1
00:00:00,266 --> 00:00:01,600
Did you cheat on me?
2
00:00:01,667 --> 00:00:04,333
{\an8}
Now, on Tribunal Justice...
3
00:00:04,400 --> 00:00:06,467
- It was an open relationship.
- Correct.
4
00:00:07,233 --> 00:00:09,166
Did you have a boyfriend
on the side?
5
00:00:09,233 --> 00:00:10,533
Yes, I did.
6
00:00:10,600 --> 00:00:12,533
You accused her of being a sexaholic.
7
00:00:12,600 --> 00:00:14,533
- That's correct.
- Whatever!
8
00:00:14,600 --> 00:00:16,567
She was transparent,
you didn't like it.
9
00:00:16,633 --> 00:00:19,133
If she's that screwed up,
leave her.
10
00:00:19,200 --> 00:00:20,200
You need some help.
11
00:00:44,200 --> 00:00:47,000
Today's case
was filed in Spokane, Washington.
12
00:00:48,066 --> 00:00:50,900
{\an8}Your Honor, this is Case #3074
on the calendar
13
00:00:50,967 --> 00:00:52,934
{\an8}in the matter of
Earney vs. Perkins.
14
00:00:53,000 --> 00:00:54,934
{\an8}- Thank you, Byrd.
You're welcome, Judge.
15
00:00:55,000 --> 00:00:57,266
Parties have been sworn in.
Be seated.
16
00:00:57,333 --> 00:01:00,200
Ms. Earney and Mr. Perkins,
the two of you
17
00:01:00,266 --> 00:01:04,533
{\an8}had an on again, off again relationship
over the past five years.
18
00:01:04,600 --> 00:01:07,166
{\an8}At one point, the two of you
even lived together.
19
00:01:07,233 --> 00:01:10,767
During that time, Ms. Earney,
you became quite ill,
20
00:01:10,834 --> 00:01:13,834
and then you broke up.
And then, you got back together again.
21
00:01:13,900 --> 00:01:17,200
Uh, you reconnected
and you planned a trip.
22
00:01:17,266 --> 00:01:20,233
But you broke up again
before that trip.
23
00:01:20,300 --> 00:01:23,233
And Ms. Earney, you're in court today
suing the Defendant
24
00:01:23,300 --> 00:01:26,800
because you allege
that you paid for your half of the trip.
25
00:01:26,867 --> 00:01:30,333
But he's refused to reimburse you
for those expenses.
26
00:01:30,400 --> 00:01:34,033
{\an8}You are suing the Defendant for $1,690.
27
00:01:34,100 --> 00:01:37,633
{\an8}And sir, you say that any money
that she did pay you,
28
00:01:37,700 --> 00:01:39,934
{\an8}went toward another debt
that she owed you.
29
00:01:40,000 --> 00:01:42,333
{\an8}And in fact,
you have a countersuit against her.
30
00:01:42,400 --> 00:01:45,767
You maintain that after she recovered
from her brain condition,
31
00:01:45,834 --> 00:01:50,033
she never reassumed her rent obligations,
and she owes you money for that.
32
00:01:50,100 --> 00:01:53,033
{\an8}Uh, you're suing her also
for invasion of privacy
33
00:01:53,100 --> 00:01:56,200
{\an8}for going through your phone.
And you also have a claim against her
34
00:01:56,266 --> 00:02:00,800
{\an8}for emotional distress
as a result of her alleged cheating.
35
00:02:00,867 --> 00:02:04,667
Uh, well, the two of you have
a really nice origin story.
36
00:02:04,734 --> 00:02:07,433
You met about five years ago
on a dating site.
37
00:02:07,500 --> 00:02:11,800
And I thought that your first date
sounded so delightful.
38
00:02:11,867 --> 00:02:14,500
You went to the park.
You swung on the swings.
39
00:02:14,567 --> 00:02:16,800
- Yes.
- And you moved in together
40
00:02:16,867 --> 00:02:18,734
- about a year later.
- Correct.
41
00:02:18,800 --> 00:02:21,967
I think it was a little over a year
after you moved in
42
00:02:22,033 --> 00:02:24,600
that you were diagnosed
with a brain injury.
43
00:02:24,667 --> 00:02:29,133
{\an8}Correct. Um, basically,
it was my memory that went.
44
00:02:29,200 --> 00:02:32,934
{\an8}Um, first started having
memory issues,
45
00:02:33,000 --> 00:02:35,900
and then it began into hallucinations.
46
00:02:35,967 --> 00:02:39,700
And slurred speech.
47
00:02:39,767 --> 00:02:45,266
Kevin can even allude to it more,
because he was there, and I wasn't.
48
00:02:45,333 --> 00:02:50,467
In fact, sir, you know, Mr. Perkins,
what the Plaintiff says in her complaint
49
00:02:50,533 --> 00:02:52,700
is that you did your best
to take care of her.
50
00:02:52,767 --> 00:02:55,767
What were the circumstances like
when she wasn't doin' so well
51
00:02:55,834 --> 00:02:57,066
and you were stepping up?
52
00:02:57,133 --> 00:02:59,867
{\an8}Like the first week is
when she started hallucinating.
53
00:02:59,934 --> 00:03:01,600
{\an8}She went down pretty fast.
54
00:03:01,667 --> 00:03:04,467
She started getting slow movements,
you know,
55
00:03:04,533 --> 00:03:07,567
and then she was kind of just
in and out of it, reality.
56
00:03:07,633 --> 00:03:10,934
She would like start picking things up
off the floor that weren't there,
57
00:03:11,000 --> 00:03:12,700
or in the air, you know?
58
00:03:12,767 --> 00:03:15,033
So, I took her to ER
to find out what was going on.
