Previously on Matlock... I'm Madeline Matlock.
I'm a lawyer,
like the old TV show.
Why do you want to work at my firm?
I woke up at 75 years old without a husband
or money and a 12-year-old kid to raise.
I need this job more than you can possibly imagine.
Meet me in the conference room,
and bring the new lawyer with you.
MATTY: Who's Olympia divorcing?
Julian. Oh. The guy she was arguing with.
See, there's this funny thing that happens when women age.
People assume I'm a harmless old lady,
and that's how I'm going to trick them.
Good evening, Mrs. Kingston.
There she is.
Well, you'd be a lot less cheery if you knew
how I talked about you at work.
Gambling, cheating,
not to mention dead.
Grammy! Alfie.
Was I right? Perfect name?
Reminds us of Mom?
MATTY: I had a daughter, and she died
after a long battle with drugs.
The law firm Jacobson Moore, hid documents
that could've taken opioids off the market
ten years earlier.
Think of how many lives that could've saved,
including our daughter's.
So I'm gonna figure out who knew what when,
and then, I'm gonna put them in jail.
Let's just make this, see how you feel.
It's a message from that infernal dating site.
"Madeline Kingston, is that you?"
EDWIN: Someone recognized you.
♪ ♪
Oh! (shouts)
Watch where you're going.
You're not the only damn person on Earth.
♪ ♪
MATTY: Once in a while, Alfie, the universe
sends you a sign.
A sign to do it, or not to do it?
I'm doing it.
We're doing it.
Really? Truly.
Mom would be so proud.
Remind me of that
when this gets hard, okay, darling?
I will
because it's true,
Mom would be so proud.
Let's abbreviate that, okay?
So I'm not a mess every time.
M-W-B-S-P?
M-W-B-S-P.
Perfect.
EDWIN: What's perfect?
Ah.
This year's birthday trip.
Hand over those dogs.
(laughs) Happy birthday, Mom.
Happy birthday, Ellie. Happy birthday, Ellie.
It's gonna be a good year.
Okay, what's going on with you two?
I made a decision.
I want to move forward.
Figure out if one of those lawyers
hid documents for Wellbrexa.
But it's so dangerous. I know.
And crazy, it's so crazy. I know, I know that, too.
I just...
it's my last chance
to parent our child.
Well, I guess we're moving to New York.
Really?
Yes!
I wonder what my new name should be.
♪ ♪
Matty, hurry.
Look.
I can make it with paraffin wax.
Just like they did with the first
lithographic reproduction in 1792.
And who would think that you'd be using it
200 years later to cook up
a fake thumbprint for your wife
to break into a server room?
We're basically Mr. and Mrs. Smith.
Yeah, but way sexier.
Ooh.
(both chuckle)
Give me one or two days,
I'll perfect it. I got this.
You do got this.
ALFIE: What is ethical non-monogamy
and why are old people so into it?
I'll tell you in four to seven years.
Did you get me off that dating app
so Stanley can't find me or contact me or...
Yup, deleted the whole thing.
You've officially ghosted him.
Hallelujah. I gotta hustle to work.
I got an email this morning
that Olympia and Julian
got an old case overturned on appeal.
What's that mean? For the plaintiff,
a retrial. But for me,
face time with Julian.
I want to knock his socks off,
so he pulls me over to pharma.
And then I can have access to
the whole Wellbrexa file.
Well, go get 'em, Mrs. Smith.
(laughs) Yeah.
I'm getting 'em, Mr. Smith.
I'm getting 'em.
What about romance?
True love? Taking a leap of faith?
Now, who would want that when you could have
the safety net of beautifully defined terms
that outline the distributions
of all rights and responsibilities?
I don't need a safety net.
Claudia and I aren't getting divorced.
Said every person who ever got divorced.
Matty, your marriage turned into
a rotten, loveless, black hole.
What is your stance on prenups?
My stance? Make sure your spouse
doesn't gamble away your life savings before they croak.
Well, Claudia doesn't even like scratch offs,
so I think I'm good.
