1 00:00:01,142 --> 00:00:04,446 ♪ 2 00:00:04,546 --> 00:00:06,848 Some stories are unforgettable. 3 00:00:06,948 --> 00:00:09,618 This is one of them. 4 00:00:11,152 --> 00:00:12,187 I remember my knees were shaking, 5 00:00:12,287 --> 00:00:15,156 my palms were all clammy. 6 00:00:15,257 --> 00:00:18,593 I mean, that was an awful day. 7 00:00:18,693 --> 00:00:20,128 It was just so shocking. 8 00:00:20,228 --> 00:00:22,998 I mean, who this has happened to, 9 00:00:23,098 --> 00:00:24,699 my little sister. 10 00:00:24,799 --> 00:00:26,868 What struck me immediately about this story 11 00:00:26,968 --> 00:00:29,871 was the bond between the Shunick sisters. 12 00:00:29,971 --> 00:00:31,706 They were inseparable. 13 00:00:31,806 --> 00:00:33,808 Until the night Mickey vanished... 14 00:00:33,909 --> 00:00:35,944 This was an extraordinary circumstance. 15 00:00:36,044 --> 00:00:38,613 Suddenly, Charlie was everywhere. 16 00:00:38,713 --> 00:00:42,217 Relentless in a crusade for her sister. 17 00:00:42,317 --> 00:00:45,086 Whatever path I was on before, this is different now. 18 00:00:45,186 --> 00:00:46,454 Where was Mickey? 19 00:00:46,554 --> 00:00:50,759 Someone knew the answer and was hiding in plain sight. 20 00:00:50,859 --> 00:00:51,793 [crying] 21 00:00:51,893 --> 00:00:54,029 Even those closest to him didn't know that 22 00:00:54,129 --> 00:00:55,530 he had that secret life. 23 00:00:55,630 --> 00:00:58,300 This case was full of dramatic twists. 24 00:00:58,400 --> 00:01:00,902 The biggest came from Mickey herself. 25 00:01:01,002 --> 00:01:03,738 She helped solve her own murder. 26 00:01:03,838 --> 00:01:05,273 She knew she was fighting for her life. 27 00:01:05,373 --> 00:01:06,875 And she fought. - You're proud of her? 28 00:01:06,975 --> 00:01:09,244 Yeah, it's amazing. Good for Mickey. 29 00:01:09,377 --> 00:01:16,051 ♪ 30 00:01:16,151 --> 00:01:17,986 This is Dateline: Unforgettable. 31 00:01:18,086 --> 00:01:21,856 I'm Josh Mankiewicz with a fresh look at Missing Mickey. 32 00:01:23,959 --> 00:01:26,127 ♪ 33 00:01:26,228 --> 00:01:27,729 Southern Louisiana, 34 00:01:27,829 --> 00:01:33,702 laced with mysterious bayous and twisting waterways, 35 00:01:33,802 --> 00:01:37,472 where surprises lurk around every bend. 36 00:01:37,572 --> 00:01:42,010 A place that can be as dangerous as it is majestic. 37 00:01:43,144 --> 00:01:47,082 It's where all the currents of our story cross. 38 00:01:47,182 --> 00:01:50,852 Fear, secrets, loss. 39 00:01:50,952 --> 00:01:53,622 But most of all, love and family. 40 00:01:53,755 --> 00:01:55,924 ♪ 41 00:01:56,024 --> 00:01:59,361 Charlene and Michaela Shunick grew up here, 42 00:01:59,461 --> 00:02:01,963 near the Gulf Coast in Lafayette. 43 00:02:02,063 --> 00:02:06,568 At first, these two barely tolerated one another. 44 00:02:06,668 --> 00:02:08,803 You and your sister are how far apart in age? 45 00:02:08,904 --> 00:02:09,905 Two years. 46 00:02:10,005 --> 00:02:12,007 So I'm guessing growing up, you were probably 47 00:02:12,107 --> 00:02:15,610 at each other's throats. - Yeah, all the time. 48 00:02:15,710 --> 00:02:16,912 You know, it's war between girls 49 00:02:17,012 --> 00:02:19,314 until they realize they're friends. 50 00:02:19,414 --> 00:02:23,385 But then these two sisters didn't just become friends, 51 00:02:23,485 --> 00:02:24,953 they became best friends. 52 00:02:25,053 --> 00:02:26,288 And once I moved out of my parents house, 53 00:02:26,388 --> 00:02:27,789 we got really close. 54 00:02:27,889 --> 00:02:31,226 In my job, I see all types of family dynamics. 55 00:02:31,326 --> 00:02:33,461 The good, the bad, and sometimes 56 00:02:33,562 --> 00:02:35,730 the impossible to process. 57 00:02:35,830 --> 00:02:38,100 This was different because the bond the Shunick sisters had 58 00:02:39,100 --> 00:02:41,136 was extraordinarily tight. 59 00:02:41,236 --> 00:02:44,139 It's a big reason this story has stayed with me. 60 00:02:44,239 --> 00:02:45,974 Like a lot of siblings close in age, 61 00:02:46,074 --> 00:02:48,143 these two young women expected to share 62 00:02:48,243 --> 00:02:50,545 all of life's milestones. 63 00:02:50,645 --> 00:02:52,981 That future was stolen from them. 64 00:02:53,081 --> 00:02:58,920 And the loss transformed the sister who was left behind. 65 00:02:59,020 --> 00:03:01,489 The Shunick girls had plenty in common. 66 00:03:01,590 --> 00:03:05,493 Big smiles, equally big, puffy yellow hair, 67 00:03:05,594 --> 00:03:08,897 and nicknames they preferred to use. 68 00:03:08,997 --> 00:03:12,033 Charlene was known around Lafayette as Charlie. 69 00:03:12,133 --> 00:03:13,134 And Michaela? 70 00:03:13,235 --> 00:03:15,937 She never ever went by anything but Mickey. 71 00:03:16,037 --> 00:03:18,506 It was always Mickey. No Michaela. 72 00:03:18,607 --> 00:03:21,977 Parents, Tom, a scientist working in the oil industry, 73 00:03:22,077 --> 00:03:25,881 and Nancy, a stay at home mom, kept a watchful eye 74 00:03:25,981 --> 00:03:28,717 as two very similar looking girls 75 00:03:28,817 --> 00:03:31,987 developed two very different personalities. 76 00:03:32,087 --> 00:03:34,122 - Charlie... - Charlie was the dominant one. 77 00:03:34,222 --> 00:03:36,791 She was always really outgoing, really, you know, 78 00:03:36,892 --> 00:03:38,593 just a-a fireball. 79 00:03:38,693 --> 00:03:41,363 Mickey, on the other hand, had an intriguing, 80 00:03:41,463 --> 00:03:43,031 quiet way about her. 81 00:03:43,131 --> 00:03:46,735 She seemed to be sort of an enchanted, magical creature. 82 00:03:46,835 --> 00:03:50,372 She was sarcastic and kind of shy. 83 00:03:50,472 --> 00:03:52,307 - Are you recording? - Are you-- 84 00:03:52,407 --> 00:03:55,377 Are you doing that right now? Come on. 85 00:03:55,477 --> 00:03:57,812 Really quick witted, really funny. 86 00:03:57,913 --> 00:03:59,614 [laughing] 87 00:03:59,714 --> 00:04:03,485 At 21, Mickey lived at home while studying anthropology 88 00:04:03,585 --> 00:04:07,088 at the home of the Ragin Cajuns, 89 00:04:07,188 --> 00:04:10,091 the University of Louisiana at Lafayette. 90 00:04:10,192 --> 00:04:11,593 Where'd you see her going? 91 00:04:11,693 --> 00:04:13,295 I was pretty sure she was gonna end up teaching 92 00:04:13,395 --> 00:04:17,132 horseback riding lessons and... - Mickey go to the jump. 93 00:04:17,232 --> 00:04:19,034 You know, working for an equestrian farm 94 00:04:19,134 --> 00:04:20,735 and maybe owning her own someday. 95 00:04:20,835 --> 00:04:23,305 And when Mickey wasn't with her animals, 96 00:04:23,405 --> 00:04:26,975 you could see her whizzing around town on her bike. 97 00:04:27,075 --> 00:04:28,510 Lafayette's a small town. 98 00:04:28,610 --> 00:04:30,045 You can get anywhere in that city on a bike 99 00:04:30,145 --> 00:04:31,713 in 20 or 30 minutes. 100 00:04:31,813 --> 00:04:33,915 Which is why on a late Friday night 101 00:04:34,015 --> 00:04:35,917 back in May of 2012, 102 00:04:36,017 --> 00:04:38,420 having listened to live music with friends, 103 00:04:38,520 --> 00:04:40,922 Mickey planned on riding her bike home. 104 00:04:41,022 --> 00:04:43,191 We grew up there. It seemed really safe. 105 00:04:43,291 --> 00:04:45,393 Mickey's brother's high school graduation 106 00:04:45,493 --> 00:04:47,629 was just hours away. 107 00:04:47,729 --> 00:04:50,565 But before calling it a night, she decided to stop off 108 00:04:50,665 --> 00:04:54,069 at the home of her friend Brettley Wilson. 109 00:04:54,169 --> 00:04:57,105 She's like, "It's nice out, you know, I'm tired, 110 00:04:57,205 --> 00:04:58,607 but the bike ride's gonna be amazing. 111 00:04:58,707 --> 00:05:00,642 I'll put in my headphones, I'll bike home, 112 00:05:00,742 --> 00:05:01,810 I'll get a couple hours of sleep 113 00:05:01,910 --> 00:05:03,612 and then I'll do the graduation." 114 00:05:03,712 --> 00:05:05,981 Walked her to the door and turned 115 00:05:06,081 --> 00:05:08,750 and told her goodnight and to be safe. 116 00:05:08,850 --> 00:05:12,887 That did not at the time seem like an important moment, 117 00:05:12,988 --> 00:05:17,359 but it would later be revisited and re-examined again and again. 118 00:05:17,459 --> 00:05:19,895 Because somewhere, at some point, 119 00:05:19,995 --> 00:05:23,265 after Brettley says she left his house, 120 00:05:23,365 --> 00:05:25,367 Mickey Shunick vanished. 121 00:05:25,467 --> 00:05:27,168 That was the last time I saw her. 122 00:05:27,269 --> 00:05:29,704 Later that morning, Charlie called Mickey 123 00:05:29,804 --> 00:05:33,008 to remind her about their brother Zach's graduation. 124 00:05:33,108 --> 00:05:34,009 Her phone wasn't on. 125 00:05:34,109 --> 00:05:35,277 I was like, "Oh, that's kind of weird." 126 00:05:35,377 --> 00:05:36,645 You know, I get home, my mom's all mad. 127 00:05:36,745 --> 00:05:38,446 She's like, "Where's Mickey? 