59
00:03:15,100 --> 00:03:17,400
I took her like three times
during that time.
60
00:03:17,467 --> 00:03:19,533
How long would you say she was sick
61
00:03:19,600 --> 00:03:21,767
during the period of time
you were living together?
62
00:03:21,834 --> 00:03:25,100
She moved in in August.
The first three months was really good.
63
00:03:25,166 --> 00:03:27,333
You know, everything
was going really good.
64
00:03:27,400 --> 00:03:29,900
Late January, it just started
going downhill from there.
65
00:03:29,967 --> 00:03:32,500
But it took like August
till she got better.
66
00:03:32,567 --> 00:03:37,500
After August, that's when things started
to kind of go downhill
67
00:03:37,567 --> 00:03:39,367
between the two of you
again personally.
68
00:03:39,433 --> 00:03:41,934
And then, you moved out
that following January.
69
00:03:42,000 --> 00:03:44,266
- Correct.
- And then, you reconnected.
70
00:03:44,333 --> 00:03:48,266
In, I think it was in October
of around last year,
71
00:03:48,333 --> 00:03:50,867
you planned a trip that was
going to take place this year.
72
00:03:50,934 --> 00:03:53,100
- Yes.
- You were gonna go on a Carnival Cruise.
73
00:03:53,166 --> 00:03:56,033
{\an8}- Where was the cruise?
To the Western Caribbean.
74
00:03:56,100 --> 00:03:57,734
{\an8}
You were going to the Western Caribbean,
75
00:03:57,800 --> 00:04:03,300
{\an8}and she did pay you for what she maintains
was some portion of the cruise.
76
00:04:03,367 --> 00:04:04,567
How much did you pay him, ma'am?
77
00:04:04,633 --> 00:04:06,467
One thousand, six hundred ninety dollars.
78
00:04:06,533 --> 00:04:08,867
One thousand,
six hundred and ninety dollars.
79
00:04:08,934 --> 00:04:10,700
And you don't deny receiving that money.
80
00:04:10,767 --> 00:04:13,066
She wrote you a check.
We have a copy of the check.
81
00:04:13,133 --> 00:04:14,834
That was a combination of a lot of things.
82
00:04:14,900 --> 00:04:17,500
What she says was the cruise,
you say something else.
83
00:04:17,567 --> 00:04:18,700
Correct, ma'am.
84
00:04:18,767 --> 00:04:21,100
So, she writes you a check for the cruise.
85
00:04:21,166 --> 00:04:24,333
But before the two of you are supposed
to go on the cruise together,
86
00:04:24,400 --> 00:04:27,533
something else happens.
You take a trip to Vegas.
87
00:04:27,600 --> 00:04:29,533
- Yes, I did.
- You didn't like the fact
88
00:04:29,600 --> 00:04:30,967
that she took a trip to Vegas.
89
00:04:31,033 --> 00:04:34,233
{\an8}It's weird, because she never
goes on a vacation by herself.
90
00:04:34,300 --> 00:04:38,000
I believe that Brenda Earney
has a sex addiction.
91
00:04:38,066 --> 00:04:41,467
{\an8}Oh, no, no, no. I thought
we were going in a different direction.
92
00:04:41,533 --> 00:04:42,633
{\an8}
93
00:04:42,700 --> 00:04:44,967
{\an8}
No, no, no.
94
00:04:45,033 --> 00:04:47,367
{\an8}Um, here's what I'm gonna do,
95
00:04:47,433 --> 00:04:51,333
because I don't really want to go...
96
00:04:51,400 --> 00:04:55,467
too deeply into your bedroom.
97
00:04:55,533 --> 00:04:58,667
But you take pains in your complaint
to say,
98
00:04:58,734 --> 00:05:01,700
you know, when we reconnected,
he was seeing somebody,
99
00:05:01,767 --> 00:05:04,066
I was seeing somebody.
It was an open relationship.
100
00:05:04,133 --> 00:05:06,533
- Correct.
- And you tell us in your answer
101
00:05:06,600 --> 00:05:09,033
that you were very suspicious
about that trip.
102
00:05:09,100 --> 00:05:13,000
And that trip is why you
ultimately canceled the Caribbean trip.
103
00:05:13,066 --> 00:05:16,533
So, tell me why you canceled
the trip to the Caribbean
104
00:05:16,600 --> 00:05:17,967
you were planning with the Plaintiff.
105
00:05:18,033 --> 00:05:21,734
The second time we got back together
I said, you gotta be transparent with me,
106
00:05:21,800 --> 00:05:25,133
100% transparent. She told me
she was seeing this guy named Scott.
107
00:05:25,200 --> 00:05:26,834
And she would see him on Fridays.
108
00:05:26,900 --> 00:05:29,500
{\an8}Well, I've never shared somebody
with somebody else.
109
00:05:29,567 --> 00:05:32,100
{\an8}This is kinda weird
and different for me, you know.
110
00:05:32,166 --> 00:05:33,700
{\an8}
But she told you.
111
00:05:33,767 --> 00:05:36,700
But I just think it was more to it
than just that Scott guy.
112
00:05:36,767 --> 00:05:39,934
But anyhow, I met this gal
at the landfield
113
00:05:40,000 --> 00:05:41,700
in Portland, Oregon.
114
00:05:41,767 --> 00:05:45,467
'Cause I haul ash over there, right.
I met her,
115
00:05:45,533 --> 00:05:48,266
but there was no sexual relationship
goin', just friendship.
116
00:05:48,333 --> 00:05:51,233
So, you met somebody,
you say it wasn't intimate.
117
00:05:51,300 --> 00:05:55,633
She told you that she was seeing Scott
on Fridays.
