1
00:00:01,142 --> 00:00:04,446
♪
2
00:00:04,546 --> 00:00:06,848
Some stories are
unforgettable.
3
00:00:06,948 --> 00:00:09,618
This is one of them.
4
00:00:11,152 --> 00:00:12,187
I remember
my knees were shaking,
5
00:00:12,287 --> 00:00:15,156
my palms were all clammy.
6
00:00:15,257 --> 00:00:18,593
I mean, that was an awful day.
7
00:00:18,693 --> 00:00:20,128
It was just so shocking.
8
00:00:20,228 --> 00:00:22,998
I mean,
who this has happened to,
9
00:00:23,098 --> 00:00:24,699
my little sister.
10
00:00:24,799 --> 00:00:26,868
What struck me immediately
about this story
11
00:00:26,968 --> 00:00:29,871
was the bond between
the Shunick sisters.
12
00:00:29,971 --> 00:00:31,706
They were inseparable.
13
00:00:31,806 --> 00:00:33,808
Until the night
Mickey vanished...
14
00:00:33,909 --> 00:00:35,944
This was an extraordinary
circumstance.
15
00:00:36,044 --> 00:00:38,613
Suddenly,
Charlie was everywhere.
16
00:00:38,713 --> 00:00:42,217
Relentless in a crusade
for her sister.
17
00:00:42,317 --> 00:00:45,086
Whatever path I was on before,
this is different now.
18
00:00:45,186 --> 00:00:46,454
Where was Mickey?
19
00:00:46,554 --> 00:00:50,759
Someone knew the answer
and was hiding in plain sight.
20
00:00:50,859 --> 00:00:51,793
[crying]
21
00:00:51,893 --> 00:00:54,029
Even those closest to him
didn't know that
22
00:00:54,129 --> 00:00:55,530
he had that secret life.
23
00:00:55,630 --> 00:00:58,300
This case was full
of dramatic twists.
24
00:00:58,400 --> 00:01:00,902
The biggest came
from Mickey herself.
25
00:01:01,002 --> 00:01:03,738
She helped solve her own murder.
26
00:01:03,838 --> 00:01:05,273
She knew she was
fighting for her life.
27
00:01:05,373 --> 00:01:06,875
And she fought.
- You're proud of her?
28
00:01:06,975 --> 00:01:09,244
Yeah, it's amazing.
Good for Mickey.
29
00:01:09,377 --> 00:01:16,051
♪
30
00:01:16,151 --> 00:01:17,986
This is
Dateline: Unforgettable.
31
00:01:18,086 --> 00:01:21,856
I'm Josh Mankiewicz with
a fresh look at Missing Mickey.
32
00:01:23,959 --> 00:01:26,127
♪
33
00:01:26,228 --> 00:01:27,729
Southern Louisiana,
34
00:01:27,829 --> 00:01:33,702
laced with mysterious bayous
and twisting waterways,
35
00:01:33,802 --> 00:01:37,472
where surprises lurk
around every bend.
36
00:01:37,572 --> 00:01:42,010
A place that can be as dangerous
as it is majestic.
37
00:01:43,144 --> 00:01:47,082
It's where all the currents
of our story cross.
38
00:01:47,182 --> 00:01:50,852
Fear, secrets, loss.
39
00:01:50,952 --> 00:01:53,622
But most of all,
love and family.
40
00:01:53,755 --> 00:01:55,924
♪
41
00:01:56,024 --> 00:01:59,361
Charlene and Michaela Shunick
grew up here,
42
00:01:59,461 --> 00:02:01,963
near the Gulf Coast
in Lafayette.
43
00:02:02,063 --> 00:02:06,568
At first, these two
barely tolerated one another.
44
00:02:06,668 --> 00:02:08,803
You and your sister
are how far apart in age?
45
00:02:08,904 --> 00:02:09,905
Two years.
46
00:02:10,005 --> 00:02:12,007
So I'm guessing growing up,
you were probably
47
00:02:12,107 --> 00:02:15,610
at each other's throats.
- Yeah, all the time.
48
00:02:15,710 --> 00:02:16,912
You know,
it's war between girls
49
00:02:17,012 --> 00:02:19,314
until they realize
they're friends.
50
00:02:19,414 --> 00:02:23,385
But then these two sisters
didn't just become friends,
51
00:02:23,485 --> 00:02:24,953
they became best friends.
52
00:02:25,053 --> 00:02:26,288
And once I moved out
of my parents house,
53
00:02:26,388 --> 00:02:27,789
we got really close.
54
00:02:27,889 --> 00:02:31,226
In my job, I see all types
of family dynamics.
55
00:02:31,326 --> 00:02:33,461
The good, the bad,
and sometimes
56
00:02:33,562 --> 00:02:35,730
the impossible to process.
57
00:02:35,830 --> 00:02:38,100
This was different because
the bond the Shunick sisters had
58
00:02:39,100 --> 00:02:41,136
was extraordinarily tight.
59
00:02:41,236 --> 00:02:44,139
It's a big reason
this story has stayed with me.
60
00:02:44,239 --> 00:02:45,974
Like a lot of siblings
close in age,
61
00:02:46,074 --> 00:02:48,143
these two young women
expected to share
62
00:02:48,243 --> 00:02:50,545
all of life's milestones.
63
00:02:50,645 --> 00:02:52,981
That future was
stolen from them.
64
00:02:53,081 --> 00:02:58,920
And the loss transformed
the sister who was left behind.
65
00:02:59,020 --> 00:03:01,489
The Shunick girls
had plenty in common.
66
00:03:01,590 --> 00:03:05,493
Big smiles,
equally big, puffy yellow hair,
67
00:03:05,594 --> 00:03:08,897
and nicknames
they preferred to use.
68
00:03:08,997 --> 00:03:12,033
Charlene was known
around Lafayette as Charlie.
69
00:03:12,133 --> 00:03:13,134
And Michaela?
70
00:03:13,235 --> 00:03:15,937
She never ever went by
anything but Mickey.
71
00:03:16,037 --> 00:03:18,506
It was always Mickey.
No Michaela.
72
00:03:18,607 --> 00:03:21,977
Parents, Tom, a scientist
working in the oil industry,
73
00:03:22,077 --> 00:03:25,881
and Nancy, a stay at home mom,
kept a watchful eye
74
00:03:25,981 --> 00:03:28,717
as two very similar
looking girls
75
00:03:28,817 --> 00:03:31,987
developed two very different
personalities.
76
00:03:32,087 --> 00:03:34,122
- Charlie...
- Charlie was the dominant one.
77
00:03:34,222 --> 00:03:36,791
She was always really outgoing,
really, you know,
78
00:03:36,892 --> 00:03:38,593
just a-a fireball.
79
00:03:38,693 --> 00:03:41,363
Mickey, on the other hand,
had an intriguing,
80
00:03:41,463 --> 00:03:43,031
quiet way about her.
81
00:03:43,131 --> 00:03:46,735
She seemed to be sort of
an enchanted, magical creature.
82
00:03:46,835 --> 00:03:50,372
She was sarcastic
and kind of shy.
83
00:03:50,472 --> 00:03:52,307
- Are you recording?
- Are you--
84
00:03:52,407 --> 00:03:55,377
Are you doing that right now?
Come on.
85
00:03:55,477 --> 00:03:57,812
Really quick witted,
really funny.
86
00:03:57,913 --> 00:03:59,614
[laughing]
87
00:03:59,714 --> 00:04:03,485
At 21, Mickey lived at home
while studying anthropology
88
00:04:03,585 --> 00:04:07,088
at the home of the Ragin Cajuns,
89
00:04:07,188 --> 00:04:10,091
the University of Louisiana
at Lafayette.
90
00:04:10,192 --> 00:04:11,593
Where'd you see her going?
91
00:04:11,693 --> 00:04:13,295
I was pretty sure she was
gonna end up teaching
92
00:04:13,395 --> 00:04:17,132
horseback riding lessons and...
- Mickey go to the jump.
93
00:04:17,232 --> 00:04:19,034
You know, working for
an equestrian farm
94
00:04:19,134 --> 00:04:20,735
and maybe
owning her own someday.
95
00:04:20,835 --> 00:04:23,305
And when Mickey wasn't
with her animals,
96
00:04:23,405 --> 00:04:26,975
you could see her whizzing
around town on her bike.
97
00:04:27,075 --> 00:04:28,510
Lafayette's a small town.
98
00:04:28,610 --> 00:04:30,045
You can get anywhere
in that city on a bike
99
00:04:30,145 --> 00:04:31,713
in 20 or 30 minutes.
100
00:04:31,813 --> 00:04:33,915
Which is why
on a late Friday night
101
00:04:34,015 --> 00:04:35,917
back in May of 2012,
102
00:04:36,017 --> 00:04:38,420
having listened to
live music with friends,
103
00:04:38,520 --> 00:04:40,922
Mickey planned on
riding her bike home.
104
00:04:41,022 --> 00:04:43,191
We grew up there.
It seemed really safe.
105
00:04:43,291 --> 00:04:45,393
Mickey's brother's
high school graduation
106
00:04:45,493 --> 00:04:47,629
was just hours away.
107
00:04:47,729 --> 00:04:50,565
But before calling it a night,
she decided to stop off
108
00:04:50,665 --> 00:04:54,069
at the home of her friend
Brettley Wilson.
109
00:04:54,169 --> 00:04:57,105
She's like, "It's nice out,
you know, I'm tired,
110
00:04:57,205 --> 00:04:58,607
but the bike ride's
gonna be amazing.
111
00:04:58,707 --> 00:05:00,642
I'll put in my headphones,
I'll bike home,
112
00:05:00,742 --> 00:05:01,810
I'll get
a couple hours of sleep
113
00:05:01,910 --> 00:05:03,612
and then I'll do
the graduation."
114
00:05:03,712 --> 00:05:05,981
Walked her to the door
and turned
115
00:05:06,081 --> 00:05:08,750
and told her goodnight
and to be safe.
116
00:05:08,850 --> 00:05:12,887
That did not at the time
seem like an important moment,
117
00:05:12,988 --> 00:05:17,359
but it would later be revisited
and re-examined again and again.
118
00:05:17,459 --> 00:05:19,895
Because somewhere,
at some point,
119
00:05:19,995 --> 00:05:23,265
after Brettley says
she left his house,
120
00:05:23,365 --> 00:05:25,367
Mickey Shunick vanished.
121
00:05:25,467 --> 00:05:27,168
That was the last time
I saw her.
122
00:05:27,269 --> 00:05:29,704
Later that morning,
Charlie called Mickey
123
00:05:29,804 --> 00:05:33,008
to remind her about
their brother Zach's graduation.
124
00:05:33,108 --> 00:05:34,009
Her phone wasn't on.