128 00:05:38,547 --> 00:05:40,081 Mickey's always off doing something. 129 00:05:40,181 --> 00:05:43,084 I don't know what she got up to, but she's not here," you know. 130 00:05:43,184 --> 00:05:45,086 So we go to my brother's graduation. 131 00:05:45,186 --> 00:05:46,688 - And she's not there. - She's not there. 132 00:05:46,788 --> 00:05:48,189 - Now, that's not like her. - No, I mean, 133 00:05:48,290 --> 00:05:49,958 I remember texting her, like, "You're an idiot. 134 00:05:50,058 --> 00:05:51,693 Where are you? What's going on here?" 135 00:05:51,793 --> 00:05:54,763 So even at the graduation, you're still thinking, 136 00:05:54,863 --> 00:05:56,898 "You're a moron"? Not "something's wrong." 137 00:05:56,998 --> 00:06:00,769 Yeah, yeah, like, "Darn it, Mickey." 138 00:06:00,869 --> 00:06:04,673 But by late afternoon, that started to change. 139 00:06:04,773 --> 00:06:07,342 My mom texts me, "Hey, have you heard from Mickey?" 140 00:06:07,442 --> 00:06:08,877 You know, "What's going on?" 141 00:06:08,977 --> 00:06:14,015 If she had some plan to run off with somebody or alone, 142 00:06:14,115 --> 00:06:16,151 you'd have known about it. - Oh, yeah. 143 00:06:16,251 --> 00:06:18,587 Mickey and I talked about everything, so... 144 00:06:18,687 --> 00:06:22,424 And in that instant, irritation turned to fear. 145 00:06:22,524 --> 00:06:24,926 Nancy started calling all the hospitals 146 00:06:25,026 --> 00:06:27,395 as Charlie turned to Brettley Wilson, 147 00:06:27,495 --> 00:06:29,931 the last person to have seen Mickey. 148 00:06:30,031 --> 00:06:32,867 Charlie told Brettley her sister never made it home 149 00:06:32,968 --> 00:06:34,035 that morning. 150 00:06:34,135 --> 00:06:38,273 So Brettley tells you...? - Well, h-he's confused. 151 00:06:38,373 --> 00:06:41,409 He says, "Oh, no! Well, she left my house 152 00:06:41,509 --> 00:06:44,145 and said she had to go home for Zach's graduation." 153 00:06:44,246 --> 00:06:46,848 That's when I freaked out and started crying, 154 00:06:46,948 --> 00:06:49,217 and I couldn't process anything. - From the startup, 155 00:06:49,317 --> 00:06:52,120 you could tell that this was an extraordinary circumstance. 156 00:06:52,220 --> 00:06:55,123 Captain Kelly Gibson and Detective Stephen Bajat of 157 00:06:55,223 --> 00:06:58,093 the Lafayette Police Department caught Mickey's case. 158 00:06:58,193 --> 00:07:02,163 This was not somebody who was just gonna vanish. 159 00:07:02,264 --> 00:07:04,299 No, she'd never done that before. 160 00:07:04,399 --> 00:07:09,170 She'd always let her family know where she was gonna be. 161 00:07:09,271 --> 00:07:11,406 The Shunick family took to the streets 162 00:07:11,506 --> 00:07:13,475 in search of Mickey, 163 00:07:13,575 --> 00:07:15,977 and they'd be joined by legions of people 164 00:07:16,077 --> 00:07:18,413 from the Lafayette community. 165 00:07:18,513 --> 00:07:21,683 It was just unbelievable to see. 166 00:07:21,783 --> 00:07:24,486 We still have hope. What we want to do is find her. 167 00:07:24,586 --> 00:07:27,923 So we've got that. That's what we're trying to do. 168 00:07:28,023 --> 00:07:30,592 Soon, police would have questions for that friend 169 00:07:30,692 --> 00:07:33,628 who was the last person to see Mickey 170 00:07:33,728 --> 00:07:35,263 before she vanished. 171 00:07:35,363 --> 00:07:38,233 I remember yelling, "No, I didn't do anything to her! 172 00:07:38,333 --> 00:07:39,634 No!" 173 00:07:39,768 --> 00:07:43,371 ♪ 174 00:07:43,905 --> 00:07:53,982 ♪ 175 00:07:55,016 --> 00:07:57,519 There is not a single name that we came up with 176 00:07:57,619 --> 00:07:59,854 that could've-- someone who could be responsible for this. 177 00:07:59,955 --> 00:08:01,623 No one could think of even one person. 178 00:08:01,723 --> 00:08:02,591 Well, she didn't have any enemies. 179 00:08:02,691 --> 00:08:05,427 Everyone I know liked her. 180 00:08:05,527 --> 00:08:10,198 No one ever said anything bad about her. 181 00:08:10,298 --> 00:08:14,369 No obvious suspects, no real evidence of foul play. 182 00:08:14,469 --> 00:08:18,673 A beautiful girl gone without a trace. 183 00:08:18,773 --> 00:08:20,742 There was very little physical evidence 184 00:08:20,842 --> 00:08:22,978 that we had to follow. 185 00:08:23,078 --> 00:08:26,281 The last message that s-she received on her-- 186 00:08:26,381 --> 00:08:30,385 On her cell phone was around 1:46 in the morning on May 19. 187 00:08:30,485 --> 00:08:32,454 But after that, there has been no activity. 188 00:08:32,554 --> 00:08:36,558 I mean, that in and of itself sounds kind of ominous. 189 00:08:36,658 --> 00:08:39,561 - Yes. - It's a truism of police work 190 00:08:39,661 --> 00:08:42,297 that the last person to see a victim alive 191 00:08:42,397 --> 00:08:45,333 is the first focus of the investigation. 192 00:08:45,433 --> 00:08:47,002 So police brought in Mickey's friend, 193 00:08:47,102 --> 00:08:49,371 Brettley Wilson for questioning. 194 00:08:49,471 --> 00:08:52,374 At first, it was just, "Help us eliminate you." 195 00:08:52,474 --> 00:08:56,044 And then it transitioned into, you know, "Mistakes happen. 196 00:08:56,144 --> 00:08:59,447 You can-You can tell us if there was a mistake." 197 00:08:59,548 --> 00:09:04,219 Um, and that segued into, "You loved her, didn't you? 198 00:09:04,319 --> 00:09:07,956 I mean, you know, pretty girl loved you, you spurned her. 199 00:09:08,056 --> 00:09:11,359 Uh, you know, maybe you should just let us know now." 200 00:09:11,459 --> 00:09:14,029 Wilson insisted he had nothing to do with 201 00:09:14,129 --> 00:09:16,164 his good friend's disappearance. 202 00:09:16,264 --> 00:09:18,099 I remember yelling that repeatedly. 203 00:09:18,200 --> 00:09:21,403 "No, no, we were just friends. 204 00:09:21,503 --> 00:09:23,638 No, I didn't do anything to her. 205 00:09:23,738 --> 00:09:26,141 No, that was the last time I saw her!" 206 00:09:26,241 --> 00:09:27,309 It was unrelenting. 207 00:09:27,409 --> 00:09:29,077 You guys took this pretty seriously. 208 00:09:29,177 --> 00:09:30,011 Absolutely. 209 00:09:30,111 --> 00:09:32,180 We could take nothing for granted. 210 00:09:32,280 --> 00:09:34,716 As the investigation gathered steam, 211 00:09:34,816 --> 00:09:36,651 several hundred friends and neighbors 212 00:09:36,751 --> 00:09:39,521 of the Shunick family came together 213 00:09:39,621 --> 00:09:41,590 to scour the streets of Lafayette. 214 00:09:41,690 --> 00:09:43,792 It was a really small city with a lot of people in it. 215 00:09:43,892 --> 00:09:45,093 Everyone knew a Shunick, 216 00:09:45,193 --> 00:09:46,561 someone knew someone who knew us. 217 00:09:46,661 --> 00:09:48,230 And it just kind of set-- 218 00:09:48,330 --> 00:09:52,200 It was like wildfire, you know, everyone got involved. 219 00:09:52,300 --> 00:09:55,604 Soon more than 1800 people from in and around Lafayette 220 00:09:55,704 --> 00:09:58,707 were filtering through a makeshift search headquarters 221 00:09:58,807 --> 00:10:02,210 set up on the University of Louisiana campus. 222 00:10:02,310 --> 00:10:03,445 It was amazing. 223 00:10:03,545 --> 00:10:06,881 There would just be people coming in covered in rashes 224 00:10:06,982 --> 00:10:09,985 and poison ivy and bug bites and dirt in their hair 225 00:10:10,085 --> 00:10:11,720 and they've been climbing up trees 226 00:10:11,820 --> 00:10:13,121 and digging through brush and-- 227 00:10:13,221 --> 00:10:14,556 Looking for a girl they had never met. 228 00:10:14,656 --> 00:10:15,557 Yeah. 229 00:10:15,657 --> 00:10:17,525 Social media played a big part in this. 230 00:10:17,626 --> 00:10:19,728 Facebook is, like, the number one way 231 00:10:19,828 --> 00:10:21,162 we reached anyone. 232 00:10:21,263 --> 00:10:22,964 Usually in the stories we cover, 233 00:10:23,064 --> 00:10:25,667 one family member takes the lead in keeping the case 234 00:10:25,767 --> 00:10:27,569 in the public spotlight. 235 00:10:27,669 --> 00:10:29,471 If a child or young adult is missing, 236 00:10:29,571 --> 00:10:32,140 frequently a parent takes on that role. 237 00:10:32,240 --> 00:10:34,943 Because Mickey's parents were so devastated, 238 00:10:35,043 --> 00:10:37,279 Charlie stepped up instead. 239 00:10:37,379 --> 00:10:40,515 She and I have stayed in touch and I can tell you 240 00:10:40,615 --> 00:10:45,086 "determined" does not begin to describe her single minded focus 241 00:10:45,186 --> 00:10:47,255 and grit. - She talked to everybody. 242 00:10:47,355 --> 00:10:50,525 She did radio interviews at midnight. 243 00:10:50,625 --> 00:10:51,993 We've divided the city into quadrants... 244 00:10:52,093 --> 00:10:53,395 {\an8}She got up at 3:00 in the morning 245 00:10:53,495 --> 00:10:56,264 {\an8}and went over to a TV station. - We're searching every day. 246 00:10:56,364 --> 00:10:57,866 {\an8}It was always the same thing. "We've gotta find Mickey. 