118
00:05:55,700 --> 00:05:59,100
You suspect that there may have been
other Scotts.
119
00:05:59,166 --> 00:06:02,000
But the point is,
she goes to Vegas,
120
00:06:02,066 --> 00:06:05,133
and you cancel the trip
to the Caribbean.
121
00:06:05,200 --> 00:06:06,333
Yes, I did.
122
00:06:06,400 --> 00:06:08,700
And then,
that brings us to her claim.
123
00:06:08,767 --> 00:06:14,433
Because she wrote you a check
on October 26th, 2024,
124
00:06:14,500 --> 00:06:17,033
for $1,690.
125
00:06:17,100 --> 00:06:20,367
She alleges that that was money
she paid toward the cruise.
126
00:06:20,433 --> 00:06:23,367
You allege that that was money
that went toward
127
00:06:23,433 --> 00:06:25,100
- rental expenses and the like.
- No.
128
00:06:25,166 --> 00:06:26,967
I thought that's what you said
in your answer.
129
00:06:27,033 --> 00:06:30,767
{\an8}Concert tickets, um...
and then, I got this, uh...
130
00:06:30,834 --> 00:06:34,367
{\an8}mess-free cat litter box.
I said I'd go half on it.
131
00:06:34,433 --> 00:06:37,233
Yeah, that's right. You were suing her
also for the cat litter box.
132
00:06:37,300 --> 00:06:39,066
Not... I wasn't suing her for that.
133
00:06:39,133 --> 00:06:42,166
But that was just part of the money
that she's talking about.
134
00:06:42,233 --> 00:06:45,867
That's why I said,
that isn't exactly the ticket expenses.
135
00:06:45,934 --> 00:06:49,400
Um, I'll be quite candid.
I'm inclined to see it as cruise money.
136
00:06:49,467 --> 00:06:51,700
You planned the trip in October.
137
00:06:51,767 --> 00:06:53,834
She wrote you the check in October.
138
00:06:53,900 --> 00:06:55,767
She moved out in January.
139
00:06:55,834 --> 00:06:58,900
I didn't see any record
of your saying,
140
00:06:58,967 --> 00:07:02,000
you know, look, I need you
to pay me back for the rent.
141
00:07:02,066 --> 00:07:04,433
I need you to pay me back
for the money I spent
142
00:07:04,500 --> 00:07:06,033
moving you out of my home.
143
00:07:06,100 --> 00:07:09,700
I never saw any request
for repayment of those items.
144
00:07:09,767 --> 00:07:11,800
How are you gonna
convince me otherwise?
145
00:07:13,533 --> 00:07:16,133
Coming up on Tribunal Justice...
146
00:07:16,200 --> 00:07:17,400
You guys need counseling.
147
00:07:17,467 --> 00:07:19,200
Really.
148
00:07:19,266 --> 00:07:20,934
You're suspicious
of every move she makes.
149
00:07:21,000 --> 00:07:23,467
If she goes to the grocery store
and isn't back in an hour,
150
00:07:23,533 --> 00:07:26,533
you start to think she's got
a relationship goin' on with the cashier.
151
00:07:31,600 --> 00:07:34,233
{\an8}Brenda Earney
says ex-boyfriend Kevin Perkins
152
00:07:34,300 --> 00:07:39,233
{\an8}owes her almost $1,700, her half
of a cruise that Kevin canceled.
153
00:07:39,300 --> 00:07:42,834
Kevin admits pulling the plug,
blaming Brenda for cheating on him.
154
00:07:42,900 --> 00:07:46,600
So, he's countersuing for $5,000,
in rent, concert tickets,
155
00:07:46,667 --> 00:07:49,967
a cat litter box,
and invasion of privacy.
156
00:07:50,033 --> 00:07:52,500
{\an8}I didn't see any record of your saying,
157
00:07:52,567 --> 00:07:55,633
{\an8}you know, look, I need you
to pay me back for the rent.
158
00:07:55,700 --> 00:07:57,967
{\an8}I need you to pay me back
for the money I spent
159
00:07:58,033 --> 00:07:59,600
{\an8}moving you out of my home.
160
00:07:59,667 --> 00:08:03,266
{\an8}I never saw any request
for repayment of those items.
161
00:08:03,333 --> 00:08:05,300
How are you gonna
convince me otherwise?
162
00:08:05,367 --> 00:08:07,667
It was the 13th through the 16th
she was down in Vegas;
163
00:08:07,734 --> 00:08:10,233
of November.
The 16th, I picked her up.
164
00:08:10,300 --> 00:08:12,266
She comes over to the house,
stays the night.
165
00:08:12,333 --> 00:08:15,834
{\an8}The next morning, she made me coffee,
and I said, I'm gonna go and shower.
166
00:08:15,900 --> 00:08:19,000
{\an8}I go in and shower and come back out,
and I leave the water running,
167
00:08:19,066 --> 00:08:22,033
'cause I kinda dropped my phone.
I baited her to see if she'd use my...
168
00:08:22,100 --> 00:08:23,800
get in my phone.
And she got in my phone.
169
00:08:23,867 --> 00:08:26,233
We're now talking
about your counterclaim.
170
00:08:26,300 --> 00:08:28,033
- Did you go through his phone?
- No, ma'am.
171
00:08:28,100 --> 00:08:31,467
{\an8}He has face recognition
and a code on it.
172
00:08:31,533 --> 00:08:32,834
{\an8}And if he had a code on it,
173
00:08:32,900 --> 00:08:34,667
{\an8}and he thought I was goin'
through his phone,
174
00:08:34,734 --> 00:08:36,033
{\an8}he should've changed his code.
175
00:08:36,100 --> 00:08:37,934
I watched her for ten seconds.