Lucky you. I just got off the phone
with the orthodontist.
My grandson needs braces,
which means I need moolah, which means--
Time to get on pharma. Time to get on pharma.
I feel so observed.
It's "seen." Anyhoo,
face time with Julian means Granny gotta slay all day.
Anyone know how they won the appeal?
JULIAN: Four simple words.
Olympia argued that
four words in the jury instructions,
"Known or knowable risks,"
created prejudice against
our lesser educated plaintiffs,
and the judge agreed. Beautiful lawyering.
They should teach courses on it.
And bring you in as a special speaker,
seeing as you drafted the motion.
After I called it crazy.
No one wants me speaking.
What's happening right now?
Clearly they had a great prenup.
The point is,
we have a second bite at the apple.
So, what kind of apple we biting into?
Ana and Vanessa Sampson.
Their child died
at nine months as a result of
contaminated baby formula.
That's awful.
We sued the formula company for health
and safety violations at the factory.
The defense argued that the contamination
happened at the parents' apartment.
It was a brutal loss.
Matty, if it's too hard
to dive into a case about the loss of a child,
you can sit this one out.
I appreciate that, Olympia. I really do.
But, actually, I'd like to help the parents get justice.
So...
I assume you polled the jury.
Why'd they rule against you?
JULIAN: First off,
they didn't believe conditions at the factory
were bad enough.
And the factory foreman was adamant
that it wasn't the cause.
Well, that must be this guy,
Harold P. Wong, with all the Dr. Evil doodles
next to his name.
That's supposed to be Voldemort.
So, we need to undermine Voldemort's credibility
this time around.
Which means going back to the factory
and talking to everyone again.
Sarah and Billy, get started
on scheduling those interviews.
And if you are really up for it,
Matty, I think you'd be helpful
with another issue that came up in the polling.
Of course. What was it?
The jurors didn't feel sympathy for the moms.
After they testified about losing their baby?
(sighs)
Can we just-- Shh.
Hi, there.
I'm Julian Markston,
this is Olympia Lawrence.
We've met with four lawyers,
all wanting to profit off our pain.
Why should we pick you?
I'd love to reframe that.
We want to make First 12 Formula pay
so that this never happens to anyone ever again.
By putting us on the stand,
and questioning every single thing I did?
Ana, we both handled the bottles.
ANA: I made them.
They'll say I made it wrong.
No. Stop.
I'm sorry, but I won't
let you blame yourself for something
that should have been 100% safe.
You have no idea what this is like.
You're right,
but I do know what it feels like
to be under a microscope,
holding yourself to an impossible standard,
blaming yourself for things you shouldn't,
that others wouldn't.
But you can't protect us from that.
We know what will happen on cross.
They're going to make us look like
bad parents who weren't careful.
Well, there won't be a cross if you go with Jacobson Moore.
Because we will prove
your case without putting you on the stand.
(Julian clears throat) Um...
what I think Olympia means--
I said what I said.
Look, there is no such thing
as perfect parenting.
By making that our burden to prove,
we only set ourselves up to lose.
So, instead of focusing on what you two did right,
we will focus exclusively on
what the factory did wrong.
(elevator dings)
What the hell was that?
You wanted them to choose us,
and they did. I also want to win the case.
And that's the only way to win.
Because if we put Ana and Vanessa on the stand,
all the jury will see is how guilty they feel,
and I can already hear the defense.
"See? Even they blame themselves."
Let's hope you didn't screw us.
Olympia did this.
She's the reason we have another shot.
I can't believe it.
And to get this call now.
I'm four months pregnant.
(laughs) Just started telling people,
and I don't know, it feels like a sign.
Everything's a sign if you want it to be.
ANA: V, how often
do you get a second chance?
VANESSA: Nothing has changed.
What makes you think you can win this time?
Because you'll testify.
I let my emotions override
my judgment last time,
and... it was a mistake.
The jury needs to connect with your family,
needs to hear
what your child meant to you.
We have a baby coming.
We want to be moving forward, not back.
You don't have to testify.
I can do it.
