1 00:00:07,807 --> 00:00:09,342 [soothing music] 2 00:00:09,376 --> 00:00:11,311 - Brad was charismatic. 3 00:00:11,711 --> 00:00:13,179 - Just a ball of sunshine. 4 00:00:13,213 --> 00:00:15,215 I wanna remember that smile. 5 00:00:15,982 --> 00:00:18,518 - He walked around and he made it apparent 6 00:00:18,551 --> 00:00:19,719 that he was gay. 7 00:00:19,753 --> 00:00:20,987 He didn't hide it. 8 00:00:21,021 --> 00:00:22,822 [Faith] He is an openly gay man, 9 00:00:22,856 --> 00:00:26,092 living in a small town with big judgment. 10 00:00:26,926 --> 00:00:29,095 - This is who he was, and around here 11 00:00:29,129 --> 00:00:30,096 that attracts attention, 12 00:00:30,130 --> 00:00:32,766 and unfortunately, it's negative attention. 13 00:00:32,799 --> 00:00:35,101 [Faith] So when he's found dead... 14 00:00:40,273 --> 00:00:41,841 [Faith] Investigators are left 15 00:00:41,875 --> 00:00:43,977 with an endless pool of suspects. 16 00:00:44,744 --> 00:00:46,980 - Brad had felt like he was being looked down upon 17 00:00:47,013 --> 00:00:48,314 because he was gay. 18 00:00:52,686 --> 00:00:54,187 - What we had was a whodunit. 19 00:00:54,220 --> 00:00:56,623 [Faith] But when a hidden secret is exposed... 20 00:01:00,794 --> 00:01:02,729 - What kinda relationship did they have? 21 00:01:02,762 --> 00:01:03,897 - There's something off about this. 22 00:01:03,930 --> 00:01:05,865 [Faith] It will eventually reveal... 23 00:01:05,899 --> 00:01:08,201 - I know what you did. 24 00:01:08,234 --> 00:01:10,704 [gun fires] [Faith] A killer relationship. 25 00:01:10,737 --> 00:01:13,139 [crying] 26 00:01:14,507 --> 00:01:26,453 [dramatic music] 27 00:01:27,287 --> 00:01:30,890 What really defines a relationship is an association, 28 00:01:30,924 --> 00:01:32,425 a connection, 29 00:01:32,459 --> 00:01:33,493 a bond. 30 00:01:33,526 --> 00:01:36,863 Bonds exist between parents and their children, 31 00:01:36,896 --> 00:01:37,864 colleagues, 32 00:01:37,897 --> 00:01:39,165 neighbors, 33 00:01:39,199 --> 00:01:40,467 sisters, 34 00:01:40,500 --> 00:01:41,434 brothers. 35 00:01:41,468 --> 00:01:44,104 And by brothers, I don't always mean family. 36 00:01:44,104 --> 00:01:46,172 Brothers can be best friends. 37 00:01:47,307 --> 00:01:49,376 Such is the bond that Brad McGarry had 38 00:01:49,409 --> 00:01:50,777 with David Kinney, 39 00:01:50,810 --> 00:01:53,113 and David's wife, Cheri. 40 00:01:53,146 --> 00:01:55,915 The trio's eight-year friendship became a bond 41 00:01:55,949 --> 00:01:57,617 that was unbreakable. 42 00:01:57,650 --> 00:01:58,785 That is, 43 00:01:58,818 --> 00:02:01,121 until the unthinkable happened. 44 00:02:01,354 --> 00:02:02,756 [keypad beeping] 45 00:02:02,789 --> 00:02:03,757 [person crying] 46 00:02:26,579 --> 00:02:31,851 [dark ominous music] 47 00:02:31,885 --> 00:02:33,253 [siren blares] 48 00:02:33,286 --> 00:02:38,825 - May 7th, 2017, I was working as a patrolman, 49 00:02:38,858 --> 00:02:39,826 by myself, 50 00:02:39,859 --> 00:02:41,728 when I received a dispatch. 51 00:02:42,395 --> 00:02:45,331 All I knew at the time was a man was down. 52 00:02:45,365 --> 00:02:48,268 [dog barks] [siren blares] 53 00:02:48,301 --> 00:02:50,270 When I got to the scene, 54 00:02:50,303 --> 00:02:54,607 it was only David Kinney, his wife and daughter, 55 00:02:54,641 --> 00:02:56,376 and they're highly upset. 56 00:02:57,377 --> 00:03:01,481 Mr. Kinney told me their friend Brad McGarry, 57 00:03:01,514 --> 00:03:03,116 he's inside, 58 00:03:03,149 --> 00:03:04,517 in the basement. 59 00:03:06,720 --> 00:03:08,221 [footsteps] 60 00:03:08,254 --> 00:03:11,057 When I entered the garage, 61 00:03:11,057 --> 00:03:13,893 the garage and the basement are adjacent, 62 00:03:13,927 --> 00:03:16,563 and I seen Brad McGarry. 63 00:03:17,630 --> 00:03:19,799 I'm seeing his body there. 64 00:03:20,066 --> 00:03:22,435 I'm looking at a face, the blood, 65 00:03:22,469 --> 00:03:23,603 he's dead. 66 00:03:23,636 --> 00:03:25,338 [radio chatter] 67 00:03:25,372 --> 00:03:27,974 And then I radio for assistance. 68 00:03:28,074 --> 00:03:30,977 [sirens blaring] 69 00:03:31,077 --> 00:03:32,345 [Ryan] It was a Sunday. 70 00:03:32,379 --> 00:03:34,214 It was a really nice day out. 71 00:03:34,247 --> 00:03:36,349 I got a call about 6:30 72 00:03:36,383 --> 00:03:38,218 saying that there was a possible homicide 73 00:03:38,251 --> 00:03:41,121 in Bellaire, Ohio. 74 00:03:42,088 --> 00:03:44,224 [radio chatter] 75 00:03:44,257 --> 00:03:45,925 As I'm arriving on scene, 76 00:03:45,959 --> 00:03:49,929 we had David Kinney and Cheri Kinney remain outside, 77 00:03:49,963 --> 00:03:51,431 and then Chief Kovalyk and I 78 00:03:51,464 --> 00:03:54,000 went on a walkthrough of the scene. 79 00:03:54,100 --> 00:03:55,602 - The basement of 80 00:03:55,635 --> 00:03:57,771 Brad McGarry's house, 81 00:03:57,804 --> 00:04:00,040 there was a narrow walkway 82 00:04:00,073 --> 00:04:02,742 where things were just stacked on each side. 83 00:04:04,678 --> 00:04:08,348 [Michael] There was a lot of blood. 84 00:04:09,082 --> 00:04:12,218 - We could see what looks like a gunshot wound 85 00:04:12,252 --> 00:04:14,054 to the back of his head. 86 00:04:14,054 --> 00:04:17,057 We don't know, is that an entry wound? 87 00:04:17,090 --> 00:04:18,758 It could be an exit wound, 88 00:04:18,792 --> 00:04:22,062 and at that point they weren't totally clear what it was. 89 00:04:22,462 --> 00:04:24,698 [Faith] Joining the detectives is the coroner, 90 00:04:24,731 --> 00:04:26,332 Investigator Skinner. 91 00:04:30,370 --> 00:04:32,072 - One of the things he'll give to us pretty quickly 92 00:04:32,105 --> 00:04:33,807 is a time of death. 93 00:04:33,840 --> 00:04:35,642 We were told three to six hours. 94 00:04:38,378 --> 00:04:41,081 - The scene's starting to tell us that this is possibly 95 00:04:41,114 --> 00:04:43,550 something he didn't see coming, 96 00:04:43,583 --> 00:04:45,085 but we don't know. 97 00:04:45,118 --> 00:04:48,488 It's way too soon to tell without an autopsy. 98 00:04:49,956 --> 00:04:50,990 [Faith] Outside the house, 99 00:04:51,091 --> 00:04:53,326 Officer Martin and Chief Kovalyk 100 00:04:53,360 --> 00:04:55,528 question David and Cheri. 