176
00:08:38,000 --> 00:08:40,000
But listen. You know, without more,
177
00:08:40,066 --> 00:08:42,467
I just don't see a path
to invasion of privacy.
178
00:08:42,533 --> 00:08:46,734
What I see is somebody who is miffed,
broken-hearted,
179
00:08:46,800 --> 00:08:50,066
annoyed she's suing you after
everything you went through together.
180
00:08:50,133 --> 00:08:52,133
You did take care of her
while she was sick.
181
00:08:52,200 --> 00:08:55,533
And I don't think you expected her
to pay you rent while she was ill.
182
00:08:55,600 --> 00:08:58,300
There's not one text message.
There's nothing.
183
00:08:58,367 --> 00:09:00,700
{\an8}There was a verbal agreement
when she moved in with me.
184
00:09:00,767 --> 00:09:03,266
{\an8}There was three things
that I said to her.
185
00:09:03,333 --> 00:09:06,533
{\an8}Three hundred dollars a month,
help with the food,
186
00:09:06,600 --> 00:09:08,800
and then, I also said
we're not getting married.
187
00:09:08,867 --> 00:09:10,467
So... she had Scott on Friday.
188
00:09:10,533 --> 00:09:14,667
It sounds like marriage wasn't necessarily
on her radar.
189
00:09:14,734 --> 00:09:18,834
But I am not seeing the legal basis
on which you could recover.
190
00:09:18,900 --> 00:09:20,367
You know, my colleagues may differ.
191
00:09:20,433 --> 00:09:23,900
You'll have more time to testify.
I'm gonna pass the case to Judge DiMango.
192
00:09:23,967 --> 00:09:26,533
You guys need counseling.
193
00:09:26,600 --> 00:09:28,467
Really. It's not funny.
194
00:09:28,533 --> 00:09:30,767
I read these papers
and I'm here saying,
195
00:09:30,834 --> 00:09:32,700
{\an8}you're suspicious
of every move she makes.
196
00:09:32,767 --> 00:09:35,100
{\an8}If she goes to the grocery store
and isn't back in an hour,
197
00:09:35,166 --> 00:09:38,166
you start to think she's got
a relationship goin' on with the cashier.
198
00:09:38,233 --> 00:09:41,667
I mean, seriously,
you were an extremely jealous person.
199
00:09:41,734 --> 00:09:44,300
- Am I right or wrong?
- No, ma'am, you're not.
200
00:09:44,367 --> 00:09:46,734
You're not jealous?
Do you want me to read this stuff?
201
00:09:46,800 --> 00:09:50,066
I give all the ladies
a lot of freedom in my life.
202
00:09:50,133 --> 00:09:51,400
- Uh-huh.
- I do.
203
00:09:51,467 --> 00:09:53,033
And I'm gonna go back to you.
204
00:09:53,100 --> 00:09:56,433
Just out of curiosity,
did you have a boyfriend on the side?
205
00:09:56,500 --> 00:09:59,200
{\an8}- Scott. On Friday night.
Scott on the side?
206
00:09:59,266 --> 00:10:01,900
{\an8}So, he's not crazy,
but he's jealous.
207
00:10:01,967 --> 00:10:03,233
{\an8}I mean, that's normal.
208
00:10:03,300 --> 00:10:05,934
But you accused her
of being a sexaholic.
209
00:10:06,000 --> 00:10:07,000
That's correct.
210
00:10:07,066 --> 00:10:09,800
You're saying that from August
when she got better
211
00:10:09,867 --> 00:10:12,834
until January,
when she moved out,
212
00:10:12,900 --> 00:10:15,000
that she was foolin' around.
213
00:10:15,066 --> 00:10:18,633
That she was gettin' all dolled up.
That was your words.
214
00:10:18,700 --> 00:10:19,767
Correct.
215
00:10:19,834 --> 00:10:25,166
Now, that's the only timeframe, however,
that you're looking for this $300 a month.
216
00:10:25,233 --> 00:10:27,400
I'm gonna ask you,
'cause I believe you had an agreement.
217
00:10:27,467 --> 00:10:30,300
I don't think you were freeloading
off of him. Were you giving him money?
218
00:10:30,367 --> 00:10:33,400
I gave him some when I could
before I got sick.
219
00:10:33,467 --> 00:10:35,033
- Do you work for a living?
- Yes, I do.
220
00:10:35,100 --> 00:10:37,367
- What do you do?
- I'm a medical assistant.
221
00:10:37,433 --> 00:10:39,967
So, you are giving him
a certain amount of money a month
222
00:10:40,033 --> 00:10:41,700
- to cover expenses.
- Sure.
223
00:10:41,767 --> 00:10:43,800
And you took care of her
for four months.
224
00:10:43,867 --> 00:10:46,000
So, you really did have feelings
for one another,
225
00:10:46,066 --> 00:10:48,100
strong feelings.
And then, once she got better
226
00:10:48,166 --> 00:10:51,066
and started to go back out again,
August to July,
227
00:10:51,133 --> 00:10:53,000
that was when you want that money.
228
00:10:53,066 --> 00:10:55,166
Now, she admits to giving you some money,
229
00:10:55,233 --> 00:10:57,700
but I don't know the nature
of that relationship.
230
00:10:57,767 --> 00:11:01,633
So, when she writes that check
for $1,168
231
00:11:01,700 --> 00:11:06,533
on the date that you booked the trip,
that is exactly half of the cruise. Half.
232
00:11:06,600 --> 00:11:09,000
But if you prematurely canceled the trip,
233
00:11:09,066 --> 00:11:11,700
there's an issue as to
who's responsible for the airfare
234
00:11:11,767 --> 00:11:14,767
and what role she played
in this cancelation on a trip.