Could I say one thing?
I know I'm new to the case,
so I hope you don't mind my jumping in.
The thing is
I lost my daughter ten years ago,
and one thing I know is that...
...grief comes in waves.
I just don't want you to make
a decision today
that you might regret later.
ANA: Exactly.
Can we get a minute?
Of course.
(Julian clears throat)
Thank you. Mm-hmm.
(phone buzzes)
I, um, sorry.
I've got to go. I'll be right back.
Edwin, you have to call me back.
Alfie said he deleted SeniorSweeties,
but then I just got this email from Stanley.
He said he works a block away from Jacobson Moore,
and he wants to get together.
Edwin, he actually said Jacobson Moore.
He found me.
OLYMPIA: Matty, you okay?
Who found you?
Oh, it's just these G.D. creditors.
They're just pushier than me at Talbots
on clearance day.
What's going on, Matty?
Um...
You know my husband died and just left me all kinds of debt
and I'm just trying to handle it.
If you need help, financially,
the firm can advance your salary.
Your job is secure.
Well, you don't know how much that means to me.
But, um, you know, I've got it covered.
The only thing is,
I just need some time to talk to my accountant about all of this.
Of course, of course.
Uh, but, uh...
can we-- can we keep this between us?
I mean, I don't want Julian to think that I'm somebody
who brings their personal life trumping into work.
I got you.
No problem. Okay. Thanks.
Mm-hmm.
(door closes)
JULIAN: Is Matty okay?
She's fine.
Tell me Vanessa said yes.
She said yes.
Ana's gonna be the one to testify.
They both feel good. Perfect.
Want more good news? Mm-hmm.
Sarah texted me about our interviews.
Guess who no longer works at the factory.
Harold P. Wong.
I hope you didn't go out of your way.
Turns out it's not a good time. No problem.
We'll just subpoena all your line supervisors
to our office for depositions.
Wait here, I'll be right back.
When are you not going to be angry?
Can I get a time, even an estimate?
We talked about this.
You have no idea what it's like to be a Black kid
in a rich, white school.
Your hair has to be perfect,
your clothes can't have holes.
It's pajama day. Even on pajama day. Which is why--
WONG: The supervisors will meet you when the shift ends.
Be quick, this is an inconvenience.
We really apprec--
I left you a note telling you not to put them in sweats.
Their friends were all doing it, y-you're overreacting.
I just love how you prioritize my experience in the world
when it suits you.
What are you talking about?
Bring your Black wife onto the case
so you could seal the deal?
But when it comes to our children, I'm overreacting?
One is professional, the other is our family.
(bell rings) The family, I should have an equal say.
Uh, thank you, everyone, for your time.
Uh, my name is Julian.
This is my colleague Olympia.
We'll be asking each of you a few questions.
It'll be quick and painless.
As your manager already told you,
we are from the law firm of Jacobson Moore.
No, I quit ages ago.
I just like to hold one from time to time.
Good on you. You miss it?
Mostly just the escape hatch.
I used to go out onto the smoking patio at work
when I, you know, needed time alone.
Now the first-year associates call it the crime patio.
Think I don't know.
You make 'em cry?
Never the goal.
Look, everyone in there is going to toe the company line.
But if you know anything at all,
as a man of faith,
you can help me right this wrong.
All I know is the violations were worse
than the FDA report said, much worse.
And nothing ever really got fixed around here.
All they ever do is patch things up and move along.
Would you testify to that in court?
I can't. I need this job.
There are retaliation laws. They can't fire you.
I can't risk it. I got six kids.
No wonder you can't quit smoking.
(laughing)
My mom was one of eight.
Mm-hmm.
When I was little, she made me pray every night.
Let me guess. Baptist.
You know it.
(chuckles) Took me the longest time
to understand what it was really about.
My mom had so little growing up,
nothing to give to anyone,
so she prayed for them instead.
I don't see it being that different.
Praying, and telling the truth.
Teddy. (laughs)
You sure you want me up on the stand again?
I didn't help last time. OLYMPIA: Oh, you helped a lot, trust me.