125
00:05:34,109 --> 00:05:35,277
I was like,
"Oh, that's kind of weird."
126
00:05:35,377 --> 00:05:36,645
You know, I get home,
my mom's all mad.
127
00:05:36,745 --> 00:05:38,446
She's like, "Where's Mickey?
128
00:05:38,547 --> 00:05:40,081
Mickey's always off
doing something.
129
00:05:40,181 --> 00:05:43,084
I don't know what she got up to,
but she's not here," you know.
130
00:05:43,184 --> 00:05:45,086
So we go to
my brother's graduation.
131
00:05:45,186 --> 00:05:46,688
- And she's not there.
- She's not there.
132
00:05:46,788 --> 00:05:48,189
- Now, that's not like her.
- No, I mean,
133
00:05:48,290 --> 00:05:49,958
I remember texting her,
like, "You're an idiot.
134
00:05:50,058 --> 00:05:51,693
Where are you?
What's going on here?"
135
00:05:51,793 --> 00:05:54,763
So even at the graduation,
you're still thinking,
136
00:05:54,863 --> 00:05:56,898
"You're a moron"?
Not "something's wrong."
137
00:05:56,998 --> 00:06:00,769
Yeah, yeah, like,
"Darn it, Mickey."
138
00:06:00,869 --> 00:06:04,673
But by late afternoon,
that started to change.
139
00:06:04,773 --> 00:06:07,342
My mom texts me, "Hey,
have you heard from Mickey?"
140
00:06:07,442 --> 00:06:08,877
You know, "What's going on?"
141
00:06:08,977 --> 00:06:14,015
If she had some plan to
run off with somebody or alone,
142
00:06:14,115 --> 00:06:16,151
you'd have known about it.
- Oh, yeah.
143
00:06:16,251 --> 00:06:18,587
Mickey and I talked
about everything, so...
144
00:06:18,687 --> 00:06:22,424
And in that instant,
irritation turned to fear.
145
00:06:22,524 --> 00:06:24,926
Nancy started calling all the
hospitals
146
00:06:25,026 --> 00:06:27,395
as Charlie turned to
Brettley Wilson,
147
00:06:27,495 --> 00:06:29,931
the last person
to have seen Mickey.
148
00:06:30,031 --> 00:06:32,867
Charlie told Brettley
her sister never made it home
149
00:06:32,968 --> 00:06:34,035
that morning.
150
00:06:34,135 --> 00:06:38,273
So Brettley tells you...?
- Well, h-he's confused.
151
00:06:38,373 --> 00:06:41,409
He says, "Oh, no!
Well, she left my house
152
00:06:41,509 --> 00:06:44,145
and said she had to go home
for Zach's graduation."
153
00:06:44,246 --> 00:06:46,848
That's when I freaked out
and started crying,
154
00:06:46,948 --> 00:06:49,217
and I couldn't process anything.
- From the startup,
155
00:06:49,317 --> 00:06:52,120
you could tell that this was
an extraordinary circumstance.
156
00:06:52,220 --> 00:06:55,123
Captain Kelly Gibson
and Detective Stephen Bajat of
157
00:06:55,223 --> 00:06:58,093
the Lafayette Police Department
caught Mickey's case.
158
00:06:58,193 --> 00:07:02,163
This was not somebody
who was just gonna vanish.
159
00:07:02,264 --> 00:07:04,299
No, she'd never
done that before.
160
00:07:04,399 --> 00:07:09,170
She'd always let her family know
where she was gonna be.
161
00:07:09,271 --> 00:07:11,406
The Shunick family
took to the streets
162
00:07:11,506 --> 00:07:13,475
in search of Mickey,
163
00:07:13,575 --> 00:07:15,977
and they'd be joined by
legions of people
164
00:07:16,077 --> 00:07:18,413
from the Lafayette community.
165
00:07:18,513 --> 00:07:21,683
It was just unbelievable
to see.
166
00:07:21,783 --> 00:07:24,486
We still have hope.
What we want to do is find her.
167
00:07:24,586 --> 00:07:27,923
So we've got that.
That's what we're trying to do.
168
00:07:28,023 --> 00:07:30,592
Soon, police would have
questions for that friend
169
00:07:30,692 --> 00:07:33,628
who was the last person
to see Mickey
170
00:07:33,728 --> 00:07:35,263
before she vanished.
171
00:07:35,363 --> 00:07:38,233
I remember yelling, "No,
I didn't do anything to her!
172
00:07:38,333 --> 00:07:39,634
No!"
173
00:07:39,768 --> 00:07:43,371
♪
174
00:07:43,905 --> 00:07:53,982
♪
175
00:07:55,016 --> 00:07:57,519
There is not a single name
that we came up with
176
00:07:57,619 --> 00:07:59,854
that could've-- someone who
could be responsible for this.
177
00:07:59,955 --> 00:08:01,623
No one could think of
even one person.
178
00:08:01,723 --> 00:08:02,591
Well, she didn't have
any enemies.
179
00:08:02,691 --> 00:08:05,427
Everyone I know liked her.
180
00:08:05,527 --> 00:08:10,198
No one ever said
anything bad about her.
181
00:08:10,298 --> 00:08:14,369
No obvious suspects,
no real evidence of foul play.
182
00:08:14,469 --> 00:08:18,673
A beautiful girl
gone without a trace.
183
00:08:18,773 --> 00:08:20,742
There was very little
physical evidence
184
00:08:20,842 --> 00:08:22,978
that we had to follow.
185
00:08:23,078 --> 00:08:26,281
The last message that
s-she received on her--
186
00:08:26,381 --> 00:08:30,385
On her cell phone was around
1:46 in the morning on May 19.
187
00:08:30,485 --> 00:08:32,454
But after that,
there has been no activity.
188
00:08:32,554 --> 00:08:36,558
I mean, that in and of itself
sounds kind of ominous.
189
00:08:36,658 --> 00:08:39,561
- Yes.
- It's a truism of police work
190
00:08:39,661 --> 00:08:42,297
that the last person
to see a victim alive
191
00:08:42,397 --> 00:08:45,333
is the first focus
of the investigation.
192
00:08:45,433 --> 00:08:47,002
So police brought in
Mickey's friend,
193
00:08:47,102 --> 00:08:49,371
Brettley Wilson for questioning.
194
00:08:49,471 --> 00:08:52,374
At first, it was just,
"Help us eliminate you."
195
00:08:52,474 --> 00:08:56,044
And then it transitioned into,
you know, "Mistakes happen.
196
00:08:56,144 --> 00:08:59,447
You can-You can tell us
if there was a mistake."
197
00:08:59,548 --> 00:09:04,219
Um, and that segued into,
"You loved her, didn't you?
198
00:09:04,319 --> 00:09:07,956
I mean, you know, pretty girl
loved you, you spurned her.
199
00:09:08,056 --> 00:09:11,359
Uh, you know, maybe you should
just let us know now."
200
00:09:11,459 --> 00:09:14,029
Wilson insisted
he had nothing to do with
201
00:09:14,129 --> 00:09:16,164
his good friend's disappearance.
202
00:09:16,264 --> 00:09:18,099
I remember yelling that
repeatedly.
203
00:09:18,200 --> 00:09:21,403
"No, no, we were just friends.
204
00:09:21,503 --> 00:09:23,638
No, I didn't do anything to her.
205
00:09:23,738 --> 00:09:26,141
No, that was the last time
I saw her!"
206
00:09:26,241 --> 00:09:27,309
It was unrelenting.
207
00:09:27,409 --> 00:09:29,077
You guys took this
pretty seriously.
208
00:09:29,177 --> 00:09:30,011
Absolutely.
209
00:09:30,111 --> 00:09:32,180
We could take
nothing for granted.
210
00:09:32,280 --> 00:09:34,716
As the investigation
gathered steam,
211
00:09:34,816 --> 00:09:36,651
several hundred
friends and neighbors
212
00:09:36,751 --> 00:09:39,521
of the Shunick family
came together
213
00:09:39,621 --> 00:09:41,590
to scour the streets of
Lafayette.
214
00:09:41,690 --> 00:09:43,792
It was a really small city
with a lot of people in it.
215
00:09:43,892 --> 00:09:45,093
Everyone knew a Shunick,
216
00:09:45,193 --> 00:09:46,561
someone knew someone
who knew us.
217
00:09:46,661 --> 00:09:48,230
And it just kind of set--
218
00:09:48,330 --> 00:09:52,200
It was like wildfire, you know,
everyone got involved.
219
00:09:52,300 --> 00:09:55,604
Soon more than 1800 people
from in and around Lafayette
220
00:09:55,704 --> 00:09:58,707
were filtering through
a makeshift search headquarters
221
00:09:58,807 --> 00:10:02,210
set up on the University of
Louisiana campus.
222
00:10:02,310 --> 00:10:03,445
It was amazing.
223
00:10:03,545 --> 00:10:06,881
There would just be people
coming in covered in rashes
224
00:10:06,982 --> 00:10:09,985
and poison ivy and bug bites
and dirt in their hair
225
00:10:10,085 --> 00:10:11,720
and they've been
climbing up trees
226
00:10:11,820 --> 00:10:13,121
and digging through brush and--
227
00:10:13,221 --> 00:10:14,556
Looking for a girl
they had never met.
228
00:10:14,656 --> 00:10:15,557
Yeah.
229
00:10:15,657 --> 00:10:17,525
Social media
played a big part in this.
230
00:10:17,626 --> 00:10:19,728
Facebook is, like,
the number one way
231
00:10:19,828 --> 00:10:21,162
we reached anyone.
232
00:10:21,263 --> 00:10:22,964
Usually in the stories
we cover,
233
00:10:23,064 --> 00:10:25,667
one family member takes the lead
in keeping the case
234
00:10:25,767 --> 00:10:27,569
in the public spotlight.
235
00:10:27,669 --> 00:10:29,471
If a child or young adult
is missing,
236
00:10:29,571 --> 00:10:32,140
frequently a parent
takes on that role.
237
00:10:32,240 --> 00:10:34,943
Because Mickey's parents
were so devastated,
238
00:10:35,043 --> 00:10:37,279
Charlie stepped up instead.
239
00:10:37,379 --> 00:10:40,515
She and I have stayed in touch
and I can tell you
240
00:10:40,615 --> 00:10:45,086
"determined" does not begin to
describe her single minded focus
241
00:10:45,186 --> 00:10:47,255
and grit.
- She talked to everybody.
242
00:10:47,355 --> 00:10:50,525
She did radio interviews
at midnight.
243
00:10:50,625 --> 00:10:51,993
We've divided the city
into quadrants...
244
00:10:52,093 --> 00:10:53,395
{\an8}She got up
at 3:00 in the morning
245
00:10:53,495 --> 00:10:56,264
{\an8}and went over to a TV station.