235
00:11:14,834 --> 00:11:18,400
The excursion.
She was giving you half the excursion.
236
00:11:18,467 --> 00:11:20,300
{\an8}Half of it was $240.
237
00:11:20,367 --> 00:11:22,734
{\an8}That's one thing she didn't pay for
is the excursion.
238
00:11:22,800 --> 00:11:24,233
{\an8}Did you pay for the excursion?
239
00:11:24,300 --> 00:11:26,166
It was included in the check.
240
00:11:26,233 --> 00:11:29,400
Do you have proof you paid?
The check for $1,600 and some odd dollars.
241
00:11:29,467 --> 00:11:33,266
Correct? By the way, you got reimbursed by
the cruise ship for the money.
242
00:11:33,333 --> 00:11:34,600
I got reimbursed.
243
00:11:34,667 --> 00:11:36,967
You got reimbursed.
So, you have that money.
244
00:11:37,033 --> 00:11:40,500
So, moving along.
I want to go to your counterclaim.
245
00:11:40,567 --> 00:11:42,967
You think she's cheating all the time.
246
00:11:43,033 --> 00:11:45,934
You were trying to set her up
with that phone.
247
00:11:46,000 --> 00:11:49,266
Why would you think that she was
going through your phone,
248
00:11:49,333 --> 00:11:51,667
when you were the one thinking
she was cheating?
249
00:11:51,734 --> 00:11:53,633
Why were you trying to set her up
with that?
250
00:11:53,700 --> 00:11:55,700
Ma'am, I have nothing to hide.
Seriously.
251
00:11:55,767 --> 00:11:58,834
She's just guilty because the fact
that she wanted to see if I was cheating.
252
00:11:58,900 --> 00:12:01,633
I'm gonna tell ya, she said nothing
about looking at your phone.
253
00:12:01,700 --> 00:12:04,333
You're suing for what isn't
a legal cause of action at all.
254
00:12:04,400 --> 00:12:07,233
Invasion of privacy
because somebody looks at your phone.
255
00:12:07,300 --> 00:12:09,967
But you're saying here
that when Brenda returned
256
00:12:10,033 --> 00:12:12,867
from her trip in Vegas, November 24,
257
00:12:12,934 --> 00:12:16,100
that Sunday morning,
she got up and made us coffee.
258
00:12:16,166 --> 00:12:20,900
When I went to take a shower,
you put in quotes "accidentally."
259
00:12:20,967 --> 00:12:24,800
Which means, you intentionally
"dropped my phone,"
260
00:12:24,867 --> 00:12:27,200
that's you talking,
"in the hamper.
261
00:12:27,266 --> 00:12:30,867
I wanted to see if she
would go through my phone or not.
262
00:12:30,934 --> 00:12:35,467
I left the shower on in the bathroom
to grab my phone,
263
00:12:35,533 --> 00:12:37,633
and saw Brenda going through it.
264
00:12:37,700 --> 00:12:40,433
She was caught red-handed.
265
00:12:40,500 --> 00:12:43,000
I never had anything to hide."
266
00:12:43,066 --> 00:12:47,567
You see, you're suspicious of her.
You think she's hiding.
267
00:12:47,633 --> 00:12:50,400
This is so typical,
you'd be a therapist's delight.
268
00:12:50,467 --> 00:12:53,700
You think she's cheating.
You're checking everything she's doing.
269
00:12:53,767 --> 00:12:55,633
You're monitoring her every move.
270
00:12:55,700 --> 00:12:57,734
That's wrong to do in a relationship.
271
00:12:57,800 --> 00:13:00,333
If she's that screwed up, leave her.
272
00:13:00,400 --> 00:13:04,633
If we give you any money at all,
take it to the first psychiatrist.
273
00:13:04,700 --> 00:13:06,367
Because you need some help.
274
00:13:07,600 --> 00:13:09,800
Coming up on Tribunal Justice...
275
00:13:10,200 --> 00:13:11,734
You know, you're saying very little.
276
00:13:11,800 --> 00:13:13,767
- And you have the case to prove here.
- Mm-hmm.
277
00:13:13,834 --> 00:13:15,867
I want to know,
why did you go through his phone?
278
00:13:20,467 --> 00:13:23,567
{\an8}Brenda Earney
is suing ex-boyfriend Kevin Perkins
279
00:13:23,633 --> 00:13:25,633
{\an8}for almost $1,700,
280
00:13:25,700 --> 00:13:29,166
half the cost of a Caribbean cruise
canceled out of jealousy.
281
00:13:29,233 --> 00:13:32,600
But Kevin says Brenda
ruined the relationship by cheating again,
282
00:13:32,667 --> 00:13:35,734
and is countersuing for $5,000,
for concert tickets,
283
00:13:35,800 --> 00:13:39,400
a cat litter box, rent,
and invasion of privacy.
284
00:13:39,467 --> 00:13:42,433
{\an8}You know, you're saying very little,
and you have the case to prove here.
285
00:13:42,500 --> 00:13:45,266
{\an8}So, I want to know,
why'd you go through his phone?
286
00:13:45,333 --> 00:13:49,100
{\an8}That one day, he threw it in front of me
in the hamper.
287
00:13:49,166 --> 00:13:52,000
{\an8}- Mm-hmm.
To hide it, in front of me.
288
00:13:52,066 --> 00:13:54,633
So, I pick it up.
Like, he's trying to hide something.
289
00:13:54,700 --> 00:13:57,667
So, I pick up his phone,
he comes out of the bathroom.
290
00:13:57,734 --> 00:14:01,400
I'm holding his phone.
And he said, caught ya.
