Downloaded from YTS.BZ
[solemn music playing]
Official YIFY movies site: YTS.BZ
[man] Going against a big company like Boeing does not happen every day.
[beeps]
[woman] Raise your right hand.
Do you solemnly swear the testimony you're about to give is the truth,
the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
I do.
Boeing will fight you to the bitter end.
So what he was instructing people to do was violate rules and regulations
that they could be actually held liable, criminally charged for.
We could very well be putting the public at risk.
The intensity of the implications of what he was testifying about
made me take a pause.
John was a brave guy for speaking out.
But I personally thought to myself that this shit could get somebody killed.
[thunder rumbles]
We were scheduled for John to continue the deposition the next morning.
[solemn music continues]
But at ten o'clock, John had not arrived yet.
So I called the hotel…
[phone ringing]
…and asked to be put through to his room.
And the phone just rang.
I asked if someone can go up
and do a check to see if he was still sleeping.
They said, "No, he's not there."
I asked, "Is his truck outside?"
And the manager came back on the phone and said she had gone out to his truck
and looked at him from the passenger side.
And that's when she called 911.
[solemn music fades]
-[siren wailing] -[dramatic music playing]
[reporter 1] Boeing has given the world yet another reason to fear flying.
Several of the company's new Dreamliner planes have caught on fire.
[reporter 2] One of the Boeing 777's engines failed minutes after takeoff.
[man] And this is my parents' house after a 777 engine blew up in the sky.
[reporter 3] A hundred and twenty-nine passengers were evacuated.
Five people were injured.
[reporter 4] Fifty injured after a flight lost control midair.
[reporter 5] One passenger was killed from an explosion.
[reporter 6] These are incredibly dangerous things that continue to happen.
[reporter 7] When you see news story after news story, incident after incident,
you wonder how Boeing is still in the air.
[dramatic music continues]
[music fades]
I'm that kid that still looks up at airplanes every time I hear one.
"Oh my God!" [chuckles] Yeah.
I always loved aviation.
[intriguing music playing]
My dad worked on a F-14.
So I always would go to the gates and watch the airplanes fly off.
Growing up in the Seattle area, I always thought
that I would eventually work at Boeing.
I was very happy when Boeing recruited me out of school.
Boeing was a fantastic company.
If you had your Boeing shirt on, people would come up to you and talk to you.
It was just a sense of pride.
[engine rumbles]
[launch announcer] We have ignition. We have liftoff.
[man 1] I was a rocket scientist for a long time,
but I wanted to move to airplanes.
And I wanted to work
in the best airplane manufacturer in the world.
[reporter 1] Over a century, Boeing transformed travel across the globe.
[reporter 2] The biggest aerospace company in the world.
Really, I was proud working for Boeing.
I'm still proud working for Boeing.
[man 2] Boeing changed my life.
We were really poor growing up.
And the financial trajectory just totally changed.
Working at Boeing, to have a job there, it was really a badge of honor.
[dramatic music playing]
[narrator] This is Boeing. They build airplanes.
And always there is one idea,
make everything just a little better than it really needs to be.
[Meyers] Boeing Company was very unique in that if there was ever a dispute,
the quality department made the final decision
as to whether or not to sign off on the work.
-[man] Okay, so we're ready to go, right? -Yes.
You had, like, two or three eyes on everything that you did
to just make sure it was accurate.
I don't think that's gonna work. I really don't.
[Mohawk] Back in those days, quality was the brakes of the system.
If there was a problem, quality managers stopped the line.
Management had your back.
-Have the guys stand by till we're ready. -Okay.
-[drill whirs] -[dramatic music continues]
Then all of a sudden, that whole atmosphere changed.
So what is it like to be the CEO? To arrive? What's day one there?
What did you find when you arrived at Boeing?
The approach was to start at the beginning.
That the culture needed a ground-up discussion.
-[continues indistinctly] -[man 1] The decline of Boeing.
You can trace a lot of it right back to the hiring of the CEO, Jim McNerney.
He seemed the perfect candidate.
He had gone to Yale to do his BA and gone to Harvard to do his MBA.
Jim McNerney looked like a U.S. senator from central casting.
[man 2] Jim McNerney was a long-time executive at General Electric
and a protégé of arguably the most influential CEO of the 20th century,
a man named Jack Welch.
I'm part, like so many others are, of an American dream.
[Gelles] Jack Welch was the first CEO of a major American company
to focus on maximizing profits at all costs.
He was quick to institute outsourcing, offshoring, mass layoffs.
[Welch] The best thing you can do to an employee,
as early as you know they're the bottom ten, let them know.
Famously, Jack Welch at GE would let the bottom 10% go every year.
Always have people nervous about their jobs.
[Gelles] With all of these strategies, Jack Welch turned GE
into the most valuable company in the world.
The kind of company that almost every other American corporation
looked up to.
And the Boeing board was no exception.
I knew I wanted to run something. I didn't know what it was.
[Gelles] When McNerney takes over, Boeing goes all in
on the Jack Welch-style "profits above all else."
[intriguing music playing]
He was also now tasked with developing a new airplane.
[reporter] The new 787 hasn't been built yet,
but Boeing is so certain of its creature comforts,
it calls it the Dreamliner.
[Gates] To design and build the 787,
it was going to cost approximately $10 billion.
But the Boeing board didn't want to spend that.
[computer beeps]
[printer buzzes]
A source gave me internal documents
showing that Boeing's plan was to build this plane for $5 billion,
half of what it would normally have cost.
[intriguing music continues]
[Meyers] Boeing was always known for the engineering
and the building of their airplanes.
The real big shift was during the 787.
We found out that they were going to be outsourcing
major sections of the airplane to save money.
[Irvin] Mid-body section was built in Italy.
[Salehpour] Wings and batteries from Japan.
[Meyers] From South Korea, wingtips and the aft fuselage parts.
The outsourcing was almost the entire airplane.
[Mohawk] You knew that was gonna have a direct effect on safety and quality.
We no longer have the immediate control about the safety of those parts.
We just have to accept what is given to us and put them on the airplane.
[Gates] Parts started coming in from these suppliers…
[solemn music playing]
…and the plan was the plane would be snapped together in three days.
The first time Boeing joined the two fuselage barrels together,
somebody sent me a picture.
-[camera clicking] -[solemn music continues]
There was a huge gap between the two.
The problem was that some of these companies
couldn't do what Boeing hired them to do.
They couldn't produce the parts they were supposed to produce.
It went horrible.
Too much of the airplane was outsourced.
Nothing snapped together.
And the delays were just one after the other.
So Boeing wanted to build a second 787 assembly line
in an effort to increase production.
[intriguing music playing]
Boeing had started in Seattle
and had never built a plane anywhere else.
[Gelles] This was a place where Boeing had
perhaps the most skilled aviation manufacturing workforce in the world.
But it was largely unionized.
And McNerney hated unions.
They cost Boeing more money.
And now in 2009, he's saying,
"Well, we're gonna build a second 787 line in South Carolina."
I am always proud to say we don't have unions in South Carolina
because we don't need unions in South Carolina.
[crowd applauding, cheering]
[Gelles] This was, again, Boeing leadership making decisions,
not in the name of safety but in the name of cost savings,
in the name of corporate profits.
What have you learned from your engineers
about bringing it back and reconstructing the old Boeing
that we all grew up with?
Well, we're not going back to the old Boeing.
-[man] Five, four, three, two, one. -[crowd] …two, one.