Heard Harold's gone. What happened?
No idea.
Couple of months after the trial, he was out.
Canned, I think, because it was fast.
New foreman any better?
Yeah, I'll introduce you.
Guy's much more transparent, approves days off.
Those pipes...
Are they new?
Oh, yeah, they're copper-lined now.
And I'm glad.
The old ones never fit the gasket quite right.
Once, one popped off.
I had to jump in and hold it up in place.
Felt like I was on Survivor.
W-Who put these in? New guy?
No, Harold did it before he left. Why?
Because at trial, I argued that
the factory should've used copper--
more antibacterial and anticorrosive--
and Harold made a huge deal
about stainless steel being good enough.
So why'd he make the change?
Makes no damn sense.
Once you delete the damn thing,
they shouldn't be able to email you.
EDWIN: Well, that's what you get
for using a 12-year-old as our dating app expert.
Did you get the draft I sent you?
Let's see.
"Hi, Stanley.
"I'm embarrassed, but I'm actually still with my husband.
"My grandson made this as a joke.
"Sorry for the confusion.
And I wish you well in the future."
What do you think?
You ghost with grace, my love.
Edwin, I'm worried.
I know you are. But it's gonna be okay.
You just focus on your work,
focus on impressing Julian,
focus on how sexy I look
cooking up thumbprints.
Did you get it to work?
Oh, not even close. (chuckles)
But I've got a lot of YouTubers to get through.
(hold music playing)
And now we've been on hold
longer than most celebrity marriages last.
Don't start. Because you want to be
Mel Gibson and pay out
$425 million to your ex-wife?
I don't want to be Mel Gibson for quite a few reasons.
And why are you giving me marriage advice
when you can't even ask Kira on a date?
I'm crafting the perfect email.
It needs one reference to our unexpected lunch,
one slightly suggestive open-ended question,
and two witty lines, and no ellipses.
FDA EMPLOYEE: Food and Drug Administration.
How may I help you?
Uh, hi, yes, uh, we're calling about
the latest research regarding bacterial contamination
in stainless steel pipes.
Type of contaminant?
Uh, there's a few we'd like to ask about.
But no matter what it is,
or how small, it can breed and fester
until it becomes a major problem
you never saw coming, right?
Sorry about that.
Uh, can we start with mycotoxins?
You're out of your damn mind.
Harold is not gonna open up to me.
Or me. Actually...
You know who we can send.
I was just thinking the same thing.
(rings)
HAROLD: I'm not buying anything.
Whoa, where's that voice coming from?
Hello?
I can't hear you. I'm here.
You, you have to press the button when you talk.
(rings doorbell)
(mouthing silently)
I can't hear you.
Are you an idiot?
Press the button...
Oh, come on.
(rings doorbell)
Hello there, I'm Madeline Matlock,
junior legal counsel from Jacobson Moore.
I have nothing to say to you people.
Just to set the table for you, Harold,
the only reason I'm standing here
with my foot in your door, still working at 75,
is because I'm too broke to retire.
So could you just please answer a few questions
so I can go home?
No. Now move your foot.
Did you know, Harold,
women lose up to 20% of their bone density
in the years following menopause,
which means my metatarsals
are just brittle little matchsticks
that could snap, crackle and pop
if you pushed just the tiniest bit on that door.
Now, technically, I can't make you talk,
but I'm not moving my foot until you do.
Or you could try to close that door.
And did I mention I'm from Jacobson Moore?
We have a killer personal injury department.
Lady... Ow, my foot!
Just three quick questions.
Ow. Ow. Enough. Fine.
Three questions. Go.
Why did you change the pipes from stainless steel to copper?
The price of copper is tied to oil.
Both tanked.
All of a sudden, copper pipes-- affordable.
No conspiracy, no funny business,
just simple economics.
Next.
Regarding your departure from the factory,
we heard from some of your ex-coworkers...
Ex-employees.
...ex-employees
that it wasn't exactly your choice to leave.
Those jerkoffs need to spend more time working
and less time talking about me.
