1
00:00:21,083 --> 00:00:24,643
‎我在那裡看到飛機殘骸,大約在那裡

2
00:00:34,763 --> 00:00:37,643
‎如果是墜機的話,會有罹難者

3
00:00:38,283 --> 00:00:40,803
‎所以我們立刻想到他們的家人

4
00:00:44,843 --> 00:00:47,603
‎當時我們趕緊用無線電報警

5
00:00:52,963 --> 00:00:55,363
‎(2015年7月29日)

6
00:00:55,363 --> 00:00:59,083
‎(最後一次聯繫在16個月前)

7
00:00:59,083 --> 00:01:00,123
‎(突發新聞)

8
00:01:00,123 --> 00:01:04,243
‎今早新聞快報
‎馬航370班機搜索行動...

9
00:01:04,243 --> 00:01:06,323
‎一塊飛機殘骸被沖上

10
00:01:06,323 --> 00:01:09,203
‎位於印度洋的法屬留尼汪島

11
00:01:09,203 --> 00:01:12,043
{\an8}‎調查人員認為圖片中的殘骸

12
00:01:12,043 --> 00:01:16,563
{\an8}‎跟失蹤的馬航客機波音777一致

13
00:01:16,563 --> 00:01:17,643
{\an8}‎這似乎是真的

14
00:01:17,643 --> 00:01:21,203
{\an8}‎假如這是波音777零件,那就是MH370

15
00:01:21,203 --> 00:01:23,363
{\an8}‎毫無疑問,這就是失蹤的班機

16
00:01:23,363 --> 00:01:26,963
{\an8}‎而且有跡象顯示它長時間泡在水裡

17
00:01:26,963 --> 00:01:29,443
{\an8}‎這對家屬來說是很難熬的一天

18
00:01:33,683 --> 00:01:36,483
‎我個人完全否認

19
00:01:36,483 --> 00:01:40,523
‎飛機最後墜毀了

20
00:01:42,123 --> 00:01:45,963
‎我生活中的一切又失控了

21
00:01:49,403 --> 00:01:54,123
‎對我而言,看到殘骸的當下我心想

22
00:01:55,243 --> 00:01:57,203
‎“好吧,他們不會回來了”

23
00:01:57,723 --> 00:02:03,723
‎這景象迫使我們接受他們葬身海底

24
00:02:07,003 --> 00:02:08,043
‎我們要接受

25
00:02:09,643 --> 00:02:11,963
‎他們不會回來了,就這樣

26
00:02:16,323 --> 00:02:20,443
‎我本身並不相信
‎MH370在南印度洋墜毀

27
00:02:21,603 --> 00:02:25,083
‎所以我第一次看到新聞時

28
00:02:25,083 --> 00:02:26,843
‎老實說,我心想

29
00:02:27,483 --> 00:02:28,843
‎“是誰放在那的?”

30
00:02:30,443 --> 00:02:32,243
‎“是誰把那塊碎片帶過去的?”

31
00:02:36,843 --> 00:02:38,763
‎我們沒有答案

32
00:02:38,763 --> 00:02:42,483
‎這是航空史上最大的謎團之一

33
00:02:42,483 --> 00:02:47,003
‎MH370:消失的馬航客機

34
00:02:56,203 --> 00:02:59,603
‎我們懷著極其沉重的心情

35
00:03:00,163 --> 00:03:01,403
‎向各位宣布

36
00:03:02,083 --> 00:03:08,723
‎國際專家團隊最終證實

37
00:03:09,643 --> 00:03:13,803
‎在留尼汪島找到的飛機殘骸

38
00:03:14,443 --> 00:03:18,203
‎的確來自MH370

39
00:03:18,203 --> 00:03:21,683
‎這消息破解了
‎幾十年來最大的航空謎團

40
00:03:21,683 --> 00:03:25,683
‎這對獨立專家組成員來說是大消息

41
00:03:26,403 --> 00:03:31,963
{\an8}‎這是飛機在印度洋墜毀
‎第一個確鑿的證據

42
00:03:31,963 --> 00:03:34,483
‎這是他們認為飛機墜落的大致區域

43
00:03:34,483 --> 00:03:40,003
‎這些白色圓點模擬出
‎MH370殘骸可能的地點

44
00:03:42,243 --> 00:03:44,803
‎得知我們倡導的推論得到加強

45
00:03:45,403 --> 00:03:49,323
‎讓我們感到欣慰

46
00:03:52,043 --> 00:03:53,243
‎在那之前

47
00:03:53,243 --> 00:03:57,203
‎唯一指出飛機最後在南印度洋的資訊

48
00:03:57,203 --> 00:03:58,603
‎是國際海事衛星組織數據

49
00:04:02,243 --> 00:04:05,123
‎被沖上岸的殘骸證實了這一點

50
00:04:07,843 --> 00:04:12,083
‎這是首次出現獨立的證據

51
00:04:12,083 --> 00:04:16,923
‎飛機出現在我們預估的地方

52
00:04:20,323 --> 00:04:24,363
‎找到殘骸時
‎竄改數據的假設不攻自破

53
00:04:25,483 --> 00:04:29,483
‎我先前推測
‎國際海事衛星組織蓄意竄改數據

54
00:04:29,483 --> 00:04:33,883
‎好讓飛機看似走這條路線
‎但其實是另一條

55
00:04:34,763 --> 00:04:36,643
‎飛機顯然沒有往北走

56
00:04:36,643 --> 00:04:39,203
‎因為這是那架飛機的殘骸

57
00:04:41,683 --> 00:04:42,523
‎然而

58
00:04:44,123 --> 00:04:45,443
‎我仔細思考後

59
00:04:46,123 --> 00:04:47,803
‎心想:“好吧”

60
00:04:47,803 --> 00:04:49,163
‎(航空記者 傑夫懷斯)

61
00:04:49,723 --> 00:04:54,323
‎“我必須百分之百說服自己
‎那是MH370的殘骸”

62
00:04:56,763 --> 00:05:00,923
‎(柬埔寨)

63
00:05:02,843 --> 00:05:05,243
‎我從小就喜歡

64
00:05:05,243 --> 00:05:09,163
‎冒險、旅行和解開謎題

65
00:05:12,243 --> 00:05:16,523
‎我一直想去世界上每個國家

66
00:05:16,523 --> 00:05:20,803
‎學習各地風土民情和未解的謎題

67
00:05:20,803 --> 00:05:23,723
‎我想解開謎題、釐清謎題

68
00:05:26,763 --> 00:05:29,443
‎我加入了一個臉書社團

69
00:05:29,443 --> 00:05:32,043
‎專門討論馬航370班機

70
00:05:32,043 --> 00:05:36,203
‎我想知道我能提供哪些協助

71
00:05:37,923 --> 00:05:40,483
‎所以在發現襟副翼後

72
00:05:41,443 --> 00:05:45,563
‎我知道外面還有更多殘骸

73
00:05:47,443 --> 00:05:49,523
‎我向海洋學家請教

74
00:05:49,523 --> 00:05:52,043
‎我說:“我想去找更多殘骸”

75
00:05:52,043 --> 00:05:53,763
‎“我該去哪裡?”

76
00:05:56,243 --> 00:05:57,083
‎他們的回覆是

77
00:05:57,723 --> 00:06:01,883
‎“莫三比克海岸的
‎莫三比克海峽會有殘骸”

78
00:06:01,883 --> 00:06:04,083
‎“去那裡,也許你會有好運”

79
00:06:04,603 --> 00:06:06,003
‎於是我就去了

80
00:06:08,283 --> 00:06:09,843
‎(莫三比克維蘭庫洛)

81
00:06:09,843 --> 00:06:12,083
‎我去了維蘭庫洛

82
00:06:12,883 --> 00:06:14,923
‎莫三比克海峽沿岸的城市

83
00:06:14,923 --> 00:06:18,763
‎我到處問維蘭庫洛當地居民

84
00:06:18,763 --> 00:06:20,923
‎有沒有看到飛機殘骸

85
00:06:22,363 --> 00:06:26,243
‎我遇到一個人
‎他說:“那裡有個沙丘”

86
00:06:27,043 --> 00:06:31,923
‎“漁民會去那裡拿漁網、浮標、魚漂”

87
00:06:35,483 --> 00:06:36,843
‎所以我跟他一起去

88
00:06:37,923 --> 00:06:40,643
‎我們走著走著

89
00:06:40,643 --> 00:06:44,083
‎差不多走了20分鐘左右

90
00:06:44,683 --> 00:06:46,003
‎突然間

91
00:06:47,523 --> 00:06:49,483
‎我說:“那是什麼?”