247 00:10:57,966 --> 00:11:00,735 We gotta bring Mickey home." - We just want her back. 248 00:11:00,835 --> 00:11:04,706 The 24 year old, 5 foot 2, sometimes blond, 249 00:11:04,806 --> 00:11:08,643 sometimes redhead, had become the tip of the spear 250 00:11:08,743 --> 00:11:12,814 in a multi-state, multinational search effort. 251 00:11:12,914 --> 00:11:15,584 Charlie had all t-the missing posters 252 00:11:15,684 --> 00:11:18,119 translated into Spanish and people went 253 00:11:18,220 --> 00:11:21,990 and flooded all the border towns and the border crossings. 254 00:11:22,090 --> 00:11:23,325 I was telling the social media team 255 00:11:23,425 --> 00:11:25,060 what to say and what they shouldn't say 256 00:11:25,160 --> 00:11:26,828 and how they should phrase things 257 00:11:26,928 --> 00:11:30,498 and telling the headquarter coordinators 258 00:11:30,599 --> 00:11:34,936 where to put bottles of water and the sandwiches and stuff. 259 00:11:35,036 --> 00:11:36,104 Doesn't leave you a lot of time 260 00:11:36,204 --> 00:11:38,874 to worry about your sister. Maybe that was the idea. 261 00:11:38,974 --> 00:11:40,542 That's just what happened. 262 00:11:40,642 --> 00:11:42,377 What was this doing to Charlie? 263 00:11:42,477 --> 00:11:45,647 Man, s-she stood up. 264 00:11:45,747 --> 00:11:48,350 She turned out to have a spine of steel, that kid. 265 00:11:48,450 --> 00:11:50,252 I felt like everyone was depending on me 266 00:11:50,352 --> 00:11:56,124 to stay positive and, you know. - Be the rock? 267 00:11:57,993 --> 00:12:00,762 I think it was tougher on you than you're letting on. 268 00:12:00,862 --> 00:12:06,067 You have to put up barriers, otherwise you can't function. 269 00:12:06,167 --> 00:12:09,838 A week went by, and then a major breakthrough, 270 00:12:09,938 --> 00:12:13,508 coming from a security camera that had captured 271 00:12:13,608 --> 00:12:15,143 this haunting image. 272 00:12:15,243 --> 00:12:18,847 A bicyclist heading down a dark, deserted street 273 00:12:18,947 --> 00:12:21,349 in the direction of Mickey's home 274 00:12:21,449 --> 00:12:23,852 on the night she disappeared. 275 00:12:23,952 --> 00:12:27,122 Police called you to come in and look at that video. 276 00:12:27,222 --> 00:12:28,657 Was that Mickey? - Yes. 277 00:12:28,757 --> 00:12:31,426 You could see the big, blonde afro that, you know, 278 00:12:31,526 --> 00:12:33,495 we're very well known for. It was her mannerisms. 279 00:12:33,595 --> 00:12:36,398 It was her bike. - What was that like to see her? 280 00:12:36,498 --> 00:12:37,766 It was exciting. 281 00:12:37,866 --> 00:12:39,434 It proves that she got at least this far. 282 00:12:39,534 --> 00:12:41,269 So now we have a place where we can start from, 283 00:12:41,369 --> 00:12:45,173 instead of searching the whole city. 284 00:12:45,273 --> 00:12:46,975 Police came to believe that whatever happened 285 00:12:47,075 --> 00:12:49,010 to Mickey Shunick probably happened 286 00:12:49,110 --> 00:12:52,147 right around here, on this lonely stretch of road 287 00:12:52,247 --> 00:12:54,649 that was part of her normal route home. 288 00:12:54,749 --> 00:12:56,952 Now, police saw Mickey on security cameras 289 00:12:57,052 --> 00:12:59,254 during the early part of her journey, 290 00:12:59,354 --> 00:13:02,457 but not on the cameras that she would have passed later on. 291 00:13:02,557 --> 00:13:05,427 The only problem was that a detailed and extensive search 292 00:13:05,527 --> 00:13:08,763 of this area turned up nothing. 293 00:13:08,864 --> 00:13:11,132 But there was something else detectives saw 294 00:13:11,233 --> 00:13:14,736 on that security video, something much more ominous. 295 00:13:14,836 --> 00:13:18,807 Here, just after Mickey cycles out of frame, 296 00:13:18,907 --> 00:13:23,011 someone in a white pickup truck drives into frame, 297 00:13:23,111 --> 00:13:26,748 following Mickey at an uncomfortably close distance. 298 00:13:26,848 --> 00:13:30,485 Now, for the first time, police felt they had evidence 299 00:13:30,585 --> 00:13:32,921 someone else was involved. 300 00:13:33,021 --> 00:13:36,124 Charlie knew that if Mickey had been abducted, 301 00:13:36,224 --> 00:13:39,394 it wouldn't have happened without a fight. 302 00:13:39,494 --> 00:13:41,396 If someone took her and she was conscious, 303 00:13:41,496 --> 00:13:42,497 they're hurting. 304 00:13:42,597 --> 00:13:44,299 They have broken ribs, they have a broken arm, 305 00:13:44,399 --> 00:13:45,767 broken nose. I kept saying that. 306 00:13:45,867 --> 00:13:48,770 "Look for someone who's beat up around the office, 307 00:13:48,870 --> 00:13:51,106 around your neighborhood because they might be 308 00:13:51,206 --> 00:13:52,741 responsible for this, - It would have been 309 00:13:52,841 --> 00:13:56,511 totally in character for her to fight back. 310 00:13:56,611 --> 00:13:59,915 But the clue in that video would prove as frustrating 311 00:14:00,015 --> 00:14:03,418 to detectives as it was fascinating. 312 00:14:03,518 --> 00:14:04,920 There got to be a lot of white pickup trucks 313 00:14:05,020 --> 00:14:06,588 in Louisiana. - There are indeed. 314 00:14:06,688 --> 00:14:08,623 Within Lafayette Parish and surrounding parishes, 315 00:14:08,723 --> 00:14:10,425 there's over 3,000. 316 00:14:10,525 --> 00:14:14,196 Lucky for them, they were about to catch a big break. 317 00:14:14,296 --> 00:14:15,564 Stephen Bajat turned to me and said, 318 00:14:15,664 --> 00:14:18,133 "Okay, I don't want you to freak out or anything, 319 00:14:18,233 --> 00:14:20,302 but I think we found her bike." 320 00:14:20,435 --> 00:14:23,572 ♪ 321 00:14:24,206 --> 00:14:34,015 ♪ 322 00:14:34,115 --> 00:14:38,553 A blonde on a bicycle, a white truck pursuing her. 323 00:14:38,653 --> 00:14:41,756 Now, investigators were pursuing that truck, 324 00:14:41,856 --> 00:14:44,626 and it wouldn't be easy. 325 00:14:44,726 --> 00:14:47,295 Here on the Gulf Coast, white Chevy pickups 326 00:14:47,395 --> 00:14:49,631 are as common as hot sauce. 327 00:14:49,731 --> 00:14:51,466 Definitely didn't narrow down t-the search. 328 00:14:51,566 --> 00:14:53,468 It was probably one of the m-more popular vehicles 329 00:14:53,568 --> 00:14:57,105 in the area. - Definitely kept us busy. 330 00:14:57,205 --> 00:15:00,508 Those images did prove one thing conclusively. 331 00:15:00,609 --> 00:15:02,711 They were taken after Brettley Wilson says 332 00:15:02,811 --> 00:15:04,646 he last saw Mickey, 333 00:15:04,746 --> 00:15:07,148 proving he was telling the truth. 334 00:15:07,249 --> 00:15:10,518 Mickey had left his house alive and well 335 00:15:10,619 --> 00:15:12,120 when he said she did. 336 00:15:12,220 --> 00:15:14,556 That was a big deal because Brettley was cleared. 337 00:15:14,656 --> 00:15:17,025 It proved that someone we didn't know 338 00:15:17,125 --> 00:15:19,194 probably took her. 339 00:15:22,364 --> 00:15:24,933 As the relentlessly hot Louisiana summer days 340 00:15:25,033 --> 00:15:28,503 slowly came and went, Charlie Shunick proved to be 341 00:15:28,603 --> 00:15:30,538 equally relentless, 342 00:15:30,639 --> 00:15:32,908 continuing her appeals to the public, 343 00:15:33,008 --> 00:15:36,011 determined to find her sister, Mickey. 344 00:15:36,111 --> 00:15:37,779 Nothing else really seemed very important 345 00:15:37,879 --> 00:15:38,680 at the time either, 346 00:15:38,780 --> 00:15:41,716 aside from what we were doing, so... 347 00:15:41,816 --> 00:15:43,018 All the other things in your life 348 00:15:43,118 --> 00:15:47,088 kind of just fade away? - Yeah. Yeah. 349 00:15:47,188 --> 00:15:50,091 But by week two, the fear of the unknown 350 00:15:50,192 --> 00:15:53,228 began to take its toll on the Shunick family, 351 00:15:53,328 --> 00:15:56,498 which was now forced to re-examine just what it was 352 00:15:56,598 --> 00:15:59,634 they were hoping had happened to Mickey. 353 00:15:59,734 --> 00:16:01,770 I thought, you know, so someone saw 354 00:16:01,870 --> 00:16:05,006 this cute little girl riding her bike down the street 355 00:16:05,106 --> 00:16:06,241 and hit her on purpose. 356 00:16:06,341 --> 00:16:09,911 And they have her and are doing God knows what with. 357 00:16:10,011 --> 00:16:11,079 But... - But she's still alive. 358 00:16:11,179 --> 00:16:14,149 Yeah, that's what we were thinking. Absolutely. 359 00:16:14,249 --> 00:16:16,818 As for Mickey's mom, Nancy, hers was a hope 360 00:16:16,918 --> 00:16:19,387 only a mother could feel. 361 00:16:19,487 --> 00:16:21,489 Anybody who spends any time with her 362 00:16:21,590 --> 00:16:23,358 is not gonna want to hurt her. 363 00:16:23,458 --> 00:16:26,027 Because if you spend a few minutes with her, 364 00:16:26,127 --> 00:16:28,930 you like her and you love her and you don't wanna hurt her. 365 00:16:29,030 --> 00:16:32,667 Hearing that was heartbreaking and also familiar. 