101 00:05:04,704 --> 00:05:06,039 [David sobs] 102 00:05:06,072 --> 00:05:09,409 - First thing that I asked them was, 103 00:05:09,442 --> 00:05:11,911 "What was it that brought you here?" 104 00:05:53,086 --> 00:05:55,155 [dark ominous music] 105 00:05:55,188 --> 00:05:57,157 [Faith] Leaving a wake of sadness and grief 106 00:05:57,190 --> 00:06:00,126 amongst the group of friends he left behind, 107 00:06:00,160 --> 00:06:01,728 detectives wonder, 108 00:06:01,761 --> 00:06:04,197 who is Brad McGarry? 109 00:06:04,230 --> 00:06:06,466 - Brad had some struggles growing up. 110 00:06:06,499 --> 00:06:08,568 He did have a rough childhood. 111 00:06:08,601 --> 00:06:12,639 He didn't have all the things in life that other kids did. 112 00:06:12,672 --> 00:06:16,443 - Brad McGarry was born in October of 1973, 113 00:06:16,476 --> 00:06:18,311 and grew up in Louisville, 114 00:06:18,345 --> 00:06:20,814 a rural village in southeastern Ohio, 115 00:06:20,847 --> 00:06:23,049 with fewer than 200 people. 116 00:06:23,083 --> 00:06:24,684 Brad was raised by a single mother 117 00:06:24,718 --> 00:06:27,821 in a household where money was always tight, 118 00:06:27,854 --> 00:06:30,890 but financial insecurity wouldn't be the only challenge 119 00:06:30,924 --> 00:06:32,759 he'd have to face. 120 00:06:34,961 --> 00:06:36,229 - Being called a (BLEEP) 121 00:06:36,262 --> 00:06:37,831 or being called a fairy, 122 00:06:37,864 --> 00:06:39,866 it was something that you just dealt with. 123 00:06:39,899 --> 00:06:41,468 People just didn't understand. 124 00:06:42,535 --> 00:06:45,071 He walked around and he made it apparent 125 00:06:45,071 --> 00:06:46,339 that he was gay. 126 00:06:46,373 --> 00:06:47,907 He didn't hide it. 127 00:06:47,941 --> 00:06:49,809 He wasn't gonna live a lie. 128 00:06:49,843 --> 00:06:53,913 [somber music] 129 00:06:53,947 --> 00:06:55,081 - The earliest memory I have 130 00:06:55,115 --> 00:06:56,516 of Brian McGarry being in my life 131 00:06:56,549 --> 00:06:58,351 is him playing with my hair. 132 00:06:58,385 --> 00:07:01,721 I had really long, thick blonde hair, and he loved it. 133 00:07:01,755 --> 00:07:05,158 - Brad originally went to school to do hair, 134 00:07:05,191 --> 00:07:06,693 so he started working at the salon, 135 00:07:06,726 --> 00:07:08,261 but unfortunately he wasn't happy 136 00:07:08,294 --> 00:07:09,796 with the money he was making. 137 00:07:09,829 --> 00:07:13,166 So he called me one day and he says, 138 00:07:13,199 --> 00:07:15,035 "Guess what, 139 00:07:15,035 --> 00:07:17,037 I'm gonna become a coal miner." 140 00:07:17,037 --> 00:07:22,909 [soft dramatic music] 141 00:07:22,942 --> 00:07:26,112 - The coal mining industry in the Ohio Valley is huge. 142 00:07:26,146 --> 00:07:27,580 Almost everyone that I know 143 00:07:27,614 --> 00:07:30,550 has a family member within the coal mine. 144 00:07:30,583 --> 00:07:32,452 - I was like, "You're gonna do what? 145 00:07:32,485 --> 00:07:34,921 You're going to be a coal miner?" 146 00:07:35,588 --> 00:07:39,125 It's a different culture from hairdresser to coal miner. 147 00:07:39,159 --> 00:07:40,460 It's a rough job. 148 00:07:40,493 --> 00:07:42,395 I was like, you know, "Be careful." 149 00:07:42,429 --> 00:07:44,164 - I think a lot of the coal miners 150 00:07:44,197 --> 00:07:46,766 do have religious beliefs, 151 00:07:46,800 --> 00:07:50,270 and I didn't think they'd be as willing to accept 152 00:07:50,303 --> 00:07:52,906 Brad's openness of being gay. 153 00:07:53,707 --> 00:07:56,776 - But he showed that you can be an openly gay man 154 00:07:56,810 --> 00:08:01,014 and still be able to do physical labor like straight guys, 155 00:08:01,848 --> 00:08:03,817 and that's kinda what he was wanting to do, 156 00:08:03,850 --> 00:08:05,585 is change the stereotype. 157 00:08:05,618 --> 00:08:09,255 [soft dramatic music] 158 00:08:09,289 --> 00:08:11,825 [Faith] As Brad continues to grow his career, 159 00:08:11,858 --> 00:08:13,493 he meets David Kinney, 160 00:08:13,526 --> 00:08:16,029 a 20-year-old, newly married rookie, 161 00:08:16,029 --> 00:08:18,231 whom he takes under his wing. 162 00:08:18,264 --> 00:08:20,934 - Coal mining is a very dangerous job, 163 00:08:21,034 --> 00:08:23,436 and Brad took care of David, 164 00:08:23,470 --> 00:08:26,072 just like he took care of all of his other friends, 165 00:08:26,106 --> 00:08:29,476 and looked after 'em to make sure that they were all safe. 166 00:08:29,509 --> 00:08:35,081 [soft guitar music] 167 00:08:35,115 --> 00:08:37,851 [Abby] Brad and David just became best friends. 168 00:08:37,884 --> 00:08:40,053 They would do everything together. 169 00:08:40,053 --> 00:08:41,321 They were always telling jokes, 170 00:08:41,354 --> 00:08:43,923 just playing pranks on each other all the time. 171 00:08:45,091 --> 00:08:49,562 [Mary Kay] David introduced him to his wife and children. 172 00:08:50,397 --> 00:08:51,331 Brad loved children, 173 00:08:51,364 --> 00:08:54,668 so he always had a soft spot for the kids. 174 00:08:54,701 --> 00:08:57,070 [Faith] And the kids loved him right back, 175 00:08:57,103 --> 00:08:59,105 which endeared Brad to Cheri. 176 00:08:59,372 --> 00:09:00,907 - David, Cheri and Brad 177 00:09:01,007 --> 00:09:03,209 were more like family than friends. 178 00:09:03,243 --> 00:09:05,211 - They just fell in love with Brad. 179 00:09:05,245 --> 00:09:09,182 He was a gay friend who was a good friend of the family. 180 00:09:09,549 --> 00:09:11,484 - It was just a natural thing. 181 00:09:11,518 --> 00:09:13,353 We have openly gay family members. 182 00:09:13,386 --> 00:09:15,822 It's not nothing unusual. 183 00:09:15,855 --> 00:09:21,394 - Christmas, birthdays, Brad was invited in as Uncle Brad. 184 00:09:21,428 --> 00:09:26,266 [dramatic music] 185 00:09:26,299 --> 00:09:27,367 [Faith] It's clear the Kinneys 186 00:09:27,400 --> 00:09:30,637 had a very close relationship with Brad, 187 00:09:30,670 --> 00:09:33,373 but were they close enough for Brad to confide in them 188 00:09:33,406 --> 00:09:36,242 about his romantic relationships? 189 00:09:36,276 --> 00:09:37,677 - One of the most important things 190 00:09:37,711 --> 00:09:40,747 that any investigator should zero in on is, 191 00:09:40,780 --> 00:09:42,749 who are their intimate partners? 192 00:09:43,416 --> 00:09:46,186 There's something that drives that thin line 193 00:09:46,219 --> 00:09:47,354 between love and hate. 194 00:09:47,387 --> 00:09:49,756 It's all one big, nasty emotion. 