92
00:06:50,123 --> 00:06:51,443
‎所以我走過去

93
00:06:52,603 --> 00:06:57,963
‎看到灰色的三角形物品
‎上面寫著“禁止踩踏”

94
00:06:58,483 --> 00:07:05,363
‎(禁止踩踏)

95
00:07:05,883 --> 00:07:07,843
‎我握在手裡

96
00:07:09,683 --> 00:07:10,763
‎我跟你說

97
00:07:11,803 --> 00:07:14,763
‎那一刻,我就知道

98
00:07:16,723 --> 00:07:19,043
‎我的心中和腦中都很清楚

99
00:07:19,043 --> 00:07:22,203
‎我找到馬航370的殘骸

100
00:07:24,803 --> 00:07:28,083
{\an8}‎今晚有殘骸的最新進展

101
00:07:28,083 --> 00:07:31,083
{\an8}‎在東非發現的殘骸有可能是

102
00:07:31,083 --> 00:07:34,163
{\an8}‎失蹤的馬航370班機

103
00:07:34,163 --> 00:07:36,243
{\an8}‎馬來西亞當局今天重申

104
00:07:36,243 --> 00:07:40,763
{\an8}‎照片證據顯示其可能來自波音777

105
00:07:40,763 --> 00:07:43,803
{\an8}‎來聽聽發現的美國人怎麼說

106
00:07:43,803 --> 00:07:46,003
‎這絕對是飛機零件

107
00:07:46,523 --> 00:07:48,403
‎可能是波音客機的

108
00:07:48,923 --> 00:07:51,483
‎可能是波音777客機的

109
00:07:52,163 --> 00:07:55,803
‎這可能來自馬航370班機

110
00:07:58,523 --> 00:08:00,403
‎從照片中看來

111
00:08:00,403 --> 00:08:02,323
‎那塊飛機殘骸

112
00:08:03,523 --> 00:08:06,723
‎有很高的機率來自波音777客機

113
00:08:07,563 --> 00:08:10,603
‎有人叫我去莫三比克尋找殘骸

114
00:08:10,603 --> 00:08:12,243
‎我去了,也找到了

115
00:08:12,243 --> 00:08:16,483
‎海洋學家告訴我
‎最好的地點是馬達加斯加

116
00:08:17,283 --> 00:08:18,363
‎所以我去那裡

117
00:08:19,043 --> 00:08:20,323
‎尋找更多殘骸

118
00:08:27,523 --> 00:08:30,763
‎布萊恩吉布森發現至少20件殘骸

119
00:08:30,763 --> 00:08:35,523
‎其中7件被歸類為
‎幾乎能確定來自MH370

120
00:08:35,523 --> 00:08:39,163
‎另外10件有可能
‎或極有可能來自該架飛機

121
00:08:39,163 --> 00:08:44,603
‎這是目前為止找到的最重要一塊

122
00:08:46,443 --> 00:08:47,963
‎布萊恩艾倫吉布森

123
00:08:47,963 --> 00:08:52,523
‎展現出尋找殘骸不可思議的本領

124
00:08:52,523 --> 00:08:55,083
‎這是其他人想做也做不到的事

125
00:08:56,963 --> 00:08:59,163
‎他是唯一能走出戶外

126
00:08:59,883 --> 00:09:02,923
‎去海灘散步,撿到殘骸的人

127
00:09:02,923 --> 00:09:09,963
‎我們相信這塊殘骸來自馬航370...

128
00:09:11,403 --> 00:09:12,923
‎對啊,你看

129
00:09:12,923 --> 00:09:14,643
‎天啊

130
00:09:15,883 --> 00:09:18,323
‎而且...

131
00:09:18,323 --> 00:09:21,803
‎他找到的殘骸

132
00:09:21,803 --> 00:09:26,283
‎佔了找回的MH370殘骸絕大多數

133
00:09:26,883 --> 00:09:29,883
‎大部分的MH370實體證據

134
00:09:29,883 --> 00:09:31,923
‎出自同一個人的手

135
00:09:31,923 --> 00:09:34,203
{\an8}‎這位是現代的印第安納瓊斯

136
00:09:34,203 --> 00:09:37,403
{\an8}‎他這兩年多來的使命是去世界各地

137
00:09:37,403 --> 00:09:39,803
{\an8}‎尋找馬航客機的蹤跡

138
00:09:40,323 --> 00:09:41,803
‎對布萊恩來說,這似乎很簡單

139
00:09:42,323 --> 00:09:46,443
‎我必須要問的問題是

140
00:09:46,443 --> 00:09:47,963
‎“這怎麼可能?”

141
00:09:49,723 --> 00:09:51,043
‎如果我是對的

142
00:09:51,043 --> 00:09:53,403
‎MH370事件是俄羅斯的陰謀

143
00:09:53,403 --> 00:09:57,163
‎在過程中誤導各界

144
00:09:57,163 --> 00:09:59,483
‎假裝飛機進入南印度洋

145
00:09:59,483 --> 00:10:04,003
‎那就意味著殘骸是陰謀的一部分

146
00:10:04,763 --> 00:10:07,803
‎並由為俄羅斯工作的人移到當地

147
00:10:08,523 --> 00:10:11,323
‎這不是俄羅斯第一次

148
00:10:12,283 --> 00:10:17,243
‎利用假飛機殘骸來誤導調查人員

149
00:10:17,843 --> 00:10:22,403
‎大韓航空007班機,機上載有269人

150
00:10:22,403 --> 00:10:26,683
‎從紐約起飛,前往首爾
‎經過阿拉斯加與東京

151
00:10:26,683 --> 00:10:30,843
‎國務院宣稱
‎飛機在蘇聯庫頁島附近被擊落

152
00:10:30,843 --> 00:10:32,523
‎早在1983年

153
00:10:32,523 --> 00:10:36,923
‎蘇聯在日本海域擊落一架韓國客機

154
00:10:37,403 --> 00:10:42,003
‎日本的無線電監視顯示
‎蘇聯飛機是從地面控制的

155
00:10:42,923 --> 00:10:46,883
‎取回黑盒子的任務必須分秒必爭

156
00:10:46,883 --> 00:10:50,763
‎美國和日本搜救隊尋找殘骸時

157
00:10:50,763 --> 00:10:56,323
‎蘇聯在海床上
‎放了假的聲波訊號誤導搜救行動

158
00:10:57,843 --> 00:11:01,923
‎有沒有可能這起事件也是這樣?

159
00:11:02,483 --> 00:11:04,683
‎我想知道是否能找到

160
00:11:04,683 --> 00:11:08,083
‎布萊恩和俄羅斯有關係的證據

161
00:11:12,723 --> 00:11:16,963
‎後來我發現
‎要找到俄羅斯和布萊恩的關係很簡單

162
00:11:19,803 --> 00:11:22,643
‎我查到他的登記資料

163
00:11:22,643 --> 00:11:25,563
‎上面顯示他在1990年代早期

164
00:11:25,563 --> 00:11:29,163
‎和兩位來自俄羅斯中部的
‎合夥人開公司

165
00:11:30,003 --> 00:11:33,363
‎他在蘇聯解體時也在場

166
00:11:34,163 --> 00:11:36,963
‎他會說流利的俄文

167
00:11:36,963 --> 00:11:42,003
‎所以他和俄羅斯有幾十年的關係

168
00:11:45,803 --> 00:11:48,043
‎我高度懷疑

169
00:11:48,043 --> 00:11:53,443
‎傑夫懷斯會上Netflix
‎指控我是俄羅斯間諜

170
00:11:55,003 --> 00:11:57,123
‎他的指控毫無根據

171
00:11:57,123 --> 00:12:01,003
‎他也知道這是非常嚴重的誹謗

172
00:12:03,963 --> 00:12:09,003
‎我第一次聽說布萊恩的事
‎是在他發現第一塊殘骸的時候

173
00:12:10,203 --> 00:12:12,163
‎這故事很有趣

174
00:12:12,163 --> 00:12:16,283
‎他坐上船,停靠在海灘上猜想
‎“也許那裡有殘骸”

175
00:12:16,283 --> 00:12:18,683
‎他在海灘上待了兩小時就找到殘骸

176
00:12:19,843 --> 00:12:23,523
‎碰巧的是,所有英文媒體也在那裡

177
00:12:26,043 --> 00:12:26,883
‎奇不奇怪?