366 00:16:32,767 --> 00:16:37,038 I regularly see families engaging in magical thinking, 367 00:16:37,138 --> 00:16:38,306 and understandably, 368 00:16:38,406 --> 00:16:40,942 because the alternative is unbearable. 369 00:16:41,042 --> 00:16:44,512 In most cases like Mickey's, the terrible truth is that 370 00:16:44,613 --> 00:16:46,982 the missing person is often killed 371 00:16:47,082 --> 00:16:49,784 before anyone knows to look for them. 372 00:16:49,884 --> 00:16:53,755 When I spoke with the Shunicks, their grief was palpable. 373 00:16:53,855 --> 00:16:56,157 And those conversations are the hardest thing 374 00:16:56,258 --> 00:16:58,260 about doing this job. 375 00:16:58,360 --> 00:17:01,596 Without Mickey, your mom was having a very tough time. 376 00:17:01,696 --> 00:17:04,266 Yeah. 377 00:17:04,366 --> 00:17:07,269 Yeah, I don't-- 378 00:17:07,369 --> 00:17:09,771 It's just, I feel so bad for my mom, you know? 379 00:17:09,871 --> 00:17:14,075 Um... 380 00:17:18,580 --> 00:17:20,415 She always said that if she ever lost one of us, 381 00:17:20,515 --> 00:17:25,120 she would... not be able to go on in life and... 382 00:17:27,322 --> 00:17:28,723 But yeah, it was pretty hard on her. 383 00:17:28,823 --> 00:17:30,759 It was just so shocking. 384 00:17:30,859 --> 00:17:34,462 I mean, who this has happened to. 385 00:17:34,563 --> 00:17:37,465 And then eight days after Mickey vanished, 386 00:17:37,566 --> 00:17:41,336 the investigation took a huge leap forward. 387 00:17:41,436 --> 00:17:42,837 Stephen Bajat turned to me and said, 388 00:17:42,938 --> 00:17:45,273 "Okay, I don't want you to freak out or anything, 389 00:17:45,373 --> 00:17:47,108 but I think we found her bike." 390 00:17:47,209 --> 00:17:51,179 Two fishermen had found Mickey's bike east of Lafayette 391 00:17:51,279 --> 00:17:53,848 in a body of water called Whiskey Bay, 392 00:17:53,949 --> 00:17:56,351 just under the interstate. 393 00:17:56,451 --> 00:17:59,387 It was covered in mud and, you know, dried water 394 00:17:59,487 --> 00:18:00,622 from being in the swamp. 395 00:18:00,722 --> 00:18:02,390 How far away from where she disappeared 396 00:18:02,490 --> 00:18:03,992 was the bicycle found? 397 00:18:04,092 --> 00:18:05,794 Um, 25 miles. 398 00:18:05,894 --> 00:18:08,530 - That's not a good sign. - No, it's not. 399 00:18:08,630 --> 00:18:11,166 Now, police had hard, physical evidence 400 00:18:11,266 --> 00:18:14,236 with which to build a theory of the crime. 401 00:18:14,336 --> 00:18:16,471 What could you tell from looking at the bicycle? 402 00:18:16,571 --> 00:18:18,640 That there was significant damage to the back tire. 403 00:18:18,740 --> 00:18:20,575 It looked like it had been impacted. 404 00:18:20,675 --> 00:18:22,877 - Somebody had rammed her? - That's what it looked like. 405 00:18:22,978 --> 00:18:24,746 - Scary? - Yeah. 406 00:18:24,846 --> 00:18:25,914 I almost passed out, actually. 407 00:18:26,014 --> 00:18:29,050 I, like, had to brace myself up against the table. 408 00:18:29,150 --> 00:18:31,920 And so I was thinking, okay, this was a malicious act 409 00:18:32,020 --> 00:18:35,123 and who did this? 410 00:18:35,223 --> 00:18:37,826 Police immediately began the sober task 411 00:18:37,926 --> 00:18:41,196 of searching for Mickey in the several thousand acres 412 00:18:41,296 --> 00:18:44,799 of Louisiana's largest swamp land. 413 00:18:44,900 --> 00:18:47,669 We focused a lot of manpower a-and efforts into the-- 414 00:18:47,769 --> 00:18:49,437 into the search of this area. 415 00:18:49,538 --> 00:18:51,373 Uh, we had individuals on airboats, uh, 416 00:18:51,473 --> 00:18:53,675 like we're on now, uh, ATVs, 417 00:18:53,775 --> 00:18:55,777 we had, uh, officers on horseback. 418 00:18:55,877 --> 00:18:57,646 Just amazing search efforts. 419 00:18:57,746 --> 00:18:59,781 Is that where you sort of began to think, 420 00:18:59,881 --> 00:19:02,951 we're probably no longer looking for somebody who's alive? 421 00:19:03,051 --> 00:19:05,987 Right. It was more of a recovery effort at that point. 422 00:19:06,087 --> 00:19:09,124 But several days of searching turned up nothing. 423 00:19:09,224 --> 00:19:12,093 Meanwhile, investigators appealed for help 424 00:19:12,193 --> 00:19:17,332 in identifying the owner of a white Chevrolet Z71 pickup. 425 00:19:17,432 --> 00:19:20,001 That vehicle should be able to be spotted by the public. 426 00:19:20,101 --> 00:19:23,071 We got a lot of tips, well over a-a thousand tips 427 00:19:23,171 --> 00:19:26,174 from, uh, the tips line that, alone that we had. 428 00:19:26,274 --> 00:19:28,276 Tips saying, "There's a white pickup here." 429 00:19:28,376 --> 00:19:30,078 Women calling on their boyfriends or husbands 430 00:19:30,178 --> 00:19:31,713 saying he's kind of deviant. 431 00:19:31,813 --> 00:19:34,816 And w-we-- "I think he could be responsible 432 00:19:34,916 --> 00:19:36,918 for the disappearance of Mickey." 433 00:19:37,018 --> 00:19:40,855 I mean, it ran the whole gamut of-of tips. 434 00:19:40,956 --> 00:19:43,024 It's interesting, I mean, you had half the community 435 00:19:43,124 --> 00:19:44,726 sort of pulling together to find Mickey 436 00:19:44,826 --> 00:19:46,828 and like the other half sort of informing on each other 437 00:19:46,928 --> 00:19:48,463 about that case. 438 00:19:48,563 --> 00:19:49,497 Uh, I don't know about that, 439 00:19:49,598 --> 00:19:51,533 but we certainly had a lot of tips coming in. 440 00:19:51,633 --> 00:19:54,836 And that's how police received their best lead yet. 441 00:19:54,936 --> 00:20:00,075 A story rich in detail involving this man, Rocky McGee. 442 00:20:00,175 --> 00:20:02,043 We received a tip that he was intoxicated 443 00:20:02,143 --> 00:20:05,614 and that he had encountered, um, Mickey riding her bicycle, 444 00:20:05,714 --> 00:20:09,384 had struck her with his vehicle, uh, and picked up her bike 445 00:20:09,484 --> 00:20:12,721 a-and her body a-and dumped her in the, uh, 446 00:20:12,821 --> 00:20:14,289 the Whiskey Bay area. 447 00:20:14,389 --> 00:20:16,725 19 year old Rocky McGee did indeed 448 00:20:16,825 --> 00:20:19,127 drive a white pickup truck. 449 00:20:19,227 --> 00:20:22,664 He also had a history of drinking and driving. 450 00:20:22,764 --> 00:20:24,132 Was involved in-in a traffic crash, 451 00:20:24,232 --> 00:20:27,402 that involved alcohol and a fatality. 452 00:20:27,502 --> 00:20:29,838 In fact, at the time Mickey disappeared, 453 00:20:29,938 --> 00:20:33,408 Rocky was about to be tried for DUI manslaughter. 454 00:20:33,508 --> 00:20:37,012 To frustrated detectives, all the pieces of the puzzle 455 00:20:37,112 --> 00:20:38,713 were coming together. 456 00:20:38,813 --> 00:20:41,616 He had had a prior, uh, a-and was going through 457 00:20:41,716 --> 00:20:44,553 a court process at the time, so i-it would fit 458 00:20:44,653 --> 00:20:46,421 and be feasible t-that he would try 459 00:20:46,521 --> 00:20:49,124 a-and dispose of a bicycle and a body 460 00:20:49,224 --> 00:20:51,826 so that you would eliminate the crime completely. 461 00:20:51,927 --> 00:20:56,731 Had Mickey Shunick become Rocky McGee's second victim? 462 00:20:56,831 --> 00:20:58,700 It seemed to be great information. 463 00:20:58,800 --> 00:21:02,671 Well, in Louisiana, just like in its waterways, 464 00:21:02,771 --> 00:21:05,040 things in this case seldom were predictable 465 00:21:05,140 --> 00:21:07,943 or followed a logical path. 466 00:21:08,043 --> 00:21:10,245 If detectives were ready to believe this was simply 467 00:21:10,345 --> 00:21:12,447 the work of a drunk driver, 468 00:21:12,547 --> 00:21:15,951 they would soon be proven completely wrong. 469 00:21:16,051 --> 00:21:20,689 A tantalizing new lead was about to fall into their laps. 470 00:21:20,789 --> 00:21:23,325 Even those closest to him didn't know that 471 00:21:23,425 --> 00:21:25,393 he had that secret life. 472 00:21:25,527 --> 00:21:28,563 ♪ 473 00:21:29,564 --> 00:21:36,304 ♪ 474 00:21:36,404 --> 00:21:38,707 Come on in, guys. 475 00:21:38,807 --> 00:21:40,875 The search for Mickey Shunick had spread over 476 00:21:40,976 --> 00:21:42,978 most of the Gulf Coast. 477 00:21:43,078 --> 00:21:45,614 It had involved hundreds of people 478 00:21:45,714 --> 00:21:47,849 and thousands of police hours. 479 00:21:47,949 --> 00:21:49,884 And now, a caller to the tip line, 480 00:21:49,985 --> 00:21:52,887 claiming that Mickey had been the victim of a drunk driver 481 00:21:52,988 --> 00:21:55,323 was a game changer for detectives. 482 00:21:55,423 --> 00:21:56,992 If you strike someone and you're intoxicated, 483 00:21:57,092 --> 00:22:00,228 that's foul play. So it looked promising. 