195 00:10:09,709 --> 00:10:11,611 - David and Cheri said that Brad 196 00:10:11,644 --> 00:10:14,214 was recently in a romantic relationship 197 00:10:14,247 --> 00:10:15,949 with a man named Scotty, 198 00:10:15,982 --> 00:10:17,417 and they indicated to us 199 00:10:17,450 --> 00:10:19,486 that it wasn't a healthy relationship. 200 00:10:22,088 --> 00:10:22,922 - At this point in the case, 201 00:10:22,956 --> 00:10:24,657 we need to know who this Scotty is, 202 00:10:24,691 --> 00:10:27,460 and wanna learn more about him. 203 00:10:27,494 --> 00:10:30,330 It's extremely important that we identify this Scotty. 204 00:10:30,363 --> 00:10:32,365 [sirens blaring] 205 00:10:32,399 --> 00:10:34,768 At first, Scotty played it off like, 206 00:10:34,801 --> 00:10:37,437 "Hey, we messed around a couple times. 207 00:10:37,470 --> 00:10:39,539 It really wasn't that big of a deal." 208 00:10:43,243 --> 00:10:44,911 - Is this a hate crime or not? 209 00:10:47,414 --> 00:10:49,916 A whodunit is not what you want. 210 00:10:49,949 --> 00:10:51,184 - Oh. [cries] 211 00:10:57,089 --> 00:11:01,427 [dramatic music] 212 00:11:01,460 --> 00:11:04,163 [siren blares] 213 00:11:04,196 --> 00:11:05,964 - Any true crime junkie knows 214 00:11:06,065 --> 00:11:09,068 that when a homicide investigation gets underway, 215 00:11:09,068 --> 00:11:11,537 the first person law enforcement looks at 216 00:11:11,570 --> 00:11:13,906 is the spouse or significant other. 217 00:11:13,939 --> 00:11:16,075 Detectives need to rule them in, 218 00:11:16,075 --> 00:11:17,543 or rule them out. 219 00:11:17,576 --> 00:11:19,578 In the case of Brad McGarry, 220 00:11:19,611 --> 00:11:22,448 investigators learn about his former boyfriend, 221 00:11:22,481 --> 00:11:24,249 a man named Scotty, 222 00:11:24,283 --> 00:11:27,753 but you can't question someone if you can't find them. 223 00:11:28,687 --> 00:11:30,089 - We definitely want to talk to him, 224 00:11:30,089 --> 00:11:32,624 but we need to have Scotty's last name. 225 00:11:32,658 --> 00:11:35,728 [suspenseful music] 226 00:11:35,761 --> 00:11:36,895 [Faith] As investigators work 227 00:11:36,929 --> 00:11:39,465 to track down Scotty's identity, 228 00:11:39,498 --> 00:11:41,934 they continue to process the crime scene, 229 00:11:41,967 --> 00:11:45,504 looking for any clues as to why Brad was murdered, 230 00:11:45,537 --> 00:11:47,606 and who may have done it. 231 00:11:49,608 --> 00:11:52,311 - Things are scattered all over the place. 232 00:11:52,678 --> 00:11:54,113 The kitchen: 233 00:11:54,113 --> 00:11:55,481 you see drawers out, 234 00:11:55,514 --> 00:11:56,648 silverware, 235 00:11:56,682 --> 00:11:59,418 articles scattered on the floor. 236 00:11:59,451 --> 00:12:00,519 You go in the bedroom, 237 00:12:00,552 --> 00:12:02,888 you see the, the drawers are out. 238 00:12:06,425 --> 00:12:08,427 - I'm in this house and I'm thinking, 239 00:12:08,460 --> 00:12:10,095 with how ransacked it is, 240 00:12:10,129 --> 00:12:12,431 did Brad walk in and catch some robbers, 241 00:12:12,464 --> 00:12:14,066 and there was an altercation? 242 00:12:14,066 --> 00:12:16,135 That would explain why Brad's dead. 243 00:12:17,736 --> 00:12:19,538 - If there was a forced entry, 244 00:12:19,571 --> 00:12:21,273 there would be indicators, 245 00:12:21,306 --> 00:12:22,107 a door, 246 00:12:22,141 --> 00:12:23,208 a window. 247 00:12:23,809 --> 00:12:25,778 There was none of that here. 248 00:12:26,211 --> 00:12:29,815 - What I'm seeing is, somebody that had a lotta nice stuff. 249 00:12:29,848 --> 00:12:32,985 Doesn't appear to be that there's anything missing. 250 00:12:34,153 --> 00:12:35,554 One of the things that you need to do 251 00:12:35,587 --> 00:12:36,889 in any type of investigation 252 00:12:36,922 --> 00:12:39,258 is get to know your victim as soon as possible. 253 00:12:40,225 --> 00:12:41,960 [Faith] With the town of Bellaire shaken 254 00:12:41,994 --> 00:12:44,096 by the murder of one of its own, 255 00:12:44,129 --> 00:12:47,299 Detective Allar and his team work through the night, 256 00:12:47,333 --> 00:12:48,801 and by daybreak, 257 00:12:48,834 --> 00:12:52,671 news of Brad's death hits the airwaves in Eastern Ohio. 258 00:12:53,138 --> 00:12:54,740 [Male Reporter] An investigation is underway in Bellaire 259 00:12:54,773 --> 00:12:56,875 after a man was found dead in his home. 260 00:12:56,909 --> 00:12:59,478 [Female Reporter] And we're told he was a coal miner in the area. 261 00:12:59,511 --> 00:13:00,446 - I'm driving to work, 262 00:13:00,479 --> 00:13:03,816 and I'm listening to the local radio station. 263 00:13:03,849 --> 00:13:05,050 [Female Reporter] We've learned the victim 264 00:13:05,050 --> 00:13:07,286 was 43-year-old Brad McGarry. 265 00:13:08,721 --> 00:13:11,357 - It talks about this murder 266 00:13:11,390 --> 00:13:13,359 of a Brad McGarry 267 00:13:13,392 --> 00:13:14,593 in Bellaire, 268 00:13:14,626 --> 00:13:18,497 and you hear that and like all the sound stops around you. 269 00:13:18,530 --> 00:13:21,333 And I was like, "Did I hear that right?" 270 00:13:21,867 --> 00:13:23,135 [Female Reporter] Bellaire police say they received a call 271 00:13:23,168 --> 00:13:27,206 about 6:15 Sunday night, after a couple and their daughter 272 00:13:27,239 --> 00:13:28,707 found McGarry dead in the- 273 00:13:28,741 --> 00:13:31,377 - My mom told me Brad had been murdered, 274 00:13:31,410 --> 00:13:34,380 and I fell to the floor, 275 00:13:34,413 --> 00:13:35,881 crying. 276 00:13:36,949 --> 00:13:40,152 I felt like my heart had been ripped out of my chest. 277 00:13:42,755 --> 00:13:45,290 It was the worst news I have ever gotten in my life. 278 00:13:46,959 --> 00:13:48,927 - How do you tell your child that-- 279 00:13:48,961 --> 00:13:51,130 that one of her favorite people in the entire world 280 00:13:51,163 --> 00:13:53,732 is now gone and will never come back? 281 00:13:54,466 --> 00:13:56,835 - It's really hard. [cries] 282 00:13:59,905 --> 00:14:02,041 - One of the hardest things detectives have to do 283 00:14:02,041 --> 00:14:04,209 early into an investigation, 284 00:14:04,243 --> 00:14:07,079 is to interview friends and family of the deceased, 285 00:14:07,112 --> 00:14:09,748 who are still so raw with grief. 