Last question.
This one's easy.
Could you pretty please let me use your commode
before I get back on the PATH train?
The bladder takes a nosedive after 70
because the vaginal walls...
Stop. Fine, fine. Follow me. (phone buzzes)
Matty said no on the pipes.
Sarah and Billy are striking out with the FDA.
I can't find... Ana's testifying.
That's going to make the difference.
Without proof, it still might not be enough.
We're in the exact same place we were before.
...not negligent in maintaining the safety
of its product and therefore...
We should have put them on the stand.
We are in such a different place.
We're communicating, we're, we're listening to each other.
We're gonna figure it out together.
Loving the support.
I'm just not sure if working well together
is going to change the outcome.
(phone ringing) (sighs)
OLYMPIA: Hey, Matty.
MATTY: I think I found something.
Boy, were you right.
That Harold P. Wong is not a very nice fellow.
See that fancy new stove poking its little head out
from the kitchen?
I saw a British lady on TV
using one to make an arrabiata.
A stove like that starts at $6,000.
Floors were redone, fancy music equipment.
Outside the place is still a shell,
but inside, money has been spent.
And as a factory foreman how much was he making, again?
$83,000 a year.
He must have been embezzling.
That's why he got fired.
Or that's what he wants us to think
so we don't look too hard at what really happened.
Exactly. I was setting you up to make that point.
OLYMPIA: Think he's got a golden parachute?
He's covering for the contamination.
Retire at 48 with no worries and an arrabiata stove.
JULIAN: Okay, we need to look at everything
Harold touched during our potential contamination window
and figure out exactly what he was rewarded
for doing or hiding. BILLY: I'll take the OSHA reports,
see if anything was misreported to the regulatory agencies.
I will take payroll.
Maybe Harold inflated somebody's salary
to buy their silence.
Great. Matty, you got maintenance reports,
we'll comb through the financials,
let's reconvene in the morning.
All right.
What if he messed around with sick pay to cover up
some sort of illness that was going around?
Teddy would have told us.
Ah, you are not pawning this off on me.
It was your Christmas present.
From your Great-Aunt Sylvia.
Donate pile. Donate pile.
The inspector's coming Monday. Did I tell you that? Mm-hmm.
It's the final walk-through before closing.
Could always sabotage the thermostat.
Finally called the heating guy.
You were right.
Thermostat was off by a good ten degrees.
Go ahead, say "I told you so."
That's your move.
You think I'm not torturing myself over the case?
What did you want me to say?
Something, anything, so I wasn't alone again.
Again? Is this, uh, is this...?
My father died, and you hid in your office
every night till midnight.
You said you needed space.
Stop assuming the worst.
Then stop being the worst.
Oh, my God.
How much did it cost to fix the heat?
The heat? Um, like $3K?
That invoice from the factory roof repair.
$350,000 for a re-shingling.
Authorized by Harold P. Wong.
No shingling job would cost that much.
There was clearly something else going on with that roof.
Which probably had to do with our contamination.
We are on fire.
Babe, that was all me.
(shift bell ringing)
OLYMPIA: Does the date June 21st mean anything to you?
TEDDY: It's the date when the ceiling
in the break room caved in.
That's when I broke my arm.
Do you think the rupture could have breached the outside?
Harold swore it didn't.
That's why I ain't mention it to you.
What would you say if I told you
that Harold paid a roofing company
$350,000 to fix it?
I'd say
it sounds like the whole darn roof caved in.
(snaps fingers)
How'd you like to spot a lady in heels up a very tall ladder?
(both laugh)
So I went on up... What? Onto the roof?
Yeah, it's easy. There's an access door.
And not only did I see where the roof was repaired,
the whole damn place is covered in mold,
which could have easily entered the factory during the collapse,
and I got us a sample.
So we just need to confirm that the bacteria
in the mold is the same one that made Dante sick.
Already put Sarah and Billy on it.
We wait to tell Ana and Vanessa until we know for sure?
(elevator bell dings) Definitely.