291
00:14:01,467 --> 00:14:04,633
And I'm, whatever.
Why are you hiding...
292
00:14:04,700 --> 00:14:08,567
{\an8}What are you hiding in your phone
that you have to hide it in the hamper?
293
00:14:08,633 --> 00:14:11,867
{\an8}Why didn't the two of you
break up sooner and stay apart?
294
00:14:11,934 --> 00:14:15,467
{\an8}You shouldn't be with anybody if you're
gonna be this jealous and concerned...
295
00:14:15,533 --> 00:14:16,900
I knew it wouldn't work out.
296
00:14:16,967 --> 00:14:19,433
Good I got you talking.
You've been so quiet for so long.
297
00:14:19,500 --> 00:14:21,166
Now, we can't stop you.
Judge Levy.
298
00:14:21,233 --> 00:14:23,633
Mr. Perkins, you said to Judge Acker
299
00:14:23,700 --> 00:14:29,000
{\an8}that the $1,690 check
that you received from the Plaintiff
300
00:14:29,066 --> 00:14:32,133
{\an8}on October 26th, 2024,
301
00:14:32,200 --> 00:14:36,033
was for a lot of things,
but not the cruise expenses.
302
00:14:36,100 --> 00:14:37,934
- Do you recall that testimony?
- Yes, Your Honor.
303
00:14:38,000 --> 00:14:41,467
So, what were
the other things that you claim
304
00:14:41,533 --> 00:14:44,967
that $1,690 was for?
305
00:14:45,033 --> 00:14:50,033
{\an8}Um, the concert ticket
and um, the cat litter box.
306
00:14:50,100 --> 00:14:52,967
{\an8}I told her I'd go half
on the cat litter box with her, so.
307
00:14:53,033 --> 00:14:57,033
So, concert, cat litter box,
and also a portion of this rent
308
00:14:57,100 --> 00:14:58,800
that you claim that she owed you?
309
00:14:58,867 --> 00:15:00,433
No, that wasn't part of that.
310
00:15:00,500 --> 00:15:02,166
That wasn't part. Okay.
311
00:15:02,233 --> 00:15:04,867
Now we know what you thought
that check was for.
312
00:15:04,934 --> 00:15:08,367
Now, I want you to tell me
what all the expenses were
313
00:15:08,433 --> 00:15:12,033
for the cruise to see
if all the expenses for the cruise,
314
00:15:12,100 --> 00:15:16,867
which included airfare, the ticket
for the cruise, and the excursion.
315
00:15:16,934 --> 00:15:21,834
'Cause you would agree
that if those three things equal $1,690,
316
00:15:21,900 --> 00:15:25,033
then your argument
would just fall, correct?
317
00:15:25,100 --> 00:15:26,233
Correct.
318
00:15:26,300 --> 00:15:28,800
So, what was the cruise price?
319
00:15:28,867 --> 00:15:31,200
Between the two of us,
it was $2,324.
320
00:15:31,266 --> 00:15:33,166
- Cruise price per person...
- Hold on.
321
00:15:33,233 --> 00:15:34,233
...eleven sixty-eight.
322
00:15:34,300 --> 00:15:37,667
Okay.
So, even according to your math,
323
00:15:37,734 --> 00:15:39,900
- it was about $1,171.
- Correct.
324
00:15:39,967 --> 00:15:43,467
{\an8}So, let's take $1,168.
That's close enough, right?
325
00:15:43,533 --> 00:15:47,200
{\an8}The Alaskan flight, $562.42,
326
00:15:47,266 --> 00:15:50,066
which equals $282 each.
Correct?
327
00:15:50,133 --> 00:15:52,100
- Yes.
- Yes, Your Honor.
328
00:15:52,166 --> 00:15:56,734
{\an8}Okay. And then, finally,
the two excursions were $240, right?
329
00:15:56,800 --> 00:15:58,166
{\an8}- Mm-hmm, correct.
Correct.
330
00:15:58,233 --> 00:16:03,500
{\an8}So, $1,168
plus $282 for the flight,
331
00:16:03,567 --> 00:16:05,834
{\an8}plus the excursions for $240.
332
00:16:05,900 --> 00:16:08,767
{\an8}Can you take guess
what those three numbers add up to?
333
00:16:08,834 --> 00:16:10,266
{\an8}
Probably around $1,690?
334
00:16:10,333 --> 00:16:14,734
{\an8}Sixteen-ninety. So in fact,
that check you received from the Plaintiff
335
00:16:14,800 --> 00:16:17,367
was only for the trip
and for nothing else. Correct?
336
00:16:17,433 --> 00:16:18,767
Yes, Your Honor.
337
00:16:18,834 --> 00:16:20,100
I have nothing further.
Thank you.
338
00:16:20,166 --> 00:16:22,667
Ms. Earney, when did you go back to work,
339
00:16:22,734 --> 00:16:24,500
- or did you go back to work.
- Yes.
340
00:16:24,567 --> 00:16:26,233
- When did you go back?
- Yes.
341
00:16:26,300 --> 00:16:29,633
{\an8}In January 30th of 2022.
342
00:16:29,700 --> 00:16:32,233
Which is when
you moved out of the Plaintiff's home.
343
00:16:32,300 --> 00:16:33,867
- Yes.
- So, you got a new job
344
00:16:33,934 --> 00:16:35,800
- after you moved out.
- Correct.
345
00:16:35,867 --> 00:16:40,500
August, September, or thereabouts,
were you still in treatment?
346
00:16:40,567 --> 00:16:41,734
For your condition?
347
00:16:41,800 --> 00:16:45,333
I was, um... In August of '22,
348
00:16:45,400 --> 00:16:50,633
{\an8}I completely opened myself up
to identity theft.