- We're searching every day.
246
00:10:56,364 --> 00:10:57,866
{\an8}It was always the same thing.
"We've gotta find Mickey.
247
00:10:57,966 --> 00:11:00,735
We gotta bring Mickey home."
- We just want her back.
248
00:11:00,835 --> 00:11:04,706
The 24 year old,
5 foot 2, sometimes blond,
249
00:11:04,806 --> 00:11:08,643
sometimes redhead,
had become the tip of the spear
250
00:11:08,743 --> 00:11:12,814
in a multi-state,
multinational search effort.
251
00:11:12,914 --> 00:11:15,584
Charlie had all
t-the missing posters
252
00:11:15,684 --> 00:11:18,119
translated into Spanish
and people went
253
00:11:18,220 --> 00:11:21,990
and flooded all the border towns
and the border crossings.
254
00:11:22,090 --> 00:11:23,325
I was telling
the social media team
255
00:11:23,425 --> 00:11:25,060
what to say and
what they shouldn't say
256
00:11:25,160 --> 00:11:26,828
and how they should
phrase things
257
00:11:26,928 --> 00:11:30,498
and telling
the headquarter coordinators
258
00:11:30,599 --> 00:11:34,936
where to put bottles of water
and the sandwiches and stuff.
259
00:11:35,036 --> 00:11:36,104
Doesn't leave you
a lot of time
260
00:11:36,204 --> 00:11:38,874
to worry about your sister.
Maybe that was the idea.
261
00:11:38,974 --> 00:11:40,542
That's just what happened.
262
00:11:40,642 --> 00:11:42,377
What was this doing
to Charlie?
263
00:11:42,477 --> 00:11:45,647
Man, s-she stood up.
264
00:11:45,747 --> 00:11:48,350
She turned out to have
a spine of steel, that kid.
265
00:11:48,450 --> 00:11:50,252
I felt like everyone
was depending on me
266
00:11:50,352 --> 00:11:56,124
to stay positive and, you know.
- Be the rock?
267
00:11:57,993 --> 00:12:00,762
I think it was tougher on you
than you're letting on.
268
00:12:00,862 --> 00:12:06,067
You have to put up barriers,
otherwise you can't function.
269
00:12:06,167 --> 00:12:09,838
A week went by,
and then a major breakthrough,
270
00:12:09,938 --> 00:12:13,508
coming from a security camera
that had captured
271
00:12:13,608 --> 00:12:15,143
this haunting image.
272
00:12:15,243 --> 00:12:18,847
A bicyclist heading down
a dark, deserted street
273
00:12:18,947 --> 00:12:21,349
in the direction
of Mickey's home
274
00:12:21,449 --> 00:12:23,852
on the night she disappeared.
275
00:12:23,952 --> 00:12:27,122
Police called you to come in
and look at that video.
276
00:12:27,222 --> 00:12:28,657
Was that Mickey?
- Yes.
277
00:12:28,757 --> 00:12:31,426
You could see the big,
blonde afro that, you know,
278
00:12:31,526 --> 00:12:33,495
we're very well known for.
It was her mannerisms.
279
00:12:33,595 --> 00:12:36,398
It was her bike.
- What was that like to see her?
280
00:12:36,498 --> 00:12:37,766
It was exciting.
281
00:12:37,866 --> 00:12:39,434
It proves that
she got at least this far.
282
00:12:39,534 --> 00:12:41,269
So now we have a place
where we can start from,
283
00:12:41,369 --> 00:12:45,173
instead of searching
the whole city.
284
00:12:45,273 --> 00:12:46,975
Police came to believe
that whatever happened
285
00:12:47,075 --> 00:12:49,010
to Mickey Shunick
probably happened
286
00:12:49,110 --> 00:12:52,147
right around here,
on this lonely stretch of road
287
00:12:52,247 --> 00:12:54,649
that was part of
her normal route home.
288
00:12:54,749 --> 00:12:56,952
Now, police saw Mickey
on security cameras
289
00:12:57,052 --> 00:12:59,254
during the early part
of her journey,
290
00:12:59,354 --> 00:13:02,457
but not on the cameras that
she would have passed later on.
291
00:13:02,557 --> 00:13:05,427
The only problem was that
a detailed and extensive search
292
00:13:05,527 --> 00:13:08,763
of this area
turned up nothing.
293
00:13:08,864 --> 00:13:11,132
But there was something else
detectives saw
294
00:13:11,233 --> 00:13:14,736
on that security video,
something much more ominous.
295
00:13:14,836 --> 00:13:18,807
Here, just after Mickey cycles
out of frame,
296
00:13:18,907 --> 00:13:23,011
someone in a white pickup truck
drives into frame,
297
00:13:23,111 --> 00:13:26,748
following Mickey at an
uncomfortably close distance.
298
00:13:26,848 --> 00:13:30,485
Now, for the first time,
police felt they had evidence
299
00:13:30,585 --> 00:13:32,921
someone else was involved.
300
00:13:33,021 --> 00:13:36,124
Charlie knew that
if Mickey had been abducted,
301
00:13:36,224 --> 00:13:39,394
it wouldn't have happened
without a fight.
302
00:13:39,494 --> 00:13:41,396
If someone took her
and she was conscious,
303
00:13:41,496 --> 00:13:42,497
they're hurting.
304
00:13:42,597 --> 00:13:44,299
They have broken ribs,
they have a broken arm,
305
00:13:44,399 --> 00:13:45,767
broken nose.
I kept saying that.
306
00:13:45,867 --> 00:13:48,770
"Look for someone who's beat up
around the office,
307
00:13:48,870 --> 00:13:51,106
around your neighborhood
because they might be
308
00:13:51,206 --> 00:13:52,741
responsible for this,
- It would have been
309
00:13:52,841 --> 00:13:56,511
totally in character for her
to fight back.
310
00:13:56,611 --> 00:13:59,915
But the clue in that video
would prove as frustrating
311
00:14:00,015 --> 00:14:03,418
to detectives
as it was fascinating.
312
00:14:03,518 --> 00:14:04,920
There got to be a lot of
white pickup trucks
313
00:14:05,020 --> 00:14:06,588
in Louisiana.
- There are indeed.
314
00:14:06,688 --> 00:14:08,623
Within Lafayette Parish
and surrounding parishes,
315
00:14:08,723 --> 00:14:10,425
there's over 3,000.
316
00:14:10,525 --> 00:14:14,196
Lucky for them, they were
about to catch a big break.
317
00:14:14,296 --> 00:14:15,564
Stephen Bajat turned to me
and said,
318
00:14:15,664 --> 00:14:18,133
"Okay, I don't want you
to freak out or anything,
319
00:14:18,233 --> 00:14:20,302
but I think we found her bike."
320
00:14:20,435 --> 00:14:23,572
♪
321
00:14:24,206 --> 00:14:34,015
♪
322
00:14:34,115 --> 00:14:38,553
A blonde on a bicycle,
a white truck pursuing her.
323
00:14:38,653 --> 00:14:41,756
Now, investigators were
pursuing that truck,
324
00:14:41,856 --> 00:14:44,626
and it wouldn't be easy.
325
00:14:44,726 --> 00:14:47,295
Here on the Gulf Coast,
white Chevy pickups
326
00:14:47,395 --> 00:14:49,631
are as common as hot sauce.
327
00:14:49,731 --> 00:14:51,466
Definitely didn't
narrow down t-the search.
328
00:14:51,566 --> 00:14:53,468
It was probably one of
the m-more popular vehicles
329
00:14:53,568 --> 00:14:57,105
in the area.
- Definitely kept us busy.
330
00:14:57,205 --> 00:15:00,508
Those images did prove
one thing conclusively.
331
00:15:00,609 --> 00:15:02,711
They were taken after
Brettley Wilson says
332
00:15:02,811 --> 00:15:04,646
he last saw Mickey,
333
00:15:04,746 --> 00:15:07,148
proving he was
telling the truth.
334
00:15:07,249 --> 00:15:10,518
Mickey had left his house
alive and well
335
00:15:10,619 --> 00:15:12,120
when he said she did.
336
00:15:12,220 --> 00:15:14,556
That was a big deal because
Brettley was cleared.
337
00:15:14,656 --> 00:15:17,025
It proved that someone
we didn't know
338
00:15:17,125 --> 00:15:19,194
probably took her.
339
00:15:22,364 --> 00:15:24,933
As the relentlessly hot
Louisiana summer days
340
00:15:25,033 --> 00:15:28,503
slowly came and went,
Charlie Shunick proved to be
341
00:15:28,603 --> 00:15:30,538
equally relentless,
342
00:15:30,639 --> 00:15:32,908
continuing her appeals
to the public,
343
00:15:33,008 --> 00:15:36,011
determined to find
her sister, Mickey.
344
00:15:36,111 --> 00:15:37,779
Nothing else really seemed
very important
345
00:15:37,879 --> 00:15:38,680
at the time either,
346
00:15:38,780 --> 00:15:41,716
aside from
what we were doing, so...
347
00:15:41,816 --> 00:15:43,018
All the other things
in your life
348
00:15:43,118 --> 00:15:47,088
kind of just fade away?
- Yeah. Yeah.
349
00:15:47,188 --> 00:15:50,091
But by week two,
the fear of the unknown
350
00:15:50,192 --> 00:15:53,228
began to take its toll
on the Shunick family,
351
00:15:53,328 --> 00:15:56,498
which was now forced
to re-examine just what it was
352
00:15:56,598 --> 00:15:59,634
they were hoping
had happened to Mickey.
353
00:15:59,734 --> 00:16:01,770
I thought, you know,
so someone saw
354
00:16:01,870 --> 00:16:05,006
this cute little girl
riding her bike down the street
355
00:16:05,106 --> 00:16:06,241
and hit her on purpose.
356
00:16:06,341 --> 00:16:09,911
And they have her and
are doing God knows what with.
357
00:16:10,011 --> 00:16:11,079
But...
- But she's still alive.
358
00:16:11,179 --> 00:16:14,149
Yeah, that's what
we were thinking. Absolutely.
359
00:16:14,249 --> 00:16:16,818
As for Mickey's mom, Nancy,
hers was a hope
360
00:16:16,918 --> 00:16:19,387
only a mother could feel.
361
00:16:19,487 --> 00:16:21,489
Anybody who spends any time
with her
362
00:16:21,590 --> 00:16:23,358
is not gonna want to hurt her.
363
00:16:23,458 --> 00:16:26,027
Because if you spend
a few minutes with her,
364
00:16:26,127 --> 00:16:28,930
you like her and you love her
and you don't wanna hurt her.
365
00:16:29,030 --> 00:16:32,667
Hearing that was heartbreaking
and also familiar.