178
00:12:27,403 --> 00:12:32,523
‎真巧!就在荒郊野外
‎空無一人的海灘上

179
00:12:34,083 --> 00:12:35,403
‎那是布萊恩的故事

180
00:12:36,443 --> 00:12:40,603
‎我被人說是醜陋不堪的惡棍

181
00:12:40,603 --> 00:12:43,483
‎太荒謬了,簡直可笑

182
00:12:43,483 --> 00:12:46,483
‎我被指控為美國間諜

183
00:12:46,483 --> 00:12:48,003
‎俄羅斯間諜

184
00:12:48,003 --> 00:12:49,643
‎中國間諜

185
00:12:49,643 --> 00:12:52,083
‎跨國器官販賣分子

186
00:12:52,083 --> 00:12:54,323
‎跨國賣淫分子

187
00:12:54,323 --> 00:12:55,763
‎什麼稱呼都有

188
00:12:55,763 --> 00:12:58,163
‎實在有夠誇張

189
00:13:02,123 --> 00:13:04,923
‎我確實沒有任何證據

190
00:13:04,923 --> 00:13:08,323
‎能證明他和俄羅斯軍情局有關聯

191
00:13:08,323 --> 00:13:10,323
‎或是假裝發現殘骸

192
00:13:12,043 --> 00:13:15,523
‎但我不是唯一懷疑布萊恩的人

193
00:13:18,683 --> 00:13:22,363
‎(法國巴黎)

194
00:13:28,043 --> 00:13:32,363
‎布萊恩吉布森
‎成為非洲東岸的殘骸之王

195
00:13:32,883 --> 00:13:37,283
‎但我說什麼也不相信他的發現,沒錯

196
00:13:37,283 --> 00:13:38,643
‎(作家、調查記者 陳翡)

197
00:13:40,203 --> 00:13:43,243
‎看看澳洲關於殘骸的報導

198
00:13:43,243 --> 00:13:45,723
‎報導指出這些殘骸

199
00:13:45,723 --> 00:13:50,363
‎極有可能是MH370的一部分

200
00:13:50,363 --> 00:13:52,883
‎“極有可能”基本上代表著

201
00:13:52,883 --> 00:13:57,603
‎他們不能證明那是MH370的一部分

202
00:13:57,603 --> 00:14:02,963
‎所以他們只能猜測其可能性
‎因為它看起來像飛機零件

203
00:14:05,923 --> 00:14:07,283
‎但儘管如此

204
00:14:08,003 --> 00:14:14,283
‎有關當局確認襟副翼是MH370的零件

205
00:14:14,883 --> 00:14:20,123
‎這是在留尼汪島海灘
‎發現的第一塊殘骸

206
00:14:20,963 --> 00:14:25,843
‎所以我很想進一步研究

207
00:14:27,083 --> 00:14:30,083
‎我開始更深入地調查

208
00:14:30,083 --> 00:14:32,363
‎我在調查時

209
00:14:32,363 --> 00:14:35,163
‎得知的第一個內部消息

210
00:14:35,163 --> 00:14:38,243
‎是殘骸少了辨識牌

211
00:14:40,323 --> 00:14:41,523
‎(缺少辨識牌)

212
00:14:41,523 --> 00:14:42,883
‎一個金屬零件

213
00:14:42,883 --> 00:14:48,323
‎以鉚接或特殊的黏著劑附著在上面

214
00:14:48,323 --> 00:14:54,403
‎那顯然能夠承受各種壓力

215
00:14:54,403 --> 00:14:57,643
‎大氣、濕度、熱、冷

216
00:15:00,523 --> 00:15:03,843
‎我發現只有在一種情況下

217
00:15:03,843 --> 00:15:08,563
‎辨識牌才會脫離飛機零件

218
00:15:08,563 --> 00:15:12,603
‎那就是飛機被解體

219
00:15:14,683 --> 00:15:18,483
‎辨識牌不見是巨大的危險訊號

220
00:15:19,163 --> 00:15:22,523
‎那應該要馬上讓人聯想到

221
00:15:22,523 --> 00:15:25,683
‎“這一定是來自被解體的飛機”

222
00:15:28,403 --> 00:15:32,443
‎調查人員發現上面沒有辨識牌時

223
00:15:32,443 --> 00:15:37,123
‎他們說:“沒關係
‎我們會找到其他編號

224
00:15:37,123 --> 00:15:42,363
‎終究會幫我們辨認出殘骸從哪裡來”

225
00:15:42,363 --> 00:15:46,123
‎聽說襟副翼有幾組序號

226
00:15:46,123 --> 00:15:48,843
‎被送去製造商那裡

227
00:15:48,843 --> 00:15:53,003
‎試圖在工廠紀錄中找出對應序號

228
00:15:54,523 --> 00:15:57,883
‎我從調查的內部消息得知

229
00:15:57,883 --> 00:16:00,283
‎他們傳了十二組號碼

230
00:16:00,883 --> 00:16:02,523
{\an8}‎而在這十二組序號當中

231
00:16:02,523 --> 00:16:06,763
{\an8}‎只有一組序號吻合

232
00:16:08,523 --> 00:16:09,763
‎只有一組?

233
00:16:11,123 --> 00:16:14,923
‎我聽了脫口說出:“什麼?”

234
00:16:14,923 --> 00:16:19,963
‎這根本不足以毫無懷疑地證明

235
00:16:19,963 --> 00:16:23,763
‎這個襟副翼就是MH370的零件

236
00:16:26,803 --> 00:16:28,403
‎但儘管如此

237
00:16:29,163 --> 00:16:31,643
‎襟副翼被證實

238
00:16:32,683 --> 00:16:35,123
‎是MH370的一部分

239
00:16:35,763 --> 00:16:42,083
‎國際專家團隊最終證實

240
00:16:42,083 --> 00:16:47,483
‎那塊飛機殘骸的確來自MH370

241
00:16:48,603 --> 00:16:51,443
‎殘骸和飛機之間的關聯...

242
00:16:52,883 --> 00:16:55,003
‎看看我們得知的消息

243
00:16:55,003 --> 00:16:59,003
‎證據非常微薄
‎“這和那架飛機用一樣的油漆”

244
00:16:59,003 --> 00:17:01,363
‎(取樣油漆)

245
00:17:01,363 --> 00:17:02,763
‎他們還告訴我們

246
00:17:02,763 --> 00:17:06,443
‎“那是該地區唯一的墜機事件
‎所以一定是那架飛機”

247
00:17:10,123 --> 00:17:14,923
‎飛機與殘骸之間有關聯的證據

248
00:17:14,923 --> 00:17:18,003
‎一點說服力也沒有

249
00:17:24,043 --> 00:17:26,403
‎(2016年12月2日)

250
00:17:26,403 --> 00:17:29,203
‎(最後一次聯繫在1000天前)

251
00:17:31,203 --> 00:17:35,403
‎(印度洋馬達加斯加)

252
00:17:42,763 --> 00:17:46,123
‎距離MH370失蹤已經過了一千個日子

253
00:17:46,643 --> 00:17:50,363
‎我們決定跟布萊恩
‎一同前往馬達加斯加

254
00:17:53,323 --> 00:17:56,403
{\an8}‎布萊恩發現殘骸的事帶來一些激勵

255
00:17:57,883 --> 00:18:00,123
‎許多人不喜歡布萊恩

256
00:18:00,123 --> 00:18:01,123
‎但就我個人而言

257
00:18:01,123 --> 00:18:05,203
‎他總是很尊重家屬和我們的需求

258
00:18:06,923 --> 00:18:10,323
‎我認為這麼對待布萊恩是不公平的

259
00:18:10,323 --> 00:18:13,203
‎我相信他的意圖是好的

260
00:18:13,203 --> 00:18:18,483
‎如果他想繼續找下去,我很樂見

261
00:18:18,483 --> 00:18:21,203
‎願上帝保佑布萊恩

262
00:18:26,003 --> 00:18:29,723
‎我們370乘客的家屬
‎親自到馬達加斯加

263
00:18:31,683 --> 00:18:33,283
‎去尋找殘骸的時候

264
00:18:36,923 --> 00:18:40,203
‎我覺得是有多種的感情在裡面

265
00:18:44,603 --> 00:18:47,283
‎一種悲哀...