484 00:22:00,328 --> 00:22:02,030 I only spoke to him one time. 485 00:22:02,130 --> 00:22:04,132 He denied any involvement. 486 00:22:04,232 --> 00:22:07,402 Ultimately, when pressured, he asked for an attorney. 487 00:22:07,502 --> 00:22:08,970 For a town on edge, 488 00:22:09,070 --> 00:22:11,973 and still determined to find Mickey, 489 00:22:12,073 --> 00:22:14,376 news quickly leaked that police were questioning 490 00:22:14,476 --> 00:22:15,944 a person of interest. 491 00:22:16,044 --> 00:22:17,846 And when it did, 492 00:22:17,946 --> 00:22:20,916 the name Rocky McGee went viral. 493 00:22:21,016 --> 00:22:22,317 It was, like, all over the news, 494 00:22:22,417 --> 00:22:25,453 all over the social media pages and everything. 495 00:22:25,554 --> 00:22:26,621 And the next thing you know, 496 00:22:26,721 --> 00:22:28,323 everybody was talking about Rocky McGee. 497 00:22:28,423 --> 00:22:29,157 Correct. 498 00:22:29,257 --> 00:22:31,726 And it spread like wildfire. 499 00:22:31,826 --> 00:22:34,663 The tip line was suddenly full of callers, 500 00:22:34,763 --> 00:22:37,132 including one claiming to have firsthand knowledge 501 00:22:37,232 --> 00:22:40,068 that not only had Rocky killed Mickey, 502 00:22:40,168 --> 00:22:42,203 but he also had an accomplice. 503 00:22:42,304 --> 00:22:43,572 This individual came forward and said 504 00:22:43,672 --> 00:22:46,541 that Rocky's girlfriend, she was present 505 00:22:46,641 --> 00:22:48,810 when he was drunk and hit her, 506 00:22:48,910 --> 00:22:50,845 and that they picked up the bike and the body 507 00:22:50,946 --> 00:22:53,081 and-and disposed of her. 508 00:22:53,181 --> 00:22:54,983 Andie Cormier is the girlfriend 509 00:22:55,083 --> 00:22:57,219 accused of helping Rocky. 510 00:22:57,319 --> 00:22:59,187 She first learned of the accusations 511 00:22:59,287 --> 00:23:02,757 against her and her boyfriend from Rocky's mother. 512 00:23:02,857 --> 00:23:04,593 His mom comes up to me, and she tells me 513 00:23:04,693 --> 00:23:06,661 that Rocky has been taken by Lafayette police 514 00:23:06,761 --> 00:23:08,930 to be questioned in the Mickey Shunick case. 515 00:23:09,030 --> 00:23:11,132 She's hysterical. She's crying. 516 00:23:11,233 --> 00:23:13,101 She's confused. 517 00:23:13,201 --> 00:23:16,671 And she was like, well, they think you did it, too. 518 00:23:16,771 --> 00:23:19,574 Like her significant other, Rocky, 519 00:23:19,674 --> 00:23:24,546 Andie Cormier found herself grilled like a redfish. 520 00:23:24,646 --> 00:23:26,114 It never happened. 521 00:23:26,214 --> 00:23:27,916 It never happened. 522 00:23:30,318 --> 00:23:32,554 For days, police worked around the clock 523 00:23:32,654 --> 00:23:35,790 investigating McGee's alleged involvement. 524 00:23:35,891 --> 00:23:37,659 They processed his white pickup, 525 00:23:37,759 --> 00:23:41,263 looking for any DNA that could be traced back to Mickey. 526 00:23:41,363 --> 00:23:42,697 We spent a lot of manpower 527 00:23:42,797 --> 00:23:44,100 and a lot of time investigating this. 528 00:23:45,100 --> 00:23:47,569 I actually thought that we were really gonna be blamed 529 00:23:47,669 --> 00:23:48,803 for something we didn't do. 530 00:23:48,904 --> 00:23:52,807 And I was praying for somebody to come forward 531 00:23:52,908 --> 00:23:56,011 and admit what they said was false. 532 00:23:56,111 --> 00:23:59,080 Then, almost as quickly as Rocky McGee surfaced 533 00:23:59,180 --> 00:24:01,216 as Mickey's alleged killer, 534 00:24:01,316 --> 00:24:03,385 the case around him collapsed. 535 00:24:03,485 --> 00:24:06,121 When police brought McGee's first accuser back 536 00:24:06,221 --> 00:24:07,689 to be questioned again. 537 00:24:07,789 --> 00:24:08,924 The original tipster admitted 538 00:24:09,024 --> 00:24:12,127 that he had fabricated the story. 539 00:24:12,227 --> 00:24:14,429 It turned out that neither Rocky McGee 540 00:24:14,529 --> 00:24:16,064 nor his girlfriend Andie 541 00:24:16,164 --> 00:24:18,934 had anything to do with Mickey's disappearance. 542 00:24:19,034 --> 00:24:20,402 They were instead 543 00:24:20,502 --> 00:24:23,405 the victims of what turned out to be a hoax. 544 00:24:23,505 --> 00:24:24,940 And so this tip that you got, 545 00:24:25,040 --> 00:24:28,009 this was what, just somebody who had it out for him? 546 00:24:28,109 --> 00:24:30,145 I think what it was was it turned out to be 547 00:24:30,245 --> 00:24:32,447 someone who just wanted attention. 548 00:24:32,547 --> 00:24:33,415 And it ate up a lot of your time. 549 00:24:33,515 --> 00:24:34,849 Ate up a lot of our time. 550 00:24:34,950 --> 00:24:35,951 And it turned out to be absolutely nothing. 551 00:24:36,051 --> 00:24:36,952 Yes, sir. 552 00:24:37,052 --> 00:24:38,987 That was probably the negative aspect 553 00:24:39,087 --> 00:24:40,422 of the social media. 554 00:24:40,522 --> 00:24:42,591 - Frustrating? - Very. 555 00:24:42,691 --> 00:24:45,961 But the saying, "once burned, twice shy," 556 00:24:46,061 --> 00:24:49,030 was a luxury detectives couldn't afford. 557 00:24:49,130 --> 00:24:51,600 So when two new tips came in about another owner 558 00:24:51,700 --> 00:24:54,869 of a white pickup truck who'd been acting suspiciously, 559 00:24:54,970 --> 00:24:58,406 Detective Bajat rolled up his sleeves once again. 560 00:24:58,506 --> 00:25:00,842 Both tips, they came in a week apart 561 00:25:00,942 --> 00:25:03,011 and they were independent of themselves. 562 00:25:03,111 --> 00:25:04,779 And who were they telling you to look at? 563 00:25:04,880 --> 00:25:06,181 Brandon Scott Lavergne. 564 00:25:06,281 --> 00:25:10,185 Brandon Scott Lavergne was a 33-year-old mechanic 565 00:25:10,285 --> 00:25:12,621 who worked on oil rigs just offshore. 566 00:25:12,721 --> 00:25:14,155 Tell me what the two tips said. 567 00:25:14,256 --> 00:25:16,224 The first tip that came in was from an acquaintance, 568 00:25:16,324 --> 00:25:17,959 uh, that had close knowledge of him 569 00:25:18,059 --> 00:25:20,095 that said that he was acting suspiciously. 570 00:25:20,195 --> 00:25:21,096 The tipster also said 571 00:25:21,196 --> 00:25:23,531 that on the weekend Mickey went missing, 572 00:25:23,632 --> 00:25:25,700 Lavergne traveled to New Orleans 573 00:25:25,800 --> 00:25:28,570 and came back with some serious stab wounds 574 00:25:28,670 --> 00:25:30,005 on his upper body. 575 00:25:30,105 --> 00:25:32,073 He was telling them that he had been robbed 576 00:25:32,173 --> 00:25:34,442 and mugged in New Orleans while he was down there. 577 00:25:34,542 --> 00:25:36,511 What they found suspicious was that he had no reason 578 00:25:36,611 --> 00:25:38,213 to go to New Orleans that weekend, 579 00:25:38,313 --> 00:25:41,516 uh, and his story just didn't make sense. 580 00:25:41,616 --> 00:25:43,818 And it wasn't just what the tipster was saying 581 00:25:43,919 --> 00:25:45,854 that interested Detective Bajat. 582 00:25:45,954 --> 00:25:48,523 It was also who the tipster was. 583 00:25:48,623 --> 00:25:50,091 The tipster that called in 584 00:25:50,192 --> 00:25:52,494 was the future father-in-law of Mr. Lavergne. 585 00:25:52,594 --> 00:25:54,963 And that second tip only tightened the net 586 00:25:55,063 --> 00:25:56,765 around Lavergne. 587 00:25:56,865 --> 00:26:00,001 It came from an employee of a Lafayette car dealership 588 00:26:00,101 --> 00:26:02,070 who said that soon after Mickey vanished, 589 00:26:02,170 --> 00:26:05,674 Lavergne came in looking to buy a white pickup. 590 00:26:05,774 --> 00:26:07,909 The second tip said that Brandon Lavergne 591 00:26:08,009 --> 00:26:09,444 had gone in to purchase a vehicle, 592 00:26:09,544 --> 00:26:10,912 was acting suspiciously, 593 00:26:11,012 --> 00:26:16,218 and said that he had owned a white Z71 that was stolen, 594 00:26:16,318 --> 00:26:18,753 and that he's here to buy another one. 595 00:26:18,853 --> 00:26:21,489 In what way was he behaving suspiciously? 596 00:26:21,590 --> 00:26:23,091 During the time that he was purchasing the truck 597 00:26:23,191 --> 00:26:27,028 on the news, they showed a story about Mickey 598 00:26:27,128 --> 00:26:29,464 and he got really suspicious and really nervous they said. 599 00:26:29,564 --> 00:26:32,200 It was visibly nervous. 600 00:26:32,300 --> 00:26:33,268 Detectives also learned 601 00:26:33,368 --> 00:26:36,004 that the soon-to-be married Brandon Lavergne 602 00:26:36,104 --> 00:26:39,241 lived in the little town of Church Point, Louisiana, 603 00:26:39,341 --> 00:26:41,776 40 minutes outside Lafayette. 604 00:26:43,144 --> 00:26:45,413 He was funny. I mean, he really was. 605 00:26:45,513 --> 00:26:46,848 That's where Lavergne got to know 606 00:26:46,948 --> 00:26:49,417 his friend Kandee McDaniels. 