366
00:16:32,767 --> 00:16:37,038
I regularly see families
engaging in magical thinking,
367
00:16:37,138 --> 00:16:38,306
and understandably,
368
00:16:38,406 --> 00:16:40,942
because the alternative
is unbearable.
369
00:16:41,042 --> 00:16:44,512
In most cases like Mickey's,
the terrible truth is that
370
00:16:44,613 --> 00:16:46,982
the missing person
is often killed
371
00:16:47,082 --> 00:16:49,784
before anyone knows
to look for them.
372
00:16:49,884 --> 00:16:53,755
When I spoke with the Shunicks,
their grief was palpable.
373
00:16:53,855 --> 00:16:56,157
And those conversations are
the hardest thing
374
00:16:56,258 --> 00:16:58,260
about doing this job.
375
00:16:58,360 --> 00:17:01,596
Without Mickey, your mom
was having a very tough time.
376
00:17:01,696 --> 00:17:04,266
Yeah.
377
00:17:04,366 --> 00:17:07,269
Yeah, I don't--
378
00:17:07,369 --> 00:17:09,771
It's just, I feel so bad
for my mom, you know?
379
00:17:09,871 --> 00:17:14,075
Um...
380
00:17:18,580 --> 00:17:20,415
She always said that
if she ever lost one of us,
381
00:17:20,515 --> 00:17:25,120
she would... not be able to
go on in life and...
382
00:17:27,322 --> 00:17:28,723
But yeah, it was
pretty hard on her.
383
00:17:28,823 --> 00:17:30,759
It was just so shocking.
384
00:17:30,859 --> 00:17:34,462
I mean,
who this has happened to.
385
00:17:34,563 --> 00:17:37,465
And then eight days
after Mickey vanished,
386
00:17:37,566 --> 00:17:41,336
the investigation took
a huge leap forward.
387
00:17:41,436 --> 00:17:42,837
Stephen Bajat turned to me
and said,
388
00:17:42,938 --> 00:17:45,273
"Okay, I don't want you to
freak out or anything,
389
00:17:45,373 --> 00:17:47,108
but I think we found her bike."
390
00:17:47,209 --> 00:17:51,179
Two fishermen had found
Mickey's bike east of Lafayette
391
00:17:51,279 --> 00:17:53,848
in a body of water
called Whiskey Bay,
392
00:17:53,949 --> 00:17:56,351
just under the interstate.
393
00:17:56,451 --> 00:17:59,387
It was covered in mud
and, you know, dried water
394
00:17:59,487 --> 00:18:00,622
from being in the swamp.
395
00:18:00,722 --> 00:18:02,390
How far away from
where she disappeared
396
00:18:02,490 --> 00:18:03,992
was the bicycle found?
397
00:18:04,092 --> 00:18:05,794
Um, 25 miles.
398
00:18:05,894 --> 00:18:08,530
- That's not a good sign.
- No, it's not.
399
00:18:08,630 --> 00:18:11,166
Now, police had hard,
physical evidence
400
00:18:11,266 --> 00:18:14,236
with which to build
a theory of the crime.
401
00:18:14,336 --> 00:18:16,471
What could you tell from
looking at the bicycle?
402
00:18:16,571 --> 00:18:18,640
That there was significant
damage to the back tire.
403
00:18:18,740 --> 00:18:20,575
It looked like
it had been impacted.
404
00:18:20,675 --> 00:18:22,877
- Somebody had rammed her?
- That's what it looked like.
405
00:18:22,978 --> 00:18:24,746
- Scary?
- Yeah.
406
00:18:24,846 --> 00:18:25,914
I almost passed out, actually.
407
00:18:26,014 --> 00:18:29,050
I, like, had to brace myself
up against the table.
408
00:18:29,150 --> 00:18:31,920
And so I was thinking,
okay, this was a malicious act
409
00:18:32,020 --> 00:18:35,123
and who did this?
410
00:18:35,223 --> 00:18:37,826
Police immediately began
the sober task
411
00:18:37,926 --> 00:18:41,196
of searching for Mickey
in the several thousand acres
412
00:18:41,296 --> 00:18:44,799
of Louisiana's
largest swamp land.
413
00:18:44,900 --> 00:18:47,669
We focused a lot of manpower
a-and efforts into the--
414
00:18:47,769 --> 00:18:49,437
into the search of this area.
415
00:18:49,538 --> 00:18:51,373
Uh, we had individuals
on airboats, uh,
416
00:18:51,473 --> 00:18:53,675
like we're on now, uh, ATVs,
417
00:18:53,775 --> 00:18:55,777
we had, uh,
officers on horseback.
418
00:18:55,877 --> 00:18:57,646
Just amazing search efforts.
419
00:18:57,746 --> 00:18:59,781
Is that where you sort of
began to think,
420
00:18:59,881 --> 00:19:02,951
we're probably no longer looking
for somebody who's alive?
421
00:19:03,051 --> 00:19:05,987
Right. It was more of
a recovery effort at that point.
422
00:19:06,087 --> 00:19:09,124
But several days of searching
turned up nothing.
423
00:19:09,224 --> 00:19:12,093
Meanwhile, investigators
appealed for help
424
00:19:12,193 --> 00:19:17,332
in identifying the owner of
a white Chevrolet Z71 pickup.
425
00:19:17,432 --> 00:19:20,001
That vehicle should be able to
be spotted by the public.
426
00:19:20,101 --> 00:19:23,071
We got a lot of tips,
well over a-a thousand tips
427
00:19:23,171 --> 00:19:26,174
from, uh, the tips line that,
alone that we had.
428
00:19:26,274 --> 00:19:28,276
Tips saying,
"There's a white pickup here."
429
00:19:28,376 --> 00:19:30,078
Women calling on
their boyfriends or husbands
430
00:19:30,178 --> 00:19:31,713
saying he's kind of deviant.
431
00:19:31,813 --> 00:19:34,816
And w-we-- "I think
he could be responsible
432
00:19:34,916 --> 00:19:36,918
for the disappearance
of Mickey."
433
00:19:37,018 --> 00:19:40,855
I mean, it ran the whole gamut
of-of tips.
434
00:19:40,956 --> 00:19:43,024
It's interesting, I mean,
you had half the community
435
00:19:43,124 --> 00:19:44,726
sort of pulling together
to find Mickey
436
00:19:44,826 --> 00:19:46,828
and like the other half
sort of informing on each other
437
00:19:46,928 --> 00:19:48,463
about that case.
438
00:19:48,563 --> 00:19:49,497
Uh, I don't know about that,
439
00:19:49,598 --> 00:19:51,533
but we certainly had
a lot of tips coming in.
440
00:19:51,633 --> 00:19:54,836
And that's how police
received their best lead yet.
441
00:19:54,936 --> 00:20:00,075
A story rich in detail
involving this man, Rocky McGee.
442
00:20:00,175 --> 00:20:02,043
We received a tip
that he was intoxicated
443
00:20:02,143 --> 00:20:05,614
and that he had encountered, um,
Mickey riding her bicycle,
444
00:20:05,714 --> 00:20:09,384
had struck her with his vehicle,
uh, and picked up her bike
445
00:20:09,484 --> 00:20:12,721
a-and her body a-and dumped her
in the, uh,
446
00:20:12,821 --> 00:20:14,289
the Whiskey Bay area.
447
00:20:14,389 --> 00:20:16,725
19 year old Rocky McGee
did indeed
448
00:20:16,825 --> 00:20:19,127
drive a white pickup truck.
449
00:20:19,227 --> 00:20:22,664
He also had a history of
drinking and driving.
450
00:20:22,764 --> 00:20:24,132
Was involved in-in
a traffic crash,
451
00:20:24,232 --> 00:20:27,402
that involved alcohol
and a fatality.
452
00:20:27,502 --> 00:20:29,838
In fact, at the time
Mickey disappeared,
453
00:20:29,938 --> 00:20:33,408
Rocky was about to be tried
for DUI manslaughter.
454
00:20:33,508 --> 00:20:37,012
To frustrated detectives,
all the pieces of the puzzle
455
00:20:37,112 --> 00:20:38,713
were coming together.
456
00:20:38,813 --> 00:20:41,616
He had had a prior, uh,
a-and was going through
457
00:20:41,716 --> 00:20:44,553
a court process at the time,
so i-it would fit
458
00:20:44,653 --> 00:20:46,421
and be feasible t-that
he would try
459
00:20:46,521 --> 00:20:49,124
a-and dispose of a bicycle
and a body
460
00:20:49,224 --> 00:20:51,826
so that you would
eliminate the crime completely.
461
00:20:51,927 --> 00:20:56,731
Had Mickey Shunick become
Rocky McGee's second victim?
462
00:20:56,831 --> 00:20:58,700
It seemed to be
great information.
463
00:20:58,800 --> 00:21:02,671
Well, in Louisiana,
just like in its waterways,
464
00:21:02,771 --> 00:21:05,040
things in this case
seldom were predictable
465
00:21:05,140 --> 00:21:07,943
or followed a logical path.
466
00:21:08,043 --> 00:21:10,245
If detectives were ready
to believe this was simply
467
00:21:10,345 --> 00:21:12,447
the work of a drunk driver,
468
00:21:12,547 --> 00:21:15,951
they would soon be proven
completely wrong.
469
00:21:16,051 --> 00:21:20,689
A tantalizing new lead was
about to fall into their laps.
470
00:21:20,789 --> 00:21:23,325
Even those closest to him
didn't know that
471
00:21:23,425 --> 00:21:25,393
he had that secret life.
472
00:21:25,527 --> 00:21:28,563
♪
473
00:21:29,564 --> 00:21:36,304
♪
474
00:21:36,404 --> 00:21:38,707
Come on in, guys.
475
00:21:38,807 --> 00:21:40,875
The search for Mickey Shunick
had spread over
476
00:21:40,976 --> 00:21:42,978
most of the Gulf Coast.
477
00:21:43,078 --> 00:21:45,614
It had involved
hundreds of people
478
00:21:45,714 --> 00:21:47,849
and thousands of police hours.
479
00:21:47,949 --> 00:21:49,884
And now, a caller
to the tip line,
480
00:21:49,985 --> 00:21:52,887
claiming that Mickey had been
the victim of a drunk driver
481
00:21:52,988 --> 00:21:55,323
was a game changer
for detectives.
482
00:21:55,423 --> 00:21:56,992
If you strike someone
and you're intoxicated,
483
00:21:57,092 --> 00:22:00,228
that's foul play.
So it looked promising.
484
00:22:00,328 --> 00:22:02,030
I only spoke to him
one time.
485
00:22:02,130 --> 00:22:04,132
He denied any involvement.
486
00:22:04,232 --> 00:22:07,402
Ultimately, when pressured,
he asked for an attorney.