286 00:14:09,782 --> 00:14:13,719 As tough as it is, it's absolutely necessary, 287 00:14:13,752 --> 00:14:16,722 as those closest to Brad may hold the key 288 00:14:16,755 --> 00:14:18,424 to solving his murder. 289 00:14:46,685 --> 00:14:49,455 - Wendy was telling us that in the last year, 290 00:14:49,488 --> 00:14:52,458 Brad had felt like he was being looked down upon 291 00:14:52,491 --> 00:14:53,492 because he was gay. 292 00:14:56,428 --> 00:14:58,931 [dramatic music] 293 00:14:58,964 --> 00:15:01,700 - Let's think about Brad's situation. 294 00:15:01,734 --> 00:15:04,036 He's a gay man in a deeply religious city 295 00:15:04,036 --> 00:15:06,772 of close to 4,000 people, 296 00:15:06,805 --> 00:15:09,041 so the detectives have to consider, 297 00:15:09,041 --> 00:15:11,176 by just being himself, 298 00:15:11,210 --> 00:15:13,145 did Brad have a target on his back? 299 00:15:14,813 --> 00:15:17,149 - I grew up in this area my whole life, 300 00:15:17,182 --> 00:15:20,252 and you'll have prejudices wherever you go. 301 00:15:20,819 --> 00:15:22,788 - A small town, 302 00:15:22,821 --> 00:15:25,090 everybody knows everybody's business. 303 00:15:25,657 --> 00:15:28,260 - This is who he was, and around here, 304 00:15:28,293 --> 00:15:29,228 that attracts attention, 305 00:15:29,261 --> 00:15:31,597 and unfortunately it's negative attention. 306 00:15:32,164 --> 00:15:33,866 - You gotta look at that and say, 307 00:15:33,899 --> 00:15:35,467 is that a problem for Brad? 308 00:15:35,501 --> 00:15:38,070 Could there be somebody that has 309 00:15:38,070 --> 00:15:42,307 such a bias towards same-sex people... 310 00:15:44,810 --> 00:15:45,844 that they're gonna kill him? 311 00:15:46,845 --> 00:15:48,080 [Faith] While investigators take into account 312 00:15:48,080 --> 00:15:51,316 that Brad's murder could be the result of a hate crime, 313 00:15:51,350 --> 00:15:53,819 in a town of nearly 4,000 people, 314 00:15:53,852 --> 00:15:55,521 where do they begin? 315 00:15:56,221 --> 00:15:58,824 And, is there also a possibility 316 00:15:58,857 --> 00:16:01,493 that Brad was killed in a crime of passion? 317 00:16:11,036 --> 00:16:13,105 - Wendy was able to give us Scotty's full name. 318 00:16:13,138 --> 00:16:15,574 We knew it was time to- to interview him. 319 00:16:16,308 --> 00:16:18,344 - What kinda relationship did they have? 320 00:16:18,377 --> 00:16:21,880 Were they deeply involved and had an argument? 321 00:16:22,414 --> 00:16:24,316 Because if they did, 322 00:16:24,350 --> 00:16:27,586 it could possibly be a lover's quarrel that went sideways. 323 00:16:36,628 --> 00:16:38,397 [dramatic music] 324 00:16:47,741 --> 00:16:51,077 [dark ominous music] 325 00:16:51,077 --> 00:16:53,580 [Faith] Just over two days into the investigation 326 00:16:53,613 --> 00:16:55,648 of Brad McGarry's shooting death, 327 00:16:55,682 --> 00:16:59,152 detectives in the tiny town of Bellaire, Ohio 328 00:16:59,185 --> 00:17:01,621 are no closer to solving the crime 329 00:17:01,654 --> 00:17:03,857 than they were when Brad's best friends, 330 00:17:03,890 --> 00:17:07,027 David and Cheri Kinney, called 911. 331 00:17:07,761 --> 00:17:10,730 Although they don't yet know who killed Brad, 332 00:17:10,764 --> 00:17:13,700 investigators are hoping that an autopsy 333 00:17:13,733 --> 00:17:18,038 might uncover more specific details of how Brad was killed. 334 00:17:20,874 --> 00:17:23,443 - The autopsy showed that there was two gunshot wounds 335 00:17:23,476 --> 00:17:24,811 to the back of the head, 336 00:17:24,844 --> 00:17:27,881 and they were from a 22-caliber weapon. 337 00:17:29,683 --> 00:17:31,351 - We're seeing that the shots were fired 338 00:17:31,384 --> 00:17:34,120 within 10, 15 feet. 339 00:17:34,921 --> 00:17:38,091 Someone just walked up behind him and shot him twice. 340 00:17:38,124 --> 00:17:40,927 All we have are the wounds in Brad's body, 341 00:17:40,960 --> 00:17:42,796 so there's not enough data for us 342 00:17:42,829 --> 00:17:44,564 to estimate some other things, 343 00:17:44,597 --> 00:17:46,900 like the height of the killer, 344 00:17:46,933 --> 00:17:50,203 or to try to figure out more details. 345 00:17:51,171 --> 00:17:53,373 The most likely explanation 346 00:17:53,406 --> 00:17:56,576 is that this was a ambush killing. 347 00:17:57,711 --> 00:17:59,746 Whoever killed Brad had to be someone 348 00:17:59,779 --> 00:18:02,382 that he was comfortable enough to turn his back on. 349 00:18:02,415 --> 00:18:05,385 [dramatic music] 350 00:18:05,418 --> 00:18:06,886 [Faith] With these new details, 351 00:18:06,920 --> 00:18:10,390 detectives track down Brad's ex-boyfriend, Scotty, 352 00:18:10,423 --> 00:18:12,726 whose information they just received 353 00:18:12,759 --> 00:18:15,795 from Brad's good friend, Wendy Neubauer. 354 00:18:16,863 --> 00:18:20,033 - Once we had Scotty's last name, 355 00:18:20,033 --> 00:18:23,903 we end up finding the residence of Scotty, 356 00:18:23,937 --> 00:18:26,940 and we went out to the property. 357 00:18:27,440 --> 00:18:28,341 [knocking] 358 00:18:28,375 --> 00:18:30,243 [Faith] Investigators arrive at Scotty's 359 00:18:30,276 --> 00:18:32,545 last known address, 360 00:18:32,579 --> 00:18:34,881 and are met by his parents. 361 00:18:34,914 --> 00:18:36,883 - They're like, you know, "He's not here. 362 00:18:36,916 --> 00:18:39,953 He's actually in jail in West Virginia." 363 00:18:42,055 --> 00:18:45,458 So we're like, "Okay, when did he get there?" 364 00:18:45,492 --> 00:18:48,228 And he had been there for almost a month. 365 00:18:48,661 --> 00:18:53,967 [dark ominous music] 366 00:18:54,067 --> 00:18:57,437 What I know for a fact is, Brad was killed on May 7th. 367 00:18:57,470 --> 00:19:00,240 I could prove that Scotty was incarcerated, 368 00:19:00,273 --> 00:19:04,010 so he by his own hand, could not have killed Brad, 369 00:19:04,010 --> 00:19:06,880 but Scotty could have paid someone to do it, 370 00:19:06,913 --> 00:19:09,416 or he could have asked a friend to do it. 371 00:19:12,085 --> 00:19:13,820 [Faith] Scotty's parents have no knowledge 372 00:19:13,853 --> 00:19:16,656 of their son's relationship with Brad, 373 00:19:16,690 --> 00:19:18,625 but detectives have a plan. 374 00:19:18,658 --> 00:19:20,694 They arrange a jailhouse interview 375 00:19:20,727 --> 00:19:22,696 and make a strategic decision 376 00:19:22,729 --> 00:19:25,498 to inform Scotty of Brad's death, 377 00:19:25,532 --> 00:19:28,435 gauging his reaction for guilt or grief. 