266
00:18:48,883 --> 00:18:50,243
‎一種憤怒...

267
00:18:53,723 --> 00:18:54,723
‎一種...

268
00:18:54,723 --> 00:18:57,123
‎(MH370乘客兒子 姜輝)

269
00:18:57,123 --> 00:18:58,043
‎...恐懼

270
00:19:00,883 --> 00:19:02,483
‎還有一種...

271
00:19:04,603 --> 00:19:06,123
‎對我母親的一種...

272
00:19:08,323 --> 00:19:09,163
‎思念

273
00:19:09,163 --> 00:19:10,083
‎姜輝

274
00:19:11,883 --> 00:19:13,643
‎-同一個地方
‎-同一個地方

275
00:19:13,643 --> 00:19:15,643
‎MH370海灣

276
00:19:21,723 --> 00:19:22,563
‎這是一樣的

277
00:19:24,083 --> 00:19:26,643
‎當我手裡拿著那塊殘骸的時候

278
00:19:27,283 --> 00:19:28,243
‎我想

279
00:19:29,403 --> 00:19:32,123
‎這個東西可能是我

280
00:19:32,963 --> 00:19:36,603
‎距離我母親最後那段時間最近的東西

281
00:19:38,043 --> 00:19:40,323
‎這塊碎片很有意思

282
00:19:40,323 --> 00:19:41,443
‎對啊

283
00:20:04,723 --> 00:20:06,443
‎過去兩年來

284
00:20:06,443 --> 00:20:11,283
‎根據英國公司
‎國際海事衛星組織的衛星影像

285
00:20:11,283 --> 00:20:15,163
‎政府出動大批人馬
‎到最有可能失事的地點搜索

286
00:20:15,923 --> 00:20:21,003
‎南印度洋12萬平方公里區域

287
00:20:21,003 --> 00:20:23,683
‎但尚未在那裡發現任何東西

288
00:20:25,323 --> 00:20:28,323
‎搜尋持續了很長一段時間

289
00:20:29,763 --> 00:20:32,283
‎我們搜尋了兩年多

290
00:20:33,763 --> 00:20:35,443
‎但我們搜尋得越久

291
00:20:35,443 --> 00:20:39,883
‎我們越有信心找到

292
00:20:42,283 --> 00:20:43,803
‎我見過家屬

293
00:20:43,803 --> 00:20:46,763
{\an8}‎我完全能理解他們的遭遇

294
00:20:46,763 --> 00:20:47,803
{\an8}‎(彼得佛利)

295
00:20:47,803 --> 00:20:49,523
{\an8}‎而且...

296
00:20:49,523 --> 00:20:51,723
{\an8}‎我試著向他們保證

297
00:20:51,723 --> 00:20:57,403
‎我們會盡全力找到飛機
‎把他們的親人帶回家

298
00:20:59,323 --> 00:21:01,563
‎所以我們只需要堅持下去

299
00:21:02,243 --> 00:21:03,643
‎我們必須繼續

300
00:21:10,083 --> 00:21:13,003
‎也許他們真的想繼續搜索

301
00:21:13,003 --> 00:21:14,043
‎可是...

302
00:21:16,123 --> 00:21:19,683
‎不,他們絕對找不到飛機

303
00:21:19,683 --> 00:21:20,603
‎不可能

304
00:21:22,003 --> 00:21:23,323
‎飛機不在那裡

305
00:21:28,923 --> 00:21:31,283
‎到了這個時候,謎團還沒解開

306
00:21:31,283 --> 00:21:32,963
‎我們依舊不知道飛機怎麼了

307
00:21:34,123 --> 00:21:36,043
‎主嫌仍有可能是機長

308
00:21:36,043 --> 00:21:38,203
‎也有可能是劫機者

309
00:21:39,443 --> 00:21:43,363
‎接下來的消息可能會讓人大吃一驚

310
00:21:44,163 --> 00:21:46,483
‎出現了驚人的最新報告

311
00:21:46,483 --> 00:21:50,123
‎指出失事的MH370客機機長

312
00:21:50,123 --> 00:21:54,923
‎在飛機墜毀前一個月
‎曾在家中的飛行模擬器演練相同航線

313
00:21:54,923 --> 00:21:56,683
‎我們從一開始就知道

314
00:21:56,683 --> 00:22:00,883
‎機長家的地下室有飛行模擬器

315
00:22:00,883 --> 00:22:03,243
‎我錄了這支YouTube影片...

316
00:22:03,243 --> 00:22:05,803
‎許多航空公司的機師熱愛飛行

317
00:22:05,803 --> 00:22:09,963
‎所以扎哈里有飛行模擬器是很正常的

318
00:22:09,963 --> 00:22:13,163
‎但如果他在模擬器上飛的航線

319
00:22:13,923 --> 00:22:16,323
‎和飛機飛過的航線一模一樣

320
00:22:16,923 --> 00:22:19,163
‎很難想像他是清白的

321
00:22:20,363 --> 00:22:22,203
‎在調查過程中

322
00:22:22,203 --> 00:22:27,283
‎MH370機長的家用飛行模擬器硬碟

323
00:22:27,283 --> 00:22:31,763
{\an8}‎被調查員帶走,交給聯邦調查局

324
00:22:31,763 --> 00:22:35,163
{\an8}‎聯邦調查局對這些硬碟做了徹底分析

325
00:22:35,163 --> 00:22:38,003
{\an8}‎找到了數據點,根據這項...

326
00:22:38,003 --> 00:22:39,523
‎原來聯邦調查局

327
00:22:39,523 --> 00:22:43,323
‎早在取得模擬器數據後
‎就知道這項資訊

328
00:22:43,323 --> 00:22:45,723
‎但兩年後才在媒體上曝光

329
00:22:45,723 --> 00:22:50,163
‎黃線是假設的飛機飛行航線

330
00:22:50,163 --> 00:22:53,643
‎紅線是模擬器上的飛行航線

331
00:22:55,123 --> 00:22:57,603
‎模擬器的數據似乎顯示

332
00:22:57,603 --> 00:23:00,443
‎飛機沿著麻六甲海峽的航線飛行

333
00:23:01,043 --> 00:23:03,403
‎接著進入南印度洋

334
00:23:04,563 --> 00:23:05,443
‎直到

335
00:23:07,043 --> 00:23:08,123
‎燃料耗盡

336
00:23:11,483 --> 00:23:14,403
‎這可能是目前為止最有力的證據

337
00:23:14,403 --> 00:23:19,803
‎證據出來的時候,許多人目瞪口呆

338
00:23:19,803 --> 00:23:23,523
‎很多人認為這可能是犯罪證據

339
00:23:23,523 --> 00:23:28,563
‎(是機長幹的)

340
00:23:28,563 --> 00:23:29,843
‎但是...

341
00:23:29,843 --> 00:23:32,283
‎這不像表面上那樣

342
00:23:32,843 --> 00:23:35,843
‎對,模擬飛機飛越麻六甲海峽

343
00:23:35,843 --> 00:23:41,323
‎但飛機的地點似乎被人更改過

344
00:23:43,163 --> 00:23:46,843
‎他基本上只是移動游標,重新定位

345
00:23:46,843 --> 00:23:52,003
‎移到地圖上靠近南印度洋的地方

346
00:23:52,003 --> 00:23:54,763
‎他沒有真的飛進南印度洋

347
00:23:54,763 --> 00:23:57,363
‎他只是把游標放在南印度洋

348
00:23:57,363 --> 00:24:00,963
‎距離搜尋區有幾百公里遠

349
00:24:02,563 --> 00:24:07,523
‎這就像事件中的每件事一樣
‎你只看得到你想看的

350
00:24:07,523 --> 00:24:10,243
‎機師的模擬飛行航線...