487
00:22:07,502 --> 00:22:08,970
For a town on edge,
488
00:22:09,070 --> 00:22:11,973
and still determined
to find Mickey,
489
00:22:12,073 --> 00:22:14,376
news quickly leaked that
police were questioning
490
00:22:14,476 --> 00:22:15,944
a person of interest.
491
00:22:16,044 --> 00:22:17,846
And when it did,
492
00:22:17,946 --> 00:22:20,916
the name Rocky McGee
went viral.
493
00:22:21,016 --> 00:22:22,317
It was, like,
all over the news,
494
00:22:22,417 --> 00:22:25,453
all over the social media
pages and everything.
495
00:22:25,554 --> 00:22:26,621
And the next thing
you know,
496
00:22:26,721 --> 00:22:28,323
everybody was talking
about Rocky McGee.
497
00:22:28,423 --> 00:22:29,157
Correct.
498
00:22:29,257 --> 00:22:31,726
And it spread
like wildfire.
499
00:22:31,826 --> 00:22:34,663
The tip line was suddenly
full of callers,
500
00:22:34,763 --> 00:22:37,132
including one claiming
to have firsthand knowledge
501
00:22:37,232 --> 00:22:40,068
that not only
had Rocky killed Mickey,
502
00:22:40,168 --> 00:22:42,203
but he also had
an accomplice.
503
00:22:42,304 --> 00:22:43,572
This individual came forward
and said
504
00:22:43,672 --> 00:22:46,541
that Rocky's girlfriend,
she was present
505
00:22:46,641 --> 00:22:48,810
when he was drunk
and hit her,
506
00:22:48,910 --> 00:22:50,845
and that they picked up
the bike and the body
507
00:22:50,946 --> 00:22:53,081
and-and disposed of her.
508
00:22:53,181 --> 00:22:54,983
Andie Cormier
is the girlfriend
509
00:22:55,083 --> 00:22:57,219
accused of helping Rocky.
510
00:22:57,319 --> 00:22:59,187
She first learned
of the accusations
511
00:22:59,287 --> 00:23:02,757
against her and her boyfriend
from Rocky's mother.
512
00:23:02,857 --> 00:23:04,593
His mom comes up to me,
and she tells me
513
00:23:04,693 --> 00:23:06,661
that Rocky has been taken
by Lafayette police
514
00:23:06,761 --> 00:23:08,930
to be questioned in
the Mickey Shunick case.
515
00:23:09,030 --> 00:23:11,132
She's hysterical.
She's crying.
516
00:23:11,233 --> 00:23:13,101
She's confused.
517
00:23:13,201 --> 00:23:16,671
And she was like, well,
they think you did it, too.
518
00:23:16,771 --> 00:23:19,574
Like her significant
other, Rocky,
519
00:23:19,674 --> 00:23:24,546
Andie Cormier found herself
grilled like a redfish.
520
00:23:24,646 --> 00:23:26,114
It never happened.
521
00:23:26,214 --> 00:23:27,916
It never happened.
522
00:23:30,318 --> 00:23:32,554
For days, police worked
around the clock
523
00:23:32,654 --> 00:23:35,790
investigating McGee's
alleged involvement.
524
00:23:35,891 --> 00:23:37,659
They processed
his white pickup,
525
00:23:37,759 --> 00:23:41,263
looking for any DNA that could
be traced back to Mickey.
526
00:23:41,363 --> 00:23:42,697
We spent a lot of manpower
527
00:23:42,797 --> 00:23:44,100
and a lot of time
investigating this.
528
00:23:45,100 --> 00:23:47,569
I actually thought that
we were really gonna be blamed
529
00:23:47,669 --> 00:23:48,803
for something
we didn't do.
530
00:23:48,904 --> 00:23:52,807
And I was praying for somebody
to come forward
531
00:23:52,908 --> 00:23:56,011
and admit what they said
was false.
532
00:23:56,111 --> 00:23:59,080
Then, almost as quickly
as Rocky McGee surfaced
533
00:23:59,180 --> 00:24:01,216
as Mickey's alleged killer,
534
00:24:01,316 --> 00:24:03,385
the case around him
collapsed.
535
00:24:03,485 --> 00:24:06,121
When police brought
McGee's first accuser back
536
00:24:06,221 --> 00:24:07,689
to be questioned again.
537
00:24:07,789 --> 00:24:08,924
The original tipster
admitted
538
00:24:09,024 --> 00:24:12,127
that he had fabricated
the story.
539
00:24:12,227 --> 00:24:14,429
It turned out that neither
Rocky McGee
540
00:24:14,529 --> 00:24:16,064
nor his girlfriend Andie
541
00:24:16,164 --> 00:24:18,934
had anything to do
with Mickey's disappearance.
542
00:24:19,034 --> 00:24:20,402
They were instead
543
00:24:20,502 --> 00:24:23,405
the victims of
what turned out to be a hoax.
544
00:24:23,505 --> 00:24:24,940
And so this tip
that you got,
545
00:24:25,040 --> 00:24:28,009
this was what, just somebody
who had it out for him?
546
00:24:28,109 --> 00:24:30,145
I think what it was
was it turned out to be
547
00:24:30,245 --> 00:24:32,447
someone who just
wanted attention.
548
00:24:32,547 --> 00:24:33,415
And it ate up
a lot of your time.
549
00:24:33,515 --> 00:24:34,849
Ate up a lot of our time.
550
00:24:34,950 --> 00:24:35,951
And it turned out to be
absolutely nothing.
551
00:24:36,051 --> 00:24:36,952
Yes, sir.
552
00:24:37,052 --> 00:24:38,987
That was probably
the negative aspect
553
00:24:39,087 --> 00:24:40,422
of the social media.
554
00:24:40,522 --> 00:24:42,591
- Frustrating?
- Very.
555
00:24:42,691 --> 00:24:45,961
But the saying,
"once burned, twice shy,"
556
00:24:46,061 --> 00:24:49,030
was a luxury
detectives couldn't afford.
557
00:24:49,130 --> 00:24:51,600
So when two new tips came in
about another owner
558
00:24:51,700 --> 00:24:54,869
of a white pickup truck
who'd been acting suspiciously,
559
00:24:54,970 --> 00:24:58,406
Detective Bajat rolled up
his sleeves once again.
560
00:24:58,506 --> 00:25:00,842
Both tips,
they came in a week apart
561
00:25:00,942 --> 00:25:03,011
and they were independent
of themselves.
562
00:25:03,111 --> 00:25:04,779
And who were they
telling you to look at?
563
00:25:04,880 --> 00:25:06,181
Brandon Scott Lavergne.
564
00:25:06,281 --> 00:25:10,185
Brandon Scott Lavergne
was a 33-year-old mechanic
565
00:25:10,285 --> 00:25:12,621
who worked on oil rigs
just offshore.
566
00:25:12,721 --> 00:25:14,155
Tell me
what the two tips said.
567
00:25:14,256 --> 00:25:16,224
The first tip that came in
was from an acquaintance,
568
00:25:16,324 --> 00:25:17,959
uh, that had
close knowledge of him
569
00:25:18,059 --> 00:25:20,095
that said that
he was acting suspiciously.
570
00:25:20,195 --> 00:25:21,096
The tipster also said
571
00:25:21,196 --> 00:25:23,531
that on the weekend
Mickey went missing,
572
00:25:23,632 --> 00:25:25,700
Lavergne traveled
to New Orleans
573
00:25:25,800 --> 00:25:28,570
and came back with
some serious stab wounds
574
00:25:28,670 --> 00:25:30,005
on his upper body.
575
00:25:30,105 --> 00:25:32,073
He was telling them
that he had been robbed
576
00:25:32,173 --> 00:25:34,442
and mugged in New Orleans
while he was down there.
577
00:25:34,542 --> 00:25:36,511
What they found suspicious
was that he had no reason
578
00:25:36,611 --> 00:25:38,213
to go to New Orleans
that weekend,
579
00:25:38,313 --> 00:25:41,516
uh, and his story
just didn't make sense.
580
00:25:41,616 --> 00:25:43,818
And it wasn't just
what the tipster was saying
581
00:25:43,919 --> 00:25:45,854
that interested
Detective Bajat.
582
00:25:45,954 --> 00:25:48,523
It was also
who the tipster was.
583
00:25:48,623 --> 00:25:50,091
The tipster that called in
584
00:25:50,192 --> 00:25:52,494
was the future father-in-law
of Mr. Lavergne.
585
00:25:52,594 --> 00:25:54,963
And that second tip
only tightened the net
586
00:25:55,063 --> 00:25:56,765
around Lavergne.
587
00:25:56,865 --> 00:26:00,001
It came from an employee
of a Lafayette car dealership
588
00:26:00,101 --> 00:26:02,070
who said that
soon after Mickey vanished,
589
00:26:02,170 --> 00:26:05,674
Lavergne came in
looking to buy a white pickup.
590
00:26:05,774 --> 00:26:07,909
The second tip said
that Brandon Lavergne
591
00:26:08,009 --> 00:26:09,444
had gone in
to purchase a vehicle,
592
00:26:09,544 --> 00:26:10,912
was acting suspiciously,
593
00:26:11,012 --> 00:26:16,218
and said that he had owned
a white Z71 that was stolen,
594
00:26:16,318 --> 00:26:18,753
and that he's here
to buy another one.
595
00:26:18,853 --> 00:26:21,489
In what way was he
behaving suspiciously?
596
00:26:21,590 --> 00:26:23,091
During the time that
he was purchasing the truck
597
00:26:23,191 --> 00:26:27,028
on the news, they showed
a story about Mickey
598
00:26:27,128 --> 00:26:29,464
and he got really suspicious
and really nervous they said.
599
00:26:29,564 --> 00:26:32,200
It was visibly nervous.
600
00:26:32,300 --> 00:26:33,268
Detectives also learned
601
00:26:33,368 --> 00:26:36,004
that the soon-to-be married
Brandon Lavergne
602
00:26:36,104 --> 00:26:39,241
lived in the little town
of Church Point, Louisiana,
603
00:26:39,341 --> 00:26:41,776
40 minutes
outside Lafayette.
604
00:26:43,144 --> 00:26:45,413
He was funny.
I mean, he really was.
605
00:26:45,513 --> 00:26:46,848
That's where Lavergne
got to know
606
00:26:46,948 --> 00:26:49,417
his friend
Kandee McDaniels.
607
00:26:49,517 --> 00:26:50,785
When we first met,
I was like,
608
00:26:50,885 --> 00:26:53,188
"Man, he's a great guy.
He's got a great job.
609
00:26:53,288 --> 00:26:55,257
I mean, he's good looking.
He's the perfect guy."
610
00:26:55,357 --> 00:26:57,125
I was like, "I gotta find
one of my girlfriends
611
00:26:57,225 --> 00:26:58,393
who's single
and, you know,
612
00:26:58,493 --> 00:27:00,328
see if they would
hit it off."