378 00:19:30,670 --> 00:19:33,073 - They talked about his relationship with Brad. 379 00:19:33,506 --> 00:19:35,575 It was a brief relationship, 380 00:19:35,608 --> 00:19:38,778 and by Scotty's own admission, it was over. 381 00:19:39,179 --> 00:19:43,249 He's very upset to hear about Brad's death, 382 00:19:43,283 --> 00:19:48,054 and in their notation, appropriately upset, 383 00:19:48,088 --> 00:19:51,725 and he claimed that he did not kill Brad. 384 00:19:53,059 --> 00:19:56,596 Scotty was a bit of a bad seed, 385 00:19:56,629 --> 00:19:58,465 didn't have the best reputation, 386 00:19:58,498 --> 00:20:00,867 but didn't have the reputation 387 00:20:00,900 --> 00:20:03,503 of going to killing people either. 388 00:20:03,536 --> 00:20:06,239 So at the conclusion of that interview, 389 00:20:06,272 --> 00:20:09,509 we pretty much closed the door on Scotty. 390 00:20:10,377 --> 00:20:13,847 - With Brad's ex-boyfriend crossed off the suspect list, 391 00:20:13,880 --> 00:20:15,515 detectives wonder, 392 00:20:15,548 --> 00:20:17,217 could this have been a hate crime? 393 00:20:17,250 --> 00:20:21,187 If so, that just deepens the suspect pool, 394 00:20:21,221 --> 00:20:25,025 but it's a pool of people investigators believe Brad knew, 395 00:20:25,058 --> 00:20:28,628 a pool of people Brad was comfortable enough with 396 00:20:28,661 --> 00:20:30,597 to turn his back on, 397 00:20:30,630 --> 00:20:32,298 his coworkers. 398 00:20:34,634 --> 00:20:36,936 - You got Brad, that's openly gay, 399 00:20:36,970 --> 00:20:38,405 working in a coal mine. 400 00:20:39,406 --> 00:20:40,573 We gotta look into that. 401 00:20:41,241 --> 00:20:43,810 Has anybody really taken an issue with him? 402 00:20:43,843 --> 00:20:45,145 Was this guy persecuted 403 00:20:45,178 --> 00:20:48,214 because of his sexual preferences? 404 00:20:48,248 --> 00:20:51,051 And you'll have prejudices wherever you go, 405 00:20:51,084 --> 00:20:53,086 where people don't like this group of people 406 00:20:53,119 --> 00:20:55,188 or that group of people, it's everywhere, 407 00:20:55,221 --> 00:20:57,590 and you're never gonna get rid of that 100%. 408 00:20:58,324 --> 00:21:01,127 But we had a lot of contacts in the coal industry, 409 00:21:01,161 --> 00:21:04,931 so we're lucky we were able to cut through the BS. 410 00:21:04,964 --> 00:21:06,766 We were able to call people that we knew and trusted, 411 00:21:06,800 --> 00:21:08,802 and say, "Hey, what's the score on this?" 412 00:21:09,736 --> 00:21:13,073 Talking to Brad's coworkers, 413 00:21:13,106 --> 00:21:15,575 it seemed, for the most part, 414 00:21:15,608 --> 00:21:17,243 he was extremely well-liked, 415 00:21:17,277 --> 00:21:19,079 that there wasn't a lot of problems, 416 00:21:19,079 --> 00:21:21,614 and there- there certainly weren't any reported incidents 417 00:21:21,648 --> 00:21:24,684 that seemed to have any huge substance, 418 00:21:24,718 --> 00:21:26,353 to where somebody had a grudge. 419 00:21:27,620 --> 00:21:30,790 A whodunit is not what you want. 420 00:21:32,292 --> 00:21:34,627 It's almost a curse word with investigators. 421 00:21:35,395 --> 00:21:37,664 At that point, we need to revisit this. 422 00:21:37,697 --> 00:21:38,631 Who's his friends? 423 00:21:38,665 --> 00:21:39,833 Who's his enemies? 424 00:21:39,866 --> 00:21:42,502 We should really be looking at friends and family. 425 00:21:43,269 --> 00:21:45,438 [Faith] On Tuesday afternoon, May 9th, 426 00:21:45,472 --> 00:21:49,109 after interviewing witnesses for two consecutive days, 427 00:21:49,142 --> 00:21:51,778 detectives catch a lucky break 428 00:21:51,811 --> 00:21:53,113 when Brad's cousin, 429 00:21:53,113 --> 00:21:54,614 a woman named Schuyler, 430 00:21:54,647 --> 00:21:55,782 comes down to the station 431 00:21:55,815 --> 00:21:57,183 with new information. 432 00:22:12,932 --> 00:22:14,234 [Ryan] Schuyler was telling me 433 00:22:14,267 --> 00:22:16,302 that Brad had another relationship, 434 00:22:16,336 --> 00:22:17,203 a man named DJ, 435 00:22:17,237 --> 00:22:19,172 who he was gonna meet to have sex with. 436 00:22:25,078 --> 00:22:28,882 - And we know that Brad shortly thereafter ends up dead. 437 00:22:29,949 --> 00:22:31,618 What we're looking for is, 438 00:22:31,651 --> 00:22:33,319 who's in the middle here? 439 00:22:33,353 --> 00:22:35,321 This was huge. 440 00:22:38,224 --> 00:22:40,694 - But, we don't know who DJ is, 441 00:22:40,727 --> 00:22:43,363 and just like we dealt with with Scotty, 442 00:22:43,396 --> 00:22:45,365 if we don't know who he is, we can't find him. 443 00:22:49,169 --> 00:22:51,404 - The next crucial step in the investigation 444 00:22:51,438 --> 00:22:53,540 is to identify who is DJ? 445 00:23:02,449 --> 00:23:04,818 [dramatic music] 446 00:23:04,851 --> 00:23:07,854 - Detective Ryan Allar has just learned 447 00:23:07,887 --> 00:23:10,357 that Brad McGarry was in a secret, 448 00:23:10,390 --> 00:23:13,126 long-term romantic relationship 449 00:23:13,159 --> 00:23:15,328 with a man named DJ, 450 00:23:15,362 --> 00:23:17,664 and that DJ was going to Brad's house 451 00:23:17,697 --> 00:23:19,899 on the day Brad was murdered. 452 00:23:19,933 --> 00:23:21,801 So who is DJ? 453 00:23:22,936 --> 00:23:25,238 - Could this be the lover itself, 454 00:23:25,271 --> 00:23:27,307 or could this be someone that's jealous 455 00:23:27,340 --> 00:23:29,376 that Brad's in another relationship? 456 00:23:30,977 --> 00:23:32,345 Who is DJ? 457 00:23:44,591 --> 00:23:45,692 [dramatic music] 458 00:23:45,725 --> 00:23:47,694 - And I'm like, "Wow, okay." 459 00:23:47,727 --> 00:23:50,230 It was kind of just... 460 00:23:52,132 --> 00:23:53,466 in shock. 461 00:23:53,767 --> 00:23:55,235 Schuyler tells us that DJ 462 00:23:55,268 --> 00:23:57,937 is just a nickname of David Kinney. 463 00:23:57,971 --> 00:23:59,706 David Kinney did not tell us 464 00:23:59,739 --> 00:24:04,344 that he's in this long-term sexual relationship with Brad, 465 00:24:04,377 --> 00:24:06,446 and there could be a lotta reasons for that. 466 00:24:06,746 --> 00:24:09,249 I can think of one big one right off the bat. 467 00:24:09,282 --> 00:24:10,150 We talked to David. 