351
00:24:10,243 --> 00:24:15,883
‎雖然我不認為
‎光憑模擬器數據就能作為證據

352
00:24:17,043 --> 00:24:21,883
‎但這和我們所知的事實有關聯

353
00:24:21,883 --> 00:24:23,643
‎而且,你知道的

354
00:24:23,643 --> 00:24:26,963
‎模擬飛行的最後階段

355
00:24:26,963 --> 00:24:30,043
‎在南印度洋耗盡燃料非常詭異

356
00:24:32,243 --> 00:24:34,723
‎模擬器數據不是謎團真相

357
00:24:34,723 --> 00:24:37,563
‎這只是剛好符合現況

358
00:24:38,043 --> 00:24:40,843
‎我們今早跟家屬聊過這個消息

359
00:24:40,843 --> 00:24:42,763
‎他們表示感到灰心

360
00:24:42,763 --> 00:24:44,283
‎事故發生的時候

361
00:24:44,283 --> 00:24:49,523
‎機師家中的飛行模擬器
‎被聯邦調查局扣押

362
00:24:50,643 --> 00:24:55,243
‎大家必須明白
‎聯邦調查局早就知道這個資訊

363
00:24:56,323 --> 00:24:57,923
‎接著在幾年後

364
00:24:57,923 --> 00:25:01,723
‎“對了!機師的飛行模擬器上
‎也有相同的航線”

365
00:25:03,923 --> 00:25:05,643
‎聯邦調查局脫不了關係

366
00:25:06,163 --> 00:25:09,843
‎對我來說,這再次證明
‎美國參與其中

367
00:25:10,963 --> 00:25:15,323
‎聯邦調查局從來沒有將任何資料
‎交給馬來西亞進行正式調查

368
00:25:15,323 --> 00:25:17,083
‎也沒有交給法國法官

369
00:25:17,083 --> 00:25:18,483
‎連一份報告都沒有

370
00:25:19,203 --> 00:25:21,483
‎所以我們想知道他們做了什麼

371
00:25:29,603 --> 00:25:34,403
‎聯邦調查局並不以透明文化著稱

372
00:25:35,163 --> 00:25:36,803
‎但在這起事件中...

373
00:25:36,803 --> 00:25:38,163
‎(基蘭的律師 瑪麗朵賽)

374
00:25:38,163 --> 00:25:42,643
‎...我指的是請求司法合作

375
00:25:42,643 --> 00:25:46,723
‎保密性對司法調查有益無害

376
00:25:48,763 --> 00:25:52,443
‎這種事件讓我覺得很可恥

377
00:25:53,083 --> 00:25:56,683
‎我們見證了這麼多惡意和沈默,真的

378
00:26:04,283 --> 00:26:06,163
‎我相信馬來西亞

379
00:26:06,163 --> 00:26:09,283
‎是事件中所謂的“傀儡”

380
00:26:12,363 --> 00:26:17,563
‎他們收到消息,卻悶不吭聲

381
00:26:18,643 --> 00:26:22,363
‎所以一開始主導調查的是美國

382
00:26:23,043 --> 00:26:28,283
‎找到飛機位置的是
‎英國國際海事衛星組織

383
00:26:29,283 --> 00:26:30,123
‎好吧

384
00:26:32,443 --> 00:26:34,403
‎主導搜尋行動的是澳洲

385
00:26:34,403 --> 00:26:35,963
‎大家都被排除在外

386
00:26:36,483 --> 00:26:38,203
‎“走開,這裡沒什麼好看的”

387
00:26:38,203 --> 00:26:39,123
‎什麼都沒有

388
00:26:39,763 --> 00:26:40,603
‎一無所獲

389
00:26:50,843 --> 00:26:55,723
‎身為記者,當然要相信政府當局

390
00:26:57,843 --> 00:27:03,443
‎第一個直覺是不要想像這些人在騙你

391
00:27:05,803 --> 00:27:07,723
‎但在我看來

392
00:27:07,723 --> 00:27:10,643
‎這種官方說法有問題

393
00:27:10,643 --> 00:27:13,723
‎他們說飛機在南印度洋墜毀

394
00:27:13,723 --> 00:27:17,723
‎還期待大家都相信這種說法

395
00:27:18,243 --> 00:27:23,043
‎問題是這種說法基本上沒有證據

396
00:27:24,723 --> 00:27:27,763
‎首先,假如官方的說法可信

397
00:27:27,763 --> 00:27:33,963
‎MH370飛越六個國家的領空

398
00:27:33,963 --> 00:27:40,723
‎分別是越南、泰國
‎馬來西亞、印尼、新加坡

399
00:27:40,723 --> 00:27:42,363
‎最後是澳洲

400
00:27:43,163 --> 00:27:45,643
‎但在這些國家之中

401
00:27:45,643 --> 00:27:50,003
‎沒有一個能提供

402
00:27:50,003 --> 00:27:55,443
‎MH370的雷達影像

403
00:27:57,403 --> 00:28:01,323
‎雖然馬來西亞宣稱

404
00:28:01,323 --> 00:28:05,083
‎“我們看到MH370掉頭”

405
00:28:07,283 --> 00:28:09,843
‎他們在事發一週後告訴我們

406
00:28:10,363 --> 00:28:16,163
‎“那天晚上我們的軍用雷達
‎看到那架飛機飛回馬來西亞”

407
00:28:16,683 --> 00:28:21,443
‎可是...我們沒有證據
‎證明馬來西亞當天晚上

408
00:28:21,443 --> 00:28:22,843
‎在雷達上看到飛機

409
00:28:22,843 --> 00:28:25,603
‎-實在太混亂了
‎-我不這麼認為

410
00:28:25,603 --> 00:28:28,763
‎就連關鍵元素也沒有附上證據

411
00:28:29,283 --> 00:28:32,283
‎既然他們隱瞞重要證據

412
00:28:32,283 --> 00:28:34,963
‎為什麼要相信官方的說法?

413
00:28:35,563 --> 00:28:36,603
‎不好意思,先生

414
00:28:41,923 --> 00:28:44,723
‎還有一件事,我覺得很有意思

415
00:28:44,723 --> 00:28:48,523
‎MH370應該會飛越

416
00:28:49,203 --> 00:28:52,763
‎皇家空軍北海基地

417
00:28:52,763 --> 00:28:55,643
‎該基地由澳洲指揮

418
00:29:01,803 --> 00:29:05,363
‎你怎麼能夠相信

419
00:29:06,283 --> 00:29:12,683
‎脫離航線的波音777飛越空軍基地

420
00:29:12,683 --> 00:29:18,363
‎沒有觸發戰鬥機出動

421
00:29:18,963 --> 00:29:21,083
‎前去攔截

422
00:29:21,083 --> 00:29:23,723
‎進入戒備狀態?

423
00:29:25,123 --> 00:29:26,603
‎沒有,完全沒有

424
00:29:28,003 --> 00:29:29,163
‎什麼也沒發生

425
00:29:30,523 --> 00:29:33,883
‎而這一切更是不可思議

426
00:29:33,883 --> 00:29:37,723
‎你要知道在那當下

427
00:29:39,043 --> 00:29:42,123
‎MH370消失的時候

428
00:29:42,843 --> 00:29:47,163
‎我們有兩次重要的軍事演習

429
00:29:47,163 --> 00:29:50,723
‎地點在中國南海,美國也有參與

430
00:29:58,803 --> 00:29:59,883
‎基本上

431
00:29:59,883 --> 00:30:05,163
‎軍事勢力集中在該地區

432
00:30:05,683 --> 00:30:07,723
‎這太難以置信了

433
00:30:07,723 --> 00:30:10,763
‎都這個年代了,還會有波音777失蹤

434
00:30:11,963 --> 00:30:15,843
‎更加難以置信的是失蹤地點

435
00:30:15,843 --> 00:30:20,563
‎竟然在世界上受到高度監控的地區

436
00:30:23,163 --> 00:30:27,843
‎這絲毫不可信

437
00:30:31,363 --> 00:30:34,763
‎所以我們唯一的依據

438
00:30:34,763 --> 00:30:37,523
‎判斷飛機在南印度洋墜毀

439
00:30:38,123 --> 00:30:42,483
‎是國際海事衛星組織的交握訊號

440
00:30:42,483 --> 00:30:43,963
‎(衛星位置與速度資訊)

441
00:30:43,963 --> 00:30:48,003
‎那麼要問的問題很明顯

442
00:30:48,003 --> 00:30:49,843
‎“國際海事衛星組織是誰?”