-[man] Cut! -[crowd cheers]
[Gates] When Boeing set up the plants in South Carolina,
there was no aviation business there.
And so, of course, they didn't have experienced workers.
They constantly were sending experts from the Seattle area.
[solemn music playing]
John Barnett was one of them.
[beeps]
When I first started with Boeing,
a group of us were standing around and talking about where you're from.
I was telling them that I'm from Louisiana.
One of my buddies popped off,
"Well, you're just an old swamp dog from Louisiana, ain't you?" [laughs]
You know, from then on, I was "Swampy."
[laughs]
I was a quality manager in Seattle for 15 years.
I was actually one of the first quality managers
brought down to Charleston to help set up the new Dreamliner site.
As a quality manager, it's my job to make sure the airplane's built right.
John was a solid quality man, an airplane man.
We were both quality managers.
We were good friends.
I used to buy gator tail by the pound from John
'cause he was a Louisiana boy.
[Barnett] Me being a Southern man,
South Carolina was my opportunity to get close to my family.
We always said he was loud and proud.
You knew when he walked in the room because he was loud. [laughs]
-Yeah, Swamp Dog. -[chuckles]
[man] When I moved to Charleston and met John Barnett,
I could see that we were from the same cloth,
that quality doesn't take a back seat to anything.
[intriguing music playing]
John and I really got to know each other through our recruitment trips.
We would interview in excess of 100 people in a week.
We were told from the beginning
they didn't want the union influence in Charleston.
And part of the agreement that Boeing made with South Carolina
was they would hire the majority of the employees locally.
We was doing job fairs.
We were hiring people straight out of college.
Pretty much we got to where if you knew what a screwdriver was,
you was hired by Boeing.
[man 1] What do you think about the people here?
[man 2] They fucking suck.
[man 1] They suck. Not everyone of course.
[man 2] Not everyone, but the majority of them here fucking suck.
[man 1] They're just punching a clock, that's my opinion.
[man 2] Yeah, it's all they do.
[Barnett] I went to my leadership and said,
"These people aren't being trained the way they should."
"Nothing about procedures, FAA requirements."
"They're just being trained how to rubber-stamp paperwork."
But my leadership, they didn't care about training.
They just wanted product pushed out the door.
Charleston had a workforce that simply didn't know how to construct
one of the most complicated machines in the world.
Mistakes started piling up almost immediately.
[solemn music playing]
[Seitz] I was walking through the production facility,
and I heard a very loud pounding.
[metallic pounding]
As I got closer, I witnessed a manager taking a sledgehammer
to pound a pin in a landing gear.
I thought to myself, I need to record what's going on here.
I took that camera and showed John Barnett.
[solemn music continues]
[Barnett] You don't use a sledgehammer to put together an airplane.
The fuse pin had to be just beat to hell.
And actually, back in the '90s, we had issues with those pins,
cracking from fatigue.
[reporter] The Israeli El Al jet slammed into the building Sunday
after two engines fell off.
Boeing, the company that built the jumbo jet, is now urging all airlines
to inspect the pins that hold the engines to the wings of 747s.
[Barnett] There's so many possibilities for fractures in that, it's unreal.
John said, "Man, you gotta take this to upper management."
I expected them to reprimand this manager and make it right.
Instead, I was instructed to get rid of the video.
[camera beeping]
[solemn music continues]
I was sent off-site to keep me from investigating what was going on.
It seemed like a way to tell us production is gonna move on
whether we wanted them to or not.
[McNerney] You've got to end up being better and reaching higher.
So it's not a matter of hanging around a hot tub
and everybody feeling good about the conversation.
Uh, there's an element of push, leadership, uh,
and stretch, uh, provided by the boss.
[tense music playing]
[Gates] Jim McNerney was laser-focused
on meeting the schedule at the lowest cost.
And so any delays in production were not to be countenanced.
[man] Here, everybody's being pushed to meet this fucking schedule,
regardless of quality.
[Irvin] If the airplane was not finished as quickly as possible,
it would hurt the manager's bonuses.
At the time, I was inspecting an airplane.
I saw a hole in the aft body join,
and the fastener that was in there was not the right size.
I had concerns with what I'd seen.
[tense music builds]
They've lost airplanes with fasteners like that.
I raised it to my quality manager,
and he said, "Mind your own business."
It was a major ass-chewing for anybody that would have stopped the process
to be able to fix a defect.
Those people would be in trouble.
[man] It's my pleasure to welcome you to the certification ceremony
for the Boeing 787 Dreamliner.
[crowd applauding]
[Gates] After the rollout of the Dreamliner,
Boeing was in financial trouble.
[pensive music playing]
And it didn't want to invest in another all-new design.
Because investing in a new plane is an awful lot of money.
[reporter 1] Boeing finds itself facing turbulence by a foreign rival
with some very big ambitions.
[reporter 2] Airbus has received the good-to-go.
The A320neo has the thumbs-up.
[Gates] Then Airbus announced it would put new fuel-efficient engines
on its most popular jet
that would save something like 20% of the fuel cost.
[reporter 2] Customers have ordered over 4,300 of the planes.
[reporter 3] Airbus has simply been cleaning Boeing's clock.
Jim McNerney freaked out.
They needed to develop a new airplane.
[Gates] Boeing was tending towards an all-new replacement for the 737.
But that would have taken years.
Jim McNerney made a really rushed decision.
[Gates] McNerney decided, "Let's just do the simple thing
and put new fuel-efficient engines on the existing 737."
And that becomes the 737 MAX.
[tense music playing]
[Gates] As soon as they announced this, it began to have really heavy sales.
[reporter 1] Massive order that Southwest Airlines will be placing.
[reporter 2] Lion Air Group has purchased 50 Boeing 737 MAX aircraft.
We've got an order book as far as the eye can see.
[reporter 1] Big relief for Boeing.
And that meant profits for shareholders.
-Jim McNerney. [chuckles] -Thank you.
[Gelles] And a lot of money for the CEO.
Ah!
[tense music continues]
[Gelles] In 2015, when Jim McNerney stepped down,
he'd made hundreds of millions of dollars
and took home many tens of millions in retirement.
I'm sure when he left, he thought, "Wow, I did a great job."
"Look at the stock price now."
[tense music crescendos, fades]
And because cost-cutting looked successful,
it was gonna continue to happen even after he left.
[tense music resumes]
[Gelles] When McNerney stepped down,
the board installed his hand-picked successor,
a man named Dennis Muilenburg.
[Gates] Before he took over, Muilenburg shadowed McNerney for 18 months.
And I think, in that time, McNerney pointed out to him
all these things he'd been doing that were so successful financially
and told him, "Keep it up."
So he did.
[man 1] Shares of Boeing continuing to soar.
[man 2] Were you surprised watching your stock price move up parabolically?
I don't say that I was surprised. We had promised production ramp-up.
We're now delivering on that ramp-up.
Which I guess deserves a higher multiple.
-That's what I'm thinking. -We'll talk a lot about commercial but…
When Muilenburg came in, I thought, "Well, nothing changes."
And actually, it gets worse.
[ominous music playing]
One day, I was called down to the Dreamliner.
We found all these metal slivers
on all this electronic wiring under the floorboard.
As they were installing the floorboards,
it's peeling the threads off of these fasteners.
Well, over time, this metal sliver's gonna vibrate down in there,
and it's gonna short wires out.
[electricity zapping]
It's been known that just a little short
will bring down a whole plane.
[whistling]
[ominous music builds]
[pilot] Swissair 111, we have smoke in the cockpit.