468 00:24:10,183 --> 00:24:12,419 He was with his wife, 469 00:24:12,452 --> 00:24:15,922 and he might not have wanted to mention to her that, 470 00:24:15,955 --> 00:24:17,590 "Hey, you know, by the way, 471 00:24:17,624 --> 00:24:20,493 I've been having an affair with him for years." 472 00:24:20,760 --> 00:24:22,262 Doesn't mean he killed Brad, 473 00:24:22,295 --> 00:24:24,731 but he's already keeping things from us. 474 00:24:24,764 --> 00:24:27,067 That's the biggest takeaway that I had at that point. 475 00:24:27,634 --> 00:24:30,103 - There's a lot to consider here. 476 00:24:30,136 --> 00:24:31,638 David has been withholding 477 00:24:31,671 --> 00:24:34,407 crucial information from investigators, 478 00:24:34,441 --> 00:24:37,143 so they're right to be suspicious of him. 479 00:24:37,177 --> 00:24:39,746 Perhaps David had been keeping his affair 480 00:24:39,779 --> 00:24:41,448 a secret from Cheri, 481 00:24:41,481 --> 00:24:44,250 or perhaps she knew all along, 482 00:24:44,284 --> 00:24:47,087 and took matters into her own hands. 483 00:24:47,087 --> 00:24:50,657 Could this affair be a motive for murder? 484 00:24:51,658 --> 00:24:53,326 - We know that her husband was involved 485 00:24:53,360 --> 00:24:55,261 in a sexual relationship. 486 00:24:55,295 --> 00:24:57,764 We had to look at her and say, 487 00:24:57,797 --> 00:24:59,366 "Was she involved in this? 488 00:24:59,399 --> 00:25:02,369 Did she find out about the affair and go and kill Brad, 489 00:25:02,402 --> 00:25:05,672 and David's helping her cover this up outta loyalty?" 490 00:25:05,705 --> 00:25:08,174 Could that be what we're dealing with here? 491 00:25:08,208 --> 00:25:11,111 - Investigators look into the Kinney's marriage, 492 00:25:11,144 --> 00:25:13,079 and learn that, by all accounts, 493 00:25:13,113 --> 00:25:14,647 the two seemed happy. 494 00:25:14,681 --> 00:25:17,717 And it's still unclear who knew what, 495 00:25:17,751 --> 00:25:20,620 and if David or Cheri had anything to do 496 00:25:20,653 --> 00:25:22,322 with Brad's murder. 497 00:25:22,355 --> 00:25:25,692 To get answers, investigators wanna talk to David. 498 00:25:28,495 --> 00:25:30,897 - All this is making him a person of interest 499 00:25:30,930 --> 00:25:33,366 that needs to be re-interviewed. 500 00:25:33,400 --> 00:25:36,403 - It's time to have DJ or David, 501 00:25:36,436 --> 00:25:37,737 or whatever he calls himself, 502 00:25:37,771 --> 00:25:39,439 come in and have a chat. 503 00:25:40,440 --> 00:25:42,242 [Faith] On the evening of May 9th, 504 00:25:42,275 --> 00:25:46,079 David Kinney is escorted into an interrogation room, 505 00:25:46,079 --> 00:25:47,647 but before they begin, 506 00:25:47,681 --> 00:25:51,651 detectives ask David for access to his cell phone. 507 00:25:57,991 --> 00:26:00,060 - He had told us about conversations 508 00:26:00,093 --> 00:26:05,065 and text messages he had with Brad prior to Brad's death. 509 00:26:05,699 --> 00:26:07,934 It's important to us to get this timeline. 510 00:26:36,062 --> 00:26:39,599 [David sobbing] 511 00:26:54,681 --> 00:26:55,915 [David inhales] 512 00:26:57,350 --> 00:26:58,852 [David exhales] 513 00:26:59,686 --> 00:27:01,554 [Faith] Meanwhile, in another room, 514 00:27:01,588 --> 00:27:04,591 Detective Cruse has been studying David's phone, 515 00:27:04,624 --> 00:27:07,827 and has information to share with Detective Allar. 516 00:27:14,034 --> 00:27:14,901 [door opens] 517 00:27:14,934 --> 00:27:17,037 And it's like, "Go, give me, what do ya got?" 518 00:27:17,070 --> 00:27:19,572 So we were able to confirm through David's phone 519 00:27:19,606 --> 00:27:23,209 that David sent text messages to Brad 520 00:27:23,243 --> 00:27:25,879 that corroborate what Schuyler was telling us. 521 00:27:26,579 --> 00:27:27,881 Doesn't mean he killed him. 522 00:27:27,914 --> 00:27:29,749 It means he lied to us. 523 00:27:51,237 --> 00:27:52,605 - So now it's getting to the point 524 00:27:52,639 --> 00:27:54,941 to where I need to ask the more difficult questions. 525 00:28:05,351 --> 00:28:07,286 [dramatic music] 526 00:28:07,319 --> 00:28:11,323 - Detectives in Bellaire, Ohio have just uncovered proof 527 00:28:11,357 --> 00:28:13,158 on David Kinney's cell phone 528 00:28:13,192 --> 00:28:16,328 that he was not only Brad McGarry's best friend, 529 00:28:16,362 --> 00:28:18,063 he was also his lover. 530 00:28:18,764 --> 00:28:21,900 A significant detail he conveniently left out 531 00:28:21,934 --> 00:28:24,069 when initially questioned at the crime scene. 532 00:28:24,303 --> 00:28:26,772 But Detective Allar masterfully pulls 533 00:28:26,805 --> 00:28:29,308 the true story out of David Kinney. 534 00:28:45,124 --> 00:28:46,058 - At first, 535 00:28:46,058 --> 00:28:48,193 he really played it off like, you know, 536 00:28:48,227 --> 00:28:50,763 "Hey, we messed around a couple times. 537 00:28:50,796 --> 00:28:52,631 It really wasn't that big of a deal. 538 00:28:52,664 --> 00:28:54,133 We were more friends." 539 00:29:12,217 --> 00:29:14,019 - I'm listening, I'm asking questions. 540 00:29:14,053 --> 00:29:15,654 So I'm letting him tell me things. 541 00:29:15,688 --> 00:29:18,390 I'm trying to take what he's giving me, 542 00:29:18,424 --> 00:29:20,125 plugging it into the case. 543 00:29:23,429 --> 00:29:27,399 - David has not only lied to investigators, a big no-no, 544 00:29:27,433 --> 00:29:31,437 but he's just been exposed as living a double life. 545 00:29:31,470 --> 00:29:33,238 To determine if he's a killer, 546 00:29:33,272 --> 00:29:37,309 Detective Allar needs answers to some important questions. 547 00:29:37,343 --> 00:29:39,845 If they were best friends and lovers, 548 00:29:39,878 --> 00:29:42,948 what reason would David have to want Brad dead? 549 00:29:43,048 --> 00:29:44,683 Did something occur between them 550 00:29:44,717 --> 00:29:47,052 at the time of Brad's death? 551 00:29:47,052 --> 00:29:50,322 And how deep did this relationship really go? 552 00:29:51,757 --> 00:29:54,159 - Brad was attracted to David Kinney. 553 00:29:54,193 --> 00:29:56,395 They were good friends at first. 554 00:29:56,428 --> 00:29:57,596 David was married. 555 00:29:57,629 --> 00:30:03,402 He also had children, and as the friendship grew closer, 556 00:30:03,435 --> 00:30:04,870 Brad started telling me 557 00:30:04,903 --> 00:30:09,208 that he felt that David was attracted to guys. 558 00:30:09,241 --> 00:30:11,710 He had just a lot of questions. 