349
00:16:50,700 --> 00:16:54,266
{\an8}To give you an idea
of where my mental health was.
350
00:16:54,333 --> 00:16:56,166
I took a phone call,
351
00:16:56,233 --> 00:17:01,567
thought it was, um, our power company.
352
00:17:01,633 --> 00:17:04,266
It was not, it was a scam artist.
353
00:17:04,333 --> 00:17:07,800
My mental capacity was so bad,
354
00:17:07,867 --> 00:17:11,233
I gave them all of my identity.
355
00:17:11,300 --> 00:17:15,133
Gave 'em my social security number,
my driver's license,
356
00:17:15,200 --> 00:17:18,834
my password to my bank account.
Everything.
357
00:17:18,900 --> 00:17:22,166
How was your health the balance
of the year, before you moved out?
358
00:17:22,233 --> 00:17:23,600
Getting stronger every month.
359
00:17:23,667 --> 00:17:26,033
- But you weren't working?
- Not working.
360
00:17:26,100 --> 00:17:27,700
Thank you.
I don't have anything else.
361
00:17:27,767 --> 00:17:29,433
You did write a letter to her, correct?
362
00:17:29,500 --> 00:17:30,633
{\an8}
I did, ma'am.
363
00:17:30,700 --> 00:17:33,600
{\an8}And the purpose of this letter
was what?
364
00:17:33,667 --> 00:17:36,934
The letter that's dated
December 14th, 2024,
365
00:17:37,000 --> 00:17:39,333
when you say,
"I tried to be friends with you again
366
00:17:39,400 --> 00:17:42,266
and all you do is lie
and cheat on me.
367
00:17:42,333 --> 00:17:45,800
I wasn't ever going to get back with you,
just be friends.
368
00:17:45,867 --> 00:17:49,667
Our understanding was
we would be transparent with one another.
369
00:17:49,734 --> 00:17:52,200
I thought maybe you would change.
370
00:17:52,266 --> 00:17:55,433
Boy, was I wrong.
You are more messed up."
371
00:17:55,500 --> 00:17:58,033
- You got this letter, didn't you?
- Yes, I did.
372
00:17:58,100 --> 00:17:59,867
- We're gonna...
- Yeah, just, just...
373
00:17:59,934 --> 00:18:02,834
Just one last thing, Mr. Perkins,
with respect to that letter.
374
00:18:02,900 --> 00:18:07,500
{\an8}You also said, quote,
"Since you never paid me the $1,500
375
00:18:07,567 --> 00:18:11,300
for five months' rent,
I'm keeping the cruise money."
376
00:18:11,367 --> 00:18:12,600
- Correct?
- Yes, Your Honor.
377
00:18:12,667 --> 00:18:15,500
That was the first time
that you had mentioned to her
378
00:18:15,567 --> 00:18:18,900
since you got back together,
anything about the $300 a month
379
00:18:18,967 --> 00:18:21,567
- that was owed to you. Correct?
- Yes, Your Honor.
380
00:18:21,633 --> 00:18:24,433
We're gonna retire
to deliberate. Thank you both.
381
00:18:24,500 --> 00:18:25,867
Thank you.
382
00:18:25,934 --> 00:18:27,633
Court now stands in recess.
383
00:18:27,700 --> 00:18:30,500
This case will be recalled.
Parties are excused.
384
00:18:36,900 --> 00:18:39,867
I think I'd like to first start
with the counterclaim.
385
00:18:39,934 --> 00:18:43,934
She never disputes
that she was paying him $300 a month
386
00:18:44,000 --> 00:18:47,800
before she got sick.
She even says that in her complaint.
387
00:18:47,867 --> 00:18:50,133
I think that the question that I have is
388
00:18:50,200 --> 00:18:52,500
whether or not he had
a reasonable expectation
389
00:18:52,567 --> 00:18:55,967
that she was gonna continue that
from the time that she got sick
390
00:18:56,033 --> 00:18:57,700
until the time that she moved out.
391
00:18:57,767 --> 00:19:00,233
And I just don't see any evidence
of that.
392
00:19:00,300 --> 00:19:02,500
There's not a demand,
there's not a request,
393
00:19:02,567 --> 00:19:04,734
there's not a sweet note.
Like, no mention
394
00:19:04,800 --> 00:19:08,333
of any owed monies
until they have a break up
395
00:19:08,400 --> 00:19:12,066
that was clearly very painful for him.
I think that the other items -
396
00:19:12,133 --> 00:19:15,033
money for invasion of privacy
for looking through the phone...
397
00:19:15,100 --> 00:19:16,967
You didn't see
the legal cause of action there?
398
00:19:17,033 --> 00:19:18,633
...the emotional distress.
399
00:19:18,700 --> 00:19:21,233
Again, you know, let's treat it
like a summary judgment.
400
00:19:21,300 --> 00:19:24,467
Assuming she did all of the things
that he says that she did,
401
00:19:24,533 --> 00:19:27,934
I still don't think that they give rise
to a legally cognizable claim.
402
00:19:28,000 --> 00:19:29,266
Hundred percent.
403
00:19:29,333 --> 00:19:30,967
I would dismiss the counterclaim.
404
00:19:31,033 --> 00:19:32,500
- Hundred percent.
- Unanimous.
405
00:19:32,567 --> 00:19:35,333
So, unanimous
on dismissing the counterclaim.
406
00:19:35,400 --> 00:19:38,734
And I think that she's met her burden
on the case in chief.
407
00:19:38,800 --> 00:19:42,166
She's actually taken into account,
I believe, the penalty
408
00:19:42,233 --> 00:19:45,467
that was incurred for the cancelation.
He canceled the trip.
