Those are decisions that Jeremy Motyka made 827 00:39:37,051 --> 00:39:38,985 in taking Angela Spence-Shaw's life 828 00:39:39,086 --> 00:39:40,887 without any ounce of remorse 829 00:39:40,955 --> 00:39:44,257 as to what he did to Angela. 830 00:39:47,829 --> 00:39:50,730 [Kenda] Jeremy Motyka goes to Cape Cod the next da 831 00:39:51,599 --> 00:39:53,399 But he throws up, he's sick. 832 00:39:54,469 --> 00:39:55,301 The vomiting... 833 00:39:56,471 --> 00:39:58,771 Is from exposing himself 834 00:39:58,840 --> 00:40:01,107 to what he knows he can be. 835 00:40:02,343 --> 00:40:03,876 He can be Dr. Jekyll, 836 00:40:03,945 --> 00:40:06,078 but he can certainly be a Mr. Hyde. 837 00:40:06,080 --> 00:40:07,213 [toilet flushes] 838 00:40:08,950 --> 00:40:11,250 [reporter] Did this man, Jeremy Motyka 839 00:40:11,252 --> 00:40:13,252 kill and rape 66-year-old 840 00:40:13,254 --> 00:40:14,487 Angela Spence-Shaw? 841 00:40:14,589 --> 00:40:17,723 That is the question jurors must try to answer. 842 00:40:17,725 --> 00:40:19,859 [lawyer] In that early morning hour, 843 00:40:19,861 --> 00:40:21,260 Sunday, May 30th, 844 00:40:21,863 --> 00:40:23,262 get in your car, 845 00:40:23,264 --> 00:40:24,597 drive down to Little Compto 846 00:40:24,665 --> 00:40:26,466 on Sakonnet Point Road 847 00:40:26,468 --> 00:40:28,568 enter the property of Angela Spence-Shaw? 848 00:40:28,570 --> 00:40:29,969 No. 849 00:40:29,971 --> 00:40:32,004 -[lawyer] Sure about that? -Positive. 850 00:40:32,073 --> 00:40:33,973 [reporter] On the stand, in his own defense, 851 00:40:33,975 --> 00:40:36,242 Motyka told jurors that he felt state police 852 00:40:36,244 --> 00:40:38,544 were trying to pin the murder on him. 853 00:40:38,546 --> 00:40:40,446 I was just some guy doing carpentry work. 854 00:40:40,448 --> 00:40:41,413 That's all. 855 00:40:41,415 --> 00:40:42,748 Despite the fact that he doesn't wanna 856 00:40:42,850 --> 00:40:44,350 own up to his responsibilities, 857 00:40:44,352 --> 00:40:46,552 I felt very confident 858 00:40:46,554 --> 00:40:49,755 that, uh, Jeremy Motyka, 859 00:40:49,757 --> 00:40:51,657 uh, would be found and held accountable 860 00:40:51,726 --> 00:40:53,759 for what he did to Angela Spence-Shaw. 861 00:40:53,828 --> 00:40:55,461 [juror] Jury finds the defendant 862 00:40:55,463 --> 00:40:57,797 guilty of murder in the first degree. 863 00:40:57,799 --> 00:41:00,867 Count two, the jury also fin the defendant guilty 864 00:41:00,869 --> 00:41:02,568 of first degree sexual assault. 865 00:41:03,571 --> 00:41:06,873 They convict him and send him away forever. 866 00:41:06,875 --> 00:41:08,774 [door buzzes] 867 00:41:08,843 --> 00:41:12,845 He received a life without parole sentence 868 00:41:12,847 --> 00:41:14,580 'cause that was what, 869 00:41:14,649 --> 00:41:16,549 I believe, personally, 870 00:41:16,551 --> 00:41:19,452 was the appropriate and just sentence 871 00:41:19,454 --> 00:41:20,553 for this case. 872 00:41:22,257 --> 00:41:23,990 [Bannon] The most frustrating thing 873 00:41:23,992 --> 00:41:26,959 was not being able 874 00:41:26,961 --> 00:41:29,495 to hear those words come out of his mouth. 875 00:41:30,565 --> 00:41:33,766 The only gratifying look back at this 876 00:41:33,768 --> 00:41:37,403 is that we're able to provide those sons with an answer. 877 00:41:37,472 --> 00:41:40,072 [Nicholas] Sitting with the family in court, 878 00:41:40,074 --> 00:41:41,107 it broke my heart. 879 00:41:41,843 --> 00:41:43,309 It was quite emotional. 880 00:41:43,344 --> 00:41:46,145 But it brought us great satisfaction 881 00:41:46,147 --> 00:41:48,714 that we removed this dangerous 882 00:41:48,716 --> 00:41:50,650 predator from the street. 883 00:41:50,652 --> 00:41:52,351 Because he was just getting started. 884 00:41:53,988 --> 00:41:56,255 [Kenda] Stephen Lynch is a quarterback 885 00:41:56,257 --> 00:41:59,392 of a professional team of homicide investigators. 886 00:41:59,460 --> 00:42:01,594 The game is what they do. 887 00:42:02,964 --> 00:42:04,564 Jeremy was not going to esca 888 00:42:05,266 --> 00:42:06,399 and Jeremy didn't.