607 00:26:49,517 --> 00:26:50,785 When we first met, I was like, 608 00:26:50,885 --> 00:26:53,188 "Man, he's a great guy. He's got a great job. 609 00:26:53,288 --> 00:26:55,257 I mean, he's good looking. He's the perfect guy." 610 00:26:55,357 --> 00:26:57,125 I was like, "I gotta find one of my girlfriends 611 00:26:57,225 --> 00:26:58,393 who's single and, you know, 612 00:26:58,493 --> 00:27:00,328 see if they would hit it off." 613 00:27:00,428 --> 00:27:01,930 But the more detectives delved into 614 00:27:02,030 --> 00:27:04,332 Brandon Scott Lavergne's past, 615 00:27:04,432 --> 00:27:06,134 the more they realized just how much 616 00:27:06,234 --> 00:27:09,137 wasn't known to those around him. 617 00:27:09,237 --> 00:27:11,006 And even those closest to him 618 00:27:11,106 --> 00:27:13,708 didn't know that he had that secret life. 619 00:27:13,808 --> 00:27:16,711 And that would include his fiance. 620 00:27:16,811 --> 00:27:19,714 He used me. Oh, my God! 621 00:27:24,286 --> 00:27:32,294 ♪ 622 00:27:32,394 --> 00:27:35,697 Kandee McDaniels counted Brandon Scott Lavergne 623 00:27:35,797 --> 00:27:37,732 as one of her good friends. 624 00:27:37,832 --> 00:27:39,701 I mean, he was that good of a guy, 625 00:27:39,801 --> 00:27:41,803 in my opinion, I mean, 626 00:27:41,903 --> 00:27:44,573 that I would want to set one of my friends up with him. 627 00:27:44,673 --> 00:27:46,708 He may have seemed like a catch to her, 628 00:27:46,808 --> 00:27:48,777 but police now felt they almost had him 629 00:27:48,877 --> 00:27:52,013 on the hook for the murder of Mickey Shunick. 630 00:27:52,113 --> 00:27:53,582 For one thing, detectives determined 631 00:27:53,682 --> 00:27:55,584 that the story Lavergne had allegedly told 632 00:27:55,684 --> 00:27:57,385 his future father-in-law 633 00:27:57,485 --> 00:28:00,422 about being stabbed in a mugging at a gas station 634 00:28:00,522 --> 00:28:02,223 wasn't holding up. 635 00:28:02,324 --> 00:28:03,792 Any evidence that he reported that mugging 636 00:28:03,892 --> 00:28:04,859 to police? 637 00:28:04,960 --> 00:28:06,228 The Jefferson Parish detectives 638 00:28:06,328 --> 00:28:07,462 responded to the scene, 639 00:28:07,562 --> 00:28:09,164 interviewed the gas station attendant, 640 00:28:09,264 --> 00:28:11,099 and reviewed the video surveillance 641 00:28:12,100 --> 00:28:14,703 And he was nowhere near that site. 642 00:28:14,803 --> 00:28:17,772 And as detectives looked deeper into Lavergne's past, 643 00:28:17,873 --> 00:28:20,475 they found themselves heading down a rabbit hole 644 00:28:20,575 --> 00:28:23,011 into a very dark place. 645 00:28:23,111 --> 00:28:24,679 We found out that he had girlfriends, 646 00:28:24,779 --> 00:28:26,815 you know, all over the place that-- 647 00:28:26,915 --> 00:28:30,619 he more or less thrived on the game of seducing women. 648 00:28:30,719 --> 00:28:31,953 What's more, detectives say, 649 00:28:32,053 --> 00:28:35,123 Lavergne had an addiction to prostitutes, 650 00:28:35,223 --> 00:28:38,260 Something his fiance didn't know. 651 00:28:38,360 --> 00:28:40,061 He would leave her residence 652 00:28:40,161 --> 00:28:42,397 and contact sexual escorts. 653 00:28:42,497 --> 00:28:43,331 You found that out 654 00:28:43,431 --> 00:28:44,666 by checking his cell phone records. 655 00:28:44,766 --> 00:28:45,700 Correct. 656 00:28:45,800 --> 00:28:47,135 So this was a guy who sort of had a life 657 00:28:47,235 --> 00:28:48,537 that he didn't show anybody else. 658 00:28:48,637 --> 00:28:49,838 Exactly. 659 00:28:49,938 --> 00:28:51,373 But this seemingly normal, 660 00:28:51,473 --> 00:28:53,842 everyday guy, detectives learned, 661 00:28:53,942 --> 00:28:56,611 was also a registered sex offender, 662 00:28:56,711 --> 00:29:00,348 having been convicted of sexual battery back in 2000. 663 00:29:00,448 --> 00:29:02,050 That was definitely an attention getter. 664 00:29:02,150 --> 00:29:04,686 As provocative as all this was, 665 00:29:04,786 --> 00:29:06,388 there was nothing connecting Lavergne 666 00:29:06,488 --> 00:29:08,690 to Mickey Shunick's disappearance. 667 00:29:08,790 --> 00:29:10,792 So Detective Bajat turned his attention 668 00:29:10,892 --> 00:29:12,928 to Lavergne's white Chevy pickup 669 00:29:13,028 --> 00:29:14,796 and to that other tip 670 00:29:14,896 --> 00:29:16,865 coming from the local car dealer. 671 00:29:16,965 --> 00:29:18,533 The tipster had said that his truck was stolen 672 00:29:18,633 --> 00:29:20,001 out of Texas. 673 00:29:20,101 --> 00:29:22,404 Insurance records indicated where in Texas 674 00:29:22,504 --> 00:29:25,006 Lavergne said his truck had been stolen. 675 00:29:25,106 --> 00:29:26,942 When Bajat called the sheriff there, 676 00:29:27,042 --> 00:29:29,611 he learned the truck had been found abandoned 677 00:29:29,711 --> 00:29:31,346 and badly burned. 678 00:29:31,446 --> 00:29:33,148 We went, recovered and brought it back 679 00:29:33,248 --> 00:29:34,616 to Louisiana as evidence. 680 00:29:34,716 --> 00:29:35,750 And what's in there? 681 00:29:35,850 --> 00:29:37,052 There was absolutely nothing left. 682 00:29:37,152 --> 00:29:39,120 You couldn't even tell the color of the paint. 683 00:29:39,221 --> 00:29:40,789 So, if Mickey was ever in that truck, 684 00:29:40,889 --> 00:29:41,756 you couldn't tell? 685 00:29:41,856 --> 00:29:44,292 That's correct. The heat was intense. 686 00:29:44,392 --> 00:29:45,360 But Lafayette PD 687 00:29:45,460 --> 00:29:48,063 now had Lavergne's license plate number. 688 00:29:48,163 --> 00:29:49,931 And from that, it turned out, 689 00:29:50,031 --> 00:29:53,168 came an extraordinary piece of police work. 690 00:29:53,268 --> 00:29:54,836 We did a little bit of research and found, 691 00:29:54,936 --> 00:29:56,905 uh-uh, an image that had been taken 692 00:29:57,005 --> 00:29:59,474 from a traffic camera of his truck 693 00:29:59,574 --> 00:30:00,909 about eight hours prior 694 00:30:01,009 --> 00:30:03,044 to the time that Mickey disappeared. 695 00:30:03,144 --> 00:30:05,747 That traffic camera not only snapped a photo 696 00:30:05,847 --> 00:30:07,682 of Lavergne's plate number, 697 00:30:07,782 --> 00:30:09,951 but amazingly, it also managed to capture 698 00:30:10,051 --> 00:30:12,487 what was in the bed of his truck. 699 00:30:12,587 --> 00:30:14,656 We were able to see that there's a 4x4 post 700 00:30:14,756 --> 00:30:16,424 as well as a white styrofoam ice chest 701 00:30:16,524 --> 00:30:18,493 that's in the bed of the pickup truck. 702 00:30:18,593 --> 00:30:21,596 Bajat then compared the truck in that image 703 00:30:21,696 --> 00:30:24,099 to the mysterious one seen following Mickey. 704 00:30:24,100 --> 00:30:26,601 When we looked at the footage again 705 00:30:26,701 --> 00:30:29,638 on the night that Mickey disappeared, 706 00:30:29,738 --> 00:30:34,309 we could clearly see a 4x4 post 707 00:30:34,409 --> 00:30:35,710 as well as a white ice chest 708 00:30:35,810 --> 00:30:38,146 in the same position that it was 709 00:30:38,246 --> 00:30:40,582 on the traffic camera eight hours earlier. 710 00:30:40,682 --> 00:30:43,184 Suddenly, after six long weeks, 711 00:30:43,285 --> 00:30:46,321 Lafayette PD felt they had their man. 712 00:30:46,421 --> 00:30:49,224 That was our "aha" moment. That was his truck. 713 00:30:49,324 --> 00:30:52,761 All roads were now leading to Brandon Lavergne. 714 00:30:52,861 --> 00:30:55,430 But detectives couldn't with absolute certainty 715 00:30:55,530 --> 00:30:58,533 place Lavergne behind the wheel of that truck 716 00:30:58,633 --> 00:30:59,901 at that moment. 717 00:31:00,001 --> 00:31:01,503 Most important of all, 718 00:31:01,603 --> 00:31:05,173 they still had no clue what had become of Mickey. 719 00:31:05,273 --> 00:31:06,708 Did you think that Mr. Lavergne was aware 720 00:31:06,808 --> 00:31:08,143 that you guys were looking at him? 721 00:31:08,243 --> 00:31:09,611 No, I don't think he was. 722 00:31:09,711 --> 00:31:10,912 And that was part of our thinking 723 00:31:11,012 --> 00:31:12,581 that if he had killed Mickey, 724 00:31:12,681 --> 00:31:13,815 we could keep him under surveillance 725 00:31:13,915 --> 00:31:16,885 and hopefully he would lead us to a gravesite. 726 00:31:16,985 --> 00:31:18,386 {\an8}But Lavergne never did. 727 00:31:18,486 --> 00:31:21,122 {\an8}So now investigators raised the stakes. 728 00:31:21,222 --> 00:31:22,958 {\an8}They decided to arrest Lavergne 729 00:31:23,058 --> 00:31:25,527 {\an8}and sit him down for some quality time. 730 00:31:36,972 --> 00:31:40,375 {\an8}At first, Lavergne denied knowing anything about Mickey. 731 00:31:40,475 --> 00:31:43,511 {\an8}Then, a veteran of the criminal justice system, 732 00:31:43,612 --> 00:31:45,380 {\an8}he asked for his attorney. 733 00:31:54,489 --> 00:31:56,591 That's when detectives turned to the one person 734 00:31:56,691 --> 00:31:58,727 they hoped could break the case. 735 00:31:58,827 --> 00:32:02,197 They brought in Lavergne's fiance for questioning. 