409
00:19:45,533 --> 00:19:48,500
She paid him for the trip.
I think she's entitled to be reimbursed.
410
00:19:48,567 --> 00:19:49,967
She gets what she's asked for.
411
00:19:50,033 --> 00:19:51,433
- I agree.
- Me, too.
412
00:19:51,500 --> 00:19:52,934
- Thank you.
- This is so simple.
413
00:19:53,000 --> 00:19:54,800
- So far, so good.
- We're unanimous.
414
00:19:58,734 --> 00:20:00,000
Court is back in session.
415
00:20:00,066 --> 00:20:01,967
I remind parties you're still under oath.
416
00:20:02,033 --> 00:20:03,233
Thank you, Byrd.
417
00:20:03,300 --> 00:20:06,867
Mr. Perkins, I understand that you have
a question you want to ask Ms. Earney.
418
00:20:06,934 --> 00:20:09,066
- Yes, ma'am.
- You may.
419
00:20:09,133 --> 00:20:11,100
Did you cheat on me?
420
00:20:11,166 --> 00:20:13,166
- Okay...
- That's it.
421
00:20:14,367 --> 00:20:15,567
They need therapy.
422
00:20:15,633 --> 00:20:17,767
I was told I could ask her a question.
423
00:20:17,834 --> 00:20:21,367
I was advised that
you wanted to ask her a question.
424
00:20:21,433 --> 00:20:23,934
- That was the question.
- And that's the question.
425
00:20:24,000 --> 00:20:26,633
You don't have to answer it.
Because I'm gonna say this,
426
00:20:26,700 --> 00:20:28,934
she told you about Scott on Fridays.
427
00:20:29,000 --> 00:20:30,166
I'm not talking about that.
428
00:20:30,233 --> 00:20:32,934
You knew about Scott on Fridays.
You had Mary Mondays.
429
00:20:33,000 --> 00:20:35,867
By the way, she was transparent,
you didn't like it.
430
00:20:35,934 --> 00:20:38,533
And that brings me
to your countersuit, sir.
431
00:20:38,600 --> 00:20:42,967
There is no doubt, the record is clear.
The Plaintiff even acknowledged
432
00:20:43,033 --> 00:20:47,066
that before she got sick,
she was paying you $300 a month.
433
00:20:47,133 --> 00:20:49,133
What you have failed to prove is
434
00:20:49,200 --> 00:20:52,033
that there was
any reasonable expectation of repayment
435
00:20:52,100 --> 00:20:54,900
after she got sick
and during the period of her recovery.
436
00:20:54,967 --> 00:20:57,433
Because you cared about her,
and you were looking after her,
437
00:20:57,500 --> 00:20:58,734
and you wanted her to be well.
438
00:20:58,800 --> 00:21:01,100
You know, again,
as Judge Levy pointed out,
439
00:21:01,166 --> 00:21:03,834
you didn't even ask for any money
until after the breakup.
440
00:21:03,900 --> 00:21:06,533
So, we're unanimous
in dismissing your counterclaim.
441
00:21:06,600 --> 00:21:10,233
This was painful for you.
But you don't always get damages,
442
00:21:10,300 --> 00:21:13,033
money damages, for relationships
that cause you pain.
443
00:21:13,100 --> 00:21:16,734
Ms. Earney, we're also unanimous
in sustaining your complaint
444
00:21:16,800 --> 00:21:19,367
for your request for $1,690.
445
00:21:19,433 --> 00:21:22,066
The Defendant canceled the trip,
and he had your money.
446
00:21:22,133 --> 00:21:23,967
So, you're entitled to that money back.
447
00:21:24,033 --> 00:21:26,867
Look, the two of you
seem like very, very nice people.
448
00:21:26,934 --> 00:21:30,166
And there are many more Scotts,
and Marys,
449
00:21:30,233 --> 00:21:32,300
and all sorts of folks
in the world for you.
450
00:21:32,367 --> 00:21:34,000
So, we really do wish you the best.
451
00:21:34,066 --> 00:21:37,800
The unanimous verdict of this court is
that the Plaintiff should prevail
452
00:21:37,867 --> 00:21:40,300
{\an8}in her complaint,
and the countersuit is dismissed.
453
00:21:40,367 --> 00:21:41,834
{\an8}And good luck to both of you.
454
00:21:41,900 --> 00:21:43,433
{\an8}- Thank you.
Thank you.
455
00:21:43,500 --> 00:21:44,900
{\an8}This case is now concluded.
456
00:21:44,967 --> 00:21:46,700
Parties are excused.
You may step out.
457
00:21:49,867 --> 00:21:53,967
{\an8}They're thinkin' that
I was a controlling person, but I wasn't.
458
00:21:54,033 --> 00:21:58,166
{\an8}Um, the truth came out,
and I got my cruise money back.
459
00:21:58,233 --> 00:22:01,200
{\an8}She just...
She just wouldn't answer me.
460
00:22:01,266 --> 00:22:05,467
{\an8}Us not having a monogamous relationship
wasn't gonna work.
461
00:22:05,533 --> 00:22:06,800
{\an8}She was cheating on me.
462
00:22:06,867 --> 00:22:09,800
{\an8}I wasn't cheating on him.
It was an open relationship.
463
00:22:10,900 --> 00:22:12,000
{\an8}Part ways.
464
00:22:12,066 --> 00:22:13,467
{\an8}Oh, that ship has sailed.
465
00:22:13,533 --> 00:22:16,000
{\an8}
Don't let a bad breakup break the bank.
466
00:22:16,066 --> 00:22:20,166
{\an8}Let the judges of Tribunal Justice
propose a fair solution.
467
00:22:20,233 --> 00:22:22,834
{\an8}Find us on social media.