443
00:30:54,843 --> 00:30:56,083
‎耐人尋味的是

444
00:30:56,883 --> 00:31:01,643
‎國際海事衛星組織
‎有個負責政府業務的部門...

445
00:31:01,643 --> 00:31:04,043
‎(政府通訊網路服務)

446
00:31:04,043 --> 00:31:09,923
‎為世界強權國家的軍隊提供服務

447
00:31:11,563 --> 00:31:13,043
‎其中包括美國

448
00:31:14,803 --> 00:31:20,803
‎所以一旦瞭解國際海事衛星組織
‎和美國政府的關係

449
00:31:21,563 --> 00:31:24,603
‎這很難相信嗎?

450
00:31:24,603 --> 00:31:27,563
‎國際海事衛星組織提供的數據

451
00:31:27,563 --> 00:31:32,523
‎其實是設計好或捏造出來

452
00:31:32,523 --> 00:31:39,203
‎用來掩蓋MH370真實發生的事

453
00:31:44,283 --> 00:31:45,123
‎在我看來

454
00:31:45,643 --> 00:31:48,203
‎MH370沒有掉頭

455
00:31:49,923 --> 00:31:51,443
‎不管發生了什麼事

456
00:31:51,443 --> 00:31:53,923
‎都發生在中國南海

457
00:32:00,083 --> 00:32:02,763
‎我不是唯一這麼想的人

458
00:32:02,763 --> 00:32:06,243
‎(美國佛羅里達州)

459
00:32:09,083 --> 00:32:10,483
‎我很清楚我發現了什麼

460
00:32:10,483 --> 00:32:13,603
‎我知道證據就在中國南海

461
00:32:14,123 --> 00:32:16,843
‎我搜索越久,發現的殘骸越多

462
00:32:17,843 --> 00:32:21,443
‎所以我相信MH370的下落

463
00:32:21,443 --> 00:32:23,563
‎就在越南外海

464
00:32:25,043 --> 00:32:29,083
‎當時我已經聯絡過馬來西亞航空

465
00:32:30,203 --> 00:32:34,643
‎我試著聯繫很多人
‎告訴他們殘骸就在那裡

466
00:32:35,243 --> 00:32:36,883
‎偏偏沒有人要聽我的

467
00:32:38,523 --> 00:32:41,763
‎陳翡聯絡上我,我們討論了MH370

468
00:32:42,403 --> 00:32:45,803
‎我們交換了彼此的想法

469
00:32:47,323 --> 00:32:50,843
‎我跟她說:“別忘了,有鑽油工人

470
00:32:50,843 --> 00:32:53,523
‎宣稱他在當晚看到天空有火球”

471
00:32:54,683 --> 00:32:58,883
‎國泰航空的機師說
‎他們看到大片飛機殘骸

472
00:32:59,603 --> 00:33:01,163
‎他們後來怎麼了?

473
00:33:02,003 --> 00:33:03,683
‎證據在哪裡?

474
00:33:05,203 --> 00:33:08,843
‎我跟陳翡討論的時候
‎她說:“我跟幾個人聊過

475
00:33:08,843 --> 00:33:10,963
‎他們跟我說的都一樣”

476
00:33:13,083 --> 00:33:17,203
‎又有人告訴我

477
00:33:17,203 --> 00:33:21,963
‎一定有人刻意隱瞞那天晚上該地區

478
00:33:22,683 --> 00:33:24,763
‎實際發生的情況

479
00:33:28,963 --> 00:33:31,323
‎當時,我真的很想知道

480
00:33:31,323 --> 00:33:36,763
‎“究竟是什麼原因讓MH370成了

481
00:33:36,763 --> 00:33:40,843
‎民航史上最大的懸案?”

482
00:33:46,723 --> 00:33:49,403
‎我仔細研究了貨櫃

483
00:33:51,763 --> 00:33:54,483
‎我發現的東西很有趣

484
00:33:55,083 --> 00:33:59,523
‎是重達2.5噸的電子產品

485
00:34:00,123 --> 00:34:05,563
‎內容有對講機
‎無線電配件、小零件

486
00:34:07,243 --> 00:34:11,483
‎這個貨櫃是在被護送下

487
00:34:11,483 --> 00:34:18,003
‎於那天晚上運上MH370

488
00:34:19,523 --> 00:34:22,483
‎而且沒有經過儀器掃描

489
00:34:23,163 --> 00:34:25,283
‎我覺得這很奇怪

490
00:34:25,283 --> 00:34:27,443
‎(沒有可用的X光機)

491
00:34:27,443 --> 00:34:28,643
‎眾所皆知

492
00:34:28,643 --> 00:34:33,083
‎中國非常想要取得

493
00:34:33,083 --> 00:34:39,683
‎高度敏感的美國監視科技

494
00:34:39,683 --> 00:34:42,603
‎隱形無人機技術

495
00:34:43,443 --> 00:34:48,483
‎所以這極有可能是

496
00:34:48,483 --> 00:34:51,683
‎MH370事件的主因

497
00:34:54,523 --> 00:34:59,083
‎也許美國在最後一刻發現

498
00:34:59,083 --> 00:35:03,883
‎MH370載著有問題的貨櫃飛往中國

499
00:35:03,883 --> 00:35:10,843
‎於是想盡辦法阻止貨櫃抵達目的地

500
00:35:20,683 --> 00:35:23,523
‎我頓時想到基蘭跟我說過

501
00:35:24,123 --> 00:35:27,843
‎當時有兩架美國空中預警機

502
00:35:27,843 --> 00:35:31,323
‎(空中預警機
‎北約組織的“空中之眼”)

503
00:35:36,603 --> 00:35:40,883
‎我對這消息不知所措
‎直到我遇到一個人

504
00:35:40,883 --> 00:35:44,603
‎我們聊的話題跟MH370無關

505
00:35:47,843 --> 00:35:53,643
‎這位消息人士剛好是前美國空軍成員

506
00:35:54,923 --> 00:35:57,923
‎他說:“空中預警機啊”

507
00:35:59,443 --> 00:36:03,443
‎“它們的干擾能力很強”

508
00:36:04,803 --> 00:36:09,163
‎當下我立刻茅塞頓開

509
00:36:11,883 --> 00:36:14,923
‎因為我意識到空中預警機

510
00:36:14,923 --> 00:36:21,243
‎有能力完全干擾MH370的通訊系統

511
00:36:21,243 --> 00:36:27,323
‎讓它從飛航管制員的螢幕上消失

512
00:36:41,203 --> 00:36:43,443
‎現在我終於有了

513
00:36:43,443 --> 00:36:46,563
‎技術上的說明

514
00:36:46,563 --> 00:36:51,443
‎解釋MH370突然失蹤的方式與原因

515
00:36:52,003 --> 00:36:56,163
‎我試著將這些資訊統整起來

516
00:36:57,163 --> 00:37:01,563
‎整理出一個假設情境

517
00:37:01,563 --> 00:37:05,803
‎有關MH370可能遇到的情況

518
00:37:09,083 --> 00:37:13,163
‎(第三個推論:攔截)

519
00:37:16,923 --> 00:37:20,403
‎(2014年3月7日晚上11點20分)

520
00:37:29,403 --> 00:37:31,563
‎我們知道那天晚上

521
00:37:31,563 --> 00:37:35,323
‎這個極為神秘又可疑的貨櫃

522
00:37:36,043 --> 00:37:37,763
‎繞過掃描儀

523
00:37:38,523 --> 00:37:41,603
‎在被護送下運上飛機...

524
00:37:46,443 --> 00:37:49,363
‎放進MH370貨艙

525
00:37:54,323 --> 00:37:58,723
‎飛機按照計畫在12點41分起飛

526
00:38:09,283 --> 00:38:12,203
‎飛機爬升到巡航高度

527
00:38:14,243 --> 00:38:17,803
‎馬航370,維持350區域

528
00:38:22,003 --> 00:38:24,243
‎一切都很正常

529
00:38:35,203 --> 00:38:37,003
‎到了凌晨1點19分

530
00:38:37,003 --> 00:38:40,163
‎MH370收到指令

531
00:38:40,163 --> 00:38:43,443
‎向越南航管單位報到

532
00:38:44,683 --> 00:38:48,323
‎馬航370,聯絡胡志明市120.9

533
00:38:51,163 --> 00:38:57,203
‎機長札哈里說了著名的“晚安”後
‎就失去蹤影

534
00:38:57,203 --> 00:38:59,163
‎晚安,馬航370

535
00:39:04,603 --> 00:39:08,403
‎接著MH370進入了無人地帶

536
00:39:08,923 --> 00:39:13,923
‎這是攔截飛機最佳的時間點

537
00:39:19,203 --> 00:39:21,963
‎所以有可能在那一刻

538
00:39:22,563 --> 00:39:26,403
‎兩架美國空中預警機開始行動

539
00:39:27,323 --> 00:39:30,803
‎然後干擾了MH370的訊號...