613
00:27:00,428 --> 00:27:01,930
But the more detectives
delved into
614
00:27:02,030 --> 00:27:04,332
Brandon Scott Lavergne's past,
615
00:27:04,432 --> 00:27:06,134
the more they realized
just how much
616
00:27:06,234 --> 00:27:09,137
wasn't known
to those around him.
617
00:27:09,237 --> 00:27:11,006
And even those
closest to him
618
00:27:11,106 --> 00:27:13,708
didn't know that he had
that secret life.
619
00:27:13,808 --> 00:27:16,711
And that would include
his fiance.
620
00:27:16,811 --> 00:27:19,714
He used me.
Oh, my God!
621
00:27:24,286 --> 00:27:32,294
♪
622
00:27:32,394 --> 00:27:35,697
Kandee McDaniels counted
Brandon Scott Lavergne
623
00:27:35,797 --> 00:27:37,732
as one of her good friends.
624
00:27:37,832 --> 00:27:39,701
I mean, he was
that good of a guy,
625
00:27:39,801 --> 00:27:41,803
in my opinion,
I mean,
626
00:27:41,903 --> 00:27:44,573
that I would want to set
one of my friends up with him.
627
00:27:44,673 --> 00:27:46,708
He may have seemed like
a catch to her,
628
00:27:46,808 --> 00:27:48,777
but police now felt
they almost had him
629
00:27:48,877 --> 00:27:52,013
on the hook for the murder
of Mickey Shunick.
630
00:27:52,113 --> 00:27:53,582
For one thing,
detectives determined
631
00:27:53,682 --> 00:27:55,584
that the story Lavergne
had allegedly told
632
00:27:55,684 --> 00:27:57,385
his future father-in-law
633
00:27:57,485 --> 00:28:00,422
about being stabbed
in a mugging at a gas station
634
00:28:00,522 --> 00:28:02,223
wasn't holding up.
635
00:28:02,324 --> 00:28:03,792
Any evidence that
he reported that mugging
636
00:28:03,892 --> 00:28:04,859
to police?
637
00:28:04,960 --> 00:28:06,228
The Jefferson Parish
detectives
638
00:28:06,328 --> 00:28:07,462
responded to the scene,
639
00:28:07,562 --> 00:28:09,164
interviewed the
gas station attendant,
640
00:28:09,264 --> 00:28:11,099
and reviewed
the video surveillance
641
00:28:12,100 --> 00:28:14,703
And he was
nowhere near that site.
642
00:28:14,803 --> 00:28:17,772
And as detectives looked
deeper into Lavergne's past,
643
00:28:17,873 --> 00:28:20,475
they found themselves
heading down a rabbit hole
644
00:28:20,575 --> 00:28:23,011
into a very dark place.
645
00:28:23,111 --> 00:28:24,679
We found out
that he had girlfriends,
646
00:28:24,779 --> 00:28:26,815
you know,
all over the place that--
647
00:28:26,915 --> 00:28:30,619
he more or less thrived
on the game of seducing women.
648
00:28:30,719 --> 00:28:31,953
What's more,
detectives say,
649
00:28:32,053 --> 00:28:35,123
Lavergne had an addiction
to prostitutes,
650
00:28:35,223 --> 00:28:38,260
Something his fiance
didn't know.
651
00:28:38,360 --> 00:28:40,061
He would leave
her residence
652
00:28:40,161 --> 00:28:42,397
and contact sexual escorts.
653
00:28:42,497 --> 00:28:43,331
You found that out
654
00:28:43,431 --> 00:28:44,666
by checking
his cell phone records.
655
00:28:44,766 --> 00:28:45,700
Correct.
656
00:28:45,800 --> 00:28:47,135
So this was a guy
who sort of had a life
657
00:28:47,235 --> 00:28:48,537
that he didn't
show anybody else.
658
00:28:48,637 --> 00:28:49,838
Exactly.
659
00:28:49,938 --> 00:28:51,373
But this seemingly normal,
660
00:28:51,473 --> 00:28:53,842
everyday guy,
detectives learned,
661
00:28:53,942 --> 00:28:56,611
was also a registered
sex offender,
662
00:28:56,711 --> 00:29:00,348
having been convicted of
sexual battery back in 2000.
663
00:29:00,448 --> 00:29:02,050
That was definitely
an attention getter.
664
00:29:02,150 --> 00:29:04,686
As provocative
as all this was,
665
00:29:04,786 --> 00:29:06,388
there was nothing
connecting Lavergne
666
00:29:06,488 --> 00:29:08,690
to Mickey Shunick's
disappearance.
667
00:29:08,790 --> 00:29:10,792
So Detective Bajat
turned his attention
668
00:29:10,892 --> 00:29:12,928
to Lavergne's
white Chevy pickup
669
00:29:13,028 --> 00:29:14,796
and to that other tip
670
00:29:14,896 --> 00:29:16,865
coming from
the local car dealer.
671
00:29:16,965 --> 00:29:18,533
The tipster had said that
his truck was stolen
672
00:29:18,633 --> 00:29:20,001
out of Texas.
673
00:29:20,101 --> 00:29:22,404
Insurance records
indicated where in Texas
674
00:29:22,504 --> 00:29:25,006
Lavergne said his truck
had been stolen.
675
00:29:25,106 --> 00:29:26,942
When Bajat called
the sheriff there,
676
00:29:27,042 --> 00:29:29,611
he learned the truck
had been found abandoned
677
00:29:29,711 --> 00:29:31,346
and badly burned.
678
00:29:31,446 --> 00:29:33,148
We went, recovered
and brought it back
679
00:29:33,248 --> 00:29:34,616
to Louisiana as evidence.
680
00:29:34,716 --> 00:29:35,750
And what's in there?
681
00:29:35,850 --> 00:29:37,052
There was absolutely
nothing left.
682
00:29:37,152 --> 00:29:39,120
You couldn't even tell
the color of the paint.
683
00:29:39,221 --> 00:29:40,789
So, if Mickey was ever
in that truck,
684
00:29:40,889 --> 00:29:41,756
you couldn't tell?
685
00:29:41,856 --> 00:29:44,292
That's correct.
The heat was intense.
686
00:29:44,392 --> 00:29:45,360
But Lafayette PD
687
00:29:45,460 --> 00:29:48,063
now had Lavergne's
license plate number.
688
00:29:48,163 --> 00:29:49,931
And from that,
it turned out,
689
00:29:50,031 --> 00:29:53,168
came an extraordinary piece
of police work.
690
00:29:53,268 --> 00:29:54,836
We did a little bit
of research and found,
691
00:29:54,936 --> 00:29:56,905
uh-uh, an image
that had been taken
692
00:29:57,005 --> 00:29:59,474
from a traffic camera
of his truck
693
00:29:59,574 --> 00:30:00,909
about eight hours prior
694
00:30:01,009 --> 00:30:03,044
to the time
that Mickey disappeared.
695
00:30:03,144 --> 00:30:05,747
That traffic camera
not only snapped a photo
696
00:30:05,847 --> 00:30:07,682
of Lavergne's plate number,
697
00:30:07,782 --> 00:30:09,951
but amazingly,
it also managed to capture
698
00:30:10,051 --> 00:30:12,487
what was in
the bed of his truck.
699
00:30:12,587 --> 00:30:14,656
We were able to see
that there's a 4x4 post
700
00:30:14,756 --> 00:30:16,424
as well as a white styrofoam
ice chest
701
00:30:16,524 --> 00:30:18,493
that's in the bed
of the pickup truck.
702
00:30:18,593 --> 00:30:21,596
Bajat then compared
the truck in that image
703
00:30:21,696 --> 00:30:24,099
to the mysterious one
seen following Mickey.
704
00:30:24,100 --> 00:30:26,601
When we looked at
the footage again
705
00:30:26,701 --> 00:30:29,638
on the night
that Mickey disappeared,
706
00:30:29,738 --> 00:30:34,309
we could clearly see
a 4x4 post
707
00:30:34,409 --> 00:30:35,710
as well as
a white ice chest
708
00:30:35,810 --> 00:30:38,146
in the same position
that it was
709
00:30:38,246 --> 00:30:40,582
on the traffic camera
eight hours earlier.
710
00:30:40,682 --> 00:30:43,184
Suddenly,
after six long weeks,
711
00:30:43,285 --> 00:30:46,321
Lafayette PD felt
they had their man.
712
00:30:46,421 --> 00:30:49,224
That was our "aha" moment.
That was his truck.
713
00:30:49,324 --> 00:30:52,761
All roads were now leading
to Brandon Lavergne.
714
00:30:52,861 --> 00:30:55,430
But detectives couldn't
with absolute certainty
715
00:30:55,530 --> 00:30:58,533
place Lavergne
behind the wheel of that truck
716
00:30:58,633 --> 00:30:59,901
at that moment.
717
00:31:00,001 --> 00:31:01,503
Most important of all,
718
00:31:01,603 --> 00:31:05,173
they still had no clue
what had become of Mickey.
719
00:31:05,273 --> 00:31:06,708
Did you think that
Mr. Lavergne was aware
720
00:31:06,808 --> 00:31:08,143
that you guys
were looking at him?
721
00:31:08,243 --> 00:31:09,611
No, I don't think he was.
722
00:31:09,711 --> 00:31:10,912
And that was part
of our thinking
723
00:31:11,012 --> 00:31:12,581
that if he had killed Mickey,
724
00:31:12,681 --> 00:31:13,815
we could keep him
under surveillance
725
00:31:13,915 --> 00:31:16,885
and hopefully he would
lead us to a gravesite.
726
00:31:16,985 --> 00:31:18,386
{\an8}But Lavergne never did.
727
00:31:18,486 --> 00:31:21,122
{\an8}So now investigators
raised the stakes.
728
00:31:21,222 --> 00:31:22,958
{\an8}They decided
to arrest Lavergne
729
00:31:23,058 --> 00:31:25,527
{\an8}and sit him down
for some quality time.
730
00:31:36,972 --> 00:31:40,375
{\an8}At first, Lavergne denied
knowing anything about Mickey.
731
00:31:40,475 --> 00:31:43,511
{\an8}Then, a veteran of
the criminal justice system,
732
00:31:43,612 --> 00:31:45,380
{\an8}he asked for his attorney.
733
00:31:54,489 --> 00:31:56,591
That's when detectives turned
to the one person
734
00:31:56,691 --> 00:31:58,727
they hoped
could break the case.
735
00:31:58,827 --> 00:32:02,197
They brought in Lavergne's
fiance for questioning.
736
00:32:02,297 --> 00:32:03,865
I know you're
a little nervous.
737
00:32:03,965 --> 00:32:05,033
Yeah.
738
00:32:05,133 --> 00:32:06,201
You want to know
what this is all about.