Uh, request immediate return.
[Barnett] Swissair Flight 111 had a chafed wire
in an entertainment system,
caused a fire and brought down the whole plane.
Killed everybody on board.
[reporter] We're about 6,000 feet, hovering above the wreckage.
[Barnett] TWA Flight 800 had a chafed wire in the fuel tanks,
blew it out of the sky.
[solemn music playing]
There's something like 20,000 of these fasteners
on a 787 Dreamliner.
We're looking at potentially 60,000 slivers
flying around on these wires.
So I brought it up to my boss.
And he said, "Ah, it's gonna cost too much and take too much time to clean it."
How much is it gonna cost and how much time is it gonna take
if one of these planes goes down with 350 people on board?
[solemn music continues]
I said, "I will not put my name on this airplane
saying it's safe and airworthy."
But they didn't want to hear it.
And after that, they moved me about every four or six months
just to mess with me.
And every time I'd move and get put in a different area,
I'd find some major issue.
[music fades]
[man 1] I just wanted to ask your opinion, man.
My in-laws are gonna fly on one of these.
Do you think they're safe?
[man 2] They're just your in-laws. [laughs]
[man 1] Would you fly on one?
[man 2] No.
[man 1] I got a free vacation.
[woman] What's that?
[man 1] You just have to fly on a 787.
-[woman] Shit. -[man 1] What?
[woman] No, we ain't going on no vacation on a 787.
You know what be going on on the 787?
[man 1] What happens?
[woman] What don't happen?
[man 3] I wouldn't fly on one of these planes. Because I see the quality
of the fucking shit going down around here.
[ominous music playing]
[Barnett] Charleston is the first plant I've ever heard
where the majority of the people working on the plane will not fly on it.
If your own people do not have enough confidence to fly on the product,
why are you letting it go out the door to the flying public?
[jet engines humming]
The Charleston plant, we thought, it's a totally different culture
than up here in Seattle.
But in 2015, the alarm bells went off
when I uncovered that some corroded 787 landing gear axles
that we had previously scrapped, spray-painted red with the word "scrap,"
wound up being used back in the Dreamliner production line.
These parts, they were basically rotted.
And as I started to research it, I found that scrap parts
were put back on the airplane for years and years.
[ominous music intensifies]
We'll never know the scope of how many of these parts made it to airplanes.
Boeing has delivered over 1,200 Dreamliners.
The fleet operates across more than 85 countries
with one billion passengers.
And so we had a corporate investigation launched.
Not one manager was fired or went to jail or got time off.
It's like it was just part of the business.
I don't know what it means for the thousands of planes flying around.
At this point, it's anyone's guess.
[music fades]
This new Boeing, the way they treat people and their quality managers
is ruining the entire company.
And that scares me.
Scares me to death.
[Stokes] John would come home worried.
He said, "You know, I just can't believe that they just don't understand."
I could see later on that it was starting to really get to him.
[Barnett] I had to seriously think about going to human resources,
because at Boeing, when you go to HR, now you're a target.
I knew from past history and other incidents
that chances are Boeing's gonna fire you on the spot.
They're gonna confiscate your computer. They're gonna confiscate your cell phone.
They're gonna confiscate all your documents.
So now you're a terminated employee
who gets blacklisted from an entire industry.
[solemn music playing]
So I'm scared of what they're gonna do.
But putting the flying public in danger, this is unacceptable.
I decided I'm going to just fight them.
So I went to human resources.
I told them they're violating procedures.
HR said, "Yep, you're right."
They wouldn't do anything to correct it.
So I filed an ethics complaint.
Nothing.
I wrote a letter to the VP of Corporate Ethics in Washington, D.C.
Executives didn't do anything.
I filed a complaint with OSHA.
I went to FAA, the Oversight Enforcement Organization,
to get these issues taken care of.
[solemn music continues]
It's like, does anybody care?
Or is it gonna take an airplane to go down before some people say,
"Wow, I guess we should have listened."
[woman] I remember waking up on the Sunday morning.
I had the two kids next to me, so I said, you know,
it would be nice for him to… to see a picture of the kids.
So I took a little selfie shot of… of the two kids
saying, "Good morning, Daddy," and, you know, lots of emojis.
[text message pops]
[swooshes]
I noticed that the message hadn't delivered,
which I thought was a little bit unusual.
But I put it down to maybe bad signal in… in Addis Ababa.
Mick was traveling, doing a lot of work with the United Nations.
He always had this desire to help people.
[pensive music playing]
A number of hours later, I picked up my phone,
and there was still no reply from him,
but there was a load of missed calls from… from a friend of mine.
[phone line ringing]
So I rang our friend, he said, "Naoise, have you seen the news?"
"There's been a plane crash."
And then he said, "I think Mick is on the plane."
And I said, "No. No."
[reporter] An Ethiopian Airlines flight has crashed shortly after takeoff,
killing all 157 passengers and crew thought to be on board.
[Naoise] It's like time stood still.
People don't just disappear from your life.
They're there one minute, and then they're not.
But that's what happened.
He wa… he was gone.
I suppose, being an engineer, that's where my brain kicked in,
and I started to research.
[somber music playing]
[reporter 1] Boeing faces a lot of safety questions this morning
because this is the second crash in just five months.
[reporter 2] The Lion Air flight crashed off the coast of Indonesia
with almost 200 people on board.
[people crying]
[Naoise] I learned this wasn't even the first MAX crash.
Brand-new planes falling from the sky, you know, twice.
How could this be?
I wanted answers.
[dramatic music playing]
[reporter 1] An emergency order grounding all Boeing MAX 8s and 9s.
[reporter 2] The FAA grounded the planes until their safe use has been confirmed.
[reporter 3] The focus in the two crashes quickly zeroed in
on a new system called MCAS.
[reporter 4] Powerful MCAS software can take over the plane's controls in flight.
[reporter 5] That left pilots powerless.
[reporter 6] Boeing withheld crucial information from the FAA,
its customers, and 737 MAX pilots.
[reporter 7] The FAA estimated that 15 more MAX planes
would crash over the next few decades.
Boeing and its CEO knew that the flawed system was a safety risk,
yet they told the public MAX was as safe as any airplane
that has ever flown the skies.
[Naoise] The more I learned, the more I realized
that everything was so wrong
and that we needed to push for justice.
[dramatic music continues]
My kids are aware that their dad got on a plane,
and the plane was made by bad guys.
My son asked me, "Will we catch the bad guys?"
And I said, "I don't know. We'll have to wait and see."
[music fades]
[Mohawk] After the 737 MAX crashes,
everyone in our factory was in a state of shock.
We take our work seriously, especially the work quality,
that we're signing off on a good product.
And I was devastated.
Um…
[somber music playing]
Can I get a sec? Sorry.
[Meyers] Emotionally, it was a dark cloud,
I think, for everybody.
[somber music continues]
Because what are we doing?
Why are we in this field?
And why do we rush?
[Mohawk] It impacts you.
Every day we spend doing our work, we're concerned for the flying public, so…
[emotional music playing]
[Meyers] We were upset about the families,
and especially watching them with the big pictures of their loved ones.
That's hard for anybody,
but a Boeing employee, that was very hard to watch.
[woman 1] My daughter was a humanitarian.
She had decided to dedicate her life to other people.
It was actually her first day of work.
[woman 2] Why did we have to wake up to get a call
that our two boys were on a plane that crashed?
[man] Our daughter, Samya, was headed to East Africa
on her way to start her career in public health.