559 00:30:11,744 --> 00:30:15,047 He wanted to know about gay sex. 560 00:30:15,080 --> 00:30:18,283 He wanted to know about what gay people did. 561 00:30:18,317 --> 00:30:20,753 And you know, Brad basically said, 562 00:30:20,786 --> 00:30:23,956 "Okay, follow me and I'll show you the life." 563 00:30:25,858 --> 00:30:27,292 [Faith] Behind closed doors, 564 00:30:27,326 --> 00:30:30,329 a sexual relationship flourishes. 565 00:30:30,362 --> 00:30:31,330 And over the years, 566 00:30:31,363 --> 00:30:35,000 Brad and David find ways to be alone together. 567 00:30:36,402 --> 00:30:38,771 - David Kinney didn't want his wife to find out. 568 00:30:38,804 --> 00:30:43,942 It was a vicious circle of highs and lows. 569 00:30:47,446 --> 00:30:49,081 David was having fun, 570 00:30:49,114 --> 00:30:51,950 but Brad was slowly falling in love, 571 00:30:51,984 --> 00:30:57,756 and that's what made it so difficult for Brad. 572 00:30:58,424 --> 00:31:01,293 Very confusing for all parties involved. 573 00:31:01,326 --> 00:31:05,264 [dramatic music] 574 00:31:18,510 --> 00:31:21,513 - He's worried about his wife finding out, 575 00:31:21,547 --> 00:31:24,350 and at this point, I honestly told him, 576 00:31:24,383 --> 00:31:26,452 "Whatever you want to tell your wife's your business. 577 00:31:26,485 --> 00:31:29,221 I'm not the marriage police here. 578 00:31:31,090 --> 00:31:34,093 - Even though David may be a closeted bisexual 579 00:31:34,093 --> 00:31:36,528 who was sleeping with his best friend, 580 00:31:36,562 --> 00:31:39,698 it still doesn't necessarily make him a murderer. 581 00:31:39,732 --> 00:31:40,733 But to clear him, 582 00:31:40,766 --> 00:31:44,136 Detective Allar needs to pin down David's timeline 583 00:31:44,169 --> 00:31:46,138 and that of his wife Cheri, 584 00:31:46,171 --> 00:31:48,240 during the hours prior to the murder. 585 00:32:18,203 --> 00:32:20,806 [Faith] David is precise in laying out his movements 586 00:32:20,839 --> 00:32:22,574 the day Brad was killed. 587 00:32:22,608 --> 00:32:25,511 So the detectives take another look at his cell phone 588 00:32:25,544 --> 00:32:28,547 to see if they can corroborate his story. 589 00:32:29,148 --> 00:32:32,584 - Detective Cruse is looking for the pings 590 00:32:32,618 --> 00:32:34,420 off the phone towers. 591 00:32:34,453 --> 00:32:38,190 He's getting information off of David Kinney's phone. 592 00:32:39,491 --> 00:32:43,462 The towers put David Kinney at Brad's house 593 00:32:43,495 --> 00:32:46,598 at the same time Brad McGarry was killed. 594 00:32:46,632 --> 00:32:50,803 - Now we can put David at the scene when Brad arrives home, 595 00:32:50,836 --> 00:32:52,204 you know, around three o'clock, 596 00:32:52,237 --> 00:32:54,106 right around the hot zone 597 00:32:54,106 --> 00:32:57,376 for when we really believe the shots were fired. 598 00:33:02,247 --> 00:33:03,315 - So now it's getting to the point 599 00:33:03,349 --> 00:33:06,085 to where I need to ask the more difficult questions. 600 00:33:27,840 --> 00:33:31,443 - David's cell phone evidence might seem incriminating, 601 00:33:31,477 --> 00:33:33,312 but here you see Detective Allar 602 00:33:33,345 --> 00:33:36,248 avoiding making any accusations, 603 00:33:36,281 --> 00:33:40,085 and instead, giving David a chance to explain. 604 00:33:40,119 --> 00:33:41,320 By doing this, 605 00:33:41,353 --> 00:33:43,789 he's trying to get David to reveal his role 606 00:33:43,822 --> 00:33:45,791 in Brad's death on his own, 607 00:33:45,824 --> 00:33:47,393 whatever it may be. 608 00:33:47,426 --> 00:33:49,561 But David refuses to budge. 609 00:34:05,277 --> 00:34:07,112 He's telling me this story about, 610 00:34:07,146 --> 00:34:09,682 he's waiting for Brad with this weed eater, 611 00:34:09,715 --> 00:34:14,420 and Brad comes pulling up with a unknown male in the car. 612 00:34:31,770 --> 00:34:36,175 [ominous music] 613 00:34:49,955 --> 00:34:52,091 [ominous music] 614 00:34:52,124 --> 00:34:54,360 [Faith] After eight long hours of questioning, 615 00:34:54,393 --> 00:34:57,563 Detective Allar decides to call David's bluff. 616 00:36:12,771 --> 00:36:14,907 [dramatic music] 617 00:36:22,781 --> 00:36:25,751 [dramatic music] 618 00:36:25,784 --> 00:36:29,088 - David Kinney has just confessed to two things, 619 00:36:29,121 --> 00:36:30,456 having a long-time affair 620 00:36:30,489 --> 00:36:33,325 with his best friend, Brad McGarry, 621 00:36:33,359 --> 00:36:35,194 and killing him. 622 00:36:35,227 --> 00:36:37,496 But what we don't know for sure, 623 00:36:37,529 --> 00:36:38,630 is why. 624 00:36:49,742 --> 00:36:53,112 - David Kinney relayed that Brad had a pistol, 625 00:36:53,145 --> 00:36:54,813 and David disarmed him, 626 00:36:54,847 --> 00:36:57,683 and then shot him, claiming this was self-defense. 627 00:36:57,716 --> 00:36:59,451 Okay, David, how'd that happened? 628 00:37:15,267 --> 00:37:18,704 [dramatic music builds] 629 00:37:18,737 --> 00:37:21,040 This is the man that killed Brad. 630 00:37:21,073 --> 00:37:23,776 I know what you did. 631 00:37:23,809 --> 00:37:25,811 I said, "David, you're going to jail." 632 00:37:27,680 --> 00:37:31,316 - David Kinney's lies have finally caught up with him, 633 00:37:31,350 --> 00:37:33,318 and there's more than enough to charge him 634 00:37:33,352 --> 00:37:35,154 with Brad's murder. 635 00:37:35,187 --> 00:37:37,322 But his wife Cheri's possible involvement 636 00:37:37,356 --> 00:37:39,058 is still unclear. 637 00:37:39,058 --> 00:37:42,428 For the last eight hours of David's interrogation, 638 00:37:42,461 --> 00:37:44,596 Cheri has been waiting outside. 639 00:37:44,630 --> 00:37:48,133 The only question investigators now have is, 640 00:37:48,167 --> 00:37:50,836 did Cheri have a hand in this homicide? 641 00:37:55,908 --> 00:37:59,878 - David says he wanted to tell Cheri his version of events. 642 00:37:59,912 --> 00:38:03,015 So we put her right in the interview room, 643 00:38:03,048 --> 00:38:05,884 and after we left, 644 00:38:05,918 --> 00:38:08,887 we're watching this unfold through the cameras. 645 00:38:08,921 --> 00:38:10,756 And what we're looking for, the whole team, 646 00:38:10,789 --> 00:38:13,459 is really eyeballing her reaction. 