540
00:39:38,003 --> 00:39:41,723
‎讓它從雷達上消失

541
00:39:48,043 --> 00:39:50,563
‎如今MH370不能與外界聯繫

542
00:39:52,443 --> 00:39:57,083
‎說不定它收到空中預警機的命令

543
00:39:57,083 --> 00:40:00,443
‎要它就近降落

544
00:40:04,243 --> 00:40:06,803
‎機長札哈里收到了命令

545
00:40:07,843 --> 00:40:10,403
‎他可能說了:“不”

546
00:40:12,203 --> 00:40:15,123
‎他不接受這個命令

547
00:40:22,363 --> 00:40:27,003
‎我認為他繼續按計畫的航線飛往北京

548
00:40:37,523 --> 00:40:41,643
‎機長札哈里拒絕服從命令後

549
00:40:42,323 --> 00:40:44,963
‎緊張氣氛繼續惡化

550
00:40:46,923 --> 00:40:51,563
‎最終,MH370接近中國領空

551
00:40:53,243 --> 00:40:57,043
‎此時空中預警機必須撤退

552
00:40:58,203 --> 00:41:00,843
‎儘管這麼做很可怕

553
00:41:00,843 --> 00:41:02,643
‎他們還是得阻止

554
00:41:02,643 --> 00:41:06,163
‎飛機和珍貴的貨櫃抵達北京

555
00:41:07,323 --> 00:41:08,163
‎於是

556
00:41:09,243 --> 00:41:11,523
‎要嘛用飛彈攻擊

557
00:41:12,083 --> 00:41:14,123
‎要嘛在半空中撞擊

558
00:41:14,763 --> 00:41:16,243
‎MH370...

559
00:41:18,163 --> 00:41:19,243
‎遭遇不幸

560
00:41:26,643 --> 00:41:31,683
‎我是第一個說這聽起來很牽強的人

561
00:41:32,203 --> 00:41:36,163
‎這個推論也有些瑕疵

562
00:41:36,883 --> 00:41:43,883
‎但我相信我比官方說法更接近真相

563
00:41:44,763 --> 00:41:48,963
‎我工作中最重要的部分就是證實

564
00:41:48,963 --> 00:41:52,683
‎官方說法是捏造的

565
00:42:06,043 --> 00:42:07,003
‎天啊

566
00:42:09,603 --> 00:42:14,203
‎我實在不想談陳翡或傑夫

567
00:42:14,203 --> 00:42:16,763
‎或是這些陰謀論者

568
00:42:16,763 --> 00:42:19,283
‎他們只會讓人分散注意力

569
00:42:22,043 --> 00:42:27,723
‎我一直看著像陳翡這樣的人
‎出書後得到大量關注

570
00:42:29,123 --> 00:42:30,803
‎上各種採訪

571
00:42:30,803 --> 00:42:32,323
‎有各種報紙報導

572
00:42:33,123 --> 00:42:37,083
‎這些人不太了解事實和數據

573
00:42:41,643 --> 00:42:44,243
‎有關國際海事衛星組織

574
00:42:44,243 --> 00:42:46,723
‎偽造或操控數據的指控

575
00:42:47,603 --> 00:42:49,123
‎簡直大錯特錯

576
00:42:49,123 --> 00:42:50,563
‎數據就是數據

577
00:42:51,563 --> 00:42:54,043
‎我不懂為什麼會有人認為

578
00:42:54,043 --> 00:42:58,043
‎我們會想操控或竄改相關資料

579
00:42:58,043 --> 00:43:02,283
‎這不是我們的作風
‎而且這種不實指控...

580
00:43:03,643 --> 00:43:06,523
‎我覺得很傷人...

581
00:43:07,523 --> 00:43:08,963
‎對,這影響了我

582
00:43:12,483 --> 00:43:16,883
‎這架飛機在中國南海被擊落的推論...

583
00:43:16,883 --> 00:43:17,803
‎不

584
00:43:17,803 --> 00:43:22,923
‎照這麼說來
‎殘骸會遍布中國南海,泰國灣...

585
00:43:23,603 --> 00:43:27,483
‎那也代表雷達的掉頭紀錄是錯的

586
00:43:27,483 --> 00:43:30,043
‎國際海事衛星組織的數據是錯的

587
00:43:30,043 --> 00:43:35,003
‎這基本上否認了所有證據

588
00:43:37,763 --> 00:43:40,843
‎沒有人能夠讓中國

589
00:43:40,843 --> 00:43:44,563
‎美國、澳洲、英國

590
00:43:44,563 --> 00:43:48,403
‎馬來西亞、越南,全串通起來

591
00:43:49,123 --> 00:43:52,123
‎策劃掩蓋飛機下落的陰謀

592
00:43:52,123 --> 00:43:53,963
‎那些國家不是盟友

593
00:43:55,043 --> 00:43:58,003
‎他們會洩密,他們會說出去

594
00:43:58,003 --> 00:44:00,123
‎這是不可能的

595
00:44:00,123 --> 00:44:01,803
‎並沒有這一回事

596
00:44:03,723 --> 00:44:05,163
‎我認為不幸的是

597
00:44:05,163 --> 00:44:09,803
‎有些人沉迷於
‎自己的理論和意圖有的沒的

598
00:44:09,803 --> 00:44:13,203
‎他們似乎失去了客觀性

599
00:44:13,203 --> 00:44:14,963
‎那樣很可悲

600
00:44:15,523 --> 00:44:18,403
‎傑夫懷斯來到現場
‎謝謝你來上節目

601
00:44:18,403 --> 00:44:21,123
‎你真的認為飛機去了哈薩克嗎?

602
00:44:21,123 --> 00:44:23,283
{\an8}‎冒著言論輕率的風險...

603
00:44:23,283 --> 00:44:26,003
{\an8}‎(彼得佛利)

604
00:44:26,003 --> 00:44:28,963
{\an8}‎...意見就像屁眼,每個人都有

605
00:44:32,043 --> 00:44:33,283
‎拜託把那段剪掉

606
00:44:34,043 --> 00:44:34,883
‎但這是真的

607
00:44:36,763 --> 00:44:40,723
‎我聽過各種理論和陰謀論

608
00:44:40,723 --> 00:44:44,123
‎我覺得這很令人惱火和反常

609
00:44:44,123 --> 00:44:45,563
‎這些人...

610
00:44:47,403 --> 00:44:49,283
‎證據就擺在眼前

611
00:44:49,283 --> 00:44:54,203
‎卻想出一些最詭異又瘋狂的陰謀論

612
00:44:56,483 --> 00:44:58,803
‎(2017年1月17日)

613
00:44:58,803 --> 00:45:00,523
‎(最後一次聯繫在2年10個月前)

614
00:45:00,523 --> 00:45:03,163
{\an8}‎三年前失蹤的馬航班機

615
00:45:03,163 --> 00:45:05,083
{\an8}‎搜索行動結束了

616
00:45:05,083 --> 00:45:08,523
{\an8}‎調查人員突然宣布正式暫停搜索

617
00:45:08,523 --> 00:45:11,603
{\an8}‎載有239名乘客的波音777客機

618
00:45:11,603 --> 00:45:14,963
‎我們得暫時停止搜索

619
00:45:14,963 --> 00:45:17,763
‎直到有進一步的可靠證據

620
00:45:20,363 --> 00:45:24,923
‎那對家屬來說
‎是個非常訝異、痛苦的時刻

621
00:45:24,923 --> 00:45:27,803
‎因為我們的希望都寄託在

622
00:45:27,803 --> 00:45:29,803
‎持續搜索行動上

623
00:45:29,803 --> 00:45:31,763
‎我感到痛不欲絕

624
00:45:31,763 --> 00:45:36,043
{\an8}‎家屬支援團體370之聲在聲明中表示

625
00:45:36,043 --> 00:45:40,163
{\an8}‎“不能任由商業客機
‎消失得無影無蹤”

626
00:45:40,763 --> 00:45:45,123
‎這麼久的搜索怎麼可能沒有結果?