What got me the angriest of all was reading the Boeing lawyers
saying that the families don't deserve, uh, compensation
for the pain and suffering that their loved ones went through.
They said it happened so fast,
the victims didn't know what was going on.
I think about their last six minutes a lot.
My wife and my mom-in-law knew they were going to die.
They had to somehow comfort the children during those final moments,
knowing they were all their last.
I wish I was there with them.
It never leaves me that my family's flesh is there in Ethiopia,
mixed with the soil, the jet fuel, and pieces of the aircraft.
[dramatic sting]
In the months after the second crash, Muilenburg is on the hot seat.
Finally, in December of 2019, Muilenburg is fired.
[solemn music playing]
But even though he had presided over two devastating crashes,
which had killed hundreds of people,
he made about $120 million as CEO
and left with a retirement package worth approximately $60 million.
He was immediately replaced
by the chairman of the board, Dave Calhoun.
Calhoun was a seasoned executive.
He'd been on the board for ten years at this point.
[reporter] Boeing entering a new era.
David Calhoun taking over as CEO. It happens today.
At the same time, there were multiple investigations.
The House was very aggressive.
We shouldn't have to have tragedies to change the rules
if the rules need to be changed.
We shouldn't have to be here today.
And the DOJ pursued a possible criminal case.
Nobody knew what legal consequences Boeing would face.
[music fades]
It was two years into the investigations of the MAX crashes,
I was in my mother-in-law's house,
and we were talking about Mick.
-[indistinct newscast] -The news was on in the background.
[reporter 1] We have some breaking news on Boeing.
Suddenly, Boeing is mentioned,
and you kind of stop in your tracks, and you're listening to it.
Boeing has entered into a deferred prosecution agreement
regarding the 737 MAX.
And I'm… I'm like, "What… what the hell? What… what's this?"
You know, "What's a deferred prosecution agreement?"
This charge will be essentially dismissed after three years
if Boeing meets all of the stipulations in this agreement.
This essentially ends the criminal investigation, if you will,
by the DOJ looking into what Boeing did.
And… and I went, no way, 346 lives lost.
Brand-new planes falling from the sky.
Somebody's got something wrong here. This can't be true.
[reporter 2] Does that also end any threats
to individual executives at Boeing?
[reporter 3] Apparently.
We'll get them to pay a fine. We'll tell them that they're on probation.
If after three years, you've been really, really good, you get a clean slate.
It's like it never happened.
The CEO should have been prosecuted.
Instead, they wrote that senior management
knew nothing about what was going on.
[reporter 3] There are a couple of terms within there
in terms of things that Boeing has to meet.
[Naoise] It is utter disbelief that somebody could get away
with killing 346 people.
This, it hurts.
[somber music playing]
[Meyers] We were upset about the plea deal.
It's not justice for these families.
[Irvin] It wasn't nearly severe enough for Boeing.
It's just checking the box and… and moving on.
[dramatic music playing]
[Mohawk] The fine's nothing to Boeing.
If there's actually people that are subject to jail time,
that'll stop their practices.
[Meyers] A lot of these government agencies think, "Oh my gosh,
you know, if we lead one of them out in handcuffs,
the whole company… the house of cards is gonna collapse."
No, you lead them out in handcuffs,
that's gonna make people start to think twice.
Until you hold people accountable, they will not change.
[music fades]
[Naoise] I had this feeling like I needed to do something.
[pensive music playing]
And there was a number of families
that were prepared to stand up and fight.
-[woman 1] Hi, hi. -[woman 2] Hello.
[Naoise] The only way we could go after the CEOs
was by proving that Boeing violated the terms
during their probationary period,
that they had failed to improve their safety standards.
And we had three years to do that.
[dramatic music playing]
[man] Our families, we meet every month online.
We keep track of what Boeing's safety failures have been.
There are always more.
[Naoise] There's a reporting procedure in America.
Every time there's a problem on an aircraft,
this goes into the system, and the public can view it.
[Stumo] Yesterday there was a MAX that declared an emergency in Rome
and another one that declared an emergency in India.
We were looking for patterns,
and there was a huge amount with brand-new aircraft.
Electrical problems, the pressurization problem,
52 bad stabilizer trim motors. These are critical safety systems.
[reporter 1] Boeing's had production issues with an aft bulkhead.
[reporter 2] Electrical problem with the instrument panel.
[reporter 3] One of the right engine fan blades was fractured.
[man 1] All of a sudden, we hear this loud explosion.
[reporter 4] A hole ripped open mid-flight in the roof of a Southwest Airlines--
[man 2] The FAA has given us a bulletin saying if you leave the engine anti-ice
when you're in clear air for five minutes or more,
the engine could actually come undone.
[dramatic music continues]
I'm flying with a Post-it note to remind me,
hey, turn that engine anti-ice off
'cause I have no other alert on the airplane.
And we realized that this wasn't just a software problem with the MAX aircraft.
There were enormous manufacturing problems.
We needed to find out what was happening in the Boeing factories.
[music fades]
[Seitz] John Barnett wanted nothing more
than to see a quality product go out the door.
But it seemed like he was getting pushback instead of support.
John raised up enough issues
and raised enough flags from inside the company
that they eventually decided to move him to somewhere
where he couldn't have that effect on the production system.
Seeing what John went through, it was upsetting.
[solemn music playing]
[Barnett] I had multiple managers berating me.
On my performance management review, I was downgraded
and my pay was docked for putting quality concerns in writing.
They said flat out they do not want anything in documentation
so they can maintain culpable deniability.
That's exact words.
Followed that up with what's called a corrective action plan.
And basically, you're about to get fired.
[solemn music continues]
The stress and the humiliation and the hostility towards me,
it just… it wore me down.
To have 30 years in an industry where you're looked at as a go-to guy,
and just the next day, you're just the scum of the organization…
How do you process that?
[solemn music continues]
So I ended up taking a retirement.
[music fades]
[birds chirping]
But after I left, I knew issues continued to exist.
That weighs heavy on my heart.
Maybe I should have went to the president of Boeing instead of just the VP.
I mean, you know, you can't help but think about those things.
You know, what could I have done different?
And I'm sitting there, I'm thinking, "What do I do now?"
And it was a choice of either "sit down, shut up"
or go outside of Boeing.
[contemplative music playing]
We're talking airplanes, we're talking people's lives,
we're talking the flying public.
I can't sit back and let that go.
[music continues]
And I wasn't gonna sit down, shut up.
[reporter] John Barnett says he spent 32 years with Boeing,
and he's blowing the whistle on where he works.
It's just all been about schedule and hurry up and just get it done,
push the planes out, we're behind schedule.
I know what's under the skin, and it's scary.
I just think it's critically important
that the activities going on within Boeing
are made aware to the people whose lives could be affected.
You know, I mean, look at the 737 MAX.
[sighs] Those lives and those families.
That's why I keep telling my story.
Somebody's got to step in and get it addressed.
[Naoise] As we continued to research,
we became aware that there was a small group of workers
that had come forward to say that there were manufacturing problems
at the Boeing factory,
that there was total chaos.
And some of them have reached out to us personally.
We've had the honor of working with many of you for several years now.
And there's been a lot of…
[Naoise] We started to be in contact a lot with whistleblowers.
We had kind of formed a group at this stage.
[indistinct chatter]
There was a number of meetings with them, some in person, then some online.
We couldn't just sit back and do nothing.
Because as families, we need to feel that our loved ones mattered.