647 00:38:13,492 --> 00:38:16,362 Did Cheri have any idea about the affair, 648 00:38:16,395 --> 00:38:18,130 knew about it or suspected about it? 649 00:38:25,404 --> 00:38:27,940 - It's very sugar-coated, but he tells her 650 00:38:28,040 --> 00:38:30,909 that they've been involved in a sexual affair. 651 00:38:31,577 --> 00:38:34,313 Cheri was kind of, 652 00:38:34,346 --> 00:38:35,647 just... 653 00:38:35,681 --> 00:38:36,715 in shock. 654 00:38:36,749 --> 00:38:40,786 She has no clue about the relationship with Brad. 655 00:39:20,025 --> 00:39:23,662 - Cheri finds out that her husband was betraying her 656 00:39:23,696 --> 00:39:26,098 with this man that she considered family. 657 00:39:26,131 --> 00:39:28,233 [Cheri cries] 658 00:39:28,267 --> 00:39:31,170 She finds out her husband willingly brought her daughter 659 00:39:31,203 --> 00:39:34,506 to discover a body, 660 00:39:34,540 --> 00:39:37,643 and she finds out that her husband killed this man. 661 00:39:37,676 --> 00:39:40,546 All this stuff, all at once, 662 00:39:40,579 --> 00:39:42,147 just thrown at her feet. 663 00:39:54,393 --> 00:39:56,495 - I mean, our hearts really went out to her. 664 00:39:56,528 --> 00:40:00,933 You know, her entire world gets blown up. 665 00:40:07,506 --> 00:40:09,641 [Ryan] For a parent to bring a child 666 00:40:09,675 --> 00:40:11,610 to find Brad's murdered body, 667 00:40:11,643 --> 00:40:13,278 what kind of father would do that. 668 00:40:22,521 --> 00:40:24,490 [dramatic music] 669 00:40:24,523 --> 00:40:26,925 [Hank] What I think happened was, 670 00:40:26,959 --> 00:40:29,862 David and Brad had an argument on the phone. 671 00:40:29,895 --> 00:40:32,598 They had probably had several conversations. 672 00:40:32,631 --> 00:40:33,799 - David said that there was no way 673 00:40:33,832 --> 00:40:35,367 he was gonna leave his wife. 674 00:40:35,401 --> 00:40:36,735 He was stuck in a relationship 675 00:40:36,769 --> 00:40:38,604 that he didn't want to be in. 676 00:40:39,271 --> 00:40:41,306 - Brad threatened to tell Cheri 677 00:40:41,340 --> 00:40:44,476 about their homosexual relationship. 678 00:40:44,510 --> 00:40:46,178 He was going to show her pictures 679 00:40:46,211 --> 00:40:47,680 and text messages that he had-- 680 00:40:47,713 --> 00:40:50,182 - And say, "Look, look what he's doing to you. 681 00:40:50,215 --> 00:40:52,051 He's doing it to me too." 682 00:40:52,084 --> 00:40:53,852 And that was the motive. 683 00:40:53,886 --> 00:40:56,722 The only way out of this relationship was to kill. 684 00:40:57,723 --> 00:41:00,225 - I believe that David Kinney made up his mind 685 00:41:00,259 --> 00:41:02,795 that Brad McGarry had to die, 686 00:41:02,828 --> 00:41:05,531 so he lured him there with the promise of sex, 687 00:41:05,564 --> 00:41:06,465 killed him, [gun fires] 688 00:41:06,498 --> 00:41:09,068 and then covered it up the best he could. 689 00:41:09,101 --> 00:41:11,337 [Faith] With his verbal confession memorialized 690 00:41:11,370 --> 00:41:13,305 in an interrogation video, 691 00:41:13,339 --> 00:41:17,576 David Kinney is arrested for the murder of Brad McGarry. 692 00:41:19,778 --> 00:41:21,480 - Sometime about midnight, 693 00:41:21,513 --> 00:41:22,648 I get a phone call. 694 00:41:22,681 --> 00:41:23,916 Cheri tells me 695 00:41:26,085 --> 00:41:28,253 that David killed Brad, 696 00:41:28,287 --> 00:41:30,689 and I was in utter shock. 697 00:41:30,723 --> 00:41:35,728 Who thinks that their child would kill somebody? 698 00:41:35,761 --> 00:41:42,868 [soft somber music] 699 00:41:42,901 --> 00:41:46,405 [Faith] On February 14th, 2018, 700 00:41:46,438 --> 00:41:48,140 following an eight-day trial, 701 00:41:48,173 --> 00:41:50,943 David Kinney learns his fate. 702 00:41:50,976 --> 00:41:53,412 - We the jury, duly impaneled and sworn, 703 00:41:53,445 --> 00:41:55,781 find the defendant, David Carl Kinney, 704 00:41:55,814 --> 00:41:59,785 guilty of aggravated murder, as charged in the indictment. 705 00:42:00,419 --> 00:42:03,655 - David Kinney is sentenced to life without parole, 706 00:42:03,689 --> 00:42:06,458 and a year later, loses an appeal. 707 00:42:06,492 --> 00:42:09,495 He will spend the rest of his life 708 00:42:09,528 --> 00:42:11,830 in the Belmont Correctional Institution 709 00:42:11,864 --> 00:42:14,199 in St. Clairsville, Ohio. 710 00:42:15,434 --> 00:42:21,173 - I will miss the fun, loving, caring spirit that he had. 711 00:42:21,206 --> 00:42:24,109 I can't believe David took that away from me. 712 00:42:24,143 --> 00:42:26,945 - Brad was just a ball of sunshine. 713 00:42:26,979 --> 00:42:31,450 Whenever I look at pictures of Brad, I just see that smile. 714 00:42:31,483 --> 00:42:34,086 I wanna remember that smile, 715 00:42:34,086 --> 00:42:35,387 that laugh. 716 00:42:40,159 --> 00:42:41,694 - I do miss him, 717 00:42:41,727 --> 00:42:44,129 very much every day, 718 00:42:44,163 --> 00:42:45,230 yeah. 719 00:42:46,398 --> 00:42:50,369 - The tears that I'm crying is not only for my son, 720 00:42:50,402 --> 00:42:52,137 but for Brad's family. 721 00:42:52,171 --> 00:42:55,407 I would not say I've lost just as much as Brad's mother. 722 00:42:55,441 --> 00:42:59,645 There is no way I can compare my life to her life. 723 00:42:59,678 --> 00:43:01,780 She literally lost her son, 724 00:43:01,814 --> 00:43:04,683 who will never have a life. 725 00:43:06,352 --> 00:43:09,655 - There is a famous saying that love conquers all, 726 00:43:09,688 --> 00:43:12,191 and many of us believe that to be true. 727 00:43:12,224 --> 00:43:15,761 Perhaps Brad, in his desire to find a life partner, 728 00:43:15,794 --> 00:43:17,763 thought love would find a way. 729 00:43:17,796 --> 00:43:20,899 His bond with David was that strong. 730 00:43:20,933 --> 00:43:25,337 And David, a man who found himself in love with two people, 731 00:43:25,371 --> 00:43:27,239 thought he could have it all. 732 00:43:27,272 --> 00:43:30,209 But love built upon lies, 733 00:43:30,242 --> 00:43:31,443 mistrust, 734 00:43:31,477 --> 00:43:32,644 and cruel deception 735 00:43:32,678 --> 00:43:35,381 is never destined for a happy ending. 736 00:43:35,981 --> 00:43:38,650 Sadly, what may have once started 737 00:43:38,684 --> 00:43:40,519 as a hopeful love story, 738 00:43:40,552 --> 00:43:41,920 was turned 739 00:43:41,954 --> 00:43:44,390 into a killer relationship.