739
00:32:06,301 --> 00:32:08,103
Well, basically, we just
want to know about Brandon.
740
00:32:08,203 --> 00:32:10,739
Did he ever get angry
or ever push you
741
00:32:10,839 --> 00:32:13,041
or hit you or--
- Never. Not one time.
742
00:32:13,141 --> 00:32:14,609
You don't see that at all.
743
00:32:14,709 --> 00:32:17,212
I don't--
He's never showed that.
744
00:32:17,312 --> 00:32:18,980
I've never seen it.
745
00:32:19,080 --> 00:32:21,149
I don't even see that
in him. I don't--
746
00:32:21,249 --> 00:32:25,687
He has been so gentle
and kind and compassionate.
747
00:32:25,787 --> 00:32:26,855
It's-- He's amazing.
748
00:32:26,955 --> 00:32:29,925
I would have never said
yes to a marriage.
749
00:32:30,025 --> 00:32:32,827
As it turned out,
police ended up telling her
750
00:32:32,928 --> 00:32:34,629
more than she told them.
751
00:32:34,729 --> 00:32:37,799
Her reaction would only
confirm for investigators
752
00:32:37,899 --> 00:32:40,135
just how sinister
Lavergne was.
753
00:32:40,235 --> 00:32:42,337
I'm not sure
you know Brandon
754
00:32:42,437 --> 00:32:44,439
as well as you think
you know him.
755
00:32:44,539 --> 00:32:45,707
- Okay.
- Okay.
756
00:32:45,807 --> 00:32:48,543
- I'd like to.
- You-you'd like to.
757
00:32:48,643 --> 00:32:49,811
If there's something
I don't know,
758
00:32:49,911 --> 00:32:51,246
I need to know.
759
00:32:51,346 --> 00:32:53,515
It would take the work
of two detectives
760
00:32:53,615 --> 00:32:55,750
to reveal the rest.
761
00:32:55,850 --> 00:32:57,552
I'm a brutally
honest person.
762
00:32:57,652 --> 00:33:02,023
Brandon is under arrest
for first-degree murder.
763
00:33:02,123 --> 00:33:03,091
- What?
- Yes.
764
00:33:03,191 --> 00:33:06,728
He is,
without a reasonable doubt,
765
00:33:06,828 --> 00:33:09,564
the man who kidnapped
and murdered Mickey Shunick.
766
00:33:09,664 --> 00:33:11,733
- Y'all have proof?
- We do. Okay.
767
00:33:11,833 --> 00:33:13,468
Oh, my God!
768
00:33:13,568 --> 00:33:15,670
I know.
769
00:33:15,770 --> 00:33:17,739
I would not walk in here
and tell you this if I didn't.
770
00:33:17,839 --> 00:33:19,307
Okay?
- I can't believe--
771
00:33:19,407 --> 00:33:20,408
Okay, listen to me.
772
00:33:20,508 --> 00:33:21,876
Take a deep breath.
Take a deep breath.
773
00:33:21,977 --> 00:33:24,145
Because you asked me
for proof. Okay?
774
00:33:24,246 --> 00:33:24,980
It's hard for you to believe
775
00:33:25,080 --> 00:33:26,514
because you think
you know him.
776
00:33:26,615 --> 00:33:29,851
I would never be
associated with some--
777
00:33:29,951 --> 00:33:31,419
- We know that.
- We're not accusing you.
778
00:33:31,519 --> 00:33:32,687
- Listen to me.
- Oh, my God.
779
00:33:32,787 --> 00:33:35,490
Listen, listen. Take--
Take a deep breath.
780
00:33:35,590 --> 00:33:36,825
You want to hear
the facts, right?
781
00:33:36,925 --> 00:33:38,560
Yes! What is--
What's the--
782
00:33:38,660 --> 00:33:40,362
Okay.
783
00:33:40,462 --> 00:33:42,998
I cannot lay out
100 percent of it, okay?
784
00:33:43,098 --> 00:33:44,032
Not at this point.
785
00:33:44,132 --> 00:33:46,334
- He used me!
- Okay.
786
00:33:46,434 --> 00:33:47,836
He's good at it.
That's what he does.
787
00:33:47,936 --> 00:33:49,237
He is a sociopath.
788
00:33:49,337 --> 00:33:51,973
- I believed him.
- He's a manipulator. Okay.
789
00:33:55,010 --> 00:33:57,012
Lavergne's fiance
may have been shocked,
790
00:33:57,112 --> 00:33:59,214
but detectives weren't.
791
00:33:59,314 --> 00:34:00,949
They knew something else.
792
00:34:01,049 --> 00:34:03,652
Brandon Lavergne's past
was far darker
793
00:34:03,752 --> 00:34:05,687
than anyone had imagined.
794
00:34:05,787 --> 00:34:07,355
We learned that
Brandon's name had come up
795
00:34:07,455 --> 00:34:08,556
in a neighboring parish,
796
00:34:08,657 --> 00:34:12,193
uh, that he was a suspect
of a murder back in 1999.
797
00:34:12,294 --> 00:34:14,062
In fact, prosecutors
took the case
798
00:34:14,162 --> 00:34:17,199
to the grand jury,
but it failed to indict,
799
00:34:17,299 --> 00:34:19,668
citing insufficient evidence.
800
00:34:19,768 --> 00:34:21,036
For detectives,
801
00:34:21,136 --> 00:34:22,837
it was the final
piece of the puzzle
802
00:34:22,938 --> 00:34:25,640
that put this case
over the top.
803
00:34:25,740 --> 00:34:27,242
For the Shunicks,
804
00:34:27,342 --> 00:34:28,410
any lingering hope
805
00:34:28,510 --> 00:34:33,048
that Mickey would be
found alive was now gone.
806
00:34:33,148 --> 00:34:34,516
Me and my mom
shut down after that.
807
00:34:34,616 --> 00:34:36,184
We just...
808
00:34:36,284 --> 00:34:37,519
And then I got to
listen to Charlie
809
00:34:37,619 --> 00:34:40,422
through the wall
cry all night.
810
00:34:40,522 --> 00:34:44,526
I mean, you know,
the aching crying.
811
00:34:44,626 --> 00:34:46,628
But prosecutors
were now struggling
812
00:34:46,728 --> 00:34:48,897
with worries of their own.
813
00:34:48,997 --> 00:34:51,967
Could they get a conviction
without knowing
814
00:34:52,067 --> 00:34:55,003
what had happened
to the victim.
815
00:34:55,103 --> 00:34:58,640
Our primary concern
was to find the body.
816
00:35:02,711 --> 00:35:09,150
♪
817
00:35:09,251 --> 00:35:12,454
Three weeks after police
arrested Brandon Lavergne,
818
00:35:12,554 --> 00:35:14,289
the Lafayette District
Attorney's office
819
00:35:14,389 --> 00:35:17,058
charged him with
Mickey Shunick's murder.
820
00:35:17,158 --> 00:35:18,727
For Charlie Shunick,
821
00:35:18,827 --> 00:35:21,696
one big question
had been answered.
822
00:35:21,796 --> 00:35:23,565
I went home
and I looked him up,
823
00:35:23,665 --> 00:35:26,434
and I was like, well,
if this guy is responsible,
824
00:35:26,534 --> 00:35:28,603
Mickey is definitely
not alive anymore.
825
00:35:28,703 --> 00:35:29,538
That's probably
when we all
826
00:35:29,638 --> 00:35:32,941
really started mourning
the loss of her.
827
00:35:33,041 --> 00:35:35,010
Daniel Landry
and Keith Stutes
828
00:35:35,110 --> 00:35:36,945
were prosecuting Lavergne.
829
00:35:37,045 --> 00:35:38,446
What made you
so sure about him?
830
00:35:38,547 --> 00:35:40,348
I don't know that
there was a single event
831
00:35:40,448 --> 00:35:41,516
or a single circumstance.
832
00:35:41,616 --> 00:35:44,219
It was the mountain
of circumstances.
833
00:35:44,319 --> 00:35:46,021
Not the least of which
was that Lavergne had been
834
00:35:46,121 --> 00:35:49,958
a prime suspect
in a murder back in 1999.
835
00:35:50,058 --> 00:35:52,460
The possibility Lavergne
had killed before
836
00:35:52,561 --> 00:35:55,897
only strengthened prosecutor
Keith Stutes resolve.
837
00:35:55,997 --> 00:35:59,901
It was, how can we make
this case better
838
00:36:00,001 --> 00:36:03,071
by the existence
of this prior investigation.
839
00:36:03,171 --> 00:36:04,506
Each case is made stronger
840
00:36:04,606 --> 00:36:07,175
by the existence
of the other case.
841
00:36:07,275 --> 00:36:10,412
Still, prosecutors knew
it wouldn't be easy.
842
00:36:10,512 --> 00:36:12,314
This would be
a death penalty case,
843
00:36:12,414 --> 00:36:14,716
making the bar
that much higher.
844
00:36:14,816 --> 00:36:16,217
And your
classic defense is,
845
00:36:16,318 --> 00:36:17,752
you're in the middle
of the trial,
846
00:36:17,852 --> 00:36:19,087
they point at
the back door
847
00:36:19,187 --> 00:36:20,422
and tell the jury,
848
00:36:20,522 --> 00:36:23,291
how do you know that person
is not gonna walk in
849
00:36:23,391 --> 00:36:24,392
through that door?
850
00:36:24,492 --> 00:36:25,860
Is that
a reasonable doubt?
851
00:36:25,961 --> 00:36:27,462
Well, you can end up
with a not guilty
852
00:36:27,562 --> 00:36:29,264
just by that fact alone.
853
00:36:29,364 --> 00:36:34,135
Our primary concern
was to find the body.
854
00:36:34,236 --> 00:36:36,871
But Brandon Lavergne
wasn't cooperating.
855
00:36:36,972 --> 00:36:40,475
So prosecutors gathered
to make a very tough decision,
856
00:36:40,575 --> 00:36:43,478
offer to take the death
penalty off the table
857
00:36:43,578 --> 00:36:45,947
in exchange for
a full confession
858
00:36:46,047 --> 00:36:49,317
and the whereabouts
of Mickey's body.
859
00:36:49,417 --> 00:36:50,285
Did you hate that,
860
00:36:50,385 --> 00:36:52,954
or were you eager
to make that deal?
861
00:36:53,054 --> 00:36:54,956
I was eager
to make that deal.
862
00:36:55,056 --> 00:36:56,625
Finding the body
was important, obviously,
863
00:36:56,725 --> 00:36:59,527
for the prosecution,
but as important for us
864
00:36:59,628 --> 00:37:01,062
in this case
was finding her
865
00:37:01,162 --> 00:37:04,432
to bring her back
to her family.