But also because real justice and accountability
can prevent something from happening in the future.
[anticipatory music playing]
[woman] How long do you think we're gonna be there again?
-In the meeting? -Yeah.
Oh, another three, four hours.
[Naoise] And then we started having these meetings with the FAA.
[Stumo] The FAA is the Federal Aviation Administration.
Their job is to make sure
there's the safe design and manufacture of aircraft.
It has a large part of its duty to monitor and inspect Boeing.
[Naoise] This deferred prosecution agreement was going to expire
in about two years.
So every week we informed the FAA that there was still an awful lot of problems.
[Stumo] We're seeing continuing problems with brand-new aircraft
that you're not seeing with older aircraft.
It's just lunacy that it's not fixed.
[Naoise] And what they said at the time was,
"You don't need to worry about it."
"Boeing have changed their ways, and they're a fantastic company now."
[music fades]
We're gonna share all issues so that when things do go a little wrong,
we can get ahead of them with all of our employees and with the public.
[mellow music playing]
Many people had hopes that Calhoun would turn the company around.
CEO of Boeing, he mentioned the guidance…
[Mohawk] We need somebody to make a change.
Hopefully, he's the person that will make the change within our company.
[Meyers] Dave Calhoun committed to cleaning up processes.
[man] It reorganized its engineering organization.
It created a chief safety officer.
All these different tactical positions
that allowed them to… to make sure that this doesn't happen again.
[Mohawk] They started to create some kind of system
where leadership listened to what was going on on the floor.
[woman] Welcome to the Boeing Company's conference call.
[Calhoun] We will encourage and reward employees for speaking up
to slow things down if that's what's needed.
The Speak Up program was going to make it easy for employees
to identify ethical problems, bad behaviors,
and safety concerns to get quicker action.
Transparency is what we lost for a moment,
and it's something we have to regain
because it speaks to the trust that the world has in us.
[signal beeping]
Breaking news. Boeing's 737 MAX is allowed to fly again.
The FAA just lifted the grounding this morning.
[reporter 1] The company has worked to update the software, computers,
and pilot training for the MAX.
[man] You are flying on a Boeing 737 MAX.
[reporter 2] In this American Airlines cabin,
applause for a new chapter in 737 MAX safety
as the first domestic departure roared off the runway.
[Calhoun] I'm very proud of our team, and I'm very proud of that airplane.
It is a, uh, remarkable, uh, machine,
and… and as safe as anything… anything in the air.
[engine roaring]
[Gates] After the planes were ungrounded, I was convinced that the MAX was safe.
It was safe to fly.
[reporter 1] Big boost for Boeing and its 737 MAX.
[reporter 2] A multi-billion dollar order for Southwest Airlines.
[reporter 3] Ryanair ordered 75 MAXs.
[reporter 4] Looking to increase production of the 737 MAX.
[reporter 5] The rent and flight line tonight is very busy.
[reporter 3] Ryanair's CEO says the MAX
is now the safest plane in aviation history.
Once the MAX was back in the air, the whole atmosphere changed.
[mysterious music playing]
[Mohawk] Boeing went back to business as usual.
It's time to make money again.
Let's push these airplanes out and make that money.
Work exploded.
I was now responsible for, like, ten times the amount of airplanes
I'm usually responsible for.
[Meyers] It was a schedule-driven, chaotic rush again.
We were having a lot of problems.
We had counted about 50,000 parts that bypassed quality
that had escaped to the airplane.
A lot of flight-critical parts too.
So I reported this through the Speak Up program.
There are so many of my nonconformance records still open.
And that's usually because the part has gone missing.
Head of our material review board came up with the decision
to go ahead and delete those nonconformance records.
That was a criminal activity.
So the first thing I did was I went through the Speak Up system.
[mouse clicks]
We're seeing a lot of defects in these joint areas
where the parts are coming together.
I brought that up in a Speak Up.
But I don't think a whistleblower calls Speak Up more than once.
Because when we did, we were immediately retaliated against.
[train rattling]
My boss came to my desk and chewed me out, and he said,
"I would have killed someone who said what you said."
[tense music playing]
What did I say?
I said, we need to consider engineering fundamentals.
[Mohawk] They were trying to work me through a corrective action,
saying that I wasn't listening to leadership doing my job.
[Meyers] The ethics advisor called me
and said, "Merle, yeah, you're going to be singled out
and made an example of."
My senior manager said, "Here's 12 things that you're doing wrong,
and you have to correct these in 30 days, or I'll fire you."
"I started keeping documentation about safety concerns."
I was thinking, "I don't want to call the press."
Because we've seen with whistleblowing,
you lose your job, you lose your community.
[Mohawk] I was whistleblowing internally for a couple years,
but I never wanted to go public.
Because I'm just, at the end of the day, an employee.
I would have been crucified.
[Salehpour] A lot of my coworkers were really scared to come forward,
even within the company.
But when I see a problematic area that could cause loss of life,
I'm gonna speak up until my face is blue.
So I kept on following it.
And they finally just kicked me out of the Dreamliner program.
Then my tire was slashed.
I didn't know who did it, but I think that was a warning call.
Things are a little more serious than what you want to be.
It threw me off.
I was waking up with, uh, nightmares three o'clock every morning.
And I was talking to three different psychologists at the time,
to just be able to cope with it.
[somber music playing]
[Irvin] There's a lot of lives at stake.
I would have nightmares of airplanes crashing very close to me.
I've had airplanes crash so close to me, I can feel the heat from them in my sleep.
[Mohawk] That keeps me up at night.
I hope there's not another MAX airplane loss,
but it does keep me up at night.
Just losing battle after battle, and betrayed over and over again.
It just is gonna weigh you down.
I felt helpless.
[Seitz] The workers would be more than happy
to speak out to the public,
but they're in fear of losing their jobs.
They have years to work.
They can't afford to be fired from their positions.
There's definitely a culture of fear.
[crickets chirping]
[boat engine rumbling]
After John left Boeing, he kept seeing all these problems,
and it really weighed on him.
So we filed the case.
John Barnett's case against Boeing involved exposure
to a hostile work environment,
with allegations of retaliation by Boeing against him.
He had been gaslighted
for years and years and years and years when he was there.
Mr. Barnett, you testified that, what did he say,
something about he was gonna break you?
-He was gonna push me until I broke. -[Boeing lawyer] Okay.
Was… Was he joking when he said that?
Oh, absolutely not.
[Turkewitz] We filed a complaint,
and we had to compel Boeing to produce documents.
It took forever to get responses from Boeing.
Whistleblower cases are very complicated cases.
Oftentimes, when whistleblowers go public, when they're terminated,
the employer takes possession of their laptops or their phones.
That means they have no evidence to back up.
It's just he said, she said.
[pensive music playing]
[Turkewitz] What really set John's situation apart from others
is that John had actually documented everything.
And he said that someday in the future,
there was gonna be a reckoning with Boeing,
and he was gonna have the proof to demonstrate where they failed.
[Boeing lawyer] Let's talk about the oxygen investigation.
Around July 2016, there was an issue with defective oxygen canisters.
-Is that correct? -Right.
[Boeing lawyer] You discovered that some of the oxygen squibs
were not properly dispensing oxygen.
[Barnett] We had about 15% that didn't initiate.
[Boeing lawyer] You had just performed kind of informal tests
and had come up with this 15% failure rate, correct?
No, it really wasn't an informal test.
-I said, "We need to take a closer look." -[Boeing lawyer] Mm-hmm.