627
00:45:47,483 --> 00:45:49,643
‎就連...結果是零,什麼都沒有

628
00:45:54,203 --> 00:45:56,603
‎我們感到很內疚

629
00:45:56,603 --> 00:46:00,883
‎這...我們投入了這麼久

630
00:46:05,883 --> 00:46:09,483
‎最後失敗...影響我們所有人

631
00:46:10,283 --> 00:46:11,323
‎我們很難過

632
00:46:12,283 --> 00:46:15,403
‎我們覺得我們讓家屬失望了

633
00:46:16,003 --> 00:46:18,203
‎(基於飛安考量,解開370謎題)

634
00:46:18,203 --> 00:46:20,523
{\an8}‎(為了更好的明天,今天展開搜索)

635
00:46:20,523 --> 00:46:25,523
‎除非找到那架飛機
‎否則我們永遠不會釋懷

636
00:46:26,603 --> 00:46:29,643
‎機上還有239個人

637
00:46:30,763 --> 00:46:32,003
‎需要回家

638
00:46:37,123 --> 00:46:38,083
‎(2017年1月17日)

639
00:46:40,803 --> 00:46:43,043
‎(2018年7月30日)

640
00:46:43,043 --> 00:46:46,523
‎(最後一次聯繫在4年4個月前)

641
00:46:53,683 --> 00:46:56,443
‎調查人員連夜發布了

642
00:46:56,443 --> 00:47:00,003
‎馬航370班機的失蹤報告

643
00:47:00,003 --> 00:47:03,723
‎調查小組表示波音777性能良好

644
00:47:04,683 --> 00:47:06,923
‎機師非常稱職

645
00:47:06,923 --> 00:47:10,003
‎沒有壓力大或行為改變的跡象

646
00:47:10,883 --> 00:47:15,723
‎他們也不能排除第三方的非法干涉

647
00:47:17,923 --> 00:47:21,003
‎我們無法確切地斷定

648
00:47:21,603 --> 00:47:27,403
‎飛機偏離飛行航線的原因

649
00:47:27,403 --> 00:47:30,563
{\an8}‎(安全調查報告)

650
00:47:33,683 --> 00:47:36,723
{\an8}‎(綜上所述,調查團隊無法確定)

651
00:47:36,723 --> 00:47:39,323
{\an8}‎(MH370失蹤真正的原因)

652
00:47:46,123 --> 00:47:51,003
‎我們每次來這種會議都感到很失望

653
00:47:51,003 --> 00:47:56,643
‎沒有人能回答我們的問題

654
00:47:58,643 --> 00:48:01,923
‎唯一的好事是

655
00:48:01,923 --> 00:48:07,283
‎他們不再指控機長札哈里

656
00:48:07,923 --> 00:48:09,723
‎是MH370墜毀的兇手

657
00:48:13,923 --> 00:48:14,883
‎到了最後

658
00:48:14,883 --> 00:48:19,003
‎就連官方調查小組
‎也沒有對機師提出指控

659
00:48:19,003 --> 00:48:20,483
‎他們不這麼說了

660
00:48:21,723 --> 00:48:24,563
‎唯一的結論是那不是機師幹的

661
00:48:24,563 --> 00:48:26,483
‎這顯然不是機師幹的

662
00:48:31,603 --> 00:48:34,643
‎所以馬來西亞官方調查結束了

663
00:48:36,683 --> 00:48:38,923
‎他們沒有答案,但還是結束了

664
00:48:42,843 --> 00:48:45,243
‎法國司法系統的優點是

665
00:48:45,243 --> 00:48:48,043
‎他們不能停,他們不准停下來

666
00:48:48,843 --> 00:48:53,763
‎直到他們找到真相
‎所以這很好,對我們也有用

667
00:48:53,763 --> 00:48:56,363
‎在找到答案前,我也不想停下來

668
00:48:57,163 --> 00:48:59,523
‎如果要花十年,那就花十年

669
00:49:17,603 --> 00:49:23,643
‎MH370事件
‎讓人為之狂熱的原因在於這無比重要

670
00:49:24,203 --> 00:49:26,683
‎我們說的是數百條人命

671
00:49:26,683 --> 00:49:30,603
‎和全世界的航空運輸系統

672
00:49:31,203 --> 00:49:32,603
‎所以這真的很重要

673
00:49:35,203 --> 00:49:38,203
‎MH370有讓我發瘋嗎?

674
00:49:39,363 --> 00:49:42,083
‎有啊!但它需要讓我發瘋

675
00:49:42,083 --> 00:49:44,603
‎這很重要,幸好它讓我發瘋

676
00:49:46,843 --> 00:49:48,123
‎合理的假設是

677
00:49:48,123 --> 00:49:51,523
‎MH370失蹤事件是蓄意行為

678
00:49:52,043 --> 00:49:54,643
‎其中一個謎題是“是誰幹的?”

679
00:49:56,643 --> 00:50:00,163
‎雖然我想知道答案
‎但我們可能永遠不會知道

680
00:50:01,323 --> 00:50:03,083
‎我們必須接受事實

681
00:50:07,443 --> 00:50:10,403
‎另一個謎題是“在哪裡?”

682
00:50:11,203 --> 00:50:16,563
‎這個問題會有明確的具體答案

683
00:50:19,483 --> 00:50:24,243
‎因為這架飛機的存在是具體事實

684
00:50:24,243 --> 00:50:25,723
‎它就在某處

685
00:50:26,363 --> 00:50:28,683
‎大家的目標都一樣

686
00:50:29,363 --> 00:50:31,963
‎大家都想找到MH370

687
00:50:38,723 --> 00:50:43,283
‎對於從那天起
‎就活在不安之中的家屬來說

688
00:50:43,283 --> 00:50:45,603
‎很不幸,這種被蒙在鼓裡的狀態

689
00:50:45,603 --> 00:50:48,603
‎在可預見的未來將持續下去

690
00:50:49,923 --> 00:50:52,363
‎我們得給家屬一個交代

691
00:50:52,363 --> 00:50:55,363
‎我們得給飛機乘客一個交代

692
00:50:56,043 --> 00:50:58,923
‎我們得證明飛機不會憑空消失

693
00:50:59,843 --> 00:51:02,403
‎我們欠他們證據

694
00:51:02,403 --> 00:51:04,603
‎我們欠他們解釋

695
00:51:04,603 --> 00:51:06,683
‎我們欠他們一個了結

696
00:51:16,763 --> 00:51:19,963
‎我不知道我能不能放下...

697
00:51:21,323 --> 00:51:24,443
‎但我會盡我所能繼續尋找我母親

698
00:51:24,443 --> 00:51:26,083
‎發現事情真相

699
00:51:30,683 --> 00:51:33,443
‎我相信外界有人

700
00:51:34,683 --> 00:51:37,483
‎知道某些內幕,知道事情真相

701
00:51:42,443 --> 00:51:44,883
‎我們還在這裡等待答案

702
00:51:45,963 --> 00:51:47,323
‎我們要答案

703
00:51:58,603 --> 00:52:02,723
‎很難想像我們會得知事情真相

704
00:52:05,683 --> 00:52:07,883
‎我從很久以前就向他保證

705
00:52:07,883 --> 00:52:10,843
‎我會帶他回家,我會找到他

706
00:52:12,003 --> 00:52:13,243
‎我還沒做到

707
00:52:14,523 --> 00:52:16,923
‎在我做到以前

708
00:52:18,483 --> 00:52:19,963
‎我不會善罷甘休

709
00:52:30,123 --> 00:52:33,403
‎對,我們仍懷抱希望
‎我們永遠不會放棄希望

710
00:52:33,403 --> 00:52:38,203
‎不管發生什麼事
‎我們絕不會放棄希望

711
00:52:39,723 --> 00:52:41,443
‎我們有權利知道真相

712
00:52:42,603 --> 00:52:45,363
‎我的孩子有權利知道

713
00:52:46,403 --> 00:52:47,243
‎真相

714
00:54:09,043 --> 00:54:12,363
‎字幕翻譯:張瀛