866
00:37:04,532 --> 00:37:06,468
My feeling was,
we want her found.
867
00:37:06,568 --> 00:37:08,136
Yeah, before I could say
a word, she says,
868
00:37:08,236 --> 00:37:09,604
"I want the body found."
- Yeah.
869
00:37:09,704 --> 00:37:10,939
But the DA's office
870
00:37:11,039 --> 00:37:12,908
wasn't going to make this
easy for Lavergne.
871
00:37:13,008 --> 00:37:14,175
He would also have to
plead guilty
872
00:37:14,276 --> 00:37:17,479
to the other murder,
back in 1999.
873
00:37:17,579 --> 00:37:19,547
He had
two death penalty cases
874
00:37:19,648 --> 00:37:21,316
to think about,
not one.
875
00:37:21,416 --> 00:37:22,584
You think that swayed him?
876
00:37:22,684 --> 00:37:24,786
- I think it was a factor.
- Certainly.
877
00:37:24,886 --> 00:37:27,422
Just one day after
being offered the deal,
878
00:37:27,522 --> 00:37:29,224
Lavergne accepted.
879
00:37:29,324 --> 00:37:33,495
He received
two life sentences.
880
00:37:33,595 --> 00:37:35,697
Do you think Brandon Lavergne
is responsible
881
00:37:35,797 --> 00:37:36,898
for any other abductions
882
00:37:36,998 --> 00:37:39,634
or any other murders
that you don't know about?
883
00:37:39,734 --> 00:37:41,002
I think
it's quite possible
884
00:37:41,102 --> 00:37:45,473
if he's capable of two,
why not three, why not four?
885
00:37:45,574 --> 00:37:47,208
Lavergne also revealed
886
00:37:47,309 --> 00:37:49,611
the whereabouts
of Mickey's body.
887
00:37:49,711 --> 00:37:52,047
It was here in this
small rural cemetery
888
00:37:52,147 --> 00:37:54,049
that police found Mickey
889
00:37:54,149 --> 00:37:57,519
30 miles from where
she'd been abducted.
890
00:37:57,619 --> 00:38:00,722
He placed her body here,
covered her up with some brush.
891
00:38:00,822 --> 00:38:02,657
The coroner's office
later determined
892
00:38:02,757 --> 00:38:05,594
Mickey had been stabbed
multiple times.
893
00:38:05,694 --> 00:38:08,997
The fatal wound
was a gunshot to the head.
894
00:38:09,097 --> 00:38:11,099
It was
a very violent death.
895
00:38:13,535 --> 00:38:15,203
In his confession,
Lavergne claimed
896
00:38:15,303 --> 00:38:17,572
it was all an accident.
897
00:38:17,672 --> 00:38:18,640
He was driving drunk
898
00:38:18,740 --> 00:38:21,042
and didn't mean
to bump Mickey's bike.
899
00:38:21,142 --> 00:38:22,110
{\an8}He said that what followed
900
00:38:22,210 --> 00:38:24,512
{\an8}was a heated argument
that became physical.
901
00:38:27,048 --> 00:38:30,819
{\an8}Mickey pulled out her mace.
Lavergne pulled his knife.
902
00:38:30,919 --> 00:38:32,787
{\an8}It was very close quarters.
903
00:38:32,887 --> 00:38:34,923
{\an8}The cab of
Lavergne's truck.
904
00:38:35,023 --> 00:38:37,792
{\an8}He won only when
he drew his gun.
905
00:38:45,667 --> 00:38:47,736
What ultimately happens
at the moment
906
00:38:47,836 --> 00:38:49,437
of the confrontation,
907
00:38:49,538 --> 00:38:53,041
I think is,
uh, we'll never know.
908
00:38:53,141 --> 00:38:54,809
But Keith Stutes
is certain
909
00:38:54,910 --> 00:38:58,146
it did not begin
as an accident.
910
00:38:58,246 --> 00:39:00,348
Lavergne, he says,
was a predator
911
00:39:00,448 --> 00:39:02,117
stalking his prey.
912
00:39:02,217 --> 00:39:04,019
It's very clear
from the video
913
00:39:04,119 --> 00:39:08,790
that he went out of his way
to actually follow her.
914
00:39:08,890 --> 00:39:09,991
There was also
no disputing
915
00:39:10,091 --> 00:39:13,862
that before Lavergne
fired the fatal gunshot,
916
00:39:13,962 --> 00:39:17,065
Mickey Shunick
fought back hard,
917
00:39:17,165 --> 00:39:19,067
stabbing Lavergne
several times
918
00:39:19,167 --> 00:39:20,669
with his own knife.
919
00:39:20,769 --> 00:39:21,937
She was way outmatched,
920
00:39:22,037 --> 00:39:23,471
and she knew she was
fighting for her life,
921
00:39:23,572 --> 00:39:26,441
and she fought. That was--
She wanted that life.
922
00:39:26,541 --> 00:39:31,213
Mickey did
what she had to do.
923
00:39:31,313 --> 00:39:33,848
- You're proud of her?
- Oh, absolutely.
924
00:39:33,949 --> 00:39:35,717
You bet.
925
00:39:35,817 --> 00:39:37,586
If she doesn't fight back,
926
00:39:37,686 --> 00:39:39,287
he doesn't get stabbed.
- Yeah.
927
00:39:39,387 --> 00:39:42,557
Then he has no wounds
for anyone to notice.
928
00:39:42,657 --> 00:39:44,726
And the tip
never comes in about him.
929
00:39:44,826 --> 00:39:45,961
I mean, she caught him.
930
00:39:46,061 --> 00:39:49,831
Yeah. Amazing.
Good for Mickey.
931
00:39:49,931 --> 00:39:50,966
For Charlie,
932
00:39:51,066 --> 00:39:54,302
it had been an excruciating
three month journey.
933
00:39:54,402 --> 00:39:57,939
She'd achieved her goal
of bringing Mickey home.
934
00:39:58,039 --> 00:40:00,742
Now it was time to mourn.
935
00:40:00,842 --> 00:40:03,578
Lavergne took a lot
from your family.
936
00:40:03,678 --> 00:40:05,280
What did he take from you?
937
00:40:05,380 --> 00:40:06,448
My entire future.
938
00:40:06,548 --> 00:40:09,251
And he rearranged
my whole past.
939
00:40:09,351 --> 00:40:11,953
I mean, he took that
whole life away from me.
940
00:40:12,053 --> 00:40:13,288
It's different now.
941
00:40:13,388 --> 00:40:18,893
Took my best friend
away and...
942
00:40:18,994 --> 00:40:20,595
My little sister.
943
00:40:23,398 --> 00:40:25,834
On a very wet
fall afternoon,
944
00:40:25,934 --> 00:40:27,669
weeks after
Lavergne was led away
945
00:40:27,769 --> 00:40:30,438
to spend the rest of his life
in prison,
946
00:40:30,539 --> 00:40:32,073
Mickey's friends and family,
947
00:40:32,173 --> 00:40:34,643
who had all worked so hard
to find her,
948
00:40:34,743 --> 00:40:36,912
gathered to celebrate
her life.
949
00:40:37,012 --> 00:40:38,079
The community
was so involved,
950
00:40:38,179 --> 00:40:40,181
and we kind of wanted
to have like a big memorial
951
00:40:40,282 --> 00:40:42,217
which turned into
a life celebration.
952
00:40:42,317 --> 00:40:43,552
Thank y'all
for comin' out here.
953
00:40:43,652 --> 00:40:48,189
Uh, I know Mickey
still is feeling the love.
954
00:40:48,290 --> 00:40:51,393
There was food,
dancing and music.
955
00:40:51,493 --> 00:40:53,128
There was also, of course,
956
00:40:53,228 --> 00:40:55,330
a ceremonial bike ride.
957
00:40:55,430 --> 00:40:58,166
Leading the back,
Mickey's mother, Nancy,
958
00:40:58,266 --> 00:41:02,571
riding Mickey's
now refurbished bicycle.
959
00:41:02,671 --> 00:41:06,241
They stopped at the spot
where Mickey was abducted.
960
00:41:06,341 --> 00:41:07,309
Today at this place,
961
00:41:07,409 --> 00:41:10,245
we're gathered
to place this bike
962
00:41:10,345 --> 00:41:12,047
in her honor
and as a testament
963
00:41:12,147 --> 00:41:14,416
to her strength
and courage.
964
00:41:14,516 --> 00:41:16,318
[applause]
965
00:41:16,418 --> 00:41:18,620
And then
they released butterflies.
966
00:41:20,855 --> 00:41:22,390
How do you go on
from this?
967
00:41:22,490 --> 00:41:23,792
I wouldn't have a clue.
968
00:41:23,892 --> 00:41:25,827
You just really have to
think about that person
969
00:41:25,927 --> 00:41:27,796
and say, well, would
Mickey really want me
970
00:41:27,896 --> 00:41:30,398
to be miserable
for the rest of my life?
971
00:41:30,498 --> 00:41:32,033
She wouldn't want me
to be sad for five minutes,
972
00:41:32,133 --> 00:41:34,069
let alone
five months almost.
973
00:41:34,169 --> 00:41:40,876
And you just have to
live your life for that person.
974
00:41:40,976 --> 00:41:43,578
Four years
after finding Mickey,
975
00:41:43,678 --> 00:41:47,515
Charlie's spine of steel
was tested yet again.
976
00:41:47,616 --> 00:41:48,583
This time after learning
977
00:41:48,683 --> 00:41:51,419
she had a rare type
of brain tumor.
978
00:41:51,519 --> 00:41:54,122
The good news,
it was benign.
979
00:41:54,222 --> 00:41:55,423
And Charlie
is looking forward
980
00:41:55,523 --> 00:41:58,159
to a long, bright future.
981
00:41:58,260 --> 00:42:02,497
Just what sister Mickey
would have wanted.
982
00:42:02,597 --> 00:42:04,165
Charlie Shunick
never imagined
983
00:42:04,266 --> 00:42:06,401
a future
without her sister.
984
00:42:06,501 --> 00:42:08,770
And Mickey's murder
led her to a career
985
00:42:08,870 --> 00:42:10,839
she also didn't expect.
986
00:42:10,939 --> 00:42:12,574
Charlie became
an associate professor
987
00:42:12,674 --> 00:42:15,710
at Delgado Community College
in New Orleans.
988
00:42:15,810 --> 00:42:18,880
There she has used lessons
from Mickey's case
989
00:42:18,980 --> 00:42:22,817
to train students to one day
help solve other crimes.
990
00:42:22,918 --> 00:42:25,754
{\an8}Charlie also consults
on missing persons cases
991
00:42:25,854 --> 00:42:28,490
{\an8}and runs a non-profit
she created
992
00:42:28,590 --> 00:42:32,594
{\an8}called Resource Association
for Missing People.