[Barnett] So I actually pulled fresh squibs out of stores,
still in the packages,
and we sent that control group.
The failure rate actually went up to 25%.
That set off all kinds of alarms,
and I was like, "Okay, this is a serious issue."
Say you're flying at 40,000 feet, and for some reason,
you have a massive decompression, and the oxygen masks drop.
[alert dinging]
You have 20 seconds to get your mask on
before it starts getting into lack of oxygen,
and it'll actually create brain damage and, in some cases, even death.
[clock beeping]
Imagine you're not getting oxygen.
Say you're sitting there with your kids.
Who gets the oxygen? Who don't?
-[pensive music playing] -[zapping]
[Boeing lawyer] During the course of you documenting
the issue with the oxygen squibs,
no one criticized you for documenting that issue, correct?
Actually, we do have an email.
Pretty nasty.
He's like, just stop the madness.
That's the kind of attitude he had.
[Boeing lawyer] Mm-hmm. We didn't see that in any of the emails we just looked at.
-Not these, but you have my copies, yes. -[Boeing lawyer] Okay. Okay.
[Turkewitz] John used to say that it takes 8, 10, 12 years
for those defects to manifest.
So he was really concerned about these problems,
that they would manifest down the road and cause a disaster.
[Naoise] The three-year probation from the Department of Justice
was going to expire in a month.
That was kind of a mental process,
a psychological process we were all going through.
[somber music playing]
The meetings had gone on for months and months.
I even flew to Washington to sit down with the Department of Justice
to explain our concerns that nothing had changed
in the Boeing culture and in the Boeing factories.
We sat down with the head of the fraud section, Glenn Leon.
Then he started to read from a script.
And if we said, "Hang on a sec, what about what we have to say?"
he might huff and puff a bit.
And then he carried on as though we hadn't said anything.
It very much seemed like the Department of Justice
was trying to protect Boeing.
[contemplative music playing]
[cameras clicking]
We go to these courtrooms, and the DOJ and the Boeing lawyers
are on one side of the courtroom talking to each other,
and we're on the other side.
It's like we're the criminals.
[Naoise] When you see the number of lawyers that have passed
from Boeing into the Department of Justice
and from the Department of Justice into the Boeing law firm,
it is complete political entanglement.
Now the deferred prosecution agreement was about to expire.
There was no hope. There was no justice.
There was never going to be accountability.
Forget it. Go home.
[man 1] It doesn't seem that the DOJ is interested in getting the criminals out.
They're interested in getting this case behind them any way they can.
And they're gonna allow the criminals to stay in and do what.
And a lesson will never be learned by anybody.
[man 2] Right now, we are showing
that there are countless issues with production quality matters.
When is the next crash gonna be?
I hope it doesn't happen.
But this is what we're dealing with.
[pensive music playing]
[pilot over radio] Ground, Alaska 1282, push up Charlie 7 North Yankee.
[air traffic controller] Pushback's approved, 2-8 Left.
[passenger 1] It was a typical start-up, taxi, takeoff.
[air traffic controller] Alaska 1282. Runway 2-8 Left. Cleared to take off.
[pilot] Good day, Alaska 1282.
[passenger 2] My daughter pulled out all sorts of sketching materials
as the flight took off.
[passenger 1] My son was sitting on my lap.
My 3-year-old was in the middle.
And then my 5-year-old was in the window seat.
[passenger 2] We're climbing.
I remember looking over
and just kind of wanting to see how my family was doing.
[pilot] Seattle, Alaska 1282, 11,000 climbing 15,000.
[air traffic controller] Alaska 1282, Seattle Center,
climb and maintain level of 2-3-0.
[high-pitched whistling]
[passenger 2] There was a high-pitched whistling sound and then a boom.
[loud bang]
[alarms blaring]
[pilot] 1282, we are declaring an emergency.
We are descending down to 10,000--
[continues indistinctly]
[engine roaring]
[passenger 1] Almost instantly, oxygen masks dropped,
and I realized there was something really wrong.
[pilot] We're about to go down.
[passenger 2] I immediately am disoriented but quickly turn my head, and I see…
[whooshing]
…open sky.
I was just absolutely in shock.
[passenger 1] I stuck my 1-year-old's legs in between my legs,
and I pinned him down.
He was screaming the whole time.
[wind whooshing]
[passenger 3] When I got the mask on, there was no airflow.
Tried to breathe again. There was no oxygen.
[tense music playing]
[passenger 2] And I was looking over at my daughter,
seeing her hair being pulled back.
She was two rows in front of that opening.
We thought that the next panel was going to fail
and that we were not gonna make it out of that flight alive.
[passenger 1] The oxygen had depleted.
We started getting that dizzy feeling again,
and my vision started clouding.
Both my daughters were looking at me just afraid.
I hadn't told them it was going to be okay because I didn't know.
[passenger 2] I was assuming that I had minutes with my family.
So I'm reaching over, and I put my hand on my wife's back.
And I just begin to pray.
[passenger 3] I send a text to my son to say goodbye.
Let him know he's been the best thing that's ever happened to me.
[tense music continues]
[passenger 1] I looked out the window, and the plane dipped under the clouds.
And we could breathe again.
I was able to look at my kids and say, "It's gonna be okay."
[airplane landing]
[announcer] We begin with breaking news.
[newscaster] That breaking news is out of Oregon.
And take a look at this.
Video from inside an airliner still in the air
after a large section of its fuselage blew out during the flight.
[pensive music playing]
[Gates] When the Alaska incident occurred,
I was just gathering information like everyone else.
I didn't know what had happened.
[Ostrower] I was in my kitchen and my phone blew up.
I knew something was very, very wrong.
[newscaster] National Transportation Safety Board are investigating this.
At cruise altitude, we could have lost the aircraft.
[reporter] The plane is a Boeing 737 MAX that had just been certified.
[Gates] What blew off was what's called a door plug.
It's not an actual door,
but there is an opening there that some airlines put an extra door in.
[Ostrower] I called a close contact at Boeing and told them,
"This is the kind of stuff that grounds airplanes."
[reporter 1] The FAA grounded all 737 MAX 9s in the U.S.
[reporter 2] Saying what happened is likely to exist
or develop in other planes.
[reporter 3] Boeing denied liability, saying its products were,
quote, "improperly maintained, or misused
by persons and/or entities other than Boeing."
Our job is to understand literally everything that has happened.
[woman] Boeing has not provided us with the documents
and information that we have requested numerous times over the past few months.
They talk about transparency,
but certainly, at least so far,
they're not being transparent about exactly what happened with that plug.
[Mohawk] I was not surprised by the door plug incident.
I've been fighting for a couple years,
knowing that something like that was gonna happen.
[mellow music playing]
I was just relieved that nobody died.
It was a nightmare just having that kind of failure.
I said to myself, "This is what happens if you don't hold people accountable."
When the door blowout happened and I saw that on the news,
I predicted exactly what they were gonna find during their investigation.
[music building]
[Gates] This panel blowing off the plane incident
was traced back to a quality lapse inside the factory.
[Ostrower] In 2023, an airplane is coming down the line
at Boeing's 737 plant near Seattle.
And it's the airplane that became Alaska 1282.
There's chaos elsewhere in the factory
as Boeing is trying to keep up with its own increased production
and dealing with outsourcing.
[Gates] The investigation discovered
that the door team at Boeing had taken off the door plug
in order to fix things that suppliers didn't get right.
To do so, they would have had to remove four retaining bolts.