Let's let them focus on Ana's testimony. Okay.
Hi, Vanessa.
Where's Ana? Oh, she's not coming.
Her obstetrician says she needs to get some rest.
Blood pressure got too high,
so...
I'll testify instead.
When Matty gets here, tell her
we're prepping in the small conference room.
MAN: I wanted to drop something off
for someone who works at Jacobson Moore.
Maybe you could buzz me up. Her name's Madeline Kin...
Stanley. Madeline.
Why don't we go over here? I got your message.
And please believe me when I say
I want to respect your space.
I just wanted to drop this off.
Thank you. Uh, now I-I-I have to...
It's a photo of Ellie.
Tommy kept this little photo book, all his friends.
I fished it out
when I saw you on the app.
I-I couldn't believe you'd moved east.
I needed a change after Ellie passed.
I really should... Tommy's missing.
Started using again last year and...
I-I guess I also wanted to talk to someone who understood.
I can spare a few minutes, Stanley.
Okay. Yeah. Okay? Yeah.
Thank you. Yeah.
How long has it been since you last heard from Tommy?
Three weeks.
He relapsed about nine months ago,
but he'd check in.
And now...
I just have this feeling...
Yeah, it's the scariest feeling in the world.
You've got to think of yourself
as a private investigator, not as a parent.
Go to each and every place where he got high.
Take food. People will talk.
OLYMPIA: Try to think
of your testimony as a conversation
with an old friend.
You want to be open, emotional and...
VANESSA: Everything okay?
Yes.
All good. Let's get started.
Vanessa, let's start at the beginning.
When you first brought Dante home,
can you tell me what that was like?
It was life with a newborn.
Lots of laundry, diapers, sleepless nights.
I can imagine you would give anything
to get those sleepless nights back.
Of course.
Let's move on to after Dante died.
What were those days like?
Hard.
Can you be more specific?
What was it like getting through the day?
What more do you want from me?
I am sorry, but this is our last shot.
We are suing for pain and suffering.
The jury needs to see it.
So you need me back in a place where I can't function?
Is that what you want?
Of course not, no. I was just...
Actually, let's just take ten, okay?
(panting)
It's just too painful.
I'm sorry. I thought I could help you.
Madeline, I'm so sorry... Stay away from me.
I mean it, it's too hard.
What was that about?
Accountant. Wanted me to give him a certified check.
Are you okay?
I just felt like a vulture trying to tear out this pain.
You're doing your job. But I'm not.
We still can't prove the contamination.
And it's unclear to me at this point if this is even ethical.
You know, I'm trying to make Vanessa cry.
I'm trying to take her back to her trauma.
And what if we lose?
Then it'll hurt like hell.
(sighs) But most people don't get a second chance.
She doesn't even want one. Now.
But if she doesn't do it, I promise you,
they will wake up in the middle of the night at some point
and they will regret not taking this last opportunity
to parent their child.
Were you and Ellie close?
Sometimes.
But we weren't on the best of terms when she passed.
Can you tell me about Ellie?
She was bigger than life.
She just...
...wanted more of it all the time.
And you could not tell that child she couldn't do something.
(both chuckle)
I remember I took her to the park.
She was about five,
and she was having none of that
rinky-dinky kid play structure. Mm-mm.
She just marched right up to that
big kid one.
She pushed past all these ten-year-olds,
and she climbed up to that
double-decker jungle gym. (both laugh)
You must've been terrified and a little proud.
I was a lot proud.
Till she decided
she liked all the attention and she wouldn't come back down.
Eventually ended up in a cast.
Boy, she was a piece of work, that kid.
She was the G-darn love of my life.
Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to take you back there.
I know everyone says it,
but I do not know how you can lose a kid
and keep going.
You learn to breathe again.
That's what it's like.
Learning to breathe on some new planet that's...
...totally inhospitable to human life.
And then somebody says,
"Tell me about Ellie."
Anyway, most of the time I'm okay,
like I said, but sometimes I just...
Well... (sighs)
I'm kind of jealous of Teddy.