736 00:32:02,297 --> 00:32:03,865 I know you're a little nervous. 737 00:32:03,965 --> 00:32:05,033 Yeah. 738 00:32:05,133 --> 00:32:06,201 You want to know what this is all about. 739 00:32:06,301 --> 00:32:08,103 Well, basically, we just want to know about Brandon. 740 00:32:08,203 --> 00:32:10,739 Did he ever get angry or ever push you 741 00:32:10,839 --> 00:32:13,041 or hit you or-- - Never. Not one time. 742 00:32:13,141 --> 00:32:14,609 You don't see that at all. 743 00:32:14,709 --> 00:32:17,212 I don't-- He's never showed that. 744 00:32:17,312 --> 00:32:18,980 I've never seen it. 745 00:32:19,080 --> 00:32:21,149 I don't even see that in him. I don't-- 746 00:32:21,249 --> 00:32:25,687 He has been so gentle and kind and compassionate. 747 00:32:25,787 --> 00:32:26,855 It's-- He's amazing. 748 00:32:26,955 --> 00:32:29,925 I would have never said yes to a marriage. 749 00:32:30,025 --> 00:32:32,827 As it turned out, police ended up telling her 750 00:32:32,928 --> 00:32:34,629 more than she told them. 751 00:32:34,729 --> 00:32:37,799 Her reaction would only confirm for investigators 752 00:32:37,899 --> 00:32:40,135 just how sinister Lavergne was. 753 00:32:40,235 --> 00:32:42,337 I'm not sure you know Brandon 754 00:32:42,437 --> 00:32:44,439 as well as you think you know him. 755 00:32:44,539 --> 00:32:45,707 - Okay. - Okay. 756 00:32:45,807 --> 00:32:48,543 - I'd like to. - You-you'd like to. 757 00:32:48,643 --> 00:32:49,811 If there's something I don't know, 758 00:32:49,911 --> 00:32:51,246 I need to know. 759 00:32:51,346 --> 00:32:53,515 It would take the work of two detectives 760 00:32:53,615 --> 00:32:55,750 to reveal the rest. 761 00:32:55,850 --> 00:32:57,552 I'm a brutally honest person. 762 00:32:57,652 --> 00:33:02,023 Brandon is under arrest for first-degree murder. 763 00:33:02,123 --> 00:33:03,091 - What? - Yes. 764 00:33:03,191 --> 00:33:06,728 He is, without a reasonable doubt, 765 00:33:06,828 --> 00:33:09,564 the man who kidnapped and murdered Mickey Shunick. 766 00:33:09,664 --> 00:33:11,733 - Y'all have proof? - We do. Okay. 767 00:33:11,833 --> 00:33:13,468 Oh, my God! 768 00:33:13,568 --> 00:33:15,670 I know. 769 00:33:15,770 --> 00:33:17,739 I would not walk in here and tell you this if I didn't. 770 00:33:17,839 --> 00:33:19,307 Okay? - I can't believe-- 771 00:33:19,407 --> 00:33:20,408 Okay, listen to me. 772 00:33:20,508 --> 00:33:21,876 Take a deep breath. Take a deep breath. 773 00:33:21,977 --> 00:33:24,145 Because you asked me for proof. Okay? 774 00:33:24,246 --> 00:33:24,980 It's hard for you to believe 775 00:33:25,080 --> 00:33:26,514 because you think you know him. 776 00:33:26,615 --> 00:33:29,851 I would never be associated with some-- 777 00:33:29,951 --> 00:33:31,419 - We know that. - We're not accusing you. 778 00:33:31,519 --> 00:33:32,687 - Listen to me. - Oh, my God. 779 00:33:32,787 --> 00:33:35,490 Listen, listen. Take-- Take a deep breath. 780 00:33:35,590 --> 00:33:36,825 You want to hear the facts, right? 781 00:33:36,925 --> 00:33:38,560 Yes! What is-- What's the-- 782 00:33:38,660 --> 00:33:40,362 Okay. 783 00:33:40,462 --> 00:33:42,998 I cannot lay out 100 percent of it, okay? 784 00:33:43,098 --> 00:33:44,032 Not at this point. 785 00:33:44,132 --> 00:33:46,334 - He used me! - Okay. 786 00:33:46,434 --> 00:33:47,836 He's good at it. That's what he does. 787 00:33:47,936 --> 00:33:49,237 He is a sociopath. 788 00:33:49,337 --> 00:33:51,973 - I believed him. - He's a manipulator. Okay. 789 00:33:55,010 --> 00:33:57,012 Lavergne's fiance may have been shocked, 790 00:33:57,112 --> 00:33:59,214 but detectives weren't. 791 00:33:59,314 --> 00:34:00,949 They knew something else. 792 00:34:01,049 --> 00:34:03,652 Brandon Lavergne's past was far darker 793 00:34:03,752 --> 00:34:05,687 than anyone had imagined. 794 00:34:05,787 --> 00:34:07,355 We learned that Brandon's name had come up 795 00:34:07,455 --> 00:34:08,556 in a neighboring parish, 796 00:34:08,657 --> 00:34:12,193 uh, that he was a suspect of a murder back in 1999. 797 00:34:12,294 --> 00:34:14,062 In fact, prosecutors took the case 798 00:34:14,162 --> 00:34:17,199 to the grand jury, but it failed to indict, 799 00:34:17,299 --> 00:34:19,668 citing insufficient evidence. 800 00:34:19,768 --> 00:34:21,036 For detectives, 801 00:34:21,136 --> 00:34:22,837 it was the final piece of the puzzle 802 00:34:22,938 --> 00:34:25,640 that put this case over the top. 803 00:34:25,740 --> 00:34:27,242 For the Shunicks, 804 00:34:27,342 --> 00:34:28,410 any lingering hope 805 00:34:28,510 --> 00:34:33,048 that Mickey would be found alive was now gone. 806 00:34:33,148 --> 00:34:34,516 Me and my mom shut down after that. 807 00:34:34,616 --> 00:34:36,184 We just... 808 00:34:36,284 --> 00:34:37,519 And then I got to listen to Charlie 809 00:34:37,619 --> 00:34:40,422 through the wall cry all night. 810 00:34:40,522 --> 00:34:44,526 I mean, you know, the aching crying. 811 00:34:44,626 --> 00:34:46,628 But prosecutors were now struggling 812 00:34:46,728 --> 00:34:48,897 with worries of their own. 813 00:34:48,997 --> 00:34:51,967 Could they get a conviction without knowing 814 00:34:52,067 --> 00:34:55,003 what had happened to the victim. 815 00:34:55,103 --> 00:34:58,640 Our primary concern was to find the body. 816 00:35:02,711 --> 00:35:09,150 ♪ 817 00:35:09,251 --> 00:35:12,454 Three weeks after police arrested Brandon Lavergne, 818 00:35:12,554 --> 00:35:14,289 the Lafayette District Attorney's office 819 00:35:14,389 --> 00:35:17,058 charged him with Mickey Shunick's murder. 820 00:35:17,158 --> 00:35:18,727 For Charlie Shunick, 821 00:35:18,827 --> 00:35:21,696 one big question had been answered. 822 00:35:21,796 --> 00:35:23,565 I went home and I looked him up, 823 00:35:23,665 --> 00:35:26,434 and I was like, well, if this guy is responsible, 824 00:35:26,534 --> 00:35:28,603 Mickey is definitely not alive anymore. 825 00:35:28,703 --> 00:35:29,538 That's probably when we all 826 00:35:29,638 --> 00:35:32,941 really started mourning the loss of her. 827 00:35:33,041 --> 00:35:35,010 Daniel Landry and Keith Stutes 828 00:35:35,110 --> 00:35:36,945 were prosecuting Lavergne. 829 00:35:37,045 --> 00:35:38,446 What made you so sure about him? 830 00:35:38,547 --> 00:35:40,348 I don't know that there was a single event 831 00:35:40,448 --> 00:35:41,516 or a single circumstance. 832 00:35:41,616 --> 00:35:44,219 It was the mountain of circumstances. 833 00:35:44,319 --> 00:35:46,021 Not the least of which was that Lavergne had been 834 00:35:46,121 --> 00:35:49,958 a prime suspect in a murder back in 1999. 835 00:35:50,058 --> 00:35:52,460 The possibility Lavergne had killed before 836 00:35:52,561 --> 00:35:55,897 only strengthened prosecutor Keith Stutes resolve. 837 00:35:55,997 --> 00:35:59,901 It was, how can we make this case better 838 00:36:00,001 --> 00:36:03,071 by the existence of this prior investigation. 839 00:36:03,171 --> 00:36:04,506 Each case is made stronger 840 00:36:04,606 --> 00:36:07,175 by the existence of the other case. 841 00:36:07,275 --> 00:36:10,412 Still, prosecutors knew it wouldn't be easy. 842 00:36:10,512 --> 00:36:12,314 This would be a death penalty case, 843 00:36:12,414 --> 00:36:14,716 making the bar that much higher. 844 00:36:14,816 --> 00:36:16,217 And your classic defense is, 845 00:36:16,318 --> 00:36:17,752 you're in the middle of the trial, 846 00:36:17,852 --> 00:36:19,087 they point at the back door 847 00:36:19,187 --> 00:36:20,422 and tell the jury, 848 00:36:20,522 --> 00:36:23,291 how do you know that person is not gonna walk in 849 00:36:23,391 --> 00:36:24,392 through that door? 850 00:36:24,492 --> 00:36:25,860 Is that a reasonable doubt? 851 00:36:25,961 --> 00:36:27,462 Well, you can end up with a not guilty 852 00:36:27,562 --> 00:36:29,264 just by that fact alone. 853 00:36:29,364 --> 00:36:34,135 Our primary concern was to find the body. 854 00:36:34,236 --> 00:36:36,871 But Brandon Lavergne wasn't cooperating. 855 00:36:36,972 --> 00:36:40,475 So prosecutors gathered to make a very tough decision, 856 00:36:40,575 --> 00:36:43,478 offer to take the death penalty off the table 857 00:36:43,578 --> 00:36:45,947 in exchange for a full confession 858 00:36:46,047 --> 00:36:49,317 and the whereabouts of Mickey's body. 859 00:36:49,417 --> 00:36:50,285 Did you hate that, 860 00:36:50,385 --> 00:36:52,954 or were you eager to make that deal? 861 00:36:53,054 --> 00:36:54,956 I was eager to make that deal. 862 00:36:55,056 --> 00:36:56,625 Finding the body was important, obviously, 863 00:36:56,725 --> 00:36:59,527 for the prosecution, but as important for us 864 00:36:59,628 --> 00:37:01,062 in this case was finding her 865 00:37:01,162 --> 00:37:04,432 to bring her back to her family. 