[cranking]
And there was one photo in their preliminary report
that was very telling.
You could actually see three of the four corners of the door plug.
And the retaining bolts that were needed to secure it in place weren't there.
[tense music playing]
They were never put back.
Afterwards, that plane flew 154 flights.
And each time it landed or took off,
the vibrations shifted the door plug a little tiny bit
until, eventually, on January 5th of 2024, it blew out.
[loud bang]
[man] To date, we have still found no paperwork documenting
the removal of 8789's left-hand MED plug.
[Lund] That is correct.
Whoever did the work never recorded it.
Why not?
Probably because somebody wanted it done quickly.
There was a whole system here that was inadequate.
This was a close call, too close.
[reporter] On Capitol Hill today, the FAA chief said
Boeing quality control had clearly failed.
If you don't have that safety culture, it's hard to make safe airplanes.
[contemplative music playing]
[Naoise] Everything that we had been saying,
that Boeing's culture was broken
and that these defective planes are continuing to fly,
had just been proved correct.
That happened two days before
this deferred prosecution agreement was about to expire.
In a way, it's a miracle
because not only was no one killed,
now how could they say Boeing have been good during their probationary period?
They couldn't.
[newscaster] The Justice Department announced Boeing violated a 2021 agreement
that protected the company from any charges.
[reporter] Boeing has responded.
"We believe that we have honored the terms of that agreement."
The question now, though,
what does a potential punishment even look like for Boeing?
Nobody seems to know just yet.
It opened up everything again.
[pensive music playing]
The investigation by the DOJ and criminal prosecution.
Everything was back on the table.
[Boeing lawyer] In the days leading up to you leaving Boeing,
did you talk to anyone about the stress that you were experiencing at work?
[Barnett] I talked to my doctors.
[Boeing lawyer] What did your doctor say?
She said I was gonna have a heart attack and die,
or I could have a heart attack and die in that environment, yes.
[Boeing lawyer] She said, during this appointment,
you could have a heart attack and die if you don't leave work.
That's your testimony?
If I don't get out of that environment, yes.
[pensive music playing]
[birds chirping]
Can we take a few minutes?
[Turkewitz] Boeing's counsel took his deposition for a full seven hours.
John was really tired.
He said that he would like to go back home and resume his deposition at a later date.
Boeing objected to John's request.
By this stage,
John didn't want to do anything that was going to cause a delay in the trial,
and that he will just come back the next morning and we'd finish it up.
And he went back to his hotel.
[thunder rumbling]
The morning of Saturday, March 9th,
it was storming outside.
A lot of thunder, lightning, and really heavy rain.
By ten o'clock, we hadn't heard anything from John.
So when the rain slowed down, we all drove there.
[suspenseful music playing]
[Knowles] Our hopes as we drove to the hotel
was that we were gonna just find John having a medical situation
but that he was gonna be okay.
I was thinking he maybe had a really severe panic attack
or something like that.
But when we went inside the hotel,
the manager took us in the back,
and the first thing she said to us was, "I'm sorry for your loss."
It was really surprising and overwhelming and just a lot of emotion
when we're learning that they had found John in his truck
with a gunshot wound to the head.
The police detective believed it was most likely, uh, suicide.
[Turkewitz] We had a lot of questions,
and we wanted to make sure that the police did a full, complete investigation.
[Knowles] We wanted to see his cell phone content.
Any witnesses that they interviewed, I'd like to see those witness statements.
And did they fingerprint the outside of his truck?
A former employee of the U.S. plane maker Boeing,
who turned whistleblower, has been found dead.
[mysterious music playing]
[Stokes] I talked to him on the Monday before.
I asked him, I said, "When are you coming home?"
He said, "They put my meeting off, and so I have to stay here."
"I'll be so glad to get home."
He said, "I just want to get in my bed."
And we still have a lot of unanswered questions.
We just want to know what happened.
I was shocked.
Nobody wants to accept the fact that John would do this
so close to completing what he set out to accomplish,
bringing awareness to the fact that Boeing was overlooking quality.
He was at the finish line.
Um…
Being found in his truck like that, um,
you know, it just… it just didn't seem to us that
that was John… the John that we knew.
[beeping]
[Knowles] After that, things got very weird.
I mean, it was like jumping into an alternate universe.
[host] He was obviously under an enormous amount of scrutiny,
but was it enough to take his own life?
That's what everyone wants to know.
We're trying to nail down the timeline of John Barnett's death
and whether this was indeed a suicide.
People are raising their eyebrows.
[Knowles] People were saying that John had been killed
to silence others from speaking out.
[woman] He said, "But if anything happens to me, it's not suicide."
I know that he did not commit suicide.
There's no way.
[Watters] It just doesn't make sense.
Well, that's our feeling too.
And the Charleston City Police are investigating, and so is the coroner.
And we're just waiting for the police department and the coroner
to release a report on what they believe happened.
[tense music playing]
[Knowles] The atmosphere was just tense.
And even I started thinking,
you know, I'm not clear on what's really happened here.
[music fades]
[Meyers] When I had heard about John Barnett losing his life,
that was traumatic.
But what really got me angry
was finding out how he was treated by management for years,
'cause I could identify with that.
[pensive music playing]
I was furious.
They had their chance to fix all this, and they did nothing.
So I called The New York Times reporter.
I just said, use my name
and let people know I gave you Boeing documentation.
Going public was completely against my grain for the most part.
I… I'm not, you know, one that's drawn to a camera.
Roy Irvin is speaking publicly, on camera, for the first time.
John Barnett was a lighthouse.
When I first started at the company,
he was pointing people in the right direction.
He's continuing to do that now.
[Emerson] Roy is on a mission to finish what Barnett started.
I'm not John, but somebody needs to keep pushing.
[Seitz] My family has concerns about me taking part in this movie,
but I'm doing it for John.
[Salehpour exhales sharply] I was really scared.
But I promised myself I will be speaking up,
regardless of the consequences.
I'm here today because I felt that I must come forward.
I have serious concerns about the safety of the 787 and 777 aircraft.
And I'm willing to take on professional risk to talk about them.
[reporter] We've now learned there is a new whistleblower
named Sam Mohawk.
[Mohawk] I put a big target on my back in there.
So why'd you do it?
Because I'm concerned with safety.
Like, at the end of the day,
my friends and family fly on these airplanes.
[Knowles] Since John's passing,
we've been contacted by dozens and dozens and dozens of aviation whistleblowers.
They all have the same common concerns that John Barnett had.
[reporter] The New York Times interviewed current and former Boeing employees
who say the workforce has, quote, "dropped."
The inspection process has, quote, "weakened."
And production speed is being prioritized over quality control.
John inspired a lot of people to come forward.
[music fades]
We're headed to the Charleston County Coroner's Office
to meet with the coroner
who reached a conclusion related to John Barnett's passing.
They're gonna be disclosing the results of their investigation,
including forensic results and the autopsy results.
[Knowles] Yeah, there's a lot of questions.
[Turkewitz] This is gonna be a very tough day for John's family.
Can y'all hear me okay?
Yes, thank you.
-Good morning, Rodney. Can you hear me? -Good morning. Yes, ma'am.
So we were notified, um, of a… a death in a vehicle at the hotel.
The vehicle, it was locked, and they had to open it up.
We then, uh, photographed everything as we found it.
[somber music playing]
The Charleston Police Department came up with about 80 fingerprints
that belonged to John.
There was nothing to let us think that there had been a struggle
or anything of that nature.