Mm? You know,
he's just working those rosary beads
and full of faith that there's a plan and...
He's been texting me,
by the way.
Theories, ideas, just trying to help.
You know, do the right thing.
He once jumped on the line
and held up a 40-pound pipe
with a broken arm-- did I tell you that?
Mm-hmm.
Was his arm in a cast?
Teddy, can you explain what the contamination window is?
It's the window of time when my factory
made batches of formula that
the plaintiffs' baby ingested.
OLYMPIA: And the roof collapse, when you broke your arm,
that happened before that window, correct?
That's right.
How long were you in a cast for?
Eight weeks.
OLYMPIA: And during that time,
did you continue to work? TEDDY: Yes.
The company didn't grant me a medical leave,
but as a line supervisor,
I didn't have to use my arms as much.
But did you have to use your arms at one point?
Yes.
A pipe on the manufacturing line burst.
It was chaos.
Someone could've got hurt.
So I jumped in to hold the pipe in place.
And that happened during the estimated contamination window?
Yes, it did.
And were you wearing gloves?
I always do,
but, um...
I...
I couldn't get one over the cast.
In your expertise,
as a supervisor in charge of quality control,
was there a risk of contamination
from you holding the pipe?
Yes.
My cast must've touched
an open end.
I must've introduced germs into the sterile environment.
Into the formula.
I'm so sorry.
OLYMPIA: Thank you, Teddy.
MIA: Mr. Copeland.
About how long do you estimate
you were holding that broken pipe?
Two to three minutes?
But the plaintiffs interacted
with their baby every moment, every hour
leading up to his death. Objection.
That's not a question.
Sustained. DEFENSE COUNSEL: I'm wondering,
from a mathematical standpoint,
how likely Teddy thinks it is
that his brief heroic act caused the contamination,
compared to the parents' hourly contact with their baby.
Well, the witness isn't an expert mathematician.
Good point. Let's explore
what else he's not an expert in.
Do you know whether the plaintiffs used purified water
every time they mixed a bottle of formula?
Your Honor. SHELTON: You asked
for the witness's opinion
on the risk he created.
Sir, you can answer the question.
No, I don't.
What about if they washed their hands properly?
No.
Or how often they sterilized their bottles?
No. If they bleached their sink...
SHELTON: Okay, I think you've made
your point, Counselor.
DEFENSE COUNSEL: No further questions. We'll adjourn for one hour.
We'll see you after lunch.
Okay, the defense scored some points,
but Teddy's direct was convincing.
He gave us causation. Mm-hmm.
So, maybe we don't put Vanessa on the stand.
No, I-I won't make the same mistake we made last time.
Look, we need both. Causation and sympathy.
MATTY: She's protecting herself
with her anger. You need to get underneath it.
I know I do, I just...
I don't know if I should.
You should, because when Ana and Vanessa hear
that jury find in their favor, hold those people responsible
for taking Dante away from 'em,
it'll be worth it, trust me.
Let's start with the routine you and Ana followed
when it came to the formula.
Did you ever premix the bottles?
Sometimes.
But we always made sure to put them in the refrigerator.
Always? Yes.
Ana kept a chart
to track how long they'd been in there.
What about the partially used bottles? Did you save them?
No. We threw them away
because, um, we were afraid of making Dante sick.
Tell me about Dante.
What?
We've spent so much time
talking about his death.
Tell me
what he was like when he was alive.
Tell me about Dante?
He used to wake up smiling.
He just loved people, so...
which meant he didn't sleep.
He'd wake up
five, six times a night.
Sometimes to eat, but...
mostly just to be in the world.
It's like he couldn't get enough of it.
I started to sleep in his room
so Ana could be fresh for work.
All those long nights, just me and Dante.
16 steps.
That's how many it took to get from one side
of his room to the other.
I walked with him so many times...
(sniffles)
...holding him,
singing to him...
(exhales)
For months after he died,
I would just go in there and walk back and forth.
(softly): And back and forth.
(sniffles)
Oh, I hate this part. The waiting.
Not me. It's out of our hands.