866 00:37:04,532 --> 00:37:06,468 My feeling was, we want her found. 867 00:37:06,568 --> 00:37:08,136 Yeah, before I could say a word, she says, 868 00:37:08,236 --> 00:37:09,604 "I want the body found." - Yeah. 869 00:37:09,704 --> 00:37:10,939 But the DA's office 870 00:37:11,039 --> 00:37:12,908 wasn't going to make this easy for Lavergne. 871 00:37:13,008 --> 00:37:14,175 He would also have to plead guilty 872 00:37:14,276 --> 00:37:17,479 to the other murder, back in 1999. 873 00:37:17,579 --> 00:37:19,547 He had two death penalty cases 874 00:37:19,648 --> 00:37:21,316 to think about, not one. 875 00:37:21,416 --> 00:37:22,584 You think that swayed him? 876 00:37:22,684 --> 00:37:24,786 - I think it was a factor. - Certainly. 877 00:37:24,886 --> 00:37:27,422 Just one day after being offered the deal, 878 00:37:27,522 --> 00:37:29,224 Lavergne accepted. 879 00:37:29,324 --> 00:37:33,495 He received two life sentences. 880 00:37:33,595 --> 00:37:35,697 Do you think Brandon Lavergne is responsible 881 00:37:35,797 --> 00:37:36,898 for any other abductions 882 00:37:36,998 --> 00:37:39,634 or any other murders that you don't know about? 883 00:37:39,734 --> 00:37:41,002 I think it's quite possible 884 00:37:41,102 --> 00:37:45,473 if he's capable of two, why not three, why not four? 885 00:37:45,574 --> 00:37:47,208 Lavergne also revealed 886 00:37:47,309 --> 00:37:49,611 the whereabouts of Mickey's body. 887 00:37:49,711 --> 00:37:52,047 It was here in this small rural cemetery 888 00:37:52,147 --> 00:37:54,049 that police found Mickey 889 00:37:54,149 --> 00:37:57,519 30 miles from where she'd been abducted. 890 00:37:57,619 --> 00:38:00,722 He placed her body here, covered her up with some brush. 891 00:38:00,822 --> 00:38:02,657 The coroner's office later determined 892 00:38:02,757 --> 00:38:05,594 Mickey had been stabbed multiple times. 893 00:38:05,694 --> 00:38:08,997 The fatal wound was a gunshot to the head. 894 00:38:09,097 --> 00:38:11,099 It was a very violent death. 895 00:38:13,535 --> 00:38:15,203 In his confession, Lavergne claimed 896 00:38:15,303 --> 00:38:17,572 it was all an accident. 897 00:38:17,672 --> 00:38:18,640 He was driving drunk 898 00:38:18,740 --> 00:38:21,042 and didn't mean to bump Mickey's bike. 899 00:38:21,142 --> 00:38:22,110 {\an8}He said that what followed 900 00:38:22,210 --> 00:38:24,512 {\an8}was a heated argument that became physical. 901 00:38:27,048 --> 00:38:30,819 {\an8}Mickey pulled out her mace. Lavergne pulled his knife. 902 00:38:30,919 --> 00:38:32,787 {\an8}It was very close quarters. 903 00:38:32,887 --> 00:38:34,923 {\an8}The cab of Lavergne's truck. 904 00:38:35,023 --> 00:38:37,792 {\an8}He won only when he drew his gun. 905 00:38:45,667 --> 00:38:47,736 What ultimately happens at the moment 906 00:38:47,836 --> 00:38:49,437 of the confrontation, 907 00:38:49,538 --> 00:38:53,041 I think is, uh, we'll never know. 908 00:38:53,141 --> 00:38:54,809 But Keith Stutes is certain 909 00:38:54,910 --> 00:38:58,146 it did not begin as an accident. 910 00:38:58,246 --> 00:39:00,348 Lavergne, he says, was a predator 911 00:39:00,448 --> 00:39:02,117 stalking his prey. 912 00:39:02,217 --> 00:39:04,019 It's very clear from the video 913 00:39:04,119 --> 00:39:08,790 that he went out of his way to actually follow her. 914 00:39:08,890 --> 00:39:09,991 There was also no disputing 915 00:39:10,091 --> 00:39:13,862 that before Lavergne fired the fatal gunshot, 916 00:39:13,962 --> 00:39:17,065 Mickey Shunick fought back hard, 917 00:39:17,165 --> 00:39:19,067 stabbing Lavergne several times 918 00:39:19,167 --> 00:39:20,669 with his own knife. 919 00:39:20,769 --> 00:39:21,937 She was way outmatched, 920 00:39:22,037 --> 00:39:23,471 and she knew she was fighting for her life, 921 00:39:23,572 --> 00:39:26,441 and she fought. That was-- She wanted that life. 922 00:39:26,541 --> 00:39:31,213 Mickey did what she had to do. 923 00:39:31,313 --> 00:39:33,848 - You're proud of her? - Oh, absolutely. 924 00:39:33,949 --> 00:39:35,717 You bet. 925 00:39:35,817 --> 00:39:37,586 If she doesn't fight back, 926 00:39:37,686 --> 00:39:39,287 he doesn't get stabbed. - Yeah. 927 00:39:39,387 --> 00:39:42,557 Then he has no wounds for anyone to notice. 928 00:39:42,657 --> 00:39:44,726 And the tip never comes in about him. 929 00:39:44,826 --> 00:39:45,961 I mean, she caught him. 930 00:39:46,061 --> 00:39:49,831 Yeah. Amazing. Good for Mickey. 931 00:39:49,931 --> 00:39:50,966 For Charlie, 932 00:39:51,066 --> 00:39:54,302 it had been an excruciating three month journey. 933 00:39:54,402 --> 00:39:57,939 She'd achieved her goal of bringing Mickey home. 934 00:39:58,039 --> 00:40:00,742 Now it was time to mourn. 935 00:40:00,842 --> 00:40:03,578 Lavergne took a lot from your family. 936 00:40:03,678 --> 00:40:05,280 What did he take from you? 937 00:40:05,380 --> 00:40:06,448 My entire future. 938 00:40:06,548 --> 00:40:09,251 And he rearranged my whole past. 939 00:40:09,351 --> 00:40:11,953 I mean, he took that whole life away from me. 940 00:40:12,053 --> 00:40:13,288 It's different now. 941 00:40:13,388 --> 00:40:18,893 Took my best friend away and... 942 00:40:18,994 --> 00:40:20,595 My little sister. 943 00:40:23,398 --> 00:40:25,834 On a very wet fall afternoon, 944 00:40:25,934 --> 00:40:27,669 weeks after Lavergne was led away 945 00:40:27,769 --> 00:40:30,438 to spend the rest of his life in prison, 946 00:40:30,539 --> 00:40:32,073 Mickey's friends and family, 947 00:40:32,173 --> 00:40:34,643 who had all worked so hard to find her, 948 00:40:34,743 --> 00:40:36,912 gathered to celebrate her life. 949 00:40:37,012 --> 00:40:38,079 The community was so involved, 950 00:40:38,179 --> 00:40:40,181 and we kind of wanted to have like a big memorial 951 00:40:40,282 --> 00:40:42,217 which turned into a life celebration. 952 00:40:42,317 --> 00:40:43,552 Thank y'all for comin' out here. 953 00:40:43,652 --> 00:40:48,189 Uh, I know Mickey still is feeling the love. 954 00:40:48,290 --> 00:40:51,393 There was food, dancing and music. 955 00:40:51,493 --> 00:40:53,128 There was also, of course, 956 00:40:53,228 --> 00:40:55,330 a ceremonial bike ride. 957 00:40:55,430 --> 00:40:58,166 Leading the back, Mickey's mother, Nancy, 958 00:40:58,266 --> 00:41:02,571 riding Mickey's now refurbished bicycle. 959 00:41:02,671 --> 00:41:06,241 They stopped at the spot where Mickey was abducted. 960 00:41:06,341 --> 00:41:07,309 Today at this place, 961 00:41:07,409 --> 00:41:10,245 we're gathered to place this bike 962 00:41:10,345 --> 00:41:12,047 in her honor and as a testament 963 00:41:12,147 --> 00:41:14,416 to her strength and courage. 964 00:41:14,516 --> 00:41:16,318 [applause] 965 00:41:16,418 --> 00:41:18,620 And then they released butterflies. 966 00:41:20,855 --> 00:41:22,390 How do you go on from this? 967 00:41:22,490 --> 00:41:23,792 I wouldn't have a clue. 968 00:41:23,892 --> 00:41:25,827 You just really have to think about that person 969 00:41:25,927 --> 00:41:27,796 and say, well, would Mickey really want me 970 00:41:27,896 --> 00:41:30,398 to be miserable for the rest of my life? 971 00:41:30,498 --> 00:41:32,033 She wouldn't want me to be sad for five minutes, 972 00:41:32,133 --> 00:41:34,069 let alone five months almost. 973 00:41:34,169 --> 00:41:40,876 And you just have to live your life for that person. 974 00:41:40,976 --> 00:41:43,578 Four years after finding Mickey, 975 00:41:43,678 --> 00:41:47,515 Charlie's spine of steel was tested yet again. 976 00:41:47,616 --> 00:41:48,583 This time after learning 977 00:41:48,683 --> 00:41:51,419 she had a rare type of brain tumor. 978 00:41:51,519 --> 00:41:54,122 The good news, it was benign. 979 00:41:54,222 --> 00:41:55,423 And Charlie is looking forward 980 00:41:55,523 --> 00:41:58,159 to a long, bright future. 981 00:41:58,260 --> 00:42:02,497 Just what sister Mickey would have wanted. 982 00:42:02,597 --> 00:42:04,165 Charlie Shunick never imagined 983 00:42:04,266 --> 00:42:06,401 a future without her sister. 984 00:42:06,501 --> 00:42:08,770 And Mickey's murder led her to a career 985 00:42:08,870 --> 00:42:10,839 she also didn't expect. 986 00:42:10,939 --> 00:42:12,574 Charlie became an associate professor 987 00:42:12,674 --> 00:42:15,710 at Delgado Community College in New Orleans. 988 00:42:15,810 --> 00:42:18,880 There she has used lessons from Mickey's case 989 00:42:18,980 --> 00:42:22,817 to train students to one day help solve other crimes. 990 00:42:22,918 --> 00:42:25,754 {\an8}Charlie also consults on missing persons cases 991 00:42:25,854 --> 00:42:28,490 {\an8}and runs a non-profit she created 992 00:42:28,590 --> 00:42:32,594 {\an8}called Resource Association for Missing People.