We did obtain the hotel surveillance cameras
where we can see John coming into the lobby.
And then he exits the hotel at 8:37.
His truck is seen backing into a parking spot at 8:45.
No one is seen entering the vehicle, exiting the vehicle
until first responders find him.
One of the questions that has been lingering is,
were you able to determine that the bullet matched the gun?
Yes. What was found in the headliner is what matches to his weapon.
I think it's consistent that it's John's weapon,
he's inside his vehicle,
and the manner of death is suicide.
[somber music playing]
[Stokes] Heart-wrenching…
to know what, uh, my son had gone through,
and I saw some of it,
but I guess I just didn't realize how much it bothered him.
[O'Neal] Call me if you need me.
Thank you.
[O'Neal] You're welcome.
-Bye-bye. -[Rodney] Bye.
[Stokes sighs]
Give me a hug after that. [sobs]
[Knowles] These are the items
that the Charleston City Police Department released back to us.
John's, uh, laptop.
This was his cell phone.
And John's notebook.
[intriguing music playing]
And written inside there
is the suicide note that John left before he took his life.
"Fuck Boeing."
"I can't do this any longer. Enough."
"I pray the motherfuckers that destroyed my life pay."
"I pray Boeing pays."
"Bury me face down so Boeing and their lying-ass leaders can kiss my ass."
"To my family and friends, I found my purpose. I'm at peace."
"I love you more."
And then he signed, John Mitch, aka Swampy.
[Turkewitz] And it's one of those things where you just keep asking yourself,
"What could have I done differently?"
Yeah.
But one thing is for sure, and that is,
you know, Boeing may not have pulled the trigger,
but Boeing was responsible for John's death.
[reporter] Today, a congressional hearing is putting the safety and quality
of Boeing's commercial jets in the spotlight.
[pensive music playing]
After the 737 MAX crashes, Boeing promised to turn things around.
And whistleblowers came forward reporting to us
that, in fact, there was simply more of the same.
Improper fastening,
use of defective and damaged parts,
lapses in manufacturing quality.
There is certainly mounting evidence that a prosecution is justified.
And we felt more and more that we had to demand accountability.
And that's the reason why Dave Calhoun, the CEO, will be a witness today.
[pensive music continues]
[music fades]
[woman] This is my daughter, Danielle Moore.
Danielle was just 24 years old
when she died on Boeing 737 MAX.
So, my name is Zipporah Kuria,
and I lost my dad, Joseph Kuria Waithaka.
As the agencies involved in making decisions that matter,
if you fail to prosecute,
if you fail to teach history a real lesson of justice, and it repeats itself,
how will you live with yourselves?
-[indistinct chatter] -[cameras clicking]
[somber music playing]
[parent of deceased] You destroyed our son's life,
and you killed our children.
We will never have a chance to see and hug them
just the way you do with your family.
Give us the answer.
[woman] Stop putting profit over people.
[parent of deceased] Think of the six minutes
of my daughter's last breath on the plane.
Six minutes that she called for me.
Five years ago, 346 innocent people
lost their lives in two preventable tragedies.
In the wake of those tragedies, Boeing promised to turn itself around.
And for a while, some sort of believed that Boeing might have changed.
But then this past January,
the facade literally blew off the hollow shell
that had been Boeing's promises to the world.
The issues before us today are a matter of life and death.
And this hearing is a moment of reckoning.
I would like to welcome in particular some of the members of the audience
who are here today.
The family of John Barnett,
his mother, Vicky Stokes, and brother, Rodney Barnett,
a Boeing whistleblower who committed suicide
under the immense pressure that the company put on him
for raising safety claims.
David Calhoun has served as President and Chief Executive Officer of Boeing
since January 2020,
and he began his career at General Electric Company, GE,
where he spent 26 years.
Mr. Calhoun, it seems like every other day
news breaks of a new problem or safety concern with Boeing aircraft.
So what are the root causes of this systemic failure?
How are you gonna fix it? And who should we hold accountable?
Does the buck stop with you or with somebody else?
The contributing causes to most everything outside of the Alaska accident
relate to a variety of inputs that are downstream
with respect to operating and maintenance and et cetera with an airplane.
Um…
Alaska was a manufacturing defect.
I'm not aware of any others that were. Um…
[Blumenthal] The suppliers of parts and components,
Boeing blames them.
The workers whose jobs are at stake, Boeing blames them.
The pilots who fly these planes, Boeing blames them.
Boeing blames everyone except itself.
This… So much of this relates to an untrained workforce.
I… I… It's all about that, honestly.
Uh, Mr. Calhoun, what is it that… that you get paid currently?
Senator, that's well disclosed in our proxy documents,
uh, in… in each of the years that I've been employed.
Yeah, but what is it?
-It's a big number, sir. -[Hawley] Well, let me help you out.
It's $32.8 million this year. Does that sound right?
Yes, it does.
That's a 45% increase over last year. Does that sound right?
[smacks lips] Yes, it does.
[Hawley] What is it you get paid to do exactly?
I get paid to run the Boeing Company.
Yeah. Is quality part of your compensation package?
Because we've had multiple whistleblowers come before this committee and allege
that Boeing is cutting every possible corner on quality and safety,
not just in the past but now.
They've alleged that you've eliminated safety inspections,
that there are fewer inspectors doing quality inspections out there.
They've alleged that when they raised issues and concerns,
they were reassigned, they were retaliated against,
they were physically threatened.
That doesn't sound like attention to quality to me.
And yet you're getting paid $33 million a year.
[pensive music playing]
[Gelles] Boeing is in worse shape than ever,
and what's really hard to accept
is that the executives who made all those decisions
are worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
Boeing is in shambles,
and the very small group of men who got the company there
are some of the richest people in the world.
[Gates] There have been many executives who have come into Boeing,
come into companies across America,
who see their jobs as cost-cutting,
squeezing money out of the company to increase profits.
You're strip-mining it. You're strip-mining Boeing.
It was one of the greatest American companies ever.
It has employed thousands of people in my state,
and you are strip-mining it for profit, shareholder value,
and you're being rewarded for it.
You got a huge raise, a huge increase.
So, it's working out great for you, not for the American people.
Many of these executives have no connection
to the product they're making.
They were hired because they had some kind of business degree.
It's a characteristic that successful companies have
and unsuccessful companies don't have.
This year, we're at 47 a month.
We're gonna be taking it up to 52 a month.
That forecast is getting more and more robust every day,
and if we can get some help from the Congress,
we will ultimately realize those gains.
[air traffic controller] Frontier Flight 2688,
Portland Tower, runway 2-8 Left, cleared for takeoff.
[pilot] 2-8 Left, cleared for takeoff.
[Meyers] Boeing likes to attack the symptoms.
Some part flies off an airplane, or an engine catches fire,
they want to go after a quick fix, and then they can say they did something.
Boeing never attacks the disease, which is their leadership model.
Pursuit of money at all costs
rather than making the greatest airplane in the world.
[Gelles] In most companies, the stakes aren't people's lives.
But at Boeing, they are.
When the quality of Boeing suffers, people die.
[Gates] We all need safe air travel.
We need safe airplanes.
Boeing needs to be held accountable.
[pensive music playing]
[Naoise] They really just wanted to get rid of us.
But I don't think I can walk away and just say, "There's nothing we can do,"
and put my hands in the air.
There's been no justice, no accountability.
It makes me so angry.
And I think that we have to keep fighting.
It can't be allowed to just stay this way.
Something has to change.
[solemn music playing]
[music fades]