That's the problem. It could go either way.
It's completely out of our control. Exactly.
So you can't micromanage risk out of life.
Or relationships or "almost relationship."
Text Kira.
Use all the ellipses.
Okay, fine, deal, but only if you talk to Claudia
about the possibility of a prenup
after you pop the question.
Fine, but if she doesn't want one,
you don't mention it again. Deal?
Deal. Good.
You know, if you really think about it,
you and I would make the perfect couple.
(coughs) (phone buzzes)
The verdict is in. Come on.
BAILIFF: All rise.
FOREPERSON: The jury finds
First 12 Formula was negligent
in maintaining the safety of its product
and is therefore liable for the death of Dante Sampson.
We award $3 million in punitive damages
and $5 million for pain and suffering.
(whispered chatter)
You did it.
You held them responsible.
(children chattering playfully)
(grunts)
Edwin. Are-are you okay?
I think I'm having a heart attack.
Are you sure it was just a panic attack?
Positive. Go to your doctor to get a beta blocker
in case it happens again.
Your wife's heart looks fine.
She just needs to rest,
avoid stress.
Did you hear that? Heard that.
Thank you.
Darling... I know.
You need to take your health more seriously.
It was a particularly hard day.
It's only gonna get harder.
When you get deeper in, the risk,
the stress...
maybe next time it'll be a real heart attack.
Yes, but we're so close.
We're not.
If you were on Wellbrexa,
maybe it would be different,
but you're not close to it at all.
I can't get the damn thumbprints right
because I'm a retired art history professor.
And you are not superhuman,
though there's a lot of evidence to the contrary.
You're saying we're not Mr. and Mrs. Smith?
I'm saying we're Mr. and Mrs. Kingston.
Whose daughter was one
of hundreds of thousands of Americans
who died of an opioid overdose.
And, yes, Jacobson Moore hid the documents,
but that's not your responsibility.
You could just be like everybody else and...
...grieve.
(sobs)
I won't get another chance.
If I stop now, I'll always regret it.
I have to keep going,
I owe it to Ellie.
No.
What you owe to Ellie is to take care of Alfie.
He's our second chance.
And I need you
to be here to help raise him.
Today was a sign, Matty.
It was a warning sign.
Okay.
Look what I found.
I haven't worn it since we lost.
Time to bring it back.
(sighs)
You okay?
I just hope it was worth it.
It was. Or it will be.
Thank you for tonight.
You can go.
No, I can't.
I shouldn't have left you before...
and I'm not leaving now.
Good, because...
(exhales) I had a whole speech I was gonna do.
Don't need it.
If we weren't keeping it professional at work,
I would tell you how sexy you look in that suit.
And I would say that I feel very different
from the last time I wore it.
I'm pivoting.
I want to do cases where I can actually help people,
less corporate litigation.
There is no way Senior will agree.
He will if I'm the one asking.
Is that what this is about? Showing me up?
Because I'm really not buying this sudden passion
for helping anyone other than yourself. I don't care what you buy.
Ah! Oh!
Watch where you're going.
You're not the only damn person on Earth.
(exhales)
I just-- I want my life to feel meaningful.
You used to think your life was meaningful
by being in a family with me.
I want a divorce.
(elevator bell dings)
(exhales) It's gonna be hard to keep this a secret.
Undercover operations are sexy, baby.
EDWIN: Today was a sign, Matty.
If you were working on Wellbrexa,
that might be a different story,
but you're not close to it at all. (elevator bell dings)
I can't help it. What? Stop.
Matty!
Oh, I was just about to come talk to both of you
about my time here.
That's actually what we wanted to talk to you about.
JULIAN: Four words, Matty.
You're going to pharma.
JULIAN: I've got a new case with Wellbrexa,
and I'm bringing you on. OLYMPIA: You've earned it.
OLYMPIA: So, what did you want to talk to us about?
MATTY: Exactly that.
I wanted my shot.
This must be a sign.
I'm right where the universe wants me to be.
Captioning sponsored by CBS
and TOYOTA.
Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org